Risti Lukki actually that’s true! Meryl stated in an interview that she just couldn’t see herself running around and singing without hurting herself or her voice
Biggest Sin: LITERALLY NONE of the details in Donna’s diary matched up with the plot of this movie. They literally had it SO EASY. The timeline of events, where they went, what they did etc. was all laid out for them but I guess they just said “Screw it” 🤷🏼♀️ Also there were multiple points in the first movie that indicated Donna’s mother being DEAD AND GONE
Well, except the dot dot dotsL the sequal faithfully had three off-screen sex scenes. But yeah, I too noticed Donna's mother was implied to be dead at one point in the original: At 00h 53m 09s, to be exact: "Somebody up there has got it in for me. I bet it's my mother." "And wasn't _she_ a ray of sunshine!"
The only thing I’m confused about is that in the first movie, it depicted the three guys as a bunch of hippies and rockstars, with one of them having eye tattoos on his knees... in this movie, none of that is depicted, and instead their a bunch of hot dudes in their 20s-30s....
I think I read somewhere that when making this movie, they didn’t want to be held back by plot points in the first one made purely for comedic purposes. They had no intention of making a sequel so they didn’t think that far in the future at the time.
I fully agree! I watched this movie only to accompany my mom and her middle-aged ladyfriends (hey, free popcorn) and had no idea what it'd be about other than a sequel to the original Mamma Mia. When I realized it was a movie of flashbacks, the one thing that really excited me was the thought of getting to see those colorful characters that were hinted at in the first movie! When they were all plain-ass "pretty boys" I was thoroughly disappointed. Utilizing the characters from the first movie would've made for a much more interesting story, in my opinion.
I know there may be some inconsistencies when you're making a sequel, but there's a limit to everything. Remember how in "Mamma Mia" Donna said "Somebody up there has got it in for me. I bet it's my mother"? Is asking the filmmakers to remember who's dead and who's alive too much?
I thought the movie was going to be about Sky leaving her and that she had to figure out how to be a single mother with the help of her friends, mom’s friends, dads, and some flashback scenes of her mom going through similar stuff
Yes then it decided to spring into songs, the lesser known ones by ABBA except Waterloo and SOS... Its all over the place. Past, Present blah blah blah and we still don't know who the real father is.
"Andy Garcia is featured in no more than 3% of the total runtime of the movie cliche". That's true, I'm starting to believe that it must be written in his contract that he has to briefly appear in films, similiar to how Sean Bean almost always gets killed off in his own roles...
I was classically trained and have sung professionally off and on over the years and I disagree with him too. Besides the scene he picked she wasn't supposed to be singing her best. It was on purpose. having said that...this movie was a far cry from Les Mis!
@RuleofVicus Yes because being trained in Opera as a child, singing on a kids album and being the lead singer in a local band is sooooo unbelievable...for gods sake, you can hear that I can sing by watching some of the silly, crappy recordings on my channel. I could see if I claimed some crazy level of achievement but damn. What possesses someone to call some random person on the internet a liar without doing your homework? And especially for such mediocre achievements as mine?
I listen to Cinema sins for the persnickety, pedantic picking, but the tirade against the grape baskets seriously cracked me up. Now the office is staring at me.
Yeah! I mean, he could've taken off those heavy pants, and maybe his underwear just to be safe. Aw heck, at that point take the shirt off too. The guy holding the camera SHOULD NOT look away at this point.
Don’t forget the fact the order in which Donna meets Sam, Bill, and Harry is out of order from the first movie. Also none of her crushes look like what their supposed to in regards to the photo
But.... Mayyyybe sam bill and harry all met at different times for the second time. First is harry the first time than bill than sam. but when they got to see donna for the second time it goes Sam, Bill than harry. cause in the first movie sfie reads donnas diarie you'll know if you watched the first movie
AMEN SOMEONE SAID IT. A friend and I went to watch this, in love with the first movie and the whole time we were freaking out and confused because the plots are not the same. Whoever recreated this movie did not apprently understand the first.
ikr! even sam don't have the long hair. i prefer it to stick more to the first movie, even when it looks goofy. it could be a cool hippie 70s vibe. they missed it!
1. "One of us" is a great song. 2. You totally misunderstood "Waterloo". 3. The main sin of bringing in Cher was how it reminds us how badly everybody else is singing in this movie.
Waterloo is losing yourself to love, the lyrics say “feel like I win when I lose” so knowing my fate is to be with you is still winning in this context
I watched the trailer for this and I thought the plot was that Meryl Streep travelled back in time after she slid down the banister considering how they framed it. I would unironically watch that.
I had issues with this film from just the trailers! (Some points are from when I saw the film) - the boys look nothing like the first film *showed* them to look like - where tf did this hotel come from? - different island?! - why tf is Donna dead?! - Cher?? - random plot points which help *nothing* but get another ABBA song in. - They *didn’t* use one of Skarsgard’s sons to play a younger him! - Waterloo. Nuff said. - the lack of time each spent with Donna. No way do you fall *so* deeply in love with someone after sleeping with them once. - THAY ALL MET DONNA IN FRANCE!! - Cher.
What do you mean "where did this hotel come from" it's the same hotel Donna had in the first movie. And they all did not meet Donna in Paris, she met 1 in Paris,1 on her way to the island and the last on the island.
What so a mother dying isn't realistic, a young girl making her mother proud by leading the hotel isn't realistic? The mothers mother coming to see her grand daughter after her daughter died isn't realistic? Having flashbacks isn't realistic?
The problem is they stuck b.c with the original timeline of the Broadway musical which was set in 1999. So it added up. The movie was made in 2008 and 2018. All they had to do was make the flashback 1989 and all would add up
Because at this point cinemasins is no longer about pointing out actual glaring flaws in movies, but rather the most nitpicky pendantic shit like “ANOTHER song in this musical???” Or “this extra changes shirts between shots in the background!”
The first movie was apparently set in 2000, as the concept of advertising businesses online is considered new. The second has a time skip of about five years, as it's noted that Sophie is now 25, and it's now 2005, despite the advanced technology that some of the characters have.
to me the sinniest sin was the costumes of the locals. I mean I get it, filming in Greece was too expensive and they went for Croatia, but seriously I bet even non greeks feel something is off... I am not even talking about the obviously different scenery - in the first one it was all aegean, barren and rocky, and here it's suddenly all green. Even the actors who are supposed to be greek, speak it broken. Also when I saw it I actually LOLed with the storm thing, and legit thought of the same thing.
That would be great. I'm guessing he will sin the "having to start from the beginning and watching scenes we already know" function that happens everytime you chose an option that doesn't help progress the story in any way
@@saoirsedeltufo7436 She is not a professional singer, is that what you're saying? She is better than 98% of the people. No where near average, not good enough to be a singer.
As the Onion's reviewer so aptly said: “a film which you can either choose to enjoy for the perfectly fine piece of entertainment it is, or live out the rest of your existence as a miserable killjoy who slogs through life recoiling at anything remotely joyful or upbeat in the world. Your choice.”
Since it's The Onion, I assume they're making light of the average response of some incessant Mamma Mia fan to criticism on the film? Unless that's their serious take on the film. If that's the case, then any awful or poorly-executed movie that was made with the intention to be uplifting can just get a pass because "if you dislike it you're just being a grouch who hates fun and happiness."
@@dancingtornado4527 If watching cinemasins ruins movies you actually enjoy, you should probably stop watching them. I love watching his videos on movies I like, it just makes them better for me. Videos on terrible movies are just cotton candy fluff.
Just ignore Penny, I’ve seen her go into comment sections that involve around people requesting movies that she likes, and she takes it so seriously and tells them to stop.
They forgot to sin the fact that the guests are flying into Athens when Athens is nearly 7 hours away from the Island this takes place on, which is the fictional Greek island, Kalokairi, which is based on the real Greek island Skopelos. Skiathos International airport would've been a much better choice for guest to fly into as it is much closer. They also forgot to sin the fact that given that Skopelos is located East of the Greek mainland, if you sailed past it you would end up in Turkey. People in Europe thought you'd sail off the edge of the world if you sailed west, not east. They knew Asia was in the East.
I can't help but laugh at the fact that Brosnan is clearly supposed to be the dream boat dad, but clearly nobody expected Firth to still be rocking his Kingsman 2 bod for filming of this movie.
I disagree with the Waterloo sin. I don't think it's comparing the love to the defeat of Waterloo, I think it's comparing how she *fell* in love like how Napoleon fell in waterloo. Like I mean that she lost the war, so to speak, and fell in love
My EWW wishlist for 2019: Teen Titans GO! to the Movies Hereditary Annihilation Game Night Suspiria Crazy Rich Asians Ant-Man and the Wasp The Avengers (1998) (in time for Avengers: Endgame) Pet Sematary (1989) Every Tarantino movie you haven’t covered Every Shyamalan movie you haven’t covered The Cornetto trilogy The Iron Giant The South Park, Simpsons, and SpongeBob movies Punisher: War Zone The Godfather trilogy The Indiana Jones trilogy Roma (or whatever movie wins Best Picture for this year) A Star is Born Some Coen Brothers movies Some Scorcese movies Some Laika movies The Prince of Egypt Elf The Lion King 2: Simba’s Pride (in time for the “live-action” remake) Frozen (2010) (in time for Frozen 2-even though this one is NOT related at ALL) Spaceballs (in time for Star Wars Episode IX)
I thought he just wanted her to move to New York. I'm guessing a hotel in New York makes far more profit than one on an island in Greece so I'm sure it was more due to practical considerations rather than selfishness.
I disagree, I think Sophie was the selfish one. According to the first movie, she knew from the get-go that he didn’t want to live there forever. But she did. She eventually agrees to leave the island with him and live the life he’s been wanting. then in the second movie, she takes it all back and is like “nah, we livin here now forever homie, cause mama died and I must devote my life to her spirit.” He was understanding in the first movie about her not wanting to leave her mom. I’d also be irritated though if the mom dies/leaves and my SO is still unwilling to live their own life.
Shananananon He didn’t care whatsoever about Sophie’s poor mom, if just wanted her to want he wanted. If I was her I would have broken up with him immediately after that phone conversation. So Sophie is in the right here!
They did a good job finding people who could be younger versions of the actors... Though I'm kinda surprised that they didn't bring in a younger Skarsgård to be the younger Skarsgård... There's a whole bunch of them running around and they undeniably look alike
Last note about this video: why didn’t you mention the timeline? If Donna had just graduated uni and less than a year later she was pregnant with Sophie and the flashbacks are all in the 70s like makes sense for ABBA (and Donna graduates from Uni in ‘79) then Sophie would be way way older in the present day. Someone else has pointed out that the present day is actually 1999 and the movie is trying to line up with that as canon, the same year ABBA came out on broadway 🎭 , but that would make the presence of iPhones in Sophie’s present day wrong. Sophie would be 37 or 38...
Yea. Keeping talking shit now. I’m sticking by JKs side until the series is finished, because knowing her, after the next movie is released, Crimes is going to make much more sense
@@drewkalsto2646 its not that the plot didnt make sense it was just badly written lol too many subplots at once that choked out the main story they should've picked 1 or 2 subplots and taken their time exploring them and letting the characters breathe a bit instead of trying so hard to have 6 individual storylines all squeezed into one movie
I think you've misinterpreted Waterloo, it's about someone winning your affection despite your best efforts not to succumb to love. "So how could I ever refuse I feel like I win when I lose Waterloo couldn't escape if I wanted to Waterloo knowing my fate is to be with you..." This sort of love song, about your resistance to love being overcome, is pretty popular from this era.
Cinemasins is the best thing I've ever found in my entire life. I put these videos on while I work at home and my dogs are actually so used to hearing Jeremy's voice once the videos start they just chill out on the couch, and one of my dogs actually just watches the TV for hours. It's pretty awesome.
"And if they were all Muppets? Fine. But they're not Muppets" - sin total 1: I think we can agree the people involved in rolling out this sequel were certainly muppets of a sort
Did anyone else notice the mix up with Harry Brite's guitar? In the first movie, Donna has it in her collection of the past, because Harry borrows it and Sophie mentions it as her "mom's guitar." In number 2 he had the guitar still on the docks as she's sailing away. It doesn't mention him ever going back to the island for her in the second movie to my knowledge. That and the fact that Donna died 'off screen' were the major problems I had with these movies. Love them otherwise!
I never watched this movie but I am glad I watched this video for one simple reason. Jeremy's alliterative talent and whimsical wordplay are well worth whatever time it takes to hear the sublime rhymes he playfully placated the public with while maliciously mocking the musical misery this miscarriage "Mamma Mia" made. Thanks. I genuinely appreciate some literary love and creativity on this usually very ordinary regurgitation of pop culture known as RUclips.
“The role of Captain Von Trapp in a third-grade presentation of The Sound Of Music.” I laughed so hard I had to pause the video because I legit played Maria opposite a guy who sang flat half the time It was a nightmare when our music cut it halfway through the love song
Doing a straight-up prequel on Donna's youth would've been better already, specially if it had been accurate to the first movie's depiction of the past.
The thing that annoys me about this movie... Sophie's friends in Mamma Mia were never mentioned again. Where'd they go?
I think it's because this was a personal event for Donna
Yeah.. she was considering inviting her grandmother who she has never seen but not her two best friends for her hotel’s grand opening?
Pratap Purswani but they were apart of Donna’s life too
So one of em is pregnant during the filming of this movie, and the other one don't want to come if the other can't
Friends don't last forever u know
the biggest sin of this movie is that they NEVER explain why and how the mother died..
They also still don't tell us who Amanda Seyfried's character's real dad is... things happen, but no explanation.
Why she died: because Meryl Streep didn’t want to be in the whole movie
@@ritasmith6781 Nope.
Risti Lukki actually that’s true! Meryl stated in an interview that she just couldn’t see herself running around and singing without hurting herself or her voice
she died of how bad the movie is
Biggest Sin: LITERALLY NONE of the details in Donna’s diary matched up with the plot of this movie. They literally had it SO EASY. The timeline of events, where they went, what they did etc. was all laid out for them but I guess they just said “Screw it” 🤷🏼♀️ Also there were multiple points in the first movie that indicated Donna’s mother being DEAD AND GONE
they took "screw em' if they cant take a joke" a little to seriously
Well, except the dot dot dotsL the sequal faithfully had three off-screen sex scenes. But yeah, I too noticed Donna's mother was implied to be dead at one point in the original: At 00h 53m 09s, to be exact: "Somebody up there has got it in for me. I bet it's my mother." "And wasn't _she_ a ray of sunshine!"
The only thing I’m confused about is that in the first movie, it depicted the three guys as a bunch of hippies and rockstars, with one of them having eye tattoos on his knees... in this movie, none of that is depicted, and instead their a bunch of hot dudes in their 20s-30s....
RonJon well when they filmed that part in the first movie, they had no idea that they would make a sequel, so I mean it’s not that serious ig
RonJon right??!?!???? Harry Headbanger was actually a well-coiffed, well-groomed prude of a young Englishman
I think I read somewhere that when making this movie, they didn’t want to be held back by plot points in the first one made purely for comedic purposes. They had no intention of making a sequel so they didn’t think that far in the future at the time.
I fully agree! I watched this movie only to accompany my mom and her middle-aged ladyfriends (hey, free popcorn) and had no idea what it'd be about other than a sequel to the original Mamma Mia. When I realized it was a movie of flashbacks, the one thing that really excited me was the thought of getting to see those colorful characters that were hinted at in the first movie! When they were all plain-ass "pretty boys" I was thoroughly disappointed. Utilizing the characters from the first movie would've made for a much more interesting story, in my opinion.
Why are you confused exactly ? Obviously that part was changed ... they had no credibility...
Sophie: She never comes anyway.
Me: Maybe because she was DEAD in the original film, Sophie!
EditorOfSL THIS I’VE BEEN SAYING THIS TO MY FRIENDS
Continuity issues, ya’ll
James Campbell she was. When Donna gets compared to her mom she gets offended
THANK YOU SO MUCH OH MY GOD
what's funny is they added her grandma into this movie JUST so she can cause some drama 😂
"Amanda is an average singer"
Me: *Chokes on spaghetti*
Endre Jansson I was waiting for someone to say this!! I think she’s amazing
@@samanthapweidman same xx
I know right
OH THANK GOD SOMEONE SAID IT
That’s triggered me
I know there may be some inconsistencies when you're making a sequel, but there's a limit to everything.
Remember how in "Mamma Mia" Donna said "Somebody up there has got it in for me. I bet it's my mother"?
Is asking the filmmakers to remember who's dead and who's alive too much?
I thought the movie was going to be about Sky leaving her and that she had to figure out how to be a single mother with the help of her friends, mom’s friends, dads, and some flashback scenes of her mom going through similar stuff
Yeah...
Yes then it decided to spring into songs, the lesser known ones by ABBA except Waterloo and SOS... Its all over the place. Past, Present blah blah blah and we still don't know who the real father is.
That's Godfather II-type storytelling. You think the writers were smart enough to even consider it?
Helena Rosno The previews were misleading.
I would watch that
When you’re to poor to afford Netflix so you watch cinema sins.
Haha 🤣😂. That how I watch them.
I wish here we go again was on Netflix
You could watch it on 123movies
Bum off someone else's account
DaKrazy one ME TOO
No, one, literally no one:
CinemaCins: LoOK At ThOsE GrApE BaSkEtS
Josh MJ ikr
Yeah! 5 sins for CinemaSins!
"Andy Garcia is featured in no more than 3% of the total runtime of the movie cliche". That's true, I'm starting to believe that it must be written in his contract that he has to briefly appear in films, similiar to how Sean Bean almost always gets killed off in his own roles...
i only know sean bean because of Funhaus XD
Nice work if you can get it
Well if Amanda Seyfried’s voice is average, I don’t know what mine is 😂
Lori Hyslop yeah seriously he needs to hear what she sounds like in les mis because that’s some good shit
at least she is an amazing actress!
I was classically trained and have sung professionally off and on over the years and I disagree with him too. Besides the scene he picked she wasn't supposed to be singing her best. It was on purpose. having said that...this movie was a far cry from Les Mis!
Lori Hyslop ...WAY BELOW AVERAGE OBVIOUSLY
@RuleofVicus Yes because being trained in Opera as a child, singing on a kids album and being the lead singer in a local band is sooooo unbelievable...for gods sake, you can hear that I can sing by watching some of the silly, crappy recordings on my channel. I could see if I claimed some crazy level of achievement but damn. What possesses someone to call some random person on the internet a liar without doing your homework? And especially for such mediocre achievements as mine?
*Dunkirk:* Here we go again!
CinemaSins - Negative Sins Supercut 2018 Part 2 (July to December) & TV Sins
ruclips.net/video/UpAThP9Dosw/видео.html
**jumps overboard**
Falklands edition
reminds me that he hasn't done Everything wrong with Dunkirk...
12:37 This guy got bars
The timeline in the sequel doesn’t match with the first movie
Emily Ann they didn’t know they would make a sequel when they made the first one.
Mikaela Noriega but they had the first movie
Ikr? If it's the late 70s/early 80s when she was conceived, and the first took place in 2008 when her character was 20.... that is not how you math...
Grace Haven the first one was set in 2000 which doesn’t help with Sophie having an iPhone (annoyingly with the same ringtone as my alarm)
@@katashworth41 oh lol
I listen to Cinema sins for the persnickety, pedantic picking, but the tirade against the grape baskets seriously cracked me up. Now the office is staring at me.
so you are saying Cinema Sins is NSFW?
"Died offscreen", code for "studio didn't want to shell out the money she demanded to demean herself in a sequel."
Mr Iczer
Ding!
Like with Will in the ID4 sequel. He lucked out there.
Apparently Meryl Streep didn't want to do all the singing and dancing.
Meryl got paid most out of all the actors and actresses
Mr Iczer she was busy filming another movie so they worked the plot around that.
"He takes off his light-ass t-shirt but leaves on his heavy as jeans" hahah. The one liners are stepping up in 2019. Got me laughing.
Yeah! I mean, he could've taken off those heavy pants, and maybe his underwear just to be safe. Aw heck, at that point take the shirt off too. The guy holding the camera SHOULD NOT look away at this point.
Don’t forget the fact the order in which Donna meets Sam, Bill, and Harry is out of order from the first movie. Also none of her crushes look like what their supposed to in regards to the photo
But.... Mayyyybe sam bill and harry all met at different times for the second time. First is harry the first time than bill than sam. but when they got to see donna for the second time it goes Sam, Bill than harry. cause in the first movie sfie reads donnas diarie you'll know if you watched the first movie
AMEN SOMEONE SAID IT. A friend and I went to watch this, in love with the first movie and the whole time we were freaking out and confused because the plots are not the same. Whoever recreated this movie did not apprently understand the first.
In general the sequel changes practically all the story
And that is 15 more sins added to the counter
ikr! even sam don't have the long hair. i prefer it to stick more to the first movie, even when it looks goofy. it could be a cool hippie 70s vibe. they missed it!
1. "One of us" is a great song.
2. You totally misunderstood "Waterloo".
3. The main sin of bringing in Cher was how it reminds us how badly everybody else is singing in this movie.
The second sin of Cher being in the movie is that Donnas mom is supposed to be dead according to the first one
The third sin of having Cher is her one song in the main movie is ONLY due to Garcia’s part having the name Fernando. THAT IS IT AND IT IS SO LAZY.
....cher is one of the worst singers of them all
@@imogen__ws Are you a full-time troll or is it just s hobby..?
Waterloo is losing yourself to love, the lyrics say “feel like I win when I lose” so knowing my fate is to be with you is still winning in this context
Do Everything Wrong With Bird Box
CinemaSins - Negative Sins Supercut 2018 Part 2 (July to December) & TV Sins
ruclips.net/video/UpAThP9Dosw/видео.html
yeah but it’s so good!
Lol I just commented that.
Not naming the girl Cinderella
Ya I hate that movie it’s so stupid
This movie is pure shite and I loved every second of it
Then why did you say it was pure shite but you liked every second of it
Oh yeah bye the way it is *shit*
Whooohoooooo first one too comment on yayyyy
K'Hairi Ross I cant tell if you’re taking the piss
It was one of the films that was so bad it was almost good😂 almost
Mama Mia 2: electric boogaloo
Bruh.
@@dontsubscribetothischannel8496 bruh sound effect #2
this is such a *MOBAMBA* n epic bruh moment haha epci time 😎😎😎
Awesome reference
omg you kremit
Oh come on CinemaSins, did you even take a chance on it?
If this joke is intentional I love u 😅
PriceyFern
I think they just wanted to tell what’s wrong.
HAHAHAHHAHA
I love this
Take a change on meeee
do birdbox pls
Tommy Craze I did one over birdbox!!! React to it man!
69th like
Omg yes
They did
I think "here we go again" sums it up
Sins I tall you sins !
Lol
I watched the trailer for this and I thought the plot was that Meryl Streep travelled back in time after she slid down the banister considering how they framed it. I would unironically watch that.
Mysterious Jojo hahahha that sounds amazing
Hey it sounds better than what we got.
Ha ha, that sounds like an intriguing concept for another time travel movie featuring the "Mamma Mia" characters!
I had issues with this film from just the trailers! (Some points are from when I saw the film)
- the boys look nothing like the first film *showed* them to look like
- where tf did this hotel come from?
- different island?!
- why tf is Donna dead?!
- Cher??
- random plot points which help *nothing* but get another ABBA song in.
- They *didn’t* use one of Skarsgard’s sons to play a younger him!
- Waterloo. Nuff said.
- the lack of time each spent with Donna. No way do you fall *so* deeply in love with someone after sleeping with them once.
- THAY ALL MET DONNA IN FRANCE!!
- Cher.
retweet
The France bit is wrong.
what do you mean 'where did the hotel come from'?
What do you mean "where did this hotel come from" it's the same hotel Donna had in the first movie. And they all did not meet Donna in Paris, she met 1 in Paris,1 on her way to the island and the last on the island.
@@bobbihearn6168 that isn't the same hotel from the first movie.... or is it supposed to be?
seriously it’s a musical unrealistic things happen
Black Ninja hsm? have you seen other musicals ? Because hsm isn’t an exception 😂
What so a mother dying isn't realistic, a young girl making her mother proud by leading the hotel isn't realistic? The mothers mother coming to see her grand daughter after her daughter died isn't realistic? Having flashbacks isn't realistic?
Welcome to CinemaSins
This movie really forgot Colin Firth’s character was gay in the first movie and found a partner...
I’m surprised he didn’t talk about how the timeline didn’t match up and how she couldn’t have gotten pregnant until like 8 or 9 years later...
The problem is they stuck b.c with the original timeline of the Broadway musical which was set in 1999. So it added up. The movie was made in 2008 and 2018. All they had to do was make the flashback 1989 and all would add up
Sassafras & Lemons gotcha
Because at this point cinemasins is no longer about pointing out actual glaring flaws in movies, but rather the most nitpicky pendantic shit like “ANOTHER song in this musical???” Or “this extra changes shirts between shots in the background!”
Frog Whisperer And a lot still enjoy that so who cares
The first movie was apparently set in 2000, as the concept of advertising businesses online is considered new. The second has a time skip of about five years, as it's noted that Sophie is now 25, and it's now 2005, despite the advanced technology that some of the characters have.
Donna wasn't the valedictorian. She was the student body's favorite student
And they don’t have valedictorian speeches at Oxford (or universities over here in general).
surely the students' favourite student body eyyyyyyyyyy
to me the sinniest sin was the costumes of the locals. I mean I get it, filming in Greece was too expensive and they went for Croatia, but seriously I bet even non greeks feel something is off... I am not even talking about the obviously different scenery - in the first one it was all aegean, barren and rocky, and here it's suddenly all green. Even the actors who are supposed to be greek, speak it broken. Also when I saw it I actually LOLed with the storm thing, and legit thought of the same thing.
The Fernando scene is the most forced moment in movie history and still haunts me to this day
Donna's mother was dead in the first film
She was?
nataliexdormer yes, donna said something about heaven punishing her OR her mom I think
To be fair Donna hadn't seen her mother in how many years? She could have just assumed she was dead, and Sophie found out she wasn't later on
yeah but they wanted to add Cher just so she could cause some drama lol
@@lizziecatherine7048 I-
Movie: Come on take a chance on me
Cinemas sins: *ding*
I know it’s not technically a movie, but can you do an Everything Wrong With Bandersnatch?
CinemaSins - Negative Sins Supercut 2018 Part 2 (July to December) & TV Sins
ruclips.net/video/UpAThP9Dosw/видео.html
Yes, please!!!
That would be great. I'm guessing he will sin the "having to start from the beginning and watching scenes we already know" function that happens everytime you chose an option that doesn't help progress the story in any way
How about everything wrong with A SNATCH
This isn't technically a movie either, and he still sinned it lol.
“Christine Hornanski”!!!😭How dare he disrespect the queen😤
I'm disappointed the first sin wasn't "Movie's title is how I feel about the movie"
Mama Mia here we WENT again 😂
Taking place in a public restroom.
#Weird
Holy shit.
Its the first video of 2019 in the Cimema Sins world.
"Amanda Seyfried's voice is average" WHAT
Daviddoesrandomstuff on RUclips for real, like has he heard she sing in les mis
Like she is perfect to play Karen in the broadway version. She has such a pretty voice
OK it’s better than average but it’s nothing special. She only worked for Les Mis cos half the cast could barely sing
@@saoirsedeltufo7436 She is not a professional singer, is that what you're saying? She is better than 98% of the people. No where near average, not good enough to be a singer.
1:28
Still better than the speech our valedictorian gave..... it was the speech given in twilight at Bella’s graduation.
what the heck HAHA
Okay but like plagerism aside it was a pretty good speech
As the Onion's reviewer so aptly said: “a film which you can either choose to enjoy for the perfectly fine piece of entertainment it is, or live out the rest of your existence as a miserable killjoy who slogs through life recoiling at anything remotely joyful or upbeat in the world. Your choice.”
Since it's The Onion, I assume they're making light of the average response of some incessant Mamma Mia fan to criticism on the film?
Unless that's their serious take on the film. If that's the case, then any awful or poorly-executed movie that was made with the intention to be uplifting can just get a pass because "if you dislike it you're just being a grouch who hates fun and happiness."
Really? I didn't really like it. Guess I'm doomed
And we all know which one cinema sins is lmao
It kills off the main character! It's not actually a super-upbeat film. I thought the sequel was the killjoy, after the much happier first one.
Which, being The Onion, is most likely sarcastic.
"Despite only appearing in this movie for 3 minutes, Meryl Streep was reflexively nominated for an Academy Award" And no one would question it.
“Drunk late-night open mic at a bar in Sacramento”
That’s ridiculously specific
Ah yes the karaoke bar in old town Sacramento, he knows it well.
"Fifty shades of Galahad"
Absolutely brilliant
Yeah, because his name IS Harry.
Pappa Pia, here we don’t go again.
Its Mamma Mia!!
Meryl Streep could be in a movie for 30 seconds and still deserve an award nominations
When you said does anyone actually like One of Us song I seriously was ashamed of myself for like really loving that song😂
Still waiting for bird box. Y'all hopin on that huh?
PLEASE DONT RUIN THAT MOVIE FOR ME TOO!
@@dancingtornado4527 If watching cinemasins ruins movies you actually enjoy, you should probably stop watching them. I love watching his videos on movies I like, it just makes them better for me. Videos on terrible movies are just cotton candy fluff.
Just ignore Penny, I’ve seen her go into comment sections that involve around people requesting movies that she likes, and she takes it so seriously and tells them to stop.
"A Quiet Place Part 2" *ding*
THATS WHAT I AM SAYING HURRY I WANNA KNOW
I heard Nintendo copyrighted this movie.
Why do
What
Because apparently Nintendo thinks they own mamma mia.
@@calebproductions1264 ummm why they think that?
I'm sure that's just a rumor. That would have made national news, a gaming company buying out ABBA.
There are only 2 good things in this movie:
1) Colin Firth's jiving
2) Andy Garcia's shouting.
They forgot to sin the fact that the guests are flying into Athens when Athens is nearly 7 hours away from the Island this takes place on, which is the fictional Greek island, Kalokairi, which is based on the real Greek island Skopelos. Skiathos International airport would've been a much better choice for guest to fly into as it is much closer. They also forgot to sin the fact that given that Skopelos is located East of the Greek mainland, if you sailed past it you would end up in Turkey. People in Europe thought you'd sail off the edge of the world if you sailed west, not east. They knew Asia was in the East.
For most Greeks, *isn't* Turkey the end of the world? 😂
I can't help but laugh at the fact that Brosnan is clearly supposed to be the dream boat dad, but clearly nobody expected Firth to still be rocking his Kingsman 2 bod for filming of this movie.
Hush you, "One of Us" is a great song!
Love your work, btw!
It really is
“Amanda is an average singer”
I’m sorry wtaf!
She a bloody good singer
Yeah I agree that she average in her singing not bad though
I disagree with the Waterloo sin. I don't think it's comparing the love to the defeat of Waterloo, I think it's comparing how she *fell* in love like how Napoleon fell in waterloo. Like I mean that she lost the war, so to speak, and fell in love
I'm sinning you for not sinning the fact that no one in either of these movies knows what a paternity test is
Here we go again to another year of Sinnin'!
CinemaSins - Negative Sins Supercut 2018 Part 2 (July to December) & TV Sins
ruclips.net/video/UpAThP9Dosw/видео.html
My EWW wishlist for 2019:
Teen Titans GO! to the Movies
Hereditary
Annihilation
Game Night
Suspiria
Crazy Rich Asians
Ant-Man and the Wasp
The Avengers (1998) (in time for Avengers: Endgame)
Pet Sematary (1989)
Every Tarantino movie you haven’t covered
Every Shyamalan movie you haven’t covered
The Cornetto trilogy
The Iron Giant
The South Park, Simpsons, and SpongeBob movies
Punisher: War Zone
The Godfather trilogy
The Indiana Jones trilogy
Roma (or whatever movie wins Best Picture for this year)
A Star is Born
Some Coen Brothers movies
Some Scorcese movies
Some Laika movies
The Prince of Egypt
Elf
The Lion King 2: Simba’s Pride (in time for the “live-action” remake)
Frozen (2010) (in time for Frozen 2-even though this one is NOT related at ALL)
Spaceballs (in time for Star Wars Episode IX)
Benjamin Abramowitz a lot of great ones here
How bold of you to think there's anything wrong with the Spongebob movie or South Park: Bigger, Longer, Uncut.
Yes
Someone feels Teens Titans Go to the movies is s***
Considering Thursday's video is Scary Sins from 2018, Herditary has a really good shot.
My Little Pony: The Movie (2017)
Sophie’s boyfriend was extremely unlikable and selfish. He wanted her to forget her mother and dedicate herself entirely to him!
I thought he just wanted her to move to New York. I'm guessing a hotel in New York makes far more profit than one on an island in Greece so I'm sure it was more due to practical considerations rather than selfishness.
That's her husband
@@kiwislime1724 Don't think they're married in the movie. I don't think the movie knows either.
I disagree, I think Sophie was the selfish one. According to the first movie, she knew from the get-go that he didn’t want to live there forever. But she did. She eventually agrees to leave the island with him and live the life he’s been wanting. then in the second movie, she takes it all back and is like “nah, we livin here now forever homie, cause mama died and I must devote my life to her spirit.”
He was understanding in the first movie about her not wanting to leave her mom. I’d also be irritated though if the mom dies/leaves and my SO is still unwilling to live their own life.
Shananananon He didn’t care whatsoever about Sophie’s poor mom, if just wanted her to want he wanted. If I was her I would have broken up with him immediately after that phone conversation. So Sophie is in the right here!
They did a good job finding people who could be younger versions of the actors... Though I'm kinda surprised that they didn't bring in a younger Skarsgård to be the younger Skarsgård... There's a whole bunch of them running around and they undeniably look alike
The "wandering eyes and groin" sentence and your follow up absolutely killed me. This is premium!
ok I have to say my favorite Mamma Mia song is One of Us!!! so hate me or whatever but it is a great song!!!
ikr? my all time fav is dancing queen.
Thanks Julia. Came to the comments section looking for this. When I watched the movie, it was the best song!!!!
Literally nothing anyone says about the mamma Mia movies will make me love them any less
when donna and her friends where performing in the original movie all 3 of the dads said that was their song but donna never sang it in the sequel
Mom, before watching: Oh, she likes musicals, she'll love this!
Me, after watching: *silently spitting fire and screaming*
Mama Mia is the reason like every other musical bases the songs off the plot and not vice versa
I hate to tell you this, but 'jukebox musical' is an entire _genre_ of unconvincing plot lines. There are dozens of these things.
Happy new Thanksgiving guys have a good 2014.
Are you using internet explorer?
You mean happy 2019, right?
@@maxschoolman3950 he's trolling lol
you meant easter
Merry Christmas you filthy animals.
Please do Everything Wrong With The Nun.
thats nun of your business
@@ventus5816 get out
Outlaw7263 Jordan Peele
VentusPL WHY AM I LAUGHING
There’s like 2 nun characters I’ve seen before that make me question the mentality that humanity has developed.
I adore this movie, but you get my heart for sinning Cher being in it for no reason
Well, she's the only one who is actually a good singer.
@@LadyOnikara Couldn't disagree more. I love this soundtrack
Last note about this video: why didn’t you mention the timeline? If Donna had just graduated uni and less than a year later she was pregnant with Sophie and the flashbacks are all in the 70s like makes sense for ABBA (and Donna graduates from Uni in ‘79) then Sophie would be way way older in the present day. Someone else has pointed out that the present day is actually 1999 and the movie is trying to line up with that as canon, the same year ABBA came out on broadway 🎭 , but that would make the presence of iPhones in Sophie’s present day wrong. Sophie would be 37 or 38...
One Of Us is like my favourite ABBA song. I can’t believe you just said that.
Fantastic Beasts: Grindelwald's Crimes next please!
Or at least as soon as its possible to watch out of cinemas 😉
That was a truly awful movie.
thats gonna be a loooong video lol
Yea. Keeping talking shit now. I’m sticking by JKs side until the series is finished, because knowing her, after the next movie is released, Crimes is going to make much more sense
@@drewkalsto2646 its not that the plot didnt make sense it was just badly written lol
too many subplots at once that choked out the main story
they should've picked 1 or 2 subplots and taken their time exploring them and letting the characters breathe a bit instead of trying so hard to have 6 individual storylines all squeezed into one movie
When i saw the title i was like “boy its perfect! no sins at all”
I think you've misinterpreted Waterloo, it's about someone winning your affection despite your best efforts not to succumb to love.
"So how could I ever refuse
I feel like I win when I lose
Waterloo couldn't escape if I wanted to
Waterloo knowing my fate is to be with you..."
This sort of love song, about your resistance to love being overcome, is pretty popular from this era.
Cinemasins is the best thing I've ever found in my entire life. I put these videos on while I work at home and my dogs are actually so used to hearing Jeremy's voice once the videos start they just chill out on the couch, and one of my dogs actually just watches the TV for hours. It's pretty awesome.
Ik I asked for it, but I REALLY love this film, and didn't want this day to come. It IS funny tho, listening to all of the sins...!
Sammy FT SAMEEE
Sammy FT SAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAME I cannot tell you how much I relate
"Annnd Cher has access to doctors who can do that" Made me spit my drink!
K but what about the fact that the staircase was magically fixed in the flashback 20 minutes later? Anyone?
20mins movie time doesn't equal 20mins real time. It would be boring if they showed someone fixing her staircase
katkowalski314 okay but my point is that someone probably wouldn’t fix the staircase
The outtakes at the end were exceptional. The Soul Glo bit had me in stitches - and hankering to rewatch 'Coming to America' for the bajillionth time.
I love this movie cuz I’m a musical junkie but I love every CinemaSins video!
*Schindlers list* : Here we go again
oof!
I eat penis because ROFL! You win Best Comment hands down.
@John Wick well I mean all the events in it are real
"And if they were all Muppets? Fine. But they're not Muppets" - sin total 1: I think we can agree the people involved in rolling out this sequel were certainly muppets of a sort
Nah, they have softer heads than the Muppets ever did.
i feel like jeremy isn't the biggest fan of musicals...
Nobody’s a fan of musicals.
@@calebproductions1264 Unless its Buffy
@@calebproductions1264 speak for yourself buddy
There’s decent musicals out there...this isn’t one of them.
“Not everyone could get over Geostorm this quickly.” I choked on air.
"Discount blonde Jared Leto" loool xD
Mamma Mia! Cinema sins finally uploaded!
That's what my Italian friend said when he saw the notification
Damn even this sins video is hard to watch. I honestly can't imagine what the real thing is like.
Just a movie for the songs
One Of Us is a beautiful song, with interesting, heartfelt lyrics and a fantastic bassline.
Did anyone else notice the mix up with Harry Brite's guitar? In the first movie, Donna has it in her collection of the past, because Harry borrows it and Sophie mentions it as her "mom's guitar." In number 2 he had the guitar still on the docks as she's sailing away. It doesn't mention him ever going back to the island for her in the second movie to my knowledge. That and the fact that Donna died 'off screen' were the major problems I had with these movies. Love them otherwise!
The whole playing point of the film was Sophie being pregnant. It only happened in the end. Unnecessary af
I never watched this movie but I am glad I watched this video for one simple reason.
Jeremy's alliterative talent and whimsical wordplay are well worth whatever time it takes to hear the sublime rhymes he playfully placated the public with while maliciously mocking the musical misery this miscarriage "Mamma Mia" made.
Thanks. I genuinely appreciate some literary love and creativity on this usually very ordinary regurgitation of pop culture known as RUclips.
Happy new year .
@Magor thanks
Happy new year to you too, Bonnie!
@@yoshithefriendlydino4025 thanks . You too .
Eat shit
I’m in the future fuckers
“The role of Captain Von Trapp in a third-grade presentation of The Sound Of Music.”
I laughed so hard I had to pause the video because I legit played Maria opposite a guy who sang flat half the time
It was a nightmare when our music cut it halfway through the love song
Maybe because Donna hated her mother, she pretended and/ or told everyone her motger was dead, but Sophie somehow found out she was alive.
Everything wrong with Cool Cat Saves the Kids
Cool Cat loves to boogie woogie!
Doing a straight-up prequel on Donna's youth would've been better already, specially if it had been accurate to the first movie's depiction of the past.