Yeah like the other guy said, i already consider it the yellow album, it's actually fantastic how they found such balance and unified mixing through it, not to mention they all sound equal on this one (maybe the drums a bit too loud) but that still don't stop me from hearing everything else unlike ajfa or death magnetic where one or another took too much space in the mix even tho both had great other parts that are great but isn't heard that much.
Newsted elaborated on the tone from black album and most fans think that "something was wrong" that date from the kill em all album. Actually all was very purposeful as metallica asked bob rock to make their album sound deeper rather than flat short distortion and bass that they were doing previously. That was due to the fact that grunge and bands like alice in chains, nirvana and other were gaining traction with deep bass and simple riffs, often with dropped one string
@@hiphopgrinch As much as i love metallica. I gotta say my Snakebyte Explorer sounds absolute best in D standard, my favorite tuning. Its just much more growl to it, but still has the tightness and versatiity to go high without it being for lack of better term "muddy/same'y". Sad but true, such awsome sound in the song. But good arguments can be made for the E standard too.
Bob Rock did an awesome,e job with the Black Album but Load ReLoad and St. Anger sucked 72 Season's sounds like it should be with what I call the classic old school Metallica records
@@brianpatrickreddington1750 sonically Load and Reload are nearly flawless. The guitar tone was the only issue because of its bluesy nature. And being tuned a half step down.
Mucha Gente piensa que James puede tocar como Kill 'em All o un And Justice for All, pero, 72 seasons es una propuesta "pesada" que deleita, claro que hay canciones que suenan como relleno, pero, justamente es estos arreglos que hacen que tengan una segunda vida.
The ONLY thing is needs is a much more punchy snare. The Black album snare felt like a gunshot going off, on this it's just a bit subdued. But otherwise this is fantastic.
It's pretty damn close man jesus...One on One studio is special and even they used every trick under the sun to get that room massive (ply wood and mics all over the fucking place), there is no recreating that perfectly. Honestly, this is probably the closest I have heard someone has come to recreating it, the drum sound is close, it needs what it cannot have to make it 100% and that's the room dynamics. \m/
How do you make James Hetfield have his classic attitude sounding vocals on the new songs?? I love when James sings aggressively like on the Black album and Black album tour live !!
@@chromebull884remember they did st anger on purpose that way as a response to current trends while the band was falling apart simultaneously. bob rock would be a welcome change of pace now the producer they swiped from rick ruben has the most sterile dry uninteresting mixes i have ever heard. he also effectively neutered the metallica guitar tone. load had more distortion. bob rock could right that ship and squeeze another classic album out of those goofballs. the man makes masterful sounding albums. anyone tell me with a straight face that dr. feelgood and the black album arent two of the best sounding rock/metal albums ever.
@@bloodlinefilmsGreg Fidelman is the one who produced HTSD and 72 Seasons. He seems to be much more of a "yes-man" who doesn't give a shit about anything.
Damn now this is what I'm talking about Metallica can still kick ass but the tones make it sound so much better and heavier they should start watching these and take notes
@_PuppetMaster86 some of the new tones were good on that album buy hearing alot of the songs with tones from kill em all to black album era just makes it even better its like the perfect icing on a already awesome cake 🎂
Its cool but the sabbath part sounds of rhythmically now for some reason (at 4:05). (I think the vocals during that section should be on the offbeat instead of the downbeat)
Sounds sooo much better. Metallica shoots themselves in the foot with the guitar tones and instrument sounds they play with these days. I don't get it theyre albums could sound so much heavier.
@@user-yw5ct1px3x I think James voice sounds the best it has in a long time but other than that I can’t say I agree with their choice to sound less heavy…. Kirk doesn’t play the solos properly… he doesn’t even play the full solo at times (blackened) I don’t see how that’s a second prime but to each his own. They didn’t cut corners in the 80s and early 90s
I see these comments about James' better voice every year lol. James lost his voice in 1993 and since then, he sounds like a coverband. However, I still love them.
@@mertdinc5459 Seriously ! It’s a lack of intensity. The anger and drive that was there in them to be the best, to put on the best show possible just isn’t there anymore. I think that they think because they’re old now it’s ok for them to kinda dial it back and take it easy but people pay good money for their shows. To me they should’ve never let up from that attitude that they had when they were younger. I would respect current Metallica so much more if they still managed to play and put on a show Iike they are hungry. I miss James’ 1991 voice where he’d yell yeaaahYEAAAAH!!!!!!! With all that power and grit in his vocals it just added to the intensity. Watching them play now they just look so casual and like they’re almost going through the motions in a way. When you take heavy metal and play it like a bunch of casuals it just defeats the purpose of metal in my opinion. Metal should be loud, heavy, crunchy and intense as hell. It’s not meant to be laid back music played by guys who are acting like they’re out for a Sunday drive. That type of sound and casual play style just isn’t meant for heavy metal in my opinion. This is why as much of a fan as I am I have no desire to see them live. They’ve been playing lazy like this for way too long now and combined with the fact that they have so many high quality videos of their live performances I feel like I literally have no reason to see them live
You see the way Metallica has lost the ability to utilize the palm mute. It's hard to not just play these riffs this way straight from the beginning. In a way that makes Metallica still very original.
see the instrumental is great, but the tricky part with these covers is the ai vocals. i can never fully invest in the song cuz ai just isnt there when recreating voices
I think...Metallica should have kept the tones and production from The Black Album for Load, Reload, Death Magnetic, Hardwired and 72 Seasons...and shelved St.Anger.
You're missing a ton of legato's and stops in the main riff. Also the drums are not even close to the Black Album "bob rock gunshot" snare. A for effort tho
man, literally do all the album in the Black Album tone, and call it the Yellow Album! this is amazing !! love it..
It technically is the yellow album
Yeah like the other guy said, i already consider it the yellow album, it's actually fantastic how they found such balance and unified mixing through it, not to mention they all sound equal on this one (maybe the drums a bit too loud) but that still don't stop me from hearing everything else unlike ajfa or death magnetic where one or another took too much space in the mix even tho both had great other parts that are great but isn't heard that much.
Do it PLEASE!!!!!!
I always called the latest "yellow album"
"R.T.L" tone + 80's Hetfield, PLEASE!!! \m/
Sad but true feeling
Sad but sandman
It reminded me of sbt the first time I heard it
2023 James backed by 1991 Jaymz. I can dig this
I'm kinda getting some "Sad But True" and "The God That Failed" vibes from this! 🤘😝🤘
This was definitely my favorite song on the new album. And this version was so much better.
Oh my god when I saw this in my sub box I actually yelled OH SHIT! Love your reworks fucking tremendous my guy. The God that Failed PT2 lmao
🖤🤘
Newsted elaborated on the tone from black album and most fans think that "something was wrong" that date from the kill em all album. Actually all was very purposeful as metallica asked bob rock to make their album sound deeper rather than flat short distortion and bass that they were doing previously. That was due to the fact that grunge and bands like alice in chains, nirvana and other were gaining traction with deep bass and simple riffs, often with dropped one string
Great perspective man I agree
Keep em coming! These remakes with their classic albums tones are soo damn good!!!!
If this had the same voice that your crowned barbwire video did, it would top this off with a cherry. This kicks ass!
INAMORATA!!!!!!!!!!! I NEED IT
We need all the songs with Black album tone :). That "No leaf clover" by Bryce Barilla is perfection. What a tone.
No, it has ReLoad written all over it. It needs to be ReLoaded, not Blackened ;)
miseryyy she needs- INAMORATA IN A 80S/90S TONE
Love this, idk if it was intentional but on the vocals sometimes it sounds like you can hear Jason on the backing track
It would be cool to hear this version in D standard. The song reminds me a lot of Sad but true
I felt the exact same about it. Like a b side to SBT
I don't understand why they chose to do this song in E. It would have been so much cooler in D Standard
@@josephhunter3134 This song is absolutely brutal in E, why go lower? They do play in Eb live though, it rocked in Arlington this past weekend!
@@hiphopgrinch As much as i love metallica. I gotta say my Snakebyte Explorer sounds absolute best in D standard, my favorite tuning. Its just much more growl to it, but still has the tightness and versatiity to go high without it being for lack of better term "muddy/same'y". Sad but true, such awsome sound in the song. But good arguments can be made for the E standard too.
man i'm addicted to this what if song!!! nice work and happy new year!!
Absolutely love these. I’ve listened to your Sleepwalk remake at least 10 times now. This album is so good
They need Bob Rock back as just a producer and mixer. That is it. Keep his mouth shut about structure and writing. Just make it sound good.
Not so fast, we could get shorter sweeter songs
@@Snoopaloop1981 well their best songs tend to be 6 mins or more so I don’t know about that. Let Metallica be Metallica but make them sound good
Bob Rock did an awesome,e job with the Black Album but Load ReLoad and St. Anger sucked 72 Season's sounds like it should be with what I call the classic old school Metallica records
@@brianpatrickreddington1750 sonically Load and Reload are nearly flawless. The guitar tone was the only issue because of its bluesy nature. And being tuned a half step down.
@@cockynanderson I agree. The songs were different on Load/ReLoad, but they sounded the best with Bob Rock.
Mucha Gente piensa que James puede tocar como Kill 'em All o un And Justice for All, pero, 72 seasons es una propuesta "pesada" que deleita, claro que hay canciones que suenan como relleno, pero, justamente es estos arreglos que hacen que tengan una segunda vida.
This was my fav track of 72, now thus version May be my fav metallica song period
We need the album with classic tones, make it happen bro🤘
The legend returns…
Great version, This is of the best songs in the yellow album.
Agreed it's cool you called it the yellow album lol.
Love how the lyrics are about cancel culture. Great lyrics.
What a Riff and Sound
in my opinion the best channel on yt when it comes to this subject.
You need to make the full album,
Amazing work
😎👌❤️
The ONLY thing is needs is a much more punchy snare. The Black album snare felt like a gunshot going off, on this it's just a bit subdued. But otherwise this is fantastic.
Noted! Thank you for this feedback 🤘
It's pretty damn close man jesus...One on One studio is special and even they used every trick under the sun to get that room massive (ply wood and mics all over the fucking place), there is no recreating that perfectly. Honestly, this is probably the closest I have heard someone has come to recreating it, the drum sound is close, it needs what it cannot have to make it 100% and that's the room dynamics. \m/
This is one of the reasons why i love Black so much! 💪🤘🔥
Sounds are so brilliant!!! 🙏👍
How do you make James Hetfield have his classic attitude sounding vocals on the new songs?? I love when James sings aggressively like on the Black album and Black album tour live !!
Liked before watching, i know this is going to be insane
shows you how great the songwriting is still , just their production is whats lacking
Yes it's almost too perfect and very generic
@mind5403 yes like if the producer they are using was doing it for a different band it might work. Don't forget Bob Rock also produced St Anger
@@chromebull884remember they did st anger on purpose that way as a response to current trends while the band was falling apart simultaneously. bob rock would be a welcome change of pace now the producer they swiped from rick ruben has the most sterile dry uninteresting mixes i have ever heard. he also effectively neutered the metallica guitar tone. load had more distortion. bob rock could right that ship and squeeze another classic album out of those goofballs. the man makes masterful sounding albums. anyone tell me with a straight face that dr. feelgood and the black album arent two of the best sounding rock/metal albums ever.
@@bloodlinefilmsGreg Fidelman is the one who produced HTSD and 72 Seasons. He seems to be much more of a "yes-man" who doesn't give a shit about anything.
I guess, the tone is lacking, rather than production. Because the album sounds perfect.
Nailed it! Amazing
The one and only and best Met album forever!!!! 👊👍🤘😍🔥
Heyyyy , that’s what we were waitinggg!!!! Thanks bro..
Hell yeaaaaaaaaah🤘 pleaaaaaase do full 72 seasons album on black album tune…masterfully done! Thank you man
This is amazing well done
Amazing as usual
This sounds crushing, excellent
Black album bonus 🥰🤘🎸
BRO FUCK YEAH THIS IS SO GOOD
Thank you bro! Glad u like 🤘
@@zososound of course it’s amazing!!!! I’ll be keeping my eyes out for the instrumental version of you upload that!
Fantastic !! Thank you !! ❤❤❤❤✌️✌️
Damn now this is what I'm talking about Metallica can still kick ass but the tones make it sound so much better and heavier they should start watching these and take notes
I think I prefer the tones on the new album for these songs personally. It fits better.
@_PuppetMaster86 some of the new tones were good on that album buy hearing alot of the songs with tones from kill em all to black album era just makes it even better its like the perfect icing on a already awesome cake 🎂
Amazing work!!!
Keep up the good work, sounds awesome!
Damn bro, this is my favourite music and favourite remix. Just missing a little bass but still sounds amazing
Its cool but the sabbath part sounds of rhythmically now for some reason (at 4:05).
(I think the vocals during that section should be on the offbeat instead of the downbeat)
more like alice in chains
METALICA MÚSIC YOU MUST BURN!
Sounds sooo much better. Metallica shoots themselves in the foot with the guitar tones and instrument sounds they play with these days. I don't get it theyre albums could sound so much heavier.
they just dont want to lock themselves in their past glory days. but actually I think metallic in 2020s are in their second prime
@@user-yw5ct1px3x
I think James voice sounds the best it has in a long time but other than that I can’t say I agree with their choice to sound less heavy…. Kirk doesn’t play the solos properly… he doesn’t even play the full solo at times (blackened) I don’t see how that’s a second prime but to each his own.
They didn’t cut corners in the 80s and early 90s
metallica is a bad metallica tribute group. they are great players but they fail in sound and tone departmant imo
I see these comments about James' better voice every year lol. James lost his voice in 1993 and since then, he sounds like a coverband. However, I still love them.
@@mertdinc5459
Seriously ! It’s a lack of intensity. The anger and drive that was there in them to be the best, to put on the best show possible just isn’t there anymore.
I think that they think because they’re old now it’s ok for them to kinda dial it back and take it easy but people pay good money for their shows.
To me they should’ve never let up from that attitude that they had when they were younger. I would respect current Metallica so much more if they still managed to play and put on a show Iike they are hungry.
I miss James’ 1991 voice where he’d yell yeaaahYEAAAAH!!!!!!! With all that power and grit in his vocals it just added to the intensity.
Watching them play now they just look so casual and like they’re almost going through the motions in a way. When you take heavy metal and play it like a bunch of casuals it just defeats the purpose of metal in my opinion.
Metal should be loud, heavy, crunchy and intense as hell. It’s not meant to be laid back music played by guys who are acting like they’re out for a Sunday drive. That type of sound and casual play style
just isn’t meant for heavy metal in my opinion.
This is why as much of a fan as I am I have no desire to see them live. They’ve been playing lazy like this for way too long now and combined with the fact that they have so many high quality videos of their live performances I feel like I literally have no reason to see them live
This is so dope
If Metallica redid their last three albums in Justice tone with some Black Album, it would showcase how good those albums truly could be.
Damn. It should've been recorded like this 😎 🎸
The basssss
Impresionante
Nice Jobs man
Excelente amigo , es impresionante el trabajo que haces , saludo desde Argentina 🎉❤🔥
Sounds like harvester of sorrow at the beginning
You should do a collab with Merc. I bet you two could create something even more amazing.
Sleepwalk My Life Away was way closer to the Black sound, bthw You Must Burn! have some load vibe
this song has a harvester of sorrow type sound
You see the way Metallica has lost the ability to utilize the palm mute. It's hard to not just play these riffs this way straight from the beginning. In a way that makes Metallica still very original.
Dude you should replace the vocals with greenmiles AI!
Sad But You Must Burn. 🔥
Awesome
Excelente !! 🤘🏻
Best metallica everrrr and everrrrrrrrrrrr
Now it sounds like a Type o negative song
Very nice bass…
Full Album Plz 🔥🔥🤘🤘🎸🎤
You should produce for them.
Muy bueno
Holy frikin godzilla balls batman!! Send this to metallica immediately
🤘
Great
This song needs to be done with Load/Reload tone
People can talk shit all they want about the Black album, but im still waiting for their billion dollar album. 😂
the bass is so punchy at 3:51, it's almost too good
Can you tell us what AI did you use ? You really did a great job in the vocals👏
Harvester of Sorrow
Попахивает
Put it on 1.5 speed. You're Welcome.
Para ser sincero, me gusta más el tono actual … y es de las mejores rolas del álbum
Kinda feel like Load tuning/tone would work better on this song
When I first heard this song, it sounded straight outta the load period.
see the instrumental is great, but the tricky part with these covers is the ai vocals. i can never fully invest in the song cuz ai just isnt there when recreating voices
Add the oh wah ah ah ah part 😉
Definitely dig Rob’s tone more than Jason on this
Agreed, them bass slides are the wow-factor of the original version
How did you edit the vocals?
Hey man, how do you get the vocals?
Not D tuning ?
I think...Metallica should have kept the tones and production from The Black Album for Load, Reload, Death Magnetic, Hardwired and 72 Seasons...and shelved St.Anger.
Sounds good. But this should have sounded more like from Load or Reload, in my opinion
You're missing a ton of legato's and stops in the main riff. Also the drums are not even close to the Black Album "bob rock gunshot" snare. A for effort tho
I love most of these but this one is torture
you need some help getting some good isolated vocals?
and now we can see the weakness of this song...compared to sad but true for example.
Metallica "Bee Album"?
All this needs is to be tuned down to D standard
Okay. I'm hearing more ballod solo ing. Master is my styl.😂bobby brasy🎉
You've removed the wah wah pedal but Kirk used to play with it already at the time of the black album. It sounds wrong, sorry.
Yellow Album!
Wait
All u did was slow it down slightly lol
What do you mean
I don't really like this song cause of how James sings the chorus
this is incredible and im not even 10 secs in
Yasssss! What AI do you use for the vocals?
So-Vits-SVC, with a lot of post EQ, compression and layering/automation with the original vocals.