This Wasn't A Good Week For Gaming

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @roberttaylr
    @roberttaylr Год назад +130

    Kinda Funny had ZERO problem covering Xbox, Capcom, and Rockstar leaks in the past. Their hypocrisy is the only reason they're getting hate

    • @idionisio
      @idionisio Год назад +2

      Just curious. Did you watch their video or just basing it off of their thumbnail or what everyone has been saying? They talked about it for nearly 15 minutes. Are people upset that they didn’t talk about it enough?

    • @jaimegarcia767
      @jaimegarcia767 Год назад +20

      ​@idionisio found the pony, how's the pony dust today? My stuff ain't hitting 🤣😭

    • @roberttaylr
      @roberttaylr Год назад +14

      @@idionisio I watched the video, I didn't think it was a good explanation at all.

    • @RubMySweatyThighs
      @RubMySweatyThighs Год назад +5

      That reason is a joke @@idionisio

    • @jefurihartono1630
      @jefurihartono1630 Год назад +1

      ​@@idionisio their excuse is trash.

  • @jestahjava4255
    @jestahjava4255 Год назад +111

    You hit the nail on the head - there are actually much fewer gaming “journalists” than we really think.

    • @zackwarrington7272
      @zackwarrington7272 Год назад +4

      Duh, They are all mostly payed off. And have been for the longest time. Glad you finally see it now.

    • @bradbradson4543
      @bradbradson4543 Год назад +5

      Big eyeroll, there's lots of great gaming journalism, but most of it is ripped down by rabid gamers. That was gamers excuse for gamergate

    • @Adamtendo_player_1
      @Adamtendo_player_1 Год назад +3

      I think you mean there’s a fewer unbiased gaming journalists.

    • @chrisscott3071
      @chrisscott3071 Год назад +1

      ​@@bradbradson4543or this was what they were talking about. Gamimg journalism has been co opted for atleast 15 years

    • @ArtisChronicles
      @ArtisChronicles Год назад

      ​@@chrisscott3071 that's why I haven't paid attention to "gaming journalism" for a very long time. Took long enough for more people to notice though.

  • @hectortejeda2057
    @hectortejeda2057 Год назад +204

    This exposed the journalists of the industry to be nothing more than PR machines for the publishers.

    • @V4Now
      @V4Now Год назад +27

      We've suspected that for years (decades)

    • @Jahranimo_
      @Jahranimo_ Год назад +11

      It's been like this for a long time, even back to the 6th gen

    • @ilovecokeslurpees
      @ilovecokeslurpees Год назад +21

      And quite frankly a lot of RUclipsrs.

    • @anonymoushuman8443
      @anonymoushuman8443 Год назад +18

      Welcome to GamerGate

    • @Mrjonnyjonjon123
      @Mrjonnyjonjon123 Год назад +5

      @@ilovecokeslurpees yeah felt weird from an outsider perspective who hasn't played a lot of insomniac games hearing a different tone from the same youtubers who were less empathetic to other company leaks

  • @dookie_12
    @dookie_12 Год назад +248

    If someone isn’t honest enough to disclose a conflict of interest, you shouldn’t count on them to be honest about anything.

    • @roberttaylr
      @roberttaylr Год назад +14

      FACTS!

    • @NxtDoc1851
      @NxtDoc1851 Год назад +6

      Including Spawnwave. For years I've asked him if he's on MS payroll the way he regularly subliminally promotes game pass and seldom takes his subtle shots at Xbox, in the same way he does at Sony and Nintendo. And we just heard why...

    • @roberttaylr
      @roberttaylr Год назад +54

      @@NxtDoc1851 why is it so hard to believe he might just personally like gamepass and thinks it's a good deal?
      He's also talked plenty on how Microsoft can't seem to properly manage their studios or put out a great game.

    • @NxtDoc1851
      @NxtDoc1851 Год назад +7

      You're missing the subliminals. He's done it in an apologetic​ manner. Also, one does not prefer physical, dislike the "all digital future" inflated budgets, and like GP. They aren't mutally exclusive. He just said he's working more and more closely with MS @roberttaylr

    • @nappachief
      @nappachief Год назад +25

      ​@NxtDoc1851 huh? He definitely takes shots at Microsoft too. Between Games with Gold, he gave them crap when Halo Infinite launched, laughed at Redfall, etc. And Gamepass is a good value compared to PS Plus so where's the problem? Just because you don't see it doesn't mean he gets paid off. He's pretty fair towards all platforms compared to other creators.

  • @kboi1170
    @kboi1170 Год назад +9

    For anyone that missed it, the leaks showed that Sony:
    -Actively tried to get devs to fire workers
    -They did this despite Bungie only joining Sony for financial security
    -Insomniac is being pushed into the role of “Marvel games developer” for the next several years
    -Their AAA games are not as profitable as we were told, Shaun Layden said this several years ago but no one listened
    -Sony is planning on doing day and date releases on PC despite criticizing Xbox for doing it
    -PS exclusivity contracts with 3rd party companies can last weeelll over ten years.
    However, despite all of this news many RUclipsrs and media outlets refuse to cover these leaks

  • @Mike-sf7ex
    @Mike-sf7ex Год назад +85

    Games media will never be taken seriously until there is accountability. I see this whole Greg Miller thing as a positive sign towards that. Its the first I've seen of journalists calling each other out when for years all they've been doing is dismissing criticisms.

  • @Nintendo_Icons
    @Nintendo_Icons Год назад +27

    Lets be honest here. If Microsoft suffered a hack like this that outlined the next 10 years of their game development schedule and had a in development build of the next halo leaked. Nobody would have a problem talking about it. But because it’s Sony and PlayStation now all of a sudden it’s a problem.

  • @juicemanvon9859
    @juicemanvon9859 Год назад +49

    The biggest thing here is like you say: Consistency.
    Another thing is discernment. You cover the video game portion of the leaks, but you leave out peoples private information because that isnt news.

    • @aureliacortez3625
      @aureliacortez3625 Год назад +8

      Exactly it’s fine to cover the game leaks but people where looking at personal info bc it was their!

    • @pleasedontwatchthese9593
      @pleasedontwatchthese9593 Год назад +3

      I agree 100%. Leaking people's info could hurt that person long term. Leaking game info has not had much harm on a large studio before. Rockstar and Nintendo are still rich and making millions.

    • @fordgtguy
      @fordgtguy Год назад +1

      That's the thing, there is no outlet that is spreading any of the personal information from the leaks; they are discussing the parts of the leak that affect the gaming industry and the game in general.

    • @aweirdwombat
      @aweirdwombat Год назад

      I'm going to play devil's advocate even though I kind of agree with you. But doesn't that still encourage malicious actors to hack?
      I think the bigger is consistency. I suspect the gaming press was happy covering these stories when the leaks were smaller and happened less frequently. Now it's becoming harder to deny these are malicious actors causing real harm. But this is probably if the gaming press really cared about the victims they would have never covered this stuff in the first place.

  • @smush5653
    @smush5653 Год назад +65

    This week certainly exposed the Sony favouritism in the industry. If you don't cover leaks out of principle I can respect that but to previously cover leaks from other companies then refuse to cover a leak because it's Sony/Insomniac just shows you lack integrity despite you pretending otherwise.

  • @offspringfan89
    @offspringfan89 Год назад +135

    If this doesn't confirm these so called "gaming journalists" have a bias towards Sony, I don't know what does. The hypocrisy of these traditional outlets is yet another reason why I don't follow them and don't take critics' opinions into account. At this point the few medias I can say I really trust to be impartial are Spawn Wave and Digital Foundry.

    • @SweatyPotatoChip
      @SweatyPotatoChip Год назад +7

      Yes. Just like TGA has a bias towards Sony. Sony wins every year because they pay them to win.

    • @demi-fiendoftime3825
      @demi-fiendoftime3825 Год назад +17

      And the whole charity fraud scandal with the completionist killed my trust in a whole faction of gameing youtubers

    • @Vyyc-m9g
      @Vyyc-m9g Год назад +9

      ​@@SweatyPotatoChipSony has only won 2 GOTY awards at TGA...thats not a lot.

    • @dogg-paws
      @dogg-paws Год назад +2

      ​@@DragonHeart613 It's still a AAA game that's on a Sony platform. Sony is the kind of company that takes credit for third-party successes.

    • @maddo-hq9jr
      @maddo-hq9jr Год назад

      @@dogg-paws ... it's on XBox as well. But Sony wins? Maybe XBots want to loose.

  • @SeRiOuS1675
    @SeRiOuS1675 Год назад +41

    Jeff keelie friends with Kojima gets you 15 minutes screen time on game awards no interruptions 😂

    • @xephyrxero
      @xephyrxero Год назад +4

      It was pretty glaring just how much time that segment ate up, as while they started playing the wrap it up music like 30 seconds after the first winner got their award

  • @Ash_Yu
    @Ash_Yu Год назад +30

    I appreciate you being consistent in your own reporting, and for you and others pointing out the inconsistency in the industry. This is why, even if I was sick of Switch Pro rumors, I still come to your channel just about every morning. You do a good job spreading coverage about the whole industry. I'm sure you have your own biases like anyone else, and maybe some of your professionalism is because you don't have to worry about early review copies like other outlets, but overall your biases don't appear to get in the way of Spawn Wave as much as biases seem to interfere at other places.

    • @NuiYabuko
      @NuiYabuko Год назад +2

      His biases are showing hard as well. Perhaps stop putting people on pedestals.

    • @brandonfeliciano4746
      @brandonfeliciano4746 Год назад +4

      Maybe mind your own and simply watch a different channel if it bothers you that much?

  • @linkvagar2336
    @linkvagar2336 Год назад +114

    Actually, it's been great for gaming. It's shown how truly fucked and unsustainable the current AAA model is.
    Whether companies take these lessons and do anything about it is another thing entirely though.

    • @Mario123007
      @Mario123007 Год назад +8

      More like this shows western aaa gaming is just getting even worse, it's really time people should stop hyping up about these aaa western games and understand the vg companies more.

    • @derubor
      @derubor Год назад +9

      The AAA model isn't sustainable. There was a time when you got maybe 3 or 4 AAA per year, nowadays it's like every month there's a new AAA game.

    • @jimmythegamer2231
      @jimmythegamer2231 Год назад +7

      ​@@Mario123007 Western AAA gaming? Tf is up with that? You think inflating budgets of AAA games doesn't impact Japanese developers? Like with Spiderman 1 and 2, I would bet money that games like Resident Evil 4 Remake cost significantly more than Resident Evil 2 Remake due to how budgets are rising across the gaming industry.

    • @jimmythegamer2231
      @jimmythegamer2231 Год назад +2

      ​@@derubor Exactly, the AAA model isn't sustainable, especially if it's a singleplayer-only game with no microtransactions. In order to be sustainable in today's day and age, big budget AAA games require a source of recurring revenue, and that means microtransactions. But even then, though, a successful live service game can easily fall off and struggle the moment the quality of content decreased, as we see with Destiny 2.

    • @igotboredokay.2023
      @igotboredokay.2023 Год назад +4

      ​@@jimmythegamer2231No, what he is saying is that western aaa studios care less about the product they make, and more about profit.
      Just think about it, a new call of duty comes out every year and is considered to be a triple a game, while the remake of ff7 has been split into two games, with the other half coming out finally years after the first half. The issue with western developers is the push of a new game in the series per year, while eastern developers make sure the big games are good, most of the time

  • @Justin_Anime
    @Justin_Anime Год назад +48

    They would have been hypocrites either way BUT to GRANDSTAND after covering Xbox, Nintendo, Nvidia, Bethesda, Capcom, Suicide Squad, EVERY Ubisoft game, Rockstar, etc... To gleefully cover & profit from leaks for close to a decade & then talk about "ethics" while being featured in the video game you're White Knighting for... It's disingenuous & makes them look like complete scumbags imo.

    • @lemonlime8949
      @lemonlime8949 Год назад +6

      Insomniac workers and fans usually are. Genuinely pathetic.

  • @HaroldTheWizardCat
    @HaroldTheWizardCat Год назад +51

    You know it’s real serious when Spawn Wave has a thumbnail like that

    • @aureliacortez3625
      @aureliacortez3625 Год назад +10

      I think he’s the best game news channel that’s why I am subbed to him!

    • @jimmythegamer2231
      @jimmythegamer2231 Год назад +9

      ​@@aureliacortez3625 Agreed. Spawn Wave is like the most neutral guy ever, which is why his news channel is the best by far IMO.

    • @tanos857
      @tanos857 Год назад

      I almost mistaken Spawn Wave as ModernVintageGamer with that face 😮

  • @matthewhardwick8208
    @matthewhardwick8208 Год назад +52

    I'm just shocked that they were able to access employee information. Sony should face some form of sanction for failing to protect that private information.

    • @zybch
      @zybch Год назад +4

      And of course, this isn't the first (or second) time sony has has utterly failed at security of its staff, devs and users.

    • @chasejackson7248
      @chasejackson7248 Год назад +4

      The every company and the US government should, everyone gets hacked, someone will always be able to hack no matter the security a company has.

    • @daniellebackus819
      @daniellebackus819 Год назад +1

      My information was stolen in a hack several years back in the Veteran’s Affairs system. And now again through my health insurance. It happens a lot.

    • @dapperfan44
      @dapperfan44 Год назад +1

      ​@@mepe6809Blaming the victim, eh?

    • @propeldragon
      @propeldragon Год назад +1

      Can't stop someone on the inside. It's too easy.

  • @The_Meat_Man_81
    @The_Meat_Man_81 Год назад +16

    Xbox & Nintendo had a fine week. Sony is the one that is down bad

    • @Adamtendo_player_1
      @Adamtendo_player_1 Год назад +1

      Exactly, just because Sony didn’t have a good week doesn’t mean it was as bad week for everyone.

  • @Tacitus_kilgore_1903
    @Tacitus_kilgore_1903 Год назад +45

    The worst was dreamcastguy pretending covering it was unethical while simultaneously covering it in depth... such a joke

    • @Jay34k
      @Jay34k Год назад +9

      OOOOOOOHH

    • @maddo-hq9jr
      @maddo-hq9jr Год назад +1

      Well... it's so true.

    • @jordancromwell8267
      @jordancromwell8267 Год назад +1

      If you don't like the guy, why are you watching his videos? Makes no sense

    • @Iriseon
      @Iriseon Год назад +15

      @@jordancromwell8267what a slimy defense. The OP just summarized the ironic hypocrisy, never saying anything about not liking dreamcastguy.

    • @jordancromwell8267
      @jordancromwell8267 Год назад

      @iriseon go touch some grass you keyboard warrior. Jesus christ

  • @fordgtguy
    @fordgtguy Год назад +18

    If you are incapable of covering a studios news or game in a negative way due to a conflict of interest, they you sure as hell can't cover them in a positive way either.
    Kinda Funny just laid out that they can no longer be trusted to give any honest opinions about Insomniac, their games, or maybe even Sony as a company.

  • @HaroldTheWizardCat
    @HaroldTheWizardCat Год назад +67

    Skillup’s, RGT’s, and your response are the best I’ve seen so far. Too many people have built these strong connections with Sony and dont want to cover the news. I guess Sony created a type of social shield whether intentionally or unintentionally, but they’re benefiting from the limited press

    • @FabledFiend
      @FabledFiend Год назад +9

      Let's act like the industry/media doesn't protect Nintendo at all cost because they are the "industry darling"...

    • @Ash_Yu
      @Ash_Yu Год назад +1

      @@FabledFiend All the major early Nintendo game leaks get covered. In fact I remember some outlets even telling people where to illegally download Metroid Dread.

    • @Jay34k
      @Jay34k Год назад +25

      ​@@FabledFiendmuch deflecting? 😂

    • @noneofyourbusiness1998
      @noneofyourbusiness1998 Год назад +24

      ​@@FabledFiend You sound like a PS fanboy.....

    • @Ash_Yu
      @Ash_Yu Год назад +15

      It's definitely not an accident. Sony has always cared a lot about it's critical and media reception. We know this from other leaks and former employees that have come out over time. No early reviews would even talk about the bugs in Spiderman 2, despite many being found day 1. A lot of outlets were also quick to insist the Bungie layoffs had NOTHING to do with Sony, even though Sony is having layoffs at many other studios right now (none of which are getting nearly as much coverage) and it was Sony who set expectations for them and they're supposed to be responsible for helping Bungie now. Even indie darlings don't get this level of preference.
      It's not all the media's fault though. The fandom has been pretty bad towards anyone who reports on a story that doesn't paint Sony well. Reporters like Jason Schrier are all of a sudden just trying to stir up trouble if they talk about Sony. He and others have made posts about how hard it is to speak up against "certain companies" after a Sony story gets backlash. People on ResetEra even tried to ban a journalists for reporting on rumors that Japan Studio was going to be shut down. In fact the whole InstallBase / ResetEra split happened because Playstation trolls kept harassing others in the sales threads, all because they were upset the PS5 wasn't outselling the Switch in Japan. And the ResetEra mods actually went to the Playstation Discord to ENCOURAGE others to perpetuate the harrassment.

  • @chadcaughmann7898
    @chadcaughmann7898 Год назад +11

    Most games “journalists” have been on display for YEARS showing just how biased they are with their reporting. Whether being a mouthpiece for one company vs another, or chiming in on world/societal issues…these journalists have been showcasing their bias an hypocrisy for a LONG time.
    In other words, it’s the same ‘ol’ same ‘ol.

  • @PhotonxShockwave
    @PhotonxShockwave Год назад +35

    I think a problem for a lot of people were some news shows and journalists were saying "Hey were not gonna talk about the leaks" followed by grandstanding. Like your out here trying to pat yourself on the back for not doing something one time out of the hundreds of other times you did? Acting like your the bigger people out of all this and anyone else who reports on it is doing a disservice of some sort. They thought they were going to get claps and cheers but all it did in the end is now have a bunch of people questioning their character. Why was everyone else fine to report on but the line was drawn at Insomniac? A lot of people destroyed their own credibility over the past week.

  • @owellie
    @owellie Год назад +31

    Do whatever you want John. You are literally one of the most unbiased individuals in the RUclips gaming sphere. To you, information is information, and I along with many others respect you for that.

    • @Darkcomet222
      @Darkcomet222 Год назад +14

      John definitely has biases. He views Microsoft in a more favorable light. But guess what? That is FINE! It doesn’t stop him from covering and being critical of Microsoft. He is good at pushing past his biases and sharing the relevant information. He never shies away from doing anything from reporting.
      I think his coverage on all the leaks recently have been the perfect example. He talks about the relevant information, but never shows gameplay (like Wolverine or GTA VI) because he could get C&D’d, but he also doesn’t feel morally right with doing it.
      Spawn is the best game coverage I see because, despite his biases, he is ALWAYS professional.

    • @DS9TREK
      @DS9TREK Год назад +1

      There's no such thing as unbiased in news. Even the BBC can't achieve it. You're biased in what you report or don't report. You're biased in what your ignorance is towards.
      Like when Spawn misinforms his audience that Rockstar and Take Two got that 18 year old hacker sentenced to an indefinite hospital order. They didn't. They reported the crime, the Old Bill made the arrest, the Crown Prosecution Service made the case, and the judge used sentencing guidelines from His Majesty's Government to lay down the sentence.
      But Spawn doesn't tell you that. He tells you Rockstar and Take Two did it.

    • @NuiYabuko
      @NuiYabuko Год назад +1

      There's no such thing as an unbiased person, you just think there is based on if you agree with them or not.

    • @owellie
      @owellie Год назад +1

      @@NuiYabuko you're right

  • @wowgasp8670
    @wowgasp8670 Год назад +8

    That thumbnail lol looking like a teacher waiting for the class to be quiet

  • @derubor
    @derubor Год назад +19

    How some outlets and sites refuse to report on the Insomniac leak really puts the notion, that there is no pro Sony bias in games journalism, into question.

  • @TamalesDeRajas
    @TamalesDeRajas Год назад +72

    A lot of game journalists showed their hypocritical side when they decided not to cover the insomniac leaks even tho they hypocritically covered leaks recently like rockstar and capcom that also were crimes and had employee info. You really can’t trust journalists when they don’t do their job by covering the info for their readers just because they’re friends with the studio. It makes you think that they go easy on reviewing games from that studio because they’re friends with them, so even tho the game might be an 8/10, they’ll bump it up to a 9/10 just because of their relationship with that studio.

  • @impexxable
    @impexxable Год назад +12

    What I think? Now I know why I rock with you and your content. When I first find out about your channel years back to now, I've always thought you were solid.

  • @natalscar
    @natalscar Год назад +9

    The word for me is "hypocrisy"

  • @NintyPrime
    @NintyPrime Год назад +19

    Made a video on it myself, but yeah, it really bothered me watching these places treat this differently than everything else. Very hypocritical and yes, it has to be because they got too close to this particular company.
    I know some developers and have gotten copies of games, but if leaks at their company, no matter how obtained, land online and there is gaming relevant information that pertains to Nintendo, absolutely I’ll be covering it.
    It’s relevant to many conversations gamers want to be having. Not just info on new games and roadmaps - the budget stuff too as we saw in this hack.
    It’s wild the stance being taken. As you said, if the outlets just outright admitted they were too close to the situation to want to cover it, the conversation would then shift form the morality and irony of it all, more to “okay, we understand. So instead, we need to talk about if you should be that close”.
    Like was said in this video, it feels like in a way most journalists and media covering games about these massive companies should maybe have a more hands off approach. Like, more cynical even. Because if you aren’t doing that, you likely are encouraging some pretty bad practices.

    • @fordgtguy
      @fordgtguy Год назад +1

      This is more than just about a relationship with Insomniac, their relationship with Sony as an entity is in question too.

    • @NintyPrime
      @NintyPrime Год назад

      @@fordgtguy I questioned that in my video but, probably correct.

    • @Iriseon
      @Iriseon Год назад

      More “games journalists” need to study Gamers Nexus.

  • @Kapono5150
    @Kapono5150 Год назад +39

    The crazy part about this hack is how a insomniac employee didn’t know not to open suspicious emails

    • @ZygonCannar
      @ZygonCannar Год назад

      Suspicious emails have gotten a lot better now days, I work in IT and some look real, you'd only know if you haven't done business with them before. People think Phishing is some no brainer thing to avoid still, but it really isn't.

    • @dragonhero14
      @dragonhero14 Год назад +9

      All it takes is a nontechnical person to do that. Companies give employees yearly training on this, but I've seen even highly technical people not realize their laptop had been compromised and every time they connected to their company vpn, they were allowing hackers to gather and plan an attack. These companies are just going to lock things down and basically tell fans as little as possible.

    • @MikeGaruccio
      @MikeGaruccio Год назад +1

      Ok so I didn’t follow the details, but, phishing attacks can be super sophisticated and generally speaking one eventually gets through, especially when it’s actually normal for companies to work with partners for HR or payroll who send out emails on a regular basis that look shocking like a phishing attempt, and which are connected to their corporate logins, which conditions many employees to ignore warning signs.
      The bigger issue is when a companies security strategy involves never having anyone do something dumb, because eventually someone will. They need to have planned for that and an employee getting phished should be no big deal because there are other measures in place to prevent that one event turning into a massive leak.

  • @koiofokinawa
    @koiofokinawa Год назад +9

    I've always hated hackers and leakers, but its interesting to me that people are getting so uptight about it now that it's a Sony studio.

  • @djones1495
    @djones1495 Год назад +5

    Media and devs suddenly drawing the line at covering hacks when it comes to Insomniac, sure shows the weird double standard the industry has.

    • @chasejackson7248
      @chasejackson7248 Год назад

      No sure where you aren't looking, but I see every news outlet talking about it, just because they aren't delving into everything .

  • @xR3Dx0
    @xR3Dx0 Год назад +8

    Keep on journalising (not a word as far as my keyboard tells me) your literally my video version of a game informer that I get daily! Plus I can tell your a legit gamer by how many graphic tees I own that you also have lol keep it up man!

  • @nickw430
    @nickw430 Год назад +2

    It's ironic that an unfinished Wolverine game was leaked, considering an unfinished Wolverine film was leaked years ago. I don't recall many similar incidents of this size for either film or gaming. There's something about that Wolverine.

  • @Harold1986
    @Harold1986 Год назад +5

    I am glad with the leaks its shows sony lost its way with 100 dollar ganes, esg scores and hiring sweet baby inc for scrips. That makes my decisions to avoid these games that much easier

  • @yahyandanusa7834
    @yahyandanusa7834 Год назад +6

    It's chaos in the ponyland.. Sony fanboys and journalists alike. Birds of same feather flock together. Not surprising

  • @ExtraGloopy
    @ExtraGloopy Год назад +5

    So if news sites are conflicted on covering news because there is a conflict of interest…. that’s okay????
    I think it just shows that there is bias and favoritism at play. I don’t like it and I at the very least agree that they should be honest on why they won’t do certain things.

  • @tartellu5010
    @tartellu5010 Год назад +6

    Merry Christmas and happy holidays to everyone!

    • @jr2904
      @jr2904 Год назад

      Merry Christmas! And a Happy New Year

  • @KartKing4ever
    @KartKing4ever Год назад +2

    The Nintendo Giga Leak is different. That's actually been so helpful in terms of preservation. Something Nintendo doesn't necessarily seem to care about, beside for its main titles.

  • @sagepirotess6312
    @sagepirotess6312 Год назад +21

    Honestly you cant feel sorry for any company or government that gets hacked. Most dont invest in proper internet security, but will give millions to bonuses to CEO, or managment.

    • @Boss_Fight_Index_muki
      @Boss_Fight_Index_muki Год назад +12

      more precisely it's the board we shouldn't feel sorry for. but the company as a whole, comprising of thousands of individuals, some sympathy may be a good thing

  • @TheChudMuffin
    @TheChudMuffin Год назад +6

    So what you're saying is the games media is biased. Huh

    • @G360LIVE
      @G360LIVE Год назад +4

      And he's saying it as if it's a new thing. Back when I was reading game magazines, I could tell which ones were leaning toward more positive coverage to keep their access.

  • @DarrenTorpey
    @DarrenTorpey Год назад +2

    I really appreciate the honest questioning (about the difficult ethics of personal relationships and biases in games journalism) here and would love to hear more of your thoughts -- on the pod, maybe?

  • @nitramartin
    @nitramartin Год назад +7

    You mean it wasn't a good week for Sony!

  • @bo6892
    @bo6892 Год назад +3

    This year video game companies showed there real colors and have been in the most difficult times with the Microsoft and activision case, hacks, mass layoffs

  • @jeremyf1901
    @jeremyf1901 Год назад +10

    I’m glad Spawn Wave doesn’t cover “Controversies” like charity fraud. That has also made it feel bad in the gaming space as well. That is going to be a crazy story and probably legal trial.

  • @Supersteam09
    @Supersteam09 Год назад +9

    The leaks exposed all the bias and favoritism that has been plaguing the industry for a long time. Being a journalist means you should be willing to cover all kinds of news regardless of your relationship status. If a conflict of interest is enough for you to decide “I don’t want to cover it because [reasons]”, then you should not be talking about similar topics! You not only lose integrity, but you WILL lose respect. Losing both as a journalist is a death sentence!

    • @rockapartie
      @rockapartie Год назад

      Prime example: Review of Miasma Chronicles on Eurogamer. 🤦🏻‍♂

  • @CmoIsDaNam3i
    @CmoIsDaNam3i Год назад +5

    Just confirms to me to never take sponsorships or similar of any kind ever regardless of anything period in my whole freaking life even if it costs me my life.
    Rather die pure than live tainted with having to answer those kinds of questions because I went to buddy-buddy with the people who I should of kept at 4x arms length away.

    • @G360LIVE
      @G360LIVE Год назад +1

      I have the opposite view. I'm very much for sale. As I like to say, the only reason I have my own opinion is because no one pays me to have theirs. :)

    • @CmoIsDaNam3i
      @CmoIsDaNam3i Год назад +2

      @@G360LIVE Good for you sellout. 👌

    • @Zaque-TV
      @Zaque-TV Год назад

      Just disclose your bias. Do what you want.

  • @Kale13000
    @Kale13000 Год назад +2

    People are on the nose about Sony favoritism… it’s a pattern you can see in gaming outlets recently. I just don’t get why. Like of all gaming companies to lick the boots of, Sony? Really?

  • @larson0014
    @larson0014 Год назад +3

    what makes someone a journalist, is a journalist will vett info and dig deeper to verify it with multiple sources...

  • @alicepow260
    @alicepow260 Год назад +1

    There are sort of two lines of thought when it comes to journalistic authority. On one hand, I had some some journalism professors tell me just to try my best to be objective even though it's impossible to be truly objective, but I think a growing contingency of media audiences prefer transparency over fake objectivity. If someone is upfront about their biases, we can work with that but if you pretend you're unbiased it feels shady

  • @ventzxX
    @ventzxX Год назад +1

    I mean we always knew that the "journalists" had certain "affinities" nothing new, although it was refreshing to see them outing themselves.

  • @TripodDetergent
    @TripodDetergent Год назад +1

    I wonder how interesting the leaks even would be if the games industry was less secretive to the public about budgets, roadmaps, and sales number like other entertainment industries

  • @JustMe88419
    @JustMe88419 Год назад +2

    You know, the only thing is if they were "paid", the chances of them getting caught would absolutely skyrocket. Most currency exchanges, even with physical currency is fairly traceable. Nowadays laundering money or even being able to move the money at all without it being watched is very very very difficult to do. I really think if anyone had put up that money with the fbis involvement and assistance they likely would've gotten caught.

  • @MrAndresm900
    @MrAndresm900 Год назад +1

    The thumbnail is nightmare fuel ⛽️

  • @RainWalker24c
    @RainWalker24c Год назад +1

    As I was watching this vid & going through news, "Ubisoft investigating reports of a security breach" 26mins ago. Jesus man lol

  • @NxtDoc1851
    @NxtDoc1851 Год назад +5

    I knew you had to be working with MS the way you subliminally promote for them. On top of that, your subtle jabs at each corporations blunders, you haven't even began to jab at Xbox's lack of quality the past decade.

  • @TheeArcane
    @TheeArcane Год назад +22

    The worst part about is that some media outlets taking this stance leads credence to people thinking there is bias. Even Xbox tax now seems credible if it comes from these certain outlets taking these stances, especially when they leave reviews and vote at award shows, etc.

    • @fordgtguy
      @fordgtguy Год назад +7

      There is a bias, people have a bias, the problem is that quite a few gaming journalists allow that bias to reflect in their reporting.
      If you can't report on negative news due to a bias, then you can't be trusted for any news on the topic.

    • @FabledFiend
      @FabledFiend Год назад +2

      People who say Xbox tax shouldn't be taken seriously. Xbox fanboys make up new buzzwords just to cope.

    • @switchitup3709
      @switchitup3709 Год назад +5

      ​@Badjuice3000 but if you take a look Xbox do get flack for a lot of stuff that Sony wouldn't.

    • @fordgtguy
      @fordgtguy Год назад +2

      @@FabledFiend People that ignore that any type of bias can exist in gaming journalism and reporting news should be ignored.

    • @FabledFiend
      @FabledFiend Год назад

      ​@@switchitup3709examples?

  • @WhyYouMadDough
    @WhyYouMadDough Год назад +1

    The industry favors and has been favoring Sony/Playstation for awhile now. Journalists/publications are suppose to be non biased (unless otherwise stated). But I think that’s just every type of industry journalist/publications nowadays

  • @defur45
    @defur45 Год назад +6

    When it comes to morality in the gaming industry, stolen information from gaming companies is on the bottom of moral questions. These companies use immoral practices to make these games. Hard to see them being a victim of stolen info when the big three use China and their labor practices to make these systems. They have no problem using third world labor practices for the games or working the devs like they are robots with no lives.
    Morality is not a priority in the gaming industry, not even something considered until some leaks happen to the devs.

    • @maddo-hq9jr
      @maddo-hq9jr Год назад +2

      Well said. And, like always, there are enough 🤡 clapping along to the rhythm.
      It's not like there are more important or serious things to focus on right now.
      But maybe that is why this is happening. People's minds go bye bye for a moment 'cause the can't handle all the real sh!t anymore.

  • @Un_Popular_Opinions
    @Un_Popular_Opinions Год назад +1

    Sony has been hacked so often that it’s not surprising when it constantly happens.
    Reasons I will never trust Sony with my CC info.

  • @maui_idw7644
    @maui_idw7644 Год назад +2

    Ubisoft is investigating a breach. Let's see if the media reports that 🤔

  • @t.fernbach602
    @t.fernbach602 Год назад +14

    Nevertheless, 2023 was a banger, gaming-wise.

    • @youwayo
      @youwayo Год назад

      The positives outweigh the negatives for this year.

    • @FTChomp9980
      @FTChomp9980 Год назад

      Mario Wonder and Super Mario RPG Remake r definitely the bangers for me this year! Especially Pikman 4.

  • @JC_Denton_What_a_shame
    @JC_Denton_What_a_shame Год назад +2

    The difference? Maybe the fact that there's a playable build of their upcoming game out there? Maybe it's because of how developers were treated at the Video Game Awards? Maybe because more and more of these ransomware attacks have been happening and it's also giving these groups doing this attention/fame? Who can say.

  • @senatormarrero
    @senatormarrero Год назад +1

    Journalist is a pretty broad term and you are definitely a journalist by definition. You can be an entertainer and a presenter of news/information.

  • @Cyborg1011
    @Cyborg1011 Год назад +2

    Ooooh shots fired at Kinda Funny

  • @switchingitup_
    @switchingitup_ Год назад +1

    The main gaming media are run by larger companies, therefore the journalists are not independent. The companies need to make money and therefore will have partnerships with gaming companies. It is media as a whole that is currently biased and I believe we only get independent thoughts from channels like yours now. I appreciate your reporting of the news each day.

  • @SnipeMD
    @SnipeMD Год назад +4

    James McCaffrey (the voice of Max Payne) passed away.

  • @theshadowdirector
    @theshadowdirector Год назад +2

    my current position on this is that I will judge the various outlets who are avoiding the story based upon how they handle other hacking incidents going forward. they are all entitled to change their policies on coverage, regardless of the reasoning, so if they can stick by this line, the next time, a company is hacked, then I will look upon the more generously.

  • @rabidrabbit7853
    @rabidrabbit7853 Год назад +1

    Video was well thought out and made a lot of good points. The only thing I would say is that it wasn’t “a bad week for the gaming industry” it was a bad week for PlayStation. The industry is more than them.

  • @SotNist
    @SotNist Год назад +4

    Good for you, man. You've got more reason than most to push back on this grieving funeral lens that's been applied to the Insomniac leaks. Consistency is a really tactful choice of words.

  • @GordonFreekman
    @GordonFreekman Год назад +386

    I am here to stop some 9 year old from saying "First"
    Edit: why is this joke comment so popular

    • @mozz6344
      @mozz6344 Год назад +7

      first 😮

    • @cosmocalypse3708
      @cosmocalypse3708 Год назад +74

      In trying to defeat the 9 year old, you became the 9 year old.

    • @mozz6344
      @mozz6344 Год назад +2

      @khightofjustice2828first😢

    • @mozz6344
      @mozz6344 Год назад +2

      @khightofjustice2828first😅

    • @mozz6344
      @mozz6344 Год назад

      @khightofjustice2828first😊

  • @sketchasaurrex4087
    @sketchasaurrex4087 Год назад +2

    Journalists have prefixes of Investigating for those breaking news and Reporting for those reacting to the news. Most of youtube commentors usually report about it.

  • @OggieDoggie
    @OggieDoggie Год назад

    I think most of the issues I saw were around people reporting on this illegal hack as a leak. There is a huge difference between a hack and a leak. When someone breaks into your infrastructure and steals employees data along with your work. That is illegal and should be reported on as such not as we have another leak.

  • @tevin3916
    @tevin3916 Год назад +1

    Thank you for covering this

  • @fox_prower
    @fox_prower Год назад

    The industry as it stands looks for profit margins that align to the publisher demands. We used to be about quality margins as a whole until "too big to fail" companies started signing money making deals that align with shareholder demands.

  • @SolarSailor
    @SolarSailor Год назад +2

    This is the reason I listen to Sacred Symbols and LSM. They don't take any gaming advertising money so there is no conflict of interest

  • @pleasedontwatchthese9593
    @pleasedontwatchthese9593 Год назад +1

    I'm OK with gaming leaks about things other than the employees personal data. I have never really seen a leak destroy a large company or even slow it down.

  • @aweirdwombat
    @aweirdwombat Год назад +2

    I think if they cared they should have never covered this stuff in the first place. But what i think is really going on is it's getting harder to pretend these leaks are benign. They're getting more malicious and widespread. They're happening more regularly. And part of that is because these outlets kept covering them.
    It's getting harder to pretend these outlets are not complicit in this. And I'm sure they're getting more pushback from their fans. So instead of saying they made a mistake in the past, they're just pretending this is what they've always believed.

  • @smgofdvld
    @smgofdvld Год назад +2

    If it’s about video games in regards to new ip or a new game dlc or something that got cancelled all is fair imo that’s what the old magazines did back in the day it’s part of the rumors and speculation bit . If it’s some random stuff like peoples private info I think that’s when people should draw the line

  • @zybch
    @zybch Год назад +1

    It was a fine week for the industry. It was a shit week for sony, mostly self inflicted.

  • @GrimDMasterMind
    @GrimDMasterMind Год назад +7

    It is going to be interesting to see these people forget their strong "moral" stance when the next company gets their data leaked.

  • @kingsgaming7188
    @kingsgaming7188 Год назад +1

    Imagine Xbox and Sony telling us "With Playstation plus or Xbox live, you're "paying" for better "security" from the company, therefore we'll raise our prices".

  • @DonkThikkness
    @DonkThikkness Год назад +1

    One solution is for the industry to stop being so secretive and manipulative, and have full transparency. Honestly I would be more interested in this approach than the current world of NDAs, massive leaks, secrecy, and the pre-launch hype train. Don’t give the malicious opportunists anything interesting to hack. I’m sick of people thinking they can control the flow of information.

  • @ThisisCitrus
    @ThisisCitrus Год назад +1

    The Sony guy Greg proved himself basically dumb and scummy.

  • @Retro_Gamer_89
    @Retro_Gamer_89 Год назад +1

    Sony delaying games and firing developers and MBG saying he's quitting gaming if Microsoft wins this generation Sony have no leader, Getting sued for 8 Billion for ripping their customers off, TLOU 2 Factions gets shelved, Ponies begging for Blade to come to PS, The top selling game on PS right now is COD a ( Xbox ) game, Jim Ryan said PS can't survive without COD, Wolverine gets leaked, and they got hacked, And in the leak Wolverine documents 📃 Sony said they're concerned about Microsoft acquiring Activision, PS Portable is a flop, PSVR2 a flop, and their exclusives aren't making them that much money like they thought they would, Sony forced Insomniac to cut their budget for Spider-Man 3 Damn Sony is down bad 🤣

  • @matthewbarrett5661
    @matthewbarrett5661 Год назад +5

    You shouldn't be so hard on yourself. I stopped reading kotaku years ago cause I didn't like the direction of reporting. Other than my Google feed, you're the only gaming journalist I watch online. Keep up the good work!

    • @DS9TREK
      @DS9TREK Год назад +1

      He isn't a gaming journalist, he's what RGT85 calls a "gaming regurgitator". They both read other news services and repeat it to a camera.

  • @mrmiesfies3941
    @mrmiesfies3941 Год назад

    I would say you are journalist. Investigative journalism isn't the only kind of journalism.
    You cover gaming news on a regular schedule and you do it very objectively and factually.
    That is why I love your content. You give your personal note to everything, but still remain positioned as a beacon of unbiased information.

  • @Donald_Allan
    @Donald_Allan Год назад +14

    Thsnks for another awesome video bro. This is definitely by far one of the best channels to go to for information pertaining to videogames as you always have a neutral and unbiased take. Keep up the good work!

    • @Donald_Allan
      @Donald_Allan Год назад +3

      ​@@DragonHeart613 There's always one 🤣

    • @UArcane-b3x
      @UArcane-b3x Год назад

      @@Donald_Allanhey if we’re lucky he’ll show some teeth

    • @Donald_Allan
      @Donald_Allan Год назад +1

      @@UArcane-b3x 🤣

  • @crunchyblend8809
    @crunchyblend8809 Год назад +1

    And people still don't want to admit that the xbox tax is real

  • @youwayo
    @youwayo Год назад +1

    To be honest, your topic on “consistency” regarding journalist doesn’t only apply for gaming.

  • @tysonliphard6942
    @tysonliphard6942 Год назад +1

    I’m here to find out what brand that hexagonal led light he has. I can’t seem to find it. The ones I see are tiny. Let me know spawnwave. Please and thank you!

  • @NecroBanana
    @NecroBanana Год назад

    I remember an event in 2014 similar to this. People didn't learn then, they're not gonna learn now.

  • @blkmge
    @blkmge Год назад +1

    If there are two media companies at the center of a video game controversy stemming from their own conflicts of interest, you can bet those companies are Kotaku and Polygon. This was true ten years ago and its true today.

  • @clebbington
    @clebbington Год назад

    The biggest issue with ransomware isn't the cost of the ransom, but rather the opportunity cost when a business's files and systems get locked up. Many businesses will pony up the ransom because it costs less than the money they'd lose from not being operational for x amount of time

  • @JodouTR
    @JodouTR Год назад +1

    I can't actually care what journalists do, I just interpret news for the facts and nothing else. Their opinions and bias mean little and if that's all they have to offer, then I stop listening.

  • @chumlee9562
    @chumlee9562 Год назад +1

    Why does these computers need to be connected to the internet? A in-house network sure but why the internet? Especially the computers houseing the employees information

  • @SirRobinson510
    @SirRobinson510 Год назад

    I respect the hell out of what you just said, and appreciate it. I heard a very successful RUclipsr call themselves a journalist while doing amateur (at best) financial forensics, and it was cringey af. I respect journalists and journalism, there are great journalist and investigative journalists in gaming, sit back and enjoy the information. Aggregators are different, respected by me, yet different. Good job John!

  • @gh0stcat387
    @gh0stcat387 Год назад +6

    Games have been super disappointing the past couple of years. Games we've been waiting forever for just haven't been hitting. The industry as a whole is mostly bankrupt on ideas. I don't think leaks matter all that much honestly.

    • @G360LIVE
      @G360LIVE Год назад

      Yeah, Insomniac is going to make more Marvel games. Hooray. Good for them. Meanwhile, gamers want them to go back to making original IP. If there's anything we get out of these leaks, like the Microsoft leak as well as this one, it's the opportunity to not be disappointed in the coming years, because we know the long-term plan and how much it's probably going to suck.

    • @PlazDreamweaver
      @PlazDreamweaver Год назад +1

      They're not bankrupt on ideas. Orders from above demand profit at the cost of passion. There are plenty of amazing ideas that aren't another generic open world rpg with loot and a gearing system or another live service "game." The higher ups shoot all of them down because they're afraid to take risks (especially with these ridiculous budgets) and they realized they can make easy money with staying safe. The industry isn't creatively bankrupt, but those who run the industry are and have taken total control.

    • @Adamtendo_player_1
      @Adamtendo_player_1 Год назад

      Speak for yourself, Nintendo is the only one that hasn’t disappointed when it comes to games. Outside of Nintendo, the games industry is destroying itself and is a joke.

  • @marioochoa
    @marioochoa Год назад +2

    Kinda funny in general is kind of a joke outlet honestly.

  • @metaldiceman
    @metaldiceman Год назад

    Wow, what a surprise hit for a Saturday morning. One of your best videos in a long time.