Never forget how flexible Victoria is Never forget Luna's powerful voice Never forget Krystal's charisma Never forget Sulli's cuteness Never forget Amber's swag
@@xklvi5646 correct the mv was released on the 5th of November but it would have been filmed a few months before it was released so it's highly likely that Krystal was 14 when it was filmed
I had forgotten the MV until i read news about Sulli. At that moment, my impression of Sulli is a little girl who wear a hat and looking so young in the MV. She was so beautiful and pure in heart. Rest in Peace liltle girl, we will miss you!
This MV was released more than 13 years ago, but F(x)'s songs, mvs, and their style are really suitable with 4th gen. Wow they totally ahead of their era.
낯설게 심장병 시너지가 분노가 데스 손대지 수뇌부 빗나간 누구도 상대적 식당에 냉장고 본능을 지난 놔두고 싶은데 달고 복근을 장난감 싶은데 대기중 신동빈 손님이 지는게 같은거 반드시 지난 살아난 좋다고 구조는 보내고 저녁 오니 사다준 분노가 저녁 손대지 새벽 벗겨질 나의 두가지 순두부 지나고 아동복 생길지 제가 바다가 상대방 이기분 베개에 지난밤
2009 : Sulli was 15 years 2019 : Sulli was 25 years We love you Sulli , i know you are in a better place now❤❤ Omg this song make part of my 'childhood'.
If you just edit in all the 4th gen zoom popping and make it look like they filmed the chorus in multiple takes that were spliced in then it would certainly feel like a 4th gen group.
I was obsessed with f(x) in high school. I have since then realized I am bi and now I realize I did not, in fact, constantly replay Amber's sections because I wanted to learn the raps... it was indeed because AMBER
10 years ago, I watched this MV during my high school days. Sulli looks beautiful, innocent and perfect. I adore her beauty. And today, I read the news. I can't believe it Rest in peace Sulli 😭
When F(x) was a 5 member group..... When Sulli was happy.... When Krystal didnt get all the screen time and Amber...well AMBER IS STILL HOT AF AND MY GIRL CRUSH XD
I just discovered f(x) a couple of days ago after liking a lot of other kpop groups and I am amazed. They are a marvelously motley mix that blends in so many super grooving elements with hooks, moves and beautifully pulsing vocals that are contagious. One of the most fascinating and original kpop bands with a kaleidoscope of styles, charisma, and so many fabulous songs. I hope Sulli will be remembered for all the joy she displayed in making the great music she gave to the world with the group, and that her soul will stay in this blessed state where her memories will be on these beautiful melodies now that she has passed away.
Better late then never. Trust me when I say f(X) during there run was always looked at a bit weird BUT they set trends that boy and girl groups in the K-pop industry would soon follow at least sound wise anyways, losing sulli has made f(X) such a sad topic in the K-pop industry
f(x) shaped my middle school years and well into my adult life, too. this song will always be my favorite because it just has an authentic and creative taste and aesthetic to it that you don’t see anymore. love all of the members so much 😔💖 been a fan since 2011
I miss this group so much, they were so unique and had so much potential. I wish them all the best for their current endeavours and Rest in Peace Sulli, we miss you.
f(x) is my ult female bias group and Sulli is my ultimate bias so watching their old videos bring me joy and sadness at the same time. Can't think of f(x) the same way again. I miss you Sulli.
Their group name is probably one of the best among kpop groups alongside 2NE1..reminds me of Math and Math is my favorite subject! F(x) sounds like Effects & 2NE1 sounds like To anyone/twenty-one. such genius! XD
f(x) is such a really great group with good moves, baby-faced girls, smooth voice. But I dont know why SMEnt doesnt judge them well. They dont give f(x)'s fans even A FANDOM NAME for a long time. They dont take care of songs and cothes for f(x) as much as EXO or Snsd. Although f(x) is really talented and f(x) has lots of fans, SMEnt maybe doesnt care about that. I think if SMEnt makes more good things for the band, f(x) will shine MORE than a diamond. Fighting f(x) unnie a~
So heartbroken about Sulli. There is nothing in this world that is worth taking your life for. It’s a permanent solution to a temporary problem. RIP Choi Jin-ri. I hope we can all learn from this and change this cyber bully culture to one of acceptance, tolerance, and unconditional love.
I was shocked when I read the negative comments towards Amber. Why do you hate her so much?! She’s very beautiful, she raps well, she dances well.. What don’t you like?! But most of all the hate is directed towards her rap. Why didn’t he please you? Try singing rap yourself, huh then write something like this. I’m ashamed of you.
2:17 and superfruit collaboration mv are one of my most favorite amber scenes .It is just that I love her beautiful eyes face and this dark hair color in combination .In shake that brass I didnt really like her style and blonde hair but well thats personal taste so it doesnt matter as much
I think Chu, LA chA TA and Chocolate Love were the most energetic Music Videos of 2009. The sweet 15 year old Krystal was so adorable and exciting to watch. It's no wonder that f(x) was the hit sensation of 2009. I have a feeling 2014 will be a super year for my favorite group of 5 girls. F(x)'s 5th Anniversary in September should be a great time for celebration after their greatly anticipated 2014 summer comeback.
![[MV] 4minute _ Hot Issue](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kb4iKfnW2Yo/mqdefault.jpg)
I just love how genuine Sulli’s smile here. I will miss that.
Forreals. Haters will try to break you. Even for a genuine positive smile. The world is cold.
True🙁
Btw like your Profile pic👍🏼 (lookism)
a smile of an innocent angel who didnt deserve all of the hates :'(
Sulli🥺💔
Tabasco is my best friend, yeah that’s so sad-and I’m sorry if this is disrespectful but I love your name Jace
All of Fx’s song were definitely ahead of their time.
Ariya Leuanglitthidet their songs could come out now and still be iconic
they’d be so popular in this day and age if these songs came out now
legit
Ikrrrrrr
I hope they do something together even if it won't be under SM!
This group definately has the most experimental and musically interesting discography
everything about fx is so fresh unique and experimental, from outfits to musically
@@kyjunnie8372 liiko😀
@@kyjunnie8372 liiko😀😖
exactly, the best group from SM
Along with NCT 127!
Never forget how flexible Victoria is
Never forget Luna's powerful voice
Never forget Krystal's charisma
Never forget Sulli's cuteness
Never forget Amber's swag
Yessss
girl forget amber BYE
@@user-kljjnspkmah LMFAOOOOO
@@user-kljjnspkmah HELP😭😭😭😭
we WILL forget amber
Krystal 15 years old
sulli 15 years old
Luna 16 years old
Amber 17 years old
Victoria 22 years old
wooow
fifi MeuArmy krystal is 14
Can I have a 10,000 subscribers without any videos no 15. This MV in 5Nov and she was born in 24 October 😊
i am 15 wat am i doing with my life!
@@xklvi5646 correct the mv was released on the 5th of November but it would have been filmed a few months before it was released so it's highly likely that Krystal was 14 when it was filmed
She did say that she was 14 when this video was made
아기를 임신했을때 태교할때 사진 보면서 딱 너같이 맑고 예쁜아이였으면 좋겠다 라고 생각했는데 그래서 마음이 너무 아프다 설리야 좋은곳으로 가거라
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 설리야ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
그저 눈물 ㅠ
I had forgotten the MV until i read news about Sulli. At that moment, my impression of Sulli is a little girl who wear a hat and looking so young in the MV. She was so beautiful and pure in heart. Rest in Peace liltle girl, we will miss you!
They look alike. I don't know who is who. LOL ;p
Same
Me too. All I could see was her bright smile :(
@@henghengheng9416
Amber - shortest hair, rapper
Victoria - bangs, blue pants
Sulli - hat
Luna - slightly chubby cheeks
Krystal - long, black hair
I occasionally look up to this MV just to see Sulli. She had such a memorable visual in this MV for some reasons.
This MV was released more than 13 years ago, but F(x)'s songs, mvs, and their style are really suitable with 4th gen. Wow they totally ahead of their era.
This choreography is dope. I miss last generation kpop
anne-claude Baran Gen 2 is a reason why Gen 3 KPOP so popular !!!!!!
낯설게 심장병 시너지가 분노가 데스 손대지 수뇌부 빗나간 누구도 상대적 식당에 냉장고 본능을 지난 놔두고 싶은데 달고 복근을 장난감 싶은데 대기중 신동빈 손님이 지는게 같은거 반드시 지난 살아난 좋다고 구조는 보내고 저녁 오니 사다준 분노가 저녁 손대지 새벽 벗겨질 나의 두가지 순두부 지나고 아동복 생길지 제가 바다가 상대방 이기분 베개에 지난밤
Visal Hem 😍😍😍🇰🇷
You have red velvet and Sarah Jeffery
And I miss sulli😭😭😭
can we just talk about the fact that krystal was 14 here, Sulli 15,amber and luna 16 ??
they debuted at a really young age!! and so talented
ThIs iS uS
hahaha
+Ruby Seunghee Back Krystal is the youngest!
Really I thought Krystal was older than Amber lol I guess she just acts like it
+Call-Me-Myung Amber is the second oldest in the group!
+D.O IS MY BAE OKAY sulli and krystal was both in the same age in this video
2009 : Sulli was 15 years
2019 : Sulli was 25 years
We love you Sulli , i know you are in a better place now❤❤
Omg this song make part of my 'childhood'.
👏💖😞
MEU DEUS VC É ORBIT E MEU Q LINDO ISSO
i got goosebumps
Al-fatihah for sulli🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻
She’s with Jonghyun from SHINee now 😢
How nostalgic this was. This era was one of the real golden kpop era. I miss them so much : (
"Please don't misunderstand me. I am not a bad person."
You are not a bad person Sulli. I believe in you. Rest In Peace our Angel ❤
My heart is still broken. I cried when I heard the news. I still can't believe what happened.
No normal people ever think ‘she is a bad person’ so don’t have to tell.
WAIT WHAT HAPPENED???
@@emeralddevil3834 Sulli last word before she suici-de
@@emeralddevil3834
She was found dead in her bedroom on October 14, 2019. (I'm not an english speaker, use google translate)
지금보면 사실 어설픈부분들도 보이는데 워낙 비쥬얼이 뛰어나서 그것조차 사랑스러워보인다...룩도그렇고...설리야 조금만 더 살아줬음 어땠을까..아직도 늘 너의 팬으로써 더 적극적으로 표현못해서 미안해
sulli was the cutest idol during their early days ❤
😭😭😭😭
Why do i feel like f(x) can pass easily as a 4th gen group.
Probably cause they invented the teen crush concept which is very popular in the 4th generation
If you just edit in all the 4th gen zoom popping and make it look like they filmed the chorus in multiple takes that were spliced in then it would certainly feel like a 4th gen group.
Am I the only one who loves f(x) choreographies ???
bish they were winning multiple dancing awards back then for their choreographies
ZEGASI sorry . I am a pretty new fan and don’t know too much about them
Me too. Their dance always powerfull
Nope. I fell in love with them precisely for this reason. So organic 💕
Me tooooo
설리야 잘가 ㅠㅠ 저리도 환한 미소를 가진 소녀가 세상에 없다니..ㅜㅜ
F(x) is one of the few groups with a true female rapper
f(x)'s music and choreography are one of the most unique in k-pop. They are a legendary group
Sulli has to be the most adorable k-idol EVER!!
I wish they K-pop can go back to this era. f(x) was so underrated!
So you're telling that now you're all here because of Sulli? You can see that people don't appreciate art until it's gone.
iftv :p ikr. i never seen this much praise for her when she was still here :(
I think the most people who are here for here appreciate her and the art of the Band even befor there gone...
진짜 에프엑스 잘만든그룹이었음...
I was obsessed with f(x) in high school. I have since then realized I am bi and now I realize I did not, in fact, constantly replay Amber's sections because I wanted to learn the raps... it was indeed because AMBER
relatable
X2
SAME
Same.. it took me years to realise
이제까지 나온 걸그룹 중엔 최고같다.. 노래 춤 ... 매너... 실력 가창력... 팀웍...
I remenber being madly in love with sulli during this era bc she was immensely adorable. I miss her sm. I miss f(x) sm ♡
قديم
Who is here October 2020? I can’t believe it’s been 10 years already...
me because i always love FX
🥺
12 this year omg
I love how years later people are still watching this video
Wifey Ally I was suprised, because I didn't remember writing this comment
This song is so catchy
2019
Aside from it is f(x) and their songs are all good, what else can we watch? 😂 Seriously, we've been waiting for years. Lol
2021 but still here baby
8 years passed and I still watch it every time 💅 I really miss Fx
Alina Salvator mee too
Fans of SNSD are called Sones what are fans of f(x) called? thank you
kickit59 we are called MeU 💜
Alina thank you so much! I listen to f(X) every day!
Me too. ❤
F(x) girls have ones of the strongest voices ever
1:53 that little melody in the bg makes this song sound so nostalgic i miss simplier life and times, and i miss this kpop so much
양갈래한 진리가 웃는 거 보고 첫눈에 반했던 기억... ㅠ 진짜 다시 봐도 너무너무 사랑스럽다
10 years ago, I watched this MV during my high school days.
Sulli looks beautiful, innocent and perfect. I adore her beauty.
And today, I read the news.
I can't believe it
Rest in peace Sulli 😭
Sulli looked so happy in this music video it breaks my heart after hearing the news. Sulli you are and will forever be our beautiful angel
에스파 커버 보고 여기까지 왔다…..
이 노래가 나올 때 쯤 에프엑스랑 케이팝에 입덕했는데 아무것도 몰랐던 저의 인생에 재미를 주셔서 고마워요ㅜ 함수언니들 너무 그리워요ㅠ
I don't listen to Kpop as much anymore, but hearing this again brings back a wave of nostalgia. RIP Sulli.
에프엑스 최애곡
the views in this bop are disrespectful
sofi fr
This is pretty high considering the release date.
Amber raps like she got a riddle for us
LMFAO BYE😭
HELP
😭😭😭
HELLPPP SO IT WASNT ME WHO CAME HERE FROM TIK TOK
FOULLLL KMFAOAOOOAIDIFH
R.I.P Sulli
You're angel in my heart :(
When F(x) was a 5 member group.....
When Sulli was happy....
When Krystal didnt get all the screen time
and Amber...well AMBER IS STILL HOT AF AND MY GIRL CRUSH XD
+Ace Sulli isn't happy? :(
Well my baby used to be depresed thats why she left f(x) but now i hope she is happy as an actress and model and i hope her bf makes her happy ^^
+Ace Thought she left only because she wanted to pursue her acting career
Yeah actually there are 2 scenarios 1: that she was depresed because of haters and 2: that she wanted to pursue her acting career :)
I hope she's happy. She deserves the best. :)
0:07 지금 봐도 전설적인 귀여움이다 설리...
Chuu should make her redebut with this song 😌
Comeback pleaseeee!!!!
Youth Yogi 😔💔
unpopular opinion : this song is a *bop*
Hell *yes*
indeed
not so unpopolar
QualityBlood yes so catchy
And the unpopular part is...?
I just discovered f(x) a couple of days ago after liking a lot of other kpop groups and I am amazed. They are a marvelously motley mix that blends in so many super grooving elements with hooks, moves and beautifully pulsing vocals that are contagious. One of the most fascinating and original kpop bands with a kaleidoscope of styles, charisma, and so many fabulous songs. I hope Sulli will be remembered for all the joy she displayed in making the great music she gave to the world with the group, and that her soul will stay in this blessed state where her memories will be on these beautiful melodies now that she has passed away.
Better late then never. Trust me when I say f(X) during there run was always looked at a bit weird BUT they set trends that boy and girl groups in the K-pop industry would soon follow at least sound wise anyways, losing sulli has made f(X) such a sad topic in the K-pop industry
이 노래 나왔을때 진짜 좋아했어요❤ 설리 언니 천국에서 행복하세요
kpop was literally the most creative sounding music ever back in the day
f(x) shaped my middle school years and well into my adult life, too. this song will always be my favorite because it just has an authentic and creative taste and aesthetic to it that you don’t see anymore. love all of the members so much 😔💖 been a fan since 2011
에프엑스야…보고싶당………,,….ㅠ ㅠ ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 명작임,
The rap is the best part of this song. Get y'all's ears checked🥱
Why does this song sounds sad and breaking my heart now?
:
😭😭😭
RIP Sulli
😥😥😥
Same 😭😭😭
2018 is about to come and I'm still in love with Victoria's blue pants .. Like OMG 🙄❤️
saro_ona me too!! I wish I have one
Victoria is my favorite!
YASS ME TOO!!! that was always my favorite and Victoria unnie is just ❤️❤️
All of the f(x) ladies are beautiful & talented but Victoria is my special bias!
it now 2018 and still in love with Victoria. Like she is one of the most beautiful woman in Kpop.
Celebrating 11th Anniversary of f(x)
OT5 Forever!
Victoria
Amber
Luna
Sulli
Krystal
I miss this group so much, they were so unique and had so much potential. I wish them all the best for their current endeavours and Rest in Peace Sulli, we miss you.
f(x) is my ult female bias group and Sulli is my ultimate bias so watching their old videos bring me joy and sadness at the same time. Can't think of f(x) the same way again. I miss you Sulli.
not hating any new generation's kpop BUT it is true that old kpop is the best.
_Every time I listen to this, I will forever remember Sulli as the smiling angel that she was. Rest well, baby. We miss you._
This song is crually underrated
Their group name is probably one of the best among kpop groups alongside 2NE1..reminds me of Math and Math is my favorite subject! F(x) sounds like Effects & 2NE1 sounds like To anyone/twenty-one. such genius! XD
Yes!
Yassss!
omg i never knew that -_-
But they in the different company
KnuckleoticxMark18 and they are my two fav groups lol 1 f(x) then 2 2ne1
f(x) is such a really great group with good moves, baby-faced girls, smooth voice. But I dont know why SMEnt doesnt judge them well. They dont give f(x)'s fans even A FANDOM NAME for a long time. They dont take care of songs and cothes for f(x) as much as EXO or Snsd. Although f(x) is really talented and f(x) has lots of fans, SMEnt maybe doesnt care about that. I think if SMEnt makes more good things for the band, f(x) will shine MORE than a diamond. Fighting f(x) unnie a~
I finally found this song!! Omg I'm getting emotional, this song was a part of my childhood I'm glad I found it again
Fx is the complete package...
Dance, Voice ,beauty ....
Victoria Song is the best ....
Khuntoria Fan here..
Victoria's acrobatic is a legend in this mv.. nostalgic. RIP Sulli...
Who are here for f(x) M/V marathon with me?
Let's do it again.
Exo what?? Yeah
ME
It's me....
😭😭😭
chu chu chu chuuu
(It’s) true, true, true, true it's You~ :)
TheMarigold19 O_O
InfiniteZodiac grow up grow up grow up
2021에도 보고있는사람??
저요
저요
✋
저요😢
저요..
Sulli is very sweet ♥♥ ♥♥
Natural beauty without plastic surgery~
f (X) is one of the strongest, talented and amazing groups in K-pop !!!
15 years of love for f(x)
설리야 사랑해 왜 이렇게 되기까지 몰랐을까 이젠 너무 늦었지 미안해
f(x) is unique with their music stgle
When sulli looked so much like taemin. aahh my taelli feeling 😍😍😍
i miss u, guys 😢
I came here to see all of u ❤
i hope, even if just one member sees my comment to tell u that i'm still here to support f(x) 🥲🤍
I think I like them as much. Im constantly watching and listening to their songs…😮💨
flashbacks to 10 yr old me pretending that im not attracted to amber
I know right! Well I use to be really attractive to him ( her) but not that much anymore. И да , даров я тоже русская 🤗
Giereroid She is a girl....
literally me watching it right now. I watched this when I was 12 and did the same.
LEGIT ME TOO, NOW I'M AN ACTUAL BISEXUAL PERSON LMAO AND KNOW FOR SURE I'M ATTRACTED TO AMBER
I'm the same but with all of them
They look so young and their age in comparison to groups that debut now
Ati C Sulli changed tho
you know this is one of a kind because no other girlgroups of this generation can pull this off
💯facts 💜
두잇두잇 츄~ 지금 들어도 하나도 안 촌스러움
f(x) comeback please!!!
lunaaaaaa is the cutest
AGREED
So heartbroken about Sulli. There is nothing in this world that is worth taking your life for. It’s a permanent solution to a temporary problem. RIP Choi Jin-ri. I hope we can all learn from this and change this cyber bully culture to one of acceptance, tolerance, and unconditional love.
I was shocked when I read the negative comments towards Amber.
Why do you hate her so much?! She’s very beautiful, she raps well, she dances well.. What don’t you like?! But most of all the hate is directed towards her rap. Why didn’t he please you? Try singing rap yourself, huh then write something like this. I’m ashamed of you.
they hate her raps bc it’s cringey
@@ventaliqits not cringe💔
@@ventaliqit’s camp 😭
@@9ekoblickexactly
Whenever i watched KARA and F(X) mvs, my heart ache for the members..😔
SM gave up way too early. F(x) is so ahead of their time
Krystal=14 age
Luna=15 age
Sulli=15 age
Amber=16 age
Victoria=22 age
soojung and jinri are the same age though??
goran's mom Sulli is almost 5 or 6 months older I think
What !!!!!!
Krestal age 14 ???!!!!!!
Whaatt!!
Omg
Aram Samra Ikr. I keep rewatching this video trying to see Krystal as 14 but she's never looked that young to me.
New Jeans ETA reminds me so much for this song, I liked both groups but I lived in 2gen era and grown up with f(x), all the memories
My heart breaks watching sulli. Rest in peace little angel
They look so happy and fresh. + they're makeup is awesome.
2:17 and superfruit collaboration mv are one of my most favorite amber scenes .It is just that I love her beautiful eyes face and this dark hair color in combination .In shake that brass I didnt really like her style and blonde hair but well thats personal taste so it doesnt matter as much
Bet KARD I agree omg! I especially fell in love with her watching chu and nu abo.. she was hottet imo
설리 너무 예쁘다......인형같아........너무 보고 싶네.........
하~여기서 애들 얼굴 하나같이 애기애기하네~ 특히 설리는 완전 아가같이 해맑아~ 근데 이런 널 다시 볼수 없다니.....ㅠㅠ
정말 애썻어 설리야~ 고생 많았어~
이제는 그 곳에서 진짜 아프지말고 편안해졌으면좋겠어ㅠㅠ
FX 노래 정말 좋앗징 😢😢😢
I suddenly miss F(x) so I going back to the very beginning. Always love F(x) and will always.
i miss fx so much
I think Chu, LA chA TA and Chocolate Love were the most energetic Music Videos of 2009. The sweet 15 year old Krystal was so adorable and exciting to watch. It's no wonder that f(x) was the hit sensation of 2009. I have a feeling 2014 will be a super year for my favorite group of 5 girls. F(x)'s 5th Anniversary in September should be a great time for celebration after their greatly anticipated 2014 summer comeback.
이때로 돌아가고 싶어...
Rest in peace our sweet angel Sulli. I've loved you for 10 years and won't stop.
今のAmberしか知らない自分にとってこの映像はとても貴重
昔もこんなに素敵なんだ…