JOHN BONHAM'S CYMBALS - THE CRASHES - ANALYSIS AND DEMO

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 115

  • @stevengood6434
    @stevengood6434 3 года назад +30

    I am really glad that you and Terry take the time to make all of your videos.

  • @rick3747
    @rick3747 3 года назад +13

    I love the rides and crashes on "Stairway", "Kashmir", "Carouselambra" and of course "Fool in The Rain."

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +2

      Would love to see clear pics from the studio sessions

    • @rj7826
      @rj7826 3 года назад +1

      @@BONHAMOLOGY If only our present day A/V tech had been available back then...

  • @joerico9461
    @joerico9461 2 года назад +2

    Hey I'm one year older than you lol,but we're still Rockin 🤘👊 Hey to Terry ✌

  • @billytrance6893
    @billytrance6893 3 года назад +3

    Wow! That ride is awesome!!!

  • @anatar1166
    @anatar1166 3 года назад +5

    I haven't played drums for ca. 20 years anymore,
    but after these drumming demonstrations of yours, dear George,
    my hands and feet are itching... damn...

  • @jamietaylor2888
    @jamietaylor2888 3 года назад +4

    That snare sound is awesome!

  • @Ds_Drums
    @Ds_Drums 3 года назад +11

    Congrats on 10k! You deserve that and more. Anyone who studies John Bonham would benefit greatly from your knowledge and talent. Fun to watch and thanks for posting. See you tomorrow on the live chat.

  • @bryandrums32
    @bryandrums32 3 года назад +3

    Great video with great intel!!!!!! Your the man George!🙏🙏

  • @goesjem
    @goesjem 3 года назад +2

    George, this is so great to see man! I have two sets of black label 2002. Same sizes in both standards and mediums. All between 1971 and 1976. 15'' Sound Edge, 16'', 18'', 20' and 22''. I use the medium set more. They have more sustain and are marginally louder. I use the 22'' medium as a ride. Sometimes my 1986 2002 24'' ride. I love Bonzo's cymbal sound. They glisten in the mix! I love your 602's buddy. I really think Bonzo used the 602's on stuff like No Quarter and Down By The Seaside. They are very distinctive and ring even longer than 2002's I think lol. You and Terry are fantastic!

  • @earldrum
    @earldrum 3 года назад +4

    George congratulations on the 10k subs! You are a wealth of knowledge on these cymbals! Stay warm! Great video!

  • @DaveDamageDrums
    @DaveDamageDrums 3 года назад +3

    Great video George! Congrats on 10k subs, and this channel deserves 100k subs and more, since it's the School of Bonham for many of us. Cheers!

  • @rorymcclellan3740
    @rorymcclellan3740 3 года назад +2

    The cymbal videos have been craving my hunger to learn more about bonzos sound! I can't wait to sit down to steal fills and licks out of this video! I really look up to you and Terry as drummers not too dissimilar to how I do even my fathers playing. You guys really know how to rock!

  • @chriskarp1877
    @chriskarp1877 5 месяцев назад

    Thanks for sharing all your knowledge.

  • @kevinm8871
    @kevinm8871 3 года назад +2

    I need more Paiste in my life. Currently only have a 20 inch Giant Beat multi (reissue), and I like it a lot. When I break it out, I usually use it as a ride that I can lay into as well, rather than a standalone crash. Right now Im trying to decide between a sig full crash, 602 Modern essentials crash, and a 602 paperthin.

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад

      Nice! I love my paper thin 18 and 20.

  • @lundsean75
    @lundsean75 3 года назад +4

    Bonham also played 2 crashes to his left on the 1980 Tour Over Europe. .

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      Correct

    • @6x14ludwig1992
      @6x14ludwig1992 3 года назад +2

      @@BONHAMOLOGY
      Those are the only pics I can find of him with four crashes- two on each side. I always wonder how his kit would’ve evolved had he lived. Maybe just my OCD, but I prefer the look of the just one crash on each side.

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +2

      @@6x14ludwig1992 Yes, he played four crashes in Europe 1973 as well as Europe 1980...something about Europe I guess!

    • @goesjem
      @goesjem 3 года назад +2

      Also sometimes in 1972.

  • @doktoruzo
    @doktoruzo 3 года назад +2

    beautiful drumming man! and such a beautiful sound

  • @tonymann848
    @tonymann848 3 года назад +3

    Nice demo! You could make pie plates sound good but these are all beautiful.

  • @kevinpledger3088
    @kevinpledger3088 3 года назад +2

    I love that you do these videos. I have learned so much. Your an amazing Drummer. Thank you

  • @toddlittle9095
    @toddlittle9095 3 года назад +2

    Great video!!!

    • @porgie66
      @porgie66 2 года назад

      Thanks Todd!

  • @jamesgullo8240
    @jamesgullo8240 3 года назад +1

    Always loved the 2002 series. And the Formula 602 ride I once had and wish I never sold in the 80's. Great video that answers alot of our questions.

  • @edl3441
    @edl3441 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for the vintage photos of JHB.

  • @Baker504
    @Baker504 3 года назад +1

    Great video. Cymbals sound great 👍🏻

  • @portal432
    @portal432 3 года назад +1

    Keep it up George, your channel will keep exploding! Congrats :)

  • @iorijones6351
    @iorijones6351 3 года назад +1

    Thanks George, a fantastic lesson into Bonzo's crahes, so interesting. Your knowledge and playing is immaculate.
    Stay warm, with all that snow.
    Take care! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🥁👍

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      Thanks !!

    • @iorijones6351
      @iorijones6351 3 года назад

      @@BONHAMOLOGY Hi George, really enjoyed the live chat yesterday. Looking forward to this evening, and congrats on hitting the 10k subscribers!!
      Yes Bron yr Aur at southern edge of Snowdonia National Park near town of Machynlleth. Beautiful area of mountains and scenery, no wonder they went there. If ever you come over we can take you. We are right on the Dee Estuary 20min nw of Chester, an hour from Liverpool & Manchester (airport). If you are on a tour let us know !! Hope you cleared your snow too ! Thanks and take care ! 🥁🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🥁

  • @mjm5081
    @mjm5081 10 месяцев назад

    Thanks so much for sharing!
    Really enjoy your playing!!!
    Happy Drumming!!!

  • @fox5.043
    @fox5.043 3 года назад +1

    Great video & loved the pics with the info. Your collection of symbols is unbelievable man! Thanks for the video & congrats on your subs very well Deserved.

  • @brent3760
    @brent3760 9 месяцев назад

    You, Terry and Dan Garza are the reasons i got some Paistes! Ive always been a 50,s Zildjian guy, i have A LOT of them! Bit i got some pre serial 602s finally, and WOW! They are amazing!!!!

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  9 месяцев назад

      That's great! 👍🏻

    • @brent3760
      @brent3760 9 месяцев назад +1

      I'm already hooked and can't wait to get more!! I wouldn't say they are better than the old Z's, they are just different. And wonderfully different. So clean! ​@@BONHAMOLOGY

  • @Latitudedriver
    @Latitudedriver 2 года назад

    Love all that you do George! I would love to see some charted sticking for some of the fills. Great job…

  • @ronvallejo7987
    @ronvallejo7987 3 года назад +1

    Love the content, I’m here in Chicago your right it sucks!

  • @dashleannnn
    @dashleannnn 3 года назад +2

    this should be the intro to all videos

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      LOL. I'm so glad someone likes my singing! I think a lot of drummers are wannabe singers. 😀

  • @heyholetsgo
    @heyholetsgo 4 месяца назад

    nice video, i got the giant beats and love them. also live in chicago and am not crazy about our winters ha. served carmine a minestrone soup once.

  • @SwiftSean11
    @SwiftSean11 9 месяцев назад

    Those Giant Beat hi hats sound beautiful

  • @scottbryant2235
    @scottbryant2235 3 года назад +1

    Thanks so much for your contribution and detailed observations! I am extremely disturbed as to why Paiste is in the shadows of the other cymbal manufactures. I guess marketing and advertising rules over perfection.

  • @jimflys2
    @jimflys2 3 года назад +1

    Liking those 2oo2s a lot. The 20s,as you point out, are really similar. I think when you really lay into them, there nearly no difference. The pitch definition disappears. All are lovely. All these years, I thought he was playing 2002 except on really early stuff. Did no know it was until 77 when pretty much changed them all out.

  • @jefftegenkamp8939
    @jefftegenkamp8939 9 месяцев назад

    I prefer the 602’s and 2002’s over the Giant Beats also love the Sound Edge hats. Great videos George and thank you for passing on the knowledge.

  • @AdamStachelek
    @AdamStachelek 3 года назад +1

    Great knowledge in this video. Man I have a pre serial 602 22” ride and it is nowhere near as shiny as that one. Guess the oxidation got it. Love this series

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад

      Thanks Adam, I have another 24 602 but it's pretty dull looking as well. I have a feeling someone waxed up this one !

  • @bonzoleum
    @bonzoleum 3 года назад +6

    44th LIKE!!!!

  • @SONORSQ2guy
    @SONORSQ2guy 3 года назад +2

    I favor the 2002’s. 👍👏

  • @davewestner
    @davewestner 3 года назад +2

    Cool, love the history lesson. thanks for digging into the internet archives on the subject.
    I've always thought that Bonzo's crash on the first album was a bit of an outlier. I've got some cheap cymbals that kinda remind me a bit of it, and I reckon he didn't have a ton of money back in those days for fancy cymbals. No idea if Paiste had budget line cymbals back in those days, you know, like they had Paiste 400 line for a while? Something like that.
    cheers

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +3

      Yeah, I suspect it was a 16 Zildjian or Zyn. Paiste had the cheapo Ludwig Standards, which sounded pretty bad IMO unless you got lucky. Before that they had the Stanople, amd Stambul lines. The better quality line was 602 made of B 20 Bronze

    • @toddlittle9095
      @toddlittle9095 3 года назад

      Paiste (post WWII) always had budget cymbals. First Paistes were nickel silver Stambuls with brass Zilkos (1947) being the budget line. In 1957, Paiste starting using B20 with the Super Formula 602 line with Stambul and Zilko slotting in underneath. In 1959, the Formula 602 line that we all know and love came out with Stambul and Dixie slotting in underneath. At some point during the 60s the budget SUPER line was introduced. There was also a very rare, short-lived nickel silver line called Paiste Standard (these were not Ludwig Standard) sometime stamped as Zilko Standard in the late 50s/early 60s. The Ludwig Paiste (3-star), Ludwig Standards and Paiste Stanople (actually rebranded Dixies imo) were only sold through Ludwig in North America. Paiste's first B8 cymbals were the Stambul 65 (released in 1965 - this is a different line than Stambul - They did not replace the regular Stambul line like a lot of people think) and then Giant Beat in 1967.

    • @davewestner
      @davewestner 3 года назад

      @@toddlittle9095 dang, great info man, thanks!
      I actually thought Zliko was Zilco....is that a whole different company? Or am I remembering something incorrectly?
      So there's a Stambul AND a Stambul 65?
      I wonder why I've never seen those? Rare? did they not make it out of the 70s because rockers beat the daylights out of them?

    • @toddlittle9095
      @toddlittle9095 3 года назад

      @@davewestner Zilco = Zildjian / Zilko = Paiste. Yes, Stambul and Stambul 65 were two distinct lines. Many think that the S65 replaced Stambul in 1965 and that production of NS12 Stambuls ceased after 1964 , but that's incorrect. Stambul 65s are seen more often in Europe. I have a friend in Germany who has something like 10 of them and LOVES them. Ludwig didn't distribute them in the USA, so there aren't many around in the States. You don't see too many Stambuls or Dixies in the US for the same reason. Ludwig didn't carry them because they had their own versions. Ludwig Standard were Stambul or Stambul-quality and Stanople was Dixie or Dixie quality. Plus they (S65) were only made from 1965-1973. The original Stambul line was made up until 1978 (switching to being made of B8 alloy sometime around 1971/2)

    • @davewestner
      @davewestner 3 года назад

      @@toddlittle9095 Thanks for the info. Just when I thought I had heard of all the Paistes!
      Must have been confusing having Zilco/Zilko.
      Zilko is most definitely not a very googleable cymbal.

  • @nigelprettyc3
    @nigelprettyc3 3 года назад +1

    All lovely like 602s very much I have old 15 giant beat top over 602se there keepers

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад

      Oh I should try that! I never mix them up , for some reason.

  • @CraigFlowersMusic
    @CraigFlowersMusic 3 года назад +2

    My favorite is the 20" 2002 medium. By the way, have you ever heard my channel? I do full studio covers, mostly Zeppelin. I recently got Bonzo-sized drums and a new Gibson Les Paul, and I subsequently recorded a cover of Whole Lotta Love. I have Immigrant Song, Stairway, Black Dog, Friends, and right now I'm working on Fool in the Rain. Might be worth checking out.

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      I will, thanks for letting me know. I'll check it out!

  • @JackNiles
    @JackNiles 10 месяцев назад

    Keep warm

  • @enricosimonotti7239
    @enricosimonotti7239 3 года назад +1

    I'm blown away for the overall sound of your kit! Can you describe your mics set up? Types of mics, positioning, a processing, thanks

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      Yes, I will try to do that a bit in today's live chat , snare tuning video

    • @enricosimonotti7239
      @enricosimonotti7239 3 года назад

      @@BONHAMOLOGY thanks!

  • @geoffreygriffin4807
    @geoffreygriffin4807 3 года назад +1

    Thank you for the awesome knowledge sharing G!...If you could own only one Giant Beat crash what would it be?

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      Thank you ...prob the vintage 20

  • @chrisdavies73
    @chrisdavies73 3 года назад +1

    Great information, thank you. Ever thought of documenting your knowledge in book form?
    I purchased some Promuco reissues. I now have Bonham, Peart,
    Bruford, Carey and Gavin Harrison sticks. The latter are truly tree trunks! Any idea what Bill Ward used? Thanks again.

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      I really don't know what Bill Ward used. Thanks, I haven't thought about a book myself, but the idea has come up with Terry and Billy Harrington lately . He researched and wrote the article in Modern Drummer about Bonzos Thermo kit.

    • @chrisdavies73
      @chrisdavies73 3 года назад

      Thanks.
      Check out the Ringo story. Superb!
      ruclips.net/video/WDvA_g71Cb8/видео.html

  • @Clominee
    @Clominee 5 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks for all you do, George. Do you really think Bonzo used 2oo2 crashes and ride on the '73 US tour (and TSRS)? The Paiste agreement doesn't show him getting them until '75. I've recently become obsessed with his cymbal sound on TSRS and I'm chasing them (particularly the crashes). Are you basing your theory of him playing 2oo2 crashes and ride on sound or visual?

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  5 месяцев назад

      Thank you! Yes, I'm certain based on photos from the tour. You can clearly see he is using 2002 hi-hats and crashes and a giant beat ride. The agreement or invoice is not complete. Not sure why. He used the 24-in giant beat on the 73 and 75 tours, he started using the 2002 ride in '77

  • @daviderossi9235
    @daviderossi9235 3 года назад +1

    Great video George! I prefer the sound of 2002s and maybe the 602 ride. What are yours preferite ones?
    I just bought a 1977 2002 20" medium and it perfectly matches with the 19" crash, red logo. Now I'm wondering on how to clear and protect it, I cannot find the paiste protector anywhere.

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      I really like them all equally , just different reasons. I suppose the 2002's would cut better than the 602's live.

  • @MichelPeindaries
    @MichelPeindaries 11 месяцев назад

    la 18 fait 1734gr c est plus lourd que les 602 actuelles et les 2002 power crash , c est très épais !!

  • @jaxonsavagedrums
    @jaxonsavagedrums 3 года назад +1

    Hey George! I love your videos! I just bought a 19 inch Giant Beat! In your opinion would a 20 inch Giant Beat Thin compliment my 19?

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      I would assume so, but I'd have to hear them side by side. I do r have any experience with the 19 . Thanks!

    • @jaxonsavagedrums
      @jaxonsavagedrums 3 года назад

      Awesome! Thank you so much

  • @dugbopper
    @dugbopper Год назад

    What sticks do you use when you play these big drums?

  • @joshuajuaire8757
    @joshuajuaire8757 2 года назад

    What drumsticks are you using

  • @toddlittle9095
    @toddlittle9095 3 года назад +1

    The 18" 2002 Crash is from 1977 not 1972. The first digit (7) of Swiss Paiste from this time period reveals the year.

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      Yes, I must've mis-spoke. 😁

  • @jametz66
    @jametz66 3 года назад

    sorry if I missed it George, but ... what's the gram weight of the SECOND 20" you put up (the 'crash' model)? Thanks ... (btw, ... fellow 1966-er here too! ... 55 on Sunday!)

  • @allrequiredfields
    @allrequiredfields 3 года назад

    Hey George, a bit off topic, but what Zildjians (model, age, weight) do you think your average successful pop/rock drummers were using 64-69? So many drummers had this really distinct Zildjian (probably) sound, and the best example that immediately comes to mind is, let's say, Bill Ward, first Sabbath album - it's that super smooth, broad spread, big hollow bell sound. James Gang The Bomber is also a great example, especially in the Bolero bridge.
    I used to think that these guys were all simply playing brand new Zildjians, from 66, 67, etc but the 60s Zildjian As I've played never sound quite right, and then I started thinking these guys probably had the cymbals they were using for years, so do you think that sound is more 50s or perhaps pre-Ringo or do you think these guys were playing brand new cymbals?
    The only new cymbal I've played that has that type of sound is the new Giant Beat 20" (that size specifically) - which I'm obsessed with.

  • @brettt1268
    @brettt1268 3 года назад

    Is the paiste 602 traditionals a new cymbal close to the vintage 602’s or just a 602

  • @markmainchannel
    @markmainchannel 3 года назад +1

    What do you think Bonham used for a ride in Stairway?

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +1

      It sounds like a 602 , to me.

  • @sticksbass
    @sticksbass 3 года назад

    isnt it hard to find a paiste w a decent sounding bell?

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад +2

      Not that I've found. I like the bells on most of my Paistes, at least the vintage ones. The 24s especially

  • @gregthompson7053
    @gregthompson7053 Год назад

    I enjoy your videos however, I am confused if you look at the Paiste agreement for John Bonham‘s contract, you were clearly see all of the 20 inches that he ordered were all ride cymbals not crashes. All of the crashes were medium 20002s 602s and giant beats, but if you look on the list all of the 20s all the way up in 77 are all ride cymbals so was that recorded wrong? On the contract?

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  Год назад +1

      Hi, so that list cannot be considered complete as it is missing 2002 cymbals that were clearly used in the 1973 US tour.

    • @gregthompson7053
      @gregthompson7053 Год назад +1

      I just did some research and I never knew this but there’s no such thing as a medium crash. It’s just medium when I called paiste their medium rides or multifunctional can be used as crash or ride but in the 70s they classified them as medium ride now they’re just classified as medium. This explains the confusion

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  Год назад

      @@gregthompson7053 Yes, They made their distinctions like thin, medium etc however the 2002 line had "RIDE"

  • @markkugs6622
    @markkugs6622 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for the history of his cymbols it was interesting! You have a really nice collection there. I always thought they were giant beats at 70RAH. So if I have it correct Bonham used the medium 2002s on TSRTS? in particular No Qtr they sound really good. Thanks!

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад

      Thanks Mark. No way to know if they were Mediums but he did have 2002 18 and 20, amd 15 hats....the 24 was a Giant Beat

    • @toddlittle9095
      @toddlittle9095 3 года назад

      I agree w/ George, chances are he was using 602s at RAH.

    • @toddlittle9095
      @toddlittle9095 3 года назад +1

      and according to that sheet he didn't go to 2002 SE HHs until late 1974 - 602 SE up until then (unless clear picture proof exists of him using them prior to that). You have to keep in mind that 2002s didn't come out until late 1971 and I don't think they added SE Hats to the 2002 line until 1973. I have never seen any 2002 SE with a 1972 serial (yet)

    • @BONHAMOLOGY
      @BONHAMOLOGY  3 года назад

      @@toddlittle9095 That's interesting. I don't accept that list as being comprehensive though. Clearly he had 18 and 20 2002 crashes in the US 73 tour , but they are not noted in the list. So either that list is incomplete or Bonzo simply had some either purchased or given to him off record.

    • @toddlittle9095
      @toddlittle9095 3 года назад

      @@BONHAMOLOGY yeah, I'll agree with you there. These old lists are never exact. They always had more cymbals in the bag.

  • @nchcroy3877
    @nchcroy3877 3 года назад +1

    Im going to say something controversial and will probably get shouted at but to be perfectly honest I do think that George Fludas is a better drummer than John Bonham was (JB was still a master of course)
    He seems a much more versatile percussionist whether he is playing Jazz, Big band or of course rock.
    That said, I never saw JB playing any of the aforementioned jazz or BB style so I could be completely wrong and he might be equally as versatile as George F.
    Please note, this is only my subjective view based on my preferences - Im not trying to spark a "my dads bigger than yours" debate.. :-)

  • @earlbrackett6508
    @earlbrackett6508 2 года назад

    that 20" sings...very nice.