Can classical singing 'be' mainstream? Il Divo help you to decide!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 июл 2024
- Tonight we're taking a look at Il Divo performing 'Time to Say Goodbye'!
Original Video - • IL Divo ~ Live in Hyde...
TIME STAMPS -
0:00 Start
0:12 Introduction
0:39 Performance
4:15 Analysis Start
7:09 Synchronisation
10:06 Individual Voices
15:54 Carlos's Technique 
Развлечения
Carlos was simply unmatched in his talent.
Carlos was in a class of his own. A great baritone, he was definitely the heart and soul of il divo! He will be sadly missed...Such a humble,kind,gentle human being....Millions of 💔😢🙏💔⭐️⭐️🌹
❤️ Absolutely
I ‘ll miss him, Carlos was my favorite!! No one will ever replace him, his enthusiasm was contagious & held the group together!!!❤
Carlos was just magnificent. What a terrible loss. His voice was superb.
Carlos was amazing, the best... my favorite voice, what a devastating loss. thank you
Carlos was the best of the Best! He was IL Divo! It’s just not the same anymore without him! He’s irreplaceable! We miss his Fantastic personality, funny humor, Charisma, handsomeness, professionalism, and his magnificent Glorious voice! The voice has faded, but now we have a great Legend! He’s left us his wonderful Legacy forever! just listening to him, still brings tears to my eyes! We’ll always Love and Remember Him! Rest in Heavenly Peace my Spanish Prince!❤❤❤🌹🌹🌹🥰🥰🥰
Carlos Marin... IRREMPLAZABLE!!!! Único, se lo extraña terriblemente.
I like this song a lot. I hadn't heard this version before.
✨Carlos Marín✨
Rest in peace
Thank you, Fil 🖤
Thanks again, Fil. Carlos' voice and range was indeed incredible. I've never heard Il Divo before, but I learn something new every time from your analyses. You rock!
My favorite at this time - also most prophetic. David, Urs and Sebastian must still be in shock! At least we have videos and recordings to keep him in our hearts. Prayers and love to all who grieve. 🙏❤ 😪
What a talented and educational analysis, thank you!
I'm a huge fan of Il Divo. It broke my heart when he passed away. The group are so very talented their voices just meld into beautiful music. The loss of Carlos is a staggering blow to the rest of them, and the fans. Thanks for bringing this to a wider audience Fil. I have been a fan since their first album and the music is just so beautiful and calming.
I've been listening to them since they were formed. My favorite piece by them has to be "O Holy Night" from their concert in the ruins in Spain. When Carlos really let go with the line "Christ is the Lord..." it always gives me chills. RIP Carlos.
Toda la razón. La actuación en el Teatro Romano de MÉRIDA fue IMPRESIONANTE..LAS VOCES Y EL ENTORNO. a mi también me emociono O' ONLY NIGHT. 😮😮😢
Fil, thank you for this very informative and gracious review of Il Divo. As you said, what a great bunch of singers. I am sad that Carlos passed away so young-it leaves a gap that will never be the same. Thanks for all you do, Fil, for bringing a wide variety of music to our attention.
This is just too new, fresh the passing and the sorrow of Carlos Marin that I don't know if I can watch this and be fair with what I'm supposed to be feeling? There was only one Carlos Marin there will never be another.
ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS WE ALL NEED TO GO BACK TO GORGEOUS ROMANTIC BEAUTIFUL MUSIC. The music reaches into the soul in a way no other music does.
Fil, you are class unto your own. I love listening to you talk about so many different kinds of singers and what they are doing with their voices. You have the expertise to bring these skills or lack there of , out in the open for people to learn from and enjoy. Thank you!!!
🌹Carlos Marin ♥️ Wspaniały artysta o przepięknej barwie głosu 🌹💔👏🌹!!!
Another member added to God's eternal band,and another great loss for us. Rest easy, Carlos🦋
Listening to IL DIVO is an absolute pleasure, so refreshing to hear truly talented singers. I'm a rocker lady, and this was beauty to my ears💙
Hey Rocker Lady... diversity is the spice of life! this was beautiful. 😊 May sweet dreams carry you through the night😴
@@drewpall2598 ☮️💙😊
@@cindypowers4993 Hello my Rock & Roll friend just stop by to say have a wonderful weekend Cindy 😊🧡✌🤘
Love your analysis of these great singers. RIP Carlos 🙏
His review was spot on
Thank you for delving into Il Divo/Carlos! Great to hear notes/ranges of the boys but easier to analyze Carlos voice with a solo song, of which there are many! "Confrontation" and "If I Can't Love Her" maybe? Maybe do just Carlos next. Il Divo and Carlos need more attention and praise! This is so great! Thanks Pegusus
Tienes razón "la confrontacion entre el Dr. Yekill y mrs Hyde es impresionante, el Fantasma de la Opera con su ex, Si no puedo amarla, o Sueño Imposible, en el Hombre de la Mancha...CARLOS pidia hacer con su Vozzz lo q quisiera, que pena nos dejara con tantos proyectos en el tintero😢
Wow, Carlos' last note! I have to get my hair down from the ceiling! As usual, if I am not sure what's going on I use Fil's face as a barometer as to how well things are going.
I enjoyed this very much. I often wonder how singers find out that they have exceptional singing abilities. I love Il Divo and I was heart broken when Carlos passed. Thank you. :)
That’s so nice of you to bring this forward. I know Karen Walker has been hoping you would. I got tickets to see them at the Royal Albert Hall, my daughter thought I was a fan but the CD I had was one I inherited from my mum , however they were brilliant and I became a fan. It was so sad to hear about Carlos he had a magnetic personality as well as a fantastic voice
I love Il Divo!! Have seen them live many times. They put on an amazing show and interact with the audience well.
I'm not crying, I'm not crying! Guys, I'm fine! ;~; Oh lord, this is beautiful!
I was introduced to IL Divo years ago by a friend who is long gone, it’s so great to see you share this with others so they too can enjoy their skill.
Wow. That was such BIG singing and so rapturously pretty! I wasn't aware of this group (aside from the requests) and am grateful that you worked so quickly to analyze them. What a tragedy to lose Carlos Marin so young. Grrrr. Doggone Covid.
Felt bad loosing Carlos 😞, How are you today dear friend?
Omg I love IL devo,i, was so heart broken to here the passing of carlos,these singers are some of the best,I have heard, they all have such beautiful vibratos in their voices especially i love sabastians voice, all have such gorgeous voices,so very gifted, thank you for sharing 😀
It was really heartbreaking to hear Karen, Carlos and those other great singers!
Really bad. How are you doing today dear friend?
They made me feel it. It’s what I need. Could I listen to them for hours? No. But as a “spice” they’re awesome. More David and Carlos I could listen to longer. You know me. High notes are just not my thing. Thank you Fil.
Gracias amigo me gustaría entender lo qué dices dé IL DIVO solo entiendo Español té prometió qué estoy llorando dé pena porque no te entiendo adoró a éstos chicos por Sebastián tengo debilidad!! A Capela me tiemblan los huesos!!! 🌹🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀🇪🇸🇫🇷🇱🇷🇨🇭.
Carlos pidia hacer también las notas dulces y graves.
Their vocals are amazing. I was sad to learn one of the original members died recently.
I love their voices and listening to them perform gives me such great pleasure!
Tonality is best served with a main course of phrasing. Phrasing in music is what gives the best flavor. These guys nailed it.
Que grande Carlos, el alma de Il Divo
I'm an 80s rocker chick. Hair bands, sleeze and glam metal, thrash, speed, etc..love it all. I'm also equally passionate about Broadway and classical. And I am a huge fan of IL Divo. As much as I love metal, it simply doesn't touch my soul the way this does. I'm going to see them in a couple of weeks. But sadly without Carlos.
Beautiful ❤️💜🌹🌷💐🌺🦋
I feel so fortunate to have seen them in Houston. A memorable night indeed.
They were so good! And they enjoyed themselves immenselly while singing. I see you enjoyed it too!
Another great analysis. My cousin turned me on the Il Divo about 12 years ago. I love their music because it blends two of my favorite genres: classical and pop. I looked up Carlos, and found out he was born on the same day as me, but 13 years apart. I am the elder. Fil you rock. Thanks. Peace be.
The wonderful Il Divo, thank You
Goosebumps for days.
Sound like Simon Cowell has a lot invested in Il Divo wound that mean Simon raking in the money while these guys are doing all the work. Rest in Peace Carlos Marin.
Simon ya no les llevaba, ellos cuatro eran los dueños de ILDIVO, hacían y deshacian lo que querían..tomaron las riendas de su carrera en 2018..
I can tell you love what you do I love it when you smile your truly impressed with the singers voice. Your admiration shows. Love your channel.
Simon Cowell discovered these guys and brought them together.
So many great comments. I’ll try not to repeat what has been said. I want to thank Fil for doing the research on the artists he features. So many reaction videos are thin to almost non-existent on the technical analysis and the historical/contextual aspect of a performance and artist. I always leave Fil’s videos with knowing more, appreciating more, and feeling more rather than being annoyed at the supposed “coach” wasting my time.
Fantastic that you did a classical review. You are just a straight out music lover
That was one of the most breathtakingly beautiful performances I've ever heard, it brought tears to my eyes! Great analysis as always Fil! Thanks! 🙂👍
Hello Tammy how are you doing today
@@larrywalter6476 Hi! Doing good! How about you?
@@tammydoolittle6054 I’m good thanks. Where are you chatting from?
@@larrywalter6476 I'm in South Carolina USA
@@tammydoolittle6054 Okay I live in Oklahoma City but I’m currently working here in Syria
As a classical singer who also plays bluegrass banjo, and a former classical / jazz flute player, I'm very appreciative of your commentary on multiple styles of music. Your take on the classical style of singing, which varies on its own considerably, from bel canto to medieval styles, is really impressive. Bravo!
Thanks!
Wow! They are fabulous! This singing could be mainstream if more people were exposed from a young age. Why not?
Love the Divos. One of the most beautiful songs written. I'm such a eclectic music lover, from heavy metal to orchestral/classical. The only music I have an aversion for is the hippy hoppy stuff. Good one Fil ✌💕
Fascinating analysis of a wonderful group! Thank you, Fil! Loved it! And shared.
Carlos uses the technique of the old opera singers. No sing in the mask,no strain in the voice. He uses worderful legato,a very open throat in every range he sings,high or low you will hear the openess in his throat. One of the techears of Carlos are Alfredo Kraus and Montserrat Caballé. RIP to the best baritone I have ever heard who could sing A4s like nothing who had a fantastic grace in singing. Such a huge lost.
I love their voices ...and I bought one of their CD's about 10 years ago. I love listening to them while cooking 😊 I'm sorry to hear that one of them passed away.
Hope you're having a great weekend. Fil 💙
Thank you for the rare treat of classical male voices, I Listened to this video 4x at least to hear all that you discussed. Lovely Carlos Marin voice so sad it was silenced by death. You are so kind as you analyze and realize we are so subjective in our taste for music. I used to love Bon Jovi and it's only his political views that made me say snarky things. But you are so professional and hold back on any feelings. You're a class act. And I love opera and classical music as much as James Brown and the Beatles, Beach Boys and Dean Martin. I see you like Batman too! Like your Tee shirts
Hello Celeste how are you doing?
@@larrywalter6476 waiting for live stream
@@celestearellano3720 Oh okay. Where are you chatting from?
@@larrywalter6476 Colorado
@@celestearellano3720 Okay I live in Oklahoma City but I’m currently working here in Syria
IL DIVO 🏆🎖
Wow. He must have been young. God Bless. Talented vocal
Magnificent.
It sounds so familiar to me but can't remember ...
Didn't Andrea Bocelli sing this too?
Rest in Peace Carlos. 🕊🎶🕯💜
Yes, Andrea sang this song
you know why I'm here. Perfect singing, perfect eyes... have a beautiful evening Fil. Thank you once again. :)
Thanks for this. I liked that you played the performance and then went into the analysis. I hope your wrist is getting better.
They are magnificent Anthony is the bomb 👍🏾
I'm surprised that no one that I can find has reacted to or analyzed the incredible classical guitarist, Christopher Parkening, who was Segovia's protégé. I had the pleasure of hearing him play live five times. It would be wonderful if you were the first to react to my personal favorite selection, "Simple Gifts." Please? 😊
Carlos poiatener una VOZZZ dulce, grave o un volcan en erupcion. NADIE...NUNCA COMO ÉL 😢😢😢
Great review. Very specific and contain a lot of technical term that I Don't fully understand but still great nonetheless. I can't wait to hear your review to their song: Hymno De La Agleria as well.
WOW! ❤️
I'd be most grateful if you could include more analyses of classical singers in your future videos. It would be very interesting to compare more such singers with others like Karen Carpenter.
Yet again, another fine video! For once I really have nothing to add so I will simply repeat a suggestion for an analysis. Cathy Berberian providing the vocal on Berio's "Sequenza III" for female voice. It is here on RUclips.
As a commercial testament to how far outside of the mainstream the recording is, I recall buying my vinyl copy for 30 cents back in the 70's.
Btw, re: the performance under analysis today. It was the sound of the audience in the background that reminded me that at the time many "classic" operas were composed, the art form was not "high brow," it was raucous popular entertainment. No top hats and tails in the evening but the general populace having fun at, say, an afternoon matinée. The same is true of the plays of Shakespeare, which explains why his works are riddled with incredibly rude humour (once you understand the language).
They all had wonderful voices... one of my favorite classical groups! I would love for you to look at the singer, Édith Piaf, as she had such a unusual voice.
Great band♥️
It was really heartbreaking to hear Elizabeth, Carlos and those other great singers!
Really bad. How are you doing today dear friend?
I never heard of Devo. They are really good. It's awesome that they are so NSYNC with each other. That in itself can be a big challenge. Since I have been in a few choirs I know how important blending is. Nothing needs stick out because you are one voice that like you said are singing many different notes. I'm a supranio by the way.
Fil the one group I do know who sings like this is Callabro. They are awesome! I first saw them on Britain got Talent. It's says a lot about you that you will show appreciation for many different genres of music. I like many genres of music and your videos are always great to watch and learn from. I will this comment by telling you to keep rocking 🤘
Donde estuviste metida, llevan csntando desde 2003. Millones discos de oro y platino en todo el mundo.
TARJA classical is my stream !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FOREVER MORE ☮☮💘💘💥💥
I truly enjoyed this segment. I appreciate all an any artist.
Not sure if you ever covered Jesse Cook?
I seen him in concert in a small venue and it was so imazing! I love flamenco and all his different diversity within his strings.
I would like you to do IlDivo’s Adagio in Barsolona 😊
Ellos nunca actuaron en FactorX ni se conocian entre ellos, CARLOS estaba aactuando en una opera en Dublin, cuando le encontro Simon Cowell y fue el primero q se incorporó, el último David...
Wow
I would have passed out on that last note.
It was interesting to see what a classical voice looks like on the pitch graph. Not really familiar with Il Divo, but I did listen to Andrea Bocelli and Sarah Brightman in the 90s. And the Three Tenors, of course. I guess one could consider Mario Lanza as one of the first crossover artists. Besides being nice to listen to, classical crossover can also work as a bridge to opera, at least that's what happened to me.
CARLOS CUANDO ESCUCHO CANTAR A MARIO LANZA CON 8 AÑOS, DIJO QUIERO SER COMO ÉL...LE LLAMABAN EL.PEQUEÑO CARUSO. GRABO SU PRIMER DISCO CO 8 AÑOS CON EL.PADRE ABRAHAN( EL DE LOS PITUFOS) EN HOLANDES. O SOLE MIO..Y OTRAS.
Would be interested to hear your analysis of the group Home Free
Not related to this video but I downloaded that pitch app software that you feature and was pleased to see my voice in real time hit all the notes bang on
Who needs autotune!
Would you happen to have the name of that said application ?
@@johnnymcthunderbolt6670 Vocal Pitch Monitor -- aptly named
@@ionarra thank you.
Thank you, Fil for your great insights into all genres of music. You make is so simple and I appreciate it! Just for curiosity have you reviewed Home Free???? I missed it if you have. THanks again and by the way, great smile!
Not yet!
I really liked this one.. they're new to me...I kinda got caught up there for the whole song.. 👍...you look nice...as always..😀...any chance the new leather jacket might make another appearance..🤔
I'd loveto hear your thoughts on Pavarotti singing Caruso!
A Csrlos de niño le llamaban el Pequeño Caruso.
Fil, have you been asked to do a vocal analysis of Rick Astley? I’d be particularly interested in what you think of his two recent albums where he does his own songwriting.
Fil will have to address the giant elephant in the room,if Rick has not been covered before. Actually I thought that song really suited his voice!
Hi Fil, could you do a analysis on Howard Jones ? If he uses auto tune on his song, "No One Is to Blame".
"Can classical singing 'be' mainstream?" My guess is there are easier ways to make money in music than having an amazing voice and training for 10 years. Fil has an impressive voice but probably too late to go classical. :)
these guys would never came to existance without Luciano Pavarotti, Jose Carreras and Placido Domingo who went before them and and were much more gifted as individual singers ... check out every thing by the three tenors
Precisamente por eso busco Simón Cowell, cuando oyó cantar a los tres tenores, cantantes liricos, que pudieran cantar juntos, pero q cada uno.por separado, tuvieran vida propia. CARLOS lo dijo siempre somos cuatro cantantes que unidos podemos hacer cosas maravillosas y individualmente podemos ser nosotros mismos. Cada uno.por separado podían ser únicos.
Well, pop music capitalizes on the most common sentiments of all sentient life. It makes classical music more accessible to the mean man in contradiction to the wishes of posh folk. I too want to laugh, cry, smile, feel indignant, awed and amazed when I watch, hear and feel a talent perform. In other words, I don’t have to be afraid to try buying classical music. Be patient. Wait for it. I will get the endorphin hit.
I am grateful to the producers, composers, conductors and artists to bring beauty in any medium. I am grateful for artists like Mario Lanza, Maria Callas, Pavarotti, and even Enigma back in 1990 I think. They combined the themes of holiness with sensuality. I thought they were original but I realized they were not aboriginal in the sense of being the first in creativity. Such artists allowed me to enjoy the privilege of high art such as Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana. The original Tom and Jerry cartoons are one example of so many children entertainments that brought European music to me the son of a Haitian household. Even John Williams had the goal to bring classical music the mainstream when he composed for George Lucas and Stephen Spielberg. The first Tim Burton Batman movie had two soundtracks sold to the public. People kept thinking that Prince was the main artist but Danny Elfman was the primary composer and conductor. His themes confirmed that the story was a modern opera.
My favorite combination of classical and pop music is James Brown and Pavarotti singing THIS IS A MAN’s WORLD. That was classy.
Thanks for the music man.
Monserrat Cavallé y Freedie Mercury Barcelona 1992.
No G5 sounds like a group of high range screeming tenors.
You definitely need to react music by jose jose & Luis miguel they both naturally talented vocalist from Latin America both sing better in live performances than in studio both extremely talented singers raise in Mexico 🇲🇽🎤 both jose jose & Luis miguel are not even average singers. Both classic ballad singers. I hope you do see this
Not my style, but they were absolutely incredible, and what a shame about Carlos Marín....damn covid. Too young. I really love baritones, much more than tenors. Oh, and I believe the singer you say is French might actually Belgian or Swiss-French, but I might be wrong.
I read that the group consisted of 3 tenors and 1 baritone. Outstanding analysis!
Son un baritono CARLOS, español 2003-2021, un tenor David, Americano. Un cantante pop Sebastien Francés . Y un Tenor Urs Suizo.
Hi Fil. Thanks for this video. You may know by now that baritone Steven LaBrie was invited to take Carlos’ place as a guest as Il Divo continued with their Greatest Hits tour. I have been watching many videos of them together. Many fans were encouraging towards Steven, but some were a bit hard, I thought. Not sure yet if he will join them permanently. Take a look at the videos and hope you can share your thoughts. Cheers!
Steven tiene una potente voz operistica, pero no tiene la dulzura de la VÓZZZ de CARLOS. No tiene nada q ver sus voces, son los dos baritonos, solo se parecen en eso, también Urs y David son tenores y sus voces no tiene nada q ver...
Not sure where to send you a request to review THE Guess Who -Burton Cummings - These Eyes.
Take care, Thanks
Would like to know if Johnny Mathis has been auto tuned. As a popular signer who was classically trained. I hope not but know he experimented with disco in 70s 80s.
I think autotune came about in the 90s, unless the powers that be autotuned re mastered recordings 🤷🏼♀️. JM, one of the most precious voices ever 💕
@@leandabee yes. I should have said recent and remastered recordings. Also meant “singer” not “signer” 😂 lol
@@cw8214 😅, all good, I bet he was a good 'signer' too ✌
Seria interesante pudieras,estudiar Adagio, O Only Night en el Coliseo de MÉRIDA. GRACIAS.
Si pudieras escuchar a CARLOS Impossible Dream( sueño imposible) cantando solo.por EL. Hizo el musical el hombre de la Mancha con 30 años, haciendo de DON QUIJOTE, y volvió a cantarla el.solo cuando hizo CARLOS MARIN EN CONCIERTO.
Me encantaría q analizaras la " Confrontacion entre el Dr YEKILL y Mr HYDE. por CARLOS MARÍN( ILDIVO)
❄️❤️❄️🇨🇦
It was really heartbreaking to hear Karen, Carlos and those other great singers!
Really bad. How are you doing today dear friend?
😂 I thought this was Devo, the band that sang the song Whip It. I was listening to these men sing and I thought “Wow! Did I ever underestimate these guys in the 80’s! And they look GREAT!” Okay, one too many gins tonight, off to beddy bye. 🐑 🛌
How about rosemary Clooney?
not as good as Andrea Bocelli and Sarah Brightman's version but did like this version. Looks like i get to hear the song twice any time i want to hear it. :)
Para mí canta mejor Carlos q Andrea Bocelli. Hay más matices en su Vozzz( perdón cantaba) se me olvida q no está.
Hi Phil. I love your analysis and explanations of the technical aspects of music! I also love watching your face during the performances. I can SEE the enjoyment, appreciation, and respect reflected there! Since you're touching on the classical world here, what do you think of this lot : ruclips.net/video/BKezUd_xw20/видео.html
Fil Joaquin phoenix stars in the movie I walked the line I believe his voice was auto tune yes I know he wasn't a singer but when ask to sing on a chat show he says he hasn't got the voice his range of voice in comparison to late great Johnny cash didn't have the range
Love watching you but can’t watch this. Played at my mother’s funeral
It was really heartbreaking to hear Karen, Carlos and those other great singers!
Really bad. How are you doing today dear friend?
@@alvinscott6627 I really don’t know how to answer that. Looking after my dad with Dementia, just like mam & my daughter with mental & physical health problems. But I really appreciate you asking, you don’t know how much that means. Thank you x
@@karengray662 of course i know how that feels. I’ve been in such a situation where I looked after my sick wife with cancer till she passed away. It wasn’t easy. I just hope you find the strength and courage to push on. Where are you from?
@@alvinscott6627 thank you & I’m sorry you had to go through that, must have been incredibly difficult for you
@@karengray662 yeah, it was really difficult for me. I had to terminate my contract and come back home to look after her but she couldn’t defeat it. it’s past now Karen.
This is not classical singing though. It's classically trained singers singing popular music.
Ps personally I feel in this rendition, the song itself lost it's emotional content.It became more of a vehicle for vocal prowess.