"you have keen eyes" he said, regarding the the various bolts of bright orange lighting that would have been seen from miles around erupting from a single point in the sand
@@mankyscotchgit4986 You can see the sand moving too. So I wonder if they decided the audience might miss the effect and added the lightning in post production.
Lynch should finally do his 5-6 hours director's cut, as a three parter, with new "not financially restricted" sfx work. They really ruined Dune in post production, trying to save money and making it a 2 hour movie. So sad...
I love this version. David disowned this film because of the dwindling control over its direction from Universal. It was originally planned to be 2-3 movies but then got cut to 2.25 hours, which David & Frank knew would suck for a 400-page adaptation. The fanmade Spicediver 4k alternative cut is considered the best edit so far.
The sandworms are a reminder for us people how to save ourselves instead of watching ourselves die. Only those had a strong will to survive shall be safe, and to those who don't is just a sad quiet moment.
And Kynes, returning the stare, found himself troubled by a fact he had observed here: This Duke was concerned more over the men than he was over the spice. He risked his own life, and that of his son to save the men. He passed off the loss of a spice crawler with a gesture. The threat to men's lives had him in a rage. A leader such as that would command fanatic loyalty. He would be difficult to defeat. Against his own will and all previous judgements, Kynes admitted to himself: I like this Duke.”
@@bojanboskovic8880 The Dune universe uses a different calendar. Rather than using BC and AD, the Dune universe base all events on BG (before guild) and AG (after Guild). Though not exact, when they say 10,191 they mean 10,191 AG. Which would translate to roughly 23,325 AD
Fun fact: in the miniature they used for the sand worm eating the harvester, the only powdery substance they could find that was fine enough to look like sand at that scale was glass powder. Setting off that explosion was a serious safety hazard because the glass particles were still sharp, and if they had got into anyone's lungs or eyes they'd be virtually impossible to remove and that person would spend the rest of their life bleeding out of where ever it was.
@@squamish4244 agreed! the explosion isn't even necessary, in fact, it doesn't make much sense. the worm only needs to swallow the harvester, like in the 2021 film.
I like how they showed the scaling, but in a more natural flow. You see the men coming out of the harvester so you get an understanding of how big it is compared to you. Then the worm comes and you're thinking, "Holy Christ that thing is huge!"
Nobody ever talks about how lit that sandworm had to have been after consuming the entire fully-loaded harvester like it was nothing. Homeboy probably went around Arrakis at least 20 times that day, lol.
Similar to an exchange at work when hydrogen sulfide gas was detected. Coworker: What about the boiler? Supervisor: screw the boiler, evacuate the plant!
“Dune” is a dazzling Sci-fi masterpiece, so ahead of it’s time and crearive it set the track for so many developments in the genre. And it is visually stunning because it was created with the very very limited CGI of the time (1984), just the glow in the eyes and some minor optical effects, while 99% of the SFX are practical
@@agestone The idea of sci-fi in the 80s wasn't that different from today, look at Star Trek or Star Wars. The spaceships and ornithopters in Dune 2021 are much closer to that aesthetic (as well as how machinery and vehicles look in real life), they were just going for a much more... Strange... Aesthetic is the 80's version. All that to say I think the 2021 version will age much better. I'm sure it'll still look dated in a few decades, though.
Even though I know its just a model - the music, combined with the way Patrick Stewart says "gods what a monster" makes me want to believe I really did just see a sand worm eat a giant harvester. I also really like the way David Lynch's movie portrays Arrakis as being kind of dim, dark, smoky; wreathed in constant dust storms and inundated with spice dust in the air making it kind of a dark place full of lightening storms as opposed to the clear skies and sun drenched wide shot landscapes of other dune movies - here the desert seems more oppressive and mysterious, glimpsed, peered into and faint but still dangerous.
Patrick Stewart and Morgan freeman both lept from the womb middle aged men of class and distinction and shall not age until they go west into the undying lands to reside in the grand library. I have spoken.
@@scoto3990 Just a thought... could it be "pure" as in non-adulterated spice? I suspect some dealers might "cut" the refined spice with other stuff for... poorer clientele...? But I do like your suggestion of "RAW" would have been best
A lot of critics have said how much they hated the internal dialogue in the movie....but I always thought that was one of the best aspects of it. Let's you know what's on their mind, because it doesn't always reflect in their expressions. It also helps fill the world with all that lore that can't be explained without exposition of some kind. I wish more movies would have the whispery internal thoughts of characters. Let you know their thought process.
Agree as well. I think some find it scary, almost like looking into the place they dare not look... or just odd, because other movies don't have that. It adds another dimension.
You are absolutely right, since Herbert expresses inner voices of characters in the book, some being a page long. And I was looking for the cause of new movie's lacking ability to convey the characters fully and now I see that inner voices is one big cause where you don't get any idea about who they are in the 2021 movie. (Although I only watched some clips of it but I couldn't bare even those clips)
@@cchavezjr7 What works in books doesn't work in Cinema. Herbert wasn't writing a movie screenplay of 2 & half hour movie, he was writing a 400+ page book.. Inner monologue done multiple in any movie comes across as a lazy story telling & mediocre filmmaking. There's a reason why even to this day vast majority of viewer demand from filmmakers "show, don't tell", over use of expositions in movies have brought criticism to directors. Villeneuve in recent Dune tried to minimize that to optimal level. It's kinda worked.
@@epa2349 It wasn't a problem for me and other people. It's funny how the book fans complain that the movies are never true to the books yet when something is done true to the books, it's lazy...
The single easiest (and the only necessary) improvement to this sequence would be to remove the shot of the worm diving back under the sand at 02:06 which 1) spoils the surprise 2) is the only model shot in this that looks a bit off. The suspense continues building if we don't see the creature until when it finally attacks at 03:18
I liked the inclusion of the voice amplifier built into the ‘thopter here. Makes more sense than getting out and running towards the crawler trying to shout over the sound of the machinery and the wind. The 2021 version is epic, but this was quite well done for the limitations of the time.
My introduction to Dune was through the RTS games, which use the same harvester designs used in the movie. Abit disappointed when the harvester designs changed in the remake.
Well, Max was in his mid 50's during Dune, although he does look a bit older as Kynes, perhaps with some more makeup. But he has had quite an acting career. I will always first remember Max in the role of Jesus Christ, which I think was one of his more famous roles.
I can definitively see the limitations here because the new movie was able to build tension in this scene and showed us more details of the world than Lynch was ever able to do. The new Dune is such a masterpiece, but it also exemplify the epic scope that is necessary in vision and effect in order to convert the Dune saga to celluloid.
Bits of it. But I found Liet Kynes character pretty poor compared to this film and the book. She literally meets them for 3 seconds then converts to help them with near zero explanation. Then promptly dies. At least here we see that Liet has some respect and insight to the Dukes leading concerns. E.g. his own men.
@@FreemanicParacusia it's inconsistent in its subtle way of delivering information for the viewers. Either you have a half a second of Kynes' glimpse of newfound respect for Leto, or there is a fucking minute of Jessica fucking losing shit and crying and having a panic attack. Villeneuve have never worked well with actors. Ridley Scott was right in being on the set of BR:2049. And he was right in telling that it was too long a movie, ergo it bombed. I guarantee you Dune: Part 2 will suffer the same manner - cardboard acting from good actors and too long shots of landscape that he adopted from his documentary making career at the beginning.
Something that I like about the older version of Dune over the newer one. Duke Leto is clearly a very noble and good soul who cares about his men over monetary gain. One can clearly see why he is very popular among the Landsraad.
@@MartialMasculine It's not due to Lynch being a better director. If anything, he's a shitty one. He just had good actors, Prochow was great as Leto, you could still feel him being a bit like the Captain in Das Boot.
In that era, this was considered a colossal failure and completely out of sync with films of the time. So there's that. Everyone says the movies/music/culture from when they grew up/were young were "when ______ actually made great ________". Old people in the 80s were saying it when they were using Dune as an example of "the crap they make now."
@@jimhuffman9434 Yes. I mean, some of them. That's true of any time period. The Revenant, Moonlight, La La Land, The Shape of the Water, Get Out, 1917, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, Parasite, Hereditary, Mad Max: Fury Road... I could go on. You may disagree with some of my picks because everyone has their own tastes, but by and large these are generally recognized as such. But the nature of a "masterpiece" is that it's not THAT common. It never was.
@ass I mean, movies were good before this "Political Correctness" crap started getting shoved into everything. films in the early 2000's and before I have no problem with. But since Political Correctness came in, everything has been horrible
"Ordered by whom?" "Duke Leto Atreides." "Yes... yes _sire!_ " Gotta love that pause, the normal person reaction to encountering the ruler of your and several other _planets_
I believe that the worm represents the cycle of life on Arakkis. It symbolizes the raw strength of nature and that none of the competing factions would dare to challenge it directly.
I just feel bad because on one hand this looks like a good scene, and at the same time it’s like it is missing something. Like it is half assed somehow. Almost like in the 80s this movie was made to look like it should be in the 60s. Maybe it is the dark yellowish filters and color tones everywhere without a speck of white color, who knows.
Jesus fucking christ Until half the video, i thought it's a star trek parody, because of Captain Picard. Until i realised, im watching the original DUNe movie, lol
![Dune - Conquering Shai Hulud [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3sguaghxZG8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Dune - Conquering Shai Hulud [HD]](/img/tr.png)
Production designers: "How much leather do you want in the Ornithopter?"
David Lynch: "Yes"
Give that shit a rest
Its looks like a champagne room 🤣
haha
@@Miafunfactory
Where are the Fremen escorts?
I find this much more logical in the Royal context of the Dune lore than the military everything space marine trash of modern USA cinema, tbh...
"you have keen eyes" he said, regarding the the various bolts of bright orange lighting that would have been seen from miles around erupting from a single point in the sand
The line is taken from the book where there is no lightning, just a moving disturbance in the sand.
also it should have been from miles away in the horizon
@@mankyscotchgit4986 You can see the sand moving too. So I wonder if they decided the audience might miss the effect and added the lightning in post production.
@@zangatz Dune 2021 perfectly nailed it, quite terrifying actually
Spice is a helluva drug
RIP David Lynch. This underrated sci-fi movie is still good.
"Worm sign"
"Worm attack"
"Harvester lost"
"Training"
"Insufficient credits"
Dune 2000
I played dune: battle for arrakis on the Sega genesis back in high school.
@@himehime2044 The memories 😌 love the game
Emperor Battle for Dune.... if any game needs a remaster, it's that one
(gentle female voice): "Warning. Base is under attack."
The casting of this classic version of Dune was so on point that it's difficult to put into words.
long live the fighters!
Lynch should finally do his 5-6 hours director's cut, as a three parter, with new "not financially restricted" sfx work.
They really ruined Dune in post production, trying to save money and making it a 2 hour movie.
So sad...
There is something just so other worldly about it, it's almost spooky, and that's why I love it.
*Reality in 80s:* slim headset microphones.
*Future in 80s:* microphone is a huge weird looking brass stick.
Bruh
I rather record myself using a huge Brass stick than using a chopstick with small lolipop in the end
@@alahsiaboi8909
Looks like you have no idea. Look at NASA mission control at 80's. There is no "lollipops".
@@AliShuktu well i was refering the mics in the Clip not from NASA in the 80s lolololol
@@alahsiaboi8909
I don't know who is "ibwas".
What are you talking about?
Are you ok?
just realized now that the harvester operator is David Lynch himself!!
uh pretty sure that's Alan Smithee lol
@@PandaXs1 Depends on which version of the film this is from.
@@PandaXs1 the one in this clip was clearly david Lynch
I love this version. David disowned this film because of the dwindling control over its direction from Universal. It was originally planned to be 2-3 movies but then got cut to 2.25 hours, which David & Frank knew would suck for a 400-page adaptation. The fanmade Spicediver 4k alternative cut is considered the best edit so far.
"Spice is the variety of life!" --David Lynch
Kynes begrudgingly admitting feeling respect for the Duke to himself is one of my favorite lines in the book.
Especially as the Duke's view is, "it's not like the spice is really GOING anywhere, I need capable people to mine it. I don't want to lose people."
It was at that point he decided not to betray them
The sandworms are a reminder for us people how to save ourselves instead of watching ourselves die.
Only those had a strong will to survive shall be safe, and to those who don't is just a sad quiet moment.
“Leto turned a hard stare at Kynes.
And Kynes, returning the stare, found himself troubled by a fact he had observed here: This Duke was concerned more over the men than he was over the spice. He risked his own life, and that of his son to save the men. He passed off the loss of a spice crawler with a gesture. The threat to men's lives had him in a rage. A leader such as that would command fanatic loyalty. He would be difficult to defeat.
Against his own will and all previous judgements, Kynes admitted to himself: I like this Duke.”
More proof that picard is immortal.
This actually takes place in (about) 23,352 AD. So yeah, that would make him immortal
Really!!!!!
It's the power of spice
@@jimhuffman9434 Actually, the year is 10 191
@@bojanboskovic8880 The Dune universe uses a different calendar. Rather than using BC and AD, the Dune universe base all events on BG (before guild) and AG (after Guild).
Though not exact, when they say 10,191 they mean 10,191 AG. Which would translate to roughly 23,325 AD
Fun fact: in the miniature they used for the sand worm eating the harvester, the only powdery substance they could find that was fine enough to look like sand at that scale was glass powder. Setting off that explosion was a serious safety hazard because the glass particles were still sharp, and if they had got into anyone's lungs or eyes they'd be virtually impossible to remove and that person would spend the rest of their life bleeding out of where ever it was.
Bullshit
I would never set off the explosion if it was that dangerous!
@@squamish4244 agreed! the explosion isn't even necessary, in fact, it doesn't make much sense. the worm only needs to swallow the harvester, like in the 2021 film.
I can almost hear Black Widow saying "I don't see how that's a fun fact."
They couldn’t just use flour or cinnamon or something? 😄
I like how they showed the scaling, but in a more natural flow. You see the men coming out of the harvester so you get an understanding of how big it is compared to you. Then the worm comes and you're thinking, "Holy Christ that thing is huge!"
yeah and they didnt do the typical made it at the last second thing
Good observation!
such thin gis 120 meters long and 4 wide :)
03:34 "God's!! What a Monster!"
Always loved the way Patrick. Delivered that line 😁
JONNOG88 Gods not God’s. No need for an apostrophe. :)
Thats what She said
I've loved this movie since the late 80s. Screw the haters.
I agree.
How could anyone hate it? Epic story.
Yep.👍
I love this movie too - but it's really awful - it's like the Godfather of bad movies.
I agree
“Bless the maker and his water.Bless the coming and going of him.May his passage cleanse the world.May he keep the Word to his people.” Kynes
Great scene with David Lynch! 🥲
I honestly love the whispering for internal thoughts. So gentile.
"But sir we can't leave the spice"
"Yes you are right... Das muss das Boot abkönnen!"
JA HERR KALEUN!
Ein guter spice miner ist auch ein vorsichtiger spice miner, was Johann?!
Steht sogar fast genauso im Lehrbuch.
April fool. Practice makes perfect.
ANBLASEN!!
Nobody ever talks about how lit that sandworm had to have been after consuming the entire fully-loaded harvester like it was nothing. Homeboy probably went around Arrakis at least 20 times that day, lol.
"But Sire we can't leave all this Spice..."
"Damn the Spice!! Get out of there!!!!"
A true leader.
@The Xenomorphian
Because the Harkonnen leaders before him didn't give a damn about human lifes.
Similar to an exchange at work when hydrogen sulfide gas was detected.
Coworker: What about the boiler?
Supervisor: screw the boiler, evacuate the plant!
Forget the spice! The spice is bupkis!
The worm would have eaten the harvester and the spice anyways, might as well save the guys who can make more.
“Dune” is a dazzling Sci-fi masterpiece, so ahead of it’s time and crearive it set the track for so many developments in the genre. And it is visually stunning because it was created with the very very limited CGI of the time (1984), just the glow in the eyes and some minor optical effects, while 99% of the SFX are practical
All the opticals here are either done with cel animation or by optically processing different practical elements
laugh in star wars (1977)
Visualy stunning? - especially those weird looking brass stick microphone? 😁
@@AliShuktu it is meant to be oddly Victorian.
@Dan It's more memorable visually, acting-wise, and musically than the bland, monochromatic, monotone remake.
I love Kynes' stunned reaction when Leto says "Damn the Spice! Get out of there!"
loved the thunderous roar and shaking of the ground as this massive animal races toward the harvester...
That swallowing was actually impressive.
I beg your pardon? 🤣
Even scarier than 2021 one.
R.I.P. David Lynch (1946 - 2025).
Shortly after this they gave picard his own ship and then an entire school for gifted kids..
They did a good job with the little they had as far as effects. I tip my hat off to them
They look like they're flying inside grandpa's armchair.
💀
This is what your grandson will say about 2021 Dune)
They are
That’s a Great MST3K Joke!🤣😂
@@agestone The idea of sci-fi in the 80s wasn't that different from today, look at Star Trek or Star Wars. The spaceships and ornithopters in Dune 2021 are much closer to that aesthetic (as well as how machinery and vehicles look in real life), they were just going for a much more... Strange... Aesthetic is the 80's version. All that to say I think the 2021 version will age much better. I'm sure it'll still look dated in a few decades, though.
Years later and I'm still glued to every scene I can find of this classic.
Even though I know its just a model - the music, combined with the way Patrick Stewart says "gods what a monster" makes me want to believe I really did just see a sand worm eat a giant harvester. I also really like the way David Lynch's movie portrays Arrakis as being kind of dim, dark, smoky; wreathed in constant dust storms and inundated with spice dust in the air making it kind of a dark place full of lightening storms as opposed to the clear skies and sun drenched wide shot landscapes of other dune movies - here the desert seems more oppressive and mysterious, glimpsed, peered into and faint but still dangerous.
The absolute LEGENDS in this scene is overwhelming!
300 credits for a trike
400 for a quad
800 for a microwave tank
1200 for a carrier
The harvester probably had a full load of 700 solaris worth of spice on board. The Duke could have made a tank with that.
Wait the microwave tank isn't from Dune it's from Command and Conquer.
@@Cacowninja Maybe he talks about the atreides Sonic tank
Where the ordos though?
I think Sonic Tanks costs 1000 credits at Hard Difficulty
When the duke says "damn sloppy" he doesn't mean the spice miners, he means Thufir and the whole defense against hidden Harkonnen forces on Arrakis
Good point, I never thought of it that way
In the books, he was referring to how there was only one carry-all to each crawler and would've preferred a backup for all.
Love the book, saw this in the 80's... loved it. New movie is closer to the book especially in SFX.. can't wait for the next one.
Holy crow, Patrick Stewart has aged phenomenally
He has aged like very fine (and expensive) wine unlike some of the more "current" movie people who age like milk
@@vexile1239
Unless the blaand, kumis, and cheese are well aged. Then they are well aged milk.
Try age like politics. They seem to ageing worst.
Never heard of blaand, maybe an open wine bottle (I think it turns into a vile tasting vinegar
Patrick Stewart and Morgan freeman both lept from the womb middle aged men of class and distinction and shall not age until they go west into the undying lands to reside in the grand library. I have spoken.
I’m not convinced he doesn’t have a portrait of himself in an advanced decrepit state stashed away in an attic somewhere
Seeing a young Patrick Stewart makes me realize how much time has really passed
FYI the director, David Lynch, is the guy communicating with them on the spice harvester.
Such an interesting film, no matter how many times I've seen it.
i like all the dune movies as they tell the story differently. different tecnology for different times .
I love catching up on old Star Trek Next Generation episodes and pretending it's 1987 all over again. 🥰
Ha! Old Lynch moonlighting as a Spicer!
really? lol i never knew
R.I.P. Max von Sydow
Wonderful actor.
Love the quilted leather interior to the ship.
Four epic actors in one scene.
Epic soundtrack! It's like a Journey into the Unknown.
I always liked this film even with the new Dune film which was fantastic.
2:32 always loved this transition "pure unrefined spice"
@Goat Man You're probably on the right side, but still.. this was an epic scene.
The line sounds great, but it's actually
an oxymoron. If something is "unrefined,"
it CANNOT be "pure."
@@Llewellyn2844 true, the line should have read "RAW,, unrefined Spice." Good call
@@scoto3990 Just a thought... could it be "pure" as in non-adulterated spice? I suspect some dealers might "cut" the refined spice with other stuff for... poorer clientele...? But I do like your suggestion of "RAW" would have been best
@@Llewellyn2844while that is true he could have meant "pure" as "not been tampered with". "raw" woul dhave been better though
It's so weird to see the captain from Das boot and Picard in the same movie lol
A lot of critics have said how much they hated the internal dialogue in the movie....but I always thought that was one of the best aspects of it. Let's you know what's on their mind, because it doesn't always reflect in their expressions. It also helps fill the world with all that lore that can't be explained without exposition of some kind. I wish more movies would have the whispery internal thoughts of characters. Let you know their thought process.
Agree as well. I think some find it scary, almost like looking into the place they dare not look... or just odd, because other movies don't have that. It adds another dimension.
You are absolutely right, since Herbert expresses inner voices of characters in the book, some being a page long. And I was looking for the cause of new movie's lacking ability to convey the characters fully and now I see that inner voices is one big cause where you don't get any idea about who they are in the 2021 movie. (Although I only watched some clips of it but I couldn't bare even those clips)
@@msinaanc I never understood why so many people hated it when that is exactly how Herbert wrote the books.
@@cchavezjr7
What works in books doesn't work in Cinema. Herbert wasn't writing a movie screenplay of 2 & half hour movie, he was writing a 400+ page book..
Inner monologue done multiple in any movie comes across as a lazy story telling & mediocre filmmaking.
There's a reason why even to this day vast majority of viewer demand from filmmakers "show, don't tell", over use of expositions in movies have brought criticism to directors.
Villeneuve in recent Dune tried to minimize that to optimal level. It's kinda worked.
@@epa2349 It wasn't a problem for me and other people. It's funny how the book fans complain that the movies are never true to the books yet when something is done true to the books, it's lazy...
The single easiest (and the only necessary) improvement to this sequence would be to remove the shot of the worm diving back under the sand at 02:06 which 1) spoils the surprise 2) is the only model shot in this that looks a bit off. The suspense continues building if we don't see the creature until when it finally attacks at 03:18
It feels weird watching the new dune and then watching this dune
Damn the spice!!!
I liked the inclusion of the voice amplifier built into the ‘thopter here. Makes more sense than getting out and running towards the crawler trying to shout over the sound of the machinery and the wind. The 2021 version is epic, but this was quite well done for the limitations of the time.
Apparently no one told them that you can buy spices in the baking aisle of any grocery store
It is called Spice, but has absolutely nothing in common with spices in this world.
Put this spice in your soup, you won't have to worry about any meals after.
The funny thing is that their spice is actually sandworm shit.
Spice not spices!
@therealjustafriendlynerd IKR?
Edit: it’s even funnier that a comment from 2 years ago came back!
"Damn the spice!"
Kynes be like "Dude wut?"
You can mine once more, but you can't restore peoples life.
To those 46 and others that hated this. Your lost. This was awesome.
The scene hits way harder in this film than Dune 2021.
I was underwhelmed by the 2021 version.
Paul could care less about the crew, more concerned about the contact high.
My introduction to Dune was through the RTS games, which use the same harvester designs used in the movie.
Abit disappointed when the harvester designs changed in the remake.
A U-boat commander, an exorcist, the mayor of Portland, and the captain of the Enterprise walk into a bar...
Playing Leit-Kynes is Max Von Sydow, who played the Three-Eyed Raven in Game of Thrones. Even back in 1984, he was old!
Well, Max was in his mid 50's during Dune, although he does look a bit older as Kynes, perhaps with some more makeup. But he has had quite an acting career. I will always first remember Max in the role of Jesus Christ, which I think was one of his more famous roles.
@@robwebnoid5763 That, and Ming the Merciless in Flash Gordon.
@@kelaarin ... Ah yes, Ming too. I must be a "pathetic earthling" for that oversight.
Probably because he was an old man
@@Marvin-dg8vj my point is he was an old man for over 30 years after that too
Spice... Pure, unrefined Spice! 🤤
Anikin skywalker worst nightmare 🤣
I hAte sAnD!
It's course, rough and gets everywhere
sand lol
@Chinakiller-vn2th and reminds him of his time being a slave and his mother. Actually understandable if you really think about it.
I can definitively see the limitations here because the new movie was able to build tension in this scene and showed us more details of the world than Lynch was ever able to do. The new Dune is such a masterpiece, but it also exemplify the epic scope that is necessary in vision and effect in order to convert the Dune saga to celluloid.
no way! old dune rocks!!! new dune laaaaammmmeeee
Notices literal lightning coming out of the sand.
“You’ve got sharp eyes”
After watching this scene in the old dune, it made me realize how true to form the modern dune really was
Bits of it. But I found Liet Kynes character pretty poor compared to this film and the book. She literally meets them for 3 seconds then converts to help them with near zero explanation. Then promptly dies.
At least here we see that Liet has some respect and insight to the Dukes leading concerns. E.g. his own men.
@@JPearson1987 The 2021 version is more subtle, lacking the voiceover monologues. It’s all there, it just isn’t spell out for us the same way.
@@FreemanicParacusia it's inconsistent in its subtle way of delivering information for the viewers. Either you have a half a second of Kynes' glimpse of newfound respect for Leto, or there is a fucking minute of Jessica fucking losing shit and crying and having a panic attack. Villeneuve have never worked well with actors. Ridley Scott was right in being on the set of BR:2049. And he was right in telling that it was too long a movie, ergo it bombed.
I guarantee you Dune: Part 2 will suffer the same manner - cardboard acting from good actors and too long shots of landscape that he adopted from his documentary making career at the beginning.
Gods what a monster!
Something that I like about the older version of Dune over the newer one. Duke Leto is clearly a very noble and good soul who cares about his men over monetary gain. One can clearly see why he is very popular among the Landsraad.
That looks so cosy...
I need a Dune film with books plot and later Dunes graphics
Who knew David Lynch was a Spice Miner? 🤣
This scene by Lynch blows Villaneuve's attempt out of the water.
The scene hits way harder in this film than Dune 2021.
I was underwhelmed by the 2021 version.
@@qownson4410 Villaneuve's version feels... autistic. Full of detail, but devoid of emotion or tension.
@@MartialMasculine It's not due to Lynch being a better director. If anything, he's a shitty one. He just had good actors, Prochow was great as Leto, you could still feel him being a bit like the Captain in Das Boot.
Picard before becoming the captain of stargazer
What's Picard doing there? LOL
Well the enterprises does need fuel to
Envoy of the federation and so on.
Boldy going where no man has gone before
Doing his job, he's an actor.
@@mitrooper Picard is a Starfleet Captain 😒
David Lynch....spice miner!
is david lynch playing the pilot of the ship that gets blown up?
Yes yes he is
But you already knew that and just wanted look cool by pretending you didn't know
@@Ebolacrash exactly, but I did not know that so I thank him/her for writing this.
@@Ebolacrash he's in the movie?
The voice is unmistakable
"Worm attack"
Me: FFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUU
Das Boot "Enterprise" in Twin Peaks :)...
Imagine - This came from the era when hollywood actually made great movies.
In that era, this was considered a colossal failure and completely out of sync with films of the time. So there's that.
Everyone says the movies/music/culture from when they grew up/were young were "when ______ actually made great ________". Old people in the 80s were saying it when they were using Dune as an example of "the crap they make now."
@@mahna_mahna and you call films made in the last 2-5 years masterpieces?
@@jimhuffman9434 Yes. I mean, some of them. That's true of any time period. The Revenant, Moonlight, La La Land, The Shape of the Water, Get Out, 1917, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, Parasite, Hereditary, Mad Max: Fury Road... I could go on. You may disagree with some of my picks because everyone has their own tastes, but by and large these are generally recognized as such. But the nature of a "masterpiece" is that it's not THAT common. It never was.
@@mahna_mahna yes your spot on
@ass I mean, movies were good before this "Political Correctness" crap started getting shoved into everything. films in the early 2000's and before I have no problem with. But since Political Correctness came in, everything has been horrible
That's David Lynch playing the part of the spice worker in this clip
"Ordered by whom?"
"Duke Leto Atreides."
"Yes... yes _sire!_ "
Gotta love that pause, the normal person reaction to encountering the ruler of your and several other _planets_
Always why I'll be Atreides for life. The Atreides family has always gived a damn about common people. Something basically no other house did.
Das ist ja unser Herr Kaleun 😳
there is no scene in movie history of a spice mélange of perfect actors.
I believe that the worm represents the cycle of life on Arakkis. It symbolizes the raw strength of nature and that none of the competing factions would dare to challenge it directly.
1% Ornithopter
200% LEATHER OMG!!!!!
Did they hire Captain Picard?😁🤷
"Worm sign" -Sandy Cheeks
Patrick Stewart plays a good Gurney but no inkvine scar.
Check 1:11
Is a balliset acoustic or eclectic? Pun intended
And Gurney is said to be ugly, and so far as I concern, he isn't ugly
I like the 1984 stillsuits, the upper front is all water tanks
Kaleun wants redemption for refusing to pick up that lifeboat of survivors...
I just feel bad because on one hand this looks like a good scene, and at the same time it’s like it is missing something. Like it is half assed somehow. Almost like in the 80s this movie was made to look like it should be in the 60s. Maybe it is the dark yellowish filters and color tones everywhere without a speck of white color, who knows.
1:45 "Damn the spice, get out of there" Duke Leto Atreides said calmly...
I miss the lightning following the worms in new duen
@0:22 in the year 10191, socket wrenches are microphones
'Damn the spice' gets the same reaction in both versions!
The power of Spice compels you--!
Dune forever!!!!
Set phasers on worm!
The Dieselpunk in this version is much better than in the new Dune movie.
Great movie.
Jesus fucking christ
Until half the video, i thought it's a star trek parody, because of Captain Picard. Until i realised, im watching the original DUNe movie, lol
I like this scene because of practical effects.