Supreme Court says abortion pill can stay on market
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- The Supreme Court ruled that the abortion pill Mifepristone can stay on the market. The justices found that the anti-abortion doctors did not have legal standing. NBC News' Yamiche Alcindor, MSNBC legal analyst Leah Litman and Reproductive Freedom For All President Mini Timmaraju join Ana Cabrera to discuss.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/...
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#Abortion #SupremeCourt #Mifepristone
Kicking the can down the road. Not good enough.
They're not kicking the can. They're trying to shore up Republicans in Congress.
@@justinfowler2857Punting is kicking it down the road! But, the pill can still use the drug, but it doesn't address the fact that in many states, the laws on the books still remain for doctors being at risk for prosecution in the process of treatment and things done before leading up to abortions.
Yup. They’ll be back for your rights next term after the election.
Planned Parenthood was intended to give democrat parents advise on how to raise better children. PP found that was nearly impossible, so they resorted to abortion to prevent democrats from giving birth.
It's a states rights issue
Deal with it
All it means is that they're looking for a "better" plaintiff for their agenda.
Thats the very first thing I noticed too. "Ah so you don't think it was brought to courts by the correct people"
the next case will be brought by people with "the correct legal standing"
They didn't say that , they made a decision based on Country over Party. All 9 voted No. Why bash the decision ?
@@JimmyDiamond-vi1bs they literally said it in the video? it was rejected based on STANDING. open your ears.
@donb6897 They have to have a reason to vote No or Yes based on legal bounds. They explained their Legal reasoning. Sounds like a Decision in which they put politics aside all 9 & voted what's best for the Country & Citizens
I cant imagine any plaintiff would have standing. If you arent using the pill you arent harmed by someone else using it, and if you are using it that was your own choice.
Let doctor's treat their patients and stay out of their way, Government. This applies to not just women but anyone that needs medicine to make their lives better. It's no one else's business.
And it's crazy that not that long ago Republicans would have been the ones to say "keep the government out of medicine" and now all they want to do is stop people from getting medical care if they "just don't like it".
It's sick.
Yes it is, as huge majority of people see abortion as killing. Same as you see ,,normal" people get killed and we see it as bad, so is abortion seen as killing for others.
@Almora-gp3hs thats your opinion, and people differ. Btw its not women, its menstrual person or birthing person per liberal gibberish lol so please reeducate yourself.
@Almora-gp3hsBoth of you are wrong. A majority of Americans think medical decisions should be made by doctors not politicians. And until about 23 weeks gestation the chances of surviving outside of the womb are pretty much zilch. Most terminations happen well before that. And sometimes even wanted pregnancies have to be terminated for medical reasons, such as fetal death or incomplete miscarriages.
@@kam1470 Actually, a "huge majority" of people in the US see abortion as a personal choice, and one in which the government should play no role.
Please understand, the reason why they have decided to do this is because of the scrutiny SCOTUS is going through. See project 2025.
See project 2025 coupled with Seven Mountains Mandate. Scary ish
I think they are softening the blow for trumps immunity
@Almora-gp3hs I would NOT be all that upset.
Project 2025 = Real life Handmaid's Tale.
@Almora-gp3hs Don’t post crap like this. I understand your anger/frustration but you issued a vague threat of assassination. Cut it out.
I think they are getting a little worried about all the bad attention they are getting now.
They should be.
They need to be held accountable
Right!
Wait til after the election. It will get worse
Trump told them to back-off during election season
They are just trying to deflect from the leaked alito audio. Trying to claim they work for everyone. What a joke
For the record, this case is only a temporary minor win. THIS DOES NOT PROVIDE CERTAINTY OVER ACCESS TO MEDICAL ABORTION! It just means that for now the drug remains legal and that others could still ban it. This doesn’t end their attack on reproductive rights.
Exactly !!!
We gotta vote blue to protect our democracy.
Biden / Harris 2024
Yes, this wasn't a good case. If someone with standing comes along, the outcome might be very different.
Their attacks won’t end until at least a generation or two after our education system is fixed.
And that system is being dismantled too.
@@LulaMae21 They only way these religious nuts will stop, is if they are stopped.
For now!!! Another group will challenge it
Court did not rule for the FDA😢
After the Nov. election. You can bet on it.
doesn't matter.
the initial decision by the texas court was profoundly stupid anyway.
ofc the FDA had authority to approve it, ofc the drug is safe, and ofc the FDA was correct in approving it.
what's more, even if the FDA approval was revoked, the drug would still be available. they couldn't actually ban its use, worst case scenario the FDA would simply give it emergency approval as it went through the approval process again.
it was a stupid lawsuit, the supreme court realized there was no way to keep the ban.
Awesome, they've made the kind decision to not play doctor.....bare minimal competency.
100% political. You can bet the GOP was on the phone telling them to soften their stance (for now) to appease their constituents. They KNOW their abortion stance is hurting them at the polls.
Actually, all they just said the wrong person brought this suit.
They didn't even do that, they just said the plaintiffs were the wrong people to bring the suit.
Do you believe that there should be laws regarding medicine, or that the medical field should have any sort of legal regulation/oversight at all?
If so then that means that courts are going to be making decisions about medicine. Stop clutching your pearls and pretending that they shouldn't be involved in matters of medicine.
Are you an anarcho capitalist libertarian? If not then you don't even believe what you're saying anyway, you just don't like this particular supreme court but don't want to say that, and instead say something you don't believe about how courts shouldn't be making rulings about medicine.
@@duncanreeves225 FDA and Board of medicine makes determinations for medications based on Science specifically because they focus on evidence based practices for the public good. The courts are supposed to determine law, not medicine practices. It appears you do not understand nuace or have the understanding of the differences of specialties and how the government and medicine has been structured specifically for the public safety and so they (and you) can have access to appropraite care.
I'm waiting for the "But..."
I agree! There has to be a but somewhere
Me too..
Liberals like the but don't they?
But they'll hear a case on this next year, and rule in favor of the christian extremists.
It was rejected because the plaintiffs didnt have standing. Which means the GOP can shop around for an entity that does.
*This only stops this attempt by the people who are trying to take away our right to healthcare.*
*The fight IS NOT over! Remain vigilant.*
“Right to healthcare “ Genius wording to push the agenda on through all the years.
Your right to healthcare?? You mean, your social life? Most abortions are not done because of "healthcare" reasons. Lets be honest here: They are done for convenience reasons!
Calling abortion healthcare is like hiring a child molester to babysit your kids.
Time for congress to legislate out the Comstock act
IMMEDIATELY
The lower court knew that they did not have standing but still went ahead with it because politics and not law.
Yes, Matthew Kasmaryck (sp?) is ridiculous.
@@LulaMae21 Kacsmaryk. Just the “c” was misplaced :) Now, I knew that his ruling for this mifepristone case would be filled with pro-life and partisan BS but I was _not_ prepared for the level of insanity that was actually contained in Kacsmaryk’s ruling. It’s vile. I finally had to stop reading it. When I did, I realized my face was bright red from anger and my jaw ached from how long I had unconsciously left it dropped open from shock. That man is far too dangerous to hold _any_ position of authority or power. He shouldn’t even be a shift lead at Target.
I don't trust the Supreme Court for one second. I will be voting for Biden and Harris. For House and Senate Democrat straight ticket. Once you have shown me who you and the words come out of your mouth, the women of America believe you. We will stand up for our rights and vote BLUE!
Don't trust them. They have ulterior motives. VOTE BLUE
Exactly!!
That's the right attitude. They'll affirm a national abortion ban if it makes it into law, guaranteed.
nevermind the republican theft of a scotus appointment during obama's second term.
🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵
Breaking: SCOTUS dodges the issue until after the election. This isn't a win by any stretch.
Yep.
Rejected not because the court supports easy access to the medication but because the plaintiffs here lacked standing. Kavanaugh explicitly says this decision is NOT about limiting the authority of regulators and legislatures. The next time around the decision could go the other way.
Opinion: They're throwing a bone to fend off actual action to fix the nice little sinicure they've built.
Anything to actually back up that opinion?
@@duncanreeves225 Aside from watching and studying American history and culture for a little under 60 years? Specifically, the Conservative judges although not unintelligent, seem to have misjudged (pun intended) the reaction Dobbs was going to cause. It bodes ill for upcoming elections, based on Republican performance since. In order to finish the judicial coup, Trump must win. Otherwise, the other party will take actions to "fix" the court(s). PO more women, and the men who either love them, or are answerable to them? That will sink Trump for sure.
@@duncanreeves225 if I'd not prefaced my remark, would you have responded?
Ok.
But this doesn't change anything for the removal of the crooked judges!
America 🇺🇲 is still wanting justice.
Agreed!!
I agree! Sotomayor and Jackson must be removed now.
Ouch!
The russian bots are strong in this comment. Pretending like the court is runaway and not actually making coherent rulings
@@duncanreeves225 I mean, you're here so yes Russia or no, someone is here trying to divide people. There is so much proof the judges we currently have are extremely biased. But, go off I guess.
Supreme court justices, still have no standing. Too little too late.
Too little and far too late. The damage has already been done.
It seems more like a bone thrown to the masses so that they don't become completely restless.
Especially with the caveat that the case can be reopened at a later date.
As she pointed out the courts only said not now but as soon as a republican is in the white house you can bet this is going to come up again. We all need to vote so we can win the House and Senate and change these laws so we can bring back Row Vs Wade and make abortion legal in all states.
I am glad you have a voice in the matter must be awesome you were not aborted "Living Your Life Living the Dream" Right ?
🟩🟧🟧The Court is looking out for the Republican Party. They’ll come back and do damage later.
They're just throwing people (women) a bone thinking that's going to fix the mess they made....
Yes, and it won't work...Vote Blue 🌊🌊🌊
Damage is already done, America has seen this court for what it is.
We are still going to Vote Blue for what happened with Roe. They think this is going to blunt that anger 🌊🌊🌊
You all did Roe to yourselves. Stop bringing cases to the Supreme Court if you are unwilling to accept the outcome. Roe would still be in place if it wasn't for the Dobbs case.
@@fauxque5057what are you even talking about? Those cases were brought by conservatives. This is the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard. Another conservative hoping to escape CONSEQUENCES of their short-sighted actions. 😂
@@fauxque5057 Uh... what? Republicans brought Dobbs.
@@fauxque5057republican conservatives did that.😅
Democunts.
Alito and Thomas still have to go!!
Too little too late.....the damage is still hurting women's health
How would you know, man
The GOP’s interfering in their health care is still hurting them yes.
@@c0zyb34R what if his wife or sister is going through it? Why do you ask men if they know how women are suffering? You don't know them. You don't know if they had to watch someone suffer and nearly die from pregnancy. You don't know if someone they love was forced to be pregnant by an abusive lover or not.
@@c0zyb34Rhe reads articles like you should. There are women in hospitals with sepsis waiting as the fetus is dead
How about just swallowing?
Alito &Thomas still have to go! This is just a start.
Too little too late..only half assed.
Says who?
@@jamesswain2465 Everyone with any sense of impartiality.
You need to.go!
The video should have name shamed the original fringe right Texas judge whose ruling was overturned.
Shocked but happy for women in the USA! 😀
Well...imo it will come back if trump gets in and then they will make a new decision. They just think the wrong people brought the case to them
Even the women in the womb. Happy for them, too? Are you a women? Are you happy to be alive?
Nice registration date government bot
Whats annoying about this is that when the case was first brought by these doctors (after they found a favorable judge and set up shop in his area), people like Leah said "they dont have standing"
This is a lot of time, money, anxiety all caused because the right's favorite judge in texas was enthusiastic about entertaining this made up standing.
Alito and Thomas still need to be impeached and Roberts should retire since he's ceded control to Alito. Lacking standing has not stopped insane rulings from this corrupt court.
The House won't vote to impeach and if it did the Senate would not convict.
Try again.
@@DRKrust492 The OP stipulated (correctly) that Alito and Thomas “need” to be impeached, not that they _will_ be impeached either the GQP in Congress.
Ok. So you are OK if this country continues the murder of innocent children.
Oh thank goodness.
Good. There is absolutely no reason to ban it.
I literally can't believe the psychotic break this country is having. Makes one want to VOTE!!! NOW
There is no reason to have unprotected set and get pregnant I'd you're not prepared to raise a human baby
@@stevenbrown2316 You're not the morality police. Shut up.
@@stevenbrown2316 I don't think you're experienced enough to understand that accidents happen. Also abuse and SA happens. Just because you have your safe hand...👌🏻
Tell that to men@@stevenbrown2316
Thank you MSNBC✨🇺🇸✨💙✨
Oh I'm sure they did, they didn't want to feel the wrath of millions of women. They are already in a bad light
The wrath is coming, regardless.
Obviously bc they weaponize the cps system to recruit their scarce military in the future, instead of acting like they want peace in a world full of delusional people
Crossing my fingers that every women responds with, "Too little. Too late."
@@mile_high_topherno it’s not. Roe died but Trump got voted in to be the gop nominee even though he proudly took credit. And he’s likely to win again. Contraception will be banned as long as the court is 6-3 conservative. Wait and see.
Are they single Issue Voters 😂
SCOTUS, demonstrating the old adage that even a broken clock is right twice a day.
If they do something you don't like it's not because they have an actual reason, it's because they're corrupt.
Then people say all sorts of unsubstantiated claims like how they'll ban contraception, interracial marriage, etc. When they make a ruling showing that they definitely aren't doing that you ignore it and say it's "a broken clock being right".
@@duncanreeves225 Yeah... you're at an 11, and we need you at more like a 5.
Not nearly good enough! Thomas and Alito need to GO! Ginny Thomas needs to be prosecuted for bussing domestic terrorists to the Capitol on Jan 6th, and Alito’s wife needs to be investigated for HER part in Domestic Terrorist activities!!
Awful that it isn't definitely protected. 😢
@@ernstoesterreicher Congress doesn't approve medications, neither does the Supreme Court. Leave medicine to doctors.
@@mile_high_topher What you don't want a bunch of people who studied Political Science and Law tell you what medicine you can have. Next you are going to tell me that you don't like MBAs working for insurance companies deciding if you can have a treatment.
It's refreshing that the SC voted unanimously & put Country over Party. It's shows Idenpendence from political pressure.
@@JimmyDiamond-vi1bs No one is buying that 😆
@@JimmyDiamond-vi1bsThey made a ruling on standing, not the germane issue.
They’ll be back for this right (and others) asap. Their god can’t abide freedom.
Thank God! ❤
Great now get ALL rights back. Keep up the fight Women. Keep marching for your rights. NO MORE COAT HANGERS.
More importantly, VOTE.
Thank God. Now do the Immunity case
"Fasten your seatbelt."
Bette Davis
Why would you say thank God about this... Look up the info about God and abortion
They really want grant it, just can't figure out how to make it only Trump.
God gave us free will.
That’s all God gave us. A choice. Republicans want to take that God given choice away.
@@NolocoLawrencehave you seen the cases where women almost died going to some other state to get emergency d and c? I just saw one where the husband almost lost his wife, ridiculous.
The only reason it was unanimous is because Men don’t want to pay for the Babies!
This was only done for polling issues/concerns. After the election, I would expect this to change.
It’s absurd that SCOTUS had the gall to consider this at all.
And the immunity case ... just delaying for Trump.
Stop bringing cases to the Supreme Court then. Roe v. Wade would still be in place if it wasn't for the Dobbs case.
The Supreme Court doesn't make up laws, that's congress's job. Their job is to apply the constitution to cases brought before them.
They would have banned this drug, if the SCOTUS wasn't in the middle of scandals.
@@brothertaro2008 Intentionally bungled the 14th amendment case, too.
Even a liberal Supreme Court would have taken this case. The district court (aka the trial court) enjoined the FDA’s approval of mifepristone, effectively taking it off the market. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals then heard the case and ruled that only some of the FDA’s approval decisions were unlawful, which still allowed mifepristone to be available but with more restrictions. If the Supreme Court hadn’t taken this case, those restrictions would remain in place.
Supreme still need to go
Scotus sure is showing a crack finally,keep chipping away at the corruption..Good work Women. Proud of you
How about it's election year and they don't want to shoot themselves anymore in the feet than they have already done. Everyone is aware that this is a Republican Supreme Court!
We are playing the long game. We will keep working to keep our rights.
No they're not! Ever heard the term, "Not making a decision requires a decision." My take? They're buying time to get Trump re-elected. Don't want to PO 51% of the voters any further than they have.
I don't think they are cracking ? I think they are waiting and HOPING for a better plaintiff. They showed us their cards with past rulings.
This was weirdly patronizing…
It should be available to all women!!! No old men in government should be able to tell women what they can do with their bodies!!! 🙀
I think we are past that, I agree, but the government is constantly telling people what to do with their bodies. I think the precedent is set that it is ok for the government to do that.
That just kicked the can down the road to let the dust settle about their ethics.
It will return when they have their people in place.
❤
Right
@RickWalters-gw2ed TF are you talking about?
this doesn't change the call for reform on SCOTUS ethics and disclosure.
I bet Alito's wife is bustin out a flag right now..
Nah she still goose-stepping
As long as she doesn't wrap herself in it and take a selfie🤮....I've just had my dinner and I don't want it to go to waste.
@@iandennis7836 Or the image of her mounting it to Alito’s pole.. sorry about dinner..
She needs a GAG ORDER to stop her from saying things that make us GAG!!!🤮
Well of course, it’s a pharmaceutical.
Big pharma not gonna let that go.
Imagine the Left start to peddle, "Oh the Supreme Court made this ruling so that the Right won't lose so much elections."
Everyone who was going to vote blue will still be voting blue. This changes nothing about that. 🌊
I mean.. Alito admitted that he only cares about the right "winning."
Oh! Oh! Mr. Alito will be getting an earful from the mrs. 😂😂😂
No government or pair pants has the right to tell a woman what she can and can’t do with their body! Abortion is not to used as a birth control.
Even if it is though, I could care less what people do for birth control
They've just angered a few MAGA types 😊
It's for votes. Let's see how many complain
People on the right in general would agree with you on most points about abortion. It's the lefts extremes and right extremes that don't agree with each other.
@jillganz6381 how could it be for votes if the supreme court isn't elected?
Yawn......, so.......?
@@SpanishGold123 MAGA is the extremists.
How dare the supreme Court make a decision like that, AFTER they irresponsibly leave abortion decisions to EACH STATE!!!
DISBARR EACH SCOTUS's THAT ARE CORRUPT!!!🤬😡🤬
Why are we even debating this?
Because christian america wants to impose its will on the rest of the country.
Perhaps the truth is starting to make them squirm.
Oh yes . Let's go back to the 1800s! Comstock act needs to be abolished once and fir all. Women unite!
Well said - this is based on standing not merits. No reason to celebrate, the GQP justices will do what they were appointed to do if and when they have a legitimate path.
I wonder which flag Martha Anne will feel compelled to fly today?
Does Gilead have a flag?
Why should people connected to law rule on medical issues?
they know everyone is watching them! it's about time they do the right thing, even though the ban on abortion is endangering women's lives. Now, we will still be watching about the decision on "immunity".
Vote blue 💙💙💙💙💙
This was 100% political. They know whatever rulings they make NOW will have a negative impact at the polls come Nov. Wolf in sheep's clothing.
Correction; BREAKING: Supreme Court says abortion pill can stay on market.........for now
Good news everyone! ❤
Except for the unborn
@@jamesswain2465cry harder weirdo.
Nice registration date government bot
Alito cannot remain on the Supreme Court. Two flags, not one. And Martha-Ann can take her shame to a psychiatrist.
Vote 💙💙💙💙 and hope is there to impeach justices Alito, Thomas, and any person in authority that enables behind the scenes injustice.
I’m sure this is just a local before they do something much, much worse.
The biggest surprise is those conservative Justices doing the right thing for once.
They are just doing it as a distraction for when they give trump immunity for being a criminal
They've got enough heat on them right now, see what happens next year.
Nice registration date government bot
Say in your lane
Every once in awhile the Supreme Court accidentally does something good! They're going to allow America's women to save their own lives! That's the America I love, the America that honors everyones freedom!!
They did it to seem better after the scandals. If there wasn't scandals, I think they would have ruled differently. Zero trust.
@@einienj3281 They'll 100% ban IVF and medical abortion as soon as they feel they can get away with it.
I wouldn't trust those conservative justices any further than I could throw them.
No accident. This was 100% political. They know whatever rulings they make NOW could have a negative impact at the polls come Nov. Wolf in sheep's clothing. They're just biding their time.
This is temporary. Lose the exclamation points.
It's insane this is even being considered
WOW Unanimously?!! Wtg DOCTORS!!
Lacked standing. How many of those should there be?
It is coming to all states if elect republicans at all, including state wise
Seeing these thank God comments on a post about the abortion pill not being banned. Seems some of you folks need to do your homework in regards to gods and religion and abortions. Because there are people suffering because of these abortion nonsensical rules based off of religious nonsense
God gave us free will.
That’s all God gave us. A choice. Republicans want to take that God given choice away. The Bible is not God. The word of man is not the word of God. God only gave us free will.
I THINK you'll find that these days it's a figure of speech......certainly as an agnostic I use it myself 🙄
YOU need to do YOUR HOMEWORK Re: United States Constitution; SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE!
That’ll change if trump gets back in
@@jonathanboam5409the only time trump tells the truth is when he’s being/talking violence. Republicans have an entire project 2025….
He won't. Stay calm.
@@TheSaltydog07 🤞🤞I hope you’re right 💙
Nonsense
@@rensinclair4218 he brags about overturning Roe sooo it only stands to reason that he’ll go all the way ..he also said there has to be some form of punishment for women who get an abortion.. what planet do you live on !🤦♀️
Word
🌏🇺🇸🦾↕️🔄↕️🦾🪞💫🫵🏽🌈🫵🏻💫🌈🫵🏽💫2024.people Amen 🙏🏾🦾🌊🌊🌊🌊🦾2024. Times let Get it 🌈Done.make it make sense 🌈🗳️
Quick reminder that abortion rights still need to be codified either federally or through state constitutions.
Wonder what the Republicans are feeling now
Nice registration date government bot
How benevolent of them...
I love these things!
YAAAYYYYY!!!!!!
The prices at my Walmart are going down thank you Joe 💙🇺🇸
Forward with Biden 2024💙🇺🇸
Forward with Democrats and Democracy 💙🇺🇸
The old "one step forward, two steps backwards" routine.
That right.
Time to get scotus tf in line. Corrupt!
Would have been better if the court never gave the case standing to begin with, but this is a rare scotus w
More like SCOTUS might have thought twice about disbanding the FDA and the US postal service, which is constitutionally protected.
Yayyyyyyy🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
So these judges can't seem to make up their minds...
---- We need to get term limits on these clowns...
TOTALLY AGREE, & return to 1 vote for 1 person - whoever more Americans vote for wins. ( Gore, Hillary,...who's next?)
"Supreme" Court: You lack standing to bring this case.
Me: So basically just keep trying the case ovwr and over again until it's not an election year.
No standing = bring another case please.
Tbh, I think if what was just released about scj wife didn'thappen. This would have gone totally different
"I don't care about you, I just want your vote." ~ Donald Trump
Woohoo! One correct ruling is better than none. I’ve learned we need to enjoy the little wins because this is going to be quite a fight!
The problem is that while plaintiff has no standing to challenge the FDA, congress does. Congress gave the FDA the power to make these decisions and congress can take that power away if the gop gain control. Vote Blue!
Ohhhhh,thankyou your majestys,on behalf of wombs everywhere,thank you sovereign lords.
Americans must get a large majority in the House and Senate to get anything done without maga obstruction. VOTE DEMOCRATIC, up and down the ticket.
Firstly
Ok. Maybe it's compromise?