Well I guess I'm totally different because its really hard to feel sorry for them when not one monkey is even trying to forage. That's straight up lazy and pathetic!
Seeing how many monkeys there are gathering at the road, as cold as it may sound, sterilizing for population control is warranted, especially knowing the fact that only warm weather months can provide enough food to keep them alive. During the cold months they have to rely on handouts. Handouts are great for extra treats, but not for dependence of life.
Yes sterilization is probably one of the better methods I just hope they are more well-thought out and planned - some 2-3 years old have been chosen too that's pretty cruel.
Arroz. Yes, totally agree. I can not abide with cruelty to animals in any sense of the word. My personal love is dogs. I have a male Newfoundland now, His name is Moochy. He tips the scales at about 200 and is spoiled as I can spoil him ;)
i have to say I prefer cats but looking after a big dog takes a lot of dedication. Your dog is lucky to have you :) In HK most dogs once they are no long cute they will be abandoned. Chinese could be very cruel.
@Shay Barfield Yeah, SO INNOCENT! Like the 'innocent' one that tore a little boy's PRIVATES off and ATE them as his Mother watched in horror? Or the other 'innocent' one that tore off a 12yr old girl's FACE OFF? Oh, and this was because they didn't produce FOOD immediately!! OR, the 'INNOCENT' one that ripped a nursing 12 DAY OLD baby, from her mother( in their home!), left through the window up to the roof and DROPPED THE INFANT TO HER DEATH!! These things are FAR from 'innocent'! ALL of these channels are manipulated in one way or another to show them in whatever light that produces money for the owner of that channel. These things are cold blooded murderers and theives! Please, see them through OPEN eyes! I, personally have YEARS of primate experience as a volunteer (zoo) and former owner. THEY ARE DANGEROUS! Asia is playing with FIRE, letting their numbers get so large! A MASS STERILIZATION and CULLING NEEDS to take place. Otherwise, when food runs low, they will infiltrate human popullated areas as they become desperate. MORE DEATH OF HUMANS WILL OCCUR!!
They have so much food sources in the forest but they have now turned into waiting for handouts. This is why you don't mess with mother nature, you only end up ruining everything including the lives of animals. This is sad
What truly burns my ass is, these people who do these videos make money from them. What they need to do is take a good portion of that money and get feed and yes vet care for these animals. They could even pick up the trash in the area but no they don't. The true cruel ones aren't the other clans but the people behind the cameras that are only truly worried about making a dime from it instead of giving and putting some of the money to help support, care and feed the very things they are making money from.
I don't know if arroz is at fault of this but I truly hope this person does care enough about them to put the money into the animals he or she is making from them.
@@Sabrina-rn9dn Arroz is not like the videographers in Cambodia..he does care..he gives them food when the opportunity arises like sweet potato and chick peas and beans. Some give crunchy macaroni fruit and corn..they now have registered feeders too.. Arroz also picks up the litter left by other people who just give them crappy sweets in wrappers etc..i hope now 2 yrs down the rd you can see how much he cares about these monkeys..he is NOT in it to make money but because he loves these wonderful animals
@@kimmarievan-ever6599 yeah exactly, he's even made several video series documenting and exposing the abuse of many SE Asian channels both filming semi-wild troops and those doing these pet baby monkey video-mills all over YT. As a result he's been targetted by the Cambodian VOs mass reporting false abuse claims on his channel. They've gotten this channel completely demonetized such that for years his one channel with all his subs made no money at all. It was purely a passion project. He finally setup a new channel that's growing and getting some ad revenue but nothing compared to his day job (I think he's a surgeon).
I've been watching these videos for several months now. I didn't realize until today that I'm starting to care about some of these monkeys. Dopey and Knotty in particular have found their way into my heart. It really
Could you leave the little yellow boxes up that tell us what is going on a bit longer. They pop up and close so fast I don’t have time to read them. Even if it is just a few seconds longer. Now for me anyway they pop up and close so fast I get the first few words if I am luck. Thanks
This is what happens when we encourage dependence of wild animals. They lose the ability to be self-sufficient and forage. If you (I'm talking to the occasional feeders) are going to feed a wild animal, don't stop after dependence has set in. How cruel we are to feed these monkeys at our leisure. It should be illegal to feed wild animals, punishable by jail time.
Why do people go there and tease them? They know they want food. The way I look at it is this land belongs to them so if you want to uses the trails and parks you should bring them gifts. Also the ones that bring a small bag of peanuts or a few morsels of food and laugh as the monkeys try to kill each other over them. Sigh 😢 it’s pitiful
I love the way this little guy sits, with his feet and hands folded in.. oh and his facial expressions and big round eyes are everything. All these baby monkeys are precious and gorgeous but he just sticks out to me more Dopey is his name..
Looks like Gypsy is injured and at least we'll know who the father is if Gypsy has another baby any time soon, LOL - Sheesh - GRANDEE had the ultimate scorpion from mortal combat "Get over here" grip on her earlier in the clip LOL. I was thinking, how romantic, he's grooming her while on the fence staring at the sun go down LOL - He's definitely scoring but then she hopped off and ran off LOL...
17:05 I love watching a baby trying to touch the teats & being sneaky...its to darn funny, the try to touch without looking & miss just about every time!!! 😂😂💕🐒
That’s what happens when the population of any animal gets over fed for a long period of time without any natural predators to thin the weak of the population out it will end up either causing a mass starvation event or a mass disease event that would wipe out far more of the population than would’ve occurred naturally. By naturally I mean that people didn’t constantly feed, people didn’t interact with them all the time (besides taking pictures at a distance with the exception of an animal that is at a zoo/event for people to actually interact with the animal but those animals rarely do good with wild animals afterwards), people shouldn’t bribe them with food to train negative behaviors (Positive reinforcement with a negative behavior being the “rewarded behavior” is what has caused so many of these psychotic monkeys in the different troops.), and any natural predators should be left alone. With the exceptions for natural predators that attack people and which they should be tranquilized in order to relocate them into an ecosystem that isn’t near people with the same species that are located in the same region.
It's been a looking time since I've seen this one. I'm doing some flash backs on some old clips. I've now realized knotty waisted too much time begging. He needed to just go in for it not play with them and stare at them. I've noticed his new brother goes right in
@@oohlalalaurenn she didn't seem to be a good mother however they Have all learned to survive. So I guess if nothing else that part of her to be called a good mother. However you can tell she doesn't really like the kids only at her convenience
These things can go a whole two weeks without eating or drinking a thing once they're passed a year old. People feel bad for these things and decide to help by bringing them boxes of bread for the troop ironically it is actually devastating for the troop because they eventually rely on humans to bring them for instead of going out n getting it themselves lol just like a wild animL is supposed to do for survival. It's actually kind of funny for me tho cause these are the ugliest and most annoying animals we have on earth so f*** em lol
I meant to write, a B written on his chest. Anybody know why? How sad they all sound and look in this video. I was hoping a car would finally stop and feed all of them. They're all so precious and dear. I love your video's, so full of emotion!
Wow, I remember seeing parts of this video a long while ago. It was good to see the rest of the footage from this video. THANKYOU for sharing Mr Arroz. Wow, Skull head was skin and bones. He was never super huge like some of the grown males but he was much more filled out though. Could someone please educate me a bit more, I know these monkeys are not fed by feeders like at (for example: in Cambodia monkeys) but the part I don't understand is, I'm told that if there weren't any regular feeders passing out handouts that these monkeys wouldn't survive. Is that correct info? I simply ask because back in the old days (old world monkeys) were never around humans and stayed in the jungle eating what nature gave them year out. That's what obviously our creator made for them to survive is natural habitat living out in the wild. Old world monkeys survived on nature food only as for these monkeys can't survive without handouts? Why is that? I'm just curious and obviously still learning more abo
These monkeys in particular. (Please no hate responses, this is clearly for educating and helping me as well as those who are also trying to fully understand).. I'm just trying to learn what old world monkeys had and ate that our monkeys today don't have out in the jungle today. I read here online that wild monkeys forage and can live on greens,(grass, plants"leaves",flowers,twigs,buds,shoots,nuts,berries,insects,small rodents,even snakes,etc. any info would be greatly appreciated. 😀
Poor mr skull head is not well I love him he’s adorable chap and is never nasty to anyone I would just love to cuddle and hug him to show that he’s lovely and deserves lots of love and affection I know he’s going to die soon and it’s so sad knowing that I know how much he will be missed by everyone especially the young monkeys don’t matter what troop he’s always kind to the yearlings ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Just a quick question - Do you try to avoid showing any confrontations, or disagreements ? I hear a great deal of chattering and noise, but it never shows up on the video. Great work, by the way ! It just might be kind of interesting to be able to actually see what all the commotion and noise are all about..........
@@squareoasis6975 they do. The majority of his viewers on here think that macaques are peaceful and humans are the only reason for confrontations and fights and this channel is "proof" of that. I have read many comments on other channels accusing VOs of cutting videos to fit a narrative or instigating because "arrow hardly has fights". Plus, they won't report him because it makes him look like he does this for the love of the monkeys and not money.
My last playlist to Tha Saga of Bossy, nice playlist, looking forward for new playlist, I really love watching playlist long videos thank you Arros for all The Saga of Bossy video playlist they are all worth watching video and made me understand all the characters from the different troops and their behavior, they are wonderful creatures of God next to humans, I have learned a lot from the and learned to love and care for them,they made me cry and laughed and sometimes felt nervous mix emotions thank my dear cousins of the monkey world, hopefully when I will revisit HK I will meet you all personally and feed you.
I had a salad, fruit & a cherry turnover with water to drink for dinner & I feel so bad for the Monkey Hill monkeys. My questions are: 1) I read when food is scarce, they will eat leaves, twigs, bark, flowers, seeds, roots, insects & even dirt. There seem to be lush forests all around so why can't they eat what is there. I know they prefer fruit but if they're starving I thought they're resourceful. 2) The moms such as Reddy, Lizzie & Gypsy that are still nursing are eating what to produce milk? How is it that the moms eat but the rest go hungry? 🤔 That is all for now & the video was very informative. 🐒
the kid get the milk they produce and not only that with out mom being full can't produce milk or if she let the baby eat first she would die and so would the baby she can always have another baby
They aren't humans. Animals don't have the thought process of a human and don't live by our standards. They CAN'T think of how someone else feels or what they need because they aren't human. They don't see their offspring as we see ours because they aren't human. Their instinct is self preservation. Babies ALWAYS eat last. If babies survive, that's fine. I'd they don't... they'll be another. But no animal will sit back hungry and let their young eat
Wow. And here I sit still watching September 4, 2023!!! I would absolutely cry I think if I had to do the Where are they now game, I hate looking for a favorite and finding out they are passed away or missing. Or the little girl he saw one day by the water that was around for awhile then just disappeared . And the little boy who couldn't cope. And the ones that starve. Can't take it
Arroz Marisco I know this is a older video you made, but you have followers who would love to help you out feeding your little Bossy troupe and all your babies. I'm sure none of us will be huge contributors because many like me are retired early due to a injury and or on a fixed income. But a little here and there could go a long way to help feed your band of mothers/babies misfits and sick. Maybe even help to pay a vet to show up once in a while and give everyone a clean bill of health. I don't know how we could do it without it looking like a income except for a Go fund me or something of that nature, but I don't know how those things work in Japan. Think about it, and let us know how we can help you. We know you're a decent man just by the compassion and love you show our cousins on Monkey hill.
Clean bill of health? these are wild monkeys; you’d have to trap and sedate them to even get a vet close enough to do any sort of examination..and why would any self-respecting veterinarian offer to do such a thing? It would be like asking a physician to walk through the slums of a large city offering free medical treatment to everyone living there…its a recipe for disaster. These animals have survived thousands of years without veterinary support and without human feeding, and whatever their fate may be, it shouldn’t be up to us to decide
Wow. Very sobering video. Thank You for all that you do for them. I know you would help all of them if you could. I hope the Registered Feeder is ok & does show up for them.
They need to stop feeding them, that's all. They've grown too dependent on humans for handouts instead of foraging and teaching their babies to forage.
Maybe it's not good that they rely so much on humans to get food. Wild animals are supposed to get their food in the wild. So when there is no human to give them food, they are starving when they should not.
I am rewatching all the episodes and i don't know why i never noticed that male that is all over Gypsy's nut and crackin it! Maybe he is Knotty's dad or mabye Kneely's father when she is born Gypsy sure has strong genes! You can definitely tell all her babies!
Arroz Marisco There's no no backup feeder? That's a shame to have them all hungry like this. I'm not criticizing the regular feeder, just the management's lack of forethought.
Well sadly, some of them like us humans got reliant on fast foods, now with the pandemic even human are paying higher for fast food or scratching their heads asking, "how do I start or use this stove?" Well,, monkeys dont have pockets to carry money, so they even are thinking, where is our food delivery? Even though I like we are watching them film in as much wild as possible, once we took over so much the wilderness for highways & byways , I guess it's a bittersweet situation where we can get up and close with the monkeys, even though we are getting some joy from it, I say some, because I wonder how much the human interactions have changed some of the natural behaviors & anxiety levels of the monkey....hence we have Golden Hill, which I call Monkey Hill. (Luckily it's not like the mean VOs purposely causing friction for the monkeys for footage in Cambodia, Vietnam Nam, Golden Hill Is beautiful & real as I have witnessed.
My heart was hurting watching Knotty try to get Mom to allow him to get a drink. He knew he would be rejected, but the temptation got the best of him, bless his heart, getting closer by the second....trying not to get catch, barely reaching out to touch them😢. Ill really be happy one our little 🐵don't need the Milk Bar any more. Kkk
Apple trees have a fruiting season. They only bear fruit at a particular time of year. The same for most other fruits, vegetables, flowers, grasses seeds, and nuts. During the colder months, for example the trees, bushes, vines & plants die off or go dormant to continue their life cycle the following year. So you can plant all the fruit trees the climate can bear but it’s only going to be available during the appropriate season. So, for example, in the winter when all of that year’s crops have been harvested the trees will go dormant and await the coming spring when the leaves grow and the flowers bloom and eventually fruit is once again available. TL;DR? Apples and other fruits are only available when they are in season. The rest of the year they are out of luck unless they have access to a Grocery Store.
Does the park feed these monkeys ? If the recievs some type of government funding or donations for providing food for the monkeys ? If so it would seem that any money for this purpose and survival of the monkeys isn't being done. Is there a way to look into that ? . also could the lack of food be a reason some moms become aggressive and abusive with there new borne and refuse to nurse them, and ween them to early ?
Humans have made it worse for these monkeys these monkeys have now dependent on humans to feed them take care of them everything I blame the humans for doing this to these poor monkeys they need to fend for themselves they need to go out into the wilderness and they need to get their own foods the population grows and grows due to the fact that we feed them we harbor food for them and then they just keep making babies and then we end up with this starvation if that's what you call it but to me they don't appear to be like they're starving
What kind of crap is this again? The picture is blurry and shaky. Are there only amateurs at work here? Let people who know what they're doing film it.
@@chloeshann8142 Well, if there's no legitimate reason, then of course not. From what I understand, they're a nuisance because of overpopulation. It's a fact that almost all adult macaques carry hepatitis, the C strain, I think. They leave droppings everywhere in public places such as parks where people come with their children. They destroy crops and personal property. Reason enough? (Shows your thinking)
all the cell phone I can't tell it's about 25 .37 there's two monkeys on a fence run young monkey and one big monkey which looks like a juvenile he's been branded or are marked with a square and a big P. what's up with that? was that to show he's or she been fix?
Why was Dopey's young "Aunt" in the tree with him annoyed and biting him? I didn't see Dopey do anything wrong. She isn't doing a very good job so far. Lol. But better than the aunt who tried to make him one of "The Flying Wallendas".
They're not starving. Just become dependent on people to provide food for them.
Well I guess I'm totally different because its really hard to feel sorry for them when not one monkey is even trying to forage. That's straight up lazy and pathetic!
It is not them being lazy, they have been habituated...waiting for the feeders and fighting for food IS their foraging;)
They eat leaves, bugs , grass...how could they be starving!
Seeing how many monkeys there are gathering at the road, as cold as it may sound, sterilizing for population control is warranted, especially knowing the fact that only warm weather months can provide enough food to keep them alive. During the cold months they have to rely on handouts. Handouts are great for extra treats, but not for dependence of life.
Yes sterilization is probably one of the better methods I just hope they are more well-thought out and planned - some 2-3 years old have been chosen too that's pretty cruel.
Arroz. Yes, totally agree. I can not abide with cruelty to animals in any sense of the word. My personal love is dogs. I have a male Newfoundland now, His name is Moochy. He tips the scales at about 200 and is spoiled as I can spoil him ;)
i have to say I prefer cats but looking after a big dog takes a lot of dedication. Your dog is lucky to have you :) In HK most dogs once they are no long cute they will be abandoned. Chinese could be very cruel.
I don't like how the Chinese treat animals, especially dogs.
@Shay Barfield Yeah, SO INNOCENT! Like the 'innocent' one that tore a little boy's PRIVATES off and ATE them as his Mother watched in horror? Or the other 'innocent' one that tore off a 12yr old girl's FACE OFF? Oh, and this was because they didn't produce FOOD immediately!! OR, the 'INNOCENT' one that ripped a nursing 12 DAY OLD baby, from her mother( in their home!), left through the window up to the roof and DROPPED THE INFANT TO HER DEATH!! These things are FAR from 'innocent'! ALL of these channels are manipulated in one way or another to show them in whatever light that produces money for the owner of that channel. These things are cold blooded murderers and theives! Please, see them through OPEN eyes! I, personally have YEARS of primate experience as a volunteer (zoo) and former owner. THEY ARE DANGEROUS! Asia is playing with FIRE, letting their numbers get so large! A MASS STERILIZATION and CULLING NEEDS to take place. Otherwise, when food runs low, they will infiltrate human popullated areas as they become desperate. MORE DEATH OF HUMANS WILL OCCUR!!
They have so much food sources in the forest but they have now turned into waiting for handouts. This is why you don't mess with mother nature, you only end up ruining everything including the lives of animals. This is sad
You are 100% right. Those who feed should be ashamed
@@chloeshann8142 they are trying to do a good thing. I wouldn't say they should be ashamed.
@@hithisismyusername I would with out hesitation.
This video made me cry. Unfortunately, overpopulation can have some extremely cruel outcomes. God bless you Arroz. Every animal needs a voice.
What truly burns my ass is, these people who do these videos make money from them. What they need to do is take a good portion of that money and get feed and yes vet care for these animals. They could even pick up the trash in the area but no they don't. The true cruel ones aren't the other clans but the people behind the cameras that are only truly worried about making a dime from it instead of giving and putting some of the money to help support, care and feed the very things they are making money from.
I don't know if arroz is at fault of this but I truly hope this person does care enough about them to put the money into the animals he or she is making from them.
Sabrina 79 place is a pigstie!! Trash everywhere. Even seen photo pos’s throwing trash on ground.
@@Sabrina-rn9dn Arroz is not like the videographers in Cambodia..he does care..he gives them food when the opportunity arises like sweet potato and chick peas and beans. Some give crunchy macaroni fruit and corn..they now have registered feeders too.. Arroz also picks up the litter left by other people who just give them crappy sweets in wrappers etc..i hope now 2 yrs down the rd you can see how much he cares about these monkeys..he is NOT in it to make money but because he loves these wonderful animals
@@kimmarievan-ever6599 yeah exactly, he's even made several video series documenting and exposing the abuse of many SE Asian channels both filming semi-wild troops and those doing these pet baby monkey video-mills all over YT. As a result he's been targetted by the Cambodian VOs mass reporting false abuse claims on his channel. They've gotten this channel completely demonetized such that for years his one channel with all his subs made no money at all. It was purely a passion project. He finally setup a new channel that's growing and getting some ad revenue but nothing compared to his day job (I think he's a surgeon).
I've been watching these videos for several months now. I didn't realize until today that I'm starting to care about some of these monkeys. Dopey and Knotty in particular have found their way into my heart. It really
I understand they do grow on you and see what sort of a mess I've got myself into !
@@ArrozMarisco360 Happily you are floating now, that trough the power of your heart!.( Keep it!
Yes dopey definitely
🥰🥰🥰
Too many of them... Die from starvation. Plant trees fruit, donations go farther if you buy the tree
Are you going to feed those animals for the eternity? They do nothing in this life.
Could you leave the little yellow boxes up that tell us what is going on a bit longer. They pop up and close so fast I don’t have time to read them. Even if it is just a few seconds longer. Now for me anyway they pop up and close so fast I get the first few words if I am luck. Thanks
The sound they all make at the same time sounds like people watching a fireworks display. Lol!
This is what happens when we encourage dependence of wild animals. They lose the ability to be self-sufficient and forage. If you (I'm talking to the occasional feeders) are going to feed a wild animal, don't stop after dependence has set in. How cruel we are to feed these monkeys at our leisure. It should be illegal to feed wild animals, punishable by jail time.
Donna Wilson thank you humans need to keep there shit out of animal life..
Humans are 100% responsible for this. STOP FEEDING THEM
So much for learning how to forage.
That’s was I was thinking. Over dependence on humans whilst losing foraging skills on top of overpopulation
Seems like survival instinct would kick and they’d forage for food, if they got hungry enough. They still know where to find it.
I think many have never foraged
Why do people go there and tease them? They know they want food.
The way I look at it is this land belongs to them so if you want to uses the trails and parks you should bring them gifts.
Also the ones that bring a small bag of peanuts or a few morsels of food and laugh as the monkeys try to kill each other over them. Sigh 😢 it’s pitiful
There are many people who treat the place like a petting zoo some fool even take it like a safari park. 😝
sad
The monkeys view it as their world, the people view it as their world. They are both primates.
Lib Tard
What did they eat before humans started feeding them?
I love the way this little guy sits, with his feet and hands folded in.. oh and his facial expressions and big round eyes are everything. All these baby monkeys are precious and gorgeous but he just sticks out to me more Dopey is his name..
Look up Tiny from Arroz. Total meltdown. Has the cutest scowl.
Looks like Gypsy is injured and at least we'll know who the father is if Gypsy has another baby any time soon, LOL - Sheesh - GRANDEE had the ultimate scorpion from mortal combat "Get over here" grip on her earlier in the clip LOL. I was thinking, how romantic, he's grooming her while on the fence staring at the sun go down LOL - He's definitely scoring but then she hopped off and ran off LOL...
Grandee's definitely the smooth operator
I came upon your videos late in the game, so I have never seen so many on the road, with troops so close together.
17:05 I love watching a baby trying to touch the teats & being sneaky...its to darn funny, the try to touch without looking & miss just about every time!!! 😂😂💕🐒
😂😂😂😂😂
you probably get this question all the time but why is some of their faces are so red?!?
That’s what happens when the population of any animal gets over fed for a long period of time without any natural predators to thin the weak of the population out it will end up either causing a mass starvation event or a mass disease event that would wipe out far more of the population than would’ve occurred naturally. By naturally I mean that people didn’t constantly feed, people didn’t interact with them all the time (besides taking pictures at a distance with the exception of an animal that is at a zoo/event for people to actually interact with the animal but those animals rarely do good with wild animals afterwards), people shouldn’t bribe them with food to train negative behaviors (Positive reinforcement with a negative behavior being the “rewarded behavior” is what has caused so many of these psychotic monkeys in the different troops.), and any natural predators should be left alone. With the exceptions for natural predators that attack people and which they should be tranquilized in order to relocate them into an ecosystem that isn’t near people with the same species that are located in the same region.
It's been a looking time since I've seen this one. I'm doing some flash backs on some old clips. I've now realized knotty waisted too much time begging. He needed to just go in for it not play with them and stare at them. I've noticed his new brother goes right in
She was kinda different with each baby though..😕
@@oohlalalaurenn she didn't seem to be a good mother however they Have all learned to survive. So I guess if nothing else that part of her to be called a good mother. However you can tell she doesn't really like the kids only at her convenience
THEN YOU FEED THEM AND MAKE THEM DEPENDENT ON YOU FOR FOOD AND THEY DONT FORAGE. HUMANS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS
These things can go a whole two weeks without eating or drinking a thing once they're passed a year old. People feel bad for these things and decide to help by bringing them boxes of bread for the troop ironically it is actually devastating for the troop because they eventually rely on humans to bring them for instead of going out n getting it themselves lol just like a wild animL is supposed to do for survival. It's actually kind of funny for me tho cause these are the ugliest and most annoying animals we have on earth so f*** em lol
I meant to write, a B written on his chest. Anybody know why? How sad they all sound and look in this video. I was hoping a car would finally stop and feed all of them. They're all so precious and dear. I love your video's, so full of emotion!
Wow, I remember seeing parts of this video a long while ago. It was good to see the rest of the footage from this video. THANKYOU for sharing Mr Arroz. Wow, Skull head was skin and bones. He was never super huge like some of the grown males but he was much more filled out though. Could someone please educate me a bit more, I know these monkeys are not fed by feeders like at (for example: in Cambodia monkeys) but the part I don't understand is, I'm told that if there weren't any regular feeders passing out handouts that these monkeys wouldn't survive. Is that correct info? I simply ask because back in the old days (old world monkeys) were never around humans and stayed in the jungle eating what nature gave them year out. That's what obviously our creator made for them to survive is natural habitat living out in the wild. Old world monkeys survived on nature food only as for these monkeys can't survive without handouts? Why is that? I'm just curious and obviously still learning more abo
These monkeys in particular. (Please no hate responses, this is clearly for educating and helping me as well as those who are also trying to fully understand).. I'm just trying to learn what old world monkeys had and ate that our monkeys today don't have out in the jungle today. I read here online that wild monkeys forage and can live on greens,(grass, plants"leaves",flowers,twigs,buds,shoots,nuts,berries,insects,small rodents,even snakes,etc. any info would be greatly appreciated. 😀
actually many of them do if you see them on a bigger screen. The info is in my website. basically it means they have been sterilized .
@@shannonissweet800912:12
Do they not have regular feeders in the winter.as much tourism as they bring it during the winter the government should be sending feeders more often
And now, in 2022, they are all Fat from being overfed.
Poor mr skull head is not well I love him he’s adorable chap and is never nasty to anyone I would just love to cuddle and hug him to show that he’s lovely and deserves lots of love and affection I know he’s going to die soon and it’s so sad knowing that I know how much he will be missed by everyone especially the young monkeys don’t matter what troop he’s always kind to the yearlings ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Just a quick question - Do you try to avoid showing any confrontations, or disagreements ? I hear a great deal of chattering and noise, but it never shows up on the video. Great work, by the way ! It just might be kind of interesting to be able to actually see what all the commotion and noise are all about..........
Dave Carter see, that’s what I wanna see too
I don’t think they last long enough to be able to pan the camera in time
@@squareoasis6975 they do. The majority of his viewers on here think that macaques are peaceful and humans are the only reason for confrontations and fights and this channel is "proof" of that. I have read many comments on other channels accusing VOs of cutting videos to fit a narrative or instigating because "arrow hardly has fights". Plus, they won't report him because it makes him look like he does this for the love of the monkeys and not money.
Knotty: whos this fool sitting with my mama? 😂
My last playlist to Tha Saga of Bossy, nice playlist, looking forward for new playlist, I really love watching playlist long videos thank you Arros for all The Saga of Bossy video playlist they are all worth watching video and made me understand all the characters from the different troops and their behavior, they are wonderful creatures of God next to humans, I have learned a lot from the and learned to love and care for them,they made me cry and laughed and sometimes felt nervous mix emotions thank my dear cousins of the monkey world, hopefully when I will revisit HK I will meet you all personally and feed you.
You have people saying feed them put they will not give a human a sandwich smfh. Stop feeding them and let them get there own food
LOL..... beautiful...!!!!!
so near and can't reach them....!
I had a salad, fruit & a cherry turnover with water to drink for dinner & I feel so bad for the Monkey Hill monkeys. My questions are: 1) I read when food is scarce, they will eat leaves, twigs, bark, flowers, seeds, roots, insects & even dirt. There seem to be lush forests all around so why can't they eat what is there. I know they prefer fruit but if they're starving I thought they're resourceful. 2) The moms such as Reddy, Lizzie & Gypsy that are still nursing are eating what to produce milk? How is it that the moms eat but the rest go hungry? 🤔 That is all for now & the video was very informative. 🐒
The detailed info is in my website.
So if humans stop feeding them they would die? The natural way of foraging has left them?
9:25 Wow, Lubby's cheek pouches are huge!!!!! Dubby unfortunately didnt get any or enough to store in his pouches
:(
I can't understand how they can sit and eat in front of their kids when you know they're hungry too
the kid get the milk they produce and not only that with out mom being full can't produce milk or if she let the baby eat first she would die and so would the baby she can always have another baby
They aren't humans. Animals don't have the thought process of a human and don't live by our standards. They CAN'T think of how someone else feels or what they need because they aren't human. They don't see their offspring as we see ours because they aren't human. Their instinct is self preservation. Babies ALWAYS eat last. If babies survive, that's fine. I'd they don't... they'll be another. But no animal will sit back hungry and let their young eat
*Thank God it's 2017 and they're doing a little better! And then Thank God for people like you Arroz. I mean that. What would they do without you?*
Amy Sayers this was taken last year?
Joc Robles *Yes, its mentioned in the video.*
Wow. And here I sit still watching September 4, 2023!!! I would absolutely cry I think if I had to do the Where are they now game, I hate looking for a favorite and finding out they are passed away or missing. Or the little girl he saw one day by the water that was around for awhile then just disappeared . And the little boy who couldn't cope. And the ones that starve. Can't take it
I absolutely can not watch the Charlotte Story
Arroz Marisco I know this is a older video you made, but you have followers who would love to help you out feeding your little Bossy troupe and all your babies.
I'm sure none of us will be huge contributors because many like me are retired early due to a injury and or on a fixed income. But a little here and there could go a long way to help feed your band of mothers/babies misfits and sick. Maybe even help to pay a vet to show up once in a while and give everyone a clean bill of health.
I don't know how we could do it without it looking like a income except for a Go fund me or something of that nature, but I don't know how those things work in Japan.
Think about it, and let us know how we can help you. We know you're a decent man just by the compassion and love you show our cousins on Monkey hill.
Clean bill of health? these are wild monkeys; you’d have to trap and sedate them to even get a vet close enough to do any sort of examination..and why would any self-respecting veterinarian offer to do such a thing? It would be like asking a physician to walk through the slums of a large city offering free medical treatment to everyone living there…its a recipe for disaster. These animals have survived thousands of years without veterinary support and without human feeding, and whatever their fate may be, it shouldn’t be up to us to decide
Wow. Very sobering video. Thank You for all that you do for them. I know you would help all of them if you could. I hope the Registered Feeder is ok & does show up for them.
Dog gone it this video broke my heart
I HOPE THIS PLACE HAS DONE SOMETHING TO ALLEIATE THIS FROM LETTING HAPPEN AGAIN. THIS IS INSANE
They need to stop feeding them, that's all. They've grown too dependent on humans for handouts instead of foraging and teaching their babies to forage.
No wonder they're starving. There's tons of of them and the stupid things live on a barren hill and a road waiting for handouts.
Each female has a baby every year for its whole lifespan 30 years so population growth is astronomical
We have issues with the deer population control, farmers have a say due to crop damage, and then you have starvation .
Maybe it's not good that they rely so much on humans to get food. Wild animals are supposed to get their food in the wild. So when there is no human to give them food, they are starving when they should not.
Why do I see do many big monkeys still riding on their mothers.Can someone answer my question ty
I am rewatching all the episodes and i don't know why i never noticed that male that is all over Gypsy's nut and crackin it! Maybe he is Knotty's dad or mabye Kneely's father when she is born
Gypsy sure has strong genes! You can definitely tell all her babies!
Oh who is this Momma in the thumbnail, she is so pretty.
Why is camera having such hard time focusing? Cause it’s getting dark maybe?
Not like there's a shortage of them, let a few starve, better for the herd.
The road to hell is paved with good intentions
The mother is refusing to breastfeed because she’s in estrus again and getting ready for mating
To cut down on the amount of times they are fed gradually would meke them get back into foragin for natural foods wouldent it
Hmmm, hope the registered feeder is okay.
He's ancient I think he probably was unwell then. HE's now back into his routine. Talking about dedication he's the one to be lauded !
Arroz Marisco good!!! glad 2 hear that! I'm sure the monks were very happy to see him !
Arroz Marisco Wow, good for him. That makes me smile.
Arroz Marisco There's no no backup feeder? That's a shame to have them all hungry like this. I'm not criticizing the regular feeder, just the management's lack of forethought.
I am sure there is some food in the woods just lazy from being feef
Well sadly, some of them like us humans got reliant on fast foods, now with the pandemic even human are paying higher for fast food or scratching their heads asking, "how do I start or use this stove?" Well,, monkeys dont have pockets to carry money, so they even are thinking, where is our food delivery? Even though I like we are watching them film in as much wild as possible, once we took over so much the wilderness for highways & byways , I guess it's a bittersweet situation where we can get up and close with the monkeys, even though we are getting some joy from it, I say some, because I wonder how much the human interactions have changed some of the natural behaviors & anxiety levels of the monkey....hence we have Golden Hill, which I call Monkey Hill. (Luckily it's not like the mean VOs purposely causing friction for the monkeys for footage in Cambodia, Vietnam Nam, Golden Hill Is beautiful & real as I have witnessed.
They sure act like they think so.
Poor little Knotty! His cry sounds desperate. The thought of this sweet baby starving .......
I ❤️ your videos soooo much these monkeys are apart of my life now 🥰🥰
That's a lot of hungry mouths to feed
they feel safe and not bothered by humans
My heart was hurting watching Knotty try to get Mom to allow him to get a drink. He knew he would be rejected, but the temptation got the best of him, bless his heart, getting closer by the second....trying not to get catch, barely reaching out to touch them😢. Ill really be happy one our little 🐵don't need the Milk Bar any more. Kkk
brdlju3 I agree with you
There are too many monkeys. What do they eat??
Can't you get apple trees and other fruit trees to grown where they are? something that will give food each year
Apple trees have a fruiting season. They only bear fruit at a particular time of year. The same for most other fruits, vegetables, flowers, grasses seeds, and nuts. During the colder months, for example the trees, bushes, vines & plants die off or go dormant to continue their life cycle the following year. So you can plant all the fruit trees the climate can bear but it’s only going to be available during the appropriate season. So, for example, in the winter when all of that year’s crops have been harvested the trees will go dormant and await the coming spring when the leaves grow and the flowers bloom and eventually fruit is once again available.
TL;DR? Apples and other fruits are only available when they are in season. The rest of the year they are out of luck unless they have access to a Grocery Store.
Focus issues?
@17:33 SO CLOSE... YET SO FAR AWAY!!!😢😢😢😁
This is so entertaining lol
look how good grandee look. My 1st time seeing this video 7/12/24
Does the park feed these monkeys ? If the recievs some type of government funding or donations for providing food for the monkeys ? If so it would seem that any money for this purpose and survival of the monkeys isn't being done. Is there a way to look into that ? . also could the lack of food be a reason some moms become aggressive and abusive with there new borne and refuse to nurse them, and ween them to early ?
Why dont they start with birth control on these monkeys. They are starving.
How did skull head get an apple.
Passing visitor....
How are they all starving when people come to feed them? Have people stop giving them handouts?
Poor Knotty... he truly was an unloved baby.
I saw this big lazy boy or girl still drinking mommy,s breastfeed milk so lazy Bless you all good video thank you for sharing .
Who was speaking on a megaphone at 16:00?
Humans have made it worse for these monkeys these monkeys have now dependent on humans to feed them take care of them everything I blame the humans for doing this to these poor monkeys they need to fend for themselves they need to go out into the wilderness and they need to get their own foods the population grows and grows due to the fact that we feed them we harbor food for them and then they just keep making babies and then we end up with this starvation if that's what you call it but to me they don't appear to be like they're starving
What kind of crap is this again? The picture is blurry and shaky. Are there only amateurs at work here? Let people who know what they're doing film it.
I swear their little ears are so cute and adorable, as well as the little begging noise they make. Just makes you want to pick it up and cradle them.
Why are some marked with a B?
These poor monkeys.
A few have much longer tails than the others.
The lack of ability to keep the camera in focus is annoying….
At 16;33, there is a youngster with a bin a box on his chest. What for I'm wondering? Anybody's guess please?
Some of them have collars.
Sterilized by the government
Does the B stand for beast?
Donny Campbell No, that symbol is tattooed on them after they have been sterilized.
What are the tattoos for on their chest? Does anyone know?
It means they have been sterilized by the government. For more info about Monkey Hill in HK please visit my website am360view.com
They are not strarving. The lazy bums are always eating. Always. Tell another one. Are they pitiful, poor or weak too?
Those are fat monkeys, not starving you liars, video reported for misleading content!!!
What happens when they run out of food, they eat their weak...
Is not ok that so menny Monkeys not han fred Them self. To menny of Them on roung plase.
he want her to breast feed him poor hungry baby
How are they starving there is poo everywhere
Wow azzo u seem to scare some of them hmmm
Honest question, is there any logical reason to not destroy a huge portion of these things?
Live and let live, bro.
Is there any logical reason to destroy a huge portion of these animals, not things. (Shows your thinking)
@@chloeshann8142 Well, if there's no legitimate reason, then of course not. From what I understand, they're a nuisance because of overpopulation. It's a fact that almost all adult macaques carry hepatitis, the C strain, I think. They leave droppings everywhere in public places such as parks where people come with their children. They destroy crops and personal property. Reason enough? (Shows your thinking)
all the cell phone I can't tell it's about 25 .37 there's two monkeys on a fence run young monkey and one big monkey which looks like a juvenile he's been branded or are marked with a square and a big P. what's up with that? was that to show he's or she been fix?
Jen Hol yes
Jen Hol Yes that's what it means
wow
Why was Dopey's young "Aunt" in the tree with him annoyed and biting him? I didn't see Dopey do anything wrong. She isn't doing a very good job so far. Lol. But better than the aunt who tried to make him one of "The Flying Wallendas".
Tresa Lamb
No, I was watching on my iPad and had a lot of distractions going on. I'll go check it out on the tv right away. Thanks for answering me.🙂