I wondered why my HOYD wasn't bringing in "model pros" like his personality. Did some research and it turns out you have to go to Staff -> Responsibilities -> Staff -> Advice and reports and turn on "provides youth development information" and select your HOYD. It was previously done by my under 18 manager. I was also informed by my under 18 manager that his "influence and experience" have shaped the mentality of the players - so i'm now going to recruit an under 18 coach with a great personality. The game is very unclear and unhelpful when it comes to the question of maxing out your youth intake.
One more thing that matters massively when your selecting a HOYD is there tactical style, preferred formation, passing style, & 2nd formation. If u get HOYD that matches what ur trying to do in the first team tactic it produces players to fit the style and formation. Helps just like there personality traits do that he passes on. Hope this helps people out
Very true! Thank you, I tend not to focus on this myself as I always end up changing tactics or retrain players 😂 but I probably should have mentioned it regardless - Luke
Check out Neil bath as a head of youth development all his coaching and knowledge attributes are above 15, the lowest attribute he has is a 16 and he has a determined personality and he is almost four star ⭐️
SOme incorrect advice at the start. From a SI developer: Youth Facilities The training facilities available for Juniors (only). Does NOT apply to visible players already at the club. All visible players currently at the club use Training Facilities regardless of age.
I was surprised when he said that. In other videos that I watched, they specifically told me that youth facilities is one of the most important ways to improve youth intake. It also seems very obvious as it's called YOUTH Facilities. As I'm always playing Ajax, I never have to worry about it though.
@@trainerzard7 training facility are used by all.the players including youth and reserve squad while youth facility and junior coaching is used to determine how.good u9 u12 u17 are these players are not shown bcz they would require really powerful pc this means good youth facility means better newgens produced
I got a bit lucky with this I think. Playing with hertha Berlin, I brought in a good head of youth development and improved youth scouting in the the first season. That second Intake was damn good, and now I have five of them in my first team squad in season five, including a striker I'm very very excited about
One other thing that helps - the personality of the Under 18s Manager is also relevant. I found that out in my first West Ham save so I ended up quickly hiring a new, more desirable Under 18s Manager afterwards
Tip for scouting: Affiliate clubs in foreign clubs, especially clubs and regions where it's hard to find good scouts, also contribute to your scouting knowledge. In my save (Man United) I have affiliate clubs in Poland and the USA, the only reason is to increase my scouting knowledge. The youth players I have are often good enough to get loan to good clubs when they're the right age or step directly into the first team as challengers and cup players.
Also affiliates that send player to train i have 6 7 affiliates right now form multiple countries get at least 1 player with 5 star potential from these nations sometimes 4 stars but still worth it
Another thing to consider, if you want to keep a play style and formation, is hire staff with same tactical and play style your are using on your team, so they will bring more players that fit on your tactics
I have affiliate clubs where it says there is a possibility that they will send their youngsters through to our youth setup but in 3 seasons I haven't had one foreign player through my youth intake, but other clubs seem to get foreign players
@@Kylian273 it depends on how good the affiliate is I get 3 4 players every season with at least 1 of them with mostly 5 star sometimes 4 star potential P.s. i have 8 of these affiliates from multiple countries and 1 more about to come(i try to get 1 every time i can ask the board)
Does your club have any other things in the deal with them tho? Because I once had that exact same problem with my affiliate, but the thing is I also had loaning players there in the deal When I started loaning my boys there, I got 3 players from the nation of that club in the season I started loaning my players there I also started to play friendlies with them every now and then What also might be a factor in this, is the reputation/quality of the affiliate club, as well as its facilities(the youth ones), and maybe even the nationality of your head of youth development as well as the scouting knowledge of your club(which only makes sense, your club is not gonna take youth from a country they got absolutely no idea of)
Ill have the correct setup and more😅..and for the 4th season running..still..the best i got is 3 n half star.😩.thats why..i prefered to bought em from other youth intake..since i really dont know in which position i need to upgrade anyway so my tranfer budget is solely to bought youth player (17 yo below) Plus. It is kinda enjoyable to have control(buy) of players you assemble for the u17 rather than hoping to get it from youth intake.. ive spend 55 mills on 16yo southampton english prospect this season lol.. he was 135 in CA and had consistent trait as well.. crazyy how much english player prices is..but its a great if u had an establish squad..n dont have to worries about signing player for the first team.. 👌👌 In my save..leeds/southampton/arsenal/man utd are crazy cheating on youth intake.. they got the very best every year
yeah i always check for players in africa and countries like montenegro or asian and middle east countries. they are available for peanuts or are at end of their contract. in my lower league fc united save i found a left back from mali who i signed for 400 pound and sold him just after one season for 40mil with 50%sell on fee to brighton(he was a regular starter in championship and i had two great english left back )
So I'm Man U, am half way through season 4, at the very start i got Norbert Elgert in as my HoD, work with youngster's 20/ judge ability 16/ judge potential 20/ professional/ continental pro license, thought he would do a banging job but so far after 3 youth intakes i haven't had anyone special come through, a couple of half decent 3 star potentials but that's it, being man u i never thought to look at increase junior coaching or improve youth recruitment and turns out i didn't have the best for either so maybe something as small as that has held back the quality of youth, obviously i have done them now so hoping season 4 intake might bring a gem or 2
I have him too but as a coach. I have stuck with Nick Cox so far but like you missed out on the Finances bit. Let me know how it goes for you. I might switch to Elgert if this year's intake doesn't improve after the change!
@@abhimanyubanerjee3999 the next intake has definitely been better, 1 lad has 4 star potential and 2 others are 3 star so possibly the ugrades have helped
Hi, folks! Offtopic question: FM 2020, how to negotiate the board to build the new stadium? For example, Chelsea. After expanding - less than 50000. 9 seasons, top 1 club in the world, all cups, top income, but the board still refuses the new stadium because of the small fan base. Is it really hardcoded limit in the game?
Well the only thing I can think of is if you aren’t playing an entertaining soccer style because teams that play an entertaining soccer style are more likely to build new stadiums because it serves as revenue because the stadium will get filled up
I don’t think the level of scouting matters at all personally. You showed off one player from Algeria, but surely managing a French club you’re more likely to produce African regens anyway? I’m doing an academy challenge at the minute and have no scouts, and still get players with different nationalities coming through ever year. I’m managing in England and currently have players from Germany, Hungary, Gibraltar, Cyrpus and Spain who have all come through the youth system.
hey man i tried loading on youth intake. every year it is on different days but in one year it is on a specific day how many times ever you try and after loading you can get a player your youth intake preview gives every player a bad position. for example in my fc tokyo save i saved after a match. got youth intake the next day.had a extremely bad intake and then loaded 4-5 time and got intake on the same day(intake gets different day every year but on a particular year it is on a particular day and you can find the month of youth intake in youth preview tab) on 5th try i got a extremely great winger with pa 180(check with fmrte as wanted to check my theory),but the youth intake preview said none of the wingers are good this year(Not even one just said one good striker and one good full back).
This is probably more due to your coaches not having the best judging player ability/potential stats than anything else. I’m not sure if you checked that good winger every time but he may well have still been really good every single time you reloaded just your coaches couldn’t see that
Female head of youth development are fantastic.... I had 3 of them over the years with each of them in club for 20 years each and that time almost 75 percent of my team was from England...btw i had picked Chelsea
Junior Coaching affect the players CA Youth recruitment affect the PA For HOYD, preferered formation and the different styles also affect what kind of players he will attract EDIT: Official statement from SI developer. Training Facilities The training facilities available for all visible players at the Club, senior and youth. The quality directly impacts upon player progression and training injuries. Youth Recruitment The Club’s recruiting of Juniors, those of home and foreign origin. Impacts upon newgen quality. Youth Facilities The facilities available for Juniors only. Impacts upon newgen quality. Junior Coaching The quality and quantity of Junior Coaches at the Club. Impacts upon newgen quality. "Impact upon newgen quality" = both CA and PA. "Juniors" = invisible pre-newgen aged players.
@@reuben524 Junior coaching only affect the CA of the joining regen and nothing else. Youth facilities affact the probablity of development. Let's say my youth facilities is only at "Adequate" and I have 5* star regen. Because my facilities is only "Adequate" his probability of development is only 35%. But if my facilities is "State of the Art" his probability of development is now 85% instead. While youth recruitment do affact where regens come from it is also the one that affect their PA together with your HOYD.
@@tictac3622 no man youth facilities only improves ca as they are training facilities of your youth team while training facilities are used by everyone at the club who can play. even i thought youth coaching give higher ca players but i found in some si forum about this.
@@reuben524 Found the thread you're talking about. And it do seem like they've changed it a few years back. Here is the official statement from the SI developer. Training Facilities: The training facilities available for all visible players at the Club, senior and youth. The quality directly impacts upon player progression and training injuries. Youth Recruitment: The Club’s recruiting of Juniors, those of home and foreign origin. Impacts upon newgen quality. Youth Facilities: The facilities available for Juniors only. Impacts upon newgen quality. Junior Coaching: The quality and quantity of Junior Coaches at the Club. Impacts upon newgen quality. "Impact upon newgen quality" = both CA and PA. "Juniors" = invisible pre-newgen aged players. Now there shouldn't be anymore confusion on what each part do.
And what wouls your tip be on my case, in 11 years i have only 2 or 3 players that are decent and of them 1 is really good, i am leading Partizan, i have best facilities and everything else to improve, 4 5 star reputation, beast hoyd almost whole save, and still i only produce 2 star youngsters
Because Serbia only have a youth rating of 3* So generally there won't be coming that many good youth players through. The quality of your youth coaches also affact the regens you attract
@@tictac3622 i know thay, but in 11 years with best facilities onlh 1 5 star player and rest at best 3? That is way to dodgy, and whole serbia didn't produce world clasa talent in that time, and when I play in other leagues i find world beaters here
I swear that half an hour ago I had 5 tabs open on exactly this subject. This is weird but great, thank you!
I wondered why my HOYD wasn't bringing in "model pros" like his personality. Did some research and it turns out you have to go to Staff -> Responsibilities -> Staff -> Advice and reports and turn on "provides youth development information" and select your HOYD. It was previously done by my under 18 manager. I was also informed by my under 18 manager that his "influence and experience" have shaped the mentality of the players - so i'm now going to recruit an under 18 coach with a great personality. The game is very unclear and unhelpful when it comes to the question of maxing out your youth intake.
One more thing that matters massively when your selecting a HOYD is there tactical style, preferred formation, passing style, & 2nd formation. If u get HOYD that matches what ur trying to do in the first team tactic it produces players to fit the style and formation. Helps just like there personality traits do that he passes on. Hope this helps people out
Very true! Thank you, I tend not to focus on this myself as I always end up changing tactics or retrain players 😂 but I probably should have mentioned it regardless - Luke
It is a factor early on but if you persevere with the members of staff you find the formation changes
Check out Neil bath as a head of youth development all his coaching and knowledge attributes are above 15, the lowest attribute he has is a 16 and he has a determined personality and he is almost four star ⭐️
Or just start with Chelsea
McDermott?
SOme incorrect advice at the start. From a SI developer:
Youth Facilities
The training facilities available for Juniors (only).
Does NOT apply to visible players already at the club. All visible players currently at the club use Training Facilities regardless of age.
I was surprised when he said that. In other videos that I watched, they specifically told me that youth facilities is one of the most important ways to improve youth intake. It also seems very obvious as it's called YOUTH Facilities. As I'm always playing Ajax, I never have to worry about it though.
My bad guys! 😃 hope the rest of the video helped - Luke
@@fmscout It only shows that you're human. And the rest of the video was indeed helpful.
I dont understand
@@trainerzard7 training facility are used by all.the players including youth and reserve squad while youth facility and junior coaching is used to determine how.good u9 u12 u17 are these players are not shown bcz they would require really powerful pc this means good youth facility means better newgens produced
I got a bit lucky with this I think. Playing with hertha Berlin, I brought in a good head of youth development and improved youth scouting in the the first season. That second Intake was damn good, and now I have five of them in my first team squad in season five, including a striker I'm very very excited about
Witch HOYD you take to Hertha?
One other thing that helps - the personality of the Under 18s Manager is also relevant.
I found that out in my first West Ham save so I ended up quickly hiring a new, more desirable Under 18s Manager afterwards
Tip for scouting:
Affiliate clubs in foreign clubs, especially clubs and regions where it's hard to find good scouts, also contribute to your scouting knowledge.
In my save (Man United) I have affiliate clubs in Poland and the USA, the only reason is to increase my scouting knowledge. The youth players I have are often good enough to get loan to good clubs when they're the right age or step directly into the first team as challengers and cup players.
Also affiliates that send player to train i have 6 7 affiliates right now form multiple countries get at least 1 player with 5 star potential from these nations sometimes 4 stars but still worth it
Another thing to consider, if you want to keep a play style and formation, is hire staff with same tactical and play style your are using on your team, so they will bring more players that fit on your tactics
I have affiliate clubs where it says there is a possibility that they will send their youngsters through to our youth setup but in 3 seasons I haven't had one foreign player through my youth intake, but other clubs seem to get foreign players
It’s broken you’ll Maybe see 1 player in 10 years but I got a Spaniard and he ended winning the ballon dor with me
@@Kylian273 it depends on how good the affiliate is I get 3 4 players every season with at least 1 of them with mostly 5 star sometimes 4 star potential
P.s. i have 8 of these affiliates from multiple countries and 1 more about to come(i try to get 1 every time i can ask the board)
Does your club have any other things in the deal with them tho? Because I once had that exact same problem with my affiliate, but the thing is I also had loaning players there in the deal
When I started loaning my boys there, I got 3 players from the nation of that club in the season I started loaning my players there
I also started to play friendlies with them every now and then
What also might be a factor in this, is the reputation/quality of the affiliate club, as well as its facilities(the youth ones), and maybe even the nationality of your head of youth development as well as the scouting knowledge of your club(which only makes sense, your club is not gonna take youth from a country they got absolutely no idea of)
The best informative video you have made Luke.You deserve all the credit in the World mate.Keep these gems coming.
Hi, where can i get skin like yours?
OPZ elite skin
Just search it up on RUclips u should be able to find an FM Scout vid on it
Another great informative video luke!! Keep them coming!
Ill have the correct setup and more😅..and for the 4th season running..still..the best i got is 3 n half star.😩.thats why..i prefered to bought em from other youth intake..since i really dont know in which position i need to upgrade anyway so my tranfer budget is solely to bought youth player (17 yo below)
Plus. It is kinda enjoyable to have control(buy) of players you assemble for the u17 rather than hoping to get it from youth intake.. ive spend 55 mills on 16yo southampton english prospect this season lol.. he was 135 in CA and had consistent trait as well.. crazyy how much english player prices is..but its a great if u had an establish squad..n dont have to worries about signing player for the first team.. 👌👌
In my save..leeds/southampton/arsenal/man utd are crazy cheating on youth intake.. they got the very best every year
yeah i always check for players in africa and countries like montenegro or asian and middle east countries. they are available for peanuts or are at end of their contract. in my lower league fc united save i found a left back from mali who i signed for 400 pound and sold him just after one season for 40mil with 50%sell on fee to brighton(he was a regular starter in championship and i had two great english left back )
So I'm Man U, am half way through season 4, at the very start i got Norbert Elgert in as my HoD, work with youngster's 20/ judge ability 16/ judge potential 20/ professional/ continental pro license, thought he would do a banging job but so far after 3 youth intakes i haven't had anyone special come through, a couple of half decent 3 star potentials but that's it, being man u i never thought to look at increase junior coaching or improve youth recruitment and turns out i didn't have the best for either so maybe something as small as that has held back the quality of youth, obviously i have done them now so hoping season 4 intake might bring a gem or 2
I have him too but as a coach. I have stuck with Nick Cox so far but like you missed out on the Finances bit. Let me know how it goes for you. I might switch to Elgert if this year's intake doesn't improve after the change!
@@abhimanyubanerjee3999 the next intake has definitely been better, 1 lad has 4 star potential and 2 others are 3 star so possibly the ugrades have helped
Bruno Conti
Legend HOYD for my Spurs save
you can also change your scouting budget in scouting section for few hunders to milions :D worth checking too
How can you get a setup like that? And the faces (including the youth generated faces)
Really good video! Great job man
Can you share your FM skin? It looks amazing
Great video mate. Could you please inform me which facepack and skin that is?
Where can I find this picture for new players?
Bdw. Nice Video, help a lot to understand the youth intake.👌👍
Do you run it on Mac or Windows? Also where do you get your skin with the regen pictures from?
Adam Langston regen faces are from a creator called Chilled Moose (her real name is a Laura).
great video once again, thank you. can you please do a test of this ,Chrissy Ross's 442 tactic
Is it on the FM Scout website my friend! If so I shall find it and run a couple of tests buddy
How do you get your regens go look like that?!?! Please reply!!
Chilled moose face pack on twitter
Hi, folks!
Offtopic question: FM 2020, how to negotiate the board to build the new stadium?
For example, Chelsea. After expanding - less than 50000. 9 seasons, top 1 club in the world, all cups, top income, but the board still refuses the new stadium because of the small fan base.
Is it really hardcoded limit in the game?
Evgeniy Vovney at least 11 years before the board will even consider it.
Not likely I have a Chelsea save and in my third season the board proposed to expand the ground. You should try asking to expand the stadium first
@@stipzey1026 of course, I mean 'after expansion'.
Well the only thing I can think of is if you aren’t playing an entertaining soccer style because teams that play an entertaining soccer style are more likely to build new stadiums because it serves as revenue because the stadium will get filled up
Also don't think reputation matters either tbh. You Hoyd will gain rep as the club gains rep.
You forgot to mention the preferred tactic of the youth recruiter
Hi Omega Luke. Great video. What is the skin you use please?
I'd like to know that too!
Increase coaching budget 'common sense' true but must factor in, my board are cheapskates 😂
hi love the vids, how do i get your screen look with background/skin and face pack?
Skin called OPZ elite
FM Scout do I just find that on the workplace in steam??
@@MrWhitehouse83 google is your friend
Sounds a lot like Zealands video he posted not long ago 🤔
Maybe it does, not seen it. But Zealand's a smug prick with a face you want to punch.
How do i stop other club poaching my youth? This season alone i had 4 of my youth poached.
I don’t think the level of scouting matters at all personally. You showed off one player from Algeria, but surely managing a French club you’re more likely to produce African regens anyway?
I’m doing an academy challenge at the minute and have no scouts, and still get players with different nationalities coming through ever year. I’m managing in England and currently have players from Germany, Hungary, Gibraltar, Cyrpus and Spain who have all come through the youth system.
It just increases the chances, it’s not a garuntee
Very nice skin. Can you please tell me where I can download it? Thank you
hey man i tried loading on youth intake. every year it is on different days but in one year it is on a specific day how many times ever you try and after loading you can get a player your youth intake preview gives every player a bad position. for example in my fc tokyo save i saved after a match. got youth intake the next day.had a extremely bad intake and then loaded 4-5 time and got intake on the same day(intake gets different day every year but on a particular year it is on a particular day and you can find the month of youth intake in youth preview tab) on 5th try i got a extremely great winger with pa 180(check with fmrte as wanted to check my theory),but the youth intake preview said none of the wingers are good this year(Not even one just said one good striker and one good full back).
This is probably more due to your coaches not having the best judging player ability/potential stats than anything else. I’m not sure if you checked that good winger every time but he may well have still been really good every single time you reloaded just your coaches couldn’t see that
Yannick Menu only has scouting knowledge of France on my save?
How is your game looking so...good. Like home screen and everything, it looks beautiful. Mine looks ugly. How to do this? Are these mods?
Good video 👍
How do you create those images for your players? Mine are blank
his GUI looks so different. what are they doing?
What’s the skin and why do your regens look so real
Monthly subscription facepack
Beast Mode can u subscribe for one month get the faces and unsub after
Why do your regens look so awesome?
Regen facepack by @ChilledMoose on twitter
Female head of youth development are fantastic.... I had 3 of them over the years with each of them in club for 20 years each and that time almost 75 percent of my team was from England...btw i had picked Chelsea
your skin looks very nice.... what it is?
what skin and face pack are you using
The guy probably has France as his second nationality. Algeria are a former colony so they get a free citizenship
Does anyone know what skin he is using here is it on the FM scout site?
How can you see player potential in the stats?
Junior Coaching affect the players CA
Youth recruitment affect the PA
For HOYD, preferered formation and the different styles also affect what kind of players he will attract
EDIT: Official statement from SI developer.
Training Facilities
The training facilities available for all visible players at the Club, senior and youth. The quality directly impacts upon player progression and training injuries.
Youth Recruitment
The Club’s recruiting of Juniors, those of home and foreign origin. Impacts upon newgen quality.
Youth Facilities
The facilities available for Juniors only. Impacts upon newgen quality.
Junior Coaching
The quality and quantity of Junior Coaches at the Club. Impacts upon newgen quality.
"Impact upon newgen quality" = both CA and PA.
"Juniors" = invisible pre-newgen aged players.
junior coaching affects pa and youth facilities affect ca and youth recruitment only affect where your regens come from
@@reuben524 Junior coaching only affect the CA of the joining regen and nothing else.
Youth facilities affact the probablity of development.
Let's say my youth facilities is only at "Adequate" and I have 5* star regen. Because my facilities is only "Adequate" his probability of development is only 35%. But if my facilities is "State of the Art" his probability of development is now 85% instead.
While youth recruitment do affact where regens come from it is also the one that affect their PA together with your HOYD.
@@tictac3622 no man youth facilities only improves ca as they are training facilities of your youth team while training facilities are used by everyone at the club who can play. even i thought youth coaching give higher ca players but i found in some si forum about this.
@@reuben524 Found the thread you're talking about. And it do seem like they've changed it a few years back. Here is the official statement from the SI developer.
Training Facilities:
The training facilities available for all visible players at the Club, senior and youth. The quality directly impacts upon player progression and training injuries.
Youth Recruitment:
The Club’s recruiting of Juniors, those of home and foreign origin. Impacts upon newgen quality.
Youth Facilities:
The facilities available for Juniors only. Impacts upon newgen quality.
Junior Coaching:
The quality and quantity of Junior Coaches at the Club. Impacts upon newgen quality.
"Impact upon newgen quality" = both CA and PA.
"Juniors" = invisible pre-newgen aged players.
Now there shouldn't be anymore confusion on what each part do.
What do you use for the regen portrait
Chilled moose on twitter
@@fmscout oh and ad always. Great video
Thank you my friend - Luke
What is Your mod for regens faces?
Luke being sponsored by Vans? :)
No but if they are watching and would like to get in touch 😅
What skin is this and where can I get it?
How do you get the layout you have??
I’m gonna sound really dim here but do these fm20 tips also work on fm19?
yes
Anyone can tell me what names of Theme that he uses?
Just do a save with crewe now on epl in 2025 with youth
What skin is used in this video?
And what wouls your tip be on my case, in 11 years i have only 2 or 3 players that are decent and of them 1 is really good, i am leading Partizan, i have best facilities and everything else to improve, 4 5 star reputation, beast hoyd almost whole save, and still i only produce 2 star youngsters
Because Serbia only have a youth rating of 3*
So generally there won't be coming that many good youth players through.
The quality of your youth coaches also affact the regens you attract
@@tictac3622 i know thay, but in 11 years with best facilities onlh 1 5 star player and rest at best 3? That is way to dodgy, and whole serbia didn't produce world clasa talent in that time, and when I play in other leagues i find world beaters here
How do you get that skin
hey luke youth facilities gives regens ca
My bad 😃 Hope the rest of the video helped - Luke
Somehow, the skin reminds me of FM15
what's that skin and background
What's his skin name and where can I download it?
OPZ Elite on FM Scout
Didn't think country knowledge had anything to do with youth intake?
I know this comment is 1yr old, but idc
It only makes sense tho, your club is less likely to take youth from places they don't know anything about
Wow what skin is this?
re/newgen facepack?
What pack is this
What is the skin name pls
Just sign Bryan Klug
Got him on my Feyenoord save. What a man
This is who I have actually. What a legend
Where can i get that skin?
Fm scout website
What's your skin?
@Vic VDM thanks
What skin is this?
What skin do you use ? And regens picture?
OPZ elite and Chilled Moose regen pack
@@fmscout Thanks :)
Give me link facepack bro.
Skin?
OPZ elite you can download it for free on the fm scout website
Poor, very poor.
Thanks Neil
@@fmscout sorry but your latest batch of videos just seem to be really poorly scripted and presented. Its putting me off the channel.