Why choose Honor Magic 5 Pro over Samsung S23 Ultra?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
  • Check Out XDA on Social Media.
    Twitter: / xdadevelopers
    Facebook: / xda.developers
    When you make a purchase using links in the description, we may earn an affiliate commission. See more: www.xda-develo...

Комментарии • 60

  • @kartikverma9389
    @kartikverma9389 Год назад +34

    According to XDA you can choose anything over S23 ULTRA😂

  • @Felix21411
    @Felix21411 Год назад +33

    That's not the right reasons. Honor has way more than that. For anyone who used a Huawei, they would know. For me, the Magic 5 pro is the best smartphone in the world as an overall.

    • @jakob6b1998
      @jakob6b1998 Год назад +1

      I als bought the phone, I am pretty happy with it. Amazing display, amazing performance, amazing camera and amazing battery life. Never had a huawei tho so what are those reason's that you're talking about? (auch gerne in deutsch falls du auch deutscher bist😅)

    • @mrliberox
      @mrliberox Год назад +3

      These all Huawei haters will have a reasons why brands always are better that a real better phone.

    • @412Kamikaze
      @412Kamikaze Год назад

      ​@@jakob6b1998What's the battery life like for you? What time do you take it off the charger in the morning and by what time do you hit 10% or dead? Also, can you speak on what apps you use?

    • @jakob6b1998
      @jakob6b1998 Год назад +1

      @@412Kamikaze i guess am a somewhat average type of smartphone user.. I use standard social media apps, apps for work, shopping etc and i use the camera a lot, its just extremely refreshing even tho my last smartphone (oneplus 9 pro) also had a quite nice camera experience. But i dont play a lot on the phone. With highest settings, highest brightness etc id say i have about 8 hours screen on time. If i unplug it at 7:30 in the morning i can easily get until 12:00-14:00 the next day. I can really assure you that the battery is beyond brilliant in my opinion. Camera, display, performance, design are brilliant too. Can really recommend it, really enjoy using it every day :)

    • @ievamikalauskaite2152
      @ievamikalauskaite2152 Год назад +2

      I still have my huawei p30 pro, going on 5th year, no issues!! But still I prefer better camera, I was gonna go back to Samsung but battery and size scares me,but now I found this, I think i will stick to my huawei cousins 😂

  • @p.slgeswari4972
    @p.slgeswari4972 Год назад +10

    Honestly the software feels a bit outdated with honor x9a released early this year still not receiving android 13 and no confirmation on how many years of support they get

    • @DarkKnight-qt2dh
      @DarkKnight-qt2dh Год назад +1

      Honor magic 5 pro will get 3 years Os updates and 4 yrs security updates

    • @selfishstylishart
      @selfishstylishart Год назад

      Still samsung offers one year more of system updates.

  • @alexdenton6586
    @alexdenton6586 Год назад +18

    This phone is impressively fast. I used to have a Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra and returned it for this Honor Magic5 Pro, and I'm not disappointed.
    I bought it based on its DXOMark rating, and the photo and video quality are much better than the Samsung. It's also super smooth, and I love Honor's custom UI-it's clear and has everything you need.
    The only downside for me is the ergonomics; there's a noticeable camera bump, making the phone top-heavy, and I find it too thin. A nice leather case solved the issue for me, but it's something to be aware of.
    In summary, go for it, especially since it's cheaper than the Samsung.

    • @NicholasGoatifiFan
      @NicholasGoatifiFan 11 месяцев назад +2

      But the thing is availability and software reliance

    • @alexdenton6586
      @alexdenton6586 11 месяцев назад +5

      @@NicholasGoatifiFan perfect on the Honor
      Even better than the Samsung

    • @NicholasGoatifiFan
      @NicholasGoatifiFan 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@alexdenton6586 Its cheap, but the availability isn't as great as a Samsung, so that's one con, but overall it looks like a good phone

    • @alphawarriorthegrandmaster
      @alphawarriorthegrandmaster 9 месяцев назад +1

      Does anybody know how the update policy is and the rom scene? Is rooting possible since it is a SD version

    • @djingonthenet
      @djingonthenet 9 месяцев назад +3

      I've got the HM5P also, some of the photos that I've taken are ridiculously good. The problem with these reviews (pretty much all of them on youtube) are that the reviewer probably uses the S23 ultra on a daily basis and used the Honor for a day or so, you're never going to get an unbiased point of view from that, I mean in the main comparison video he said that the Honor doesn't have an app drawer or desktop mode, which is absolute rubbish. If you want a pen and better 10x zoom spend the extra £500 (currently) on the Samsung, I'm not that daft though.

  • @scottspa74
    @scottspa74 Год назад +12

    This was done geniusly. The way it loops is genius; it ends with the word 'ask' and begins with the words 'why choose'. It's a perfect loop. Well done, XDA video guy. (Also, I really think 'geniusly' should be a legit word, 😅 )

    • @Blastrodon
      @Blastrodon Год назад +2

      While reading your comment I waiting for the video to loop and still missed it lmao

  • @teeteeme5752
    @teeteeme5752 Год назад +1

    Hiya, where did you get the cover for the magic 5 pro, I like it

  • @novakanedj1
    @novakanedj1 Месяц назад

    The Honor camera and screen were rated the best for a short time on DXOMark. Picking the Samsung is just brand loyalty.

  • @abhiramshibu
    @abhiramshibu Год назад +8

    But the software features of samsung is ahead of the time.

  • @LDBPRODUCTIONS
    @LDBPRODUCTIONS Год назад

    I had S23 Ultra and switch it up for Magic 5 Pro. It's a great smartphone except for updates... Samsung release monthly security update when Honor struggle to do the same. For example, i'm on May security patch right now and we are in july...I hope they'll get better soon

    • @LDBPRODUCTIONS
      @LDBPRODUCTIONS Год назад +1

      EDIT : I came back on S23 Ultra ah ah ! Didn't enjoy the Magis 5 Pro as much as the S23 Ultra. Best.smartphone for me on the market right now.

    • @MADCOBRA1
      @MADCOBRA1 10 месяцев назад +1

      ​@LDBPRODUCTIONS thanks man I was really thinking to change My s23 ultra for magic 5 pro your comment stops Me As I enjoyed the customizations on s23 ultra because I can do anything I want Thanks to one ui 5.1

    • @srdjandragojevic9235
      @srdjandragojevic9235 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@LDBPRODUCTIONSso what is better on s23ultra ?

    • @djingonthenet
      @djingonthenet 7 месяцев назад

      @@srdjandragojevic9235 It's got a pen and Samsung have a better marketing team with a much bigger budget.

  • @johnnyte3
    @johnnyte3 Год назад +1

    Less store of honor . No aftersales

  • @hazemfive
    @hazemfive 11 месяцев назад +1

    I holding honor in my hand and with respect honor never compared to Samsung s series, it's the father of honor (Huawei) that compare to Samsung s series and fold series.

  • @user-jx3cx2lm5l
    @user-jx3cx2lm5l 11 месяцев назад

    No way bro really said "why choose s23 ultra over magic 5 pro"then"why choose magic 5 pro over s23 ultra"
    Both are equal lfmao people who don't know about phones are saying "s23 ultra is king" and "magic 5 pro better" both phones are equal s23 ultra slams magic 5 pro in features and magic 5 pro slams s23 ultra in camera,battery,display and performance both are equal cuz features=all

  • @wuforever
    @wuforever Год назад +4

    Honor has better shutter speed and better main camera for moving objects, better night camera. Samsung is oversaturated with unnatural colors

    • @Robeasy83
      @Robeasy83 11 месяцев назад

      Even though it's unnatural, the Samsung colors look way better.

  • @dimitararabadjiiski9152
    @dimitararabadjiiski9152 Год назад

    And I'll choose him, of course.

  • @KimJongTrump98
    @KimJongTrump98 Год назад

    That pill hole is deal breaker for me

    • @Freevo_Lowse
      @Freevo_Lowse 4 месяца назад

      Honestly I thought It would be too but I've gotten used to it

  • @didotbasmayor
    @didotbasmayor Год назад

    its not cheap here in the Philippines s23 is more cheaper

  • @Tony_Re-imagined
    @Tony_Re-imagined Год назад +3

    I really like the honor, but I'll stick with samsung

  • @Hayan_Yeou
    @Hayan_Yeou 11 месяцев назад

    It's beyond me how people trust Chinese softwares and hardwares.

  • @jackedbabington6206
    @jackedbabington6206 Год назад +1

    Honor it’s terrible with updates

  • @wuforever
    @wuforever Год назад +1

    Better battery, better camera and cheaper

  • @shubhammanna
    @shubhammanna Год назад +4

    people still buy Huawei?

    • @jaripato
      @jaripato Год назад +4

      Yeah. And too bad they don't sell Huawei or Honor phones to the U.S. anymore

    • @wuforever
      @wuforever Год назад +5

      I'm using my Huawei P30 Pro for 4 years and now will I upgrade to Honor Magic 5 Pro. Finally they made a phone that can replace my Huawei

    • @stormingblade1937
      @stormingblade1937 Год назад +4

      If they didn't get a google ban huawei would likely be top 3 in smartphones, they make such good optimised phones it's crazy

  • @AS-yf4jr
    @AS-yf4jr Год назад +1

    That thang is uglyyyy ...no way i am buying that over s23 ultra...

  • @Christopherjoe
    @Christopherjoe 11 месяцев назад

    That honor is hideous

  • @ANANT.LAL.777
    @ANANT.LAL.777 Год назад +2

    Samsung is king

  • @one6803
    @one6803 Год назад

    Buy mi 14 ultra

  • @JerryMilton
    @JerryMilton Год назад

    As if folks are gonna rush out and find, let alone go buy this phone. Your XDA reviewers must get paid by the word.

  • @ANANT.LAL.777
    @ANANT.LAL.777 Год назад

    Chinese phone is bad

    • @estherlam1822
      @estherlam1822 Год назад

      Apple is made in China 😂😂😂😂😂