There is no performance of Tchaikovsky's 5th Symphony that has such incredible sound, quality, artistry and even something that cannot be described; than this version of Celibidache.
I'm sorry, but in my humble opinion, this has to be the best symphony ever written. Everytime I hear this symphony and especially this movement, I got shivers all over my body. I can hear this all day long.
Jesse Reith I really just don’t understand its unpopularity. There’s more emotion in the whole symphony than in any other piece I’ve ever heard, though of course I haven’t heard everything.
Brilliant performance, wonderfully conducted. but could I also give a shout-out to the person who mixed the sound? It's absolutely excellent - just like sitting in the best seats in the house. Couldn't be bettered.
As in life, relishing every note, relishing every line, relishing every individual, relishing every moment! Thank God for RUclips!
7 лет назад+13
Sin arrebatos histéricos en sus gestos, ni estridencias sonoras, común en muchos directores de orquesta. Celebidache nos conduce a captar la carga emocional y tensión contenida en el discurso Chaikovskiano.
gotta love that timpanist...he brings such a life to the exposition of the movement it's always great to see celibidache perform a rhythmic piece and them screw with it...he is still one of the most underrated conductors of the 20th century which is disappointing...
No comment!!! The best musician of the 20th century !!! Please , don't even attempt to mention Kleiber, Karajan, Klemperer , etc.. and so forth... Different league. I have no doubt what's so ever Celibidache is sitting with Bruckner , Bach ...in the Eternal's heaven.
Fantastic interpretation. I like a little faster starting tempo, but the contrasts of the tempos and emotions between the formal sections is great. Well played also. Love Celibidache.
Es de una contención abrumadora esta versión, en serio. Estoy acostumbrado a Zubin Metha y Claudio Abbado y desde luego esta versión me agrada mas. Este Tchaikovsky no cae en momentos de exaltación descontrolada y mantiene pasajes de una melodiosidad que no yo desconocía en esta obra ( minuto 7.43 ).
Tthought you are right but at noting 'new to me' notes at 7:54 and 11:10 I see they are smudged at other performances. At 4th mov there is latent danger of unrestrained gallop but Celibidache and MPO know how to balance perfectly clarity and temperament. Fast and slow parts are at balanced, too. Never heard such great 4th mov performed in a really new and magnificent manner. Btw: hear "the wind sweeping across the steppes" but hear gentle wind rustling through the grass at slower parts, too. :)
it's amazing! I haven't loved this symphony since I heard it. Because I felt that this music is cheap. But celibidache's this symphony is incredible! He is the best tchaikovsky's conductor!
Loved this version, though I think I prefer Bernstein's efforts. Tchaikovsky's "endings" (this, the last movement of the 4th and the 3rd movement of the 6th) always leave me feeling shell shocked (in a good way) by the last bar. I don't think any other composer knew how to ramp up the tension, the exuberance and the sheer unabashed joy, in places, as *he* did. Some nice camera shots here and some lovely solid Timp playing.
Adri58 muss wohl ein musiktauber Mensch sein, und außerdem klebt er an seinen früheren Höreindrücken nur dem Klange nach. Mit Celibidache kann er natürlich nicht alle die verheerenden Klischees "füttern", die noch in seinen Gehörgängen kleben...
Levine is the spalla? Of what? Or maybe he is the cold shoulder you're referring to--to which everyone who reached the level of music with Celibidache turned away from. Celibidache has brought audiences, orchestras to different dimensions of sound , a higher level...his inner cosmos and sound he got out of the orchestras he conducted made music possible. But you out there with Levine, Karajan, Ozawa( who didn't and don't have a clue about what Celibidache did throughout his musical life ... Or
Celibidache makes all a triumphal march, but his clever is in the conservation of the expression. His conducting way is mistaken, too accented, but is good the usage of the eyes and the face.
![Stromae, Pomme - “Ma Meilleure Ennemie” (from Arcane Season 2) [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1F3OGIFnW1k/mqdefault.jpg)
There is no performance of Tchaikovsky's 5th Symphony that has such incredible sound, quality, artistry and even something that cannot be described; than this version of Celibidache.
最後のほうの来日公演で人見でチャイ5を聞きましたが、後にも先にも人見記念講堂がこれほど鳴ったのは聴いたことがありませんでした。もうとんでもない演奏で、30年経った今も忘れることができません。人生の糧になっております。
確かに良い演奏です！
４５年前にムラビンスキーレニングラードフィルを、大阪フェスティバルホールで、鑑賞しました。
圧倒的な演奏でした。
恋した方に鑑賞デートを申し込みましたが、駄目ですと断られました。
独り寂しく鑑賞しました。
もう一度あの青春時代に戻ってみたい〜〜〜m(_ _)m
I'm sorry, but in my humble opinion, this has to be the best symphony ever written. Everytime I hear this symphony and especially this movement, I got shivers all over my body. I can hear this all day long.
Jesse Reith I really just don’t understand its unpopularity. There’s more emotion in the whole symphony than in any other piece I’ve ever heard, though of course I haven’t heard everything.
Non mi stancherò mai di vedere questo video. Celibidache insuperabile. Orchestra grandiosa.
This is the best rendition of the Tchaik 5's finale. I love how Celibidache doesn't rush the presto, as many conductors will do.
YES! YES! YES!!
Brilliant performance, wonderfully conducted. but could I also give a shout-out to the person who mixed the sound? It's absolutely excellent - just like sitting in the best seats in the house. Couldn't be bettered.
A mio parere la più grande interpretazione della 5. Celibidache insuperabile
As in life, relishing every note, relishing every line, relishing every individual, relishing every moment! Thank God for RUclips!
Sin arrebatos histéricos en sus gestos, ni estridencias sonoras, común en muchos directores de orquesta. Celebidache nos conduce a captar la carga emocional y tensión contenida en el discurso Chaikovskiano.
Absolutely beautiful! Tchaikovsky certainly knows how to pull at those heart strings and bring tears of joy with this movement!
Always fighting with tears when listening on this masterpiece of music...i am just loving it!
Una parola sola per il M° Celibidache: grande!
30년전 영상인데도 화질 음성 깨끗하게 잘 들었습니다
As a timpanist myself, I live for that climactic moment in the fourth movement when I get to thunder away, guns blazing.
ruclips.net/video/PoINsTzSDUY/видео.html
Check this out; especially the timpani before coda
This is why I love Tchaikovsky.
gotta love that timpanist...he brings such a life to the exposition of the movement
it's always great to see celibidache perform a rhythmic piece and them screw with it...he is still one of the most underrated conductors of the 20th century which is disappointing...
Celibidache makes it greater than it is.
Was 3 when this happened. Glad I can enjoy it now for free. Thank you internet!
was minus 12.
Bogdan-Gabriel Marinica
My life for this music.
🤗🤗🤗💗💕💕💕
No comment!!! The best musician of the 20th century !!! Please , don't even attempt to mention Kleiber, Karajan, Klemperer , etc.. and so forth... Different league. I have no doubt what's so ever Celibidache is sitting with Bruckner , Bach ...in the Eternal's heaven.
「チェリビダッケ」が指揮した音楽の魅力は、他の指揮者の録音よりも殆んど凌駕してしまいます。これまでは、チャイコフスキーの第5番は、「シャイー」か「ムラヴィンスキー」でした。しかし、この録音を聴くと他の指揮者のものは聴けなくなります。まるで「麻薬」の様なものですね。YOU TUBEの音質は、おそらく圧縮されていると想像しますが、良い再生装置で聴くと、かなりダイナミックレンジが広く感じられます。凄いですね！
Super!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻⚘💐💐💐 Love Celibidache❤
We can understand the music infinitely more with Maestro Sergio......
Yeah, Bernstein and Celibidache took from brass all breath...👏👏👏
CELY, THE BEST......10 class over karayan.....
No.
tears of joy with this movement!
Maestro Celibidache
すげ〜
生で聴きたかった！
チェリ満足そう。
You see??? No partitur!!! All the music is in his head!
Fantastic interpretation. I like a little faster starting tempo, but the contrasts of the tempos and emotions between the formal sections is great. Well played also. Love Celibidache.
what paste and clarity!! Celi was the man...
Celibidache傑利畢達希 大師的指揮音色純靜分明~據說他不喜歡錄音的作品,他認為錄音的作品就像罐頭裡的豆子般索然無味~所以很可惜坊間很少有該大師的錄音~
謝謝上傳~
Alles was Celi dirigiert ist fenomenal!
Oh, I have heard it live. It was magnificent, although Celi was much older then (two years before his death, IIRC).
Oh my god, this is amazing.
Sergiu Celibdache este fara contestatie , unul dine cei mai mari dirijori din Romania si din lume,
"El Bailador" Espetacular! Que precisão !!!
Es de una contención abrumadora esta versión, en serio.
Estoy acostumbrado a Zubin Metha y Claudio Abbado y desde luego esta versión me agrada mas.
Este Tchaikovsky no cae en momentos de exaltación descontrolada y mantiene pasajes de una melodiosidad que no yo desconocía en esta obra ( minuto 7.43 ).
Tthought you are right but at noting 'new to me' notes at 7:54 and 11:10 I see they are smudged at other performances. At 4th mov there is latent danger of unrestrained gallop but Celibidache and MPO know how to balance perfectly clarity and temperament. Fast and slow parts are at balanced, too. Never heard such great 4th mov performed in a really new and magnificent manner.
Btw: hear "the wind sweeping across the steppes" but hear gentle wind rustling through the grass at slower parts, too. :)
俄羅斯🇷🇺作曲家彼德-柴科夫斯基PETER-TCHAIKOVSKI作曲的E小調第五交響曲中的第四樂章／本曲由賽爾喬-柴利比达赫SER GIU-指揮德國🇩🇪慕尼黑愛樂交響團演奏
Sei grande, ti amo per questo! fra
Great performance! Thanks.
dear Mr. Longkou sir: you are so right
1963년 피에르 몽퇴가 런던심포니오케스트라를 지휘하며 녹음한 실황음반 (뱅가드클래식 발매)를 가장 좋아하지만, 첼리비다케의 실황연주는 또다른 해석이 재밌네요.
it's amazing!
I haven't loved this symphony since I heard it.
Because I felt that this music is cheap.
But celibidache's this symphony is incredible!
He is the best tchaikovsky's conductor!
Your mind is cheap.
I've always thought of T's symphonies as #4 for musicians, #6 for the critics, and #5 for the public.
Fantastic!
The best version!!!
mravinsky's reocrding is amazing, but this interpretation is unbeatable. wow, that clarity.
12:46 Genial forma de dirigir los trombones
Épico y hasta jocoso jeje
the most awesome part!i love it !
10:37 - 12:36 I love that theme :3
So good...
@rachmi4u You can find the symphonies in CD, most of Celibidaches works were published under the EMI label.
un clásico de tchaikosvky
Loved this version, though I think I prefer Bernstein's efforts.
Tchaikovsky's "endings" (this, the last movement of the 4th and the 3rd movement of the 6th) always leave me feeling shell shocked (in a good way) by the last bar.
I don't think any other composer knew how to ramp up the tension, the exuberance and the sheer unabashed joy, in places, as *he* did.
Some nice camera shots here and some lovely solid Timp playing.
切利的细节特别美好，听到到很多其他只会家版本没有的细节。另外柴五是听不动柴六时的精神安慰。
Se nos fue el maestro y con el el secreto de la direccion de orquesta
The Best #lovemusic
Braaaaaavo!!
Celi en su plenitud.
This music is heard all.
Tschaikowsky Sinfonie Nr.5 4.Satz by Celibidache MPO*Best-Gespielt!
Meisterdirigent-Sergiu Celibidache/Münchner Philharmoniker*추천음악
That first violinist rocking the 'fro.
I really love this rendition. Can anyone tell me where I can find the full concert? Thank you in advance.
ruclips.net/video/WFyDQp7WHKs/видео.html
real master in history more than karajan
4:45-4:51! Never heard it in this way before!!
Agreed ! !
How so?? Sounds similar too NYPO - ruclips.net/video/F3ZkoN4r66A/видео.html
if I;m luck to go up when I death I hope I can hair his music ?
I remember watching this same performance Mov.1... it was a performance like no other. Would you be so kind to upload it?
Best moment at 8:09 to 8:25
Thank you for uploading this. I love it.
Could somebody please tell me who the timpanist is ?
Is that Jackie Chan playing the French Horn?!
Adri58 muss wohl ein musiktauber Mensch sein, und außerdem klebt er an seinen früheren Höreindrücken nur dem Klange nach. Mit Celibidache kann er natürlich nicht alle die verheerenden Klischees "füttern", die noch in seinen Gehörgängen kleben...
Wagner da ovo cuje ovo izvodjenje pozeleo bi da je ovo njegova simfonija !
Is the woman trombonist Abbie Conant?
Levine is the spalla? Of what? Or maybe he is the cold shoulder you're referring to--to which everyone who reached the level of music with Celibidache turned away from. Celibidache has brought audiences, orchestras to different dimensions of sound , a higher level...his inner cosmos and sound he got out of the orchestras he conducted made music possible. But you out there with Levine, Karajan, Ozawa( who didn't and don't have a clue about what Celibidache did throughout his musical life ... Or
立っているチェリの方がかっこいいなぁ。
6:36- 7:42
la fantasia..
at 12:45 it looks like he is milking two cows! :-D
12:01 慶應医学部の長文の主人公だ！
Celibidache makes all a triumphal march, but his clever is in the conservation of the expression. His conducting way is mistaken, too accented, but is good the usage of the eyes and the face.
and the position in the space, of course, that camed from his studies in the musical phenomenology
Boring performance.