As long as they don’t butcher his character they can do whatever they want imo. I’ve always loved River ripple and always wished we saw more of him so I’ll take almost anything as long as they keep him as the, chill, level headed, and kind of weird, cat that they were able to maintain so far.
tbh i liked mothflights book, it was the first wc book i read and it was fun putting pieces together once i finally read dawn of the clans and eventually reread her book
My concern is the timeline. Shadowstars life (where she looses her last two lives) takes place not that long after Thunderstar’s Echo (the first life a leader has ever lost. I hope they kind of retcon that and make Shadowstar live longer
Yeah, I'm kinda nervous for this book too. Riverstar is one of my top 10 characters and I have a feeling it's not gonna be very good... I guess we'll just have to wait and see though. I enjoyed Moth Flight's Vision, but I don't really remember what happened in Thunderstar's Echo and Shadowstar's Life. I just remember I was really sad when Lightning Tail died because he was one of my favorite characters lol.
They better remember that thunderstar has kits (forgotten in shadowstar's book) and that star flower is pregnant at the end of shadowstar's life. Speaking of that book it was pointless it mentions the warrior code even though that hasn't been created yet, that her deputy will succeed her (she is the first leader to die so um never said before and ALSO THE WARRIOR CODE DID NOT EXIST), and it say that quick water doesn't believe she belongs in starclan despite all cats ignoring one eye go there. This would also be saying the warrior code exists because she would had to have known she'd broken it to go to the dark forest. WHICH ALSO ISN'T MENTIONED OR SAID TO EXIST. one eye is also said to be the first dark forest cat meaning he founded it so he'd still be there in omen of the stars. Shadowstar's book just bothers me! As long as riverstar's home isn't like that and doesn't butcher his character it'll be fine. And um kill skystar and give us sparrowstar please! And um don't tie in too much to asc 4 so I can read it!
Cats' spirits in StarClan and Dark Forest fade away if they're forgotten about by cats of the living, so that's probably why One Eye wasn't there in Omen of the Stars. However, that also does contradict itself because idk who was out there still remembering Thistleclaw, Mapleshade and especially Snowtuft lol
I have so much hope for this book, he's one of my favorite dotc characters and the fact that he's slightly mysterious and absent here and there in the series leaves a lot of room to do something interesting, as well as the side story of his backstory as Ripple. As well in Moth Flight's Vision, in the few scenes he's in Moth Flight herself thinks of him as wise when he reasons calmly about her telling the truth, which I think fits his character pretty well I will be so upset if they find a way to mess up this opportunity
shadowstars book was epic, hopefully riverstars book is not aids, ive just been reading wings of fire and to be honest ive read damn near every warriors book up to the newest book in a starless clan. And Wings of fire is just better, I mean I like warriors but wings of fire is way less rushed
Okay- I mean this as nicely as possible, and i think it was funny on *my* part, but I had my volume too low and your voice sounded like background noise at first? So I was very confused why someone made a video that just had a couple of images and no commentary with a radio running in the background.
@@theblueblazing just do your best! :) try testing your audio or look up stuff on audio. I'm probably the same level as you are when it comes to audio, its been years since I uploaded anything that required me to record audio. Just don't give up!
I just read the excerpt, and it honestly doesn't seem that interesting, I hope the rest of the book will turn out to be better bc honestly, i don't really care much for Riverstar's life prior to DOTC.
As long as they don’t butcher his character they can do whatever they want imo. I’ve always loved River ripple and always wished we saw more of him so I’ll take almost anything as long as they keep him as the, chill, level headed, and kind of weird, cat that they were able to maintain so far.
tbh i liked mothflights book, it was the first wc book i read and it was fun putting pieces together once i finally read dawn of the clans and eventually reread her book
It was the first book I read too! :O
I personally loved Moth Flight's book, and am really looking forward to this one as well!
My concern is the timeline. Shadowstars life (where she looses her last two lives) takes place not that long after Thunderstar’s Echo (the first life a leader has ever lost. I hope they kind of retcon that and make Shadowstar live longer
loses*
Yeah, I'm kinda nervous for this book too. Riverstar is one of my top 10 characters and I have a feeling it's not gonna be very good... I guess we'll just have to wait and see though. I enjoyed Moth Flight's Vision, but I don't really remember what happened in Thunderstar's Echo and Shadowstar's Life. I just remember I was really sad when Lightning Tail died because he was one of my favorite characters lol.
They better remember that thunderstar has kits (forgotten in shadowstar's book) and that star flower is pregnant at the end of shadowstar's life. Speaking of that book it was pointless it mentions the warrior code even though that hasn't been created yet, that her deputy will succeed her (she is the first leader to die so um never said before and ALSO THE WARRIOR CODE DID NOT EXIST), and it say that quick water doesn't believe she belongs in starclan despite all cats ignoring one eye go there. This would also be saying the warrior code exists because she would had to have known she'd broken it to go to the dark forest. WHICH ALSO ISN'T MENTIONED OR SAID TO EXIST. one eye is also said to be the first dark forest cat meaning he founded it so he'd still be there in omen of the stars. Shadowstar's book just bothers me!
As long as riverstar's home isn't like that and doesn't butcher his character it'll be fine. And um kill skystar and give us sparrowstar please! And um don't tie in too much to asc 4 so I can read it!
Cats' spirits in StarClan and Dark Forest fade away if they're forgotten about by cats of the living, so that's probably why One Eye wasn't there in Omen of the Stars. However, that also does contradict itself because idk who was out there still remembering Thistleclaw, Mapleshade and especially Snowtuft lol
I have so much hope for this book, he's one of my favorite dotc characters and the fact that he's slightly mysterious and absent here and there in the series leaves a lot of room to do something interesting, as well as the side story of his backstory as Ripple. As well in Moth Flight's Vision, in the few scenes he's in Moth Flight herself thinks of him as wise when he reasons calmly about her telling the truth, which I think fits his character pretty well I will be so upset if they find a way to mess up this opportunity
Your audio is super quiet (just a fyi),..
I just read the book, and it’s technically a copy of the dawn of the clans series but in Riverstar’s point of view. It wasn’t bad though!
@duststyboi Not bad, but imo disappointing
@@theblueblazing yeah I agree. I really had higher hopes for it.
shadowstars book was epic, hopefully riverstars book is not aids, ive just been reading wings of fire
and to be honest ive read damn near every warriors book up to the newest book in a starless clan.
And Wings of fire is just better, I mean I like warriors but wings of fire is way less rushed
Okay- I mean this as nicely as possible, and i think it was funny on *my* part, but I had my volume too low and your voice sounded like background noise at first? So I was very confused why someone made a video that just had a couple of images and no commentary with a radio running in the background.
Audio is too low and somehow peaking at the same time. I do not blame you, getting audio right is very hard.
It really is, but all the comments telling me to improve has me trying my darndest to improve.
@@theblueblazing just do your best! :) try testing your audio or look up stuff on audio. I'm probably the same level as you are when it comes to audio, its been years since I uploaded anything that required me to record audio. Just don't give up!
Broo up the audio we can barely hear you
im exited buttt also a bit worried
I just read the excerpt, and it honestly doesn't seem that interesting, I hope the rest of the book will turn out to be better bc honestly, i don't really care much for Riverstar's life prior to DOTC.
Guys am i CRAZY?? I always thought river was a GIRL !!
River Ripple/ Riverstar has always been a tom