Manny Jew it’s not like she has a normal cold I think it was this year that it was confirmed that she had lupus which affects your immune system as a result which causes a long line of illness so as one said ur an ignorant ass
Thomas Conway you are honestly ignorant if you can’t even admit that she’s improved. Compare this to her most recent performances. Like her performance of same old love 2 years ago on Ellen. Or her performance son SNL a year ago. You can tell that she’s better now compared to this “come and get it” era. but continue being ignorant and a hater I guess lol.
I respect that she's singing live. Take notes, this is what a live performance sounds like while dancing. The breaths and jumps in the voice. Although I'm a fan... I'm not delusional. If y'all think that Beyonce is dancing like that while holding the perfect pitch you guys are so naive
ok so she can't sing that great, that's fine we like imperfect because her songs are amazing and not gonna lie its nice to know that you don't have to have a perfect pitch to pursue your passion.
Bruh she's sick that time imagine having lupus your body attacking your own immune system and she still managed to smile, dance, and sing. Have some respect
I appreciate her doing this after going through all that. But can't appreciate the performance because it's just not good. Dancing was average, singing was bad. But still appreciate her so much for doing this but I think everyone will prefer artists being able to do their best performance when they are physically fine
@@jonasxrblx9810 she could simply have not done this performance. Cannot appreciate something that is obviously bad and try to hide the fact by putting on an excuse of being ill. I know it's difficult, very difficult to do this with that. But simply could have chosen to not do it when you are not doing good
Jello xx please watch her live performances before you say something , every artist lip syncs, selena does the same but most of the time like revival era of star dance tour she NEVER lip synced or bij her ama of vma performances so shush please
making edits every artist does not lip sync like lady Gaga. She said numerous times she’s never lip sync. But Selena never sings live. she got caught lip syncing at jingle ball where she was performing and Ariana called her out on it. Ariana was having technical difficulties and Selena was caught lip syncing before that and Ariana said “at least you know I’m not a track right”. It’s obvious people know that Selena doesn’t sing live. People aren’t pulling this out of thin air. Look up all the times she’s got caught lip syncing.
Jello xx like i said watch her revival era live performances , and then u can come back and say something , kay , selena has a soft she doesn’t have one like ariana but it’s still lovely
@@overwicket1339 Girl No ones even heard of that and Nick's married now chile please do your research before saying thats why she gets alot of hate her, most ppl dont even know she used to date Nick bye
Y’all do know this isn’t lipsynced.... it’s called a high backtrack. She’s still singing live. And no it’s not the best but 1. she’s dancing and 2. At this time her lupus was extremely bad. Y’all are just ignorant and disgusting people. It’s always the people judging others who can’t actually sing themselves.
【VictoriasSecretHeaven】 i know that. I’m saying Indian as I’m referring to Native Indians aka “Native Americans”. You look like the fool here with all that hatred in your heart.
I think she did it very well. Try to do that yourself, bet you can't. And, also, she's dancing at the same time. Respect to her, she's a very talented girl. ❤️
m g the choreo are not difficult, kpop idol do difficult choreo and sing at the same time, but she did a great job and i heard that she was sick, so respect to her ❤️
@@bittertea9983 She didn't insult the culture in any way.The music,the dance,make up everything was on point.The makers of the song did their homework pretty well.So,I'd rather say it's a cultural appreciation. If you still wanna hate,go and watch some kdramas and kpop.It's them who know nothing about the culture and still copy it(mock it).They really need to get outta there well.
It's Dhvani Đ26 the indian dressing is due to the fact that the song has indian influences....she wears indian influenced attire for performing this song
I love Selena and I really want to say that she sounds like that because she is dancing and singing the same time but man have you seen little mix dancing and singing the time?!it's an incredible view
@Sarah Lattari let me stop you here.I dare you to search Little Mix singing live.They NEVER use autotune.And please let's face it.Selena can not sing good live and we all know that.I literally ADORE her and I know what she has been through..break up and health issues,I know everything.Also the girls of little mix and Selena have almost the same age and if you don't know the story of this group please don't say anything.They have dealt with bullying,anxiety,anorexia and one member has been through a really bad breakup that lead her to depression and she couldn't sing live because she would get emotional.❤
@@onlyme1875 guys lmao.this is what I believe and what many people believe.You won't change my opinion because I know it's right.This is ridiculous actually.I can't even express my freaking opinion.Also why do you believe my first comment has so many likes?!Because so many people share the same opinion with me.If you don't then it's okay but that doesn't we have to agree with you but you don't have to agree with us either.I want to ask you something and I want your honest answer.Do you believe Selena can actually sing good live?And don't say again she is a solo artist.Beyonce,Taylor Swift,Ellie Goulding,Ed Sherran and SO MANY MORE are solo artists but they can sing 4 songs without stopping,dancing the same time and still sing very good.So please before you say something I would ask you to see the facts you have in your hands and then decide what is right to say.Also if an artist has good voice means that has good voice and CAN sing live,Selena's voice isn't that good live.We alcan understand this for so many live performances of hers.I am telling you this with love and respect.❤
@@Ellie-cl6mj You can't say your opinion is right. No opinion is right. It has your opinion and my opinion, but not right opinion. Yes, Selena isn't good live at singing, but you still can't compare 4 women with 1. Every member in Little Mix has part of the song, but not the whole song. Selena sings the whole song alone. That's why you can't compare them.
Gerald I miss her so much she's so confident and looks so healthy in here where did that Selena go? What they've done to her? She should know how amazing she is 💔
Well you need to speak near mike that's near her neck to speak as anything far like even a few centimetres won't be caught by a mic due to noise cancellation tech! I used a mike and I am saying this by my personal experience and sorry if it's wrong! Edit: well I'm a doctor or will be in few days! (SEASON)
i know that girl isn't that really good in singing but you can't deny the fact that she making hits. everytime she releasing songs it become trending. her lyrics are filled with meaningful that can motivate you. ❤ i love this woman no matter
Making hits does not mean u are good at the craft, it means u have loyal fans would buy anything u put out no matter how bad it is and u have a strong record label behind u ready to pump in money for promotions. That's how the industry works.
Her songs go trendy because she never writes them. Big labels and great artists likes to work with her because of her followers. She has a huge blind followers who worship her as if she is a goddess. Credit mostly goes to her PR who never fails her
she must have something that she has so many blind followers. No PR, no writers can get you that much love if you dont have something that makes you have that. Later everything in addition makes her that famous including the PR team, the workers, the people in her life.
@@rachelbegmusic that is not true. It's your PR's job to make you put your best foot out. Plus some celebrities are like crybabies and who doesn't like a cry baby. They gain sympathy out of their miseries. The only thing Selena has is a very beautiful face that's it!
Ryce this is her voice in 2013, but her voice has improved, look at the songs she sang from the racial album, before her singing wasn't good, and it's getting hetter😊
KWON SOONYOUNG& MIN YOONGI “normal singers”?? you’re a disappointment as an army. A lot of artists struggle with singing while dancing. Even jungkook struggled with it at the beginning and eventually trained his endurance to be able to sing well while dancing. (I’m a predebut army). Even amazing singers like Ariana grande struggle with singing while moving around let alone dancing. Besides this was a performance from 2013, she’s obviously improved a lot now. Keep in mind that this choreo was super strenuous and she has lupus too which causes acid to hit her throat/vocal cords soooo. Continue being ignorant if you want. I suggest you do research next time before you make a comment like that. Even the most amazing artists had to train hard to be able to be stable singers while dancing. Why do you think Kpop artists train for so long? If I misunderstood your comment, please let me know
It’s definitely not her greatest performance, but she’s dancing throughout the entire song and it’s hard to sing when you’re out of breath from dancing and I applaud her so trying her best.
Come on guys! Not everyone have to be Beyonce, is not every artist that can sing and dance at the same time! She was trying to do her best, it doesn't worked, but she tryied. We have to give her credits.
+R 2001 This is from 2013, she's getting better, every year her voice is getting so nice. Also, why people don't talk about her great dance moves, her acting, everything that she does it's successful, because she's a amazing artist. If someone don't have something good to say, is bettet not say anything. Wanna be critic, be a critic, but don't be unfair. It' directly to you +R 2001, this is for the haters, they talk bullshits and don't search about, so stupid. Sad. All love
I love Selena, she is very talented but she lacks things when she is performing live, she can sing but she needs a lot more training. I know this is old and she improved so much from this!
Her dance is inspired by Indian Bollywood dance and its not a easy smooth thing , so her make up and look , but with singing and dancing like that at the same point .... I mean its call a whole great petfomence so #respect .
This woman is just freaking gorgeoussssssssss. Damn that red really takes her. The makeup outfit everything looked so amazing on her.🔥 True Selenators still here 2021💕
She a performer, I don’t get why people always criticize her singing ability. She has a descent singing voice. Just because you have a good singing voice doesn’t mean you are a good entertainer. Selena is a triple threat. Tamar Braxton is a good singer but not a good entertainer, a lot of good singers are not big because they go overboard
when it comes to selena gomez everyone are vocal coaches or producers If you don't like Selena's music, there are many more artists that you might like, go listen to them. And if you're here just to spread hate, gurl, get a life.
@@natallyemonteiro2114 She can’t sing live at all. She sounds terrible people like her because she’s Selena Gomez but her voice does not sound good at all
@@igotlostinmadsland5421 Nope, her voice is great. She got you feeling like you're stepping on buildings, cars and boats! You swear you can touch the sky! Ohhhhhh, you're ten feet tall!
FashionLoveSmile hahah it’s funny how you’re getting so pressed 😂😂 hope you fix the insecurities within yourself hun 💕 spend your time doing something productive rather than cursing at people online and hating on people that you don’t know personally. Fact of the matter is Sel is doing what she loves and she has fans that love her. She may not be your cup of tea but at the end of the day, you’re still irrelevant and she’s still making that money 🤑🤑
FashionLoveSmile lmao goodnight. You’re clearly the idiot 😂 saying you don’t get pressed yet you’re the one that commented, “get your ears checked!” on someone else’s comment. I hope you learn to be nice and get an education love! 💕💕 I’m guessing you’re probably younger than 16
I'm seeing my fellow desis praising her and like, it's ok and definitely not cultural appropriation but, it doesn't fit in with the song..? She legit just put it in there to seem 'exotic' smh
shriya raina she’s mexican. she could easily have used her own culture but it wouldn’t have fit with the song, the song has obvious indian influences. & i doubt it was her idea, probably someone from her team.
Kristopher Howse literally she is barely dancing so many artists dance and sing at the same time and do it amazingly. This is her job and she is not good at it she really needs to stick to acting. She was not made for this at all
It's awful that she did this and is still getting credit for the Indian elements in the music as though she could have made it up not to mention the rampant racism and disregard for west and south asia.
The sound of her voice isn’t bad but she has no technique or pitch she just sounds the same she can’t really do no riffs or runs and when she sings somewhat higher again no technique just like a monotone voice
Esta presentación es una de las mejores de esta canción si no es la mejor, su voz estaba temblorosa pero no podemos negar que lo dio todo en el baile, temazo que fue un hit mundial.
Do you know what I hate? When someone says watch this video as proof that she's a bad singer. And then they say "tHe ChOReO iS nOt ThAt hArD" Chile please do this choreo with the SAME energy AND sing at the same time! It does not matter how SIMPLE the choreography is. As long as you're doing the steps FULL OUT, it IS difficult to SING and DANCE at the same time. And please no one should bring k-pop idols as an example here cause American musicians do not spend years being "trainees" before they finally debut.
Vocally not the best but at least her dancing was good 😂 I never really got the whole meme that selena can’t sing until now.. like I’ve seen how she’s improved tho 🥴💀
Are you stupid? She's respecting it, she's literally just dancing a dance inspired from Bollywood and the Indians are okay with it they actually like it. Y'all learnt the words cultural appropriation and won't stop using it.
noo, that mean , everybody says she lipsync and that's not true , at that time , she has a lupus , and she dancing while singing , because that she sing like that , but its okay , im still love her no matter what 💘
Singing & Dancing especially on the ground is NOT easy! I'm proud of her idc if this is old she's still doing the damn thing! She could've copped out and lip-synced like tons of others always do! But NOPE she did the damn thing!
Here from the Buzzfeed article of hit songs musicians hate. Selena said she hated this song mainly because it was difficult to perform. Apparently it was a Rihanna reject - seems like it maybe a bit out of Selena’s range (for live performance with dancing).
PEOPLE WHO MADE HATE COMMENTS ABOUT IT *PROBABLY DONT KNOW SHE HAS LUPUS, DONT KNOW WHAT LUPUS IS AND DONT EITHER KNOW SHES A HUMAN* ICANT BELIEVE HOW STUPID CAN PEOPLE BE MAKING HATE ON HER PERFORMANCES
![DDG & G Herbo - Nosey [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I9Ra0Zc2NlQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Imagine having her health issues, dancing, singing, and doing all of that at once. Give this girl some damn well deserved RESPECT.
she deserves respect for everything but not for singing lol cause shes doing it too bad
Manny Jew it’s not like she has a normal cold I think it was this year that it was confirmed that she had lupus which affects your immune system as a result which causes a long line of illness so as one said ur an ignorant ass
Manny Jew okay? And? Are you done?
You know kpop?
@Nishtha Budholia what is kpop
I fucking love Selena with a passion, I know she didn’t sound that good singing live back then but she has improved a lot in her singing career
BurgerMeat she really hasn’t
This is from 2013, she’s improved a lot from then (:
Thomas Conway you are honestly ignorant if you can’t even admit that she’s improved. Compare this to her most recent performances. Like her performance of same old love 2 years ago on Ellen. Or her performance son SNL a year ago. You can tell that she’s better now compared to this “come and get it” era. but continue being ignorant and a hater I guess lol.
she isn't't that really good but damn her lyrics through her all songs are filled with meaningful and deep lyrics. and she is so kind hearted woman
Pink Isha she didn't even write her song
Atleast she is not lip syncing like kpop idols!!
She did justice to bindi.The grace, the power, the purity, i'm in lovvvvvveeee🔥🔥🔥❤❤❤❤
I respect that she's singing live. Take notes, this is what a live performance sounds like while dancing. The breaths and jumps in the voice. Although I'm a fan... I'm not delusional. If y'all think that Beyonce is dancing like that while holding the perfect pitch you guys are so naive
That’s a mic feed! We can totally hear the difference between her live singing and the backtrack. It was pretty good
She is looking fabulous in indian makeup+bindi 😍😍 like who love selena makeup
LA VERDADERA REINAAAAA POR DIOS CANTA HERMOSOOO
Wow indian style I loved it selena 💜I love you baby
Wooooohhhh!!!!!! I couldn't make it out she was Selena when she came in the beginning........ 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰 I Iove her....from India 🥰 I too sing ❤️
Actually selena is looking like a Indian really.love u queen
The best of all
Podemos hablar de la energía , seguridad y pasión que el "publico" le robo a Selena :( ?
Duele pero es cierto, ella tenia tanta confianza y energia
ok so she can't sing that great, that's fine we like imperfect because her songs are amazing and not gonna lie its nice to know that you don't have to have a perfect pitch to pursue your passion.
2020❤SELENA GOMEZ.
I love her
Let her live
Goddess Selena.
La mejor Selena Gomez es sensacional
Queen 😍
LINDA😍❤
Whoever dares too say something rude to my queen you better sleep with one eye open
Bruh she's sick that time imagine having lupus your body attacking your own immune system and she still managed to smile, dance, and sing. Have some respect
Fr and she might still have it she literally struggles to squeeze a lemon and people expect her to sound like adele live
you guys do know this is from 2013 right?😐💕
@@stevenmaldonado14 yea and that was when she found out she had lupus
I appreciate her doing this after going through all that. But can't appreciate the performance because it's just not good. Dancing was average, singing was bad. But still appreciate her so much for doing this but I think everyone will prefer artists being able to do their best performance when they are physically fine
@@jonasxrblx9810 she could simply have not done this performance. Cannot appreciate something that is obviously bad and try to hide the fact by putting on an excuse of being ill. I know it's difficult, very difficult to do this with that. But simply could have chosen to not do it when you are not doing good
she is dancing and singing at the same time , some respect man
It’s called lip singing. Selena Gomez is known for lip singing.
Jello xx please watch her live performances before you say something , every artist lip syncs, selena does the same but most of the time like revival era of star dance tour she NEVER lip synced or bij her ama of vma performances so shush please
making edits every artist does not lip sync like lady Gaga. She said numerous times she’s never lip sync. But Selena never sings live. she got caught lip syncing at jingle ball where she was performing and Ariana called her out on it. Ariana was having technical difficulties and Selena was caught lip syncing before that and Ariana said “at least you know I’m not a track right”. It’s obvious people know that Selena doesn’t sing live. People aren’t pulling this out of thin air. Look up all the times she’s got caught lip syncing.
Lmaoo "singing" 😭💀 Girl everyone knows she is lip singing.
Jello xx like i said watch her revival era live performances , and then u can come back and say something , kay , selena has a soft she doesn’t have one like ariana but it’s still lovely
She is wearing Bindi oh my gosh, she is looking very beautiful in bindi. Any Indian here...
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳💜💜💃💃💃♥️♥️
BTW thank u for 1k likes..😅
😍😍🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳😎😎🔥🔥
Proud to be indian🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@thesinginggirl1493 we all are proud dude...please comment something else. We are making fun of ourselves evrywhere.
Yeah❣️
I thought Selena is an indian, Selena's beauty is like an indian
This music has,touch of indian music...who agrees?
Me
Yes💯💯✨
@@bittertea9983 Are you Indian?
@@mrunmayee_ambulkar aren't punjabi people Indians..
@@rasikadurbule3025 yeah they are bro, just trying to specify the regional influence of Indian music in this song
I don't understand the hate. I really like the way she signs
@Hated yeah your right
@Hated T H I S
@Hated OOP YOU SPILLED
@@overwicket1339 Girl No ones even heard of that and Nick's married now chile please do your research before saying thats why she gets alot of hate her, most ppl dont even know she used to date Nick bye
Are you deaf?
Bruhhhh I trought that this was from this year but it’s from 2013 😂😭
Same,i got excited
Yeah i remember it from before and thought that she had done it again, for memories 😒
😒😒😒😒😒
Isn’t it from 2018?
me too
Y’all do know this isn’t lipsynced.... it’s called a high backtrack. She’s still singing live. And no it’s not the best but 1. she’s dancing and 2. At this time her lupus was extremely bad. Y’all are just ignorant and disgusting people. It’s always the people judging others who can’t actually sing themselves.
TRUE AF!
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
You dont hv to explain to them, they are human born without heart without empathy disgusting. Anyway stream duv now!!
Even I can't sing like that😐
Well said ...
indian makeup😍😍😍 specially indian Bindi💖💖💖😊😊😘😘
selena ..
But it is too long if it's small it look more beautiful
vaishali you are right dear 😊
Im west indian...
I hate her
Like a ghost
Hit lk ho agree with this
me on karaoke night
Gluta Mate AHAHAHAHAHA
then you’re good
😂😂😂
Wow! You are good!🙂
LMAO
She looks really amazing in indian makeup and totally looks like an indian love you Selena😍😍
Edit : OMG 1k, mom I'm famous....
She’s latina. Of course she has indian ancestry in her bloodline. Most latinas are mestizo.
@@surmaster4618 Native American and Indian are not the same thing. Idiot.
【VictoriasSecretHeaven】 i know that. I’m saying Indian as I’m referring to Native Indians aka “Native Americans”. You look like the fool here with all that hatred in your heart.
@@onthevergeoftears Even Indian look more gorgeous than American's India's beauty and it's earth is heaven
@Harrys voice is deeper than the Mariana Trench right whybis no one talking about this
I think she did it very well. Try to do that yourself, bet you can't. And, also, she's dancing at the same time. Respect to her, she's a very talented girl. ❤️
m g Her choreo isn’t even that hard, even at the moment she was sitting or just standing, she was still struggling. Just saying.
crescendo she also has lupus which affects her breathe control and makes her tired faster. No hate just letting you know
She did not sing well from the start do how she she well?
asmrsounds literally what
m g the choreo are not difficult, kpop idol do difficult choreo and sing at the same time, but she did a great job and i heard that she was sick, so respect to her ❤️
She needs to start performing again :( we miss our queen .
Army is every where
She changed a lot :( she lost her confidence and her mv and performances aren’t as good anymore
Queen??? lol
@@judlaw1722 Yes , Shes a Queen. Lol thats what he just said lmao what about it?
*・Hawt JiN ツ・* yessss🥺🥺🥺
Indian makeup in Latin faces 💛 Selena is really Gorgeous.
@@scarlettrose2065 she's spanish i think?
Yes, she’s Latina. Mixed Mexican and White
@@Saleena3333 She's WHITE Mexican and Italian American. Please being latino isn't race. Latino people can be white,black,mixed etc
@@bittertea9983 Bro shut up, us Indians enjoy seeing her wear this and she looks stunning
@@bittertea9983 She didn't insult the culture in any way.The music,the dance,make up everything was on point.The makers of the song did their homework pretty well.So,I'd rather say it's a cultural appreciation.
If you still wanna hate,go and watch some kdramas and kpop.It's them who know nothing about the culture and still copy it(mock it).They really need to get outta there well.
Mann...her make up makes her look totally indian...😍
ATStar 123 yes
ATStar 123 Even the starting sound of Tabla makes the effect of INDIAN
It's Dhvani Đ26 the indian dressing is due to the fact that the song has indian influences....she wears indian influenced attire for performing this song
ATStar 123 it is
ATStar 123 so true
I love Selena and I really want to say that she sounds like that because she is dancing and singing the same time but man have you seen little mix dancing and singing the time?!it's an incredible view
Fact!! ♥️
@Sarah Lattari let me stop you here.I dare you to search Little Mix singing live.They NEVER use autotune.And please let's face it.Selena can not sing good live and we all know that.I literally ADORE her and I know what she has been through..break up and health issues,I know everything.Also the girls of little mix and Selena have almost the same age and if you don't know the story of this group please don't say anything.They have dealt with bullying,anxiety,anorexia and one member has been through a really bad breakup that lead her to depression and she couldn't sing live because she would get emotional.❤
Little Mix are group. Don't compare group with solo artist.
@@onlyme1875 guys lmao.this is what I believe and what many people believe.You won't change my opinion because I know it's right.This is ridiculous actually.I can't even express my freaking opinion.Also why do you believe my first comment has so many likes?!Because so many people share the same opinion with me.If you don't then it's okay but that doesn't we have to agree with you but you don't have to agree with us either.I want to ask you something and I want your honest answer.Do you believe Selena can actually sing good live?And don't say again she is a solo artist.Beyonce,Taylor Swift,Ellie Goulding,Ed Sherran and SO MANY MORE are solo artists but they can sing 4 songs without stopping,dancing the same time and still sing very good.So please before you say something I would ask you to see the facts you have in your hands and then decide what is right to say.Also if an artist has good voice means that has good voice and CAN sing live,Selena's voice isn't that good live.We alcan understand this for so many live performances of hers.I am telling you this with love and respect.❤
@@Ellie-cl6mj You can't say your opinion is right. No opinion is right. It has your opinion and my opinion, but not right opinion. Yes, Selena isn't good live at singing, but you still can't compare 4 women with 1. Every member in Little Mix has part of the song, but not the whole song. Selena sings the whole song alone. That's why you can't compare them.
Who is here from her AMAs 2019 performance?
Gerald I miss her so much she's so confident and looks so healthy in here where did that Selena go? What they've done to her? She should know how amazing she is 💔
That horrible monstrosity???
@@kimab496 shes horrible and shes finally learning it
Laquinton Wagner actually she's good wash your eyes
@@kimab496 good WHERE?????
To be fair shes singing live which is more than most performers can say
It's not live
Shaggybro tf you can clearly hear it
Shaggybro you clearly can’t hear well. 🤪
Chris Kilpatrick the hell bro
Caner x i was talking to him not you. Lol.
They did her audio so dirty. The sound engineers could've done a better job
This was bad
@@jarednicholson4223 But the sound engineers could've done SOMETHING
exactly... why didn't they just put her at 50% and the studio version at 50% girlie was struggling
Yes, she cant sing so blame it on someone else.
NO NAME shes good at singing u jelly-fish 👌
“Selena is lipsyncing”
EXCUSE ME. DID YOU NOT HEAR HER NECKLACE CLINGS AT 2:25?
Well you need to speak near mike that's near her neck to speak as anything far like even a few centimetres won't be caught by a mic due to noise cancellation tech! I used a mike and I am saying this by my personal experience and sorry if it's wrong!
Edit: well I'm a doctor or will be in few days! (SEASON)
Harman i had a seizure trying to read that
She ain't
@@blpanick Same here 😂
Harman 😂😂😂😂😂
I dont think its bad...shes literally jumping around and shit give her some credit
Asterismz Asterismz Arianna did it
did you ever see Beyonce on stage?
It’s called lip singing. Selena Gomez is known for lip singing.
@Jello xx this isn’t lip syncing I’m not a fan of her but I can tell this isn’t lip syncing
She's not lipsyncing, you can even hear the sound of that necklace when she's dancing
i know that girl isn't that really good in singing but you can't deny the fact that she making hits. everytime she releasing songs it become trending. her lyrics are filled with meaningful that can motivate you. ❤ i love this woman no matter
Thank you for putting it out there. She's improve sooo much! Hopefully new album coming soooon.
Making hits does not mean u are good at the craft, it means u have loyal fans would buy anything u put out no matter how bad it is and u have a strong record label behind u ready to pump in money for promotions. That's how the industry works.
Her songs go trendy because she never writes them. Big labels and great artists likes to work with her because of her followers. She has a huge blind followers who worship her as if she is a goddess. Credit mostly goes to her PR who never fails her
she must have something that she has so many blind followers. No PR, no writers can get you that much love if you dont have something that makes you have that. Later everything in addition makes her that famous including the PR team, the workers, the people in her life.
@@rachelbegmusic that is not true. It's your PR's job to make you put your best foot out. Plus some celebrities are like crybabies and who doesn't like a cry baby. They gain sympathy out of their miseries. The only thing Selena has is a very beautiful face that's it!
I'm so proud of how much she has improved... 💃🙌
Candy Castillo Vlogs this is from 2013..
Girl meets games i think she means from this performance
Daisy Appiah-Asare Yes!
Candy Castillo Vlogs shes improved???
Yeah!!! Really..
I love Selena Gomez but idk how I feel abt that singing
Ryce this is her voice in 2013, but her voice has improved, look at the songs she sang from the racial album, before her singing wasn't good, and it's getting hetter😊
breanna what
Ryce same
Yeah her voice was eh back then. She improved though, in other videos
Honestly I feel the exact same
People be hating. Selena doesn't care and keep making hits 💕
A D I agree. Slaylena to death♥🔥
Well... using the word 'hits' a bit generously!
A D "HITS" 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
But she can’t sing
A D flops*
There's just some people who can sing live and some who can't.
Rainbow Cloud People who can't sing live can't sing at all.
Rainbow Cloud this was 5 years ago she's better now.
And she’s one who cant, sorry but tru
Ryx to me she still sounds bad live
Rainbow Cloud it s cause she is dancing at the same time
Why I have I seen this now ??
Omg, I love her in that Indian makeup ...🤩
Makes her look like an Indian...
Love 💗💗
From India 🇮🇳🇮🇳
That bindi🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
No tea no shade but even selenators ( that’s how Selena fans are called right?) have to admit that that she can’t sing live.
breanna and normal singers can sing when they are dancing. BTS,BEYONCE,MADONNA ETC
breanna isn’t pop music like her thing.....
KWON SOONYOUNG& MIN YOONGI “normal singers”?? you’re a disappointment as an army. A lot of artists struggle with singing while dancing. Even jungkook struggled with it at the beginning and eventually trained his endurance to be able to sing well while dancing. (I’m a predebut army). Even amazing singers like Ariana grande struggle with singing while moving around let alone dancing. Besides this was a performance from 2013, she’s obviously improved a lot now. Keep in mind that this choreo was super strenuous and she has lupus too which causes acid to hit her throat/vocal cords soooo. Continue being ignorant if you want. I suggest you do research next time before you make a comment like that. Even the most amazing artists had to train hard to be able to be stable singers while dancing. Why do you think Kpop artists train for so long? If I misunderstood your comment, please let me know
She doesn't even go here! I know my idols but in my opinion jk can sing better when they are dancing SHE CANT SING LIVE
She doesn't even go here! They trained yes but selena?? If she didnt get any help or something its not my problem
This gives me hope that she can learn the Ice Cream choreography.
Same here
@Sammy Jung true
I dont want my sele to dance if she is not well just because of public demand .
It’s definitely not her greatest performance, but she’s dancing throughout the entire song and it’s hard to sing when you’re out of breath from dancing and I applaud her so trying her best.
You need to be quiet!
@@ROCKSTAR13133ok melanie
She looked beautiful ! I love her in red. Her voice tho ☹️
She did but AGREED 😭
Come on guys! Not everyone have to be Beyonce, is not every artist that can sing and dance at the same time! She was trying to do her best, it doesn't worked, but she tryied. We have to give her credits.
Cainã SDS I'm sorry, but *It didn't work* and *she tried*
Just helping.
+R 2001 This is from 2013, she's getting better, every year her voice is getting so nice. Also, why people don't talk about her great dance moves, her acting, everything that she does it's successful, because she's a amazing artist. If someone don't have something good to say, is bettet not say anything. Wanna be critic, be a critic, but don't be unfair. It' directly to you +R 2001, this is for the haters, they talk bullshits and don't search about, so stupid. Sad. All love
+R 2001 It's not directly to you ** Sorry for the mistake
Cainã SDS I wasn't talking about Selena, i was correcting your grammar.
Cainã SDS if she perform as a singer, she should know how to sing. Simple as that.
mtv so shady i remember this why you upload this now rofl
Hypnotic Soul when this performance actually performed by selena gomez? ??
2013 when come and get it was released.
Coz of the engagement?
no because when this performance first aired in 2013 it had alot of negative commentary on it since the performance isnt the best lol
ʎʇᴉdᴉpuǝɹs shady? They know how to make them views.
I love Selena, she is very talented but she lacks things when she is performing live, she can sing but she needs a lot more training. I know this is old and she improved so much from this!
No. She hasnt
She was dancing likeee, it’s not easy
Prob lost fitness here - she sang perfectly in 2013
Her dance is inspired by Indian Bollywood dance and its not a easy smooth thing , so her make up and look , but with singing and dancing like that at the same point .... I mean its call a whole great petfomence so #respect .
This woman is just freaking gorgeoussssssssss. Damn that red really takes her. The makeup outfit everything looked so amazing on her.🔥 True Selenators still here 2021💕
White SJW's: SHE'S DOING CULTURAL APPROPRIATIONNN
South Asians: Cool. I like it
This sounds like something Camila would sing especially with the “na na na na” 😅
Selena did it first😂
Joel Rodriguez Conde you right you right. Selena did it first and Camila got inspired and continued it.
But at that year Camila wasn't online
Who’s Camilla?
She a performer, I don’t get why people always criticize her singing ability. She has a descent singing voice. Just because you have a good singing voice doesn’t mean you are a good entertainer. Selena is a triple threat. Tamar Braxton is a good singer but not a good entertainer, a lot of good singers are not big because they go overboard
Aww.....She looks so adorable 😍😍
she ruined her own song buh i love you selena
Cookies&Cream 4l she cant ruin her own song, but she can make a few mistakes
Na'Asia Owens says who
Cookies&Cream 4l lol😂😂😂btw are you ARMY...?💜
FYI she hate come & get it song
DD51606 4L lmao not really
when it comes to selena gomez everyone are vocal coaches or producers
If you don't like Selena's music, there are many more artists that you might like, go listen to them.
And if you're here just to spread hate, gurl, get a life.
THE COMMENT
True
I’m sorry I just don’t think she can sing….. like at all. I get it she’s Selena Gomez but she just can’t sing.
You are wrong
@@natallyemonteiro2114 She can’t sing live at all. She sounds terrible people like her because she’s Selena Gomez but her voice does not sound good at all
Hater be like....."she sings live coz she doesn't know how to lip sync"
Her voice still sucks lol
@@igotlostinmadsland5421 Nope, her voice is great. She got you feeling like you're stepping on buildings, cars and boats! You swear you can touch the sky! Ohhhhhh, you're ten feet tall!
selena gomez slaying for almost 4 minutes
FashionLoveSmile you need a personality check. You’re still irrelevant
FashionLoveSmile hahah it’s funny how you’re getting so pressed 😂😂 hope you fix the insecurities within yourself hun 💕 spend your time doing something productive rather than cursing at people online and hating on people that you don’t know personally. Fact of the matter is Sel is doing what she loves and she has fans that love her. She may not be your cup of tea but at the end of the day, you’re still irrelevant and she’s still making that money 🤑🤑
FashionLoveSmile if I wrote an essay, you wrote one back 😂😂 have a nice day. I’d advise for you to go to back to school
FashionLoveSmile lmao goodnight. You’re clearly the idiot 😂 saying you don’t get pressed yet you’re the one that commented, “get your ears checked!” on someone else’s comment. I hope you learn to be nice and get an education love! 💕💕 I’m guessing you’re probably younger than 16
Selenator is she rlly???
The Indian makeup was so tone deaf tbh
yes and the rest of her outfit, dance, and everything
Exactly!!!
I'm seeing my fellow desis praising her and like, it's ok and definitely not cultural appropriation but, it doesn't fit in with the song..? She legit just put it in there to seem 'exotic' smh
shriya raina she’s mexican. she could easily have used her own culture but it wouldn’t have fit with the song, the song has obvious indian influences. & i doubt it was her idea, probably someone from her team.
danny ryan she is half Mexican her mother is white.
Guys, she has not a wide range, yet she BELTS while dancing. She's amazing lol. Even tho other kinds of music would be better for her.
1:53 the exact moment where they turn on the playback so she can sing over it and sound decent
Should've done that from the beginning tbh
decent.....she is below average she literally isn't even singing properly and still sounds flat....she's a decent actress she should stick to that
lue mae she most likely sounds like that because she is dancing. Trust....it’s hard to sing while dancing and being even more out of breath
Kristopher Howse literally she is barely dancing so many artists dance and sing at the same time and do it amazingly. This is her job and she is not good at it she really needs to stick to acting. She was not made for this at all
She's sick. Her voice is loud as of now.. must be the side affects, but she's dancing and singing too
EXACTLY! She immediately sounded so much better lol. Her live performances are always bad
mtv is too shady.... they shouldn't of do the girl like that.
XAVIER
To be fair, it’s not MTV’s fault Selena can’t sing lol
@@sofiaguerrero0969 thats why she has followers in millions
@@sofiaguerrero0969 Can you sing perfectly while dancing too?? Have some respect for this beautiful woman.
fofiax she can sing but this is a more up beat song all the slower songs she sung live she sung them well
fofiax she can but this song is just hard to sing for any kind of singer cause the chorus needs to much power and breath
So many people in this comment section acting like they wouldn’t be out of breath while dancing and singing💀
Suban la presentación de t.A.T.u en los MTV Movie Awards por favor!
Iconic 🔥😍😍😍
It's awful that she did this and is still getting credit for the Indian elements in the music as though she could have made it up not to mention the rampant racism and disregard for west and south asia.
I think she is great and brave. She sing live and not lip sync👍👍👍. That is definitely the definition of singer...
Hamzah Reza Achyani the definition of a singer is being able to sing. Which she can’t do LOL
If that was the case, anyone could be a singer.
@@ginagalvan2070 literally ANYONE.
The sound of her voice isn’t bad but she has no technique or pitch she just sounds the same she can’t really do no riffs or runs and when she sings somewhat higher again no technique just like a monotone voice
@@veronicaxotwod yes. It IS... BAD
Esta presentación es una de las mejores de esta canción si no es la mejor, su voz estaba temblorosa pero no podemos negar que lo dio todo en el baile, temazo que fue un hit mundial.
She may not have the best vocals but she is a great performer, this song was always entertaining to watch her do on stage.
Do you know what I hate? When someone says watch this video as proof that she's a bad singer. And then they say "tHe ChOReO iS nOt ThAt hArD"
Chile please do this choreo with the SAME energy AND sing at the same time! It does not matter how SIMPLE the choreography is. As long as you're doing the steps FULL OUT, it IS difficult to SING and DANCE at the same time.
And please no one should bring k-pop idols as an example here cause American musicians do not spend years being "trainees" before they finally debut.
Finally someone here knows how it works
Vocally not the best but at least her dancing was good 😂 I never really got the whole meme that selena can’t sing until now.. like I’ve seen how she’s improved tho 🥴💀
Watch come and get in revival tour live
Necesito que vuelvan esos tiempos :( ¿Alguien viéndolo en el 2020?
The music and the style is kinda indian , isn't it??
This is how she should’ve kept performing
Her voice sound good n strong n steady n the dance moves were entertaining
Love you Selena
Can you compare this prestation with the one where she is singing “wolves” so sad 😭
No way!! :(
People ruined her !! She lost her confidence and she suffers from anxiety:(
This is a huge, huge example of cultural appropriation. I don't understand you guys.
This is cultural appreciation
yeah, cult appreciation
Are you stupid? She's respecting it, she's literally just dancing a dance inspired from Bollywood and the Indians are okay with it they actually like it. Y'all learnt the words cultural appropriation and won't stop using it.
agreed, only Bollywood doesn't represent Indian cinema
lmao this entire comment section is: "imagine singing and dancing at the same time"...... y'all that's her job....
noo, that mean , everybody says she lipsync and that's not true , at that time , she has a lupus , and she dancing while singing , because that she sing like that , but its okay , im still love her no matter what 💘
Lmao the hate is ridiculous. Prolly the 12 years old teens r here, claiming everything when this song was a hit that yall moms shaking their hips
Literally wasn’t even bad at all. Was dancing a lot and singing. Loved it
Queen 👑😍😍😍
Yes
Yassssss
Noooo
Y
lol yh sure...
Singing & Dancing especially on the ground is NOT easy! I'm proud of her idc if this is old she's still doing the damn thing! She could've copped out and lip-synced like tons of others always do! But NOPE she did the damn thing!
It's really hard stanning a girl with little to no vocals...Sigh
LMAO OMG
I totally feel u i cant
Leslie Diego yea her musics good but the voice ain’t it
SHE IS SINGING AND DANCING AT THE SAME TIME YALL JUST STUPID 🤦🏽♀️😭
Nahkayla Youngblood gee like every performer does 🥴 y’all preach that like it’s an accomplishment, it’s her job! 🤦🏻♀️
U literally can hear the hard breathing and the jewelry.
I miss watching this, this is iconic imagine having health issues but still performs
This is terrible 😂just mime girl
IM SORRY BUT THIS IS CULTURE APPROPIATION as an indian im offended
right but we love selena
My god ...she is looking like a negative role in an Indian tv serial with that horrible big bindi ..😂😂
My fav song of Selena 💖
My Baby has improved so much since then!
WHY IS THIS BEING RECOMMENDED NOW? This is shady asf RUclips
Here from the Buzzfeed article of hit songs musicians hate. Selena said she hated this song mainly because it was difficult to perform. Apparently it was a Rihanna reject - seems like it maybe a bit out of Selena’s range (for live performance with dancing).
PEOPLE WHO MADE HATE COMMENTS ABOUT IT *PROBABLY DONT KNOW SHE HAS LUPUS, DONT KNOW WHAT LUPUS IS AND DONT EITHER KNOW SHES A HUMAN*
ICANT BELIEVE HOW STUPID CAN PEOPLE BE MAKING HATE ON HER PERFORMANCES
She look so pretty in this get up!! I am in love with her 🔥🔥😍😍😘😘