S. Jaishankar Book - The India way - A Review । BOOK REVIEW । INDIA FOREIGN POLICY

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 янв 2025

Комментарии • 141

  • @earther-v2w
    @earther-v2w 3 года назад +24

    I am glad to see professor Khan, now Satya Hindi will provide international quality content....

    • @narendertomar9367
      @narendertomar9367 3 года назад

      Satya hindi mai bhi कई patrakar चित् पावन गोत्र वालों जैसी मानसिकता के हैं

  • @S.K.R0HAN
    @S.K.R0HAN 3 года назад +19

    Ashutosh ji, Bahut khoob... Ek aur zabaradast series ki shuruwat... Apne society & country ko mazboot banaane ke liye ye bahut zaroori hai. 👌🙏💟

  • @aaziz11
    @aaziz11 3 года назад +4

    प्रोफेसर मुक़्तक़दर ने बहुत गहराई से जयशंकर की किताब का विमोचन किया जयशंकर ने महाभारत को अर्थशास्त्र से भी ज़्यादा महत्वपूर्ण बताया जो की एक मूर्खतापूर्ण निष्कर्ष है सत्यहिंदी का ये प्रयास प्रशंसनीय और अभूतपूर्व है साधुवाद आशुतोष जारी रखें मज़ा आ गया

  • @shahzadaansari5106
    @shahzadaansari5106 3 года назад +15

    Very good initiative from Satya Hindi.... really appreciable

    • @ejazprankvlog7001
      @ejazprankvlog7001 3 года назад

      यूपी में BJP, SP, BSP, Congress और #AIMIM के बीच पांच कोणिये चुनाव होने जा रहा है l
      20-25% वोट हासिल करने वाले उम्मीदवार चुनाव जीत सकते हैं और यूपी में 143 सीट ऐसी है जहां मुस्लिम वोटर 20% से ज़्यादा हैं, 100 सीट ऐसी है जहां मुस्लिम वोटर 30% से ज़्यादा हैं, 40 सीट ऐसी है जहां मुस्लिम वोटर 40% से ज़्यादा हैं l नतीजे की परवाह किये बग़ैर अपना वोट अपनी क़यादत को दीजिये l अगर आप ने हिम्मत दिखाई तो आप के बग़ैर सरकार नहीं बन पायेगी l
      #इन्साफ़_की_सियासत #अपनी_क़यादत
      उठ बांध कमर, क्यों डरता है !
      फिर देख ख़ुदा क्या क

  • @SumanKumar-ge6gg
    @SumanKumar-ge6gg 3 года назад +1

    हिंदी में बहुत खूबसूरत जानकारी अंतरराष्ट्रीय संबंधों पर, धन्यवाद प्रो. खान

  • @सच्चाईकीतलाशमेंआमआदमी

    मेरी समझ में पेट्रोल डीजल दो सौ रुपए, गैस सिलेंडर पांच हजार रुपए,हर गली मुहल्ले में भव्य राम मंदिर (अस्पताल की जरूरत नहीं है)हो जाय तो भारत महान बन सकता है

  • @gopalagrawal3038
    @gopalagrawal3038 3 года назад +1

    Very very good session by Khan sahab. Satya Hindi is doing great work.....

  • @ratansingh437
    @ratansingh437 3 года назад

    बेहतरीन विश्लेषण के लिए साधुवाद.....अगली कड़ी के लिये उत्सुक…..

  • @pawakdas2199
    @pawakdas2199 3 года назад +6

    This is very useful for students preparing for civil services 👏

  • @abb-sz9le
    @abb-sz9le 3 года назад +1

    Satya hinde ke liya 👍 bhut khub kaam kaar rahe ho. Aap or aasa conversation channel pea Lavo hindu muslim akata ya jatewad sea janta ko chutkara mila. Taqi yuva janta in murkh neta ko sabak sikh sakea. Jai hind

  • @shashichandraray2505
    @shashichandraray2505 3 года назад +3

    Very very productive analysis I am looking ahead for more such informative analysis
    Thanks

  • @gurinderjitnagra7199
    @gurinderjitnagra7199 3 года назад +2

    Satya thanks to you please always talk about well fair of every indian

  • @ramashankar4823
    @ramashankar4823 3 года назад +2

    Very good sir. After s. Jaishankar is BJP man he will never think beyond RSS and BJP.

  • @ShakilKhan-el9pw
    @ShakilKhan-el9pw 3 года назад +2

    I appreciate your knowledge about the characters of Mahabharat and overall observation. A perfect analysis. Domestic part nicely covered. A rich experience. Thanks.

  • @bikashjha6059
    @bikashjha6059 3 года назад +5

    Professor M khan, good evening, I am very glad to see you on this platform, I have been following since your last conversation with Mukesh kumar on this Satya Hindi, I am although physics teacher but deep internet in international relationship in which I will definitely inhance my knowledge

    • @ProfMuqtedarKhan
      @ProfMuqtedarKhan 3 года назад +1

      Bikash Jha thanks for your comments. I will try my best.

    • @bikashjha6059
      @bikashjha6059 3 года назад +1

      @@ProfMuqtedarKhan Sir, how can I put my question to you, may I get your I'd?

  • @mohdshafi6615
    @mohdshafi6615 3 года назад +2

    Commendable great job Great people doing Great Things Histry creating Service SIR

  • @positivpowar4925
    @positivpowar4925 3 года назад

    सत्य हिंदी को बधाई आज के प्रोग्राम के लिए❤️👍

  • @saurav8585
    @saurav8585 3 года назад +1

    Looking forward for this very informative series..

  • @Singh.125
    @Singh.125 3 года назад +1

    Very good sir keep doing this regularly learn lots off things today

  • @saleemmohd2467
    @saleemmohd2467 3 года назад +1

    Useful discussion, touched real issues by Prof Khan in the context of domestic as well as global fronts.

  • @manharchovatiya5526
    @manharchovatiya5526 3 года назад

    Aap jaise gyani log he to bharat ko aage badhane se kaun rok shakta he....

  • @shakeebsayem
    @shakeebsayem 3 года назад +1

    Thank you sir for a wonderful conversation. Eagerly waiting for next episode.

  • @khushmindersahasi9139
    @khushmindersahasi9139 3 года назад

    Prof Khan has presented a nice criticism on Jaishankar’s book

  • @shabarinathrao7870
    @shabarinathrao7870 3 года назад +2

    Which government has the best relationship with both the gulf world along with Israel?? A country like Turkey is selling drones exclusively to india..not to be sold to Pakistan..

  • @sameekshajaiswal693
    @sameekshajaiswal693 3 года назад +1

    Thank you Professor Khan sahab.. 🙏🙏🙏

  • @shubhashlingade6018
    @shubhashlingade6018 3 года назад

    Thanks to satya hindhi channel for this programme

  • @VinodKumar-hv3hg
    @VinodKumar-hv3hg 3 года назад +2

    Bas ek hi rasta he. Health & education sabke liye free ho. Aur Constitution 10th sabhi ke liye jaruri ho

  • @pranavpratyushprabhakar526
    @pranavpratyushprabhakar526 3 года назад +1

    Very helpful 👌🏻👌🏻

  • @pankaj5080
    @pankaj5080 3 года назад

    satyahindi going next level

  • @accsltd6978
    @accsltd6978 3 года назад

    जनता का अपनाया और स्वीकार कर लिया गया नर्क कभी महान नहीं बन सकता ।🙋

  • @accsltd6978
    @accsltd6978 3 года назад +4

    From 2014 onwards, majority of the Indian public have adopted and accepted the Hindutva mythological method of governance which lead towards religious autocracy, the hell ! Any such country can never be Great !

  • @a.h.k4491
    @a.h.k4491 3 года назад

    Good point ☝️ you are writing about another planet,, but you are unaware of your planet what's happening behind you solid observation

  • @rajenkhobragade4842
    @rajenkhobragade4842 3 года назад

    बहोत खूब जाणकारी दी सरजी,

  • @VidyutDate
    @VidyutDate 2 года назад

    However, we all of us (world) agree to the flawless capabilities of Mr Jaishankar.

  • @praveendhariwal4907
    @praveendhariwal4907 3 года назад +2

    Good analysis ❤️

  • @jaswalrajkumar4293
    @jaswalrajkumar4293 3 года назад +2

    भारत महान था, महान है और महान ही रहेगा। चंद मूर्खौं की हरकत से कोई फर्क नहीं पड़ता।

    • @mumtazahmad1240
      @mumtazahmad1240 3 года назад +1

      सबसे बड़ा मूर्ख तो "MODO" है
      दुसरा A, शाह तीसरा,, " रोगी "।

  • @heiftonheifton9412
    @heiftonheifton9412 3 года назад +1

    Pls also invite tariq ali....he also has indepth view on world politics and international topics.

    • @Usamak1
      @Usamak1 3 года назад

      Tariq Ali and his Trotsky-ism are passe, irrelevant todayt.

    • @heiftonheifton9412
      @heiftonheifton9412 3 года назад

      @Usama Khalidi I know ....but he has wide range of expertise in international politics and its functioning.....also he is a authority on post independence sub continent....SO,... THAT MAKES HIM MORE OF A CANDIDATE TO ADDRESS ON TODAYS SITUATION.

    • @Usamak1
      @Usamak1 3 года назад

      @@heiftonheifton9412 "authority" on post-independence subcontinent? Whatever has he done to get that kinda credit? Wrote bad novels; played bad boy of British politics, pontificated in the wake of 9/11. Ah, yes. I think he interviewed Indira Gandhi. Playing pundit on British TV doesn't make him a historian.

  • @anilchauhan1911
    @anilchauhan1911 3 года назад +3

    आज के सरकार मे JNU के 2 product(जयशंकर & निर्मला) है, लेकिन दोनों फेव्कुफो जैसे लगते है,दोनों के मन्त्रालय कि credibility खराब हुई है। ये उस संस्थान कि अवहेलना है। ये वास्त्विक रूप से दुर्भाग्यपूर्ण है।

  • @SHIRISHPANDEY_84
    @SHIRISHPANDEY_84 3 года назад

    Behtreen vishleshan. Khan Saheb I will subscribe to ur channel.

  • @RichiAnand95
    @RichiAnand95 3 года назад

    Too Sad ! What Happens To My UMMA ??? I Am Crying For Umma !

  • @multikannan100
    @multikannan100 2 года назад +1

    Bharat phirse kaise mahan baney Bharat already mahan hai 2014 se aur jyada hai

  • @saifalam419
    @saifalam419 3 года назад

    Very good initiative . Informative video by khan saab...

  • @VidyutDate
    @VidyutDate 2 года назад

    One more thing to add is criticism of Mr Jaishankar's statement of India being neutral or non aligned. When Jaishankar says & prof agrees that the situations around the world has changed, still Jaishankar's advice is to maintain non aligned condition. I don't know why prof got confused.

  • @narendrapatel3909
    @narendrapatel3909 3 года назад

    Thank you so much sir

  • @aligadelaide9186
    @aligadelaide9186 3 года назад

    Interesting comments on js oblivion from current events in India and naivity. Show boy !

  • @ambedkarwadi3626
    @ambedkarwadi3626 3 года назад +1

    वेरी वेरी स्पेशल सीरीज

  • @miyousuf7856
    @miyousuf7856 3 года назад

    Very good presentation ham chahenge is trah ka presentation regular dikhaen. Dhanyawad

  • @kishordaware5278
    @kishordaware5278 3 года назад +1

    india me jab tak SC St OBC minority ke 90% bahujan log sattadhari nahi hota tab tak india kabhi pragati nahi kar sakta

  • @madhubalasharma2822
    @madhubalasharma2822 3 года назад

    Excellent presentation,very true to the present Indian context.

  • @AnwarAli-vc5kg
    @AnwarAli-vc5kg 3 года назад

    Wah
    Zabardast tajziya

  • @aligadelaide9186
    @aligadelaide9186 3 года назад

    Lots of good input in short time

  • @ashrufali1264
    @ashrufali1264 3 года назад

    Bharat paile se hi mahan hai Modi yogi milkar hati mahan banayenge koi sak nhi hai 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @sumitbali9194
    @sumitbali9194 3 года назад +6

    In short this book is a work of fiction, the writer has cleverly thosen to close his eyes to today's reality

  • @afzalbeg43
    @afzalbeg43 3 года назад +1

    किसी हदतक सही बात बोली है आप ने

  • @milansopariwala1350
    @milansopariwala1350 3 года назад +1

    S Jaishankar is the one of the best foreign minister of india.🇮🇳

  • @chandi6
    @chandi6 3 года назад

    एस जयशंकर पहले प्रशासनिक अधिकारी रहे है इसलिए वो पॉलिटिशियन के बीच मुखर नही हो पा रहे। जैसे मनमोहन जी सोनिया गांधी के प्रेसर के सामने कई जनकल्याणकारी नीति को लागू नहीं कर सके।

  • @pawakdas2199
    @pawakdas2199 3 года назад

    Very nice analysis 👌

  • @drbajranglalmeena2421
    @drbajranglalmeena2421 3 года назад

    Very Nice Sir 🙏🙏

  • @alexanderweakdull4566
    @alexanderweakdull4566 3 года назад

    मनुष्य महान बनने की प्रतिभा नही रखते है भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप के मनुष्य।

  • @appuratab122
    @appuratab122 3 года назад

    Awesome...

  • @umeshnarvekar2870
    @umeshnarvekar2870 3 года назад

    Thanks alot professor

  • @hemusinghjain9422
    @hemusinghjain9422 3 года назад

    Khan sir nicely expalind, question is we voter why vote politician who believe in divide and rules so blunder by voters

  • @ramdhenus.t.g.s.h.g.9086
    @ramdhenus.t.g.s.h.g.9086 3 года назад

    Thanks..

  • @pkpkmalik15
    @pkpkmalik15 3 года назад

    Looking nice at first appearance, what happen ahead, watch it

  • @chamansingh3657
    @chamansingh3657 3 года назад

    Congratulations...! Satya Hindi going international also. Nationalism of India vs others (China, US, Australia, Germany, Arabia etc) is quite different. Here the burden of nationalism is on average rather illiterate ( internationally) people. They want to pull back India to Mahabharat age as our FM says. The Varna system will never allow India to become a nation, never ever dream of this. Besides, digging the past to destroy communal harmony to get to power anyway is eating our vital parts particularly our roots. If roots are eaten/destroyed how can India as a tree survive ? A nation is not geographic boundaries but involves it's "one people" which is not in sight in near future. This is the only question I want to ask from the Hounrable channel and Dr. Khan.

  • @anketumrigar9896
    @anketumrigar9896 3 года назад

    Jaysankar knows but this is politics only he should npt mentioned in his book as title concern.

  • @gurinderjitnagra7199
    @gurinderjitnagra7199 3 года назад

    Please please every indian talk about this forget our political parties for our future

  • @hindi4222
    @hindi4222 3 года назад

    We can learn from the great Mythology

  • @nafistarin5971
    @nafistarin5971 3 года назад

    Indian politicians Double Standards includes JaiShankar. India needs a strong single face Human Priority Leaders not Rulers. It is not the matter of Chair but conduct

  • @m.z6437
    @m.z6437 3 года назад

    bharat muslimo ke ander hi no 1 tha.

  • @VidyutDate
    @VidyutDate 2 года назад +1

    Prof Khan is criticizing Mr Jaishankar's naivity on Indian Internal Dictatorship Politics. Stating India as Islamophobic & treachery. That means either prof. himself is not aware or covering treacherous Islamic activities in India which are Hinduphobic. It's Hindus reaction is coming up as a result against such terror based activities. Other words, if Jaishankar can be Islamophobic then why not prof. Hinduphobic ? Or if prof is Hinduphobic then why not Jaishankar Islamophobic. Making such conclusions need indepth comparative database, information & knowledge about it. Which is missing in this case study of Mr Jaishankar.

  • @wasiqkhan1174
    @wasiqkhan1174 3 года назад

    Bhai sahab bharat ab mahan banne ke nhi gulam banne ki taraf ja raha hay isski zimmedar bharat ki badhi aabadi hay

  • @rupalikapoor3159
    @rupalikapoor3159 3 года назад +3

    BJP ka safaya jaruri hai

  • @ravindersingh-xm6lq
    @ravindersingh-xm6lq 3 года назад +1

    Kitab likhne wala India ke hkeekat nahe janta ja fir wo manuwadi h . Punjiwad ko KISSANO ne swekar nahe kia h .
    Abhi koi mandir Masjid nahe hoga .
    85 number SHER SINGH SOTA jagchuka h New policy with old swedhan. India swedhan se he chlega na ke mandir Masjid se .

  • @ankitbhardwaj5988
    @ankitbhardwaj5988 2 года назад +1

    Sir apne sb kuch acha bola jb tk aap book se related bat kr rhe the uske bad apne apna agenda chalana suru krr diya....kya bol rhe ho aap ki india m Islamophobia promote krr rhi hai govt....areee prabhu kbhi india aa kr dekho pta bhi chle aapko..AC m baith kr india dekh rhe ho wo bhi aj ki bias media ki news dekh dekhr kr...reality janni hai ydi india ki to kbhi yha k muslim logo se milkr baat kre.....pta nii kis duniya m jee rhe ho aap....phle indian culture or indian logo ko smjh lo tb kuch comment krna wrna 70+ year ki age hh apki na india apki abhi tk smjh aaya or na aane wala ydi AC m baith kr aise hi andaja lgate rhe indian logo ka.....raay de rha hu jrur vichar krna ...jai hind 🇮🇳

  • @brig.khajuria1950
    @brig.khajuria1950 3 года назад +1

    Dear Mukhtdar Khan Sahab,
    Your analysis of the book by Jaishankar was excellent. However I feel you are not aware of actual situation in India. May be this Satya channel has got the better day of you to the extent of brainwashing you against the present dispensation as they always oppose all policies and projects of present leadership in India. India was ,is and will always remain a secular and democratic country. Some steps taken by the present government are only to bring everyone on the same playfield.
    A certain community has been given far too many concessions and you can't do a f..k about it. It's all done by a party for votes. Certain actions done in India with impunity by that community are not allowed even in most of the Islamic countries and absolutely not in Christian majority countries besides China, North Korea and Japan. The freedom enjoyed here like doing morning namaz at 5 in the morning on the loudspeakers at highest possible volume irrespective of the time when children have their final exams and doing namaz on roads and vacant lands and then claiming it as waqf board land are just a few of activities among the long list which are continuing . Has the present Government opposed/taken any action on it . Is it allowed in the country you have chosen to stay. Why have you not chosen an Islamic country for permanent residence.
    Please do not get biased by reading articles and books written by biased people who have their personal score to settle an example of that is the platform you have chosen to express your views. You must carry out some research to get to the bottom of the problem to get the real picture.
    Notwithstanding above, your talk was very well articulated with good analysis of certain issues. Well done and God bless.

  • @gurinderjitnagra7199
    @gurinderjitnagra7199 3 года назад

    Every indian fed up from castism and religion

  • @parmodkaushik6577
    @parmodkaushik6577 3 года назад

    Modi yogi aur Assam ke c.m. jaise netaon ko support kro desh sukhi to log be sukhi

  • @semikhan4179
    @semikhan4179 3 года назад +1

    Walaikumassalam wrwb

  • @chandanchoubey9915
    @chandanchoubey9915 3 года назад

    💐💐💐👌

  • @lavaphone8227
    @lavaphone8227 3 года назад

    What great thing has Jaishankar said? The current FM has set his son in US in Bhai paid org and father-son contribution has been zero or even negative in many ways. Nepotism runs rife among this group. They only give imaginary things, like paid consultant billing hourly to do something

  • @dineshw9281
    @dineshw9281 3 года назад

    S.Jaishankar is having a big wisdom no doubt but he have no support from in this government.

  • @d.s.shukla4822
    @d.s.shukla4822 3 года назад

    Read the Indian history

  • @xyzabc5909
    @xyzabc5909 3 года назад

    India is having always flaws democracy.

  • @sashams9756
    @sashams9756 3 года назад

    Mere Hindu bhaiyo kuchh kapti Log he Jo apne swarth ke Liye ( Rjnetik Labh ke Liye ) apko KAFIR Bolte he "NASTIK ko KAFIR" kehte he Hindu or kisi bhi or Dharam ko Manne wale ko Ger Muslim Bola Jata he . ye Lafz KAFIR Har Asthawan insaan or kisi Bhi Dharam ko Or Ishwar ko Manne wale ke Liye Apman ki Bat he 1 Gali ke Saman he fir Hindu Apne Aap Ko Kafir Kese BOL Sakte he ?
    Sach Mano Adharmi or Nastik insaan ko Hi KAFIR Bol sakte he . Islam Dharam ke Anusar agar Ishwar koi Doot insaan ke roop me ya farishte ke Roop me ya kisi Avatar ke Roop me Dharam ki siksha ke Liye Bheje or koi insaan ya koi Qom uska inkar Kare or Dharam ko Na Mane or Adharm Pe paap pe Kayam Rahe or Zulm Ziyadti kare Logo ko sataye na insaafy kare BeGunah Logo ki hatya kare MATLAB Dharam ko kisi Roop me na mane Adharmi Ho Jaye . usko sahi mayne me Kafir kahege . or Hindu ESE Nahi Hote ye sach he !....

  • @aligadelaide9186
    @aligadelaide9186 3 года назад

    Pity your other books review is not included in this segment.

  • @mhd230289
    @mhd230289 3 года назад +2

    In my view, Mr. Jaishankar is a total failure as a foreign minister. He has brought more shame to India than anything better.

  • @manishparmar2268
    @manishparmar2268 3 года назад

    हिंदी मे भी पब्लिश हैं?

  • @alokniranjan627
    @alokniranjan627 3 года назад

    काबिल तो mb तुगलक भी था. फिर क्या हुआ.

  • @kwochinshieh5149
    @kwochinshieh5149 3 года назад

    👏👍👌🙏

  • @qasimrazakhan8066
    @qasimrazakhan8066 3 года назад

    Jai Shanker qabil ho sakte hain lekin mafi k sàth ek chaploos hai Modi k

  • @samipakchitra9944
    @samipakchitra9944 3 года назад

    🙏🙏🙏

  • @narendertomar9367
    @narendertomar9367 3 года назад

    Mr professor ye मनुस्मृति वाले हैं books हवा में लिखी गई हैं

  • @akhlaqahmad5611
    @akhlaqahmad5611 3 года назад +2

    Professor Sahab Ab Bharat Gandhi ji Aour Nehru Wala Bharat Nahi Raha, Ab Bharat Gondse ,Gowelkar , Sawarker Aour Rss Ka Bharat Hai Ab Aapko Yaha Nafrat, Zulm, Jhooth, Pakhand, Dhokha, Aour Noutanki Ke Siwa Kuch Nahi Milega,

  • @VikashKumar-kw5ck
    @VikashKumar-kw5ck 2 года назад

    Simply, I wanna say one thing to you, you don't have ideas about India's domestic politics and India's democracy inside India, you need to study a lot about india andIndia's politics, how childish you have spoken here 😭😀😂

  • @chhandasarkar8094
    @chhandasarkar8094 3 года назад

    First view

  • @ramsharan535
    @ramsharan535 3 года назад

    Bhart main jab tak jatiwad hai
    ........,.,

  • @zaheerahmad4123
    @zaheerahmad4123 3 года назад

    I like u

  • @shabarinathrao7870
    @shabarinathrao7870 3 года назад

    Neglecting pakistan n bypassing to reach Afganistan..is it not a great move

  • @manishatambe3185
    @manishatambe3185 3 года назад

    Congress mukta bharat is best solution for it