I think you don't see a difference because you did not enable unlimited performance on both boards. That unlocks the total wattage and requires the use of a fan and is safe and tested. Unlimited performance they say has no effect on power consumption while idle. The 8 core version practically demands the use of unlimited performance. I wonder what the performance comparison is with UP disabled for both boards while transcoding videos. You might also try some utility programs that disable cores. I want to know how to enable and disable the UP mode dynamically while windows or Linux was running. I would love to see this company come out with a couple mini-itx and micro-itx, power efficient while idle, motherboards. One X16 slot would be nice. Also at least 2 nvme. But don't bother with extra power connectors. x16 is useful for a mid range graphics card. Yes people will try to pointlessly play games on it. The x16 and graphics card is useful for transcoding on the card. It's a solid strategy to use little power most of the time and then ramp it up to convert a file in 2-5 minutes. Then turn the graphics card back off.
Both CPU's have a Tjunction max of 105 degrees Celsius. They will not start throttling until 80+ degrees Celsius. That said, I agree it is warm at 60+ degrees and would prefer to use a fan. Several PCB cases are available with mounting holes for a 15mm slim or 25mm regular thickness fan depending on which case size is selected. For the performance discrepancy, my only theory is that while the N305 has a higher single core turbo frequency of 3.8Ghz (versus N97 3.6Ghz), the N97 has a higher ALL core turbo of 3.4Ghz (versus N305 3.2Ghz).
I just got the H+ for TrueNAS with HAOS and some other stuff down the road. It's a neat little guy. You can get the ram and I think an nvme from them but they don't direct you to all of it. I also didn't get the sata power cables and they were out of the office for few weeks, so I found some on Ali that work fine. I printed a little case with 92mm fan over the grill and it keeps it nice and cool. I think they offer a dreamcast case for it, not sure if that has cooling solutions though. The only thing im not pumped about is the DC jack. I'm using USB to DC so it might be the adaptor, but I have 2 that work, and they both have a bit of wiggle room that can power it off. Might just hot glue it on there. Nice find on the Windows nic drivers too, might come in handy if I install it someday. Great video, thanks!
1:29 Both captions say "Odroid H4 Ultra." Also, did you check your H4 Ultra version is configured to use 15W of TDP instead of 9W? Because it should be faster. The clock speed on the iGPU is slightly higher and it has 8 more execution units than the H4+.
Also, the TDP that Intel quotes means absolutely nothing in real terms. It refers to the "base frequency" which all CPUs happily ignore anyway in order to turbo (and in consequence, need more power) or clock down and save power. What is more, OP probably wanted to refer to power limits (PL1 or PL2), not the TDP. But somehow I doubt the power limits on any of these were 9 watts.
@@r0galik The N305 default TDP is 16W, but it can be configured down to 9W. That will limit how much the chip can turbo. This is more of a server CPU feature.
I bought the ultra with a case, fan, ram and sata cables. Still excellent value. I connected 4 sata drives and put a different version of linux on each drive so I can switch between them on real hardware.
@@TechnicallyUnsure It was the type 2 case. I left the sides off for access and got the official fan. It is almost silent and just comes on for a few seconds at a time
Glad to see a vid on something I want to get my hands on. Thanks. That said, a tiny bit more research would have bode you better results. The ram slot and the non--standard sata power plugs are clear from pics. Sata/power cables to suit are on the order of $3 each from hard kernel when you order the boards and problem solved. Also, read the wiki to unlock unlimited performance mode if not already done so get the most gains with the ultra and you'll likely have a bigger gap in benchmarks between that and the plus.
Playing RUclips videos with H4+ with a bit rate of 20-30MBps via the browser works relatively well, but the playback of native e.g. DJI videos (mp4 h.264, h.265, 50-100Mbps, 25fps directly from the onboard NVME 980 SSD + Crucial 48GB 5600 @ 4800MHz) unfortunately hacks enormously. An h.265 UHD video with 25fps and ~30Mbps with 2481 frames dropped 148 frames. 15Mbps dropped 32 frames, but I'm glad to have one H4+.
I imagine it's doing a bunch of windows update in the background so the heatsink should be very warm and power usage would be far from idle numbers, it means it's working correctly. If doing anything which requires the CPU to spin up the cores and actually tax them you will need active cooling, this could be made more clear on their site.
its a great board and I would be very interested but this power supply is a mega bummer, why no atx, why no mini itx form factor. almost good. but Ill keep on my list for now
Did they figure out a way around that seemingly hard coded from Intel bug with more than 16GB of RAM on these atom-class processors become unstable? EDIT: i have an N200 and it becomes unstable above 16GB but because i use it as my firewall/router i only need 8GB. I had wrote this chip off for anything other than a single purpose device like an entry level HTPC when i found out that it wasnt just an issue with my unit but seemingly every brand that uses AlderlakeN Atom-class processors, like the i3-N305 which i had been hoping to turn into a server+docker, to replacing my sister's file server which is i7-7700T I know its still not officially supported by Intel but i'd like to throw 64GB in one of these things(or 128GB with 2 dimms on the single channel), and find a board with four NVMe slots at 2x, or heck even 8 of them at 1x, and use that 9th lane for somewhat high speed networking for an ultra compact, ultra low powered, even portable file server, of couse both of these designs would be much larger than this package, but i think this would have worked great as an HDD file server if it had another M.2 slot on the back, and had 2x microSD slots that were bootable, with the M.2 drives for caching.
i cannot trust your review, try changhing the powersupply in between then and do the same tests. Also i am really sure you are not measuring correctly.
He would not need a stronger power supply unless he hooks up 3.5 inch HDDs. I don't doubt his performance results because other people seem to be seeing a similar trend.
I think you don't see a difference because you did not enable unlimited performance on both boards. That unlocks the total wattage and requires the use of a fan and is safe and tested. Unlimited performance they say has no effect on power consumption while idle. The 8 core version practically demands the use of unlimited performance. I wonder what the performance comparison is with UP disabled for both boards while transcoding videos. You might also try some utility programs that disable cores. I want to know how to enable and disable the UP mode dynamically while windows or Linux was running.
I would love to see this company come out with a couple mini-itx and micro-itx, power efficient while idle, motherboards. One X16 slot would be nice. Also at least 2 nvme. But don't bother with extra power connectors. x16 is useful for a mid range graphics card. Yes people will try to pointlessly play games on it. The x16 and graphics card is useful for transcoding on the card. It's a solid strategy to use little power most of the time and then ramp it up to convert a file in 2-5 minutes. Then turn the graphics card back off.
Both CPU's have a Tjunction max of 105 degrees Celsius. They will not start throttling until 80+ degrees Celsius. That said, I agree it is warm at 60+ degrees and would prefer to use a fan. Several PCB cases are available with mounting holes for a 15mm slim or 25mm regular thickness fan depending on which case size is selected. For the performance discrepancy, my only theory is that while the N305 has a higher single core turbo frequency of 3.8Ghz (versus N97 3.6Ghz), the N97 has a higher ALL core turbo of 3.4Ghz (versus N305 3.2Ghz).
I've used my h3+ everyday since it came out. Ordered my odroidh4 ultra 2 days ago!
I just got the H+ for TrueNAS with HAOS and some other stuff down the road. It's a neat little guy. You can get the ram and I think an nvme from them but they don't direct you to all of it. I also didn't get the sata power cables and they were out of the office for few weeks, so I found some on Ali that work fine.
I printed a little case with 92mm fan over the grill and it keeps it nice and cool. I think they offer a dreamcast case for it, not sure if that has cooling solutions though.
The only thing im not pumped about is the DC jack. I'm using USB to DC so it might be the adaptor, but I have 2 that work, and they both have a bit of wiggle room that can power it off. Might just hot glue it on there.
Nice find on the Windows nic drivers too, might come in handy if I install it someday. Great video, thanks!
1:29 Both captions say "Odroid H4 Ultra." Also, did you check your H4 Ultra version is configured to use 15W of TDP instead of 9W? Because it should be faster. The clock speed on the iGPU is slightly higher and it has 8 more execution units than the H4+.
Oooopss.. Sorry about that...
@@TechnicallyUnsure pls do it!
Also, the TDP that Intel quotes means absolutely nothing in real terms. It refers to the "base frequency" which all CPUs happily ignore anyway in order to turbo (and in consequence, need more power) or clock down and save power.
What is more, OP probably wanted to refer to power limits (PL1 or PL2), not the TDP. But somehow I doubt the power limits on any of these were 9 watts.
@@r0galik The N305 default TDP is 16W, but it can be configured down to 9W. That will limit how much the chip can turbo. This is more of a server CPU feature.
@@BrunodeSouzaLinoare you sure you mean TDP and not PL?
I bought the ultra with a case, fan, ram and sata cables. Still excellent value. I connected 4 sata drives and put a different version of linux on each drive so I can switch between them on real hardware.
Which one? Did you buy this? www.hardkernel.com/shop/odroid-h4-case-type-3/ As for fan, did you buy official fan from ODroid or something generic?
@@TechnicallyUnsure It was the type 2 case. I left the sides off for access and got the official fan. It is almost silent and just comes on for a few seconds at a time
The price won't go up from Hardkernel, resellers prices fluctuate for reasons.
18:20 if you designed a custom case for it, you'd including mounting points for a big fan directly above it.
I think for that budget, ur better off getting an AMD/APU or even an ARM based board depending on the application.
Glad to see a vid on something I want to get my hands on. Thanks. That said, a tiny bit more research would have bode you better results. The ram slot and the non--standard sata power plugs are clear from pics. Sata/power cables to suit are on the order of $3 each from hard kernel when you order the boards and problem solved. Also, read the wiki to unlock unlimited performance mode if not already done so get the most gains with the ultra and you'll likely have a bigger gap in benchmarks between that and the plus.
Playing RUclips videos with H4+ with a bit rate of 20-30MBps via the browser works relatively well, but the playback of native e.g. DJI videos (mp4 h.264, h.265, 50-100Mbps, 25fps directly from the onboard NVME 980 SSD + Crucial 48GB 5600 @ 4800MHz) unfortunately hacks enormously. An h.265 UHD video with 25fps and ~30Mbps with 2481 frames dropped 148 frames. 15Mbps dropped 32 frames, but I'm glad to have one H4+.
Hey, update! In Unlimited Power (UP) mode - in no way any problems with playback of h.264, h.265 mp4 UHD Video up to 100Mbps!! Cool!
can't help but think this has gotta be some kind of driver related issue. were you able to try these multimedia and gaming tests from inside Linux?
The idle power consumption seems to be quite high…
Who makes the ethernet ports Intel or Realtek? I would use this for a pfsense box if it has Intel NICs.
It's Intel I226-V
@@TechnicallyUnsure Wow, that is good to hear. I might get one and use it to run pfsense. Have you tried running pfsense on yours? Thanks
I imagine it's doing a bunch of windows update in the background so the heatsink should be very warm and power usage would be far from idle numbers, it means it's working correctly.
If doing anything which requires the CPU to spin up the cores and actually tax them you will need active cooling, this could be made more clear on their site.
To check the model of the ethernet adapter you could just boot Linux off the USB and do lspci
How long was the turnaround from the time that you placed your order and then received the devices?
Around 10 days I think
its a great board and I would be very interested but this power supply is a mega bummer, why no atx, why no mini itx form factor. almost good. but Ill keep on my list for now
You can buy a mini itx kit to use it in any normal mini itx case. Personally I rather use the gamecube case.
16:50 A bit toasty. Gonna need a fan. Great hands on video thank you.
Did they figure out a way around that seemingly hard coded from Intel bug with more than 16GB of RAM on these atom-class processors become unstable?
EDIT: i have an N200 and it becomes unstable above 16GB but because i use it as my firewall/router i only need 8GB. I had wrote this chip off for anything other than a single purpose device like an entry level HTPC when i found out that it wasnt just an issue with my unit but seemingly every brand that uses AlderlakeN Atom-class processors, like the i3-N305 which i had been hoping to turn into a server+docker, to replacing my sister's file server which is i7-7700T
I know its still not officially supported by Intel but i'd like to throw 64GB in one of these things(or 128GB with 2 dimms on the single channel), and find a board with four NVMe slots at 2x, or heck even 8 of them at 1x, and use that 9th lane for somewhat high speed networking for an ultra compact, ultra low powered, even portable file server, of couse both of these designs would be much larger than this package, but i think this would have worked great as an HDD file server if it had another M.2 slot on the back, and had 2x microSD slots that were bootable, with the M.2 drives for caching.
i cannot trust your review, try changhing the powersupply in between then and do the same tests. Also i am really sure you are not measuring correctly.
He would not need a stronger power supply unless he hooks up 3.5 inch HDDs. I don't doubt his performance results because other people seem to be seeing a similar trend.
the n97 has a newer GPU the i3 is last gen GPU so CPU havey tasks its the i3 if you have the GPU tasks its the N97
all odroid product only comes with 1 months of warranty , i would say avoid them all, some company have no confident to their own product.
C2 from 2017 with librelec 9.0 daily used and still runs fine.
im surprised how bad the n305 was at playing videos
Just shows to go ya - that benchmarks are very limited in their usefulness
Can't Trust ur Video...
Bad Video, sry...