Did a SOTA activation yesterday in CO. Had a guy 80 miles away on a UV5R with rubber duck... 57 received from him. I was blown away, he was definitely getting his $24 worth. Non-typical situation, but dang...
I once got into a uhf repeater 112 miles away, it was not on a mountain, antenna height was about 800ft, my handheld was on the second floor of a two story house. Absolutely crazy.
@@drewbrown9678 146.52 he was running 5w on the Feng and I had 8w on a Kenwood with an arrow yagi. The yagi was an advantage on my end, but still. A good Feng can get things done.
@@josephhacker6508 I enjoy radio for that very reason. Some days 100w won't get things done, but some days 5w will. So many variables, keeps it interesting. I was super happy for dude & his Feng.
i have my tech licence for several years now, but i still know nothing of armature radio and have never been on the air, so a lot of this goes over my head, but i like this channel because you make these things somewhat understandable for me, and youre not snobbish about equipment. keep up the great content.
@@lomgshorts3 it was no trouble at all. just took the test. its mostly basic safety and electronics that i already know. there are so few radio related questions you could get them all wrong and still pass. spending hundreds of dollars on equipment, otoh, is difficult.
@@502detha uv-5r is roughly $25 and you can grab a better antenna for $20 or so. Then find out if there's a local club and when they have their net. For example here the club has a repeater and has a net on Sunday nights. So I can tune in on Sunday nights and listen in and get the feel for the etiquette.
@@billtheunjust i live in the middle of bumfuck nowhere. i have a uv5r, there is NO traffic within receiving range. even tried to build a few antennas and hook them to it. the nearest "local" club is 45 min away. i feel if i want to do anything useful im going to need to buy a whole hf setup.
@@502deth well, I guess plan b would be to grab a mag mount and your uv-5r and drive into repeater range when they have their scheduled net. I know it's not something you'd want to do often, but it would at least let you get a feel for hew a net works.
I’ve been able to transmit 33.25 miles with my BF-F8HP and a NA771 antenna. From Castaic CA down to Pasadena, CA... and the people on the repeater said I was perfectly clear, rated me a 5 out of 5 for transmit clarity.
My 146.52MHz handheld to handheld record was about 60+ miles from Phoenix to the mountains to the north. I don’t know where he was exactly (other than the name of the peak) and there was a pileup after we finished. Imagine a pileup on .52 simplex.
@@yourface3154 you ask them what there location is then use a mapping service find your location then there location use a measuring tool draw a straight line from you to them then look at distance by which the crow flies meaning from air not on the ground like Google maps
@@HamRadioCrashCourse Yes, but if you want to be (Radio) Project Farm you have to test everything to destructions. Makes me cry when he does that to Snap-On’s and the like. 🤣🤣
Just upgraded to a uv5r triband after carrying my first uv5r for 4 years . It works like the day I got it and I used it like crazy. I just wanted a triband. I think I made I good choice after this . Go Fang ! Lol !
I have an older uv5r that I Carry on the farm. I have a ham neighbor that has told me on a couple occasions that it sounds better than my yaesu. Thank you for the work you put into all your videos.
Request to bring along a UV-82HP next time. That's my preferred form factor of the Feng HTs. BTech also has GMRS and MURS versions in the same form factor so the spare batteries, etc., are all swappable. Dual watch and an option of either single PTT or dual A-B PTT.
I wish you had a Baofeng AR-5RM when doing this comparison. I just ordered one as an upgrade from my BF-F8HP. It transmits at 10 watts and is unlocked on frequencies. I believe it is a pretty new model.
Signal Sticks, and Abbree's, are my go to antenna's for my HT's. And yes the Baofeng BF-F8HP is a 8 watt radio, on one frequency. Remember the lower your SWR's are the more power you will transmit. Stay safe. 73's
I'm absolutely new at all of this man, but man does it bring joy and life to see this type of content. What drew me to this is that i'm looking to use a radio with ear pieces for coaching and i want the kids to have fun while i can communicate with them directly without screaming. Liked and subscribed, and hope to learn wayyyy more on radios not only by myself, but through you.
I'm looking to buy a baofeng so it brought me here. Also would love to know what to do to not interrupt anybody else's signal. Don't want to cause anybody an inconvenience.
Uv5r, uv8hp and ft5r here. The Yaesu ft5r is so clear without the static of the baofengs that actual performance comes second to understanding what is coming over.
The Baofeng is THE radio that has brought SO MANY folks into HAM radio, it is the undisputed champ and best entry level radio. Stop your BS complaints of the UV-5r and give thanks for then number of folks that started here. HAM radio was dying until this radio came along. Yes there are better HT's and all of us who started with the UV-5FR and mostly moved one but we still have our UV-5R's and we love them.
There seems to be a significant difference between my uv5r and ft-60r in Rx and TX. I have compared the 2 on the repeaters in my area and the uv5r can be almost useless on some of them that the ft60 can operate on no problem.
I never even thought of that! I have been looking into a cheap radio to get to see how active things are in my area while studying for my tech, I knew the gt5r was cleaner but didn't think about that also improving power to the desired freq.
I tested mine last night on an HP 8920A RF test set (using a Baofeng 3800 mAh extended battery fully charged) and found high power at 146.52 only produced 5.57 watts (with .12 uV sensitivity on receive), 446.00 produced 5.27 watts (also with .12 uV sensitivity on receive).
Even though my FT3DR is a better radio, I often take my GT5R when I'm traveling. It works well enough, and it's cheap enough that I won't be super upset if it gets damaged or lost.
My first radio was a BF-F8HP that I had an extended bat and a telescopic 771 antenna on it. Forgot I put it on the roof of my car one day, realized what happened when I heard it fly off the car going 70mph on the interstate.
My primary radio is a Kenwood TH-F6A with a Diamond SRH320A antenna, my mobile is a Kenwood TM-D710GA with a Diamond CR320A. I've had the CR320A for 12 years.. and bought it because the Kenwood TH-F6A was my first radio (tri-band)... but it works wonderfully for the TM-D710 series radios. I've managed to comm with the ISS on several occasions using it as well as running APRS through the ISS. The older TM-D710A I have started having issues after a few jump starts, causing it to drain the battery due to high current draw when idle, so it has been blackholed as a spare. I bought a Baofeng GT-5R for SaG and threw a Nagoya NA-771 on it... I'm hitting repeaters here in NC clear as day with no problems. I'm about 15 miles from Raleigh and can hit almost every single repeater with no noise and zero complaints using the internal mic. Don't underestimate this little $25-$28 guy. I bought the GT-5R for my bug out bag... but with the 3800mah battery and lack of noise or issues, it''s becoming my go-to HT. -AB9XA
Great job again Josh. I have the Radioddity Baofeng UV-5RTP, UV-5X3 and GT3 and used Signal Sticks on all my HT. I only used all 3 Baofeng on AllStar. Since they have a great battery life. I monitor the East Coast Reflector, Henderson Repeater, Texas IRLP, MOHOY and the PAPA System. Only certain stations of the PAPA System have comments on the audio on the Baofeng otherwise the rest don't care at all. As long as you can transmit a readable signal. No issues at all. I rag chew for hours on other stations on these radios. Stay Safe Ruben KD6CWI
I live in northwest Ohio, toledo-ish ares, and the first night I bought the uv5r (forst ham radio) last month I picked up the east coast reflector, I had gotten so excited i heard something. But yeah with the rubber duck it sounds pretty good! Clear as day
Just bought myself a Uv-5r learning everything I can. love your videos great info always and love that park I always go walking there haha maybe one day I’ll see you around 👍🏽
My $150 Wouxun HT's do not sound any better than my $30 TP 8 Plus (aka UV13 Pro) and $40 BFH7 Baofengs. I have to go to my $300 Anytone 878 UV II Plus before I notice a big difference, and that just in sound quality buyt no differnec in Tx range. I would rather buy cheap and throw away if it breaks unless there is a real reason to spend more.
Thanks for the tests. The Gt-5R did better than I suspected it would. I own Yaesu FT-60, FT-70. The 70d is a disappointment with the parasitic drag on the battery. Love my 60 to the point of wearing the keys off of it. If the FT-60 came with Lithium batteries, I'd own 5 FT-60s. I own UV and GT-5Rs for my go bags and when riding my motorcycle. All of my radios have Signal Stick antennas.
Baofeng uv5r is a good radio why do people always putting this radio down because is made in China 🇨🇳 like everything is made in China .for 25 to 35 dollars I would buy 4 to 8 for my hunting buddies to keep in touch then spending over 100 to 200 dollars. Just saying
Hi Josh I received my Signal Stuff Signal Stick antenna yesterday. I picked orange and have it on my very old ICOM IC-V8. This is a quality antenna and I recommend getting one. Plus it supports ham training. Two thumbs up hi hi 73’s. KB9JXU
I was shocked yesterday by my baofeng uv82 max power and I was able to recieve and transmit 31 miles (in the country side in WY not in a city). I don't have a stock antenna but still I was amazed
Amazon left my new BAOFENG BF-F8HP on my doorstep at 6:00 am this morning. I’ve been using a Yaesu FT-50R for a quarter century. I’ll let you know how it stacks up. 73s KD5FPA
@HamRadioCrashCourse - Can we see a GT-5R / Yaesu FT-4X head-to-head send & receive, best-vhf/uhf antenna test on 2m/70cm next? I am curious how the Baofeng and Yaesu perform under different antennas in direct comparison. (Side note: I have a BF-F11 which claims to be 10w, and is a variant of the bf-a58s tri-band'er. The speaker on that is much clearer, then the UV5r, which i also have. - If you get a chance to test one, please share the results with the rest of us!)
What I’d love to see is the FT-5D and ID-52 up against the best of the cheapies. It would be interesting to see if there is any RF performance benefit for the much higher price, or just screen and features? You could even add in some strong local signals, and for RX, attenuate the sending radio at home, as I’d like to think selectivity as well as sensitivity and lack of front end overload is what your money gets you…..
I know you compared the VX6 to the DJ-vx50t here, but I think it would be interesting to run this test with some other submersible radios as well. Perhaps Retevis would send you a RA89 for the test.
I "recieved" my 3rd uv-5r while chasing a elk in mountains. I found it pressed into the mud I put it in my pocket, charged it later back in camp other than I still have not removed all the dirt it works great. For hunting nothing beats a uv-5r
My old UV5R TP (Tri Power) had reports of low TX audio. There's foreign instructions on how to add an SMD capacitor between the mic socket trace etc which boosted it. I also drilled the mic hole which helped a little. So compare your old and other Baofengs nearby your SDR and see if talking closer/louder to the mic helps that one. Is it really a TX power/distance issue or the mic? Or try an external mic. Also try swapping over the battery. I tried talking at various distances from the mic and I think 2.5 to 5cm was best on my SDR stick. Of course, counting the distance in cm on the radio affected things as 'five' is louder, so you'd need to say the same thing. Trying a power meter on them would be good for another video too. Maybe even hook up a bench power supply and decrease volts/current to show what happens when using an old battery. Also finding a tool to measure your old battery capacities in mah would be neat. Then make a PSA video on when to replace them.
6dB is also 4x the power. However, on UHF and VHF handhelds, the radiation pattern varies widely based on your hand position, antenna orientation, exact position relative to metal objects, moisture content of the plants, etc. you could get a more objective measurement by using a fixed field strength meter while using a fixture to hold and position the radio so it’s consistent from test to test. You can hear the variation in the receive audio at your home station and also in your tone test. Having said that, your testing is somewhat more objective than man others on RUclips. Thanks!
That great. I feel better seeing real data from a real field test. I am in Boston NY and lot of hams put them down and a lot like them in my area. a mixed bag. I respect them all . I have the GT 1 GT 3 GT3TP GT5TP G11S UV5X that my collection to this date 4/12/2023. I feel better getting DMR one and tri band one. great video. 73's
I have a GT-5R that I got for the soul purpose of listening to rocket launch repeaters. They Tx on 2-meter. The GT-5R is equipped with a Signal Stick. I've found that, in order to receive, I almost HAVE to have a ground plane. I have tried leaving the radio attached to my backpack as I am listening to the launch broadcast, but it is frustratingly bad. If I take the radio and set it on my aluminum tonneau cover on my truck, it receives like a champ. The bad thing is, I am not always next to my truck when I am trying to listen. Admittedly, I know nothing of HAM yet, just how to program frequencies on the GT-5R. I am wondering if there is anything I can do, to mimic a ground plane when the radio is in my hand, vs. sitting on my tonneau.
Josh, I'd be interested to see the transmitting power consumption between them. maybe some kind of digital power supply with a readout, while transmitting or on a dummy load.
jumbo battery pack options for any radio will help, kinda like does mpg on a vehicle matter? yes but will pick a worse one with other features that are easier to use...
Josh... Among these radios, the power choices were the UV-5R for 4W, or the BF-F8HP for up to 8W. But, I now see (on Amazon) that there is a new generation of the UV-5R... the BAOFENG UV-5R 8W that is also suppose to have an upgraded chipset as well, and 3 different output levels (1W/4W/8W). I don't see anyone talking about this new more powerful UV-5R. I'm wondering what you, or anyone, thinks about it. And given the new power for the UV-5R, is it worth the extra money for the 8W BF-F8HP? Thanks.
Lacking a test for rx desense, these results while informative and appreciated do not illustrate a susceptibility that's been frequently reported for CCRs and is very impactful to the user experience. I was surprised by the higher numbers from the non-Japanese radios.
I gotta say, the BendixKing Digital radio I used with Fire/EMS back in 2001/2008 didn't sound as good as this UV-5R. Honestly impressive how far weve come that a Sub $30 (Included Abbree ar-771 antenna) can sound and transmit this well.
I tested both my TD-F9GP 8W versions with fresh battery's into dum dum load. Both 6.7W on same sweet spot freq. Not a powerhouse but better than my old 5W Baofeng that only saw 3.9W on high. That 3W difference means something on a fringe signal. The stock antenna's are junk and the built-in mic's are weak compared to a good hand mic but still hard to beat em for the price.
Love the vx-6r. I lost my first one during a very boggy walk out from a SOTA activation... I since bought a second one as it's such a dependable and sturdy unit. As for the baofengs, most of them are fantastic value for money and reasonable performers. I guess the main difference will be consistency from one unit to the next. It would be great to see five of the same model baofeng from different sources being put through the same test.
I checked 3 BF-7H Baofengs I just bought on my Surecom 102 and they where all three basically the same. Within .25 watts of each other and with in .5 watts +/- of the advertised 10 watts.
I like to see a test on the baofeng uv53.. using this radio people have said my audio is worse when i use the cig lighter compare to when run from the stock battery that came with it.
My f8hp, like others (most likely ALL F8 series) has off center accessories port holes. This makes getting the programming cable or shoulder mic's plugged in nearly impossible unless you cut off some of the connector rubber (see photo). The manufacturer clearly didn't test a prototype before going to full production, not surprisingly, you get what you pay for now days!
Many people talk about the great clean transmitter on the GT-5R but unfortunately it does not "receive" near as good as the UV-5R5 in the ham band. I own many different baofengs and the GT-5R has the worse receiver in them inside the ham band. I own 2 GT-5R's and I would not recommend buying that radio. I am not talking about out of band as the GT-5R won't do that anyway. I am talking about inside the ham bands.
The Baofeng's problem isn't the transmission (they have 5W or more), but they have a very bad reception (0.25uV at 12dB SINAD, a good radio can receive at 0.12uV). They suck to listen to far repeaters (or simplex) and they will be deaf in a place with busy VHF signals (like a city), and don't forget about the Baofeng's spurious, it's just a garbage radio.
Which is the best radio/antenna combo to get anywhere between 15 and 20 miles in range? I can’t seem to find any information to those specifications. Hope you can help.
Josh, is there an economical tool (meter) that effectively measures the SWR of HTs? The Surecom meters don't seem to work, even with a paw around the HT acting as a ground plane. One Surecom even came with a steel plate to act as a ground plane, but it 1) greatly added to the cost of production and 2) really didn't work. They're super for mobile or base station use, but not HT use, unfortunately. Thnx!
Great vid, I've been curious about the various Boafeng variants. Does that big chain ground radial behind you going from the table and around the tree affect your test?? LOL One thing about the Baofeng's... rarely does the actually transmit power live up to the advertised wattage hype. The 8W model I bought measured less than 5W on VHF and 6W on UHF.
Hi Josh. Been following you since I got my first Baofeng and found your videos about them. Thank you for all the great videos. But, what do you think about BTech? I came across a review saying the BTech UV-5X3 can skip nuisance channels when scanning. I like that, bc I've been scanning and building a list of GMRS channels with the lowest traffic in my area to use with my buddies that only have GMRS. No, I don't have a home radio yet. My interest right now is portable communication.
Can't get over the chained bench. It would be an operation to steal that thing in the first place (2 two people + pickup truck). Not really a "keep honest people honest" thing. So if you are already going that far, whats to stop them from getting some bolt cutters? I never wanted to steal a picnic table but the chain makes me want to do it.
I have a question. I have been a ham for almost 20 years. My HT is a Yaesu VX-150. My brother and niece have shown some interest lately. I would like to get him a GT-5R. Was that static I heard while transmitting or was it on the receiving side? Anyway, for the price, it seems great, but I want to make sure it would be good for him. Thanks!
UV-5R vs BF-F8HP. Most of the review videos I watch comparing these two radios is over my head. I want to pick one for listening to VHF and UHF. Not planning to talk on one. The BAOFENG BF-F8HP appears to have wider frequency spectrum than the UV-5R. VHF: 136-174 MHz(Rx/Tx). UHF: 400-520 1000 channels vs VHF 144-148MHz, UHF 420-450MHz 128 channels. The videos I have watched don’t seem to speak about that. Can you help me understand if my reasoning is correct for my intended use.
Can you PLEASE do a video on how you have the station at home configured to TX when you send it DTMF commands? I would love to implement that to my shack for range testing of my own 73 KO4YQU
@@HamRadioCrashCourse Thank you so much! I had been eagerly waiting since the first comparison video. With such a cryptic title I didn’t even realize that was the long-awaited video
As someone that's studying for there tech license and looking to buy a radio, that was one of the better compressions I needed to see on baofeng. Thank you so much for sharing that and that helped me narrow down alot of options for me. But quick question, I'm doing alot of traveling around the US for work, what would be best for that? Not sure if that's even a worry for people in this great hobby haha. Thanks again and have a great day.
Josh, great info, thanks for posting, can you or anyone comment if there is any improvement on the receive side of the GT5R as well- pertaining to intermod rejection or is it the same as basic UV5R? Also, without the spurious emissions (GT5R) would tx power be more efficient on the chosen freq? I have a recent Amazon UV5R seems ok, but am considering if it is worth it to upgrade to the GT5R or an even bigger step to the FT60r as the radio will be accompanying me on motorcycle rides with a 771/signal stick style antenna.. Thanks all.
Hey Josh. I want to do a test like this. I have an SDR running SDRSharp on my laptop. I have the audio piped to Auacity to capture as a sound file. How do i capture the SNR value? Thanks and keep up the great work!
Josh you're becoming the Paul Harrell of HT testing.
WOW! That is a compliment! I would never have expect someone to say that about me. Paul is a legend!
Yesssssss agreed for sure
“Is this antenna better than that antenna? You be the judge.”
Well now I have to subscribe
@@HamRadioCrashCourse Now you'll have to put up with my speech impediment.
Bought a UV5R from Amazon after watching this one a while ago. Passed my Technician exam tonight. Thanks for all the great content.
How much time did you take studying before testing?
Did a SOTA activation yesterday in CO. Had a guy 80 miles away on a UV5R with rubber duck... 57 received from him. I was blown away, he was definitely getting his $24 worth. Non-typical situation, but dang...
As someone that is only GMRS licensed, what frequency range were you making contact with that Rubber Duck uv-5r
I once got into a uhf repeater 112 miles away, it was not on a mountain, antenna height was about 800ft, my handheld was on the second floor of a two story house. Absolutely crazy.
@@drewbrown9678 146.52 he was running 5w on the Feng and I had 8w on a Kenwood with an arrow yagi. The yagi was an advantage on my end, but still. A good Feng can get things done.
@@josephhacker6508 I enjoy radio for that very reason. Some days 100w won't get things done, but some days 5w will. So many variables, keeps it interesting. I was super happy for dude & his Feng.
I love my BF-F8-HP! Thanks for your signal stick rec! I now have three in orange, pink and brown! Great antenna!!
I have the BF-F8HP. Your testing only convinces me it's a decent radio, if not the very best Baofeng. Glad I bought it.
i have my tech licence for several years now, but i still know nothing of armature radio and have never been on the air, so a lot of this goes over my head, but i like this channel because you make these things somewhat understandable for me, and youre not snobbish about equipment. keep up the great content.
You went through all the trouble of getting your Ham Radio license, why not use it???
@@lomgshorts3 it was no trouble at all. just took the test. its mostly basic safety and electronics that i already know. there are so few radio related questions you could get them all wrong and still pass.
spending hundreds of dollars on equipment, otoh, is difficult.
@@502detha uv-5r is roughly $25 and you can grab a better antenna for $20 or so. Then find out if there's a local club and when they have their net. For example here the club has a repeater and has a net on Sunday nights. So I can tune in on Sunday nights and listen in and get the feel for the etiquette.
@@billtheunjust i live in the middle of bumfuck nowhere. i have a uv5r, there is NO traffic within receiving range. even tried to build a few antennas and hook them to it. the nearest "local" club is 45 min away. i feel if i want to do anything useful im going to need to buy a whole hf setup.
@@502deth well, I guess plan b would be to grab a mag mount and your uv-5r and drive into repeater range when they have their scheduled net. I know it's not something you'd want to do often, but it would at least let you get a feel for hew a net works.
I love me some Boo-fwangs. How many fars do yours get? Sorry, though I was on Randy's channel for a minute.
I’ve been able to transmit 33.25 miles with my BF-F8HP and a NA771 antenna. From Castaic CA down to Pasadena, CA... and the people on the repeater said I was perfectly clear, rated me a 5 out of 5 for transmit clarity.
Hello from Riverside! Just bought my first ham units- f8-hp and president Lincoln II+. 🍻
How far can you receive with your bf f8 hp?
My 146.52MHz handheld to handheld record was about 60+ miles from Phoenix to the mountains to the north. I don’t know where he was exactly (other than the name of the peak) and there was a pileup after we finished. Imagine a pileup on .52 simplex.
How do you know how far they are?
@@yourface3154 you ask them what there location is then use a mapping service find your location then there location use a measuring tool draw a straight line from you to them then look at distance by which the crow flies meaning from air not on the ground like Google maps
This video is old, but loved it all the same! Thanks for putting this together Josh!!!
Digging the Ham Radio meets Project Farm style videos Josh! Thank you!
Thank you!!
@@HamRadioCrashCourse Yes, but if you want to be (Radio) Project Farm you have to test everything to destructions. Makes me cry when he does that to Snap-On’s and the like. 🤣🤣
@Ammocraft I wanna see just what it would take to 'destroy' a test radio. 😅
Just upgraded to a uv5r triband after carrying my first uv5r for 4 years . It works like the day I got it and I used it like crazy. I just wanted a triband. I think I made I good choice after this . Go Fang ! Lol !
The extra band transmits almost zero watts. 200 mhz when tested on several Baofeng tribands I bought sent out a whopping 1mw.
@@realtyrocks1969 holy.. really? I always thought they were trash
I got a bag of Baofengs for my wife. It’s the best trade I’ve ever made! 😃👍
(Standing ovation)
I have an older uv5r that I Carry on the farm. I have a ham neighbor that has told me on a couple occasions that it sounds better than my yaesu.
Thank you for the work you put into all your videos.
Request to bring along a UV-82HP next time. That's my preferred form factor of the Feng HTs. BTech also has GMRS and MURS versions in the same form factor so the spare batteries, etc., are all swappable. Dual watch and an option of either single PTT or dual A-B PTT.
I wish you had a Baofeng AR-5RM when doing this comparison. I just ordered one as an upgrade from my BF-F8HP. It transmits at 10 watts and is unlocked on frequencies. I believe it is a pretty new model.
Signal Sticks, and Abbree's, are my go to antenna's for my HT's. And yes the Baofeng BF-F8HP is a 8 watt radio, on one frequency. Remember the lower your SWR's are the more power you will transmit. Stay safe. 73's
My first and only Baofeng, bwoof-wang, bo-feng is the GT-3WP. It does what I need it to do, which is get on the air. Thanks for sharing.
I'm absolutely new at all of this man, but man does it bring joy and life to see this type of content. What drew me to this is that i'm looking to use a radio with ear pieces for coaching and i want the kids to have fun while i can communicate with them directly without screaming. Liked and subscribed, and hope to learn wayyyy more on radios not only by myself, but through you.
I'm looking to buy a baofeng so it brought me here. Also would love to know what to do to not interrupt anybody else's signal. Don't want to cause anybody an inconvenience.
Thanks for watching! I have links to my preferred Baofeng in the description.
I bought a GT-5R. After watching most of the videos on it I was under the impression that it can reach the GMRS frequencies?
Great test. Thanks. I would suggest testing the UV S9 Plus. I compared it to my BF F8HP and was pleasantly surprised.
Good one! I have two tri-band BFngs and they work great with the Nagoya.
Uv5r, uv8hp and ft5r here. The Yaesu ft5r is so clear without the static of the baofengs that actual performance comes second to understanding what is coming over.
The Baofeng is THE radio that has brought SO MANY folks into HAM radio, it is the undisputed champ and best entry level radio. Stop your BS complaints of the UV-5r and give thanks for then number of folks that started here. HAM radio was dying until this radio came along. Yes there are better HT's and all of us who started with the UV-5FR and mostly moved one but we still have our UV-5R's and we love them.
I'd Like to see RX tests on these radios on the fringes/desensing, I have a feeling that's where the JA HTs will shine
There seems to be a significant difference between my uv5r and ft-60r in Rx and TX. I have compared the 2 on the repeaters in my area and the uv5r can be almost useless on some of them that the ft60 can operate on no problem.
The GT5R may have the best SNR due to sending out more power on the desired frequency rather than splitting it between those harmonics
I never even thought of that! I have been looking into a cheap radio to get to see how active things are in my area while studying for my tech, I knew the gt5r was cleaner but didn't think about that also improving power to the desired freq.
I tested mine last night on an HP 8920A RF test set (using a Baofeng 3800 mAh extended battery fully charged) and found high power at 146.52 only produced 5.57 watts (with .12 uV sensitivity on receive), 446.00 produced 5.27 watts (also with .12 uV sensitivity on receive).
Even though my FT3DR is a better radio, I often take my GT5R when I'm traveling. It works well enough, and it's cheap enough that I won't be super upset if it gets damaged or lost.
I'd be upset... Getting lost is your fault, accidents happen. If you lost a twenty from your pocket you'd be mad
For the price, it’s a good backup to vehicle mounted and worth having around.
My first radio was a BF-F8HP that I had an extended bat and a telescopic 771 antenna on it. Forgot I put it on the roof of my car one day, realized what happened when I heard it fly off the car going 70mph on the interstate.
My primary radio is a Kenwood TH-F6A with a Diamond SRH320A antenna, my mobile is a Kenwood TM-D710GA with a Diamond CR320A. I've had the CR320A for 12 years.. and bought it because the Kenwood TH-F6A was my first radio (tri-band)... but it works wonderfully for the TM-D710 series radios. I've managed to comm with the ISS on several occasions using it as well as running APRS through the ISS. The older TM-D710A I have started having issues after a few jump starts, causing it to drain the battery due to high current draw when idle, so it has been blackholed as a spare. I bought a Baofeng GT-5R for SaG and threw a Nagoya NA-771 on it... I'm hitting repeaters here in NC clear as day with no problems. I'm about 15 miles from Raleigh and can hit almost every single repeater with no noise and zero complaints using the internal mic. Don't underestimate this little $25-$28 guy. I bought the GT-5R for my bug out bag... but with the 3800mah battery and lack of noise or issues, it''s becoming my go-to HT.
-AB9XA
Great job again Josh. I have the Radioddity Baofeng UV-5RTP, UV-5X3 and GT3 and used Signal Sticks on all my HT. I only used all 3 Baofeng on AllStar. Since they have a great battery life. I monitor the East Coast Reflector, Henderson Repeater, Texas IRLP, MOHOY and the PAPA System. Only certain stations of the PAPA System have comments on the audio on the Baofeng otherwise the rest don't care at all. As long as you can transmit a readable signal. No issues at all. I rag chew for hours on other stations on these radios. Stay Safe Ruben KD6CWI
Just gave you a Thumbs Up you deserve this for all your hard work on all these videos.
Thank you!
@@HamRadioCrashCourse Always my pleasure Josh
I live in northwest Ohio, toledo-ish ares, and the first night I bought the uv5r (forst ham radio) last month I picked up the east coast reflector, I had gotten so excited i heard something. But yeah with the rubber duck it sounds pretty good! Clear as day
A radio is better than no radio.
Indeed and the feng works pretty decent ly
Just bought myself a Uv-5r learning everything I can. love your videos great info always and love that park I always go walking there haha maybe one day I’ll see you around 👍🏽
Thanks a bunch. I found this very helpful in making my first radio purchase.
Just brought one from Amazon and watch your video, thanks for the plug
My $150 Wouxun HT's do not sound any better than my $30 TP 8 Plus (aka UV13 Pro) and $40 BFH7 Baofengs. I have to go to my $300 Anytone 878 UV II Plus before I notice a big difference, and that just in sound quality buyt no differnec in Tx range. I would rather buy cheap and throw away if it breaks unless there is a real reason to spend more.
I have two UV-5R Pros that perform very well on 2m and 70cm. Sounds pretty good.
Would like to see what your first baofeng does with a newer battery. Great video.
The intro reminded of the movie Primer when they realized there time machine worked seen themselves. Great movie if you got the mind for it.
Thanks for the tests. The Gt-5R did better than I suspected it would. I own Yaesu FT-60, FT-70. The 70d is a disappointment with the parasitic drag on the battery. Love my 60 to the point of wearing the keys off of it. If the FT-60 came with Lithium batteries, I'd own 5 FT-60s. I own UV and GT-5Rs for my go bags and when riding my motorcycle. All of my radios have Signal Stick antennas.
Baofeng uv5r is a good radio why do people always putting this radio down because is made in China 🇨🇳 like everything is made in China .for 25 to 35 dollars I would buy 4 to 8 for my hunting buddies to keep in touch then spending over 100 to 200 dollars. Just saying
Hi Josh I received my Signal Stuff Signal Stick antenna yesterday. I picked orange and have it on my very old ICOM IC-V8. This is a quality antenna and I recommend getting one. Plus it supports ham training. Two thumbs up hi hi 73’s. KB9JXU
I was shocked yesterday by my baofeng uv82 max power and I was able to recieve and transmit 31 miles (in the country side in WY not in a city). I don't have a stock antenna but still I was amazed
how dangerous was the shock?
Thank you so much for the test video
Amazon left my new BAOFENG BF-F8HP on my doorstep at 6:00 am this morning. I’ve been using a Yaesu FT-50R for a quarter century. I’ll let you know how it stacks up.
73s KD5FPA
@HamRadioCrashCourse - Can we see a GT-5R / Yaesu FT-4X head-to-head send & receive, best-vhf/uhf antenna test on 2m/70cm next?
I am curious how the Baofeng and Yaesu perform under different antennas in direct comparison.
(Side note: I have a BF-F11 which claims to be 10w, and is a variant of the bf-a58s tri-band'er. The speaker on that is much clearer, then the UV5r, which i also have. - If you get a chance to test one, please share the results with the rest of us!)
What I’d love to see is the FT-5D and ID-52 up against the best of the cheapies. It would be interesting to see if there is any RF performance benefit for the much higher price, or just screen and features? You could even add in some strong local signals, and for RX, attenuate the sending radio at home, as I’d like to think selectivity as well as sensitivity and lack of front end overload is what your money gets you…..
You're likely correct across the board. I will do a different test for selectibility.
I know you compared the VX6 to the DJ-vx50t here, but I think it would be interesting to run this test with some other submersible radios as well. Perhaps Retevis would send you a RA89 for the test.
As well as a couple of UV-5Rs, I have a UV-82 which seems to have a much better speaker than the UV-5Rs.
I "recieved" my 3rd uv-5r while chasing a elk in mountains. I found it pressed into the mud I put it in my pocket, charged it later back in camp other than I still have not removed all the dirt it works great. For hunting nothing beats a uv-5r
This was mine were you outside of Dolores? Lol
@@marcus8442 yes! Just off of county road R
@@marcus8442 It might be yours
It WAS yours!😂
My old UV5R TP (Tri Power) had reports of low TX audio. There's foreign instructions on how to add an SMD capacitor between the mic socket trace etc which boosted it. I also drilled the mic hole which helped a little.
So compare your old and other Baofengs nearby your SDR and see if talking closer/louder to the mic helps that one. Is it really a TX power/distance issue or the mic? Or try an external mic. Also try swapping over the battery.
I tried talking at various distances from the mic and I think 2.5 to 5cm was best on my SDR stick. Of course, counting the distance in cm on the radio affected things as 'five' is louder, so you'd need to say the same thing.
Trying a power meter on them would be good for another video too. Maybe even hook up a bench power supply and decrease volts/current to show what happens when using an old battery.
Also finding a tool to measure your old battery capacities in mah would be neat. Then make a PSA video on when to replace them.
6dB is also 4x the power. However, on UHF and VHF handhelds, the radiation pattern varies widely based on your hand position, antenna orientation, exact position relative to metal objects, moisture content of the plants, etc. you could get a more objective measurement by using a fixed field strength meter while using a fixture to hold and position the radio so it’s consistent from test to test. You can hear the variation in the receive audio at your home station and also in your tone test. Having said that, your testing is somewhat more objective than man others on RUclips. Thanks!
Keep on forward. You are doing it very well. 73'S from WP3MD. Newark NJ.
That great. I feel better seeing real data from a real field test. I am in Boston NY and lot of hams put them down and a lot like them in my area. a mixed bag. I respect them all . I have the GT 1 GT 3 GT3TP GT5TP G11S UV5X that my collection to this date 4/12/2023. I feel better getting DMR one and tri band one. great video. 73's
I have a GT-5R that I got for the soul purpose of listening to rocket launch repeaters. They Tx on 2-meter. The GT-5R is equipped with a Signal Stick. I've found that, in order to receive, I almost HAVE to have a ground plane. I have tried leaving the radio attached to my backpack as I am listening to the launch broadcast, but it is frustratingly bad. If I take the radio and set it on my aluminum tonneau cover on my truck, it receives like a champ. The bad thing is, I am not always next to my truck when I am trying to listen. Admittedly, I know nothing of HAM yet, just how to program frequencies on the GT-5R. I am wondering if there is anything I can do, to mimic a ground plane when the radio is in my hand, vs. sitting on my tonneau.
Counterpoise?
@@shoersa yes, thank you. That's the word I was looking for, lol
Josh, I'd be interested to see the transmitting power consumption between them. maybe some kind of digital power supply with a readout, while transmitting or on a dummy load.
jumbo battery pack options for any radio will help, kinda like does mpg on a vehicle matter? yes but will pick a worse one with other features that are easier to use...
Josh... Among these radios, the power choices were the UV-5R for 4W, or the BF-F8HP for up to 8W. But, I now see (on Amazon) that there is a new generation of the UV-5R... the BAOFENG UV-5R 8W that is also suppose to have an upgraded chipset as well, and 3 different output levels (1W/4W/8W). I don't see anyone talking about this new more powerful UV-5R. I'm wondering what you, or anyone, thinks about it. And given the new power for the UV-5R, is it worth the extra money for the 8W BF-F8HP? Thanks.
I also saw that... was wondring if they would send the 5w and make it a hassle to get the 8w---- if that is actually a thing.
I love my UV5R and I just got a uv3r yesterday
What did they do to fix the GT-5R? is their any way to modify a UV-5R to make it spectrally pure?
I think it's hilarious that the park bench has to be chained to the tree! Dude! are you safe there?
Idk why people assume it’s chained for crime. It’s chained so people don’t move them all together for a massive party. They have huge parties here.
What I find interesting is that even though SNR/audio level on VX-6 sounds weaker than GT-5R, the modulation seems to be miles better...
Yes! The audio quality is far superior.
No UV 82’s? I have the dual and tri Chanel x-3’s and think they perform better than the radios you tested.
Lacking a test for rx desense, these results while informative and appreciated do not illustrate a susceptibility that's been frequently reported for CCRs and is very impactful to the user experience. I was surprised by the higher numbers from the non-Japanese radios.
I gotta say, the BendixKing Digital radio I used with Fire/EMS back in 2001/2008 didn't sound as good as this UV-5R.
Honestly impressive how far weve come that a Sub $30 (Included Abbree ar-771 antenna) can sound and transmit this well.
Good enough for govt work. Seems like the uv5R is the budget winner
I like how you have all that gear sitting on a park picnic table in an area that chains their picnic tables to trees😂
It’s so people don’t move the tables. Not steal them. 🤣
Baofeng 8W actually outputs at 6.5W according to my meter...
I recall a bunch of tests or videos saying the same
Up to 8W...hahaha
I tested both my TD-F9GP 8W versions with fresh battery's into dum dum load. Both 6.7W on same sweet spot freq. Not a powerhouse but better than my old 5W Baofeng that only saw 3.9W on high. That 3W difference means something on a fringe signal.
The stock antenna's are junk and the built-in mic's are weak compared to a good hand mic but still hard to beat em for the price.
Informative and interesting test.
Thanks!
Love the vx-6r. I lost my first one during a very boggy walk out from a SOTA activation... I since bought a second one as it's such a dependable and sturdy unit. As for the baofengs, most of them are fantastic value for money and reasonable performers. I guess the main difference will be consistency from one unit to the next. It would be great to see five of the same model baofeng from different sources being put through the same test.
I checked 3 BF-7H Baofengs I just bought on my Surecom 102 and they where all three basically the same. Within .25 watts of each other and with in .5 watts +/- of the advertised 10 watts.
Now do the UV-82HP! That's supposed to be the highest quality Baofeng.
think you should include the tri band baofeng
I like to see a test on the baofeng uv53.. using this radio people have said my audio is worse when i use the cig lighter compare to when run from the stock battery that came with it.
Thanks for another video!
Would you also do a similar test of some Wouxun and Anytone radios?
My f8hp, like others (most likely ALL F8 series) has off center accessories port holes. This makes getting the programming cable or shoulder mic's plugged in nearly impossible unless you cut off some of the connector rubber (see photo). The manufacturer clearly didn't test a prototype before going to full production, not surprisingly, you get what you pay for now days!
No, you don't always get what you pay for now days!
That is why he is testing radios.
Thanks!
Many people talk about the great clean transmitter on the GT-5R but unfortunately it does not "receive" near as good as the UV-5R5 in the ham band. I own many different baofengs and the GT-5R has the worse receiver in them inside the ham band. I own 2 GT-5R's and I would not recommend buying that radio. I am not talking about out of band as the GT-5R won't do that anyway. I am talking about inside the ham bands.
The Baofeng's problem isn't the transmission (they have 5W or more), but they have a very bad reception (0.25uV at 12dB SINAD, a good radio can receive at 0.12uV). They suck to listen to far repeaters (or simplex) and they will be deaf in a place with busy VHF signals (like a city), and don't forget about the Baofeng's spurious, it's just a garbage radio.
Which is the best radio/antenna combo to get anywhere between 15 and 20 miles in range? I can’t seem to find any information to those specifications. Hope you can help.
Josh, is there an economical tool (meter) that effectively measures the SWR of HTs? The Surecom meters don't seem to work, even with a paw around the HT acting as a ground plane. One Surecom even came with a steel plate to act as a ground plane, but it 1) greatly added to the cost of production and 2) really didn't work. They're super for mobile or base station use, but not HT use, unfortunately. Thnx!
Nice rainbow trout mat
Yeah man. I love that rag.
Could the gt5r slightly better ability be related to the fixed spurious emmisions , sending power to where it’s supposed to go?
Great vid, I've been curious about the various Boafeng variants. Does that big chain ground radial behind you going from the table and around the tree affect your test?? LOL One thing about the Baofeng's... rarely does the actually transmit power live up to the advertised wattage hype. The 8W model I bought measured less than 5W on VHF and 6W on UHF.
I do like this little radios. I have three of them.
Hi Josh.
Been following you since I got my first Baofeng and found your videos about them.
Thank you for all the great videos.
But, what do you think about BTech?
I came across a review saying the BTech UV-5X3 can skip nuisance channels when scanning.
I like that, bc I've been scanning and building a list of GMRS channels with the lowest traffic in my area to use with my buddies that only have GMRS.
No, I don't have a home radio yet. My interest right now is portable communication.
Can't get over the chained bench. It would be an operation to steal that thing in the first place (2 two people + pickup truck). Not really a "keep honest people honest" thing. So if you are already going that far, whats to stop them from getting some bolt cutters? I never wanted to steal a picnic table but the chain makes me want to do it.
Hey Josh, would love to have the Wouxun kg-uv9d thrown in there as a wild card.
I have a question. I have been a ham for almost 20 years. My HT is a Yaesu VX-150. My brother and niece have shown some interest lately. I would like to get him a GT-5R. Was that static I heard while transmitting or was it on the receiving side? Anyway, for the price, it seems great, but I want to make sure it would be good for him. Thanks!
UV-5R vs BF-F8HP. Most of the review videos I watch comparing these two radios is over my head. I want to pick one for listening to VHF and UHF. Not planning to talk on one. The BAOFENG BF-F8HP appears to have wider frequency spectrum than the UV-5R. VHF: 136-174 MHz(Rx/Tx). UHF: 400-520 1000 channels vs VHF 144-148MHz, UHF 420-450MHz 128 channels. The videos I have watched don’t seem to speak about that. Can you help me understand if my reasoning is correct for my intended use.
Would choose a bundle with a load of accessories and the extra accessories would go to my other radios.
How do you feel about Retevis RT85 or RT87 versus Baofengs, which one would be better?
Can you PLEASE do a video on how you have the station at home configured to TX when you send it DTMF commands? I would love to implement that to my shack for range testing of my own
73 KO4YQU
The Most Hated Box In Ham Radio
ruclips.net/video/nrkAqWEB7rs/видео.html
@@HamRadioCrashCourse Thank you so much! I had been eagerly waiting since the first comparison video. With such a cryptic title I didn’t even realize that was the long-awaited video
What do you think of the new 8-watt version of the UV-5R compared to the standard Amazon UV-5R.
Love your videos, but still confused as to why a public park has a metal picnic table chain to a tree is stuff that bad in California
lol. So people don’t move them for large parties.
That park must be in a sketchy neighborhood needing to chain down the trees to keep people from stealing them.😝
Have yet to get it to program. Have watched many youtube videos and even had my wife try to figure it out, but have not been able to use it.
As someone that's studying for there tech license and looking to buy a radio, that was one of the better compressions I needed to see on baofeng. Thank you so much for sharing that and that helped me narrow down alot of options for me. But quick question, I'm doing alot of traveling around the US for work, what would be best for that? Not sure if that's even a worry for people in this great hobby haha. Thanks again and have a great day.
Just for fun, you should test those against an xpr7550
Josh, great info, thanks for posting, can you or anyone comment if there is any improvement on the receive side of the GT5R as well- pertaining to intermod rejection or is it the same as basic UV5R? Also, without the spurious emissions (GT5R) would tx power be more efficient on the chosen freq? I have a recent Amazon UV5R seems ok, but am considering if it is worth it to upgrade to the GT5R or an even bigger step to the FT60r as the radio will be accompanying me on motorcycle rides with a 771/signal stick style antenna.. Thanks all.
I have not tested the GT5R receiver against the UV-5R. It's on my list to do though!
Can you do a review on the Boating UV 13 pro air band? I have one.
Hey Josh. I want to do a test like this. I have an SDR running SDRSharp on my laptop. I have the audio piped to Auacity to capture as a sound file. How do i capture the SNR value? Thanks and keep up the great work!
Idk. I don’t use SDRSharp.
@@HamRadioCrashCourse What SDR software are you using?