"Stay Back" Is One of the Worst Teachings in Baseball Swing Instruction

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 янв 2025

Комментарии • 24

  • @jeremygreen6325
    @jeremygreen6325 21 день назад +7

    Stay back means to me dont get over your front too early forcing you to just throw your hands at the ball

  • @EquityCall
    @EquityCall 23 дня назад +12

    Shifting weight aggressively into the swing, will steepen the swing.
    Can it work, yes. But it creates more of a timing challenge in an already difficult task.
    The ideal solution is to brace your weight AGAINST the front leg, not OVER it.
    This allows you to stay more balanced as your lower body rotates.

  • @TyWebb12836
    @TyWebb12836 20 дней назад +3

    Its what you cant expect from a dude wearing a winter hat white Tshirt combo

  • @Poppi-Poppa-Socky
    @Poppi-Poppa-Socky 20 дней назад +2

    There's more than one way to hit. Just like there's a thousand different ways to cut up a turkey. To say it has to be done this one way only is ridiculous. Everyone's body moves differently.

  • @SwitchHittingDaily
    @SwitchHittingDaily День назад

    no way, i wont shit forwards and swing. so more power staying back.

  • @chrislewis5069
    @chrislewis5069 23 дня назад +1

    What Edgar was saying is not to roll over with your upper body and hips but to push with legs while tagging closed with upper body so you don't roll over on ball out front

  • @LeftyfromVB
    @LeftyfromVB 22 дня назад

    Great info, thanks!

  • @gheckolock81
    @gheckolock81 23 дня назад

    Nice production quality. I saw a video of Bagwell yell “keep your hand up” at an Astros practice and the batter hit a home run on the next swing. How ‘bout them apples :)

  • @TyWebb12836
    @TyWebb12836 20 дней назад +2

    Def a middle school gym teacher who almost made the pros

  • @dape8993
    @dape8993 21 день назад

    Who would you say is the modern hitter who most exemplifies the ideas you promote? Bobby Witt, Jr.?

  • @commonsense-u5h
    @commonsense-u5h 22 дня назад

    Mookie Betts has the swing instructors should base their teachings on.
    Hank Aaron was listed at 180 when he came into the league, yet prolly played 10-20lbs heavier in his prime. He also faced weaker pitching than hitters today.
    Griffey and Bonds are bigger dudes, both 6’2
    Betts is 5’9 and listed at 180lbs, yet that’s got be after he jumped into a pool in a sweatsuit.
    He gets the most power out of his size and weight and plays in the modern era.

    • @carlingram8316
      @carlingram8316 19 дней назад

      Betts is also just a freak athlete. Just watch video of him dunking a basketball and bowling a perfect game.
      He has a great swing worth learning from. But that doesn’t mean other hitters will have similar power production using his techniques. Different people need to find what works best for them.

    • @commonsense-u5h
      @commonsense-u5h 19 дней назад +1

      @@carlingram8316 absolutely, the hitter should always do what works best for them.
      my point was more that many online hitting instructors base their teachings off Bonds and Griffey, where in my opinion "IF" someone was to base their hitting instruction off of just one hitter, ti should be Betts.
      Keep in mind, ALL these guys are freak athletes.

    • @carlingram8316
      @carlingram8316 19 дней назад

      @@commonsense-u5h That’s fair and a good point.

  • @ElginChris
    @ElginChris 21 день назад

    Let’s see the old guys face 95+ every at bat. Exploding on the ball gives back precious time the fastball has taken away. Shifting weight into the ball is correct, but the pitchers are too good these days to be “walking” to the ball like the examples you showed. Griffey jr has a nice explosive swing with a slight pre step.

  • @mattrinck7503
    @mattrinck7503 22 дня назад

    I always took "stay back" as I was swinging too soon.

    • @theswingmechanic
      @theswingmechanic  22 дня назад

      @@mattrinck7503 that may be what some coaches mean, but most of them these days mean that they want you to keep your weight back throughout.

    • @mattrinck7503
      @mattrinck7503 22 дня назад

      @theswingmechanic You're right then. Don't do that!

  • @VicInNocal
    @VicInNocal 23 дня назад

    Good video bruddah

  • @josephturkall2868
    @josephturkall2868 23 дня назад

    Is the kid swinging at 9-11 seconds and example of staying on his back hip with no weight shift?

  • @jefffinney4233
    @jefffinney4233 18 дней назад

    Yikes is all I can say

  • @TyWebb12836
    @TyWebb12836 20 дней назад +3

    This guy teaches Cricket

  • @price_98
    @price_98 23 дня назад

    real