What is Wrong With The New Criminal Laws? Explained ft. Indira Jaising | IPC vs BNS
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 июн 2024
- In this video on The Wire's Zeeshan Kaskar delves into the significant changes coming to India's criminal justice system starting July 2024. The Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) will be replaced by the Bharatiya Nyay Sanhita (BNS) and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), marking the first major overhaul since the 19th century.
The cases registered before and after 1st July will fall under two different sets of laws, potentially causing confusion and delays in the judicial process. Despite claims of decolonizing the justice system, he highlights that 95% of the new BNSS is essentially a rehashed version of the CrPC.
With insights from renowned lawyer Indira Jaising, Zeeshan breaks down the issue into six key points: the arbitrary nature of passing the law, the reintroduction of the sedition law, the non-mandatory status of FIR registration, the delays in justice amidst old versus new laws, concerns about arbitrary detention and police power abuse, and the myths surrounding digitization and technology.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
The new 'Bharatiya' laws are not only idiotic, but also pernicious!!
I've been saying this ever since these 'laws' were 'passed'...!
Just like Agnipath/Agniveer scheme was the most idiotic & pernicious thing to occur to the Indian military & national security, so are these laws for Indian legal system, judiciary, and individual rights & freedoms...!!
Yet another classic example of BJP's ineptness of framing laws/policy...Beyond a certain point, ineptness can't be distinguished from malice...and I am beyond being charitable now, and I genuinely think this was done deliberately by BJP in order to make India a more police state...in order to retain power, and try to rule in perpetuity...
yet you aren't elected by people. they have right and they did it . nothing is perfect but new law is better than old in some cases. sometimes change is good even it little
@@shantanusapru like pmla amendment act
@@Krish-cz7tgThen What about BNS 69 ? Equality ?
@@nagendrarao5607 Exactly!
The PMLA act - as so many BJP supporters point out correctly but half-ignorantly - *was* brought by/under the UPA govt. But it wasn't pernicious until the Modi govt changed it to become much more draconian! And, then, unfortunately, the SCI justified it - wrongly, in fact, as so many legal scholars have pointed out.
Who knows, someday a 5 or 7 judge bench will overturn that too...
What is connection between new law and Agniveer and Agnipath. And under old PMLA act culprits were easily bailed out and destroyed all evidence by threatening concerning men.
Modi granpa should travel in Indian made car. Why he travels in a bulletproof car that's imported from Europe?
This New should be put on hold. They have created these laws with out proper discussion with legal experts.
Thank you so much for enlightening us. God be with us to protect us as justice could be further delayed than it is now.
What was need of new Law? However, these law are amended by time. It is just botherness to common people and chance to be blundered while proceedings. BJP is stuborn party and they want to themselves to registered the name in hisotry only. They don“t has sentiments with people of Our Country.
What is the need for Judiciary as a whole😅
PJB is making laws just for their own benefit they don't do any discussion with the law experts they are utilising their arbitrary powers for making these laws that is why there are lots of confusion in these laws...
Why has it been taking years and years for cases to be investigated since Independence.
Humara durvagya hai ki dangerous criminal humare desh main crime law's bana raha hai.
The goal of bringing new criminal laws according to Mr Amit Shah is to free Indians from colonial mind set but not to ensure speedy and fair trial and justice.
First read the Laws and then talk
@@ChandranPrema123 I read it precisely
They need to freed from monarchy mindset (remember the sengol drama)
@@kanwarsingh2127 it's good but they gave more power to police which is a problem too. Let's see
@@Nikhilsharmxxxxx1928 more power to judiciary is also not good .power power to mla mp is also not good 😂
SC needs to scrap this immediately.
Supreme court has no right . Are you a traitor ?
SC won't. They didn't pull back the EVM when they had the chance.
All the condemnations by SC are a drama. The corporate elites want to dismantle this country and Modi is their best slave
They can't, it could only be removed in Parliament.
This analysis should be done in every Indian language including Hindi
Thanks Kaskar for an insightful video. These apprehensions are solvable if the opposition focuses on issues and not power. For eg opposition can demand a constitutional amplification or legal interpretation of sovereignty, integrity, and unity. Thanks
Seeing the situations of india ,the new laws may harm more to the society.
What is opposition doing?
The laws have already been passed when most of the opposition members were suspended from the Parliament.
@@prasfutita_ still its pass by parliament they had majority they pass it opposition can't do nothing.
court follow laws made by parliament with elected people of bharat
Opposition is busy celebrating its increased seat share.
@@haider9373 still can't do anything.they cheat ppl with 1lakh jumla but it's will backfire in upcoming elections
@@haider9373 they aren't in majority even there is too many parties. clashes between them will start in State election because of servival and ideological differences
The direct n most negative impact of new laws will be huge n drastic increase of corruption
When uneducated leaders are ruling the country and changing the laws, we educated guys shouldn't be concerned about digitization and implications.... Why don't we use our brains to become more creative ?
If Indira ji had enforced these three laws along with PMLA and UAPA durin 1:06 g emergency,many of the current BJP netas would have been in jail today without bail. Declared vs undeclared
Gubber Singh Taxes and Thadipar Law👿 we entered into 😱.......😭
Amit Kaal begins in India from July 1, 2024
Why this is hurriedly being implied without consent.
Why not implementing Police reform which is pending since 2006?
Really thanksfull to Britishers how they manage and controlled from infrastructure to everything. 😢
Excellent presentation on laws made by its breakers 👏
Even the Judges and Lawyers should be in the same position what the citizen will face, They have forgotten they are also the citizen.
Including police
New laws are just old wine in new bottle with a little mixture of poison
SC should take suomotou case to stay this implementation of new criminal laws.
Did British made the law your choice ?Nothing is so ideal that will satisfy every one.
Time limits are important for the judgments OR order in the Hon. Courts?????
If Indira Jaisingh says it is bad, it must be excellent.
Zeeshan, Thanks for simple explanation of the new laws.
Some Political leaders can do positive OR negative in the democracies nations ???
Thank you Zeeshan for this short but elaborate explanation
Very articulately presented and cleared explained. Will Mr Narendra Modi's picture appear as the first page of these two new laws?
These laws can be reversed by the new government
@@anthonycedrick3328 If and when a new Government appears! I, of course, hope it does but hope and reality don't always meet.
Zeeshan Kaskar ji ka do din phele ka ' bantara ' ki report ka video nehi mil rahi hai, hum share nehi kar pa rehe the ab to video hi nehi dikh raha hai 😢
Kay video delete kar di gayi hai????😢
Very good analysis
Thanks
Now that it has become a law, just follow it. This is the mandate of the majority of India. You have no way.
seriously! were the crimes done after keeping criminal justice system in mind by accused or is the pain and struggle simply changed due to dates of filling the crime?? what is the point of exercising IPC or CrPC the old provisions the old way!!?? how is that justified!!?? I Don't Know. All cases should be exercised in accordance with new laws except for the ones that are actively on trial in court for which the final hearings or such concluding dates are set or maybe give this choice of delaying the matter due to changes to victims if they want a trial in accordance with new or old laws!? otherwise I fear what kind of reaction we are gonna receive from public.
Look who's talking about Civil Liberties! The Indira Jaising 🤣
1. Criminals are making this law.
2. Bill was passed without any proper discussion.
3.It was passed during the suspension of MP's which is not valid...
Criminals and anti nationals only should fear with the new criminal laws
When The Wire is opposing the new law MEANS new law is going to be Effective
It must read was what was good of old laws for criminals!
FIR won't be mandatory, SHOs will decide if it is required, case by case basis
Dissent will be illegal by law
Getting bail in any case might be unattainable
I also saw that for mob lynching group of perpetrators will have to be above 5 people as per new law
Can Judiciary not intervene in such cases where laws are unlawfully passed in the parliament,?
Laws have been lawfully done in Parliament .
@@user-vg8mz5re5i hard to enlighten a blind bhakt
All tyranny begins with a promise of paradise.
Thank you The Wire
Nice . Informative.
Nicely narrated.
It is not that The Wire and Arfa doesn't have problem with a MP chanting *"Jai Hindu Rashtra"* in the parliament.
They are not talking about it because if they do it then they will get a backlash of people for not calling out Asaduddin for chanting *"Jai Palestine"* which The Wire, Arfa and every indian muslim believes to be from heart because they have allegiance only to the ummah as Dr. BR Ambedkar has written.
Technology should make detention unnecessary
Great analysis sir
Even judging services should be held accountable
All objections are flimsy. Oppose for some logical reason, which none of you have including Indira Jaising
How can this can be discussed publicly and then passed?
The first amendment in BNS should by bringing the gender neutral Section 69. It is a violation of the constitution.
Nicely put
It id for courts to interpret New Laws
After 1st of July or FROM 1st of July?!
What was the FIR procedure before Lalita Kumari Judgment. Unfortunately you never demanded prior the Lalita Kumari...
It is a old wine in a new bottle There is going to be lot of confusions in implementing
This time wine is bitter in taste.
Yeh files mai hi rehta hai.. Ground pe koi nahi maanta hai.. Yeh beedtantra hai.. English pinglish nahi chalta hai yahan... Delhi mai baith ker badi badi bate.. Gang land democracy bolte hai isko.. Mano ya na mano
Wire is as usual vituperative. With giving concrete remedial advice, spewing venom on an attempt to do away the colonial blot which Thaper endorses as he was a product😂🤣 of Colonial grooming
Why Modi Granpa travels in a European Bullet proof car?
Did they scrap the "My lord" phrase ???
We are doomed
The subtitles have many errors, it is confusing at times.
These laws were made in RSS bhawan .
What’s the law for all these scams under this govt
All these shameless judges want is there old system, where they could play around and The Wire is perfect platform for it
Thank god atleast this govt took initiative to change the law..
Our old laws were unconstitutional for middle class and lower class
Can you give an example
95% of the old law has been retained, and some worse things have been inserted. So listen to the video carefully several times before feeling elated
Where it is that the police won't right the FIR? However, reverse has been done FIR can be filed from anywhere in India. Kuch b!
Law are made to defend Privileged... colonial structures or manusmriti are to defend privileged and Bhramins..
New laws of new India
इसमें सोचना क्या, पूरा कानून ही जनता के अधिकारों को कुचल कर पुलिस राज्य बनाने के लिये है ताकि विरोध को दबाया जा सके l
Harassment law for some
Apex court needs to be explained
Sorry but your quoting sections and the written section on your video is different
THE WIRE, YOUR SUBTITLES FOR THIS VIDEO ARE MESSED UP 😅😅
Well were old law passed by democratic means
If 95% of the CrPC is copied, then how is it going to cause a massive confusion?
It seems you haven't listened carefully
@@ganeshbanerjee9841 I did. I listened till the very end. CrPC is considered a mix of substantive and procedural laws. The confusion of retrospective application of procedural law and prospective application of substantive law is understandable. But my question is directly to the claim made in the beginning of this video. You can rewatch the video and then perhaps I can ask you: did you watch and listen to the video carefully??
These are the same lawyers who lectured in law schools and students that the English law is now changed and amended but our Indian law is still in colonial hangover. I mean what nonsense is this! I'd ask people to read before drawing opinions from news narratives. As before CAA some of the lawyers stood and states it is discriminatory to muslims in India. And then what took place? None of them lost their citizenship.
And for any new change some cumbersome process will take place. Why can't we be united there?!
In future if any south indian MP'S talk about tax injustice and say "we will be threatened to the extend that we will be forced to ask for separate nation" for example..then the government can file a case against him and put him on jail...so much for freedom of speech lol 😂
Hey bhanumati cha bhenssa cha Kara pura shudhikaran udao garmi
Please scrap IPC ans CRPC
WHAT DO YOU SAY ABOUT OWASI QUOTING JAI PALISTINIAN WHILE TAKING OATH
New laws are anti social humanity creating police state
👍
We are also not in favour
Congress Godi Media.....
Dont bother about India. We know madam is an urban naxalite always batting for left & congress.
Though I am not a BJP supporter I do welcome this procedural change of the justice system. It was a joke before with this idiotic thing called 'stay' and the perpetrator freely roaming about and missing the hearing and taking a vacation and so on and the judges conveniently reserving the judgment for a later date etc.
The person who is writing the text should be fired😂
fear mongering in these anti nationals
😍
each time someone says BNS, all I hear BS!
MASTERMINDS of Gujrat 2002 riots are making laws 😂😂😂😂😂
New Criminal Acts 2023: ruclips.net/p/PLGVC8NNwDBjbj4r4kibUkSjDaxACZ7OKr
Oh karan thapar and indira
jaisingh no need to see
Anti national more scared so opposing it expected.
Anti national who
Subtitles are fucked up
Please replace the original names ! Disband colonial names ? then you need to disband hindi or sanskrith names ! there are languages far better than these two ! or simply keep English !
Lot of mistake in new law only copypaste
Its evolving...but Backwards
Why didn't these lawyers fo and stall this law
Because....Laws are passed in Parliament. Not by lawyers or judges