Anybody else notice how Chris Pennie buries the beater for the first phrase, then plays the kick open for the second, then buries again for 3 and 4? That attention to detail is why he's probably was one of the best drummers on Earth
0:57 isn't out of tune. It's just that the harmony is in consecutive 4ths and it isn't something we hear a lot in pop music. There are other bits that aren't perfect but hey. I love it and I love Greg's voice.
It's not out of tune, but the harmony track he laid down definitely didn't stay on pitch, which can completely ruin the harmony aspect of it. It's not perfect, but it sounds like something they did mostly just for fun
You missed the point then. The EP was to make faithful covers. They've done original covers as well. Their version of Depeche Mode's Behind the Wheel is a perfect example.
Don't much care for Timberlake (although that Super Bowl Beyonce shit was maximum trollage, and I respect that). But it'd be damn cool to hear him return the favor to DEP. Chinese Whispers would have a bitching old rockabilly feel if all the 8th notes were swung rather than straight.
Greg gives it his best shot and does a good job. Not as good as JT's original, for what it is, but when I hear JT do some of the shit Greg can do... That'll be the day
I was hoping it was the Mike Patton version. The live in San Francisco video was dope. I didn't know who's song it was and when I saw here it's Timberlake's, my whole outlook changed. I guess no one else who like's this song in whatever incarnation can say shit about certain people sometime's. Ha ha, I cringed hard when I saw his name though!
I really like this version. Maybe Gregs vocals aren't quite up to Timberlake's, but, his voice still works for this song. You don't have to be a great singer to have a voice that works with music. Though I do wish Pennie went a bit more overboard for this. He could have had so much fun with that beat.
@MrWiggerdale123 By the way, I am a musician, and I have been transcribing music for about 10 years. For example, the full score for the original Justin version. (If anyone wants it, just ask.) So I can tell the difference between singing in and out of key.
This is surprisingly similar to the original sans the guitar noodling instead of the rap verses. I expected it to be a bit more shouty. Pleasantly surprised.
he would've, the man is a mad genius. still, the concept of the album was to perform identical and 100% faithful recreations of the original songs. from what i understand, the song was first played live when mike patton was doing vocals for the group. as every member of the band actually likes justin timberlake (there's really no reason not to like him), they planned on doing just that for the album, copying it down perfectly with little to no divergence of the original.
@MrWiggerdale123 Well, English is not my mother tongue, but if you're looking for the term out of key, here it is. No sorry, it was not to offend the song or the band. It was actually a pretty serious comment - not to be taken for any ridiculous hating. And no, I'm not suggesting, I can do any better job, but I just thought such a technical band like DEP could.
The Plagiarism album is an album of covers. The band's just having fun with words. This current sentence is a "clever" & "biting" insult of something you hold dear, as per RUclips protocol.
@JonSebastianF Ohh ffffuuuuuuuuu- Haha and I actually must have been listening to just after 0:57 as opposed to the exact moment, it does in fact sound as if he's singing flat of the key, my mistake.
no. you have to listen to something before you can form an opinion. and you have the right to have a negative opinion as well. and you're free to express it. this should be common sense. unfortunately, some people are way too simple to grasp this concept.
Its funny that it says Plagiarism in the background picture. lol its like the band stole the song from Timberlake or something xD its just a cover people.
@JonSebastianF It's not out of tune? Are you aware of what "out of tune" means, haha and they wanted to remain faithful to the original, if you think you can do a better version, go do it.
the acoustic guitar tone sounds absolutely identical to the original! good cover, gregs vocals arent quite up to par though. they sound a bit flat and weak as hell. he's signing too softly. his vocals have definitely gotten better over time
It's only slightly out of tune, the kind of "out of tune" that you really only notice when you do harmonies. That's why harmonies are so critical and take practice.
Before you talk about any music and musicians. Ask yourself this. How many albums has YOUR band sold? RUclips is full of disgruntled basement musical has-beens, hating because they still play shitty covers in dive bars.
Not quite as good as I expected. It sounds almost identical to the original version, which is good in and of itself, but I was hoping for a more classic DEP-like version, with screaming and rawness.
No. "Dissonant" means in tune, but notes that are not considered to be a nice interval playing at the same time or in succession. This is just out of tune. And it's incredible I get so many negative votes just because I am using my ears. It's not so strange Dillinger didn't do the harmonies well there.. Harmonies are not so hard, but you need to do them more often to master them. And Dillinger never does vocal harmonies. They just don't use it on their songs.
Seriously, this must be joke, right? The only musician who can keep up with the original here is the drummer? And DEP are usually terrifyingly good musicians? I mean, the 2nd vocal at 0:57 isn't even in tune. Why did they just attempt to copy the original instead of doing an actual interpretation of it (aka. "a cover")? - My opinion. ...Really, IS it joke?
![[hate5six] The Dillinger Escape Plan - July 25, 2004](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X7RGe57KKGk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[hate5six] The Dillinger Escape Plan - July 25, 2004](/img/tr.png)
![FNAF Into the Pit has A LOT of Unused Graphics | LOST BITS [TetraBitGaming]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6YhZCRdipl4/mqdefault.jpg)
Anybody else notice how Chris Pennie buries the beater for the first phrase, then plays the kick open for the second, then buries again for 3 and 4? That attention to detail is why he's probably was one of the best drummers on Earth
I wanna see the face of any jt fan that looks up dep thinking they'll be similar
gregs vocals were even good back then and hes only improved exponentially since .. mans so good
They should've done this with Mike Patton...the live version is wicked!
This
Yep
now one dude ( @vithovenstyle ) uploaded on YT a best quality version of this song with Mike.
Still this.
well, if you're going to cover any pop singer....justin timberlake is the one you'd want to cover. his music is pretty damm good.
This is surprisingly faithful to the original. Good shit.
DelCtrlAlt Mike Patton did it with them too, it is even better.
YES seconded af.
Except this has such sexy drumming.
@@thattypicalslimy8548 I like Greg Puciato, more than Mike Patton.
I like it because it shows how flexible and open these guys are
Ladies and gentlemen, your target demo.
Yeah and I also love how pissed off it will make closeminded metalheads
Amazing Chris Pennie work!
When the Dillinger Esc Plan becomes on Incubus
been listening this song for like 3 days straight. perfect version
Late coming comment from me...but one of my favourite most appreciated Band performing a song I love ( can't resist Justin's voice) Fucking perfect!
0:57 isn't out of tune. It's just that the harmony is in consecutive 4ths and it isn't something we hear a lot in pop music. There are other bits that aren't perfect but hey. I love it and I love Greg's voice.
Annie Samuel That harmony is actually in the original song, it’s not something Greg or Dillinger added... lol.
Black Queen rules!!!
It's not out of tune, but the harmony track he laid down definitely didn't stay on pitch, which can completely ruin the harmony aspect of it. It's not perfect, but it sounds like something they did mostly just for fun
@@OfficiallyMaidenless i think it gives it more characer honestly, feels more off kilter
@@progfoxDude it sounds awful
Uploaded on my 18th birthday. Awesome cover.
It's so faithful to the OG that if you do the rap verse alongdide the guitar solo it lines up perfectly
My life goal is sing very well like Greg.
This guy rules.
You missed the point then. The EP was to make faithful covers. They've done original covers as well. Their version of Depeche Mode's Behind the Wheel is a perfect example.
hearing ppl hate on the singing is so funny like how can u not fall in love w this mans voice
why is it that this band is so fucking amazing! i love it!
I dig the concept they were going for
Chris Pennie is a bald God.
Don't much care for Timberlake (although that Super Bowl Beyonce shit was maximum trollage, and I respect that). But it'd be damn cool to hear him return the favor to DEP. Chinese Whispers would have a bitching old rockabilly feel if all the 8th notes were swung rather than straight.
Chinese Whispers is too hard, i think than Timberlake can't sing something like that.
i been looking for this damn this is a kick ass cover song
This is Perfect!
Been a fan of both Dillinger and JT for a couple of years now.
Greg gives it his best shot and does a good job. Not as good as JT's original, for what it is, but when I hear JT do some of the shit Greg can do... That'll be the day
Greg is the best.
Just fucking better than the original shit.
i like this version , and the original, whatever, wahen you do music or love music , we have to stay open
I was hoping it was the Mike Patton version. The live in San Francisco video was dope. I didn't know who's song it was and when I saw here it's Timberlake's, my whole outlook changed. I guess no one else who like's this song in whatever incarnation can say shit about certain people sometime's. Ha ha, I cringed hard when I saw his name though!
It sounds exacly like the original, only better
Que excelente cover 👌
I really like this version. Maybe Gregs vocals aren't quite up to Timberlake's, but, his voice still works for this song. You don't have to be a great singer to have a voice that works with music.
Though I do wish Pennie went a bit more overboard for this. He could have had so much fun with that beat.
puciato has an incredible voice, he is one of the most versatile vocalists of the last 20 years
@@theheightsboy100 Patton did it better and live to boot.
@@Yeomannn they both did a good job, would ‘t say one was better or worse, I like puciato better than patton but they’re both great vocalists
@@Yeomannn I like Greg Puciato, more than Mike Patton and Justin Timberlake. His voice is powerful and can sing in a lot of vocal styles too.
@MrWiggerdale123 By the way, I am a musician, and I have been transcribing music for about 10 years. For example, the full score for the original Justin version. (If anyone wants it, just ask.) So I can tell the difference between singing in and out of key.
Its called a 4th harmony, mister musician.
This is surprisingly similar to the original sans the guitar noodling instead of the rap verses.
I expected it to be a bit more shouty. Pleasantly surprised.
lol this is hilarious
he would've, the man is a mad genius. still, the concept of the album was to perform identical and 100% faithful recreations of the original songs. from what i understand, the song was first played live when mike patton was doing vocals for the group. as every member of the band actually likes justin timberlake (there's really no reason not to like him), they planned on doing just that for the album, copying it down perfectly with little to no divergence of the original.
maybe they just covered it because it's a cool song......does it matter that it's by justin timberlake? good music is just that
Cheers to you my friend.
@MrWiggerdale123 Well, English is not my mother tongue, but if you're looking for the term out of key, here it is. No sorry, it was not to offend the song or the band. It was actually a pretty serious comment - not to be taken for any ridiculous hating. And no, I'm not suggesting, I can do any better job, but I just thought such a technical band like DEP could.
The Plagiarism album is an album of covers. The band's just having fun with words.
This current sentence is a "clever" & "biting" insult of something you hold dear, as per RUclips protocol.
@JonSebastianF
Ohh ffffuuuuuuuuu- Haha and I actually must have been listening to just after 0:57 as opposed to the exact moment, it does in fact sound as if he's singing flat of the key, my mistake.
Never understood why people 'dislike' songs. I mean if you don't like it, don't listen to it right?
no. you have to listen to something before you can form an opinion. and you have the right to have a negative opinion as well. and you're free to express it. this should be common sense. unfortunately, some people are way too simple to grasp this concept.
I never understood how people make such stupid comments like this. I mean, if you don't think, don't speak right?
yeah, man how am I supposed to know if I like a song or not if I haven't listened to it?
The thumbs down button is not askin you if you enjoyed the video. It is askin you to rate the quality of the video.
jeleopard The expression is 'Think before you speak' and I did, but thank you ever so much for caring.
That's the idea of that EP ;)
I wish he had done the "rap" part in the middle!
It's the name of the EP ;)
That is an Opinion, But in fact dillinger actually makes their music, Timberlake doesn't write or make all his music.
it actually is true. yea of course he did write some songs but that's the keyword "SOME".
lol and that's how it should be buddy :) glad you didn't lash out in anger like most people, Good Shit!
Its funny that it says Plagiarism in the background picture. lol its like the band stole the song from Timberlake or something xD its just a cover people.
In the beginning, was that another one of their songs leading into this song or was it just some random sounds?
Random stuff maybe
It's probably a sample of the original "Like I Love You"; skewed, reversed and edited along with the opening guitar riff.
It was this song reversed
plagiarism is the name of the ep.
justin timberlake disliked this video.
This original version's way better than Timberlake's shitty pop cover of it...
Patton did this better live. Puciato sucked on this song.
@JonSebastianF
It's not out of tune? Are you aware of what "out of tune" means, haha and they wanted to remain faithful to the original, if you think you can do a better version, go do it.
the acoustic guitar tone sounds absolutely identical to the original! good cover, gregs vocals arent quite up to par though. they sound a bit flat and weak as hell. he's signing too softly. his vocals have definitely gotten better over time
this was probably all the first takes of everything....
I hope you realize that Dissonant does not mean In Tune.
@jmasterX Mm
It's only slightly out of tune, the kind of "out of tune" that you really only notice when you do harmonies. That's why harmonies are so critical and take practice.
@xhushbladex ahahaha maybe i think he like this video
this should have been recorded with Patton, this version is souless and not fun at all
It seems that shit must not sound like shit. just give it the right men.
I could say it is better because that's what an opinion is...
Justin Timberlake would never
i dont like the voice, too much efects
but still enjoy it
.......
Who the fuck is Justin Timberlake?
Before you talk about any music and musicians. Ask yourself this. How many albums has YOUR band sold? RUclips is full of disgruntled basement musical has-beens, hating because they still play shitty covers in dive bars.
Not quite as good as I expected. It sounds almost identical to the original version, which is good in and of itself, but I was hoping for a more classic DEP-like version, with screaming and rawness.
:(
this sounds exactly like the original... just not as good
I'm a fan on Timberlake and Dillinger. i gotta admit that this is a poor cover, mostly from Puciato's part.. The vocals are weak.
No. "Dissonant" means in tune, but notes that are not considered to be a nice interval playing at the same time or in succession. This is just out of tune. And it's incredible I get so many negative votes just because I am using my ears.
It's not so strange Dillinger didn't do the harmonies well there.. Harmonies are not so hard, but you need to do them more often to master them. And Dillinger never does vocal harmonies. They just don't use it on their songs.
Awful singing, bad timing
Oh no you didn't... (Damn this is terrible, and I thought the original was bad...)
0:57 out of tune.. how can incredibly skilled musicians like them let that happen?
David Duwaer Haha, you’re an idiot
Seriously, this must be joke, right?
The only musician who can keep up with the original here is the drummer? And DEP are usually terrifyingly good musicians? I mean, the 2nd vocal at 0:57 isn't even in tune.
Why did they just attempt to copy the original instead of doing an actual interpretation of it (aka. "a cover")?
- My opinion.
...Really, IS it joke?