@MadeInHistory Hi! As of 8:07, you say that "monks took a vow of poverty. So there was really no need to for them to leave their enclaves". What did you imply by saying that there was no need for them to leave their enclaves? Thanks for your feedback in advance! Kind regards, Alex
This is much better than the one the Great Courses makes I was so mad when I ordered Amazon prime just to watch a six part series on the Middle Ages and all it was , was a woman sitting in a chair and talking without the great artwork . She just sat in a chair and talked for six episodes! They called it a documentary but it clearly wasn’t. I love these they are so much more entertaining and I love the beautiful art
Rebecca it’s called the great COURSES for a reason. Those are college level classes, not meant to entertain people who can only consume history through flashy documentaries. I’m not really sure what you expected from something with COURSES in the title. No where did it say it was a documentary 😂😂😂 but glad you found something with visuals so you can understand ❤
I have to admit that medieval times were the most confusing(thus hardest) period of history in primary/high school and university. I always struggled for some reason when it comes to remembering all the people, events, hierarchy and lifestyle system. I have to say that this documantary is literally the best cover of the middle ages. I'm shocked, it was so smooth and understandable. Love it, thank you 😄
It's complicated for sure. Even just watching a history of Germany is overwhelming. There were so many kingdoms, and so much strife between them, it is impossible to remember it all. Modern Europe emerged out of this chaotic stew of kingdoms and empires battling it out with each other.
Having to remember all the freeeaking carolingians was the worst.. louis the fat, carlo the dumb, charles the bald, pipin the slow.. i probably mixed the names as i wrote them now, i just remember the descriptive middle names 😂
I was watching/listening to this while making a Kandi purse for myself. I love learning about the middle ages, I find them fascinating and this was a very educational and entertaining video!!
Referring to minute 44:50, there is a fault in this map. East Prussia (where today Kaliningrad is) never belonged to the Holy Roman Empire. Yes, the Dukes of Brandenburg acquired that territory from the previous Teutonic Order. Duke Frederick III used that situation to crown himself the first Prussian king, a promotion which the Habsburg emperor would not have allowed. So, within the empire Frederick remained Duke of Brandenburg. but outside the empire he was "King in Prussia".
An excellent overview of a much-neglected period of history. Good, clear narration and very helpful graphics. It's great to be able to take in the knowledge without the constant intrusion of the presenter
Guys, I LOVE your channel! I wish I would have found it the day you posted your first video! No way I'll be able to watch them all retroactively. Thank you for posting all of this knowledge. It is priceless.
What a presentation! Bravo! Classic. A true tour de force. Enjoyed this thoroughly, moreso than most of what is offered out in the ether. You all may be very proud of this complete exposition. So well written and narrated. Unabashed admission of the uncertainties. A Gibbonesque effort. Simply wonderful, thank you all.
This is a great video on the history of the Germanic tribes in Medieval Europe, particularly those living in Germany, France, Britain and Northern Italy. There is little to no mention of Spain, Southern Italy, or the entire Central and Eastern parts of Europe populated by Slavs.
I think this is the first video I have seen from MH. It is the very best presentation of historical periods I have seen ~ and I watch a lot! I so appreciate the use of maps current to the time being discussed, along with the timelines of people, domains, and events. This really helps bring it together. Your brief explanations of rulers, politics, religion, and culture are superb. This period is of particular interest to me because (like so many others) I can trace my lineage back to Pepin the Short (and thus Charlemagne). Having first found (or recognized) King Louis VI of France initially and having lineage from both King Louis VII and his brother, Robert de Dreux, I became acquainted with Eleanor of Aquitaine (Alienore d'Aquitaine) - now one of my favorite heroines. With her being a wife to both the Kings of France and England I have lineage to Charlemagne via France and England. So I am always seeking a greater understanding of this period. Thank you so much for what you do and how you do it. I'll be watching all your documentaries!
Its cool that you explained the Christion religious orders they give much clearer picture to me especially as none Christion. these many titles within Christion orders can create confusion but you done it so clearly.
Im only partially in to this video but want to say i am so glad to have found this channel. I lobe the presentation, the script, the music and images, i especially like the inclusion of maps to help paint the picture better. I am stopping this video and going back through the earlier period videos now. I appreciate how on your about page you explain what these phases and levels are. This is so organized and quite an incredibly huge task you have still to do. I am eager to listen to everything and see what future videos you release.
Tremendous overview. I have learned a few things. However, you completely overlooked the impact of the Albigensian Crusade of 1209, and the rise of the Troubadours, whom both Dante and Petrarch immortalized and still deeply affect modern culture. The first recognized Troubadour was Eleanor's grandfather Guilhem de Peitieus.
Excelent video, covers not only the whole middle age period but also pretty much the whole renaissance (which ends with the italian wars). My only complain is the lack of information about the other regions of europe, a little bit too focus on France. I would like to know more about the slavic populations in Europe during the early medieval period.
Norsemen were not known as Vikings back then, but more commonly known as Danes, even those who weren't Danish. This was likely because there was no way for the people of the british isles to differ between Danes, Norwegians or Swedes, as they were more or less culturally identical. Viking, in the usage of norsemen, is a relatively modern term that went into use around the 1800's when these countries were building their national identities. In the middle ages, "viking" just meant pirate or seaborne raiders, and had no ethnical ties. In the medieval saga that tells the story of King Sigurd the Crusader in the early 1100's, even muslim Moors from Spain are referred to as vikings by the norsemen.
that's interesting, I didn't consider that other ethnicities might have been referred to as Vikings. thanks for sharing (and I like your profile picture.)
There is one funny mistake on the time 1:32:32. The years of Mazaccio's life are given as 1408-1421, which means that he lived only 13 years. In fact, the last digits are mixed up, the real years of his life are 1401-1428 .
I know exactly what you mean it’s hard to watch any docs made after 2015 because they refuse to do that very thing. One can’t say a thing about the Christians that other faiths haven’t done themselves. If u listen to anything on the Crusades it’s so biased they make Saladin out to be a Saint and Christians out to be more crazy and violent than any other group in history
I got all this in middle school, then again in high school, then again in college…hated every second of it. It has zero to do with anything I cared about…now at 60 I can’t get enough of it. Too funny.
Only three narrative sources, on the South Slavic lands in the Early Middle Ages, have been preserved. The first of these, which is cited under the title De Administrando Imperio, was composed in the middle of the tenth century, and ascribed to the Byzantine Emperor Constantine seventh Porphyrogenitus, that is three hundred years after the beginning of the settlement of the South Slavs, in their new homeland. With regard to these Slavic settlers, Porphyrogenitus speaks of the Croats and Serbs under their names, which they brought from the proto-homeland, while the remaining Slavs are mentioned under tribal or regional names, for example: Zachlumoi, Terbuniotes, Kanalites, Diocletians, Arentanoi, while the Boshnyani or Bosnians, are not mentioned. The second narrative source is dedicated to the history of the Church of Salona, modern Solin, and later Split from Roman times to 1266. It was written by Thomas, the Archdeacon of Split, who lived in the thirteenth century, in the work Historia Salonitana. Thomas calls the Croats Goths, and speaks much of the relations between the autochthonous Roman, and, newly settled Slavic or Croatian element through six hundred years, while he mentions Bosnia only in passing.
Historiography dates the emergence of the third narrative source, known under the name The Chronicle of the Priest of Dioclea, or, The Genealogy of Bar, to the second half of the twelfth century. The text is very complex, and, a critical analysis of it points to a number of paradigms; the mediated information is frequently very nebulous, and not one piece is dated. For this reason this source is ideal for speculation, and desirable constructs of the distant past. The furthest to go in this direction, on the Croatian side, was Dominik Mandić Muhamed Hadžijahić on the Bosniak side, and Relja Novaković on the Serbian, as well as, of course, their publicistic epigones. Each of them made a particular effort to reconstruct a still wider political space for their own ethnic groups Croatian, Bosniak, Serbian, in the Early Middle Ages. The most important names are authors: Mladen Ančić, Danijel Đino, Neven Budak, Tibor Živković, Lujo Margetić. Bosniak historians have, generally, not participated in heated discussions on those topics. Some historians accepted the information from the three aforementioned narrative sources, as starting points for further research, but they introduced less conjecture into them, and preferred to leave them as informative torsos; they filled those gaps, which could be confirmed or corrected with meagre facts, mediated through other sources, archaeological remains, and, marginal records. In recent times this approach has been applied with the scientific precision and persuasiveness craved for by the Croatian philologist, Indo-Europeanist, and literary historian, Radoslav Katičić. In his classical work, Litterarum studia, on which he worked for nearly twenty years, Kaatichitch succeeded in reconstructing the developmental lines of early medieval Croatian cultural history. To be sure, due to the scarcity of preserved historical sources, Kaatichitch's synthesis also has not ceased being a torso, but the main lines have acquired clear contours. https : //www . youtube . com/watch?v=tFitgTDBytI
"Complete overview" - actually only about Western Europe. As a Bulgarian, I was interested in how eastern and western kingdoms interacted, but everyone makes videos only about western Europe and mostly about France and England.
Lather, rinse, repeat. How tiresome humans are with constant warring, conquering, violence, disruption, destruction, etc. Birds must be so very sick of us.
Turks indeed had a decisive role in triggering historical major events like the Migration Period, Crusades, shaping the history of Balkans, Islamization of Northern India, Age of Discovery as well as ending the Middle Ages with the conquest of Constantinople, fall of the Roman Empire.
Obvious in the work and efforts involved. (Appreciate the the reference to the mention of Germanics migratiin into N Italy/Rome). Even if I dont agree with all of the content perspectives, I recognize the value of intentions. Very Well done.
I think about this often. Not only did they survive all the mass murdering barbarian raids but they also survived the annual plagues that killed 2/3 of the whole population of Europe. It’s almost a miracle we are here at all.
When you said the monastery came from a word that meant alone or one it was eye-opening and made me think of the monarchy another word with mono in it that probably means the one ruler. With this in mind when you got to Abbott I remembered Jesus saying Abba on the cross calling out to his father. I surmise that Abbott is father in some language. Very interesting how you explain these words thank you for the video
Être fort comme un Turc (‘to be strong like a turk’): This expression originates in the 15th century when the Turks had a reputation for being strong, almost unbeatable warriors due to their numerous victories. At the time, the Ottoman Empire ruled large parts of south-east Europe, north Africa and western Asia. It is said that François I, King of France, was gifted Turkish armour by Suleiman the Magnificent (the tenth and most famous sultan of the Ottoman Empire) during their alliance. When he wore it, he is said to have exclaimed: “Here I am now, strong as a Turk!”.
@@starcapture3040hahah yeah. After watchin 1000s of years how eurapeans kill, rape, sack each other to the bone, calling Turks "savage & barbarian" pretty funny isn it😅
RUclips vs Printing press; RUclips impact will surpass the printing press by 2 standard deviations. YT will be spoken about for thousands of years. Timeline: Block Printing: Pre 868 A.D. Moveable Type: Between 970 - 1051 A.D. Wood Type Updated: 1297 The Gutenberg Press: 1450 The Spread of Printing in Europe: 1465 - 1495 Industrial Printing Press Invention: 1800 - 1843 Modern Printing Processes: Offset and Digital Printing RUclips, video streaming service 2005.
🧠🌙This is really well done, the moving stills are great and the narration is almost perfect, pace tone and story are superb, looking fwd to more content from this outfit. 🤍WORLDWIDE EUROPEAN BROTHERHOOD 🤍
Ya seriously, it's a huge complaint of mine and ruins my day when high quality content is completely ruined by the ai voice. It goes war, famine, and then of course ai voices in my book. Glad I finally found someone on the same page. We should date.
*I am playing a Total War: Atilla 1212AD Mod so learning all this history really enriches my gameplay as the Re-born of the Byzantine Empire in 1212AD.*
@2020davidabc Money yes, it would be INCREDIBLY hard to get that many voice actors. Also, it's a novelty right now, before they take over the world, we will enjoy playing with it a bit
The 4th Crusade was the single most stupid mistake in the history of medieval Europe. Christians attacking Christians for petty reason giving the opportunity to a foreign aggressive power with a different religion and culture to capture and hold one of the gates of the continent. A mistake that still today Europe finds itself locked into...no no. Letting Constantinople in ruins and giving such opportunity to the Turks! Terrible terrible affair
Years ago I thought the same way. Then I dug into the detailed history, the stuff that TV shows and most videos ignore. The Eastern Roman Emperor had a long history of back-stabbing, making false promises and selling out the crusaders to the Muslim forces so they could be attacked. This started with the First Crusade and did not improve over time. Quite frankly I'm amazed the Western forces put up with the crap from Constantinople for so long, before giving them the severe smackdown they richly deserved. Constantinople was an enemy pretending to be a friend. With friends like that you don't need bloodthirsty enemies.
Correction: Benedictines never had a vow of poverty. Their three vows are Obedience (to their Abboy and superriors), Stability (meaning the monastery they join is where they will live forever. They do not go from place to place. Friars do that. Friara sre not monks), anc Conversion of morals. The last assumes a life of chastity. Benedictines "hold all things in common."
This video is a important remenber of The history and tell me the kights for me they have honor a friend this a friend in good and bad times, wandfull history ,thank you!😊
@@atlantic_loveRegardless of what program was used it is not a pleasant listen. If the channel always uses this style of audio it's hindering it's following.
My dude religion is just a pretext for the warring that is part of human nature. Thinking it would be good to get rid of all the religion is exactly that pretext to start another war
Hope you all enjoy our double-length feature! What's your favorite story from the Middle Ages?
Who are YOU? What organization is funding this AI?
All of em! Y’all did a great job!
Thank you for all your effort!
The auto voice over isn't pronouncing Odoacer correctly .
@MadeInHistory Hi! As of 8:07, you say that "monks took a vow of poverty. So there was really no need to for them to leave their enclaves". What did you imply by saying that there was no need for them to leave their enclaves?
Thanks for your feedback in advance!
Kind regards, Alex
Your voice to text robot sucks
This is much better than the one the Great Courses makes I was so mad when I ordered Amazon prime just to watch a six part series on the Middle Ages and all it was , was a woman sitting in a chair and talking without the great artwork . She just sat in a chair and talked for six episodes! They called it a documentary but it clearly wasn’t. I love these they are so much more entertaining and I love the beautiful art
The lectures by Philip Daileader are excellent.
Chinese people are really good
Rebecca it’s called the great COURSES for a reason. Those are college level classes, not meant to entertain people who can only consume history through flashy documentaries. I’m not really sure what you expected from something with COURSES in the title. No where did it say it was a documentary 😂😂😂 but glad you found something with visuals so you can understand ❤
Accurate
There are even better in Russian. But... in Russian
I have to admit that medieval times were the most confusing(thus hardest) period of history in primary/high school and university. I always struggled for some reason when it comes to remembering all the people, events, hierarchy and lifestyle system. I have to say that this documantary is literally the best cover of the middle ages. I'm shocked, it was so smooth and understandable. Love it, thank you 😄
That means a lot! I’m very happy you enjoyed it!
You took the words right out of my mouth. If he would have been my teacher or I would have had this as an aid that semester would have gone better .
It's complicated for sure. Even just watching a history of Germany is overwhelming. There were so many kingdoms, and so much strife between them, it is impossible to remember it all. Modern Europe emerged out of this chaotic stew of kingdoms and empires battling it out with each other.
Depends what you find interesting lol
Having to remember all the freeeaking carolingians was the worst.. louis the fat, carlo the dumb, charles the bald, pipin the slow.. i probably mixed the names as i wrote them now, i just remember the descriptive middle names 😂
What a super video i wish my teacher 60 years ago had explained the medieval history like you have Just done.
Thank You !
I like the way you connect the dots with so many facts about this fascinating period of history. Great work! Thanks!
I was watching/listening to this while making a Kandi purse for myself. I love learning about the middle ages, I find them fascinating and this was a very educational and entertaining video!!
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed it!
Referring to minute 44:50, there is a fault in this map. East Prussia (where today Kaliningrad is) never belonged to the Holy Roman Empire.
Yes, the Dukes of Brandenburg acquired that territory from the previous Teutonic Order. Duke Frederick III used that situation to crown himself the first Prussian king, a promotion which the Habsburg emperor would not have allowed. So, within the empire Frederick remained Duke of Brandenburg. but outside the empire he was "King in Prussia".
An excellent overview of a much-neglected period of history. Good, clear narration and very helpful graphics. It's great to be able to take in the knowledge without the constant intrusion of the presenter
Glad you enjoyed it!
I'm still watching 👀 on earth 🌎 ❤
Is anyone watching 👀 now, May 18 12.07?
Fabulous overview. So many books still to be written!
Guys, I LOVE your channel! I wish I would have found it the day you posted your first video! No way I'll be able to watch them all retroactively. Thank you for posting all of this knowledge. It is priceless.
Thanks! That means a lot!
I very much agree!
You are awesome 👏🏻
What a presentation! Bravo! Classic. A true tour de force. Enjoyed this thoroughly, moreso than most of what is offered out in the ether. You all may be very proud of this complete exposition.
So well written and narrated. Unabashed admission of the uncertainties. A Gibbonesque effort. Simply wonderful, thank you all.
Thank you very much! Very glad you enjoyed it!
The region-specific music selection was a nice touch! 👍🏻
This is a great video on the history of the Germanic tribes in Medieval Europe, particularly those living in Germany, France, Britain and Northern Italy. There is little to no mention of Spain, Southern Italy, or the entire Central and Eastern parts of Europe populated by Slavs.
They covered the Slavic areas
Few speak of Spain. Gotta remember it was 70% Muslim occupied at the time. It's a shame though the reconquista was very eventful.
I wanted to hear more about robots but... nothing.😢
Awesome video and very good research on this period! Keep it up with good work!
Glad you enjoyed it!
22:12 Reminds of that Monty Python anarcho-syndicalist constitutional peasant "HELP HELP I'M BEING REPRESSED!" 🤣
My first video from this channel. I’m going back to catch up. Great job!!
Welcome aboard!
at high school I excelled in ancient and modern history and your 1 hour 3/4, is dare i say a perfect encapsulation, hats off.
not high praise considering the medieval period comprises neither ancient nor modern history
😂😂😂😂
How do get smart so? Like you?
It's the best documentary about the Medieval Europe! Thank you so much!
I like Chinese culture
@@ChineseAncientStories-cb8uoLao gan ma
I think this is the first video I have seen from MH. It is the very best presentation of historical periods I have seen ~ and I watch a lot! I so appreciate the use of maps current to the time being discussed, along with the timelines of people, domains, and events. This really helps bring it together. Your brief explanations of rulers, politics, religion, and culture are superb.
This period is of particular interest to me because (like so many others) I can trace my lineage back to Pepin the Short (and thus Charlemagne). Having first found (or recognized) King Louis VI of France initially and having lineage from both King Louis VII and his brother, Robert de Dreux, I became acquainted with Eleanor of Aquitaine (Alienore d'Aquitaine) - now one of my favorite heroines. With her being a wife to both the Kings of France and England I have lineage to Charlemagne via France and England. So I am always seeking a greater understanding of this period.
Thank you so much for what you do and how you do it. I'll be watching all your documentaries!
Glad you liked it!
It's estimated that 80%-100% of Europeans living today are descendants of Charlemagne
Its cool that you explained the Christion religious orders they give much clearer picture to me especially as none Christion. these many titles within Christion orders can create confusion but you done it so clearly.
Christian
@@darienwygant9138English is obviously not their first language, give em a break lol. You knew what they meant
@@oddiethefox5832it’s just a correction lol how’s somebody going to get better if nobody ever corrects mistakes? 😉 😬
These designations are not within all Christian denominations just the Catholics
@@nickinurse6433 huh?? There are a crap load of Protestant denominations.
I was literally wondering if this channel had medieval europe explanation videos few hours ago
Im only partially in to this video but want to say i am so glad to have found this channel. I lobe the presentation, the script, the music and images, i especially like the inclusion of maps to help paint the picture better.
I am stopping this video and going back through the earlier period videos now.
I appreciate how on your about page you explain what these phases and levels are. This is so organized and quite an incredibly huge task you have still to do. I am eager to listen to everything and see what future videos you release.
how could you enjoy the robotic voice narration. its horrible.
"I lobe?" Or "ear lobe"?!?! 😅😅
Well I am stopping the video now and going to get something to snack on
I am stopping the video now and then hitting play, and then stopping the video now again.
Thank you for the awesome content!! I love it
Glad you enjoyed it!
Bedankt
Thanks you!
Tremendous overview. I have learned a few things. However, you completely overlooked the impact of the Albigensian Crusade of 1209, and the rise of the Troubadours, whom both Dante and Petrarch immortalized and still deeply affect modern culture. The first recognized Troubadour was Eleanor's grandfather Guilhem de Peitieus.
You ever cup your farts and smell your hand?
@@rheinhardtgrafvonthiesenha8185 everytime
Thank you! Such a comprehensive doc! Very helpful and interesting!
Glad it was helpful!
Excelent video, covers not only the whole middle age period but also pretty much the whole renaissance (which ends with the italian wars). My only complain is the lack of information about the other regions of europe, a little bit too focus on France. I would like to know more about the slavic populations in Europe during the early medieval period.
YOU now have room to do your own video.
EXCELLENT DOC! Nice work
Glad you enjoyed it!
This is fantastic! Thanks
Glad you liked it!
Absolutely wonderful perfectly executed
Thanks for an entertaining story and then in a chronological order that is easy to understand
*I love these they are so much more entertaining and I love the beautiful art*
Norsemen were not known as Vikings back then, but more commonly known as Danes, even those who weren't Danish. This was likely because there was no way for the people of the british isles to differ between Danes, Norwegians or Swedes, as they were more or less culturally identical. Viking, in the usage of norsemen, is a relatively modern term that went into use around the 1800's when these countries were building their national identities. In the middle ages, "viking" just meant pirate or seaborne raiders, and had no ethnical ties. In the medieval saga that tells the story of King Sigurd the Crusader in the early 1100's, even muslim Moors from Spain are referred to as vikings by the norsemen.
that's interesting, I didn't consider that other ethnicities might have been referred to as Vikings. thanks for sharing (and I like your profile picture.)
Stunning work. Thank you very much.
Glad you enjoyed!
There is one funny mistake on the time 1:32:32. The years of Mazaccio's life are given as 1408-1421, which means that he lived only 13 years. In fact, the last digits are mixed up, the real years of his life are 1401-1428 .
Good catch! Errors like this are fixed in the compilation coming soon!
@@MadeInHistory Thanks. You've made an excellent series. I enjoy watching your channel.
Thanks for giving us detailed descriptions brother 😀
Also thumbnail was greatest of whatever you made in the past
Glad you liked it!
Shame this won't be seen all around the world. Thank you for the excellent presentation.
Glad you enjoyed it!
First channel I’ve enjoyed in a long time
Such a well-researched video! Kudos to the creator! 🎓👏
6:44 the word "monachos" dirives from the ancient Greek word "monos" that means alone. In modern Greek "monachos" means monk.
wow,a top quality doco,no fanfare and rubbish,thankyou
Glad you enjoyed it!
Who runs this channel? Spectacular work! Thank you!
I’m pretty sure that would be ChatGPT
@@rustyshackleford2007 lol
I hope this continues to get more views. This was fantastic. Thank you.
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed it!
Thank you for covering the Church objectively! 👍
I know exactly what you mean it’s hard to watch any docs made after 2015 because they refuse to do that very thing. One can’t say a thing about the Christians that other faiths haven’t done themselves. If u listen to anything on the Crusades it’s so biased they make Saladin out to be a Saint and Christians out to be more crazy and violent than any other group in history
I got all this in middle school, then again in high school, then again in college…hated every second of it. It has zero to do with anything I cared about…now at 60 I can’t get enough of it. Too funny.
Only three narrative sources, on the South Slavic lands in the Early Middle Ages, have been preserved. The first of these, which is cited under the title De Administrando Imperio, was composed in the middle of the tenth century, and ascribed to the Byzantine Emperor Constantine seventh Porphyrogenitus, that is three hundred years after the beginning of the settlement of the South Slavs, in their new homeland. With regard to these Slavic settlers, Porphyrogenitus speaks of the Croats and Serbs under their names, which they brought from the proto-homeland, while the remaining Slavs are mentioned under tribal or regional names, for example: Zachlumoi, Terbuniotes, Kanalites, Diocletians, Arentanoi, while the Boshnyani or Bosnians, are not mentioned.
The second narrative source is dedicated to the history of the Church of Salona, modern Solin, and later Split from Roman times to 1266. It was written by Thomas, the Archdeacon of Split, who lived in the thirteenth century, in the work Historia Salonitana. Thomas calls the Croats Goths, and speaks much of the relations between the autochthonous Roman, and, newly settled Slavic or Croatian element through six hundred years, while he mentions Bosnia only in passing.
Historiography dates the emergence of the third narrative source, known under the name The Chronicle of the Priest of Dioclea, or, The Genealogy of Bar, to the second half of the twelfth century. The text is very complex, and, a critical analysis of it points to a number of paradigms; the mediated information is frequently very nebulous, and not one piece is dated. For this reason this source is ideal for speculation, and desirable constructs of the distant past. The furthest to go in this direction, on the Croatian side, was Dominik Mandić Muhamed Hadžijahić on the Bosniak side, and Relja Novaković on the Serbian, as well as, of course, their publicistic epigones. Each of them made a particular effort to reconstruct a still wider political space for their own ethnic groups Croatian, Bosniak, Serbian, in the Early Middle Ages.
The most important names are authors: Mladen Ančić, Danijel Đino, Neven Budak, Tibor Živković, Lujo Margetić. Bosniak historians have, generally, not participated in heated discussions on those topics.
Some historians accepted the information from the three aforementioned narrative sources, as starting points for further research, but they introduced less conjecture into them, and preferred to leave them as informative torsos; they filled those gaps, which could be confirmed or corrected with meagre facts, mediated through other sources, archaeological remains, and, marginal records. In recent times this approach has been applied with the scientific precision and persuasiveness craved for by the Croatian philologist, Indo-Europeanist, and literary historian, Radoslav Katičić. In his classical work, Litterarum studia, on which he worked for nearly twenty years, Kaatichitch succeeded in reconstructing the developmental lines of early medieval Croatian cultural history. To be sure, due to the scarcity of preserved historical sources, Kaatichitch's synthesis also has not ceased being a torso, but the main lines have acquired clear contours.
https : //www . youtube . com/watch?v=tFitgTDBytI
ruclips.net/video/DC1mVgOx8EI/видео.html
Great video and for that, you have gained a new subscriber
Love this, post some more. Education it's the best gift.
More is always on the way
This is awesome
The channel is amazing
Really enjoying this video! I have such an interest in this time period. Thank you for the wonderful overview !
Glad you liked it!
Great documentary:)
Excellent summary 🙂
Glad you liked it!
Very well done! Thank you.
"Complete overview" - actually only about Western Europe. As a Bulgarian, I was interested in how eastern and western kingdoms interacted, but everyone makes videos only about western Europe and mostly about France and England.
Bulgaria is more Asian than European.
Scholarship illustrated and explained excellent
Is this made with ai?
Sounds like it
Likely but maybe edited by a human?
Yes. It's a robot.
Thank you! Liked it already cause i know its gonna be gold! Imma watch it tonight before bed, thank you thank you thank you!
Lather, rinse, repeat. How tiresome humans are with constant warring, conquering, violence, disruption, destruction, etc. Birds must be so very sick of us.
Cats too
You mean men
As they say history repeats
Very funny. Birds watching from above waiting for the body carcasses! The birds could be confident they will come sooner or later.
Even we're sick of us.
Right to the point and easy to listen to.
Well done! I like the video and look forward to more like this
Thank you! I’m glad you enjoyed it!
Super well explained. Clear as day.
Glad it was helpful!
Two minutes into the video I had to pause it... to subscribe.
same!
Manor Lords game preview, nite touch, the artwork of that game is fantastic
Turks indeed had a decisive role in triggering historical major events like the Migration Period, Crusades, shaping the history of Balkans, Islamization of Northern India, Age of Discovery as well as ending the Middle Ages with the conquest of Constantinople, fall of the Roman Empire.
Turks are not europeans
Obvious in the work and efforts involved. (Appreciate the the reference to the mention of Germanics migratiin into N Italy/Rome).
Even if I dont agree with all of the content perspectives, I recognize the value of intentions.
Very Well done.
I can't imagine 1,300 years of kingdom warmongering. It boggles the mind what my ancestors went through just this era of history.
I think about this often. Not only did they survive all the mass murdering barbarian raids but they also survived the annual plagues that killed 2/3 of the whole population of Europe. It’s almost a miracle we are here at all.
@@francesguinta8614
They were happier and richer than you
@@goyonman9655 nonsense but whatever a-ho
You have totally wrong picture of Middle Ages. Do you also think about XXc as an uninterrupted warfare and civilians dodging bullets every second?
This is the only RUclips video I found with the complete history of the middle ages good job
When you said the monastery came from a word that meant alone or one it was eye-opening and made me think of the monarchy another word with mono in it that probably means the one ruler. With this in mind when you got to Abbott I remembered Jesus saying Abba on the cross calling out to his father. I surmise that Abbott is father in some language. Very interesting how you explain these words thank you for the video
Don't forget my friend, if you ever have trouble seeing close up you can wear a monocle.ha ha
Love this! Thank you so much.
Glad you like it!
Excellent content, great production values.
Thank God for quality long form content
Subscribed to your channel!
A really great educational video.....I learned a lot from this one.
Glad it was helpful!
Perfect video.
Perfect script and perfect voice. AI much?
am i the only one who thinks the narrator is ai?
It is that's why
For sure
No. It’s not good enough. Just a bad narrator.
No. It’s not good enough. Just a bad narrator.
@@CreachterZ I understood the first time.
Extraordinary content 👌
Être fort comme un Turc (‘to be strong like a turk’):
This expression originates in the 15th century when the Turks had a reputation for being strong, almost unbeatable warriors due to their numerous victories. At the time, the Ottoman Empire ruled large parts of south-east Europe, north Africa and western Asia. It is said that François I, King of France, was gifted Turkish armour by Suleiman the Magnificent (the tenth and most famous sultan of the Ottoman Empire) during their alliance. When he wore it, he is said to have exclaimed: “Here I am now, strong as a Turk!”.
No! this is comes from al asiuty book on the good aspects of nations. Turk in Europe meant savage and barbaric.
Look
L
I pl pl) lo P0 ppl h.o
😊j
I
@@starcapture3040hahah yeah. After watchin 1000s of years how eurapeans kill, rape, sack each other to the bone, calling Turks "savage & barbarian" pretty funny isn it😅
@@starcapture3040 I know Martin Luther hated the Turks because of their cruelty.
RUclips vs Printing press;
RUclips impact will surpass the printing press by 2 standard deviations.
YT will be spoken about for thousands of years.
Timeline:
Block Printing: Pre 868 A.D.
Moveable Type: Between 970 - 1051 A.D.
Wood Type Updated: 1297
The Gutenberg Press: 1450
The Spread of Printing in Europe: 1465 - 1495
Industrial Printing Press Invention: 1800 - 1843
Modern Printing Processes:
Offset and Digital Printing
RUclips, video streaming service 2005.
🧠🌙This is really well done, the moving stills are great and the narration is almost perfect, pace tone and story are superb, looking fwd to more content from this outfit. 🤍WORLDWIDE EUROPEAN BROTHERHOOD 🤍
Enjoying this very much. Grateful ❣️. Thanks for sharing. Kind regards Niall O'Connell Dundalk Irelande 🇱🇷🌄🌹
Very glad you enjoyed it!
Would be really nice if this weren't an AI voice.
Ya seriously, it's a huge complaint of mine and ruins my day when high quality content is completely ruined by the ai voice. It goes war, famine, and then of course ai voices in my book. Glad I finally found someone on the same page. We should date.
Care for the disenfranchised is present in Machiavelli's other works. "The Prince" was an exposé rather than a normative statement.
*I am playing a Total War: Atilla 1212AD Mod so learning all this history really enriches my gameplay as the Re-born of the Byzantine Empire in 1212AD.*
Is this AI voice?
100%
@@sgb4798honestly it’s still better than most
I think so, it is a very good voice pick if it is ai
@2020davidabc Money yes, it would be INCREDIBLY hard to get that many voice actors.
Also, it's a novelty right now, before they take over the world, we will enjoy playing with it a bit
@2020davidabcif u need to ask those questions, you really are lacking basic inteligence
Fantastic documentary
The AI voice is really offputting. Although I'm sure the information is good, I had to turn this off.
Great work!
Thanks! Hope you enjoyed!
The 4th Crusade was the single most stupid mistake in the history of medieval Europe. Christians attacking Christians for petty reason giving the opportunity to a foreign aggressive power with a different religion and culture to capture and hold one of the gates of the continent. A mistake that still today Europe finds itself locked into...no no. Letting Constantinople in ruins and giving such opportunity to the Turks! Terrible terrible affair
Haha don't cry Constantinople is muslim city 4 ever i feel sorry for you
Years ago I thought the same way. Then I dug into the detailed history, the stuff that TV shows and most videos ignore. The Eastern Roman Emperor had a long history of back-stabbing, making false promises and selling out the crusaders to the Muslim forces so they could be attacked. This started with the First Crusade and did not improve over time.
Quite frankly I'm amazed the Western forces put up with the crap from Constantinople for so long, before giving them the severe smackdown they richly deserved. Constantinople was an enemy pretending to be a friend. With friends like that you don't need bloodthirsty enemies.
Correction: Benedictines never had a vow of poverty. Their three vows are Obedience (to their Abboy and superriors), Stability (meaning the monastery they join is where they will live forever. They do not go from place to place. Friars do that. Friara sre not monks), anc Conversion of morals. The last assumes a life of chastity. Benedictines "hold all things in common."
ChatGPT and AI voiceover... Absolutely scandalous that this classifies as good content now... Minimum effort put in 🙄
I need a notebook.. a lot of info here , excellent work
Hope it was helpful!
Ai voice!?
This video is a important remenber of The history and tell me the kights for me they have honor a friend this a friend in good and bad times, wandfull history ,thank you!😊
Came here expecting this to be a video from Vladimir Putin.
Very good presentation.
Glad you liked it!
This would be MUCH better if a human was talking rather than AI. It hard to follow without natural pauses. Please use humans to narrate.
It's not "AI". Get with it. It's a text to speech program.
Get used to it
@@atlantic_loveRegardless of what program was used it is not a pleasant listen. If the channel always uses this style of audio it's hindering it's following.
@@TecunLegion Agreed that it's not pleasant, but this AI THIS AI THAT needs to stop. This veiled pushing of AI isn't fooling anyone.
@@GreatWhiteClips "more gooder" 😭😭😭😭
Best documentary ever.
Stop fighting over religion .
Stop fighting over science your new religion. Silly lib
Tell RELIGIONS to stop fighting.
@@stutzbearcat5624tell everybody, Christianity is the only true religion..
@@stutzbearcat5624but yeah there, shouldn’t be any religions fighting..
My dude religion is just a pretext for the warring that is part of human nature. Thinking it would be good to get rid of all the religion is exactly that pretext to start another war
Absolutely brilliant vid! Any way we can download the thumbnail photo? Would love it on my desktop background
AI voiceover 👎🏻
...excellent, truly well done...
Thank you! I’m glad you liked it!
Another terrible AI voice over thats just horrible to listen to