안녕하세요. 오늘은 슈만의 작품중 초고난곡중 하나인 "교향적 연습곡" 을 가져왔습니다. 이 곡 또한 군생활을 하면서 연습해온 곡인데요, 묵직하고 비창적인 테마를 시작해 여러 변주곡들이 나오며 힘차고 경쾌한 피날레로 마무리짓는 화려한 대작입니다. 오늘 보여드리는 이 "1852 Version" 은 슈만이 마지막으로 개정한 버젼이라고 할수 있겠습니다. 유작 변주곡과 오리지날 버젼 에튀드를 포함한 전곡 연주는 차후에 스튜디오를 빌려서 레코딩한뒤 공개 하도록 하겠습니다. 개인적으로 여태껏 연습해온 작품중 가장 어려운곡이 아닐까라는 생각이 들정도로 힘들었네요ㅠㅠ 너무 부족한 연주 들어주셔서 감사합니다. Greetings, everyone. This is "Symphonic Études (Op. 13)", one of the most difficult works by Schumann. It's a spectacular masterpiece starting from heavy and solemn theme, followed by several variations, and ending with forceful and lilting finale. This "1852 version" is the last revision by Schumann; the full version including posthumous variations and original Études will be recorded in a studio. It is also one of the pieces I practiced in the military, and personally this is the most formidable pieces I've ever played. Thank you for listening to my humble performance. 0:01 Theme 1:38 Var.1 2:45 Var.2 5:45 Var.3 6:49 Var.4 8:04 Var.5 8:57 Var.6 10:11 Var.7 12:54 Var.8 14:11 Var.9 16:58 Finale
So happy that you recorded this piece, it sounds great! And for something that is this long and difficult, what a feat it is to record so accurately in one sitting. Many great pianists will not do that, plus the mental energy it takes. I am hoping to see more Schumann in the future! I am trying to learn the Schumann Fantasy myself.
@@seonyonghwang Op.6 to me would be the hardest musically. Kreisleriana is also a massive artistic challenge, both are over 30 minutes and contain so many ideas.
스페인 대환상곡보다도 더욱이 기다려왔던 작품이 드디어 올라왔군요! 제가 크슬, 다비드무곡과 더불어 슈만에 입문하고 깊게 빠지게 된 결정적인 곡인지라 더욱 애착이 가는 것도 있었네요. 곡 자체가 슈만 특유 조울증 뇌절들이 많아서 어렵기도 하고 유작을 빼도 20분대라 연주의 전반적인 디테일과 해석에 굉장히 애먹으셨을듯 한데 그럼에도 불구하고 훌륭한 연주 퀄리티라 제가 다 만족스럽네요. 차후에 올라올 유작 변주가 딸린 연주본은 길이가 무려 35분이나 되는데다 센티멘탈한 변주도 많아서 연주하시다가 슈만 부관참시 광화문 효수 욕구가 변주 시작마다 드실 듯 한데 지금까지 봐왔던 황선용님의 기교나 해석을 생각하면 무탈하게 기꺼이 해내시고도 남으실 듯 하다는 생각입니다 ㅋㅋㅋ 아무튼 다음에 올라올 교튀드도 기대하겠습니다
Since it's the 1852 version, it can't be helped that Etude III and Etude IX are omitted, or maybe it's normal, but I didn't want the omission of fisis in Bar 4 in Ver.2 = 3:05 ＆ 3:47
대곡을 감상하게 해 주신 노고에 감사드립니다 교향곡의 기승전결이 그대로 느껴집니다. 피날레로 경쾌한 마무리를 해주시고요. 피아노라는 한가지 악기로 이런 멋진 대곡을 편곡이 아닌 오리지날 악보로 감상하게 되어 뜻 깊은거 같습니다. 베토벤 교향곡의 피아노버전은 익히 들은봐 있지만 말입니다.. 단번에 다 듣지 못하고 이어서 들었는데 다시한번 단숨에 들어봐야겠습니다..수고하셨습니다.
My God! What a luminous finale! I understand now what this piece has a Symphonic adjective in its title. The piano certainly sounds like an orchestra here. It's a pity the piece isn't that well known. I got to admit, I wasn't that much familiar with it, until I've listened to it attentively today, performed by you. Now I'm certain it's one of my favorite pieces of the Romantic period. Thank you.
SO GREAT MAGNIFICENT WONDERFUL AS ALWAYS!!!!! Thank you for my favourite Schumann and for an excellent impressive delightful performance, again my best wishes from Poland to Korea, have a nice relaxing sunny warm weekend. Joanna
와 잘 들었어요 작년 졸업 연주때 이거 연주하고 전혀 피아노와 관련 없는 직장에 취직해버려서 퇴근 후 취미로만 연주하고 있었는데, 우연히 이번 여름에 고향에서 연주할 기회가 생겨 다시 틈틈히 공부하던 중에 이 영상에서 아이디어를 참 많이 얻어갑니다!!! 잘 참고해 좋은 연주 해보겠슴다 ! 선용님도 꼭 좋은 레코딩 하시길 바랄게요 ㅎㅎ 학창시절에 콩쿠르에서 몇번 뵌 적 있는데 인사는 첨 드리네요 앞으로 좋은 음악 많이 부탁드려요 감사합니다!!!
Well...I gave you a 'like' because this is probably my favorite Schumann piano work and I'd probably enjoy listening to it even if performed by a saxophone quartet, but....I'm afraid I thought this didn't live up to your standards. It sounds just-learned to me, lacking polish in terms of phrasing, dynamics, pedaling, even notes in some spots. This piece done well is MAGIC, but I thought this performance was just good. EDIT: Well I think I have to eat my words. After listening to your other recording of this (with the posthumous variations), It's apparent that much of what I was missing was due to the piano and the recording than to your actual playing. @victorus3160, if you want a recommendation, I highly recommend that recently uploaded version. The cleaner sound (less reverb) and warmer Yamaha sound make all the difference. (And I never thought I'd be using the term "warmer" when writing about a Yamaha!)
Do you have some interpretations to recommand? Because except var 7 I really did like this one (I never listened to Schumann, shame on me). And if you'd like to share other Schumann's piece with your favorite interpretations, I'm all eyes!
@@ArtenixBlack nah, I don’t think it would be good form to suggest one pianist’s performance on another’s video! A quick RUclips search will turn up more choices than you could ever want (although most will be the 1837 version which includes 2 additional “variations”, and many recordings these days also include a set of 5 more variations cut by Schumann and restored by Brahms in 1890 [if Wikipedia isn’t lying to me]). Happy listening!
@@mumps59 Yeah I was asking you to 1) understand in which one you discovered such magic, which one made you think : "that's my favorite from Schumann", 2) because often my favorites are not on youtube, or in bad quality, or very very hard to find on yt. But I'd understand! There is no problem to judge the performance (but you know, when I see the amount of work behind this kind of video, I just can't write something like "okay, it is good but not well, I heard better by some world-wide known pianist") but when I see many comments only write about how there is better, while my self could never reach his piano skills... I'm too sensitive I guess ^~^"
Wow haven't been here for a long time and the sound is incredible now :) I played this piece for a competition 15 years ago and this is still one of the deepest pieces in my opinion. So jealous that you can play all those 10ths easily - I can't for most of them and have to roll them. You play really beautifully - would definitely listen to your concert if you do hit up the Australia circuit in the future :)
Uff... I've been waiting for this for a long time.... Good interpretation of all the pieces. But personally you occupy a lot of pedal and the tempo is a bit fast.... But, well... Even so I quite liked your interpretations, congratulations for daring to play these pieces
I simply love all of your playing! Spanish Fantasy, then two M2U pieces then this! You are insanely good of a piano player and I hope you continue playing forever!
Se posso farti una domanda, vorrei chiederti chi è secondo te tra i brani più difficili da interpretare tra , Schumann , Liszt, Rachmaninov e Chopin...
Amazing performance!! Would like a bit more contrast between repeats, for instance, bringing out one voice in one repeat and another voice in the other.
@@seonyonghwang I can hear a slight difference, but not enough. For instance, for Variation 5, I would bring out the upper voice the first time (not ignoring the accented notes, but not letting them drown out the right hand), and the lower accented notes the second time.
![[아르떼 음감실🎵]문지영의 슈만 교향적 연습곡 / R. Schumann, Symphonic Etudes](/img/1.gif)
안녕하세요. 오늘은 슈만의 작품중 초고난곡중 하나인 "교향적 연습곡" 을 가져왔습니다. 이 곡 또한
군생활을 하면서 연습해온 곡인데요, 묵직하고 비창적인 테마를 시작해 여러 변주곡들이 나오며 힘차고 경쾌한 피날레로
마무리짓는 화려한 대작입니다. 오늘 보여드리는 이 "1852 Version" 은 슈만이 마지막으로 개정한 버젼이라고 할수 있겠습니다.
유작 변주곡과 오리지날 버젼 에튀드를 포함한 전곡 연주는 차후에 스튜디오를 빌려서 레코딩한뒤 공개 하도록 하겠습니다.
개인적으로 여태껏 연습해온 작품중 가장 어려운곡이 아닐까라는 생각이 들정도로 힘들었네요ㅠㅠ 너무 부족한 연주 들어주셔서 감사합니다.
Greetings, everyone. This is "Symphonic Études
(Op. 13)", one of the most difficult works by Schumann.
It's a spectacular masterpiece starting from heavy and solemn theme, followed by several variations, and ending with forceful and lilting finale.
This "1852 version" is the last revision by Schumann;
the full version including posthumous variations and original Études will be recorded in a studio.
It is also one of the pieces I practiced in the military, and personally this is the most formidable pieces I've ever played.
Thank you for listening to my humble performance.
0:01 Theme
1:38 Var.1
2:45 Var.2
5:45 Var.3
6:49 Var.4
8:04 Var.5
8:57 Var.6
10:11 Var.7
12:54 Var.8
14:11 Var.9
16:58 Finale
여태까지 여러 난곡?들을 해오셨는데 이게 제일 어려웠던 이유가 있을까요?
@@hemidemisemi9907 곡이 요구하는 음악적 해석이나, 곡의 긴 길이때문에 한번에 완고한 연주를 하기가 너무 힘들었습니다.. ㅠ
@@seonyonghwang 그러고보니 편집이 없군요!! 답변 감사해요
So happy that you recorded this piece, it sounds great! And for something that is this long and difficult, what a feat it is to record so accurately in one sitting. Many great pianists will not do that, plus the mental energy it takes. I am hoping to see more Schumann in the future! I am trying to learn the Schumann Fantasy myself.
Thank you! Yes. I absolutely LOVE Schumann's Music. The fantasy..! I want to play it too Omg.
@@seonyonghwang Yes you absolutely should...Or maybe Carnaval too
@@calebhu6383 Carnaval. Faschingsschwank aus Wien. Concerto Etc. I want to try his almost piano pieces. Especially I like his Op.6 nowaday!
My two favorite youtube pianists together? Pog
@@seonyonghwang Op.6 to me would be the hardest musically. Kreisleriana is also a massive artistic challenge, both are over 30 minutes and contain so many ideas.
I just saw this performed yesterday! I really like this piece, thank you for playing it!
스페인 대환상곡보다도 더욱이 기다려왔던 작품이 드디어 올라왔군요! 제가 크슬, 다비드무곡과 더불어 슈만에 입문하고 깊게 빠지게 된 결정적인 곡인지라 더욱 애착이 가는 것도 있었네요.
곡 자체가 슈만 특유 조울증 뇌절들이 많아서 어렵기도 하고 유작을 빼도 20분대라 연주의 전반적인 디테일과 해석에 굉장히 애먹으셨을듯 한데 그럼에도 불구하고 훌륭한 연주 퀄리티라 제가 다 만족스럽네요. 차후에 올라올 유작 변주가 딸린 연주본은 길이가 무려 35분이나 되는데다 센티멘탈한 변주도 많아서 연주하시다가 슈만 부관참시 광화문 효수 욕구가 변주 시작마다 드실 듯 한데 지금까지 봐왔던 황선용님의 기교나 해석을 생각하면 무탈하게 기꺼이 해내시고도 남으실 듯 하다는 생각입니다 ㅋㅋㅋ 아무튼 다음에 올라올 교튀드도 기대하겠습니다
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 감사합니닷
와....이건 모.......공짜로 듣는게 염치없을뿐이네요.....꼭 멋진 레코딩해주세요....퍄뇨도 좋은것으로....
ㅎㅎ 들어주셔서 감사합니다~
I WANT to like Schumann, really I do, but he's so pointless and boring
Since it's the 1852 version, it can't be helped that Etude III and Etude IX are omitted, or maybe it's normal, but I didn't want the omission of fisis in Bar 4 in Ver.2 = 3:05 ＆ 3:47
대곡을 감상하게 해 주신 노고에 감사드립니다
교향곡의 기승전결이 그대로 느껴집니다.
피날레로 경쾌한 마무리를 해주시고요.
피아노라는 한가지 악기로 이런 멋진 대곡을 편곡이 아닌 오리지날 악보로 감상하게 되어 뜻 깊은거 같습니다.
베토벤 교향곡의 피아노버전은 익히 들은봐 있지만 말입니다..
단번에 다 듣지 못하고 이어서 들었는데 다시한번 단숨에 들어봐야겠습니다..수고하셨습니다.
My God! What a luminous finale! I understand now what this piece has a Symphonic adjective in its title. The piano certainly sounds like an orchestra here. It's a pity the piece isn't that well known. I got to admit, I wasn't that much familiar with it, until I've listened to it attentively today, performed by you. Now I'm certain it's one of my favorite pieces of the Romantic period. Thank you.
I'm glad to you like the schumann's music!! Thank you!
Schumann is undervalued. Have you played his Fantasiestück?
Only no.1 and 2
This is all greatt but you skipped one variation.Why???
SO GREAT MAGNIFICENT WONDERFUL AS ALWAYS!!!!! Thank you for my favourite Schumann and for an excellent impressive delightful performance, again my best wishes from Poland to Korea, have a nice relaxing sunny warm weekend. Joanna
Thank you for listening Joanna!
Çok güzel olmuş. Senden Kreisleriana'yı da duymak isterim; eminim çok büyüleyici bir kaydın ortaya çıkacağına!
Bu arada 2. varyasyonda Sviatoslav Richter'den mi etkilendin? Etkilenmemek elde değil. Tempoyu daha hızlı seven tek ben değilmişim...
Your piano sounds great in these new recordings! This work is one of the best on your channel.
Wow, thank you!
I’m glad that you chose something that I would never see/hear played by any other pianist here on RUclips!
Haha, Thanks!
Welcome Back. Ah so beautiful music.
Ah relaxing listen to your music😌💙
Thank yoy for listening!
Amazing! Schumann's etudes are so beneficial in refining technique, I love them as much as any by Chopin. What etudes are your favourite to practice?
Thank you! Especially I liked var.5,9,Finale
와 잘 들었어요
작년 졸업 연주때 이거 연주하고 전혀 피아노와 관련 없는 직장에 취직해버려서 퇴근 후 취미로만 연주하고 있었는데, 우연히 이번 여름에 고향에서 연주할 기회가 생겨 다시 틈틈히 공부하던 중에 이 영상에서 아이디어를 참 많이 얻어갑니다!!! 잘 참고해 좋은 연주 해보겠슴다 ! 선용님도 꼭 좋은 레코딩 하시길 바랄게요 ㅎㅎ
학창시절에 콩쿠르에서 몇번 뵌 적 있는데 인사는 첨 드리네요 앞으로 좋은 음악 많이 부탁드려요
감사합니다!!!
헉 콩쿠르에서 뵌 적이 있군요! ㄷㄷ 세상참 좁습니다ㅠㅠ 감사합니다!
오늘도 좋은 곡 알아갑니당~ 항상 연주와 함께 악보를 보여주셔서 감상하기에 좋아요
혹시 프라움악기박물관에서 7월 26일에 하는 '황선용 피아노 독주회'가 황선용님 연주회 맞나요..? 꼭 가고싶네요
엇, 전 아직 예정된 연주회가 없어서 그건 제가 아닐것같네요 ㅎㅎ..
동성동명의 피아니스트가 있다니 ㄷㄷ
영상에 타임라인을 올려주셨으면 좋겠네요. 오늘도 연주 잘보고 갑니다!😊
감사합니다 ㅎㅎ, 영상 설명란에 추가해 드렸어요! ㅎㅎ
2:01 저걸 한번에..
I love this piece. Can't wait to listen to the "missing" variation which is my favourite of them all hehe.
Haha. I love it too:) But, way difficult..
훌륭한연주 감사합니다 점심시간에 커피한잔과 너무나 즐겼습니다
😲악보 보는것만으로도 머리아프지만 좋아서 끝까지 잘 들었어요
대체 얼마나 연습 하신겁니까
간간히 보고있었는데 이참에 정주행 가볼까 합니다
슈만이 대중 인지도가 상대적으로 낮은게 좀 안타까울 뿐입니다
이렇게 노래가 좋은데..ㅠㅠ
오우... 이런 대곡을 연주해주실줄은 몰랐네요 ㅎㅎ 진짜 피아니스트 문지영 리사이틀에서 듣고 홀딱 빠졌었는데.. 감사해요!
Well...I gave you a 'like' because this is probably my favorite Schumann piano work and I'd probably enjoy listening to it even if performed by a saxophone quartet, but....I'm afraid I thought this didn't live up to your standards. It sounds just-learned to me, lacking polish in terms of phrasing, dynamics, pedaling, even notes in some spots. This piece done well is MAGIC, but I thought this performance was just good.
EDIT: Well I think I have to eat my words. After listening to your other recording of this (with the posthumous variations), It's apparent that much of what I was missing was due to the piano and the recording than to your actual playing. @victorus3160, if you want a recommendation, I highly recommend that recently uploaded version. The cleaner sound (less reverb) and warmer Yamaha sound make all the difference. (And I never thought I'd be using the term "warmer" when writing about a Yamaha!)
Do you have some interpretations to recommand? Because except var 7 I really did like this one (I never listened to Schumann, shame on me). And if you'd like to share other Schumann's piece with your favorite interpretations, I'm all eyes!
@@ArtenixBlack nah, I don’t think it would be good form to suggest one pianist’s performance on another’s video! A quick RUclips search will turn up more choices than you could ever want (although most will be the 1837 version which includes 2 additional “variations”, and many recordings these days also include a set of 5 more variations cut by Schumann and restored by Brahms in 1890 [if Wikipedia isn’t lying to me]).
Happy listening!
@@ArtenixBlack also, don’t get me wrong, this is a good performance! You may find you like this one best and that my opinion is…well, just my opinion.
@@mumps59 Yeah I was asking you to 1) understand in which one you discovered such magic, which one made you think : "that's my favorite from Schumann", 2) because often my favorites are not on youtube, or in bad quality, or very very hard to find on yt. But I'd understand!
There is no problem to judge the performance (but you know, when I see the amount of work behind this kind of video, I just can't write something like "okay, it is good but not well, I heard better by some world-wide known pianist") but when I see many comments only write about how there is better, while my self could never reach his piano skills... I'm too sensitive I guess ^~^"
Schumann was a fantastic composer! You’re playing his etude magnificently 🤩👏🏻
Yes, Obiously beautiful set:) Thanks!
Next Hamelin??
7월 조성진 리사이틀 때문에 찾고 있었던 곡인데 ㅎㅎㅎ 잘 들었습니다~
Wow haven't been here for a long time and the sound is incredible now :) I played this piece for a competition 15 years ago and this is still one of the deepest pieces in my opinion. So jealous that you can play all those 10ths easily - I can't for most of them and have to roll them. You play really beautifully - would definitely listen to your concert if you do hit up the Australia circuit in the future :)
a truly masterpiece! Can't precisely to say how I glad to see and hear you actually play this etude. Magnificently!!!
Omg. Thank you!
폰연등때 이런 귀한걸.. 잘먹겠습니다 ㅎㅎ
폰연등 ㄷㄷ
너무너무 잘 들었습니다 연습하는데 얼마나 고생하셨을지 가늠이 안가네요 레코딩 버전도 정말 기대됩니다
감사합니다!
작곡가 칸솔님 맞으시죠? 메일로 드리고싶은 말씀이 있어서 보냈는데 혹시 확인해주시면 감사하겠습니다 ㅎㅎ
으아ㅏㅏㅏ피날레 정말 최고네요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ👍👍
Have you ever did or you do any kind of exercise? (gym, calisthenics, martial arts, etc.) Since how old did you start playing piano?
I'm doing gym but not doing that hard.
와...
ㅎㅎ 들어주셔서 고마워요~
감사합니다. 스코어와 같이 보니 너무 좋네요 :-)
플레트네프 연주를 자주 들었었는데, 꼭꼭 씹어먹으며 재밌게 듣겠습니다.
저야말로 감사합니다ㅎㅎ
The 5th variation is the hardest one
wow 23 minutes :o idk much schumann time to listen
you are the most epic youtube pianist
Omg Thank you:)
Nice and beautiful 😍 🤩 👌 ❤️
Uff... I've been waiting for this for a long time.... Good interpretation of all the pieces. But personally you occupy a lot of pedal and the tempo is a bit fast.... But, well... Even so I quite liked your interpretations, congratulations for daring to play these pieces
Sorry, if you don't like:(
Thank you for listening.
Beatiful piece and performance!
Thank you:)
사랑해도 될까요...
의도적으로 페달 줄이신거도 맘에 드네요
감사합니다 ㅎㅎ
wow, the king is back!
잘 들었습니다 특히 피날레 부분이 오페라를 보는것 같았습니다!
들어주셔서 감사합니다 ㅎㅎ
I might be asking a tad bit much from you, but would you be able to play Liszt's A Major Waltz S.208a?
yes. I could:)
@@seonyonghwang :)))
BRAVO!!!! amazingg :)
First time hearing this, sounds amazing
I simply love all of your playing! Spanish Fantasy, then two M2U pieces then this! You are insanely good of a piano player and I hope you continue playing forever!
Thank you!!!
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Schumann is a fantastic composer!
아름다워요
Awesome.
Se posso farti una domanda, vorrei chiederti chi è secondo te tra i brani più difficili da interpretare tra , Schumann , Liszt, Rachmaninov e Chopin...
Tutti sono molto difficili. Penso che Rachmaninov sia il più difficile.
@@seonyonghwang 👍👋
Finally! Bravo! 🇺🇦🫶🏻🤝🏻
Thank you for listening:)
잘 들었습니다. 늘 애청합니다.
Incredible performance, so much energy
Thank you so much for listening my performance!
Nice!
와 23분 ㄷㄷ 정말로 긴 연습곡 이네요...
연습곡 악보가 혹시 몇장 정도 되나요?
20 30장정도됬던걸로 기억해요ㅠ
Also 23 minutes is only the shortest version. He says he might record the full version which may be closer to 35 minutes 😅
@@calebhu6383 It's CRAZY Difficult.
First, yay! Cant wait to listen!
Hello! Thank you!
Amazing performance!! Would like a bit more contrast between repeats, for instance, bringing out one voice in one repeat and another voice in the other.
Thank you! Um, I little tried about that, but I think sounds like didn't work strongly.. Sorry.
@@seonyonghwang I can hear a slight difference, but not enough. For instance, for Variation 5, I would bring out the upper voice the first time (not ignoring the accented notes, but not letting them drown out the right hand), and the lower accented notes the second time.
@@zswu31416 Oh, Nice idea:) Thank you for suggetion.
@@seonyonghwang Kissin's interpretation of the Brahms Paganini Variations has many of those moments. It's worth analyzing in detail.
@@zswu31416 Ok. I will check.
Esecuzione monumentale 👏👏👏
Thx🫡🫡
기교가 부럽습니다..
허헛.. 아닙니다ㅜ
beautiful!!!
Thx so much:D
5:47
슈만 - 피아노 부수기, op.13 no.3
헠ㅋㅋㅋ..
Yay!
!yaY
What pieces do you plan on doing in the near future, whether it be classical or not?
@@advikthepianokid4583 I have beethoven's one and Czerny, Prokofiev