@@amanenr This world is cruel this world is wicked this world is deceitful filled with all kinds of Temptations. but….. Deep in each of our hearts we do know, how to escape from evil and their lies, by COMING TO CHRIST: REPENT AND BORN AGAIN. in return getting: peace protection guidance comfort wisdom and understanding about heavenly things.
Not disrespecting Indian culture, representing it in the most beautiful way. Every single one of the performances she does of this song just makes me fall in love with the song all over again!! it is so good!
What’s amazing is Selena remembering the whole choreography without missing a single step or even having to look at her fellow dancers for cues, while still singing this live. It’s not easy to manage dancing and singing plus she does this so effortlessly. Selena is a star for a reason!!!!
@@tamanna4697 That’s not true. Apart from Beyonce not many singers can sing live and dance hard. Selena didn’t dance hard but she did really well remembering choreography plus song lyrics without going out of breath. It’s not as easy as you think
@@audiroblox-240 No, some record many and choose the best one like Billie, some use vocal layering like Taylor, Some add a touch of autotune like Melanie, and some add tons of autotune and vocal layering like selena, she can't sing for shit
honestly all the people who were complaining were probably not indians and just her haters in general. She's representing the dance culture beautifully and its very obvious that her team hired an expert on India culture or indian themselves.
Honestly one of the best dances I've seen from a live show. The dancing was beautiful and matched with the song. The music enhanced the dancing and vice versa. Love this song, amazing choreography!
@@R2d2.. When Selena herself said this was a tribute to her Indian fans why are you trynna prove that this has nothing to do with India? Jealous and Insecure much?
Those who are saying that she is insulting india ...being an Indian let me tell you guys ...I liked her performance a lot and I don't think that this is insult at all ...but the actual insult is being done by our own bollywood actors ........lots of love for Selena
If anyone would do their research Selena can sing! 2013 was legit the year she was diagnosed with lupus and she had no idea how deal with it, didn't know how to cure it, probably didn't even know what it would do to her breathing at the time. I can tell this performance is t that great but you can clearly see she is trying so hard. Selena isn't Demi or Adele, if you want someone with a really strong voice then go listen to them but Selena has such a beautiful soft voice and that has been her voice since the beginning of her career, even before she was diagnosed. If you listen to her performances in 2015/2016 she sounds so much better. Her voice is stronger because she's been treating her lupus and she's been getting things done for it. But then for some performances she doesn't sound so great because it all fluctuates. Selena tries so hard and all people can ever do is bring her down for something that isn't her fault. Spread love guys, Selena tries her best.
I was wondering why Ate Selena is hardly breathing....Is she sick? I'm sorry if you putted the name of her illness, I'm 9 soo i don't understand much of what you said... P.S Sorry for that😐
+Ajalinel Andales she has lupus which can affect her breathing and vocal chords. She was diagnosed in 2013 so her singing was kinda all messed up cause she didn't know really how to deal with it. She's getting better everyday. Hope that helps :)
+Thepomafame everywhere I've read it's either said 2013/ 2014. And yea she will have to leave with it but she gets treatments like chemo when it flares and gets bad. Right now it's really bad in terms of her mental health. She's been having really bad anxiety and depression recently because of the illness so her tour is on break.
See the choreography! She is not being overly energetic banging her head or shaking terribly still she is dances so gracefully! Just the right use of hands and hips...
I'm not an Indian or from India. However I totally understand and agree that she is Respectful and Representing the Indian Culture. Funny how the ones who complain the most aren't even Indians!
I remember trying to learn this dance when I was like 9 years old🤣 update: i’m here 2 years later, i’m 17 y’all! i think i still remember the dance, i’m gonna have to try it out lmao
@@Shelby-hp5fz It would be uncomfortable for her to perform in a traditional dress of any Indian culture and just because she is wearing a bindi, doesn’t mean she has to make everything indian-style.
@@rashidamorawala3338 isn't that what cultural appropriation is? using selected parts of a specific culture to match your music's aesthetic purposes while there are people around the world who get made fun of for wearing the same thing ?
@@rashidamorawala3338 because they don't know what cultural appropriation is. No need to be offended to know it's cultural appropriation. Indians are made fun of because of their clothing,the way they eat with hands and also the skin color so a white person using it for aesthetic is not right. It's like wearing dreads and saying you're appreciating black culture.
To the haters: Selena CAN sing, she CAN dance, and she CAN act. You're really all just jealous of her. You're so miserable with your own lives you have to take it out on her. She's 100 percent talented
My dad was the first to fall in love with Selena and keeps calling her sweet words untill I got to listen to her and fell in love with both her and her music, she's such a lovely person. I pray she finds peace.
@@tuhimerameraa1 we are snowflakes and I am Indian.
3 года назад+7
Indians are really emotional they just want an air like modi lahar and they would really blew away this is modern form of culture and traditions and people should accept as time ellapsed
I love that she’s respecting and representing my beautiful Indian culture this isn’t inappropriate or offensive this is beyond incredible!!! I love it so much I love and respect Selena Gomez!!!❤️❤️✨✨🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@cureheadwhore5453 her dance and bindi is representing Indian culture.. that's why it looks more Indian.. ( it's perception that Pakistani culture is similar to Arab and afgan)
Cureheadwhre are u stupid? 1. It's Indian song, paxtani copying it and remaking it years later doesn't make it paxtani. 2. Selena is using Indian classical dance bharatnatyam, Kathak dance steps/ hand gestures. 3. Selena is wearing Indian Hindu bindi on forehead. 4. Selena sed Indian Hindu namaste!! not Paxtan Muslim salam alaikum. 5. Selena dedicated this performance for her Indian audience not paxtani. 6. Paxtan is islamic Muslim country that wears black burka, bans singing and dance in islam saying it's haram. Neither do paxtani Muslims do Indian Hindu dance forms like bharatnatyam, Kathak dedicated to Hindu gods, nor they wear Hindu bindi on foreheard that is linked to Hindu god. So there is nothing paxtani in her performance..get a life troll ##
*THE FACT THAT THIS YOUNG WOMAN EVEN HAVING LUPUS AND SO MUCH HATERS (CRITICIZING HER VOICE, PERSONAL LIFE, ETC) EFFORTS TO DANCE LIKE THAT AND SINGING AT THE SAME TIME SHOWS HOW MUCH STRONG AND PASIONATE SHE IS BOUT HER JOB* *THATS THE KIND OF ARTIST I STAN* i dont see often many artist these last years having these kind of issues and facing it like that
It’s not Indian feels the begining IS Indian and the background music is with an electro beat on top And she is doing Indian dance moves and is wearing a bindi as well
And there's Indian people in the comments saying they are proud. Culture appropriation is pure bullshit. Being racist is a problem, culture appropriation is just another way to complain about insignificant things
I can say that even if some are saying she is disrespecting the culture of indian individuals this was in 2013 and out of some of the artists since and even before that have tried to do simular nods to cultures, hers was the least problematic and it was apparent she took great effort in making this performance as respectful as possible.
@@tithisings bollywood songs also have Tablas. And this is not proper indian culture but it's very similar to bollywood dances more. So let's say this dance is bollywood ish
@@dontstalkme5332 bollywood songs don't usually have tabla. Maybe drums, but not tabla. If u check out her music video of this song, u can see Indian men wearing traditional outfits with the traditional hat on too and playing tabla. So it's more of Indian traditional music than bollywood. Bollywood is a whole other genre
@@tithisings the dance is bollywood ish. And the song is bollywood ish (only a lil bit tho,more electronic music) I was correcting u only, I respect Selena so much for representing us Indians and she tried her best and this was a top notch performance
@@dontstalkme5332 i love selena as well! My intention wasn't to shame her or anything lol. I'm glad she represented Indians too. Im even more glad that she RESPECTFULLY did this. Like she didn't just use an Indian kinda beat and acted like it was her own. She wore a bindi, which shows even more that she respected the origins of her song and tried her best to dance kinda in an Indian style way and even wore the appropriate clothes that had a tiny Indian touch to it. But in my opinion only the dance is bollywood ish. Obviously the music also sounds bollywood ish since bollywood is literally Indian traditional music but slightly changed, but i do think it's more Indian traditional music than bollywood. Especially the tabla part at the beginning. We're just gonna have to agree to disagree on that lol. I think it's more traditional Indian music cause i myself have also done lessons on Indian traditional music btw! And this is very similar to that than to bollywood
+Lain x De que carajos hablas??? Yo nunca dije que Selena es la mejor cantante del mundo, deja de inventar. Si lei tu comentario pero eso no cambia nada, es absurdo.
I don't really understand why it matters who can sing, who can't sing, who sings live, and who doesn't. They're all talented people in their own special, unique way, and if ya'll don't think so, then just don't listen to them. It's not a law saying that you have to. It's all so unnecessary, and not called for. And, if you do like it, just sit back and enjoy the music. There is no need for all of the name calling of the celebrities like ya'll know who they really are, personally. All you're doing is making them more famous by talking about them. So, they win either way it goes.
AllAboutMe why are u listening to her music if you aren't a fan? #Pathetic u know what's funny you are here bashing singers on youtube while they are out there making shit loads a cash. Who is winning?
Cannot beleive in 2022 i still love her performance.I have never ever seen such a brave girl like her yaar.If she can do her best in her critical situation then i think she can do anything. Leaving this comment her so if someone likes it in future i can enjoy this performance again!
Those who are saying she is representing Pakistani Culture, she might be using Pakistani tune and song, but the dressing style, the bindi , the dance and the namaste in the end is Indian and not Pakistani... So the song is Pakistani, but she is representing Indian culture and Indian Subcontinent at the same time.
Every Indian telling that they don't find this offensive and that everyone's saying that this is offensive when it's not. Meanwhile me who didn't find a single comment saying that this is offensive: 👁👄👁
That's bcus you are just 8 years late. There were some comments which might have been deleted now or you can find them just by scrolling down for 5 to 6 mins. Although wasting 5 min to see a Negative comment is not worth it. 💀
This is for the 1st time that I m watching sel's Indianized version n I m just so surprised n feeling sooo proud at the same time as an Indian..Shez such a positive person n such a strong feminine personality n when shez here representing Indian culture so beautifully..its just an amazing feeling..when I was going thru the same experience as her in my life,each day people around me trying to dim my light, I came across a video of hers n that was just so full of positivity n courage to face them all with no regrets,no negativity n instead with love..that was so healing..thats the only way to heal ourselves n humanity..as an empath I cud connect to her soul..shez really a pure soul ..shez Divine ..love u dear..will always respect u 4 wat u r at the core..
CAN WE TALK OF HOW AN AMAZING DANCER SHE IS LIKE THAT CHOREOGRAPHY WAS FIRE SHE KILLED IT WITHOUT MISSING A NOTE AND THAT DRESS WAS SO PRETTY IM GLAD SHE DID IT IN THIS ERA CUZ NOW SHE WOULD OF GOTTEN CANCELED CUZ EVERYTHING IS OFFENSIVE NOW A DAYS but the other comments Indian are proud of her culture representation 😁👏🇮🇳
Hi there as an Indian I truly appreciate her performance along with the background dancers and also did you guys noticed she was dancing and singing as well she is MULTI-TALENTED!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️
It’s so ironic, the light want to get darker and the dark want to get lighter, I’m not speaking generally cause I know there are some who don’t but it’s just an irony of life really
I looked that up Indians actually weren't always obsessed with pale skin...when the British people came to India,they were like coloured ppl are dirty,poor etc. And just racist to the Indians...and that made them complex abt their skin tone....and it still continues..ppl with lighter skin got the genes from the British ppl who lived in India and now they're considered good looking....they're basically still living in the 70's...and still racist to each other Smh
Coming to me, I'm Indian. Recently, I has been heard this song on Instagram and when I noticed Indian music in her song I really fall in love with this song ❤ her voice and Indian music given much attraction and attention towards this song and I'm obsessed with song and from the few years onwards I love Selena Gomez ❤️ she's amazing person in reality I respect her . Her voice and Indian music became plus point to this song ❤ I love this now
@@Lamas826 He was talking about the past. He said "did" because she DID preform this at a Disney award show for a young audience. No hate to Selena, but you just aggressively went after an innocent comment for no reason. He was simply stating his shock of a song talking about coming and getting it to a crowd full of 12 year olds
10 years later, this video is a beautiful reminder of the times when your star shone brightest. Yes, yes, time... a monster that cannot be negotiated with. And it is believed that the brighter they shine, the faster they disappear.
You do realise that you can hear her catch her breath (VERY SLOW) between the verses? And that when her lips aren't moving - you can't hear her? And that she sounds slightly different from the orignal? SHE CAN'T BE LIPSYNCING. This is an incredible performance - one of the multiple proofs of her incredible voice.
This song and dance is so 'Bollywoodish'😍 As an Indian , it wonderful to see international celebrities and artists getting inspired by our art & culture.🥳
![Charlie Puth & Selena Gomez - We Don't Talk Anymore [Official Live Performance]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/i_yLpCLMaKk/mqdefault.jpg)
Don't forget you can watch the official video for 'Come & Get It' here: Selena Gomez - Come & Get It (Official Video)
- Selena VEVO HQ
you are beautifu i love yoou :3
Thank u sand this video and i love watching this video.
I wach your video every day!)))
you ARE A BAD SINGER!!!!!
I love you
The bindi on her face the kathak moves sitting on the floor and the music and chorus just Indian vibes
Yesss, a beautiful mash of Indian and western music
Yess
ya
its not a vibe. it is.
I think in the music video there were Indian musicians so it is a mix
I am an Indian...and if she is imitating Indian culture then she has done it in a beautiful way..I loved her performance!
interesting
I can tell you A reason and she takes for Nepal that time she visited in Nepal
White people love to get angry over anything! This performance is beautiful and not offensive at all.
@@amanenr This world is cruel
this world is wicked
this world is deceitful
filled with all kinds of Temptations.
but…..
Deep in each of our hearts we do know, how to escape from evil and their lies, by COMING TO CHRIST: REPENT AND BORN AGAIN. in return getting: peace protection guidance comfort wisdom and understanding about heavenly things.
@@theharshtruthoutthere um no. The world is absolutely beautiful. Nature is the way
Not disrespecting Indian culture, representing it in the most beautiful way.
Every single one of the performances she does of this song just makes me fall in love with the song all over again!! it is so good!
What’s amazing is Selena remembering the whole choreography without missing a single step or even having to look at her fellow dancers for cues, while still singing this live. It’s not easy to manage dancing and singing plus she does this so effortlessly. Selena is a star for a reason!!!!
Omg! I just saw she was singing while dancing too! Oh my god such talent!
Well a lot of singers can do singing and dancing at the same time. But yes this performance was lit ❤️
@@tamanna4697 That’s not true. Apart from Beyonce not many singers can sing live and dance hard. Selena didn’t dance hard but she did really well remembering choreography plus song lyrics without going out of breath. It’s not as easy as you think
@@SashaDHottie I guess u never seen lady gaga then or pink , and Madonna etc and I can go on.
watch kpop
I am indian . And love sels voice and the indian music blend .. it's a masterpiece.. you are emost talented sel.. love 💕
She can't even lip sync properly
It's not her voice it's her autotune
@@shahlajaved1183 i mean every singer use autotune
@@audiroblox-240 No, some record many and choose the best one like Billie, some use vocal layering like Taylor, Some add a touch of autotune like Melanie, and some add tons of autotune and vocal layering like selena, she can't sing for shit
We love u Selena
honestly all the people who were complaining were probably not indians and just her haters in general. She's representing the dance culture beautifully and its very obvious that her team hired an expert on India culture or indian themselves.
Yes!
Yeah, though 2020 really just put a new perspective to people so cultural appropriation is really just a gray area
she could’ve had indian dancers though. it’s already so difficult for POC to get hired
Yes!!! She's not poor not to hire experts tho🥰
@@biancadesousa I-....just stop at this point...
Honestly one of the best dances I've seen from a live show. The dancing was beautiful and matched with the song. The music enhanced the dancing and vice versa. Love this song, amazing choreography!
Did you notice the occult hand jestures? The way this was performed as a 'ceremony' from start to finish?
The dancers are terrible, though. How can they be professionals? Who did the directing? They're all doing different moves, it's so weird.
on a “Selena Gomez Live Performances” marathon :)) hbu ??
Me too
me too lol
omg Ylonaa!!
Same!!
Your poor ears lol
She is doing Indian folk dance moves❤😍💃💃💃
Ydfdghf
@@keanmarielcuizon4649 did you get a seizure-?
@@disgustedrn4215 it’s Google translated
JSAMNHGREHSOGSNNSÑ6196
EN SOBGSIVTSKBkvvbnKbysnpnvb
Selena Gomez looks like a Barbie Doll that got soul in it. So stunning 😍😍😍
So true. She's like moon ❤️
I find barbie dolls freaky but I know what you mean
@@eenyweeny57 ❤️❤️❤️☺️
She is looking a barbie doll by wearing Indian cultural dress and people say Indian clothes bad
Everybody's talking about Selena's gorgeousness here but just see the look on a girl's face somewhere like 1:46 or 1:45
I'm an Indian and a classical dancer. Selena dance so well and thank you for representing our country
Being an Indian I am really glad that Selena chose our culture. This is really amazing and she dance so well......
It’s a Pakistani song… even I as a west asian felt like this could be from my culture but the language is different. It’s Pakistani.
@@R2d2.. When Selena herself said this was a tribute to her Indian fans why are you trynna prove that this has nothing to do with India? Jealous and Insecure much?
@@subhankarchakraborty2448 the song she uses in this song is a pakistani song not indian lol
@@subhankarchakraborty2448 also the person you are responding to is indian lol
@@mrym_. and song song was copied by a Pakistani Singer from Indian .. Moreover she is doing namaste and not Salam.
Are people not gonna talk bout this fire choreography? 🔥🔥🔥
@Aryan Raj 😂
It’s very much average tho🙄
@@ananyat6481 no it's amazing 🙄stfu no one cares
For someone with lupus she did an amazing job just think about how hard concerts and tours were for her
THE CHOREOGRAPHY IS AMAZING!!!! as a punjabi indian i absolutely love it!!!!!
I love how she dances in that Indian style. ...ending her beautiful performance with an Indian Namaste...🥰🥰😘😘💗💗
Yes cuz I am Indian
:)
🇮🇳
I am Indian too 🤗 I love her dance
Yes
I love this choreography. She totally killed this performance. Best live performance ever. Incredibly talented and graceful young lady.
Those who are saying that she is insulting india ...being an Indian let me tell you guys ...I liked her performance a lot and I don't think that this is insult at all ...but the actual insult is being done by our own bollywood actors ........lots of love for Selena
True❤️
Who said that
yes so true!
True
Didn't have to bring Bollywood into this, but except that, yea i agree
If anyone would do their research Selena can sing! 2013 was legit the year she was diagnosed with lupus and she had no idea how deal with it, didn't know how to cure it, probably didn't even know what it would do to her breathing at the time. I can tell this performance is t that great but you can clearly see she is trying so hard. Selena isn't Demi or Adele, if you want someone with a really strong voice then go listen to them but Selena has such a beautiful soft voice and that has been her voice since the beginning of her career, even before she was diagnosed. If you listen to her performances in 2015/2016 she sounds so much better. Her voice is stronger because she's been treating her lupus and she's been getting things done for it. But then for some performances she doesn't sound so great because it all fluctuates. Selena tries so hard and all people can ever do is bring her down for something that isn't her fault. Spread love guys, Selena tries her best.
I was wondering why Ate Selena is hardly breathing....Is she sick? I'm sorry if you putted the name of her illness, I'm 9 soo i don't understand much of what you said...
P.S Sorry for that😐
Ikr
+Ajalinel Andales she has lupus which can affect her breathing and vocal chords. She was diagnosed in 2013 so her singing was kinda all messed up cause she didn't know really how to deal with it. She's getting better everyday. Hope that helps :)
I thought she was diagnosed last year. Lupus has no cure btw it's chronic she will have to deal with it all her life.
+Thepomafame everywhere I've read it's either said 2013/ 2014. And yea she will have to leave with it but she gets treatments like chemo when it flares and gets bad. Right now it's really bad in terms of her mental health. She's been having really bad anxiety and depression recently because of the illness so her tour is on break.
See the choreography! She is not being overly energetic banging her head or shaking terribly still she is dances so gracefully! Just the right use of hands and hips...
Sinvergüenza.
yesssss😊
As an Indian and a selenator, this iconic performance would forever make me so happy!! I love you so much, Selena!
Gimmeee a hawwyeahhhh
ruclips.net/video/b9FunEkhTNo/видео.html
Right
Hahah yaa
F
F
Actually she is not disrespecting Indians she is representing the Indian culture ❤❤
Love from India ♥♥
Selena Gomez the strongest woman 😘😘
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥yes
I agree with you
what is there to represent ?
i dont get it ?
@@pallavi-nu6ow actually she is reshowing the Indian culture
I'm not an Indian or from India. However I totally understand and agree that she is Respectful and Representing the Indian Culture. Funny how the ones who complain the most aren't even Indians!
I remember trying to learn this dance when I was like 9 years old🤣
update: i’m here 2 years later, i’m 17 y’all! i think i still remember the dance, i’m gonna have to try it out lmao
somniagirl same 😂😭
Sameee
LMAOOO SAMEE
Me toooo💕💕💕
Omg Sameee Haha 😂💓🤣
I am honestly happy that Selena has chosen our dance of india and she pulled it off beautifully ❤️❤️
A moment when i feel is she is wearing something indian dress with bindi on her head btw looking gorgeous she is as always..💙😘😍
I am indian 😎
At 0:52, it showed too much.
@@shimmer4771 what it showed?
@@meghashah7099 i just normally said a moment when i feel, something like Indian dress that doesn't mean I'm saying that it is an Indian dress..
@@meghashah7099 😅 I just cleared your doubt..I didn't angry on your reply..
People need to know what cultural appropriation actually is. She isn’t appropriating, she is appreciating.
@@Shelby-hp5fz It would be uncomfortable for her to perform in a traditional dress of any Indian culture and just because she is wearing a bindi, doesn’t mean she has to make everything indian-style.
@@rashidamorawala3338 isn't that what cultural appropriation is?
using selected parts of a specific culture to match your music's aesthetic purposes while there are people around the world who get made fun of for wearing the same thing ?
@@blueblooms8740F.O
@@rashidamorawala3338 because they don't know what cultural appropriation is. No need to be offended to know it's cultural appropriation. Indians are made fun of because of their clothing,the way they eat with hands and also the skin color so a white person using it for aesthetic is not right.
It's like wearing dreads and saying you're appreciating black culture.
@@rashidamorawala3338 tamils (indian descendants ) were killed in our country for simply wearing a bindi .
people: this is cuLtUrAl aPpROpRiaTioN
Indians: she looks so good in our style 😍😍😍
True 😂
Seriously.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
It also Bangladeshi Culture ☺☺
lmaoo tru tho
This song went next level just by adding the tabla and Indian beats. Awesome music 🎶
Need more such type of fusion.
To the haters: Selena CAN sing, she CAN dance, and she CAN act. You're really all just jealous of her. You're so miserable with your own lives you have to take it out on her. She's 100 percent talented
She can dance and act but she can't sing
yeah she can act like she can sing :D I agree Brooke
THANK YOU!!! Finally someone who agrees with me :)
Ye AGREE
You clearly do not understand a good voice from a bad
She's talented to be able to dance and sing at the same time y'all don't know that complicated!
You right i try to sing and dance at the same time but i always end up hurting my self
it's called endless rehearsals
Listen to kpop
I am not sure but i think she is lipsyncing there. Or it's specially recorded before for this performance. It doesn't sound live 🤷🏼♀️
Patrīcija Teivāne no it’s obvious it’s live
Omg! She is wearing a bindi
Yes ma'am I'll do both of those and my music and whatever else you asked me to show you again thanks 🍎
Yaass
@@alehouseturismo1704 Why so feisty bro ???
Cool down.. she just asked in excitement
Hooo sss
bindi tika wow
My dad was the first to fall in love with Selena and keeps calling her sweet words untill I got to listen to her and fell in love with both her and her music, she's such a lovely person. I pray she finds peace.
So difficult to dance and sing at the same time,but you could. You are the best
+Настя Александрова beyonce can do it why cant selena
Stacy from malaysia can do it too.😉
Aferin kadın
+Настя Александрова She was doing a lip sync when she was dancing.. She sang it live when she paused dancing, if you observed it properly
i was also thinking of that.
3:49 it's an Indian classical dance pose. Especially of "Kathak". I know it as I am a kathak dancer from last 11 years.
She should've done this performance in India 😍
I agree
Yesssss❤️
As an indian, she looks drop dead gorgeous. She absolutely killed with this one.
I was getting Indian vibes from this song...was wondering if I was just imagining it but she’s actually representing my country, thanks Selena!
She has said that this song was inspired by Indian culture
People : she's disrespecting indians
Indians :wow she look gorgeous
Dont worry, indians get very easily offended also, this video simply isn't offensive at all thats all
@@tuhimerameraa1 sorry, that wasn't a question, it was a fact based in my observations.
@@quantumpolariton122 well, make better observations, because as an Indian, we ain't snowflakes.
@@tuhimerameraa1 we are snowflakes and I am Indian.
Indians are really emotional
they just want an air like modi lahar and they would really blew away
this is modern form of culture and traditions and people should accept as time ellapsed
is anyone here just going to say how amazing she sounds????
meeeee
Yes
Playback
Kirsty Birsty In this video/performance is playback because she’s dancing
Did she lip it or no cos if not then wow she really proved ppl wrong that she lips
I love that she’s respecting and representing my beautiful Indian culture this isn’t inappropriate or offensive this is beyond incredible!!! I love it so much I love and respect Selena Gomez!!!❤️❤️✨✨🇮🇳🇮🇳
🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
i'm here after the “boyfriend”'s mv and now i really really wanna see her do this performance again on rare world tour :(
Ghina Fadhila same🥺
The Tabla Is everything. ♥🔥
💯
The man's voice is amazingggggg
@@dontstalkme5332 It’s a woman
@@dthebadone123456 I'm not talking about Selena
@@dthebadone123456 the first part...the man's voice
she's a good dancer. Coolest part of the performance. Most people can't dance like that
All Kpop artists can do much more than that.
+Love Styles probably they don't know about BOA lmao
Beyonce and Britney are better lol
pretty sure anyone can so a few cool hand movements with some hips but ok
+Frankie Pie Janet Jackson was better
Oh, I remember this. I loved it then. I love it now. She’s awesome.
*HER RESPECT FOR INDIA IS JUST.. NO WORDS*
(proud to hear this song as an indian)
its pakistani
@@cureheadwhore5453
Ofc 😂 well done👏
@@cureheadwhore5453 her dance and bindi is representing Indian culture.. that's why it looks more Indian.. ( it's perception that Pakistani culture is similar to Arab and afgan)
Cureheadwhre are u stupid? 1. It's Indian song, paxtani copying it and remaking it years later doesn't make it paxtani.
2. Selena is using Indian classical dance bharatnatyam, Kathak dance steps/ hand gestures.
3. Selena is wearing Indian Hindu bindi on forehead.
4. Selena sed Indian Hindu namaste!! not Paxtan Muslim salam alaikum.
5. Selena dedicated this performance for her Indian audience not paxtani.
6. Paxtan is islamic Muslim country that wears black burka, bans singing and dance in islam saying it's haram. Neither do paxtani Muslims do Indian Hindu dance forms like bharatnatyam, Kathak dedicated to Hindu gods, nor they wear Hindu bindi on foreheard that is linked to Hindu god. So there is nothing paxtani in her performance..get a life troll ##
@@cureheadwhore5453 no it’s not. Stop feeling insecure
*THE FACT THAT THIS YOUNG WOMAN EVEN HAVING LUPUS AND SO MUCH HATERS (CRITICIZING HER VOICE, PERSONAL LIFE, ETC) EFFORTS TO DANCE LIKE THAT AND SINGING AT THE SAME TIME SHOWS HOW MUCH STRONG AND PASIONATE SHE IS BOUT HER JOB*
*THATS THE KIND OF ARTIST I STAN*
i dont see often many artist these last years having these kind of issues and facing it like that
It’s drugs
Word.
セレーナゴメスを幼い現役時代から、ロングヘアの重度のダウン症の私を応援してくれてありがとうございます。
Bro she is lyp sync ing its pre recorded she just danced never sang
@@bhoomi8503 sure, have a nice day
Who is getting Indian feel in this 🙂
Meee
Me!
Me too
Meh
Me😊😊😊
2023 and this is still her best song. The dance, the music, the energy . Perfection 👌
she said she hated that song x.x
@@MiloCarrete she can have her own opinion about it. But can’t deny how powerful she felt during this era
No one gonna talk about how amazingly she control her vocals with that hard dancing#selenator
Yesss
@@myyeschannel what do you mean? 🤣🤣🤣 you actually haven't seen any artists who dance and sing at the same time?? For real???
She’s lip syncing lol
@@myyeschannel bts😂
Selena can't sing live.
It's a well-known fact
amongst music enthusiast. Then again,
you could be new. 🤣
It’s not Indian feels the begining IS Indian and the background music is with an electro beat on top
And she is doing Indian dance moves and is wearing a bindi as well
@@aahanachakraborty ikr
She literally said this was inspired by Indian culture and more..... y’all are so late and STUPID
@@ratpoop273 can u relax bruh? When the hell did OP say anything disrespectful? You're acting stupid
@@tithisings not them in talking about other people
@@ratpoop273 none of the Indians even said that this is cultural appropriation. Also u said "yall are late and STUPID"
Selena you are looking gorgeous and dance was amazing .
Selena is effortlessly beautiful. She’s one of a kind
well, not gonna lie, she's actually a good dancer
IKR
This poor thing look like he.🤣
I agree with you
@@t.t621 maybe make that make sense
@@deborahnorman5117 ??
Welcome to another series of,"why is this in my recommended after 6 years?"
🤣😃😃😃
Me too
sameeee
Exactly lol
Yeah
I feel like if this would've came out in 2020 people would've canceled her for "cultural appropriation"
Ikr I was just thinking about that lmao
Yeah I'm surprised by the lack of offended comments lol
And there's Indian people in the comments saying they are proud. Culture appropriation is pure bullshit. Being racist is a problem, culture appropriation is just another way to complain about insignificant things
Like Ariana Grande when she put out the video for 7 rings
TRUE
The music sounds so relaxing
This India look and effect is making me fall more in love with her!!!
Amazing love the Indian Selena
She looks so stunning with that bindi 👁️👄👁️
Selena ki bindiya chura k le gyi meri nindiya 😂😎😎😆
I can say that even if some are saying she is disrespecting the culture of indian individuals this was in 2013 and out of some of the artists since and even before that have tried to do simular nods to cultures, hers was the least problematic and it was apparent she took great effort in making this performance as respectful as possible.
Can we say this performance " a Bollywood touch"
More like Indian traditional music cause the tabla and all
@@tithisings bollywood songs also have Tablas. And this is not proper indian culture but it's very similar to bollywood dances more. So let's say this dance is bollywood ish
@@dontstalkme5332 bollywood songs don't usually have tabla. Maybe drums, but not tabla. If u check out her music video of this song, u can see Indian men wearing traditional outfits with the traditional hat on too and playing tabla. So it's more of Indian traditional music than bollywood. Bollywood is a whole other genre
@@tithisings the dance is bollywood ish. And the song is bollywood ish (only a lil bit tho,more electronic music) I was correcting u only, I respect Selena so much for representing us Indians and she tried her best and this was a top notch performance
@@dontstalkme5332 i love selena as well! My intention wasn't to shame her or anything lol. I'm glad she represented Indians too. Im even more glad that she RESPECTFULLY did this. Like she didn't just use an Indian kinda beat and acted like it was her own. She wore a bindi, which shows even more that she respected the origins of her song and tried her best to dance kinda in an Indian style way and even wore the appropriate clothes that had a tiny Indian touch to it. But in my opinion only the dance is bollywood ish. Obviously the music also sounds bollywood ish since bollywood is literally Indian traditional music but slightly changed, but i do think it's more Indian traditional music than bollywood. Especially the tabla part at the beginning. We're just gonna have to agree to disagree on that lol. I think it's more traditional Indian music cause i myself have also done lessons on Indian traditional music btw! And this is very similar to that than to bollywood
she's pretty
her body is amazing
she can dance
she's an incredible actriss
she's a singer
no one can be more perfect than my queen
True!!!
Lain x ella canta mejor que ti
How about ariana
+Lain x Has escuchado sus conciertos acusticos? Deberias cerrar la boca porque no sabes de lo que hablas.
+Lain x De que carajos hablas??? Yo nunca dije que Selena es la mejor cantante del mundo, deja de inventar. Si lei tu comentario pero eso no cambia nada, es absurdo.
I don't really understand why it matters who can sing, who can't sing, who sings live, and who doesn't. They're all talented people in their own special, unique way, and if ya'll don't think so, then just don't listen to them. It's not a law saying that you have to. It's all so unnecessary, and not called for. And, if you do like it, just sit back and enjoy the music. There is no need for all of the name calling of the celebrities like ya'll know who they really are, personally. All you're doing is making them more famous by talking about them. So, they win either way it goes.
You're right ! Just let them know the truth
AMEN!!!!
AllAboutMe why are u listening to her music if you aren't a fan? #Pathetic u know what's funny you are here bashing singers on youtube while they are out there making shit loads a cash. Who is winning?
lashaun clayton Woah there, he was just making a statement. He didn't criticize anything specifically about her
Cannot beleive in 2022 i still love her performance.I have never ever seen such a brave girl like her yaar.If she can do her best in her critical situation then i think she can do anything. Leaving this comment her so if someone likes it in future i can enjoy this performance again!
I just fall in love with Selena's bindi 😍😍😍
Love from India 🇮🇳 you looking pretty amazing in bindi and you brought our culture upfront through this fusion style
She loves India she says it all the time so this is her way to show it . I loved this performance and what she’s wearing STUNNING
Those who are saying she is representing Pakistani Culture, she might be using Pakistani tune and song, but the dressing style, the bindi , the dance and the namaste in the end is Indian and not Pakistani... So the song is Pakistani, but she is representing Indian culture and Indian Subcontinent at the same time.
There is only one word for it "Beautiful."
This is my mum's song when she calls me for dinner
😂😂😂
Lmao
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🥺🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣
XD
I am not an Indian but she looks so nice in Indian style 😍💜
Ya.... She looks gorgeous.
It's 2024 how many here ?
Me haha
Me ❤
Aquiiiii
Here!
Me
This all is inspired by indian culture like her dresseup and her dance moves music almost everything😊
Thnx for the information...i knew it..😂
Proud to be a Belieber ....hey man
She is not from India
@@jaedynb2045 really
I think the dress is more gymnastic style than indian!!!
selena u are amazing and u made indians proud by trying this... kisses from india...😘
bindi on selena's forehead is looking just like full moon tonight...so pretty 🤗
Yep
Her voice is even more beautiful live
The woman who is sing so beutiful
is và sing đều là động từ ^^.
selena gomez
it selana Gomez
Phuong Uyen Duong selena 😊
she is salena gomez
Her best performance of this song! Slay queen👏🏻
Every Indian telling that they don't find this offensive and that everyone's saying that this is offensive when it's not.
Meanwhile me who didn't find a single comment saying that this is offensive:
👁👄👁
This is all new comments we can see probably we can't find that old comments who were being offensive
@@itzfatema yeah that's possible. RUclips could have deleted the offensive comment.
Same bro all are saying this shit but I don't find any comment on this
I was too like 👁️👄👁️ where are those comments 😂😂😂
That's bcus you are just 8 years late. There were some comments which might have been deleted now or you can find them just by scrolling down for 5 to 6 mins.
Although wasting 5 min to see a Negative comment is not worth it. 💀
This is for the 1st time that I m watching sel's Indianized version n I m just so surprised n feeling sooo proud at the same time as an Indian..Shez such a positive person n such a strong feminine personality n when shez here representing Indian culture so beautifully..its just an amazing feeling..when I was going thru the same experience as her in my life,each day people around me trying to dim my light, I came across a video of hers n that was just so full of positivity n courage to face them all with no regrets,no negativity n instead with love..that was so healing..thats the only way to heal ourselves n humanity..as an empath I cud connect to her soul..shez really a pure soul ..shez Divine ..love u dear..will always respect u 4 wat u r at the core..
❤️❤️❤️
For a moment I just thought that she is in India
Any one from India here in 2019 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Me🙋
Yes
Indocanadian. Do you accept it?
@@Anonymous-uh3lu Yes, we accept this
👍👍👍
I too
CAN WE TALK OF HOW AN AMAZING DANCER SHE IS LIKE THAT CHOREOGRAPHY WAS FIRE SHE KILLED IT WITHOUT MISSING A NOTE AND THAT DRESS WAS SO PRETTY IM GLAD SHE DID IT IN THIS ERA CUZ NOW SHE WOULD OF GOTTEN CANCELED CUZ EVERYTHING IS OFFENSIVE NOW A DAYS but the other comments Indian are proud of her culture representation 😁👏🇮🇳
Omg I cannot believe it.Selena did namaskar (Indian style) even the beats that play back are tabla indian style!
Her new song Good For U kinda has an Indian feel to it as well
Her new song and my (good for you) also have Indian feelings for me too
Ikr right!!
One of my favourite performances of her. So talented ♥️
Hi there as an Indian I truly appreciate her performance along with the background dancers and also did you guys noticed she was dancing and singing as well she is MULTI-TALENTED!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️
western Celebrities getting Tanned and meanwhile in India.......
"fAiR aNd LoVely"
😂😂😂
It’s so ironic, the light want to get darker and the dark want to get lighter, I’m not speaking generally cause I know there are some who don’t but it’s just an irony of life really
I looked that up Indians actually weren't always obsessed with pale skin...when the British people came to India,they were like coloured ppl are dirty,poor etc. And just racist to the Indians...and that made them complex abt their skin tone....and it still continues..ppl with lighter skin got the genes from the British ppl who lived in India and now they're considered good looking....they're basically still living in the 70's...and still racist to each other
Smh
@@richbtch546 😑 lighter skin is not from British 🤦 only few people have it from British people
I am an Indian and I loove the music.... 💖💖😍😍😍😍
I am also indian....and i love salena and salena all songs❤💖💞
Coming to me, I'm Indian. Recently, I has been heard this song on Instagram and when I noticed Indian music in her song I really fall in love with this song ❤ her voice and Indian music given much attraction and attention towards this song and I'm obsessed with song and from the few years onwards I love Selena Gomez ❤️ she's amazing person in reality I respect her . Her voice and Indian music became plus point to this song ❤ I love this now
I can't believe she did this song for the kids at Disney.
She’s not a Disney star anymore grandpa she’s 27 years old now and when that song came out she was like 21 or 20
@@Lamas826 He was talking about the past. He said "did" because she DID preform this at a Disney award show for a young audience. No hate to Selena, but you just aggressively went after an innocent comment for no reason. He was simply stating his shock of a song talking about coming and getting it to a crowd full of 12 year olds
I know, right? But it sounded and looked gracious though. So...I guess it was fine.
That's to show..she didn't forget where she came from..kids were her first audience
I think the kids didn't know what the song is actually about so it's ok I guess
1:44 she is doing "NAMASTE" wow😍😍😍
its Indian dancing style @selenagomez
yup😁
Yes
I'm Indian. This isn't Indian dancing... LOL> it's Fusion
10 years later, this video is a beautiful reminder of the times when your star shone brightest.
Yes, yes, time... a monster that cannot be negotiated with. And it is believed that the brighter they shine, the faster they disappear.
I love Selena.....anyone from India?
me hii
Meeee....i love my india....
Me too....
I am !
me
Her best live performance
I can't believe this was 3 years ago...
Same like where is time going? :O
Like you 😢
I know right 😕 x
ikr
me either
I love this video because it's the only time I actually saw Selena dance and being confident
She is doing Indian dance moves🙆woww... music is also indian👌.. she is doing superb😍
You do realise that you can hear her catch her breath (VERY SLOW) between the verses? And that when her lips aren't moving - you can't hear her? And that she sounds slightly different from the orignal? SHE CAN'T BE LIPSYNCING. This is an incredible performance - one of the multiple proofs of her incredible voice.
the weirdo. this waa 4 years ago so...
Hgyjg tiff
I'm 43 and it is the best performance I have ever seen.
Risque Rabbit The Home spa You didnt see many performances, did you?
the weirdo. *Who cares? Video got a bunch of likes/views so..😂*
love u Selena your indian style is just awesome .. no words
amo a india y selena debe de hacer películas con actores hindues
This song and dance is so 'Bollywoodish'😍
As an Indian , it wonderful to see international celebrities and artists getting inspired by our art & culture.🥳