This lady ( host) tried to establish that she is more knowledgeable in geo politics than Mr. Kishore Mahabubani and constantly interrupted in the midst of the conversation.
@@kumanet99 China 🇨🇳 is now a super power. Let's acknowledge it. India still has miles to go. John Mearshmier was asked by Palki Sharma about India's global position as a powerful nation, in which Prof. Mearshmier replied diplomatically that lndia can consider herself as an " aspiring super power"
I too felt that she should not have interrupted Mr Kishore M in an unprofessional and disrespectful way so many times. Mr Kishore is a highly accomplished person and should be given time to complete his sentences.
Thanks to Trudeau's expert diplomacy, India is fast-tracking its border settlement with China. With that out of the way, India has a clear shot at a permanent seat on the UNSC-especially with the U.S., U.K., and France cheering from the sidelines. In 1960, Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai proposed a compromise to resolve the India-China border dispute, suggesting that China would recognize India's claim to the eastern sector (Arunachal Pradesh) if India acknowledged Chinese control over Aksai Chin in the western sector. This "package deal" aimed to settle the boundary by dividing the contested areas between the two countries, with China prioritizing Aksai Chin for its strategic link between Tibet and Xinjiang. However, Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru rejected the proposal, as he was unwilling to return any territory gained by lines drawn by its former colonial master. The U.S. maintained its embargo on China during the Great Chinese Famine (1959-1961) discouraging other nations from sending food, while millions died of starvation. Confident that China is weakened and will collapse, India implemented its "Forward Policy". If this border issue had been resolved in 1960, the past 64 years of mutual suspicion and distrust might have been avoided. Anywhere in the world, if there is a border dispute, it is usually the result of a line drawn by an Englishman; if it is an internal dispute, it is usually the US fueling it with diplomatic, financial, covert, and military support. Difference in implementation of divide and conquer strategy.
The Indian anchorwoman interrupted Mr kishor and deliberately to stressed terms like Indian century, Indian superpower, Indian supply chain, Indian influence, but honestly speaking, no offences to hurt the Indians feelings, we didn't feel any Indian influence or so called Indian superpower or Indian century, my friend used to invested in India but after three years he shifted his production again back to China and ASEAN countries, he once told me it's bad idea to invest in India where authorities don't respect any laws and rules. Indians may brag about themselves Indian century but reality is not. We are seeing East Asia and Southeast Asia are integrated with each other and booming together but India is not part of the club.
@@christopherpaul4698 india did not give anything. They are just promoting yoga for their own popularity. Because they have nothing else to give or contribute to the technologically advanced new world order.
@@pausereflect5911she is definitely not alone. I heard many Indians including young Indians believe Mumbai is way more advanced than Shanghai. Even college professors telling students to study and work hard otherwise China would overtake India. Maybe this is what Mearsheimer is referring India as “aspirational” super power?
I'm a Chinese. I have to say. professor Kishore. you as a overseas Indian. I felt love and belt to your mother land from your words. As for whether locals in India can feel your true intentions. Then it depends on their fate.
You are underestimating Kishore..He has way more love for Singapore & ASEAN!! His love for China & India is equal but with a big admiration for China's economic success!! This success though was built on American/European political elites literally breast feeding the Chinese communist party who was smart to take advantage!! That said, you have a point!! India will have to dilute the western style democracy & it's colonial echo system to rise as a real economic power!!
Kishore is a SGP born and serve NS too !! Mahbubani was born in Singapore to a Sindhi-speaking Hindu family who were displaced from Sindh province during the Partition of India.[5][6] He attended Tanjong Katong Technical School and St. Andrew's School before he was awarded the President's Scholarship in 1967 to study at the University of Singapore (now the National University of Singapore), where he graduated in 1971 with a Bachelor of Arts with first class honours degree in philosophy. He subsequently went on to complete a Master of Arts degree in philosophy at Dalhousie University in 1976. Mahbubani was conferred an honorary Doctor of Philosophy from Dalhousie University in 1995.[7]
@@PurnaVarma-rk2rg Southeast Asian Chinese is a broad concept. This includes. Malaysian Chinese who have good relations with China. And it has almost nothing to do with China. Indonesian Chinese. There are also Chinese people who are warlord leaders in northern Myanmar. also. The relationship with China is neither good nor bad. Singaporean Chinese. Uh, What I don't quite understand is why you forcefully added a CCCP title to China? Although I know you mean to humiliate China, but I didn't feel very offended
peace is not good for the media. The Indian media makes money on clicks and views and having strong nationalistic, negative or antagonist headlines is what they need. So expect them to keep slandering China solely for purposes of profit even though it absolutely is detrimental to the well being of the 1.5B people in India
China is playing a Long Game: it is waiting for US's global economic , technological & military power to get much weaker & eventually becomes impotent to China's aggressive expansionist threats to its S E Asian neighbours' & India's own Himalayan border states sovereignty......China is waiting for such moment to dictate its terms to dictate its terms to settle its border disputes with India, knowing full well that a weak US leader of QUAD in the South China Sea will not pose no threat to it & similarly a weak US will not assist India should China invade Arunachal & Ladhakh....US's economic decline has begun & hence its inability to project itself militarily is will follow in due course, thereby making making S E Asian nations & its satellite states... So, your suggestion that India & China should henceforth focus on improving living standards of their people cannot be right for India ...Unless & until China surrenders Aksai Chin, occupied regions of Ladhakh & renounces its claim on Arunaxhal Pradesh within a set time frame of say, two years, India must revert to freezing its relations with China, as it has done since 2021 & consider China as a serious security threat to India's sovereignty.. Reestablishing friendly relations with China now must go hand- in- hand with securing the return of indian territories occupied illegally by China & at the same time reject outright China's claim on Arunachal Pradesh....
If you say something, say it openly. Putting down dot, dot, dot does not work on diplomatic subjects. I presume, you are saying that India is thinking too much of the grounds gained in this outcome between itself and China while you making an irrelevant drag of Bollywood on to the point you might have in your mind and can't verbalize it. Can you specify the world's No. 1&2 instead of pressuring that everybody's No. 1&2 are the same globally? And lastly, India is far, far behind in what? Or do you just like to condemn India? In managing the Muslim population control and their national patriotism, I agree that India is far, far behind than Israel who manage them far, far better. But if you meant in terms of anything else, who knows what you meant? Or are you just an all time coward that can't spell yourself out? A few other Muslims seem to have given you a thumbs up for saying that India is far, far behind even without knowing in what terms you meant that.
@@hirendesai6473When india sent weapons to Israel, it has no reason in unsc, period. A country country turned a blind eye to humanity, shouldn't even be in un.
Dividing India into multiple countries would be beneficial for the Indian people but disadvantageous for politicians, as it would reduce their power. In ancient times, India mostly consisted of many independent states. Before the British arrived, there were over 500 states on the Indian subcontinent. At that time, the economy of the Indian subcontinent was extremely prosperous, with its GDP even surpassing that of China. When the British came, they forcibly merged many of these states into one to facilitate governance under a single administrative structure. For example, Kashmiris and people from Tamil Nadu, who originally had no connection, were forced to live in the same country. Similarly, people from Kerala and Manipur, who had nothing to do with each other, were also compelled to coexist in one nation. This led to extremely low efficiency in the Indian government. Additionally, people of different religious beliefs, such as Kashmiris, Nagas, Manipuris, Andamanese, Muslims, Hindus, and Christians, were forced to live together in one country. This resulted in constant resistance across different regions, significantly increasing the cost of governance in India. A lot of money was spent on maintaining social stability and suppressing uprisings, leaving little for improving living standards and economic development.
BS!! Bharat was culturally ALWAYS ONE NATION & ruled the world for thousands of years with a binding & powerful central leadership!! It thus needs to DE-COLONIZE By reinvigorating it's culture, going back to it's roots & have a stronger central leadership!!
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 India is a subcontinent made up of many smaller princely states never a united country under a central government.. Only afterl being conquered or colonised. A modern day comparison is just like European Unions. States can just leave like UK leaving EU. Kalistanise separatist is just like the Taiwanese separatists government.
@@wionporky9937 BS!! You are ranting a FALSE & COLONIAL History written by the savage criminals against India & humanity led by the British/Europeans!!
That is why India truly needs to become Bharat!! In effect, it needs to DE-COLONIZE & go back to it's cultural roots and being in a political system that gives a strong central leadership!!
India should learn to keep their part of the bargain. Regards to Indo-Naga issue, India has never kept their part of the numerous Agreements with the Nagas, the latest being the Framework Agreement 2015 and the Agreed Position 2017. They think that talking smart and winning an argument is sufficient. After having invited such an eminent personality, so rude for so many interruptions without allowing Kishore to complete his ideas. And she even gets the "Act East" wrong as "Look East". Anyways, "Act East" is a non-starter. India is paralyzed by contradictions. All just "acting".
Perhaps India's dream to be a developed 1st world country is possible, if it managed to overcome what are its fundamental weaknesses. Anyway, having such lofty aspiration is a good start!!
Indian politicians always dream big but unable to achieve. Modi wants to make India a superpower by 2047, it’s really a laughing stock. Did Modi who run the largest democracy in the world manage to alleviate millions of Indians out of poverty? I predict in next 30 years, India will still be an impoverished country and will find it difficult to achieve developed status least to be a superpower. Cut down on defence budget and help the ordinary Indians who are struggling to make ends meet. Resolve your huge internal domestic problems first - rampant corruption, racial religious violent, primitive caste system, infrastructure deficiency, income disparity, abject poverty, etc.
@@merrick6484 this is what the western deep state wants to do to India by investing billions funding and grooming the anti-india forces. But Modi is an obstacle therefore the hate propaganda on him by the west.
Agree completely ...they can only boast, look down on China as a way to cope with their own inability to develop their country ..their head keeps getting bigger due to the unjustified flatterings from the west ... China should never never accept India into the big 5
india never said it wants to be a superpower. it said, when india grows it will help others to grow as well. that is the mode of the developing india under modi and indian ethos. By 2047 it wants to be a self sustainable developed country you are like the anti modi congress person. india has only proved that a patriotic indian, can significantly develop a country with so much of poverty left over by the colonisers, the british and the moguls. Congress could not do much to talk about in 70yrs., but modi govt. created india with in 10 yrs crossing the hurdles from religions with hidden agenda in india, congress that supports them for their own survival, and the pseudo hindus who are anti modi. and islamic atrocities in india. india with indians are not an easy task country to run.
India will never be a UNSC permanent seat member, stop dreaming. Think about how to improve your country's sanitary system for the benefit of your people first.
The problem is greatly contained with incorruptible PM Modi. Wait for Trump win on November 5, 2024 and B B Netanyahu freeing himself the very night and Trump backing PM Modi. China is making deal with India totally in anticipation of the Trump win which is also the case with President Putin.
The stupidity of the Non - Chinese is not only one way but in many ways . India is a good example . The Brilliant Lee Kuan yew ,a Non- Indian leader had the foresight n pragmatism to tell that India lost 5 decades of misopportunitues . Build up the economy first .
Very short answer, India needs to coordinate with China or Russia otherwise India will be poor and poor under the yoke of western Colonizer with to much of overconfidence just like this lady 😂
We can now argue that UK was great as long as it was colonial power and could exploit it. It won the WW1 and WW2 using the manpower of the Indian army. Without the Indian army, it would have lost the middle east and all oil supplies that they dominated. Without the larg army, it would have lost the african continent and its large reserves of resources.
As a Chinese citizen, I have no objection to India replacing the UK as a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council. It is likely that Russia and France also would not oppose it. If India makes an effort, perhaps the United States might remain neutral or even support India. In this scenario, the only opposition would come from the weakest member of the Security Council, the UK. This could be the option with the least resistance for India to become a permanent member of the UN Security Council.
@willy6658 It would be easier to remove the poorest and weakest member, Russia. Their only support on the council comes from China, a country which does not even have universal recognition. Both of these states could easily be removed to be replaced with Germany and Japan A security council consisting of the USA, UK, France, Germany and Japan would better represent the global power balance, and be much better equipped to settle global disputes, as we saw during the Korean War
BRICS is interested in economics prosperity and not wars. This is good reason to resolve such border conflict that would creat friction to cooperation for mutual interest.
Architecture , Brotherly Love , Cotton Expl : Architecture Eg. The Musical Pillars of Madurai Meenakshi Amman Temple . The Big Temple in Thanjavur , baffling world architects as to how there is no shadow on the ground of the huge granite boulder atop the temple . Brotherly Love Eg. India through PM Modi dispatched thousands of vaccines to many needy countries abroad during the height of the Chindemic. Cotton Cotton was first grown in India about 6000 years ago in the Indus Valley Civilization .
If you want to continue to live your delusion when the entire World has ack.Indian prowess in the field of healthcare and IT just to name a few than you are entitled by default to live your delusion
You don't understand because you've been living on another planet ever since MODI became PM if India in 2014....go & educate yourself about India since 2014
It's unbelievable that the 2 most populous nations are neighbours. It's inevitable they will cooperate, despite some challenges, as they search for new markets for their products and produces. And when these two great nations work together with their complementary talents and resources, they will be the world's dual engines driving up global prosperity. Nothing could be done by the global north ti stop them.
Stop dreaming, never gonna happen! India is not strong enough to carry the weight, not even mention it doesn't have any influence to other nations. India is a bench player, it'll never be changed.
India is a Land of Dreams . Has the highest mountain ranges in the world . Musical Granite Pillars . The highest Motorable Road in the World . Kurunji , flowers that blossom once in 12 years in the Western Ghats ( Moutain Ranges )
As always the Anchor had to inject her personal beliefs into the dscussion and by that her personal professional integrity on the line. It is a no no in good journalism and in chairing a session such as this by NDTV. There is clearly no independent perspective. She is like most Indians, not independent of thought, forensic or detached (emotionally or politically) from the subject matter. Her views come out clearly. It i characteristic of the untravelled Indian in India.
India is smart in the political game. the border issue is just a "tool" to unite the whole country to act hostile toward China. India was thinking to benefit as much as possible from US and western governments when they are rivalling with Chinese. but the reality and facts show them that is not the case. Eventually, they didnt benefit much and India realised the comprehensive supply chain of China will determine the success of India. I think the Chinese know the Indian's strategy and they are pretty calm in dealing with India.
surely kishore will gets in big trouble cause all he speaks are the truth😂. truth hurts. best for him to play the platitude games just like how your lord modi do it
India media hypes everything to a point of being a joke....china doesn't even bother to talk about this disengagement as it has other things to do... but out here " India 's century/ china - India thaw... India has 1000 channels running 24hrs.. so that need some feed constantly
China will release a statement eventually, but ya in general I agree. Indian media narrative is so clumsy and pigheaded. Maybe we should boast after achieving something, but no ig we choose premature ejaculation. Imagine how empty-headed the people who swallow all this and go to sleep feel proud and satisfied are
Exactly ..I just cannot believe that Indians are so immature at such media levels …I mean even a normal village peasant is more measured than these idi**ts
The fastest way for India to expand its influence in South East Asia is to export its human assets to S.E.A; as were done by the British colonialist. Duplicate what it has managed to achieved in the UK and the USA.😂😂😂😂
To be fair to the whole world, besides India, Brazil and South Africa should also be given the Security Seats to give a fairer representation to the peoples across the planet.
Spot On , bro . India without the Brutish ( and Barbarians ) would have been paradise . Expl : Brute + British = Brutish British colonisation of the world with brute force Barbarians - Of West Asia who saw India as a Sona ka Chidiya (.golden bird ) to be conquered , looted and dishonoured . Barbarians - Of East Asia aka The Golden Horde learnt Civilisation in India . Didn't one of them say , 'If there is paradise on earth , it is this it is this'
You do you bother to invite a distinguished speaker and the "westernized host" rudely cuts him off all the time!! Is this how India behaves and wants to be a "great power" or "great ego"? NDTV another emerging CNN?
These 5 countries can not hold up the UNSC, too weak. Can they influence Ukraine and Gaza wars thats happening now? Not a chance. You want China, US and Russia obey rules from these 5 countries you proposed, 😂😂😂. Never.
The UNSC is so dysfunctional that it's a waste of time and precious resources for the whole world. Makes no diff for India to join. I'd rather that the whole UN be reformed or risk becoming more and more irrelevant
Ab mdm lekhi daughter in law of Lawyer K samne koi b aa k stood,she catch his, Hand and leave matrimonial home, Just like that. Then 25 years roar,we gave such trophy, She doesn't catch!
In fact, UN and UNSC can operate without India.😂😂😂 India has brought nothing much to the world. Can not even supply India‘s own military equipments. Too Weak.
@@merrick6484 Why talk about weapons, just look at the poverty level and food security, the very basic of HR. Global hunger index of recent years speak louder than the politicians are trying to say otherwise. Inaccuracy will be a good excuse, but the reality and general observations surely tell us another story.
This lady ( host) tried to establish that she is more knowledgeable in geo politics than Mr. Kishore Mahabubani and constantly interrupted in the midst of the conversation.
Kishore is a irritating person with singapore mindset. he always is very much chinese. he studied china from singapore
@@kumanet99 China 🇨🇳 is now a super power. Let's acknowledge it. India still has miles to go. John Mearshmier was asked by Palki Sharma about India's global position as a powerful nation, in which Prof. Mearshmier replied diplomatically that lndia can consider herself as an " aspiring super power"
Sorry but the interviewer is not very articulate in my opinion
Typical Indian
I too felt that she should not have interrupted Mr Kishore M in an unprofessional and disrespectful way so many times. Mr Kishore is a highly accomplished person and should be given time to complete his sentences.
Thanks to Trudeau's expert diplomacy, India is fast-tracking its border settlement with China. With that out of the way, India has a clear shot at a permanent seat on the UNSC-especially with the U.S., U.K., and France cheering from the sidelines.
In 1960, Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai proposed a compromise to resolve the India-China border dispute, suggesting that China would recognize India's claim to the eastern sector (Arunachal Pradesh) if India acknowledged Chinese control over Aksai Chin in the western sector. This "package deal" aimed to settle the boundary by dividing the contested areas between the two countries, with China prioritizing Aksai Chin for its strategic link between Tibet and Xinjiang. However, Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru rejected the proposal, as he was unwilling to return any territory gained by lines drawn by its former colonial master.
The U.S. maintained its embargo on China during the Great Chinese Famine (1959-1961) discouraging other nations from sending food, while millions died of starvation.
Confident that China is weakened and will collapse, India implemented its "Forward Policy".
If this border issue had been resolved in 1960, the past 64 years of mutual suspicion and distrust might have been avoided.
Anywhere in the world, if there is a border dispute, it is usually the result of a line drawn by an Englishman; if it is an internal dispute, it is usually the US fueling it with diplomatic, financial, covert, and military support. Difference in implementation of divide and conquer strategy.
💯 a similar ccolonialism induced border dispute can be currently observed with Venezuela and Guyana
The Indian anchorwoman interrupted Mr kishor and deliberately to stressed terms like Indian century, Indian superpower, Indian supply chain, Indian influence, but honestly speaking, no offences to hurt the Indians feelings, we didn't feel any Indian influence or so called Indian superpower or Indian century, my friend used to invested in India but after three years he shifted his production again back to China and ASEAN countries, he once told me it's bad idea to invest in India where authorities don't respect any laws and rules. Indians may brag about themselves Indian century but reality is not. We are seeing East Asia and Southeast Asia are integrated with each other and booming together but India is not part of the club.
International Yoga Day .
Has ASEAN given anything like that to the world ?
@@christopherpaul4698 india did not give anything. They are just promoting yoga for their own popularity. Because they have nothing else to give or contribute to the technologically advanced new world order.
SHE'S Indian, Duh!
@@christopherpaul4698Oh, those who put their foot on their head? Please.
@@pausereflect5911she is definitely not alone. I heard many Indians including young Indians believe Mumbai is way more advanced than Shanghai. Even college professors telling students to study and work hard otherwise China would overtake India. Maybe this is what Mearsheimer is referring India as “aspirational” super power?
Good bye WEST...we know where the WINDS are heading, they are heading EAST !
I'm a Chinese. I have to say. professor Kishore. you as a overseas Indian. I felt love and belt to your mother land from your words. As for whether locals in India can feel your true intentions. Then it depends on their fate.
You are underestimating Kishore..He has way more love for Singapore & ASEAN!! His love for China & India is equal but with a big admiration for China's economic success!! This success though was built on American/European political elites literally breast feeding the Chinese communist party who was smart to take advantage!!
That said, you have a point!! India will have to dilute the western style democracy & it's colonial echo system to rise as a real economic power!!
As if as Nanyang chinese you don't lean on the CCCP China???
Kishore is a SGP born and serve NS too !!
Mahbubani was born in Singapore to a Sindhi-speaking Hindu family who were displaced from Sindh province during the Partition of India.[5][6]
He attended Tanjong Katong Technical School and St. Andrew's School before he was awarded the President's Scholarship in 1967 to study at the University of Singapore (now the National University of Singapore), where he graduated in 1971 with a Bachelor of Arts with first class honours degree in philosophy.
He subsequently went on to complete a Master of Arts degree in philosophy at Dalhousie University in 1976.
Mahbubani was conferred an honorary Doctor of Philosophy from Dalhousie University in 1995.[7]
@@PurnaVarma-rk2rg Southeast Asian Chinese is a broad concept. This includes. Malaysian Chinese who have good relations with China. And it has almost nothing to do with China. Indonesian Chinese. There are also Chinese people who are warlord leaders in northern Myanmar. also. The relationship with China is neither good nor bad. Singaporean Chinese. Uh, What I don't quite understand is why you forcefully added a CCCP title to China? Although I know you mean to humiliate China, but I didn't feel very offended
@@PurnaVarma-rk2rg
Brainwashed by your media.moreover it is CPC Communist Party of China not cccp😂
Peace is good for China and India. They can now focus on improving the living standard of their citizens. Isn't this what every governments want?
well. I do prefer to believe. it's about winter.
It's more benefit to Russia now, having access to the Arabian Sea market of Russian resources.
Outsiders can come and go. But neighbors stick together no matter what. Better be pragmatic. 😉
peace is not good for the media. The Indian media makes money on clicks and views and having strong nationalistic, negative or antagonist headlines is what they need. So expect them to keep slandering China solely for purposes of profit even though it absolutely is detrimental to the well being of the 1.5B people in India
China is playing a Long Game: it is waiting for US's
global economic , technological & military power to get much weaker & eventually becomes impotent to China's aggressive expansionist threats to its S E Asian neighbours' & India's own Himalayan border states sovereignty......China is waiting for such moment to dictate its terms to dictate its terms to settle its border disputes with India, knowing full well that a weak US leader of QUAD in the South China Sea will not pose no threat to it & similarly a weak US will not assist India should China invade Arunachal & Ladhakh....US's economic decline has begun & hence its inability to project itself militarily is will follow in due course, thereby making
making S E Asian nations & its satellite states...
So, your suggestion that India & China should henceforth focus on improving living standards of their people cannot be right for India ...Unless & until China surrenders Aksai Chin, occupied regions of Ladhakh & renounces its claim on Arunaxhal Pradesh within a set time frame of say, two years, India must revert to freezing its relations with China, as it has done since 2021 & consider China as a serious security threat to India's sovereignty..
Reestablishing friendly relations with China now must go hand- in- hand with securing the return of indian territories occupied illegally by China & at the same time reject outright China's claim on Arunachal Pradesh....
Indian thinking too much...overloads with Bollywood movies 😂. Compared with the world's No. 1 & 2, India is still very far far behind.
If you say something, say it openly. Putting down dot, dot, dot does not work on diplomatic subjects. I presume, you are saying that India is thinking too much of the grounds gained in this outcome between itself and China while you making an irrelevant drag of Bollywood on to the point you might have in your mind and can't verbalize it. Can you specify the world's No. 1&2 instead of pressuring that everybody's No. 1&2 are the same globally? And lastly, India is far, far behind in what? Or do you just like to condemn India? In managing the Muslim population control and their national patriotism, I agree that India is far, far behind than Israel who manage them far, far better. But if you meant in terms of anything else, who knows what you meant? Or are you just an all time coward that can't spell yourself out? A few other Muslims seem to have given you a thumbs up for saying that India is far, far behind even without knowing in what terms you meant that.
Compare the number 2 China with US in per capita income & China itself is SHAMEFUL!!
And why is our obsession with bollywood movies a problem to you
Not 🚫 in what matters, no of people and being in the top5 economically.
@@hirendesai6473When india sent weapons to Israel, it has no reason in unsc, period. A country country turned a blind eye to humanity, shouldn't even be in un.
Thank you Prof. Kishore.
Mr Kishore is a humble intellect of the highest order. Host is rather delusional to project she knows more.
20c CCP troll. 😂😂😂
Why does India need a permanent position in UNSC? On every important decision, it abstain. Should be given to a country with guts.
Like who?
Like who?
Dividing India into multiple countries would be beneficial for the Indian people but disadvantageous for politicians, as it would reduce their power. In ancient times, India mostly consisted of many independent states. Before the British arrived, there were over 500 states on the Indian subcontinent. At that time, the economy of the Indian subcontinent was extremely prosperous, with its GDP even surpassing that of China.
When the British came, they forcibly merged many of these states into one to facilitate governance under a single administrative structure. For example, Kashmiris and people from Tamil Nadu, who originally had no connection, were forced to live in the same country. Similarly, people from Kerala and Manipur, who had nothing to do with each other, were also compelled to coexist in one nation. This led to extremely low efficiency in the Indian government.
Additionally, people of different religious beliefs, such as Kashmiris, Nagas, Manipuris, Andamanese, Muslims, Hindus, and Christians, were forced to live together in one country. This resulted in constant resistance across different regions, significantly increasing the cost of governance in India. A lot of money was spent on maintaining social stability and suppressing uprisings, leaving little for improving living standards and economic development.
BS!! Bharat was culturally ALWAYS ONE NATION & ruled the world for thousands of years with a binding & powerful central leadership!! It thus needs to DE-COLONIZE By reinvigorating it's culture, going back to it's roots & have a stronger central leadership!!
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127
India is a subcontinent made up of many smaller princely states never a united country under a central government.. Only afterl being conquered or colonised.
A modern day comparison is just like European Unions.
States can just leave like UK leaving EU.
Kalistanise separatist is just like the Taiwanese separatists government.
@@wionporky9937 BS!! You are ranting a FALSE & COLONIAL History written by the savage criminals against India & humanity led by the British/Europeans!!
Have you heard of Asoka ? If not , find out .
@@wionporky9937 Indian subcontinent !
The world need to thank US and Canada for pushing India to understand where she stand. 👏👏👏
Afrika usir Amerika Prancis .. India berani ?
That is why India truly needs to become Bharat!! In effect, it needs to DE-COLONIZE & go back to it's cultural roots and being in a political system that gives a strong central leadership!!
India was a great civilization, but not under Modi, the extremist, to become great power. The hostess is so rude.
India can talk very brilliantly, but never deliver. Lol
India should learn to keep their part of the bargain. Regards to Indo-Naga issue, India has never kept their part of the numerous Agreements with the Nagas, the latest being the Framework Agreement 2015 and the Agreed Position 2017. They think that talking smart and winning an argument is sufficient.
After having invited such an eminent personality, so rude for so many interruptions without allowing Kishore to complete his ideas. And she even gets the "Act East" wrong as "Look East". Anyways, "Act East" is a non-starter. India is paralyzed by contradictions. All just "acting".
Same as China …they didn’t kept any of the agreements with Tibet..very bad China
Due to lack of confidence, India will never open up to Global Supply Chain.
India is a great nation . Would continue to be .
@@christopherpaul4698the weakest link in the BRICS
UN was founded before India independence
So what, it's not 🚫 set in stone, is it???
@@pausereflect5911 I'm just telling the reason why India was not the 5 members.
Perhaps India's dream to be a developed 1st world country is possible, if it managed to overcome what are its fundamental weaknesses. Anyway, having such lofty aspiration is a good start!!
I LOVE how everyone has an opinion on India...India can NEVER be ignored!
It’s quite annoying this lady kept interrupting Prof KM! Respect to KM for his knowledgeable and intelligence insight
India in the permanent uN ? 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Indian politicians always dream big but unable to achieve. Modi wants to make India a superpower by 2047, it’s really a laughing stock. Did Modi who run the largest democracy in the world manage to alleviate millions of Indians out of poverty? I predict in next 30 years, India will still be an impoverished country and will find it difficult to achieve developed status least to be a superpower. Cut down on defence budget and help the ordinary Indians who are struggling to make ends meet. Resolve your huge internal domestic problems first - rampant corruption, racial religious violent, primitive caste system, infrastructure deficiency, income disparity, abject poverty, etc.
In few years time, India will break up into smaller countries, N.East, South, Bengal, Khalistan.
India can never function as one united front.
@@merrick6484 this is what the western deep state wants to do to India by investing billions funding and grooming the anti-india forces. But Modi is an obstacle therefore the hate propaganda on him by the west.
Agree completely ...they can only boast, look down on China as a way to cope with their own inability to develop their country ..their head keeps getting bigger due to the unjustified flatterings from the west ... China should never never accept India into the big 5
india never said it wants to be a superpower. it said, when india grows it will help others to grow as well. that is the mode of the developing india under modi and indian ethos. By 2047 it wants to be a self sustainable developed country
you are like the anti modi congress person. india has only proved that a patriotic indian, can significantly develop a country with so much of poverty left over by the colonisers, the british and the moguls. Congress could not do much to talk about in 70yrs., but modi govt. created india with in 10 yrs crossing the hurdles from religions with hidden agenda in india, congress that supports them for their own survival, and the pseudo hindus who are anti modi. and islamic atrocities in india. india with indians are not an easy task country to run.
@@merrick6484 keep dreaming
China 🇨🇳 is not so enthused as our media is... 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
China is all doom & gloom at the moment
As usual, very good perspective from Professor Mahbubani
India will never be a UNSC permanent seat member, stop dreaming. Think about how to improve your country's sanitary system for the benefit of your people first.
Loved your comment! Hitting bull's eye...! 👍
You talk BS!!
keep dreaming
Better than swipes , no ?
There are more serious problems than sanitation, India provety are very serious
india being one incredible ZERO Olympic nation , now wants a UNSC Seat ???!
😂😂😂😂
India respect is by earn but not asking
😅India has great potential but the internal politics is the main roadblock.😅
That issue is 100% under Indian control.
The problem is greatly contained with incorruptible PM Modi. Wait for Trump win on November 5, 2024 and B B Netanyahu freeing himself the very night and Trump backing PM Modi. China is making deal with India totally in anticipation of the Trump win which is also the case with President Putin.
The stupidity of the Non - Chinese is not only one way but in many ways .
India is a good example .
The Brilliant Lee Kuan yew ,a Non- Indian leader had the foresight n pragmatism to tell that India lost 5 decades of misopportunitues .
Build up the economy first .
Internal Foters .
(.Expl : Foters - FOols + voTERS
Eg. Those who vote Congress aka Scamgress )
Thank you Prof Kishore for your wonderful analysis,India has arrived on the global stage and time for it to stake its own claim.
Who need who more.Kishor,do not waste your time with a toad in a well.
I am sorry Kishore cannot hear you, might as well call him in person
Very rude commentator, always interupt
Tell you a joke...
India Century, in the zoo, 😅😅😅 I think...
Do not get ahead of yourself. The India Century is earned by hard work but not by talking.
Time is now, the re-emergence of two great historical nations to its position on Earth as in the past.
India is still a child without proper direction is now trying to play grown up adult...a task it has a long way to go...
Very short answer, India needs to coordinate with China or Russia otherwise India will be poor and poor under the yoke of western Colonizer with to much of overconfidence just like this lady 😂
We will co-ordinate with whoever we want and whenever we want.
" It is better to be poor than be a rogue "
@@sublimeksaleel That's attitude makes India poorer.
We can now argue that UK was great as long as it was colonial power and could exploit it. It won the WW1 and WW2 using the manpower of the Indian army. Without the Indian army, it would have lost the middle east and all oil supplies that they dominated. Without the larg army, it would have lost the african continent and its large reserves of resources.
As a Chinese citizen, I have no objection to India replacing the UK as a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council. It is likely that Russia and France also would not oppose it. If India makes an effort, perhaps the United States might remain neutral or even support India. In this scenario, the only opposition would come from the weakest member of the Security Council, the UK. This could be the option with the least resistance for India to become a permanent member of the UN Security Council.
You have astutely pointed out that the Injuns were the willing running dogs of the Great White Rajah.
@willy6658
It would be easier to remove the poorest and weakest member, Russia. Their only support on the council comes from China, a country which does not even have universal recognition. Both of these states could easily be removed to be replaced with Germany and Japan
A security council consisting of the USA, UK, France, Germany and Japan would better represent the global power balance, and be much better equipped to settle global disputes, as we saw during the Korean War
Sorry to say the host got very poor manners.
She must not have disrupted Kishoreji so frequently.
Thank you Kishore Mahbubani Sir for siding with India...
did kishore ever once condemn isreal? if not, why?
India stop crushing domestic intellectual
India shd forget UNSC permanent seat with Veto power.
Wait for china’s somersault 😮
I am Nepali gorkha.
You're a "lost jewish tribe syndrome" bot
BRICS is interested in economics prosperity and not wars. This is good reason to resolve such border conflict that would creat friction to cooperation for mutual interest.
It’s not pre conflict mam..they just deferred the solution…the two points demchok and depsang are still not totally resolved
印度至今对世界有过何贡献？搞不懂
还是有，不吃牛，让欧美人多吃点牛排！牛粪留给自已养身！这种精神还是一种贡献吧！
@@ed1003 Why is eating cows such a big deal, and yes we will keep the dung. whys that a problem to you
Architecture , Brotherly Love , Cotton
Expl :
Architecture
Eg. The Musical Pillars of Madurai Meenakshi Amman Temple .
The Big Temple in Thanjavur , baffling world architects as to how there is no shadow on the ground of the huge granite boulder atop the temple .
Brotherly Love
Eg. India through PM Modi dispatched thousands of vaccines to many needy countries abroad during the height of the Chindemic.
Cotton
Cotton was first grown in India about 6000 years ago in the Indus Valley Civilization .
If you want to continue to live your delusion when the entire World has ack.Indian prowess in the field of healthcare and IT just to name a few than you are entitled by default to live your delusion
You don't understand because you've been living on another planet ever since MODI became PM if India in 2014....go & educate yourself about India since 2014
It's unbelievable that the 2 most populous nations are neighbours. It's inevitable they will cooperate, despite some challenges, as they search for new markets for their products and produces. And when these two great nations work together with their complementary talents and resources, they will be the world's dual engines driving up global prosperity. Nothing could be done by the global north ti stop them.
Stop dreaming, never gonna happen! India is not strong enough to carry the weight, not even mention it doesn't have any influence to other nations. India is a bench player, it'll never be changed.
Why don't you try Hindi if you suck at English? Do you have to state yourself in English?
BS!! That is what they used to say about China!!
Nah you keep dreaming
India is a Land of Dreams .
Has the highest mountain ranges in the world .
Musical Granite Pillars .
The highest Motorable Road in the World .
Kurunji , flowers that blossom once in 12 years in the Western Ghats ( Moutain Ranges )
@@christopherpaul4698 yes, I agree, only to those who never stepped their feet anywhere outside the india.
As always the Anchor had to inject her personal beliefs into the dscussion and by that her personal professional integrity on the line. It is a no no in good journalism and in chairing a session such as this by NDTV. There is clearly no independent perspective. She is like most Indians, not independent of thought, forensic or detached (emotionally or politically) from the subject matter. Her views come out clearly. It i characteristic of the untravelled Indian in India.
Indians get happy soon. The norders are not resolved. This agreement will enable .many soldiers to spend winters n comfortable environment.
What the F are you trying to say? Makes no sense.
So now we know why Canada is making false accusations. To set back India's ambitions to be a global responsible power.
India is smart in the political game. the border issue is just a "tool" to unite the whole country to act hostile toward China. India was thinking to benefit as much as possible from US and western governments when they are rivalling with Chinese. but the reality and facts show them that is not the case. Eventually, they didnt benefit much and India realised the comprehensive supply chain of China will determine the success of India. I think the Chinese know the Indian's strategy and they are pretty calm in dealing with India.
India was all set to join G7...then they voted in Hindutva...and this govt ensured India will remain on par with cousins Pakistan and Bangladesh..😂🤪😃
For 3 Ms we require common political concensus which is missing
China does not want 2 foes at the same time
Hahaha, he can and has been talking a lot about china. But you can read he has nothing much to comment on india
surely kishore will gets in big trouble cause all he speaks are the truth😂. truth hurts. best for him to play the platitude games just like how your lord modi do it
@@Mike-oi2th Kishore is not Indian - and I have always found him pro China, to the point I say he is half chinese. so no surprises there
First get your infrastructures up graded 🙄🙄🙄🙄
...... like having high speed trains instead of 'high density' trains.
Transport Minister Nitin Gadkari of NDA is in full swing creating record after record of Roads . World records .
Can understand why the push for India recognition here
India media hypes everything to a point of being a joke....china doesn't even bother to talk about this disengagement as it has other things to do... but out here " India 's century/ china - India thaw... India has 1000 channels running 24hrs.. so that need some feed constantly
China will release a statement eventually, but ya in general I agree. Indian media narrative is so clumsy and pigheaded. Maybe we should boast after achieving something, but no ig we choose premature ejaculation. Imagine how empty-headed the people who swallow all this and go to sleep feel proud and satisfied are
Exactly ..I just cannot believe that Indians are so immature at such media levels …I mean even a normal village peasant is more measured than these idi**ts
china is a communist with dirty uncivilised hidden agendas. only chinese can live in such a country like slaves
and so why is it a problem to you.
Other things to do like Debt Trap Lanka , Nepal , other countries ?
The fastest way for India to expand its influence in South East Asia is to export its human assets to S.E.A; as were done by the British colonialist. Duplicate what it has managed to achieved in the UK and the USA.😂😂😂😂
It will happen regardless.
😂😂😂 UK and the US on the way down ward and declining ... What are you talking about Funny
To be fair to the whole world, besides India, Brazil and South Africa should also be given the Security Seats to give a fairer representation to the peoples across the planet.
Sure, everyone should have veto
(12:34) (18:44) (21:25)
India without Without Britain, India would not be what it is today!
Oh you mean Britain wouldnt be where it is without India
Spot On , bro .
India without the Brutish ( and Barbarians ) would have been paradise .
Expl :
Brute + British = Brutish
British colonisation of the world with brute force
Barbarians - Of West Asia who saw India as a Sona ka Chidiya (.golden bird ) to be conquered , looted and dishonoured .
Barbarians - Of East Asia aka The Golden Horde learnt Civilisation in India .
Didn't one of them say , 'If there is paradise on earth , it is this it is this'
Thanks the insults or attacks from USA and Canada, who played the dirty games to not only China, but also India.
No Palki Sharma!?!
You do you bother to invite a distinguished speaker and the "westernized host" rudely cuts him off all the time!!
Is this how India behaves and wants to be a "great power" or "great ego"?
NDTV another emerging CNN?
CNN And BBC.
All 5 permanent security council members step down.. gives the seats to India, Brazil, South Africa, Germany and Japan. Better to rotate.
you talk about the fpounders and the largest shareholders giving u on their rights.... not going to happen
You expect the P5 to commit collective harakiri and bow out in favour of your 5 favourite countries? That’s not a goal that can be taken seriously.
These 5 countries can not hold up the UNSC, too weak.
Can they influence Ukraine and Gaza wars thats happening now? Not a chance.
You want China, US and Russia obey rules from these 5 countries you proposed, 😂😂😂. Never.
@@donaldjoseph3903 think it can happen only when the Sun rises from the West.
NO ONE gives power, money or even love on a platter!! It has to be earned!!
India has nothing to do in south China sea😂 wake up Indian media
The poor quality of the host can easily been seen by her "need" to constantly interrupt the interviewee. Something to consider for future.
Why do the News Reporters use those Tall Chairs ? They look quite uncomortable !
The UNSC is so dysfunctional that it's a waste of time and precious resources for the whole world. Makes no diff for India to join. I'd rather that the whole UN be reformed or risk becoming more and more irrelevant
7.33
Ab mdm lekhi daughter in law of Lawyer
K samne koi b aa k stood,she catch his,
Hand and leave matrimonial home,
Just like that.
Then 25 years roar,we gave such trophy,
She doesn't catch!
This lady not same wave length or said same level mentality
ye gawaar kya bola?
UNSC is impossible for india because chameleon india play both sides - brics & G7
Yalla
🌞🤸🏾♂️🖖🏼✌🏽
where is palki sharma😂
She just can't do this. She is biased. U know who she is against.
We dont need UN and UNSC without INDIA... 🙏
Why not Existing UN now to prove your point! Again speaking ahead of your mind.
In fact, UN and UNSC can operate without India.😂😂😂
India has brought nothing much to the world. Can not even supply India‘s own military equipments. Too Weak.
@@merrick6484 Why talk about weapons, just look at the poverty level and food security, the very basic of HR. Global hunger index of recent years speak louder than the politicians are trying to say otherwise. Inaccuracy will be a good excuse, but the reality and general observations surely tell us another story.
@@merrick6484 Since you say too weak, let anyone who says too weak try
Kishore is on payroll of china. So take all his opinion with pinch of salt
😂 He is a Singaporean. He is a brilliant guy. He is 1000000X smarter than you! He knows, but you knows NOTHING, you're so cheap
India and China’s conflict never settle down until Tibet issue will not solve . Mr Kishori Pro CCP and he always plays double standards.
This man was foreign policy adviser of CCP .
CCP spending millions dollars for propagandas of CCP’s idea and CCP’s lies around the world using like this man .
As long as the CASTE SYSTEM is in the minds of Indian people, there is no chance for China.
Neither she can put thoughts together nor she can speak fluently.
Why do Indian TV get incompetent hosts?
We found the host beautiful and bold .
Please keep your misogynistic comments about the lady interviewer at home.
If u r capable of beautiful thoughts, tells us who you have interviewed .
Nepotism
India beeds to be richer, bluntky speaking . This us tge faxt naby wouldn't admit to like it .
Do you have proof of what you speak lady? Have you sighted what has been signed?