National treasures I grew up with and was blessed to see preform in the seventies. Their music still informs me to this day. Three voices that blend this perfectly rarely find each other
This is a spectacularly uncoordinated arrangement and they seem out of sync with each other. Perhaps they are better without Neil Young, but I'm not saying it's his fault here.
So glad all 4 of them lasted a Good Long While here on Earth making such Memorable Music. David, enjoy your acoustic guitars back home in Heaven... We Love You!
@Greg Normal GO AWAY !!!!! STOP trawling YT for females , creep !!!!! I may be male ....you creep me out !! This is the 2nd or 3rd time you have picked me out !! Go away ...I am a man....hahahahaha
Been listening to your music and thinking if you today brother David. Thank you for all the insight that you gave all us kids way back then. We miss and love❤ you. R.I.P. 🌹🙏
I remember the day Bill died. I had an appt across the city (san francisco); Cancelled it bc of traffic. Went to gg park instead. Great day of music and remembering the great Bill Graham
I lived in SF when I wasn't a teen - Got lost GG State Park. But finally made it out !! And Bill Graham -- The Energizer Bunny and The Keeper of Musical Memories. I saw him at a U2 concert he was barking orders of what and how it was supposed to go. !! I'd guess a Type A Personality for all of us that paid $$$ for a great show. Blessed to have Merch from the W. Vault .
roanna, you lucky dickens. I'm sort of jealous that so many people got to see them live together, but I am happy for you that you had that experience. That had to be sooo amazing. ✌🤘❣❤
I was there. a somber day of reflection. I was honored to have met a few times and know aspects of Bill Graham when I was engineering a Rick Griffin art gallery back in 1991. Sixty members of his staff volunteered their time, energy, June 1 to inaugurate our Grand Opening. A total sense of dedication from those he picked to work closely around him. Then in Aug we lost Rick, a few months later went Bill. For some of us life just was never the same again.
Deej dawn-roxanne Over the years I inter-acted with Bill Graham upwards of a dozen times. All mine were positive energy. As Jerry Pompelli could attest I supplied the very last music artifact needed to re-complete the Bill Graham archives following the fire bombings in to the old BGP HQ down off around the 101 curve towards Army St It was the ultra rare Fillmore #7 handbill from 1966. Got it for a hundred, sold it to BGP for same via Jerry coming on down to my Haight at Masonic location circa 1990 or so. Jerry P made specific mention any one else would have soaked 500 for it then. It was NM/M white paper. When I began engineering the multi-levels towards our Rick Griffin Art Gallery thru first half of 91 BGP solicited our business for matting and framing. More meetings and such. Seemed near every one there was in awe of Rick Griffin. Most of the meetings were Bill, Rick and this lowly lost soul. Sure were fun times and many excellent memories.
Sorry, but I disagree. This version is horrible. The guitars dont match in volume and are completely out of the pocket, the electric guitar is not properly tuned, the arrangement is really bad - it sounds like a school band. Bad showmanship and not really rehearsed.
Dieser Song hat mein ganzes Leben begleitet. Ich bin mit ihm aufgewachsen, er hat mich als Erwachsener inspiriert, ich werde mit ihm gehen ... Die unterschiedlichen Versionen widerspiegeln auch die Etappen meines Daseins.
Yay 1991 Golden gate park! Can you believe they are planning some kind of crazy ass event down there this weekend with how many thousands of people in this kind of crazy environment? No thank you very much I will sit right here relaxing and watching Neil and the boys do it. Hey Neil if you are listening I made a video today figuring out how to play drums that totally reminded me and cracked me up of you figuring out how to do the harmonica and being a one-man band when you looked like you were about 12 or so... A look that I have kind of held on to for myself personally... I hope you get to see some of my stuff one day but for now hey hey My My Rock and Roll will never die!! ❤😂🎉😊
I want to disagree with most of these comments.I am 70 years old and remember the 60's ....seeing this performance under the California sun on a cool fall day in 1991 was like stepping out of a time machine to that moment in time,,to see four of the legends of rock, country/folk up on that stage( in middle age) knocking out a CSN legendary song playing classic Martin acoustic guitars and a Fender Telecaster..all together in front of that great crowd..who cares if a guitar was a little out of tune or if Stills cranked his telecaster some..it was cool as hell, that stage performance kicked ass.and the camera/editing work was great..none of that jerk, jerk ,jerk editing in modern rock videos or performances..watch that on a big computer screen or HD Television, crank up the sound and it was like you had gone back in time and were right there in the audience! It was awesome seeing those legends perform together live with that great crowd spread out in the park..Wish I could have been there! Grahm Nash stole the show,, man he's good!
correction and discipline are good for children, if a child has his own way, he will make his mother ashamed of him. Proverbs 29:15 . Train up a child in the way he should go , for when he grows old he will not depart from it Proverbs 6:15. Children must always obey their parents for that pleases the Lord . Colossians 3:20
Was 19 when CNY was released. Everyone went crazy for them. No accounting for taste, they say. I never was a fan- just didn't get it. Years later, 'Southern Cross' was a favorite.
Lord, please let Croz know how much we loved him and his music, like the song;🎶"Keep Your Children Well"🎶because your Son Jesus loved the little children, all the children of the world. May David Crosby be🎸playing in peace in the🕊Angels Choir and his music "Carry On" forevermore. Amen 19.01.2023 🇨🇦✌🏻🎶💔(+🇺🇦)✨🌎💫
THE FEELING WAS THERE BUT THE USUAL HARMONY HAS CAME TO BITE THEIR BACKSIDES UNFORTUNATELY.BEST TO REMEMBER THEM AS THE ONCE GREAT AND INFLUENCIAL SUPER GROUP THEY USED TO BE!
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
An Era is over DAVID CROSBY IS NO MORE
Let's rejoice that we got to see and experience the genius of this man
Love and peace
Just saying 🇧🇻
As teenagers we so looked up to these magnificent musicians....such a time, such a time, so different than today. LOVE, they gave us heart and wings!
RIP David Crosby. Tanx for your art.
National treasures I grew up with and was blessed to see preform in the seventies. Their music still informs me to this day. Three voices that blend this perfectly rarely find each other
Happy birthday, David. Watching on his birthday in 2022.
This is a spectacularly uncoordinated arrangement and they seem out of sync with each other. Perhaps they are better without Neil Young, but I'm not saying it's his fault here.
I LOVE Them. The harmonies, the lyrics...I just love them! The best music ever was from the 60's, 70's and 80's!!!
70's were the Best...
what's with the "80s"?
Voices of Our Generation!! Bravo!
Take me back to this time.......Please........
So glad all 4 of them lasted a Good Long While here on Earth making such Memorable Music. David, enjoy your acoustic guitars back home in Heaven... We Love You!
I used to play this to remember how to parent. I’m still learning.
Does it get any better than this! Thank you for sharing this Timeless wonderful music from Patrick
It actually does. The mix sucks and this rendition is just average. Still great music though
@@DanielC__
Nonsense
This brings back lovely memories of my youth ...what a great song !!
It’s live and they’re older.
@@veronicaherrera7586 I can see that
@@veronicaherrera7586 I can see that
@Greg Normal GO AWAY !!!!! STOP trawling YT for females , creep !!!!! I may be male ....you creep me out !! This is the 2nd or 3rd time you have picked me out !! Go away ...I am a man....hahahahaha
One of my all-time favorite songs. Top 5 for sure.
Been listening to your music and thinking if you today brother David. Thank you for all the insight that you gave all us kids way back then. We miss and love❤ you. R.I.P. 🌹🙏
A great life celebrated. Goodbye David Crosby. January 20, 2023.
I remember the day Bill died. I had an appt across the city (san francisco); Cancelled it bc of traffic. Went to gg park instead. Great day of music and remembering the great Bill Graham
I lived in SF when I wasn't a teen - Got lost GG State Park. But finally made it out !! And Bill Graham -- The Energizer Bunny and The Keeper of Musical Memories. I saw him at a U2 concert he was barking orders of what and how it was supposed to go. !! I'd guess a Type A Personality for all of us that paid $$$ for a great show. Blessed to have Merch from the W. Vault .
Wish could be here 2022
Hey I was at this concert!!! We were about 1/4 way in from the stage. Good seats, good concert, good people
I just looked up the rest of the lineup - WOW.
Is Neil Fried here? David checkin him out as well.
roanna, you lucky dickens. I'm sort of jealous that so many people got to see them live together, but I am happy for you that you had that experience. That had to be sooo amazing. ✌🤘❣❤
Thanks for the music that raised us .😃✌
So good to hear
I was there. a somber day of reflection. I was honored to have met a few times and know aspects of Bill Graham when I was engineering a Rick Griffin art gallery back in 1991. Sixty members of his staff volunteered their time, energy, June 1 to inaugurate our Grand Opening. A total sense of dedication from those he picked to work closely around him.
Then in Aug we lost Rick, a few months later went Bill.
For some of us life just was never the same again.
Robert Beerbohm sorry to hear that!! but you have a wonderful memory of him, them..
Deej dawn-roxanne Over the years I inter-acted with Bill Graham upwards of a dozen times. All mine were positive energy. As Jerry Pompelli could attest I supplied the very last music artifact needed to re-complete the Bill Graham archives following the fire bombings in to the old BGP HQ down off around the 101 curve towards Army St
It was the ultra rare Fillmore #7 handbill from 1966.
Got it for a hundred, sold it to BGP for same via Jerry coming on down to my Haight at Masonic location circa 1990 or so. Jerry P made specific mention any one else would have soaked 500 for it then. It was NM/M white paper.
When I began engineering the multi-levels towards our Rick Griffin Art Gallery thru first half of 91 BGP solicited our business for matting and framing. More meetings and such. Seemed near every one there was in awe of Rick Griffin. Most of the meetings were Bill, Rick and this lowly lost soul. Sure were fun times and many excellent memories.
Favorite songs
RIP David 😥💗
Wonderful song for ever.
I agree really bad...love the song...
I love 💕😘 this music 🎶🎵🎶🎵 awesome!!
Now this is a song!!!!!!
Timeless
In my humble opinion..there cannot be a bad version of this beauty-full song.
amen to that.
Sorry, but I disagree. This version is horrible. The guitars dont match in volume and are completely out of the pocket, the electric guitar is not properly tuned, the arrangement is really bad - it sounds like a school band. Bad showmanship and not really rehearsed.
Wow verry nice
Fueron sencillamente maravillosos e irrepetibles
Great Song!
A wonderful song, forever meaningful! We need to get back to the unity of that time and stop all of the divisive hate that so permeates our society.
Dieser Song hat mein ganzes Leben begleitet.
Ich bin mit ihm aufgewachsen, er hat mich als Erwachsener inspiriert, ich werde mit ihm gehen ...
Die unterschiedlichen Versionen widerspiegeln auch die Etappen meines Daseins.
One of my guides un bringing up my kids..
They are great
This music early make me understand the world. Thank's to this four guys!
Amazing guitar song!!!
I love them too
ALWAYS, ALWAYS, ALWAYS tune before you play
Oh yeah One of my favorite song thanks
Thinking of you as always but especially today. I love you so much 💚💚💚💚💚
I was there that day tripping on mushrooms in honey floating in a big permasmile. It was AWESOME.
Wow in 1991? Sounds like you grew up.
r.i.p. david crosby
MAGNIFICO MUSIC
RIP David Crosby .
I love it!
Classic CSN&Y. 🇺🇲 ❤
EXCELENTEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Very nice 😊😊😊😊😊
Awesome.
カッコイイ！。
RIP Graham Nash
Yay 1991 Golden gate park! Can you believe they are planning some kind of crazy ass event down there this weekend with how many thousands of people in this kind of crazy environment? No thank you very much I will sit right here relaxing and watching Neil and the boys do it. Hey Neil if you are listening I made a video today figuring out how to play drums that totally reminded me and cracked me up of you figuring out how to do the harmonica and being a one-man band when you looked like you were about 12 or so... A look that I have kind of held on to for myself personally... I hope you get to see some of my stuff one day but for now hey hey My My Rock and Roll will never die!! ❤😂🎉😊
FOREVER YOUNG
love you
I want to disagree with most of these comments.I am 70 years old and remember the 60's ....seeing this performance under the California sun on a cool fall day in 1991 was like stepping out of a time machine to that moment in time,,to see four of the legends of rock, country/folk up on that stage( in middle age) knocking out a CSN
legendary song playing classic Martin acoustic guitars and a Fender Telecaster..all together in front of that great crowd..who cares if a guitar was a little out of tune or if Stills cranked his telecaster some..it was cool as hell, that stage performance kicked ass.and the camera/editing work was great..none of that jerk, jerk ,jerk editing in modern rock videos or performances..watch that on a big computer screen or HD Television, crank up the sound and it was like you had gone back in time and were right there in the audience! It was awesome seeing those legends perform together live with that great crowd spread out in the park..Wish I could have been there! Grahm Nash stole the show,, man he's good!
I’m with you!!
Blame Crosby. Just kidding.
Wow! Can you imagine that?
HONOR THY LIFE!!!
correction and discipline are good for children, if a child has his own way, he will make his mother ashamed of him. Proverbs 29:15 . Train up a child in the way he should go , for when he grows old he will not depart from it Proverbs 6:15. Children must always obey their parents for that pleases the Lord . Colossians 3:20
They played an acoustic set the night before at the Shoreline. of course the sound was better there. I was lucky to be at both shows.
I was at both too! What an amazing 24 hours that was!
✌🏼❤️🎶
The best américain groupe Very culte
more power
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Need for this songs Crosby stills thankyou. Iran
✨!!!
When they were still civil.
Wow!! I was there,and I didnt think it was THAT bad🤣
me too
Love this video
sinceramente maravilloso pocas veses se les ha visto a estos 4 grandes musicos juntos
Love their harmonies
beautiful
Un pezzo autentico della storia del rock
hermoso registro y algo raro es muy dificil ver a estos 4 grandes en vivo y mas encima juntos
Look at Mother Nature on the Run in the nineteen seventies . 45 years later she's still hangin in .
WOW ,,,,,,,, your right that was hard
good afternoon my friend neil young when are you and stills, nash, and you going to do a tribute concert for david crosby here too
Graham Nash didn't get fast and disgusting. Love that guy-- respect
And I have the guitar that was used to practice the tune !!!
Kudos to the engineer who mixed this.
(I can tell it was MESS!)
I turn into tears when i hear teach your children, coz' i dont acheiv my part.
Then they’ll just have to teach you. You’re doing fine
However much I love them, this really hurts.
Meu amigo Beraldo ai nests Terr quente c esta Grande pedra *bituruns c o riobd9ce.
Sao velhoeg+ dao muoto home.
この曲は、小さな恋のメロディに挿入させていましたね。懐かしいです。
vejo quanto os usa mudaram nestes 30 anos
Was 19 when CNY was released. Everyone went crazy for them. No accounting for taste, they say. I never was a fan- just didn't get it. Years later, 'Southern Cross' was a favorite.
Grate musician
Just BRILLIANT 😄🤠
Should of lit up a spliff, yeah baby 😍
No kidding!
The only member appearing interested in performing the song was Graham Nash.
Grandi
Lord, please let Croz know how much we loved him and his music, like the song;🎶"Keep Your Children Well"🎶because your Son Jesus loved the little children, all the children of the world.
May David Crosby be🎸playing in peace in the🕊Angels Choir and his music "Carry On" forevermore.
Amen
19.01.2023
🇨🇦✌🏻🎶💔(+🇺🇦)✨🌎💫
Madrid febrero 2024
I think it’s great hearing more of David voice, but clearly they didn’t have a good sound check, cuz you mostly heard the guitar
THE FEELING WAS THERE BUT THE USUAL HARMONY HAS CAME TO BITE THEIR BACKSIDES UNFORTUNATELY.BEST TO REMEMBER THEM AS THE ONCE GREAT AND INFLUENCIAL SUPER GROUP THEY USED TO BE!
James Sim energy has to be transmitted and that's how we live
The sound man can make you or break you. This one was paid too much
I'll give them an F for this one.
But best was the first version. I heard whem i was teeangers years ago.
Sorely miss Jerry Garcia’s pedal steel licks and fills.
doesnt hurt me much , woodstock 1969
definitely past their prime
But not dead ( yet ) as of now 🥳🤓☺️😉😉😉😉
No this is only 1991 and they've done great performances since. Just a really bad day.