IDK - Is He Real? ALBUM REVIEW
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024
- Listen: • IDK - 42 Hundred Choic...
Many of the songs on Is He Real? are either too underdeveloped or lacking in a distinct voice to capitalize fully on the fundamentals and promising concept IDK brings to the table.
More rap reviews: • Hip Hop Reviews
Buy this album if you dig it: amzn.to/2Qaged6
===================================
Subscribe: bit.ly/1pBqGCN
Patreon: / theneedledrop
Official site: theneedledrop.com
TND Twitter: / theneedledrop
TND Facebook: / theneedledrop
Support TND: theneedledrop.c...
===================================
FAV TRACKS: 24, PORNO, NO CABLE, DIGITAL, JULIA...
LEAST FAV TRACK: EUROPEAN SKIES
IDK - IS HE REAL? / 2019 / WARNER / CONSCIOUS HIP HOP, POP RAP, TRAP
6/10
Y'all know this is just my opinion, right?
6/10 like MBDTF?? Must be an instant classic.
THIS IS THE RIGHT TAKE
Mbdtf is overrated
@@BraceInc yo mama
BraceInc still not a fucking light 6
Shut up
I don’t know either, Melon. Why don’t you tell me who he is?
FeLeS STATION_bus stop if ur not gonna contribute to the conversation with valuable information that please keep out of it
How are we meant to know if he is real if we dont even know who he is?
Jonas B no who’s on first
Or if hes real
He is real because he doesn't know, as holding knowledge means he exists, but he's not even sure he actually does exist.
Yes, Anthony, he is real. That’s how you’re reviewing his album. Silly Melon.
l m a o
y e e t
m e l o n
He’s so dumb lmao he doesn’t even know if IDK actually exists hahahaaahahah
But who is it
Fav Tracks: Porno
....Bold of you to think you could just throw in one of your personal interests like we wouldn’t notice.
And it's 24 non-cable digital pornos of julia!!!
The meme of anthony being a sex maniac has gone full circle.
Porno was in his fav tracks of Reflektor (Arcade Fire) as well
Porn is great
Luca Bonasio it’s a good song but I’m gonna pretend like he’s just randomly reminding us that he’s into porn
Melon Porn
i apologize for liking the album anthony please please just let my family go
“These bloggers giving me 6’s but my confidence say 100”
I'm just glad this at least got a full review
good work saving the artic nathan!
Same
anthony fantano is my grimy waifu
Free the Fantano
Anthony Fantano uses thot tactics to counter FADER slander
uh double bacon uh
take these melons from me das my oo, ooh
Anthony stop jogging by my house in that tracksuit, my mother said she doesn't want to see you anymore.
Your mother is lying to you.
“Anymore”
"Look, look. . She bendin over"
😂😂😂😂😂😂
THESE FUCKING COMMENT SECTIONS LMFAO
Sorry Melon, I’ve already formed my opinion on this album, better luck next time
I haven't!
@@cripwalker665 Your opinion does not matter.
@@shuteye2702 No one's opinion matters
Agreed
Alright time to retire this joke
Anthony you didn't have to squat throughout the whole video man.
Insightful review while motivating people to live a healthy lifestyle?
Unsubscribed.
he slav
His real name is Anatoly Fontanov
IDK - *exists*
Melon - “KENDRICK”
Release your review for All My Heroes Are Cornballs by MC Ride
ND Freak Nav?
McBigForeheadMan
MC Receding Hairline
Taha Kamran do you mean buttermilk jesus?
Bruj
Wow Melon, asking if black people can be real is pretty racist
As a black guy myself, Melon has been racist since who knows how many times he said the N word.
Legion Vision Nagger?
Mak7even No it rhymes with jigga.
Legion Vision bigga?
HE LITERALLY SAID IDK THAT'S SO FUCKED UP MAN IT'S A YES OR NO ANSWER
I’m sorry, I’ve aready formulated my own opinion on this album. It’s a 10
Tud 💯
Same
os terminal I can’t stop listening, my fav hip hop album of 2019
Not sure about 10 but a solid 8.5 I’d say
Easily a 10, currently my favorite album
I’m not sure I like how much that shirt is hugging you Mr. melon. 6/10
Light 9 for me. This album is so catchy and it struck a cord with me personally. I feel all of your points are justified tho. But for this album none of the "flaws" stuck out to me. It was easy to look past it cuz of the loads of fun this album is to listen to and sing along to.
Read what the first letter of every track spells out!
So everyone who reviews music is just gonna give this a 6/10
SanFranFan30 must be the correct score then
Shawn & Anthony did so yeah pretty much
@@fluhmix6786 HUH?
@@lanting.j.16 so did pitchfork
I mean a 6 is still a positive score so eh
Was getting worried that I might have to form my own opinion on this one, phew thanks Melon
Great review and all but you didn't have to repeatedly say this album would be a 10/10 if his name was IDKKK instead
dele alli underrated comment😂
it’s the way IDK called this review out on his new album for me lol
On which song?
@@kudak8162 Dogs Don’t Lie.
“I feel the bad reviews comin’
These bloggers givin’ me sixes, my confidence say a hundred”
I think Pitchfork also gave it a 6.
"The album cover really represents his past life as a slave"
That was uncalled for señor Anthony.
L
Anthony's standards for a good rap album:
1. Must be a concept album
2. CANNOT take any inspiration from any other artists, especially not Kendrick Lamar
3. Must be a Kendrick Lamar album.
And here we have the male melon, doing his monthly prayer to Kendrick Lamar.
😂
Woah melon saying he’s as real your sex life was a bold statement.
Typho, go edit your comment now.
IDK why you keep ignoring my letters Anthony, I thought we were pen pals??
There probably was a problem at the lost office or somethin
stan
@@Blueissuperior stanthony badtano
I'm already liking the new jpegmafia album. Better hurry up before i form my own opinion.
Flash back, cantaloupe dash
Flash back, cantaloupe dash
Flash back, cantaloupe dash
FLASH BACK, CANTALOUPE DASH
I listened to the album yesterday. I didn't skip a single track everything was deliberate thoughtful and just beautiful. It's my favorite album of the year !!!
Read what the first letter of every track spells out!
Thanks for the review but you really gotta do your research and find out these artist names
You should review that new Kendrick Lamar album! To Pimp a WaterMelon.
04 L
this deserves a 10/10, melon youre wrong
edit: nvm probably an 8 idk what i was thinking
edit 2: ok it’s been two years and my music taste is very different but i just came back to the album and it’s got some great tracks, but december is one of the best songs i’ve ever heard
Read what the first letter of every track spells out!
I’m disappointed that this isn’t a JPEGMAFIA - AMHAC review
Decent 9, or maybe a strong one perhaps?
lauri valkila It just came out tho, most likely review on monday
lauri valkila I thought this worked the other way around. So would have to be "pleasantly surprised"
AOTY for sure
i didn't like the jpegmafia album
I personally thought this was a 7.5-8, but its fine cuz its your opinion
NOPE MELON DOESN'T GET AWAY WITH THIS ONE!
This is a respectable review. Very underrated artist. I look forward to deeing what he comments. IDK always gives good responses.
Woah melon why did you [insert random offensive thing]?
I don’t know if Melon realizes how much it would piss IDK off to be compared to Logic
He is real anthony, and you should review his latest album "all my heroes are cornballs"
Sunny Enno Good looking fiya ass album from the music to the transition & sequence the in btw distorted commentary well placed for someone that never heard of him & this being the introduction for a new up & comer I’m impressed & highly recommend a pow wow to this it’s layered with so many elements great listen & musical experience
4 years later and all I can say is this album is a masterpiece. First album that I had a truly cathartic experience listening to
Read what the first letter of every track spells out!
@@CryptedCodes bro wut are you talking about
i like it when you review songs from albums and go over them one by one leading to a conclusion on what you thought about the overall album and what you would give it out of 10.
This album is a solid 7 for me
I'm still stoked to give it a listen. He's put out solid material over the past year or so.
Great video Anthony, but while I do vehemently love & respect you, i disagree. for me personally this is a strong 8/10
Read what the first letter of every track spells out!
@@CryptedCodes what?
no mention of Michael What TF? honestly one of the strongest songs on the album and its an amazing precursor to Julia which you def enjoyed a lot
great video but i could use a review of All My Heroes Are JPEGMAFIA by Cornballs
This whole album connected song to song in a way only Kendrick has achieved that I know of anyways but made me appreciate this album tremendously
USEE4YOURSELF needs a review Anthony, IDK’s best work yet
This album was genuinely more enjoyable than Earthgangs though.
Popping Clutch yes it was
@Popping Clutch it is EG is good but they dont flow well plus most of IHR? from IDK is short.
definitely not
both should’ve been a 7/10
Earthgang’a album was not worth that long wait they was doing for Mirror land. Just the Cover alone was horrible, felt like they had so much time that they changed so much of the album and added newer cuts to it last minute to the due date. Legit 2 good songs max, IDK’s album was enjoyable from start to finish. Even tho he also lost a-lot of the original work when his laptop fell in the pool it wasn’t like it was rushed, didn’t feel rushed every song was well thought out(not saying earthgangs album wasn’t)but the songs weren’t anything special to say their previous EPS. IDK’s album was an album I could listen to on any day and any mood. Earthgang album I had to force myself to listen to it. Thank you for the time🙏🏽🌎
I think this deserves higher than a 6 the production on this album was crazy but I know he’s gonna come out with something better in the future because he sees these reviews and takes the criticism to make his next project better
That adidas jacket cold cold🥶🥶
If someone asked me the most underrated album, I would say this
7/10 for me, I like when i can listening to album with a story behind it instead of an album that only give me singles or throwaways that i would skip in a heartbeat.
i think he just dissed you on the new album
Updated opinion on this? It’s grown on me so much
good review but probably didn't have to mention that you think drakes kid is his ghost writer and thats why he keeps him out of the lime light
🍈 Needle Drop Scores 2k19: 💉
💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥
10/10: 0
9/10: 6 ( *Lingua Ignota - Caligula* Otoboke Beaver - Itekoma Hits, Tyler, The Creator - IGOR, Weyes Blood - Titanic Rising , Little Simz - Grey Area, Xiu Xiu - Girl with Basket of Fruit)
8/10: 28
7/10: 28
6/10: *37*
5/10: 16
4/10: 10
3/10: 6 (Drake - Care Package, Pi'erre Bourne - TLOP 4, Jaden Smith - ERYS, Steve Lacy - Apollo XXI , Maggie Rogers - Heard it in the Past Life, Mac DeMarco - Here Comes the Cowboy)
2/10: 1 (Gunna 💧 - Drip or Drown 2)
1/10: 3 (Vic Mensa, - 93PUNX, Miley Cyrus - She is Coming EP, Logic - Confessions of a DANGEROUS Mind)
*ZERO/10:* (Chance The Rapper - The Big Day)
*NOT GOOD:* 6 ( Trippie Redd - !, Ed Sheeran, AJR - Neotheater, NAV - Bad Habits, Logic - Supermarket DJ Khaled - Father of Asahd)
_-Note: Not Goods have no score, only reviewed as intended for a listen._
69/10: 1 (guess, and it ain't 6ix9ine!!!)
BLARF/10 - (Blarf - Cease & Desist)
Misc: Peppa Pig First Album
There have been *144* reviews this year. *Final Verdict: IDK EITHER
If you think I have made a mistake, let me know and I'll fix it right away. Thanks for reading. 👍👍
Worked so hard for nothin
You would have Given this album a 10/10 if it was IGOR by Tyler, the creator smh
"I love the theme of blind sex hunger" is something Anthony has said
Hey Anthony, great review but I think the bit where you caressed pictures of my dad whispering "Is He Real?" was slightly unnecessary
Great review I love your videos keep up the good work, one day you’ll be great 👌👌
Personally felt like 7, though due to IDK being a cornball on some occasions - I approve the 6
I’m not sure you would even like it cause we have completely diff taste....But I like learning of new music & sharing if I’m in love. I didn’t really know of her that much before this album, but the new Sizzy Rocket GRRRL album is pretty stellar. Not a bad song on it. Give it a try even if u hate it cause Tattoos is worth it alone..... Speaking of, I did enjoy Alone off of this.
Burna boy came through on "December"
You're exquisite at explaining your thoughts.
Nice review Anthony! But you didn’t have to say that the album cover was unrealistic as the black man wasn’t chained up to a pole and shot dead.
Julia hits hard, especially with the instrumentals
Yo when is the review for USEE4YOURSELF coming out we need it
This is a good review melon and I share a lot of similar thoughts on this one. You mentioned you liked most of the tracks on here but still came away kind of ehhhh. And that’s exactly how I felt especially after how much I loved IWASVERYBAD. This is definitely a good album, but it’s almost frustrating to listen to because IDK is sooooo close to doing something really special. I have faith that the best IDK album is yet to come
IDK if this review is real melon.
When tf is the US4Y REVIEW MAN
You're too late, I already fo...
You know the rest
...forgot to listen to it on the day it dropped, because I had a bunch of homework to do for university. Luckily, I streamed it on the commute to school the next day. Pretty solid stuff! Can't wait to hear what you think, man!
More like light 9
Back to back yellow flannel incoming for Peggy and Charlie XCX
facts
charli tho ***
Wait a minute this isn’t the AMHAC review
The comment section is always the best parts of your videos but your videos are also great
Not Gonna lie this review was a surprise to me I was expecting a 8-9 from Fantano. This album was fantastic and it gets better with each listen. IDK your album was amazing. 9.2-10 Top 3 album of this year.
I don't know either, Anthony. I'm scared.
I saw him in 2016 on Isaiah Rashad's lil sunny tour and thought he had a unique sound. Glad he really came into his own on this
Well, is he? Idk.
This album is phenomenal... listen for yourself... make your own decision
can’t wait for peggy’s 10
When 42 Hundred Choices came up, I got ptsd flashbacks of Hot Shower. Hold me melon 🍈 ❤️
I fucking hate this comment section... at least talk bout the album, not some played out jokes
Ben Varney you right my friend i hate them super memeish white boys too
Ight... I’m heading out, Whatchu want from Costco?
Yo get me a fuckin' Root Beer
bean
Hot cheetos to choke on em like Lil Xan
Ik AMHAC just came out, but i need you to review it immediately
I understand not seeing the full concept of the album and completely agree with your critiques but based on how many tracks you enjoyed vs how many you did not it should be at least a light 7
SubTrap and Empty Bank were fantastic. I’d say this definitely isn’t as good as those two, but better than most other music out right now.
Melon looking swaggy in the baby blue
Never thought I needed to learn my ABCs until my wallet salesman told me otherwise
Am I the only one annoyed of all the meme comments? Like can anybody add something to the conversation? Guess not lmao
melon lookin mighty fine in that adidas jacket
IDK how to feel about this.
Once you're done with the big names, are you going to review the new glass beach album, "the first glass beach album"?
Honestly, I think of this album more as an 8 or 9, it's fun and interesting to listen to
Read what the first letter of every track spells out!
I liked this album a lot although I did notice some of the strong Kendrick influences in this album it didn’t really bother me cause that’s my favorite rap artist and I’d rate this album a solid 7 out of ten only cause I wish it was longer and I agree with you Anthony the concepts in this album were definitely not talked about properly
Papi I missed you
its clear IDK is surrounded by yes men
Looking forward to the Charli XCX Review
Its at least an 8 if not a 10, this whole review seems very much surface level and not fully thinking out the lyricism of IDK
I was waiting for this!