'We've Become a Muslim-hating Country, Face an Existential Crisis; I Despair for India, See No Hope'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 ноя 2024
- "We've become a Muslim-hating country and face an existential crisis; I despair for my country, I don't see any ray of hope": Avay Shukla, one of India's most popular bloggers, to Karan Thapar for The Wire.
..........................................
In an interview to discuss the sort of campaign waged by the BJP in Maharashtra and Jharkhand, where conscious and deliberate attempts were made in speeches and advertisements to demonize and vilify the Muslim community, one of the country’s best known bloggers and a widely read author of short stories, Avay Shukla, has said “We’ve become a Muslim-hating country” and India faces “an existential crisis”. Mr. Shukla says: “We are creating the grounds for an explosion”. He adds: “I despair for my children, I despair for my country, I don’t see any ray of hope”.
In a 30-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Avay Shukla, a former senior IAS officer, said the Prime Minister’s speeches, littered with the phrase ek hai toh safe hai, and Yogi Adityanath’s speeches, littered with the phrase batenge toh katenge, were “not dog whistles but commands to take action along these lines”.
Mr. Shukla said the Home Minister’s speeches in Jharkhand, where he spoke about infiltrators marrying tribal women as their second and third wives to take over their property and land, were, in fact, suggesting that Muslims from other parts of India who had gone to Jharkhand for work are infiltrators and this was an attempt to portray them as villains and monsters.
Mr Shukla also spoke about a BJP ad issued in Jharkhand, which the Election Commission has ordered the Party to take down, which shows scores of Muslims storming a Hindu home and literally taking it over. He said the ad filled him with “disgust and anger”. He said this was “not (just) demonizing Muslims any more but it’s a call for action against them.”
Mr. Shukla said the Election Commission’s silence in all these matters - other than asking the BJP to take down the ad - is “a serious dereliction of duty and non-adherence to the Commission’s constitutional compulsions”. He said he was “disgusted” by the Election Commission’s behaviour and not just disillusioned.
He said the Election Commission had become “a blot on our governance” and also “a blot on our service”. He was here referring to the fact the Election Commissioners are former IAS officers.
Mr. Shukla was also sharply critical of the media and press, which has failed to comment on and criticize BJP speeches and failed to point out that the Home Minister’s claim that infiltrators from Bangladesh have come to Jharkhand clearly means the government has failed to do its job of stopping them. The media even failed to point out the fact that this was an own-goal.
Mr. Shukla blamed the middle and the upper classes for spreading Muslim hatred. As Tavleen Singh writes in a recent column: “It has become normal for educated Indians to sit in their drawing rooms and talk openly about how they hate Muslims”.
I will stop there. There’s a lot in this interview that I will leave you to see when you watch the interview yourself. Mr. Shukla is pointing at some deep dark truths about the sort of country we’ve become, which may be difficult for many to accept and even unpalatable for others. But they are the truths that need to be heard and accepted. It’s hard to continue to deny them.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
I do agree with Avay Shukla ji.
"Disgust and anger".
I am planning to sell my TV on OLX.
Thanks to Karan Thapar,Ravish Kumar,Akash Banerjee,Sreenivasan Jain,Atul Charasia'sTippani and many others for not selling my TV yet.
Our country has gone to the dogs.
😅😅😅U need counseling dude. These irrelevant clowns want u guys to get paranoid😅😅😅
Paranoid that it's ,,no truth
The ancestor of every Muslim living in India today was a native Indian once in the past. They all converted to Islam like few others had adopted Buddhism, Sikhism, or Christianity due to the atrocities of Sanatana Brahmans. Even Chandragupta Maury, who ruled the largest parts of India, had ultimately adopted Jainism and his grandson Ashoka embraced Buddhism.
😮😮😮
@@mohan1997 once before people of india infact from all of the world follow nuh (Noah) pbuh whose the famous prophet of ship and before that everyone's father is Adam pbuh and later on devil mislead them by making them worship statues of their ancestors and later converted to bhagwan so you are on the wrong path that's why people came back to the only truth Islam because the stone worshippers have many flaws
It makes no difference who were our ancestors. Peace , brotherhood necessary. Let's live in present time .
@@logicalindian9227 I'm afraid it's too late - the rot has gone too deep - and WE the citizens have allowed it!
Chandragupta Mauriya was what I learnt from history lesson in early 1970s in Amravati. Yes every ancestor has its roots in native India but we have moved on from the dark or Stone age mindset. Absurd connection to make for hating Muslims and Christians. Gulf countries which millions of Indians flock to as economic migrants or labourers mostly Hindus and Christian West to lift them out of Poverty have the temerity to demonize them.
The truth is Karan Thapar sir that we Indians should be ready to face the same fate which we recently saw in Srilanka and Bangladesh, and not only that but might have to face isolation from the rest of the world.
India won't be isolated from the World but in fact will give a lot to the World and do better to rise globally.
Jai Hind.
Tavleen Singh used be a part of the same Godi Media till her son’s OCI status was cancelled!
she still is, don't let the occasional articles fool u. Overall , her aricles still represent godi nature
Absolutely...a whole lot of her interviews are available to prove that
Yes , she is more in to Gandhi Bashing. Looks for an excuse to bash them.
India following Israel's footsteps
Israel is not at peace.
@@khurshidakhtar8835 Then who is enjoying peace ❓
Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Syria ⁉️
I too feel the same... I am in my mid 50s... So when my younger son got an opportunity to pursue his undergraduate studies in Germany, I pushed him out as fast I could... I am also encouraging my elder one to leave..... I have a sense of despair...Both are bright and sincere kids, I do not want them to ruin their lives in this country....Pretty clear about it...
@@mangalapalliv your duty is also to tell people around you not fall for bjp propaganda stop hating muslims.
Also to stop voting BJP. Educated learned hindus like you should be more vocal in your societies about it
Thank you.
@@altamashbaibars9477 : For 9 years I have been at it... I am going to stay back and continue that.... come what may.. But that will not be for my children.... We are a civilzation in decay.... There is no hope in hell. We may be a big market but we will never be a country with educated people driving innovation and build a nation that can stand proudly among the comity of nations. No chance...
Take heart sir , this too shall pass . We will see to it , Isha Allah .
Thank you Karan 🙏
Modiji and yogiji both are hard core Hindu both are not forgotten history of Hindus
Jai ho Modi, Jai ho Yogi
Hindus,that feku and fake saint😂😂..u dont even know who a real hindu is?? What r inherent qualities of a real hindu?? U need to learn....kid...don't spend time on Fekus fake University..read some hindu scriptures.
Criminal complicity of EC
Karen, you are one of the rarest journalist who dares to defy and stand up for truth and justice. I hope more journalists come forward and challenge this repressive government that divides the country in the name of religion .
Karen ???😃
Thanks from a Pakistani American to the Great Karan Thapar!
Thank you Karan for this stunning Interview with Avay Shukla, IAS. Precise and clear
I am from Pakistan but I live to watch the programs Ravesh Kumar , Kiran Thapar and Sidarth and few more from India . India has very strong civil society which is my hope .
The systematic 'othering' of one community is being promoted by parties on both sides with vested interests
Modi and Shah have ruined India. But the people still vote for them. 🤷🏽 You reap what you sow…
Jai Hind sir. Nobody dares to raise the voice against BJP is obviously correct.
Even BBC
Thanks Mr Karan
Very significant program
To talk about this is important for coming generations
Unfortunately the majority of Indians cannot smell the coffee...they can only smell the perspiration of the BJP and they seem to love the odour!
Not majority, but the priviledged only.
smelling the 3rd largest economy in the air soon...
When there are right minded people like Mr. Ajay Shukla and Karan Thapar, there's still hope that Indian democracy and secularism will remain intact.
Very concerning don't know where we are heading only God can save us and our country
Which Election Commission of India you are talking about????
It should be rechristened as " Tout Commission of India".
Mr. Shukla reminded me of the last interview of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar.
Finally the time has come. The Indian experiment is over.
How is it that PM is welcomed , awarded , felicitated internationally in Islamic countries while being so much against Muslims domestically. Sir ur absolutely correct on Tavleen Singh concentrating so much on Gandhis and their dynastic privileges.
Except UAE, Modi is not welcome in any Muslim country. By the way, UAE understands the need of Modi to have a Muslim connection and milks India. Just see who benefits the most in this whole thing. UAE is becoming richer while Indians are migrating to Dubai in huge numbers.
Wait for few years, you will realise how UAE made most out of this.
@@mashraf1605 I think he is feted by all. Nigeria has given him 2nd highest national award. Yday he was meeting Papua leader. He makes it a point to travel to Muslim / Islamic countries. KSA had also conferred national award. No one raises the muslim issue with him. How can one have best of the both worlds. ? Intriguing.
@@sarabjitsingh4442 Bilateral trade 💰💰
The Harsh TRUTH - Sad BUT True
KT aren't you reminded of your conversation with Late Farooq Sheikh , the actor & theatre person , while interviewing him ( if memory serves me right ) for BBC ? He had said that everything ( he was referring to the Economy ) could/ would be set right in due course ; but if the social fabric is torn asunder we might not survive as a Nation . Have we arrived there .
Yes we have in the process of reaching there.
I'm officially &formally a Hindu, but mot a Sanghi Hindu &I don't ĥate Muslims. My best friend is a Muslim!!!!
Best wishes for Bhai Ka Chara.
so bravely he is telling the truth he is not afraid? very few people are telling the truth Salut to you sir
Rightly said by Karan.
Politically use for HATE?
Bjp has gone beyond decency and propriety to levels unimaginable. What they did in Gujarat they want to do in the rest of the country. The world should ban Modi from entering their countries like the u.s did after the Gujarat riots.
Gujarat model is best .should be applied all over India.. that's the only cure😊🙏🚩
as an indian muslim, i give you assurance that light is still their. no need to loose hope. Their is a huge pressure on muslim youth due to circumstances around us to turn equally communal like Hindutva groups. But at all cost we will be following the footsteps of Mahatma Gandhi and secularism of the constitution. this is difficult times...and it will continue for next few years....but this shall pass.
No. You can follow any footsteps, you are here because of the mistake of congress in 1947
World saw that,
Ask Indian Diplomats
Ask them any questions were Raised?
I disagree that Modi& Shah can continue to ride a difficult TIGER forever very soon the tiger will throw these 2 Jokers from it's back and disappear into thin air
💯
❤❤❤❤
I wish such interviews be conducted in Hindi...most of the voter base of BJP is in Hindi belt and they need to hear this
May be the transcript can be written in Hindi?
@zenith808 not sure who will make an effort to read in Hindi
But then the magic will be lost.
True and that is a problem
But most won't take the pain@@zenith808
Sholay filme ke dialogue " Thakur na Hijdoun ki fauj Bannia hai " 😂😂
par bania...geo-economic power (real fauj of current times) banaaata hai...
I personally know a large number of well established Medicos, Scientists, Professors and IAS, IPS etc from Punjab, Haryana, Himachal and NCR whose sons and daughters have or are migrating to US despite having high degrees and income. Their parents with initial resistance to their migration are now accepting that India is no more a country to live for honest Indians as there is rampant corruptiin, no rule of law, tax evasion by business men etc. This despite the fact that their parents savings, fully paid houses are available ti their children while in US they have to start from scratch. Mine own story validates it.
Nice interview!
Head line is true
While you are both agreeing to where India is heading,I would like to hear from somebody who doesn't feel that way and interact with you.
Indeed, the very existence of India is threatened, as it has been, a tapestry of dreams, dreams of a sparkling sky, full of stars, shining, Illuminating &promising!!!
Dr. BR AMBEDKAR on ISLAM
Islam is a close corporation and the distinction that it makes between Muslims and non-Muslims is a very real, very positive and very alienating distinction. The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is a brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity,” BR Ambedkar wrote in ‘Pakistan or Partition of India’.
Ambedkar also elucidated the incompatibility of Islam with local self-government. Underscoring the Islamic ideology of Muslim Ummah, Ambedkar said loyalty of a Muslim is not based on his domicile in the country but on the faith to which he belongs. Islam, according to BR Ambedkar, could have never allowed a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland. For that to happen, the establishment of Islamic rule was imperative.
This was a bleak possibility given that India was a Hindu majority nation. Therefore, he concluded that for a Musalman, India could never be his motherland. This, of course, was the cornerstone of the two-nation theory propounded by the Muslim League, which inevitably led to the partition of the country.
The second defect of Islam is that it is a system of social self-government and is incompatible with local self-government because the allegiance of a Muslim does not rest on his domicile in the country which is his but on the faith to which he belongs. To the Muslim ibi bene ibi patria [Where it is well with me, there is my country] is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin.”
‘For a Musalman, loyalty to faith trumps his loyalty to the country’: BR Ambedkar on the question of Muslim allegiance to India
On the question of Muslim loyalty to his country vis-a-vis his loyalty to Islam, Ambedkar wrote:
“Among the tenets, one that calls for notice is the tenet of Islam which says that in a country which is not under Muslim rule, wherever there is a conflict between Muslim law and the law of the land, the former must prevail over the latter, and a Muslim will be justified in obeying the Muslim law and defying the law of the land…The only allegiance a Musalman, whether civilian or soldier, whether living under a Muslim or under a non-Muslim administration, is commanded by the Koran to acknowledge is his allegiance to God, to His Prophet and to those in authority from among the Musalmans…”
Ambedkar opined that the teaching of the Holy Quran rendered the existence of a stable government almost impossible. However, he was more alarmed by the Muslim tenets that prescribed when a country is a motherland to the Muslims and when it is not.
“According to Muslim Canon Law, the world is divided into two camps, Dar-ul-lslam (abode of Islam), and Dar-ul-Harb (abode of war). A country is Dar-ul-Islam when it is ruled by Muslims. A country is Dar-ul-Harb when Muslims only reside in it but are not rulers of it. That being the Canon Law of the Muslims, India cannot be the common motherland of the Hindus and the Musalmans. It can be the land of the Musalmans-but it cannot be the land of the ‘Hindus and the Musalmans living as equals.’ Further, it can be the land of the Musalmans only when it is governed by the Muslims. The moment the land becomes subject to the authority of a non-Muslim power, it ceases to be the land of the Muslims. Instead of being Dar-ul-lslam, it becomes Dar-ul-Harb,” he said.
As per Islamic teachings, the world was divided into a binary setting: Muslim and non-Muslim countries. This division, Ambedkar explained, was the premise of the extremist concept of Islamic Jihad. The appellation used to describe non-Muslim lands, Dar-ul-Harb, which roughly translates to Land of War, is another testament to the bigotry promoted against the non-believers.
‘To Muslims of India, a Hindu is a Kaffir and therefore, undeserving of respect and equal treatment’: BR Ambedkar
The Muslim Canon Law made it incumbent upon Muslim rulers to convert Dar-ul-Harb into Dar-ul-Islam. This ideology was the cornerstone of the numerous crusades that Islamic invaders from the middle east carried out to conquer India starting from around the 9-10th century.
In fact, this ideology powers Jihad even today when thousands of Islamic terrorists around the world carry on with their crusade against non-believers, whom they pejoratively refer to as Kuffars or Kaffirs. How Muslims were instructed to convert Dar-ul-Harb into Dar-ul-Islam was summarised by Ambedkar as:
“…It might also be mentioned that Hijrat [emigration] is not the only way of escape to Muslims who find themselves in a Dar-ul-Harb. There is another injunction of Muslim Canon Law called Jihad (crusade) by which it becomes “incumbent on a Muslim ruler to extend the rule of Islam until the whole world shall have been brought under its sway. The world, being divided into two camps, Dar-ul-Islam (abode of Islam), Dar-ul-Harb (abode of war), all countries come under one category or the other. Technically, it is the duty of the Muslim ruler, who is capable of doing so, to transform Dar-ul-Harb into Dar-ul-Islam.” And just as there are instances of the Muslims in India resorting to Hijrat, there are instances showing that they have not hesitated to proclaim Jihad,” Christophe Jaffrelot quoted Dr BR Ambedkar as saying in his book ‘Dr Ambedkar and Untouchability: Analysing and Fighting Caste‘.
Addressing the question of Muslim obedience to a Hindu majority government at the centre, Ambedkar opined that it is an improbable prospect to expect Muslims to accept the authority of a government ruled by a Hindu majority because for them Hindus are Kaffirs and therefore, unworthy of respect and undeserving of ruling them.
+1
He even writes a Muslim in army cannot be expected to be loyal to India and can silently side with the enemy, against another Muslim country, in particular!!!
18:22
What is the purpose of copy and paste
Islam copied from Judaism and Christianity and Paganism@@AftabKhan-lg8uc
Hello Karan, please interview with Saahil exmuslim
Kahaavat " Ek hee saf mai khade ho gaye mehmud & aiyaaz, naa koee bandaa rahaa naa kooee bandaa navaaz " Seen in islamic namaaz pray..
What does it mean ? Do let me know please .
Kabir's doha gives somewhat similar thought "मन ऐसा निर्मल भया ,जैसे गंगा नीर ,
पाछे पाछे हरि फिरें , कहत कबीर कबीर ।"
The comments here on the video by and large reinforce Mr Shukla’s points.
You are absolutely right in your opinion Shukla sir
Modi ji meets Irfan Ali, Guyana PM
I love my motherland but it will be naive to not admit that Its not just about muslims , India as a country is a failed state and most disheartning thing is it will not change either.
people rent houses to people they like and may be of the same cast. Nothing wrong in it
No hate to Muslim community please
no hate to any human but to the ideology that teaches dogma bigotry misogyny terror paedophilia...is it not to be hated
I can't believe how any one have problem in statement unity is strength.
The same lines are calling in musjid before every election..
.
.
Despite all our beliefs in present day. Indian democracy we must admit that we have monarchy and paise him round the clock not only because of bribe and / or fear of crackdowns by agencies but partly because we have not yet completely come out of our colonial rule inferior mind set where we had no other option to praising and singing for rulers and it was part of our faith also Another reason is that all agencies including. Judiciary seem to have been sold out to people in power we still do not understand nationhood is above religious and ethnic identification
Musalman should enjoy similar special rights as religious minorities as Hindus are enjoying in Kashmir valley for last 70 years as religious minorities.
Truly said👍🙏
I 100% agree with Mr. Sukla.
BJP & RSS divided the country into 3 parts ( north with rss& Bjp, south with educated and clever United Dravidian , asryans & others, north east).
Karan bhai.
Be shuq aap k chahne walau ki koi kammi nahi hai. Mager aap ki baat un chahne walau tek b pahunchni chahiye jo english acchi terha nahi samhjtey. Aap ko chahiye k aap week may ek baar hindi may b program kiya kare
Yes, Tavleen is obsessed with the Gandhi family.
Am so glad he called out Tavleen Singh’s hatred towards the Gandhi’s.
Balkanisation will not be an Utopian idea for India
What is alarming is d positive response tht 80% of Hindus give to Modi's hate whistles.
Thanks to bjp and modi
Uniform Civil Code is a must for India. Waqf should be abolished for harmony of the masses. Some journalist are always against India.
But India is rising and doing well.
India should be a Hinduistic country like it was before.
Some journalist might differ.
Jai Hind.
Have you heard of inflation,hunger index.Only crony capitalism is growing in this regime.I think you belong to elite class that's why don't know the sufferings of the poor
India is moving towards highest populated country in the World overtaking china.
Every citizen should take the responsibility of educating each other as it will be difficult for creating employment.
Jai Hind
Jo batenge to katenge ka nara laga rahe
Wo Manipur me bata bhi aur kata bhi
Hating?
Yes, hate to haters,
Because we are fooled by secular and unrealistic government ideology.
We are not asked to make a secular or Sanatan Country( Hind sikh boodhh jain).
Now we can atleast see decline in popular ratio.
Which is not healthy...
Now we want a permanent salutation of upcoming problem which we have seen before like afgan pak bangal or now in india...
.
.
Disheartening views of Avay Shukla regarding how to stop the hindu muslim relations from falling apart.
Ghazwa e hind. !!
Exactly.
😢
Highly excellent conversation
Because it favors you..😂
gandhi's india became godse's india when the sabarmati ashram closed its gates to refugees begging for protection of their lives.
It was not Gandhi's India....Baap ka maal hai kya......it is Indian of Bhartiya civilization of thousands of years
Hey Ram!
Tribalism uber allez. The fundamental flaw of the human mind.
Fear the "other". Even though all humans come from the same father and mother.
Self🪴Def🌳ense
I am very sorry for my country. INDIA, we love our country more than our lives.for which we are tolerating all nonsense by bjp and allies.
people can follow any religion, but should be loyal to the motherland, which gives them food and shelter
In the past I used to confront and argue with my hindu friends in social media about these muslim hate issues but now the matter has become so worse that scope of arguments is gone completely out of window as it seems no hope is left and watch muslims dehumnisation of helplesslly.
Isn't it all Congress party's fault, didn't it foresee that if continue to slip into corruption it will lose the faith of the nation and once that happens the radical and right wing forces will dismantle the existing structure. I knew this would happen in 2011 when I was telling my friends that the way you are promoting the right wing would cause vertical rifts in society and they would say it's hyperbole, it's huge corruption and india will become advanced, look at Gujarat.
💔💔💔😞💔
Ban the EVM's. Bring back the ballot papers.
The Balcony class is responsible for all the stupidity.
A cesspit of hate and bigotry.
Ajay Shukla is much more informed than you and your clan.
The moment I see Karan Thapar on a youtube channel, the word TRAITOR comes out of my lips.
Please let of know more about his treachery , who has he betrayed ?
@jagdeepsandhu9659 Gen Manekshaw called Thapar's father naalayak. He is a naalayak aulad of a naalayak father. Just because he is related to Nehru family through blood and marriage, in all his interviews he tries to put across failed nehruvian policies, so as a journalist he is extremly biased. In his interviews with pakistani politicians he is very eager to put their point of view. He should resign as a journalist.
What about Adani and Ambani....😂😂😂😂😂😂 your father modi doesn't like him... we know what had happened with him 😂😂😂😂😂
@kareemkhan-hv1yp mian every porki considers modi as their father, i suggest you do the same
You are absolutely right.👍
I really wonder what is going to happen to our beloved country when Indian Muslim revolt’s against injustice being meted out to them every day, every where on filmsy & trumped up charges. Seems we are inching towards civil war. As Avay Shukla said, I am worried about myself, my children& above all my country. God pl. save us from the enemies of the country.🙏
beloved country becoming 3rd largest economy in 2-3years..lol
@@stallionspirit9317In your dreams busted hunger index do you know busted what it is
@@waseemmohammed5285 remember ...the same hunger index ranked pakistan higher than india..and who ended up..in atta ki line?..lol
Truly said
I haven’t seen any Muslim fleeing India while I have seen Muslims fleeing Islamic countries like Pakistan Bangladeshi and Afghanistan 13 to a dozen , Muslims from Pakistan and Bangladeshi are trying their best to obtain indian citizenship like Adnan Sami, for example how come there’s not even a single example of an indian Muslim taking citizenship in Pakistan or Bangladesh ? Would look forward to thappar or avay to answer this please ?
Adnan is married to indian
@ so? What’s your point ? Even Sania was married to Shoaib? Did she leave for Pakistan ?
Asking for hindu unity is not a dogwhistle. Get serious people. Lots of issues with the BJP, but you focus on all the wrong ones.
The appeal doesn't say "hindus to unite". It is only a general call.
This "hatred" is not "manufactured " now . Our varna system saw to it that every single caste , subcaste , group looked down upon the 'other ' . And positive hatred for lower groups .
I found it amusing when 2 gardeners working for me sat separately for their lunch . On being asked why , one replied the other is lower than him in Mali caste hiarchy !
there is no hierarchy of varnas..in hinduism...no such thing exists in hindu texts...case closed
there is nothing called caste in hinduism..caste is a portuguese word...
No hierarchy ! Wow , so , shudra and brahmin same same ?
There is no such thing as Hinduism in the Vedas , in fact , not even in any Upnishads , Puranas and Smritis.
@@jagdeepsandhu9659 yes according to the hindu texts..varna was trait based..ther e was no hierarchy...human beings end up creatimg hierarchy in everythig..see the jobs of today..there is a clear heirarchy...
It's still on RUclips
Mainstream media was bought by the BJP government as soon as they came to power, which is why Karan and others exist today (Thank goodness). turncoats continued so they could keep their jobs. As for Tavleen Singh - she's nothing but a turncoat in its worst form - first, love the Gandhis, then the BJP and now she's looking at someone else to 'love'
Change to "nadir"!
Mr. Thapar: When will you realize that this Muslim hate is a corollary to economic inequalities?
Thank you very good
The truth has been told.
May God bless you
How Muslim papulation increased in Jharkhand from 9% to 22% ????
According to Wire Musalman settled in Jharkhand from West Bengal.
Then how Muslim papulation increased in West Bengal from 14% to 29% ??????
According to the Wire it happened only because Musalman settled in West Bengal from Jharkhand !!!!!
What a bullshit logic !!!!!
What a beautiful propaganda!!!!!
You are wrong
@@AftabKhan-lg8uc Why???
Only because I do not agree with moulana of mosque of your locality !!!!!!
@ I do not agree with many moulanas. Important is to understand any. Religion by your own intellect.
Buddy how can u give a percentage of the increased muslim population when the census is not conducted in the last 12-13 years ,these figures are just quoted by the politicians in rallies and floated by the media and are absolutely baseless.without data how can one ascertain the increase or migration or anything.
@@AftabKhan-lg8uc Yes, my intellect says that such increament can not happened without planned infiltration for Kashmirization of Jharkhand.
Right... BJP is responsible for this dismay, majority of population either kept quiet or enjoyed it. Now face the inevitable.
Ohh..Do you think we are scared
Perhaps pushback come from AI
Political slogan by a Hyderabad politician provoking people about 15 mins time to wipe out the majority is considered a peaceful & secular comment by these old timers. In response if someone says" Batenge tho katenge" Is read as a dog-whgonna that goes against a community. If this is not being selective then what else is?
Look back in time - Did we think the current situation would ever come. He feels numbered so speaks but factually in the current situation how far is he effective overall ? In the turning point of political tactics
Agreed 👍
@ - Is it a question?
Please leave, if not for gandhi wud have left
Thanks Mr Karan and salute to Mr shukla for telling true boldly
In Himachal,what is Sukhkhu doing. And the Congress? And Kharge and Rahul and Priyanka?
15 lakh credited .HP deserved. Kangana ?
Karan you are a great journalist I have no words to say about our country and you