CAMBRIDGE SCIENTIST VS. MUSLIM | “IS THERE PROOF FOR GOD?” | GOD EXISTS: PROVE ME WRONG
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- Join #TheExistenceProject for a fascinating street debate between a Scientist from The University of Cambridge who challenges our friendly social experiment, “GOD EXISTS: PROVE ME WRONG.”
Don’t miss the amazing debate.
Subscribe for more thought-provoking content and share your views in the comments below!
Watch more from The Existence Project: • God Exists
Stay tuned for more engaging conversations!
Follow us on Social Media:
Twitter: x.com/ReviewRe...
Instagram: / reviewreligions
Facebook: / thereviewofreligions
Official Website: www.reviewofre...
![FNAF vs TF2 - Episode 2 [SFM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/z5b3V2-VLb0/mqdefault.jpg)
"It is not the eyes that are blind..."
But the hearts
“But the hearts.”
but the hearts!
But the heart
But the heart
I was struggling to see who the real scientist is here!
Irony!
Yeah 😅
Agreed the host came prepared!
Really great watch. I was expecting better arguments from the professor but they were quite easily contested!
LMFAO, no you were not. Prove your god is real! Now, I dont want your faith or your beliefs. Give me proof your god is real!
Yeah. That confused me, a Cambridge University Professor and that’s his argument, delusion?!
Wow! Desperation really does bring the most out of humans in good and equally bad ways….
0+0=1 😂😂😂@@Theonetruegod-hw2ei
Just goes to show that pretty much anyone can become a professor as long as they're from a privileged background and receive a top class education. It also shows that having knowledge does not necessarily mean having wisdom.
The amount of disrespect that the science professor showed at the beginning of this video disrespects all religions there are better ways of showing your beliefs
Yea 100% but I think it was just British humour lol.
Disrespect? No, religion is disrespect.
The professor made his point. 😂
Where was the disrespect?
He is an example of the mentality of western civilization.
The Professor think that He is dealing with someone that is uneducated and only say "you have to believe in God" and that's it. He tries to make the Muslim guy annoyed but it doesn't work, seeing the patience the Man gives and knowledge about science, The Professor later really appreciated it and respect the Man.. 😮💨
That scientist makes calculated decisions based on inference to the best explanation and probabilities every day but as soon as you mention God, they throw logic under the bus
A Catholic who doesn't believe in God and a scientist that doesn't believe in Science. This is who is teaching students?
😂😂😂
Less than two minutes in and wow, I’m watching a grown man act like a 12 year old.
Came to talk to a scientist, ended up talking to a grandpa with a “pull my finger” bit 😂
i got satisfaction from watching the scientist get put in his place after he started off in a demeaning manner
Why did I think that he was actually gonna pull out something from his pocket like 3 times? I was so confused for a second 😭
me too, 😂
Pulling nothing out of the pocket is the equivalent of saying "Allah says in the Quran"
loool 😂
and he's not using his little guy anymore, kept it inside his pocket and never uses it again 😂
Is this the level of a science professor in Britain? I'm really disappointed.
I really like how the channel represents a wide range of people, including both open-minded and closed-minded individuals. It’s important to see all sides of the spectrum!
I hadn't thought about it that way but that's so true!
Expectations lead to dissapointnents! The professor is a prime example. Our Imaam sahib on the other hand is so calm, well spoken, articulate & expressing his views with such clarity MashAllah! Well done ROR team ❤
_"we don't know enough"_
Yet the vast majority of humanity always believed in a Supreme Creator. What's more, our own conscience itself suggests, that deep inside us, we know we will be held accountable. In fact, if the Professor was to fall over that bridge and couldn't swim, and nobody was around to rescue him, he may even call out to God, but he would NEVER call out to his invisible pocket-sized fabrication.
Why do you assume that people who don't believe in God are simply in denial? That would be like thinking that people will believe in the tooth-fairy as soon as their teeth fall out.
@@seantaylor4095 They have given the example that when in danger even an atheist is likely to call upon the help of God out of fear. They're stating it's innate and deep within the human psyche to believe in a Creator. And yes historically far more people have believed in God due to a multitude of reasons. For example, many believers who establish consistent efforts to pray and connect with God experience their prayers being heard. This is ultimately the best method to test if God exists, which is the argument this particular speaker presents time and time again.
As for the example of a tooth fairy, it's not equivocal because the speaker is arguing that God is the cause of all causes and there is ample evidence to suggest that the order of the universe cannot just be coincidence. Not so much evidence for a tooth fairy as there is no logic there.
@@seantaylor4095 You obviously didn't grasp my point: In a do or die situation, we turn to instinct. Hence, our calling out to God in such desperate situations tells us, deep down, we know that we have a Creator.
This guy is phenomenally articulate and coherent.
U are one of my favorites currently. With no shortage of a great wide vocabulary, U are so eloquent, soft spoken, kind, and patient. Though u bring forward the microphone to ur opponent, it might be a good idea to consider dual microphones. So u don't go back n forth which can cause lack of concentration on the point u are trying to make.
My favorite RUclips series rn, Alhamdulillah
The guy on the right is the physical embodiment of the " Chill Pill" lol
Phenomenal, but the professor's insistence at the beginning is a bit annoying!
Nevertheless he represented his view well. However, it seems he had to go to such lengths to support his view! From denying God to denying gravity?
@@TariqMahmood-qs5wx ppl say Atheism is not a belief, yet some Atheists will even deny *gravity* if it means defending their Atheism!
Bro really denied gravity. He literally said "Semantics and nomenclature aside" then proceeds to debate semantics.
We still don't know how the space-time fabric is able to bend and transmit gravity almost instantaneously. Scientists are still working on the Higgs particle to understand how it creates mass when it interacts with the Higgs field.
4:34 is turning point. Mashallah Murabbi Sahib countered really well. The guy suddenly realized what had just happened
This older man is acting ridiculous. It's almost like he is refusing to take the man on the right seriously, and just assumes that anyone who believes in God must be intellectually challenged. He is not even entertaining the thought of God. That guy is "teaching science"? That's poor of mind.
God is not a theory. It is a belief without any evidence.
"It's almost like he is refusing to take the man on the right seriously"
- and why should he ?
The muhamadan thinks that donkeys can fly, trees can talk, rocks can talk just because an old book, which is full of errors, says so.
That's really strong. I expected lots of scientific reasoning from the professor, but he was clueless at times. Great work.
Science hasn't proven the creation of the universe any more than God has, so what scientific reasoning were you expecting?
Omg could not believe he's a professor....very disappointed with his knowledge and arguments
And loved the replies given to the professor 👍
May Allah bless you and may we see many more videos like these from you 😊
He walked away with his pockets empty...
That professor is not only a scientist, but a Science Extremist... I love this dialogue
Do you know his name?
I had high hopes for this one. "Cambridge Scietist" it said. I've seen college students arguing way more rationally than this "Science Professor".
He’s a sad excuse of a “professor”. I hope he conducts himself better in the academia world than he did here in this conversation. If he truly is like this as a person he should be reevaluated.
I love this, love the patience, love the rationality
This series is unlike most other debates I've seen online
The scientist is committed to the bit 😭😭😭
Says the person with an imaginary friend. 🤣😂🤣😂
I genuinely believe he was just pretending to be stupid, cause there is no way in hell did he really thought that was his “best” argument as if he was arguing with the guy to begin with….
@@AdhvaithSane I think the professor was trying to mock the concept of blind faith, but I don’t think he was expecting the host to explain that Islam actually doesn’t teach blind faith.
Atheists are comedians. This professor guys is delusional and full of contradictions, atleast he accepts that he doesn’t know
If you feel safe enough to leisurely ride a bike and talk to a stranger without a fear in the world while your son clearly is having in the water belies the chaos that he claims exists
The huberous science professor ended up being schooled on what science is. He started with so much arrogance, and ended up like a deflated balloon.
He eventually forgot about the god in his pocket 😂
so... that scientist get his morality from that pocket
Allegedly lol
Better then getting it from a useless book called Koran. Also Koran is a poor copy of the Jewish Bible and the New testament. It even gets basic stories from Bible wrong. Sounds like Mohammad stole the stories from the Syriac Christian texts so he got a lot of stuff wrong lmao. Also what's with Mouhammad's obsession with Jews lol? Looks like Jews saw through his fraud and refused to follow his cult which made him right all sorts of hateful stuff about Jews in Koran.
the Imam disarmed the Professor by sticking to evidence and rationality to the point where the professor himself expressed his appreciation for project! Probably not how the professor thought the conversation would end...Be kind folks.
Couldn’t agree more
A Professor btw : " the more we know the more we realise we don't know "
It is unironically an excellent quote though.
This is one of the only things he said that made sense to me lol, in other words with discovery you see that there is more to discover
He’s right. Only someone who doesn’t know thinks they know enough
Truly, "it is not the eyes that are blind..."
If the respected Professor, and others with similar orientations, were to open the eyes of their minds, they would easily see the truth and accept the existence of God.
Very good to hear positive feedback from the professor at the end, all and only because of good behaviour from the Muslim brother...insha'Allah hope he looks into islam some day.
Scientist: "My neighbour's garden has no gardener"
"Your neighbour's garden...??"
😅😅 😅😅 This professor was chill as compared to previous guests.
Really really good conversation. Your patience is commendable and in the end won the respect of the professor ❤. May Allah bless you always 🙏🏻
Truly, you can see the impact that the conversation had on the professor (especially at the end). We need more of these respectful, loving conversations.
Still finding it hard to figure out what the professor was driving at😅
I think he was trying to mock the concept of blind faith, but I don’t think he was expecting the host to explain that Islam actually doesn’t teach blind faith.
I listened to the professor patiently even though his worm bit was getting old and every time he was asked to give an ounce of logic for his own argument he couldn’t come up with anything. I’d say at the very least he could’ve tried to participate honestly in the conversation, the host wasn’t trying to convert him just probing thoughtful conversation.
such a great channel. may allah bless whos behind this great projet.
if it was me I would have told him to have a nice day at 2:40
his mind is so closed. he doesn't wanna talk or have a conversation
he just wants to act all high and above others
he made a good point already... it was time to move on or discuss it respectfully
but he was just so happy putting himself above while belittling an image he has in his own mind about how believers think
Commendable effort, keep spreading the truth. Regards with ❤
Your confabulations are striking and riveting; The usage of language makes it more worthwhile.
Notwithstanding, the cause of the cause of the cause of - argument doesn't hold water in the eyes of scientists. Faith can be corroborated/substantiated with logic, proof, and evidence, furthermore, could effortlessly be marred by a rational mind-as most prolific Islamic Scholars who hold PhDs in their fields. The reason, as I could compare notes, is that the versions of truth prevail over the sane minds.
I am a Muslim; I have self-studied a lot about this phenomenon.
Both sides are not sure if they know what the reality is. The convincing and satisfying power have diminishing returns as both aspects move forward.
May Allah guide us. Ameen.
I might be amiss; I am open to other notions.
Thank you for reading.
(If you (the host) read my comment, I would love to have an online discussion with you)
May I ask what "doesn't hold water" means, i cant really understand what you mean
Love your videos. Love to watch your videos and learn many things
Same, I learn so much from these videos. Alhamdulillah!
What you called chaos are the perfection of these lives cycle procedures.
this is sad that a professor of science is teaching our kids none sense. Who gave this guy the right to teach. WHy is he even teaching if he doesnt believe anything is 100% true? Gravity might not exist???? 🤦♂️
this professor wasn't on that level and wasn't able to elaborate intellectually. he follows that typical blind faith.
Mashallah murabbi sahib keep it up may Allah reward you
Ameen summa ameen
How disrespectful is this so-called educated scientist.
He tries soooo hard not to believe yet he knows how irrational he actually is at the end of this instead of the other way around! Just like with the Garden analogy... You can see his Fitra inside of him struggling and something in his brainwashed mind is trying to steer him away from it! SubhanAllah! If you turn your back on Allah, then Allah will turn away from you and if Allah turns away from you than nobody can help you! Alhamdulillah, Im Muslim!!! 🤲☝
You are brainwashed only when you hand on to faith.
What a non-sensical person? It’s amazing that Murrabi sahib has the patience for such absurdity. But no matter the person we should develop this kind of patience and focus more on the Quranic evidences and the examples of the Prophets.
First! Good to see you again!
You dont happen to have your own channel, podcast?
The Muslim Imam is from #TheExistenceProject. All of The Existence Project's street debates are posted here on The Review of Religions' channel, in the "God Exists" playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLYkV0xjDy94ZaTjFI_58eKgiO0ksxiPnv&feature=shared
There are some podcasts on this channel now too
MashaAllah great conversation and arguments, love it.
It was a good video! I feel like you took the mic away from him often though
I think we see that he had to kind of shift the conversation if they wanted to talk about anything meaningful really
The scientist regrets his garden analogy!
He does not reapond to anything. He is not listening, too clouded by thoughts. May Allah guide him.
The professor came off condescending & patronizing in the beginning (which was disappointing to say the least), but I think he soon realized, he COULD have a seriously intelligent discussion about the existence of God. Bravo. Even if in his heart, he realized that what he was doing was wrong. In the end however..... The turtle won the race.
It's worrisome to see that this is a professor? The level of ignorance and disrespect is absolutely appalling. We can agree to disagree but don't be outrageously disrespectful.
"The more We know the more don't know" yes I think it is mentioned in the Qur'an that Allah will only give us knowledge that He wills and that's it, not more not less.. so I have heard story that scientists that try to figure it all can become crazy.. because they can never will.. and it's not about knowing it all, it's about knowing enough, good evidence and believe..
In order to contest the existence of God, one must have read all scriptures. Otherwise, you operate from a point of arrogance assuming your level of intellect and understanding is superior to the scripture... At that point, you'd better ensure you thoroughly understand what you're reading...
It seems he's looking for physical proof, and our brother here keeps trying to show him that the physical proof is all around you. Not only that, but the functions were conveyed to us through an illiterate man, Hadrat Muhammad Mustafa Sallallahu Alaihis Wasalam, having received revelation in a cave over 1400 years ago. And that book fits in line with science today.
I hope he reads the Qur'an and opens his heart. It seems like you received the admiration and respect of the scientist by the end. Mashallah
the ending was good 😂 did not expect that
I’m totally shocked to hear that a Professor of Science see no order, purpose or function of the Unverse. He says and I quote " to me, this is Chaos".
May Allah guide these people who have knowledge and yet deny.
He was perfect. Our brains cannot comprehend the universe. We understand a miniscule part of it. It's like the earthworm's brain trying to define the garden.
Science is about how not why, so purpose doesn't come into it.
@@PramodKumar-gy8lb we may not understand everything about the universe, but we understand enough to know that it points toward a Creator.
I'm speechless. I wonder how someone like this will fare on the Day of Judgment
Full of regrets
Mental gymnastics from another atheist and another so called scientist.
It's astounding that he'd question whether gravity is real, all just to defend Atheism.
you spend decades of your life researching and obtaining a PhD only to be content with 'we don't really know the facts,' when its all right in front of you
Correct. We don't know about the origin of energy and space-time.
“One of the painful things about our time is that those who feel certainty are stupid, and those with any imagination and understanding are filled with doubt and indecision.” - Bertrand Russell.
How’s it I’m front of me? The Quaran is speaks of false claims. Do you really think Mohammad split the moon? There is no evidence for that, no other civilization recorded it, and it makes no logical sense.
Why did Allah have to send so many messengers who all claim they’d be the last? Your god is not omnipotent if he has to keep on sending multiple prophets.
Masha Allah intelligent brother. More like he was the professor. The Scientist was all over the shop with his wishy-washy "we just don't know" responses
Another great conversation 👍🏻
Alhamdulillah! Can't wait for the next one Insha'Allah!
To me, the concept of God covers chaos-logos- cosmos. I mean, he/she could be a chaotic being. We humans need regular, scheduled, disciplined concepts, because these provide us comfort and safety. But the God doesnt need any of them, and could be chaotic for sure
I'm a big fan brother ❤❤❤❤ may Allah bless you
Next episode NOW!!!!
Just because someone has a paper that proves his profession LEGALLY, it doesn't mean that this person is good example to be learning from.
Most professors and teachers are teaching enough for you to get the legal paper for your education and a lot of them are actually idiots.
proving the existance of God to an antheist is more difficult than proving that colours are exist to the born blind man.
....or explaining the concept of proof to an ardent theist.
Most people in western world are atheist, because of personal problems and experiences.
We all know the plan of the Elites is to devide people and confuse them on a such a level that no one would be sure what is true and what is wrong anymore.
They are prime example as victims of this propaganda that is being thrown into society for decades.
Many of them are atheists, because common sense does not agree with reality that the creator of the vast and great universe is a human and that this God died for us so God for them becomes like a fairy tale or a story of a legends that doesn't fit in modern society.
You'd be surprised how many atheists are joining Islam after learning about Islam.
So my point is, do not look at them from above, but try to help them to learn about the message of Islam.
Selamu Alaykum
point about gardener surprise professor 🎉
May Allah swt bless u brother
"There's only orderliness, according to YOUR definition of orderliness" 17:43
bro what are we doing here???
Here we go🍿🍿
The professor is always in searching because he has yet open his heart. He has to sit & reflect on something eventually ie "His Garden"
It's crazy how Murabbi Sb has patience to listen to everything and respond properly even people are absolutely wrong and don't back down. Absolutely love these videos
I m amazed a professor is speechless in front of ordinary man😂
the arguments from Islam are no ordinary arguments 🙌
its crazy that these ppl (like the so called scientist) think theyre provin smtg
quite the contrary. He is actually not proving anything and that was his point...You got it completely backwards.
It’s amazing to see how the Quran presents the answers to Atheists’ questions, regardless of the form of their argument.
Gotta love the Quran!
I have not seen a person like him 🤯
Somebody do skyfall activities and suddenly somebody in their basements contesting theory of gravity..... Ahhh they are floating now....
doubt is such destructive thing, this old man will question his own mind to oblivion. to everyone who read this, there exist people who try to put everyone else down, when they cant do it physically they do it mentally
not really, if the DNA test tells you that there's only 99% chance of your parents being your real biological ones
would you focus on the 1% doubt and discount the rest 99%?
I love this content
Is he really a scientist? I found him so illogical.
Ma"shAllah beautiful, may ALLAH swt bless you young man and may he give guidance to the professor, the Garden .
I think he would have been fired out by now by the University given the level of his 'non-existent' scientific credentials.😊
l love that professor...
especially his imaginable friend,...thus he really a professor ?
just asking.😅
On a positive note , I’ve never witnessed a professor of science question life and science so much . Its not a bad to thing to question life
You can't know what the universe really is unless you're looking at it from the outside. We're in the infant stages of knowledge of the universe.
I love this!
Same, it's my favorite series right now! I love what The Existence Project is out there doing, having friendly conversations about God's existence.
Couldn't answer a simple question professor just gobble gobble.
No matter how smart these professors can be their all the same and blindly follow their beliefs
After the school sees this video -
What he means to say is he taught science- past tense ,! Bye Jim collect your belongings and don’t show up to the Christmas party!!
The professor needs to stop interrupting and be patient. You're accomplished but you're still only a human being like everyone else - try etiquette.
😭😭 this scientist disproved science
The garden example that the prof gave just outsources the issue. " We just don't know". Same with people who say that life could have originated on another planet.