Former Elder here. My wife and I woke up about 2 years ago and we faced the same question: Should we stay? After watching the Australian Royal Commission the answer was very clear... Thank you for speaking up and sharing your story!
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
So, did you look into the Catholics.. or all the other churches' records of abuse to the tune of billions in compensation did you look at all the Government care industry of abuse? God has no choice but to use imperfection, and he has corrected who he has chosen, where have you gone? to those who kill without thought for power wealth and resources.. and they still abuse more than the JWs and cover it all up as a duty!
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Thanks so much for another great video Caleb! Like you, the shunning and CSA policies, along with the WT’s stand on blood were the 3 biggest reasons why I could no longer continue to serve as an elder, or be a part of that organization.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
My respect for your well-thought-out lecture. Your statements testify to the fact that you are really guided by a well-trained conscience. Above all, it is remarkable that you can no longer identify with an organization that has proven to be hypocritical in many ways. And that puts the defense of the organization's interests above the protection of children.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
@@ucanliv4ever How very sad that you feel the need to stick up for those who commit CSA. You are merely repeating the words of the organization. They say these same words and you are just parroting them. Try thinking about this one without ANY organizational influence and you will see that it is the RESPONSIBILITY of ALL adults to protect children, especially those in positions of trust or authority. It is the responsibility of ALL adults to create an environment where children are safe. There is no greater responsibility in life. I hope you will see that the org does not provide that safety but rather creates an environment where predator$ are free to prey on the innocent with near impunity. There are many thousands of children who have had to pay the price of the organization’s secrecy.
I also look forward to your videos, you are very informative, patient and kind. It’s so awesome to watch you become more comfortable as you teach and share. Thank you for the time you spend recording and editing, you’re very good at both.
I always look forward to your videos. This is another good one. I honestly believe the reason they don't report crimes is the scripture that says not to take your brother to court. That one, and the 2 witness rule. I had several friends that were victims of sa in the religion. It has affected them all their lives. I could never be a part of that organization ever again either. Was in for 60 years, woke up after the ARC.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Wrong...elders are not eyewitness to the wrongdoing so their testimony is hearsay and is of very little value to the police. CSA is a global problem so singling out Jehovah's witnesses is slanderous.
Wrong...elders are not eyewitness to the wrongdoing so their testimony is hearsay and is of very little value to the police. CSA is a global problem so singling out Jehovah's witnesses is slanderous.
Former Mormon here who left after 50 years. Now my teenage son is doing Bible study with the JWs because his best friend is involved in the religion. I'm highly concerned of course and want to open his eyes to the damage high-demand religions/cults cause before he gets more indoctrinated...
Thank you so much for sharing. You have been so kind in your efforts to keep things honest and with integrity. Logical conclusions are drawn out by research and desire to show the sad truth of the hurt that is being done in this organization. Yahweh bless you and keep you all safe and well 🙏🏻❤️
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Wow love this video !! Thanks for explaining things so well so we understand it and the research that’s involved ❤ you are really helping so many !! Looking forward to your next video …..
Excellent points. I have been hurt by both as have so many😢 I would add the blood issue to the top harmful JW practices. But as far as the harm they do? Let me count the ways…😖
I too was an elder and stepped aside in 2008. I attended the memorial in 2023 but not in 2024. I watched the ARC and was shocked at the lies the elders told after swearing on the Bible to tell the truth and then shocked even more when a member of the gb lied. I am now in the situation where I have stopped going completely for over a year and am torn as to whether I should officially disassociate. I am wrestling with this.
Thank you for sharing your story. I appreciate your calm and precise delivery. I bet your talks were amazing. What a wonderful thing you did for your family. It really is such a harmful organization. Personally, I still feel so much anger for being robbed and abused. Thanks again for sharing.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Funny how they won't report THESE type of crimes, yet, according to the Shepherd book, Elders should "promptly report to the authorities" any thefts or vandalism in the Kingdom Hall.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Tell me, out of interest, and for clarification, what are your policies... say killing in a war for greed and power plus resources, do you Vote for these humans to lead you.. Do you trust all they say and do? or do they.... What is the word you use.. "manipulate" = lairs, thieves, and deceivers.. but you still vote for that political Cult I suspect...Strange don't you think?
5:53 Good point here C. WT has no interest in gov’t. laws here, but when it came time to decide about an authorized only jab, WT made people feel guilty if they did not want to consent.🙄
I don’t really expect a reply but I’m curious what choices you would have made if ‘getting my family out’ wasn’t an option. For myself personally, and many others, losing my family was part of the price of leaving the Org. I only bring this up to call attention to just how strong the desire to pursue truth elsewhere has to be to feel that even this high cost must be paid in order to be free. I can’t help but wonder if watching others who are otherwise good people make this choice in spite of the cost causes some who remain in the Org to wonder what is really going on. Make no mistake, being a Jehovah’s Witness is hard. I used to refer to it as constantly trying to mentally pound square pegs into round holes. It’s exhausting.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
@@vestland3877 Without getting into the idea of whether or not we always have a choice, in this instance I simply used this common expression in the way it is usually meant. That is, most choices are made to one degree or another based on a cost vs benefit analysis. Meaning ‘I could do this but would the benefit be worth the cost?’. Sometimes the answer is yes, other times it is no. And again, I think personal priorities are the determining factor. As in ‘No way it’s worth that to me, so I have no choice but to refuse’. This seems obvious to me. Am I missing something here?
I know someone who personally struggles with addiction issues. His behaviors stem from 90% of this religion. He’s been DF for 23 years. I feel that’s where his addiction comes in. There’s a lot of people who develop those issues who leave this cult. I want raised around it at all or any religion I’ve been coming to know Jesus on my own and starting to read my Bible. I don’t think my husband will ever wake up and not go back. I don’t want him to 😢. I see what it’s done. He talked me into studying and I had a gut feeling quickly that something wasn’t right! I believe that was Jesus telling me to stay away from these false prophets.
It was because of the hidden and unreported CSA cases that I too couldn't be seen associated with WT either. To be involved with WT knowing full well what's going on, is very telling on your own character how the unreported crimes doesn't affect your conscience.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
What is also not talked about is spousal abu$e and SA within the marriage. That was my experience for over 30 years. SA of your spouse is not a grounds for marital separation so if you DO separate, you are considered “not exemplary.” It’s so disheartening to have the choice to either continue to be abu$ed in your marriage or the other option is to be marked in the congregation as someone who is not spiritually strong, have no opportunities for “privileges” and to be made to think you are not acceptable to God. Funny how SA of your spouse is illegal, but not a grounds for separation. Further, if you ever DO get the courage to come forward, you will be told NOT to tell anyone because you will be responsible for reproaching Jah’s name. There is no protection for children or women.
John 8:1-11 has been deleted from the Black and Silver New World Translation, but if you look at the King James version it has not been deleted. Jesus spoke in this scripture that has been deleted and removed.
Have you or ( I wonder other former elders) have filed reports to authorities about what they have witnessed and done in hiding it all. I know I would. It's sickening how men in the religion get away with anything. Yet as a woman I got scolded by trying to speak up about what happened... saying I was not spiritual enough... so not right
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Because they are giving witness of the Living God: Matthew 16:16 Simon Peter answered [To Jesus]: “You are the Christ, the SON.. of THE LIVING GOD.” Jeremiah 10:10 But Jehovah is the True God, HE IS - THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King.- THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King. Because of his indignation the earth will quake, And no nations will endure his denunciation. John 17:3 Jesus said praying to Jehovah: This means everlasting life, their coming to know you, the only true God, and the one whom you sent, Jesus Christ.
Leaving any religion is step one. That often leads to then confirming the bible you once believed in. That often leads to the truth about that as well, which is not good. You should really dive deep on the origin of the Jehovah character.
@@Eric_01Jehovah is the Latinized divine name of God. It’s no problem for believers to use it when addressing the God who made all things, including humans.
10:10 "My conscience couldn't bear killing people by unscriptural policy" you said. Does that mean you're ok with killing people if the scriptures call for it?
@@96t5wagon SURE, but that doesn't tell us anything about whether he's ok with killing people according to scriptural guidelines. Christians treat the Bible as a buffet, picking and choosing what they want and ignoring the rest. FFS if they actually followed what it said, then the bible students would have killed Russell for being a false prophet in 1915, and JWs would have killed the entire governing body in 1976! So yeah, i'm asking if Caleb is ok with killing people if the scriptures call for it since calling oneself a christian tells us nothing. It's an honest question on my part and one i don't know if he's considered.
@@joelee1195 visit the exJw subreddit and you’ll read of many stories of those who have had friends and family who’ve sadly ended their lives as a direct result of the man made rules of that organization. I was nearly one myself, but thanks to my therapist and real, genuine friends I’m still here. There are truly rough days still but they’re much better than the darkness I endured leading up to where I’m at.
I was threatened by a unbaptised publisher. He also threatened my unborn baby. I told elders and not a thing was done. Nothing. Not even a temporary stall on d2d. He was straight out and baptised weeks later. The threats was very bad. I won't say it here but the messages I had were very poor from him
Any Religion made up by/for Us imperfect Humans, is NOT a "True" Religion... Silliness. ALL Organización have flaws, some more abundant than others. So, just find one that suits one's style and... Enjoy!👍
How like "Balm" to the heart ,is listening ro you Caleb, your refreshing words of truth and honesty,are wonderful to hear, you say what so many of us feel in our hearts , ❤ those of us whose hearts have nor turned into charcoal 🖤 but are still seeking desperately for TRUTH , and truth can be found if we look honestly for it 💗 you are a prime example 😊Thank You for all your hard work 💕🙏
I'm was a JW from birth and was baptized at 12 years old. I made a pledge for an infinite amount of time as a minor who didn't even know about evolution by natural selection nor endogenous retroviruses as proof of evolution I didn't know about anthropology or how advanced science is. I wouldn't wish this type of forced ignorance on anyone especially if they are a minor child and especially especially if it is from birth. And you were talking about the elders and how traumatizing they can be??? you should hear what happened to me at like 15: My dad is an elder. And a different Elder while my dad was gone walked me up stairs in a special Kingdom Hall room by myself just with him and he said someone told him I wanted to put my pecker in his daughter Rebeccer. . The irony is I'm freaking gay there's no way in the world I would ever want to do that. Several decades past and now I live across the street from that same exact elder. And one day I was so irritated I walked right over to his house while he was outside working on his lawn and I told him if damn you for doing that to me, for traumatizing me when I was a child how dare you do that you knew that it was wrong in the first place shame on you and f*** you. Since there were not two witnesses I used that against him and I was able to cuss that f***** out and no one can do a single thing about it
JW are harmful because we live in a civilization that ignore the living God and they are giving witness of him: Matthew 16:16 Simon Peter answered [To Jesus]: “You are the Christ, the SON.. of THE LIVING GOD.” Jeremiah 10:10 But Jehovah is the True God, HE IS - THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King.- THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King. Because of his indignation the earth will quake, And no nations will endure his denunciation. John 17:3 Jesus said praying to Jehovah: This means everlasting life, their coming to know you, the only true God, and the one whom you sent, Jesus Christ.
Former Elder here. My wife and I woke up about 2 years ago and we faced the same question: Should we stay? After watching the Australian Royal Commission the answer was very clear...
Thank you for speaking up and sharing your story!
woke like lgtb?
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
So, did you look into the Catholics.. or all the other churches' records of abuse to the tune of billions in compensation did you look at all the Government care industry of abuse? God has no choice but to use imperfection, and he has corrected who he has chosen, where have you gone? to those who kill without thought for power wealth and resources.. and they still abuse more than the JWs and cover it all up as a duty!
Amen ❤!!!! Same here!!!
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Thanks for these excellent videos. Always look forward to them!
Thanks so much for another great video Caleb! Like you, the shunning and CSA policies, along with the WT’s stand on blood were the 3 biggest reasons why I could no longer continue to serve as an elder, or be a part of that organization.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
My respect for your well-thought-out lecture. Your statements testify to the fact that you are really guided by a well-trained conscience. Above all, it is remarkable that you can no longer identify with an organization that has proven to be hypocritical in many ways. And that puts the defense of the organization's interests above the protection of children.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Wrong. Who's responsibility is it to protect children? Primarily the parents. Of course we care but the watchtower is not a daycare facility.
Wrong. Who's responsibility is it to protect children? Primarily the parents. Of course we care but the watchtower is not a daycare facility.
@@ucanliv4ever How very sad that you feel the need to stick up for those who commit CSA. You are merely repeating the words of the organization. They say these same words and you are just parroting them. Try thinking about this one without ANY organizational influence and you will see that it is the RESPONSIBILITY of ALL adults to protect children, especially those in positions of trust or authority. It is the responsibility of ALL adults to create an environment where children are safe. There is no greater responsibility in life. I hope you will see that the org does not provide that safety but rather creates an environment where predator$ are free to prey on the innocent with near impunity. There are many thousands of children who have had to pay the price of the organization’s secrecy.
I also look forward to your videos, you are very informative, patient and kind. It’s so awesome to watch you become more comfortable as you teach and share. Thank you for the time you spend recording and editing, you’re very good at both.
I always look forward to your videos. This is another good one. I honestly believe the reason they don't report crimes is the scripture that says not to take your brother to court. That one, and the 2 witness rule. I had several friends that were victims of sa in the religion. It has affected them all their lives. I could never be a part of that organization ever again either. Was in for 60 years, woke up after the ARC.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Wrong...elders are not eyewitness to the wrongdoing so their testimony is hearsay and is of very little value to the police. CSA is a global problem so singling out Jehovah's witnesses is slanderous.
Wrong...elders are not eyewitness to the wrongdoing so their testimony is hearsay and is of very little value to the police. CSA is a global problem so singling out Jehovah's witnesses is slanderous.
Thanks for sharing your story, Caleb! I look forward to your next video.
Excellent video. Thank-you from Australia!
Very similar concerns, thank you as always for bringing awareness and sharing your story.
Good man. TY for your honesty and exposing the criminality and cruelty that actually exists within those walls. God bless you and your family ❤️
Former Mormon here who left after 50 years. Now my teenage son is doing Bible study with the JWs because his best friend is involved in the religion. I'm highly concerned of course and want to open his eyes to the damage high-demand religions/cults cause before he gets more indoctrinated...
Caleb, you are a real good man. Real men discern, and they protect. Thank you!🙏🏻
Enjoy your information. My 2 eldest daughters shunned me for not stopping talking to my daughter who left and was like a black sheep .from Australia.
Enjoy all of your videos!
Thank you so much for sharing. You have been so kind in your efforts to keep things honest and with integrity. Logical conclusions are drawn out by research and desire to show the sad truth of the hurt that is being done in this organization. Yahweh bless you and keep you all safe and well 🙏🏻❤️
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Caleb thank you for your expressions and insights .
Wow love this video !! Thanks for explaining things so well so we understand it and the research that’s involved ❤ you are really helping so many !! Looking forward to your next video …..
Excellent points. I have been hurt by both as have so many😢
I would add the blood issue to the top harmful JW practices. But as far as the harm they do? Let me count the ways…😖
I too was an elder and stepped aside in 2008. I attended the memorial in 2023 but not in 2024. I watched the ARC and was shocked at the lies the elders told after swearing on the Bible to tell the truth and then shocked even more when a member of the gb lied. I am now in the situation where I have stopped going completely for over a year and am torn as to whether I should officially disassociate. I am wrestling with this.
Thank you ❤
Thank you for sharing your story. I appreciate your calm and precise delivery. I bet your talks were amazing. What a wonderful thing you did for your family. It really is such a harmful organization. Personally, I still feel so much anger for being robbed and abused. Thanks again for sharing.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
Funny how they won't report THESE type of crimes, yet, according to the Shepherd book, Elders should "promptly report to the authorities" any thefts or vandalism in the Kingdom Hall.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
@@mr.d.c.1914.1 www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/sites/default/files/WAT.0021.001.0001.pdf
@@mr.d.c.1914.1 www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/sites/default/files/WAT.0021.001.0001.pdf
Thank you for your efforts in clarifying jw policies and manipulation.
Tell me, out of interest, and for clarification, what are your policies... say killing in a war for greed and power plus resources, do you Vote for these humans to lead you.. Do you trust all they say and do? or do they.... What is the word you use.. "manipulate" = lairs, thieves, and deceivers.. but you still vote for that political Cult I suspect...Strange don't you think?
@vestland3877 ?
5:53 Good point here C. WT has no interest in gov’t. laws here, but when it came time to decide about an authorized only jab, WT made people feel guilty if they did not want to consent.🙄
It is absolutely astonishing once u see the truth about the truth ….. it’s nauseating 🤢 We left immediately
I don’t really expect a reply but I’m curious what choices you would have made if ‘getting my family out’ wasn’t an option.
For myself personally, and many others, losing my family was part of the price of leaving the Org.
I only bring this up to call attention to just how strong the desire to pursue truth elsewhere has to be to feel that even this high cost must be paid in order to be free.
I can’t help but wonder if watching others who are otherwise good people make this choice in spite of the cost causes some who remain in the Org to wonder what is really going on.
Make no mistake, being a Jehovah’s Witness is hard. I used to refer to it as constantly trying to mentally pound square pegs into round holes. It’s exhausting.
It is vital to take to heart Christ’s words at Matt.10:34-39. Any cost to be married to Christ is priceless.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
@@vestland3877 Stay or go I think either way an individual has to feel that they have no choice.
It’s all a question of personal priorities.
@@vestland3877 Without getting into the idea of whether or not we always have a choice, in this instance I simply used this common expression in the way it is usually meant. That is, most choices are made to one degree or another based on a cost vs benefit analysis. Meaning ‘I could do this but would the benefit be worth the cost?’. Sometimes the answer is yes, other times it is no. And again, I think personal priorities are the determining factor. As in ‘No way it’s worth that to me, so I have no choice but to refuse’. This seems obvious to me. Am I missing something here?
@@vestland3877 Tough yes, but soul building.
Thank you Caleb❤
Great video
a lot of it is arrogance power and control over others
Glad I watched this video. Knew JW was weird but didn’t realize they were sick and twisted like this.
You were wise to see thru those policies.
I know someone who personally struggles with addiction issues. His behaviors stem from 90% of this religion. He’s been DF for 23 years. I feel that’s where his addiction comes in. There’s a lot of people who develop those issues who leave this cult. I want raised around it at all or any religion I’ve been coming to know Jesus on my own and starting to read my Bible. I don’t think my husband will ever wake up and not go back. I don’t want him to 😢. I see what it’s done. He talked me into studying and I had a gut feeling quickly that something wasn’t right! I believe that was Jesus telling me to stay away from these false prophets.
Excellent
Great info 💝 Thank you 👍
It was because of the hidden and unreported CSA cases that I too couldn't be seen associated with WT either. To be involved with WT knowing full well what's going on, is very telling on your own character how the unreported crimes doesn't affect your conscience.
from bitter winter - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
On book of the sheperd of the flock, If one would still be back with them, I bet one's wife would not be allowed to read that book
You would be right. Woman are not allowed to read nor even touch this book. Crazy, isn't it?
" I was too afraid to...."
Keep it up bro.
Thanks
THANK YOU!!!
What is also not talked about is spousal abu$e and SA within the marriage. That was my experience for over 30 years. SA of your spouse is not a grounds for marital separation so if you DO separate, you are considered “not exemplary.” It’s so disheartening to have the choice to either continue to be abu$ed in your marriage or the other option is to be marked in the congregation as someone who is not spiritually strong, have no opportunities for “privileges” and to be made to think you are not acceptable to God. Funny how SA of your spouse is illegal, but not a grounds for separation. Further, if you ever DO get the courage to come forward, you will be told NOT to tell anyone because you will be responsible for reproaching Jah’s name. There is no protection for children or women.
🥰🍻💯🥂💖💖💖
Hi Caleb, thanks again for sharing your videos. Really appreciate them. Carlos and Noel
John 8:1-11 has been deleted from the Black and Silver New World Translation, but if you look at the King James version it has not been deleted. Jesus spoke in this scripture that has been deleted and removed.
👋❤️❤️❤️👍
The delivery felt like a talk lol ngl. But, very informative
Have you or ( I wonder other former elders) have filed reports to authorities about what they have witnessed and done in hiding it all. I know I would. It's sickening how men in the religion get away with anything. Yet as a woman I got scolded by trying to speak up about what happened... saying I was not spiritual enough... so not right
FROM BITTER Winter article - As American scholar Holly Folk demonstrated in Bitter Winter, the Royal Commission’s figure of 1,006 cases of suspected sexual abuse of minors reflects the sum of all disciplinary reports and referrals, proven and unproven, that had been submitted to the Jehovah’s Witness organization in Australia over a 65-year period. These data were supplied to the Royal Commission by the Jehovah’s Witnesses themselves. The Jehovah’s Witnesses had regarded 383 of the 1,006 allegations as serious enough to be reported to the police, and 161 had resulted in convictions. The Royal Commission’s acquisition of all the remaining cases, which were put at the police’s disposal, has not resulted in a wave of prosecutions, confirming that the judgement of the Jehovah’s Witnesses had been sound enough. The Spanish apostates also omit to mention that, while scholars have criticized the methodology of the Australian investigation, the Jehovah’s Witnesses nonetheless fared better in terms of how they protected children than other religious organizations, including the Roman Catholic Church.
what if the police are corrupt its a bit of a connumdrum
Because they are giving witness of the Living God:
Matthew 16:16 Simon Peter answered [To Jesus]: “You are the Christ, the SON.. of THE LIVING GOD.”
Jeremiah 10:10 But Jehovah is the True God, HE IS - THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King.- THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King. Because of his indignation the earth will quake, And no nations will endure his denunciation.
John 17:3 Jesus said praying to Jehovah: This means everlasting life, their coming to know you, the only true God, and the one whom you sent, Jesus Christ.
Absolutely and totally agree.
Hi 👋🏻
Well done for waking up and leaving that damaging organisation. I pray that you have not turned your back on Jehovah.
Leaving any religion is step one. That often leads to then confirming the bible you once believed in. That often leads to the truth about that as well, which is not good. You should really dive deep on the origin of the Jehovah character.
@@Eric_01Jehovah is the Latinized divine name of God. It’s no problem for believers to use it when addressing the God who made all things, including humans.
@ you should really deep dive on the devil character.
Jehovah/Yahweh is actually the devil Jesus alluded to when he rebuked the Hebrews/Israelites for worshipping their father the devil. John 8:44
@ Yeah. Heard it all before. Seriously faulty research. Read your Bible. Next you’ll be telling me the earth is flat.
They are a massive cult. what did you expect.
10:10 "My conscience couldn't bear killing people by unscriptural policy" you said.
Does that mean you're ok with killing people if the scriptures call for it?
His latest video answers that
@@96t5wagon ? Isn't THIS his latest video? It's from 4 days ago as of now, and i don't see anything newer under his 'videos' tab on his profile...
@@jmsr77 latest is titled, “what if Jehovah’s Witnesses are right.”
@@96t5wagon SURE, but that doesn't tell us anything about whether he's ok with killing people according to scriptural guidelines. Christians treat the Bible as a buffet, picking and choosing what they want and ignoring the rest. FFS if they actually followed what it said, then the bible students would have killed Russell for being a false prophet in 1915, and JWs would have killed the entire governing body in 1976!
So yeah, i'm asking if Caleb is ok with killing people if the scriptures call for it since calling oneself a christian tells us nothing. It's an honest question on my part and one i don't know if he's considered.
Are you sure suicide is common among the shunned?
Yes it is. No question.
@ I’ll say in my 10+ years involvement with the org I never heard of any suicides.
@@joelee1195what capacity are you involved with them?
@@96t5wagon I’m Exjw
@@joelee1195 visit the exJw subreddit and you’ll read of many stories of those who have had friends and family who’ve sadly ended their lives as a direct result of the man made rules of that organization. I was nearly one myself, but thanks to my therapist and real, genuine friends I’m still here. There are truly rough days still but they’re much better than the darkness I endured leading up to where I’m at.
I was threatened by a unbaptised publisher. He also threatened my unborn baby. I told elders and not a thing was done. Nothing. Not even a temporary stall on d2d. He was straight out and baptised weeks later. The threats was very bad. I won't say it here but the messages I had were very poor from him
Any Religion made up by/for Us imperfect Humans, is NOT a "True" Religion... Silliness. ALL Organización have flaws, some more abundant than others. So, just find one that suits one's style and... Enjoy!👍
How like "Balm" to the heart ,is listening ro you Caleb, your refreshing words of truth and honesty,are wonderful to hear, you say what so many of us feel in our hearts , ❤ those of us whose hearts have nor turned into charcoal 🖤 but are still seeking desperately for TRUTH , and truth can be found if we look honestly for it 💗 you are a prime example 😊Thank You for all your hard work 💕🙏
I'm was a JW from birth and was baptized at 12 years old. I made a pledge for an infinite amount of time as a minor who didn't even know about evolution by natural selection nor endogenous retroviruses as proof of evolution I didn't know about anthropology or how advanced science is. I wouldn't wish this type of forced ignorance on anyone especially if they are a minor child and especially especially if it is from birth.
And you were talking about the elders and how traumatizing they can be??? you should hear what happened to me at like 15: My dad is an elder. And a different Elder while my dad was gone walked me up stairs in a special Kingdom Hall room by myself just with him and he said someone told him I wanted to put my pecker in his daughter Rebeccer. . The irony is I'm freaking gay there's no way in the world I would ever want to do that.
Several decades past and now I live across the street from that same exact elder. And one day I was so irritated I walked right over to his house while he was outside working on his lawn and I told him if damn you for doing that to me, for traumatizing me when I was a child how dare you do that you knew that it was wrong in the first place shame on you and f*** you. Since there were not two witnesses I used that against him and I was able to cuss that f***** out and no one can do a single thing about it
Sounds like you have some anger issues, get some therapy, dude, and then reevaluate !An chances are they are not due to that elder only .
JW are harmful because we live in a civilization that ignore the living God and they are giving witness of him:
Matthew 16:16 Simon Peter answered [To Jesus]: “You are the Christ, the SON.. of THE LIVING GOD.”
Jeremiah 10:10 But Jehovah is the True God, HE IS - THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King.- THE LIVING GOD - and the eternal King. Because of his indignation the earth will quake, And no nations will endure his denunciation.
John 17:3 Jesus said praying to Jehovah: This means everlasting life, their coming to know you, the only true God, and the one whom you sent, Jesus Christ.
I want to say I love your videos, if you ever need a friend to talk to feel free to email me :)