Extremely rare moment in the entire Star Wars where they acknowledge that the Empire have a conventional army and the Stormstroopers are just supposed to the special force
Even then, stormtroopers were given faulty equipment. I love how they make Han's blaster break to show that stormtroopers aren't terrible, they just have bad stuff
SoManySkinks Captain Rex is stupid then. Stormtroopers are the elite of the Imperial Army. The Imperial army does have regular troopers. Stormtroopers themselves are described as being very well trained and equipped.
You have to respect the Imperial Officer at 2:16. Charging first into battle and trying to inspire the troops instead of sitting behind the front lines. He even knew Solo, one of his lowly foot soldiers, by name. Definitely a lot different than most high ranking imperials.
@@lookatthepicture4107 And he didn't bark at Han, calling him a coward or saying he was going to shoot him himself if he didn't get up. He tried to encourage Han, to inspire him to bravery before pushing forwards with his troops.
Augusto Vasconcellos exactly, by the way... you’ve been drafted into the imperial guard 8th cadian, here’s some shitty flak armor we scavenged from another dead guardsmen and his lasgun, go make your self useful.
I love how in this scene it truly humanizes the Empire. The stormtroopers just seemed like expendable special units the empire threw at the rebels, but in this scene we get to see Imperial soldiers with masks off showing us their humanity as they screen in pain or mourn for their fallen comrades. This is honestly one of my favourite scenes in Star Wars
Yea they need to make a game based on regular imperial troopers in battlefront 3 and have the stormtroopers be special units and have battles just like mimban but also keep iconic battles like hoth and endor, however i would like to have endor to be more of a ambush/Vietnam type battle but just more of a real, gritty game overall
You got so many of these so called "elite" strom troopers like some glorified poster boy then we got the regular imperial army who gets tossed into a mud hole like this. More respect for the regular Joe this time around
In the original Star Wars, the Empire initially only needed to fulfill the role of a very simple fascist state pastiche. Over the course of the series, as the universe is fleshed out, far more complication is layered on. Especially thanks to the prequel trilogy. Essentially, in the wider SW setting the Empire can't really be what it is initially portrayed as in the classic trilogy. The Empire was pulled together out of a very large republic, containing thousands of worlds with hundreds of cultures and peoples. Basically, outside of the Imperial academies turning out officers and elite stormtroopers, the vast majority of people working with or for the Empire would have to represent a wide variety of viewpoints, ethics, and political beliefs - pulled from so many worlds. This is of course, a reason why a widespread rebellion is so logical. Too many different kinds of people to really control much, or even most, of the population with propaganda.
@@samalvey8168 No duh Cap'n, but we still want it to be badass. It's no fun fighting a pushover, and there's no glory in killing a daisy. The badassery of the Rebel Alliance is wholly dependent on how scary and effective the Empire is portrayed to be.
It would be cool to see a Star Wars movie that was actually just like this. No Jedis, no sith, just a straight up Saving Private Ryan type of Star Wars movie.
I'd like a Stormtrooper with one scene where the main character fights a Jedi alongside his unit only for his allies to be killed and him wounded. He would then witness an Inquisitor arrive and kill the Jedi.
That commisar officer at the beginning is really amazing, he actually knew every single trooper, he even called han by his name and not something that is expected like soldier, instead of calling them cowards, he inspired them and they actually believed even Han as well. Too bad he died early. May his soul rest in the God Emperor's name.
Yeah that tends to happen in the empire unless officers have a good chain of command the ones that are actually good at their job tend to get sent to the frontlines to die while the ones already politically connected get mor influential posistions.
What's great about this scene is the lore is built upon the Clone Wars. In a broadcast by the GAR radio droid, it mentions the mud jumpers of Mimban. They trained a militia to help fight off invading separatists that wanted the resources there. After order 66, the empire returns as conquorors, fighting for the resources against the same militants the clones helped train.
And all we got is capture this point and the next ..that's why I want dice to revamp all the maps ..no more shooting ion torpedo , capture certain objective to proceed to next phase ...it's just stupid ..only geonosis provide that battlefront feeling
@@notBrocker well I'm saying it from my personal opinion ..not hard feeling bruh if you don't feel it ..for lagging well to me it's rare to almost non existent ..depend on the day but I still stand that every map should be like geonosis ..no more shooting ion torpedo ..that style can suck dick ..and heck we need more space map and fucking server browser cos I don't want to be put into same damn map everytime
Not very much screen time of him but he seemed like someone who cared about his men, especially how he knows Han by name and face. Not just that he leads his troops into battle, while most imperials kind of just sit back and watch fights. Pretty cool dude, too bad he got fragmented.
As "eh" as this movie was, this is genuinely one of my favorite scenes in all of Star Wars. It really humanizes the empire and shows some firsthand carnage of war. I especially love the calm dialogue with no music, which then cuts to the Imperial March, explosions and gunfire.
2:26 One of the only instances I've ever seen of indirect fire in Star Wars. They usually don't show weapons like mortars and artillery, but look at that round that launches straight up and down onto the Imperial Major.
well the whole purpose of artillery is to be as far away from the front as possible while still maintaining effective range, that and when you can bombard enemies from orbit you don't really need artillery
Man, I really want a film/series with an stormtrooper or a pilot as the protagonist. And one who stays loyal to the empire (I'm looking at you, Battlefront II).
Finn _was_ a stormtrooper and Poe is a pilot. Han is a pilot. Luke is a pilot. Rey is a pilot. Chewy is a pilot. Anakin is a pilot. Obi Wan is a pilot...
@@nachoolo I know, I was just saying they got pretty darn close. I actually love the way TFA humanizes the Storm Troopers and makes them scary instead of bumbling idiots.
Yeah there's a theory out there that the Star wars movies are just propaganda videos for the rebels. So everything slanted to make the rebels look good. When in reality the empire is still a republic and the rebels are a terrorist organization.
Man this scene makes me want to watch a movie from the empires prespective rather than the standard rebels. one of the reason why many people liked the clone wars.because that was the closest we could get
I didn't like it because it was close to being the Empire, I liked those films because they put the 'War' in Star Wars (awesome expression I stole from someone else in these comments lol)
@@kungolaf4499 I got that he did know and was just playing along to potentially GTFO. He even goes to ask a final question only for Woody to shut him down as if "you want to live? Then shut it" is a subtle way of saying "say nothing and I don't kill you too".
@@ximbabwe0228 The only thing we're really missing, is that when they go over the top and out of their trench, someone needs to yell *"FOR THE EMPEROR!!!"*
@@benitoperez8884 ok. Cafeteria, Admin, and the hallway above shields are adjoined with vents. MedBay, electrical, and security are adjoined with vents. Weapons and shields are interconnected with vents. The Upper Engine and the Lower Engine are connected to the reaction with vents. There are a total of four vent connections available on Polus, which are: Electrical, Security, and O2 are connected through vents The North-West and North-East Corridors are connected through vents Laboratory is connected to Admin and the South Corridor through vents Storage, Communications, and the South Corridor are connected through vents. All the vents in Mira HQ are interconnected, which means that an imposter can perform much more efficiently while using vents and appearing almost anywhere they want to on the map.
If they did on focused on the tour of duty of a stormtrooper or even a imperial infantryman that would be cool plus make it rated R and it would be perfect.
@@spirz4557 Yes those were great but for live action they could do an updated First Battle of Geonosis, the Battle of Sarrish, the Battle of Boz Pity, Jabiim, Kamino, Coruscant, etc. So many opportunities.
@@hunter70558 that was what the republic called them. The empire called them swamp troopers Edit: Just found out the rebuplic mud troopers were called mud jumpers sry
Imagine In WW1. The Mimban tactics is to send the attack wave up and up. Similar to 100 years old tactic which almost everyone of them are swamp troopers and some from 224th armored division. They are like Strom troopers but just work on September dirty place
Time mostly, not time as in the over all length of the movie but because they had to get the movie done by a certain time. An you can see that some of the walkers, art wise, were not as well done as the parts that made it into the movie.
no, its because of pacing issues. they didnt want to make the same mistake Rogue One did on the first third of the movie! dont change locations too often this early in your movie!
There are so many possibilities for plots that could be extracted from the SW universe without even mentioning jedi or the force. Some would say, at least a bit of force presence is necessary for a story to be true Star Wars, but RO would've also worked without Darth Vader in action or the "I'm one with the force" thing. Imagine a small planet just rebelling against the empire or Coruscant underworld stories. I love the force and lightsabers but watching a simple being fighting in a world actually dominated by overpowering "higher beings" provides an attraction. It also would feed the circumstance that at least in GCW and afterwards the force and the jedi are just myths...
I’ve realised how many people focused on the creek and never cared for the other planets! “ooOoH sPaCe vIeTnaM” like dude, stfu, focus on the darn objectives instead of being a creek crawler
To be fair, when the player base was bigger , I didn't mind seeing a few failed orders here and there, just added to the narrative of having to win the next one. The Creek Divers is a cool established lore by the players, my friends and I would start with a game on the creek and end the night on the creek after doing the Orders @@Hugh_Mannn
@@CSTITAN576I wasn’t exactly getting pissed at you, I was getting pissed on the people who just focused on Malevelon because if the amount of content on it. . .
This scene & Rogue One are the closest we will ever get to my dream film of a gritty war drama like Saving Private Ryan, Band of Brothers or Dunkirk set in the Star Wars universe.
@@IuIianos because Rogue One was supposed to be a really gritty war movie and Disney re-shot it to be more lighthearted. While disney have the rights all Star Wars content will be tame
don't worry I expect there to be a retcon of the new sequel trilogy and a fan taking Star Wars as a director for a new set of movies and new younger cast to continue where we left off after the Battle of Endor with the storyline of the Expanded Universe comics.
This one scene literally puts the War in Star Wars, we really need a movie centred around an imperial squad. I also hate how Disney is handling the First Order. They are making them out to be a joke. The most likes I’ve ever gotten thanks y’all
They're actual Nazis and they don't bother going any deeper into it. It's the complete opposite of the open mindedness they preach. If they truly were open minded they'd have a large enough brain to give the First Order a solid backstory.
@@FullCircleStories they can't even do the Nazi thing right, there were greater metaphorical meanings behind the og trilogy but Disney ignores it all. Shoot they didn't even keep the all white, male driven cold military symbolism the empire was supposed to represent
@@robertogurrola7465 The og movies were not that deep.... The closest to really deep meanings are in the prequels, which people hated, until they needed an excuse to hate the newer movies. Why cant people just enjoy star wars? Also, the originals didnt treat storm troopers or the empire any better? If anything, they're weaker and dumber.
THIS IS WHAT WE NEED. A gritty Stormtrooper movie focusing on one Stormtrooper in his platoon. It shows them conquering different planets. AND NO DISNEY HE DOES NOT TURN TO THE REBELLION AT ALL HE IS LOYAL TO THE EMPIRE.
I love how this short scene is just so perfect. It shows the Army as a combined arms warfare machine which air assaults in armored fighting vehicles with support of infantry while close air support missions are being conducted. The one real officer we see before dying recognizes Solo despite the chaos of battle immediately and motivates him and his unit with positive reinforcement. Lore wise, Vader and more competent Imperials favored Generals over the Admirals, as the Army and General Staff didn’t enjoy the overwhelming funding and support of the Navy, which resulted in a pragmatic and efficient fighting force which favored effectiveness and competency above all else. Compared to the Navy which never struggled and grew complacent and heavily rigid, where Solo is instantly sacked for disobeying an order which would have gotten him killed, the Army awards outside the box thinking and the ability to take action without a crippling chain of command.
I love how this scene has a Warhammer 40K Imperial Guard feel to it. It has human wave tactics, Commissars , high casualties and everything! The Stormtroopers might be the scalpel of the Emperor while the Imperial Army is his hammer
Despite that it seems this movie had lower reviews than a lot of the newer star wars films, it's one of my favorite star wars movies in general. There's a lot here that's very underrated.
@@DarthAnimal If I understand, just like many worlds they were betrayed by the Republic/Empire. Countless worlds who had been fighting the Separatists alongside the clones found themselves being subjugated when the clone war ended. This happened on Kashyyk and Mon Calamari and many other systems. The Empire tried to do too much and was too tyrannical. This is why Palpatine wanted the Death Star. The Empire couldn't keep up with the non stop rebellions. The outer rim especially is basically impossible to hold. To quote Leia, "the more you tighten your grip the more systems slip through your fingers"
@@firingallcylinders2949 that's probably why Palpatine had the death star built twice. A weapon of that scale being used to control and mitigate rebellious systems. Tarkin said "fear will keep the local systems in line, fear of this battle station" the empire put all their eggs in one basket. Their arrogance That everyone would cower after alderaan was hilarious
It was actually awesome to see the empire struggle to take a planet as much as the Republic did. I like that not just cause it's a stablished military power, means they can take everything easily, even storm troopers would have struggled here.
@@firebottle8402 Why? from the onset there were planets that immediately refused to join the Empire and had to be subjugated. Yeah you could just bombard the planet from orbit with your fleet but then that's not going to win you any brownie points with the rest of the systems, if they think their only options are death or join, then many will rather risk choosing death cause of such an overbearing Empire, but if they think their options are join or a normal defeat followed by subjugation, not mass destruction...that's different, some will fight but part of the reason they are fighting is because they know "it can't get any worse than this once we lose", they are brave enough to fight because they think they have a chance and don't expect to be bombarded from orbit...and they won't be because it would make turning other systems to your side if they see you in a bad light and increase the chances that they join together against you. So you gotta play politics and appearances a bit as the Emperor. If you meant something else then sry.
@@firebottle8402 It does make sense though. If the planet has resources that have to be captured and the Empire can't just orbital bomb them into submission, then they are forced to undertake a ground-based campaign which (against an experienced military opposition like the Mimban locals) is going to be a slow and bloody slog no matter how you slice it. When you have to capture locations intact without wrecking them completely it's going to devolve into a firefight, where the defenders have the advantage of digging in and waiting for you to come at them. Even though it's likely the Empire will eventually win since they can pull in troops and resources from all over the galaxy, while the defenders only have their local resources and population, it's going to be an absolutely miserable time for the soldiers and leaders on the ground.
Well in Andor it is relieved that Mimban was a front they sent incurant recruits and prisoners to die. And they would often pit Imperial forces against each other without the troops knowing this beforehand.
@@jamesduffy7549 The mindless and completely ruthless droid armies lead by General Grievous invaded countless Mid Rim worlds and the Republic didn't have sufficient forces to defend them. Planetry defense forces fended off for themselves long and were supported by the Galactic Republic. After the war ended and The Galatic Republic became The Galactic Empire, much of these planetery forces were integrated in to the Imperial Army. That Major was most likely a part of those planetary forces who became extremely patriotic for the Empire for its efforts to include its citizens in its executive and military branches. The Empire and its military branch to those worlds were much more humane and closer to them that the distant corrupt Senate and the self-serving Jedi Council of the Old Republic ever were. There are heroes on both sides.
Wow, what idiot decided to cut this court martial scene from the film? It would've made the movie so much better, especially the flight school scene. I love the semi-comedy interaction with the Imperials.
@@cryptosporidium1375 what? The final cut has tons of violence regardless of this scene. Do you remember Kessel? Oh wait, you didn't watch the movie did you?
Cryptosporidium 137 anti violence? This was a very violent movie. They cut it for time and pacing. Rogue One changed locations way too often in its first half which was a problem. They’re trying not to do that too much in this one unless it’s necessary.
Given he apparently had gone after a head hunter that was likely a relic at the time or a piss poor pirate piece of junk its likely his fighter was well suited for the situation and did exactly as it was supposed to do for the pilot. Tie-Fighters at least the earlier models before the Tie-Interceptor were likely just glorified patrol ships with some decent anti-pirate capabilities. Later models like the Interceptor, The Defender, the Advanced, the Bomber, the Assault Gunboat (Screw anyone that thinks its not cannon) Were geared for all out war.
@@Quetzalcoatl_Feathered_Serpent The TIE fighter was very capable and designed for dogfighting and ship screening during the republic era, but it started to become outdated when we got to episode 4. Technology advanced very quickly and because of the vast military expansion, TIE fighters could not easily be replaced. It is a shame because the Empire had the best pilots.
@@MsAmber82 Haven't seen rebels. No. He developed the TIE Defender. Faster, it had shields and torpedoes. They were awesome fighter bombers. But unfortunately the rest of the Imperial Navy had no interest in them due to the idea that they would be costly to mass produce and they placed higher priority on the Death Star. Despite Thrawn's warnings that it's best not to allocate too many resources on one object. Putting your eggs in one basket so to speak. Though the TIE defender was picked up after the Empire's collapse by various warlords and Thrawn's own faction.
"oh this? This is a lunch break back on Armageddon". "Heh. In Catachan, this is what we do sleep-walking" "Emperors balls, that reminded me when I was a white shield back on Cadia... When there was a Cadia" "Pretty much what an Elysian dropper goes through. Except surrounded, and with even less support" *Heavy breathing in Krieg*
@@TheCajunTiger Sisters if battle actually are (for the most part) appreciative of the Imperial Guards and apart from being skilled and well equipped in power armour and all, they are also an huge motivational boost to IG troops when they are on the field. They are closer to how they are depicted in Baldermort’s video on them than how they are shown in Dawn of War
To some extent that’s how it is in real life. At least with advancing....the other option is everyone goes forward except left half, you stay and provide cover fire....then right get down and provide fire so left can go a bit more forward.. and it goes on like that until the objective is taken... or everybody goes at once.
Just seeing this makes me think Solo alone could've been a trilogy instead of the quick Han Solo checklist it was. Movie 1: Escaping Correlia, fighting on Mimban, meeting Chewy and leaving the Empire Movie 2: Han and Chewy have spend a year scouring the Galaxy for things to do and eventually join Beckett and his crew, overall plot is similair to Solo except the Kessel Run isn't a part of it. They make a deal with Crimson Dawn but the deal goes south Movie 3: Crew is at war with Crimson Dawn and destroys it at the end of the movie (Maul goes on the run --> Rebels)
@@groovyraffraff5300 my biggest complaint was just how it was way too much of a Han Solo checklist. The movie was still great but they shouldnt have shoehorned all "Han Solo things" into the movie
We need MORE of the Imperial army. They add so much to the empire. Just conscripts, regular people with less zealotry than the Stormtroopers. They show life under the empire from a POV we don't often see.
Probably because from a movie making standpoint it does little to advance the plot, and it does drag a little bit towards the middle/end, I certainly would have liked to have seen a bit more of this in the film but I don't think the whole thing.
@@misterrex684 Muzzle flash? Or intricate expanding muzzle brake to disperse non-luminous tibanthiam gas build up? The writers for the toy boxes will decide!
I say they should do a movie with the feel of this scene, and with a totally loyal Imperial lead. They can probably set it around the Empire’s early years when people were still on board with it, with our protagonist joining a squad of Stormtroopers to repress any acts of terror in this transition period. It would be a good look into the earliest days of the Empire, and...if they made the protagonist a Stormtrooper, it could totally bring a fresh new perspective of the idea that was introduced with Finn in the sequel trilogy.
Star Wars has always been about the great fight between good and evil, but it would be extremely fresh and nice to see the wars fron the perspective of the common people like this.
I think it would be great if they showed extremist rebel groups like Saw Guerrera's, commiting war crimes as to further convince the main character that they are right fighting for the Empire. In the early days of the Empire, there was no official Rebel Alliance, just different rebel groups, not all of them were good.
@asd asd if Disney wants to stick to “the Empire are just space Nazis” this could be a really powerful way of showing it without being too preachy. Show a citizen of the empire see a rise in terrorism around the galaxy (the Rebel empire forming) and they want to do their part to stop it. Goes from a simple patriotic peace keeper to actual concentration camps and genocides happening for “the greater good”. I’m not too familiar with the lore, but maybe the climax of the movie could be when the rebels help rescue the Wookiees and our Stormtrooper dies during the battle or gets captured.
“Beckette you said we were hear to pull a quick job!” “Yeah..” “Well this ain’t a quick job, it’s a WAAAR!!!” *Imperials slaughtering rebels and getting blown away in the background” One of my most favorite scenes in Star Wars
Doctor Tophat but they’re not rebelling.......they’re protecting their home. A rebellion is a movement against an established ruling. Rebels would be if the natives fought the natives and the empire took a side against the rebelling force.
I don’t think enough people realize that The Empire has an Army. This is their Army. Stormtroopers are basically Marines. They sort of kinda have an air force if you count airbases like the one on Aldhani.
I'm sure a lot of us would love to see a Star Wars movie from an Imperial perspective that shows both the benefits and flaws of both Imperial and Rebel ideology. Having extremists like Saw and his men mixed with the draconian doctrine of the Empire but understanding that life under the Empire can be a drastic improvement to life during the Republic. Maybe in the end the main character could die fighting for the Empire and protecting their family and loved ones or innocents in general from a rebel extremist attack, an attack so severe that it is what causes the Rebels to change their tactics to what we know of the modern Rebel Alliance.
So a Thrawn movie? I'd go for it. No really Thrawn was everything the Empire preached it was from his military command, treatment of his personal and prisoners, against the enemy in battle and what ever control he had of any planets under his influence.
i think everyone should appreciate this rare moment in star wars when the audience is shown that they’re still at war and war is no different on foreign planets than it is on Earth
I wish there was more units shown in Star Wars like this, as in the standard Imperial trooper, and the Stormtroopers being elite, not goofballs flying around like ragdolls. Then you would actually have an intimidating antagonist again, if the rebels are just “sooooo badass" ALL of the time then them destroying anything imperial doesn't feel earned or have any weight to it.
When this movie was released, it was the only scene in the Star Wars franchise that showed you the Empire in the midst of invading and subjugating a planet. I would love to see more of this in the future.
When I literally heard the officer shouting about the soldiers fighting for their Empire, the first thing that came to mind for me was that the Empire had hired Imperial Commissars lol.
The Empire would have won if it was unified. It fell because the imperial officers were more concerned about power than anything and fell to infighting.
Yeah lots of stars but not many actual wars. The closest you'll get to a solid ground war that isn't movie bullshit is the battle of hoth. Although it wasn't really a battle it was a defense against an onslaught
This entire scene is giving me some ww1 trench warfare vibs, the pain, the mud, the scorch land, the battle I would just love to see these types of battles, just the pure chaos of actuall ww1 and ww2 vibes makes it so real yet so reletable to our worlds warfare
Can we get a movie that follows the conventional army more? Not some made to be hero, or Jedi or what have you. Just a soldier and his squad, company, etc, getting through conflicts on various planets. It doesn't even have to be a movie, a TV show would do fine, especially if it were structured kinda like band of brothers, I think that'd be pretty cool.
I wish the movie had ended with Han fleeing as the Crimson Dawn is suddenly on the receiving end of an Imperial attack like this. If Han saw how the Imperial Army was made of men just like him, seeing it afar and faceless should have been what made him the man we knew in Episode IV. He would remember what it was like to be confused and terrified in all the dust and laserfire. So maybe when Han and Co. are making a break for it as the Crimson Dawn is distracted by the planet's sparse Imperial garrison...the sky flickers, and a Star Destroyer exits hyperspace. We get to see Vos' face go from irritated to shocked to nervous as he realizes that he bit off more than he could chew by killing that Imperial official at the start of the film, however minor the guy may have been. Imagine how Han would be if he got such an amazing example of how the Empire _always_ gets the last word. Dryden Vos has more power and influence than Han could ever think he would achieve, but imagine how that would inform seeing a _single_ Star Destroyer tear down everything Vos had ever built for going one step too far. And as Han watches the TIE fighters strafe Vos' men and landing crafts deploy Imperial soldiers, he'd also realize that his own experience wasn't special. He didn't have some uniquely-traumatizing experience that would undo the Empire if only more soldiers endured and survived it. We could even end with a shaken Han (and Chewie) in some distant bar, looking up to a broadcast of an inspiring Imperial news report about the defeat of the Vos-branch of the Crimson Dawn.
@@pale_lad1252 True, though it never hurts to have a scene where The Empire actually takes action against em the moment they step out of line. They typically let em exist but the moment they overestimate themselves, The Empire always exacts judgement right then and there with the will of remorseless agents and the might of a single star destroyer
Extremely rare moment in the entire Star Wars where they acknowledge that the Empire have a conventional army and the Stormstroopers are just supposed to the special force
Even then, stormtroopers were given faulty equipment. I love how they make Han's blaster break to show that stormtroopers aren't terrible, they just have bad stuff
Palpatine was Framed The Stormtroopers don’t have bad equipment. At all. They have are very well protected and equipped.
@@connormeng9773 Captain Rex would disagree. And he'd know. He's killed enough of them.
Imperial Army and Stormtroopers are basically US Army and Marine Corps/ Airborne... Or German Army and Waffen SS...
SoManySkinks Captain Rex is stupid then. Stormtroopers are the elite of the Imperial Army. The Imperial army does have regular troopers. Stormtroopers themselves are described as being very well trained and equipped.
You have to respect the Imperial Officer at 2:16. Charging first into battle and trying to inspire the troops instead of sitting behind the front lines. He even knew Solo, one of his lowly foot soldiers, by name. Definitely a lot different than most high ranking imperials.
Shame
He'd ironically be a soldier Vader might respect he hated the officers who hid like cowards. Afraid to get their hands dirty.
Nit only knew him
He recognized his face in the middle of battle and in the dark
That officer knew every single man under his command
@@lookatthepicture4107 And he didn't bark at Han, calling him a coward or saying he was going to shoot him himself if he didn't get up. He tried to encourage Han, to inspire him to bravery before pushing forwards with his troops.
@jasper loman
May he be welcomed in The God Emperor's table on Holy Terra
I love how this whole scene is basically a sci-fi WW1 Imperial German Army.
With various English accents
@@alexandrenunesdeoliveira9417 *coughs* there not actually imperials
So Warhammer 40k, then
Augusto Vasconcellos exactly, by the way... you’ve been drafted into the imperial guard 8th cadian, here’s some shitty flak armor we scavenged from another dead guardsmen and his lasgun, go make your self useful.
Basically you have the Death Korps of Krieg from Warhammer 40K here.
They really said: ”WW1 but it’s Star Wars!“, and I absolutely dig it. We need a show like this about the imperial army
Idiot moment fr@@GunsAndAmmo3
@@GunsAndAmmo3 Did you miss the part of the comment that says "but it's Star Wars!"
@@GunsAndAmmo3”ww1 *but star wars* “
@thatguy1132 l m a o
That last scene has gotta be an homage to Kubrick's "Paths of Glory" trench scene.
I love how in this scene it truly humanizes the Empire. The stormtroopers just seemed like expendable special units the empire threw at the rebels, but in this scene we get to see Imperial soldiers with masks off showing us their humanity as they screen in pain or mourn for their fallen comrades. This is honestly one of my favourite scenes in Star Wars
The German heer
Versus
the SS
Yea they need to make a game based on regular imperial troopers in battlefront 3 and have the stormtroopers be special units and have battles just like mimban but also keep iconic battles like hoth and endor, however i would like to have endor to be more of a ambush/Vietnam type battle but just more of a real, gritty game overall
You got so many of these so called "elite" strom troopers like some glorified poster boy then we got the regular imperial army who gets tossed into a mud hole like this. More respect for the regular Joe this time around
I agree.
In the original Star Wars, the Empire initially only needed to fulfill the role of a very simple fascist state pastiche. Over the course of the series, as the universe is fleshed out, far more complication is layered on. Especially thanks to the prequel trilogy. Essentially, in the wider SW setting the Empire can't really be what it is initially portrayed as in the classic trilogy. The Empire was pulled together out of a very large republic, containing thousands of worlds with hundreds of cultures and peoples.
Basically, outside of the Imperial academies turning out officers and elite stormtroopers, the vast majority of people working with or for the Empire would have to represent a wide variety of viewpoints, ethics, and political beliefs - pulled from so many worlds. This is of course, a reason why a widespread rebellion is so logical. Too many different kinds of people to really control much, or even most, of the population with propaganda.
“Your Empire needs you, TROOPERS FORWARD”
Best quote of the entire series. Waited years to hear something like that.
It needs you but it doesn't value you. That's not a regime worth serving, in my opinion.
@@samalvey8168 No duh Cap'n, but we still want it to be badass. It's no fun fighting a pushover, and there's no glory in killing a daisy.
The badassery of the Rebel Alliance is wholly dependent on how scary and effective the Empire is portrayed to be.
@@EgoEroTergum THIS
@@EgoEroTergum That viewpoint is too high IQ for most Star Wars fans. Most Star Wars fans are like 9 years old or just retarded normies.
@Luke Wilson yeah because people get executed in the US if they don't like it
It would be cool to see a Star Wars movie that was actually just like this. No Jedis, no sith, just a straight up Saving Private Ryan type of Star Wars movie.
Or Full Metal Jacket style in the pov of stormtroopers
Saving private Ryan sucks ass
It’s called Rogue One
@@erinv1232 *no sith
I'd like a Stormtrooper with one scene where the main character fights a Jedi alongside his unit only for his allies to be killed and him wounded. He would then witness an Inquisitor arrive and kill the Jedi.
That commisar officer at the beginning is really amazing, he actually knew every single trooper, he even called han by his name and not something that is expected like soldier, instead of calling them cowards, he inspired them and they actually believed even Han as well. Too bad he died early. May his soul rest in the God Emperor's name.
Bro I think you’re mixing things up with 40k
@@rebelfriend1818 I know, it's just very amazing.
Most scam like him just lead from the rear
@@rebelfriend1818 this scene is the closest we will get to a Death Korps of Krieg film in the next decade
Yeah that tends to happen in the empire unless officers have a good chain of command the ones that are actually good at their job tend to get sent to the frontlines to die while the ones already politically connected get mor influential posistions.
What's great about this scene is the lore is built upon the Clone Wars. In a broadcast by the GAR radio droid, it mentions the mud jumpers of Mimban. They trained a militia to help fight off invading separatists that wanted the resources there. After order 66, the empire returns as conquorors, fighting for the resources against the same militants the clones helped train.
Sounds VERY similliar to a certain conflict in the Middle East...
@@DrSabot-A I think that's the point.
@@DrSabot-A soviet-afghan to american-afghan wars
What episode?
@@mandalorian5553 I think they might say it at the beginning of the first episode with domino squad, on the rishi moon outpost
This is basically what we all thought star was battlefront was going to be like,
steak movies but in battlefronts there is only about 20 soldiers in each side
@TheOverlord818 Right
And all we got is capture this point and the next ..that's why I want dice to revamp all the maps ..no more shooting ion torpedo , capture certain objective to proceed to next phase ...it's just stupid ..only geonosis provide that battlefront feeling
conehead larry for me not even geonosis makes me get the battlefront vibe it lags everytime..
@@notBrocker well I'm saying it from my personal opinion ..not hard feeling bruh if you don't feel it ..for lagging well to me it's rare to almost non existent ..depend on the day but I still stand that every map should be like geonosis ..no more shooting ion torpedo ..that style can suck dick ..and heck we need more space map and fucking server browser cos I don't want to be put into same damn map everytime
Is it just me or does anyone else like the imperial officer at the start it’s like he cared I don’t know why
One of the few rare moments when it's acknowledged that most Imperials are just trying to live their lives and aren't blood-crazed fanatics.
Cause he was genuine?
Or isnt any asshole
Not very much screen time of him but he seemed like someone who cared about his men, especially how he knows Han by name and face. Not just that he leads his troops into battle, while most imperials kind of just sit back and watch fights. Pretty cool dude, too bad he got fragmented.
The best always get killed in combat with their men while the incompetent get promoted :/
As "eh" as this movie was, this is genuinely one of my favorite scenes in all of Star Wars. It really humanizes the empire and shows some firsthand carnage of war. I especially love the calm dialogue with no music, which then cuts to the Imperial March, explosions and gunfire.
Meh,it would be great a movie like this but from the rebels side
@@maccaroni3694 rebels are overrated
Honestly watching the delegated scenes it makes the movie a lot better. Idk why they cut the though….
@@maccaroni3694 we already have a movie like that, the original trilogy
@@maccaroni3694 no they're space terrorist and it's not like we have shows and movies about them already (Rebels, OT)
2:26 One of the only instances I've ever seen of indirect fire in Star Wars. They usually don't show weapons like mortars and artillery, but look at that round that launches straight up and down onto the Imperial Major.
We actually saw mortars and artillery in the Clone Wars show, but yea we havent seen one in live action
@@DrSabot-A there is one in mandalorian show
@@TheNord06 Didnt actually see it at the time of writing that comment, but yea there's a mortar in Mandalorian
well the whole purpose of artillery is to be as far away from the front as possible while still maintaining effective range, that and when you can bombard enemies from orbit you don't really need artillery
I’d say turbolasers are artillery
Man, I really want a film/series with an stormtrooper or a pilot as the protagonist.
And one who stays loyal to the empire (I'm looking at you, Battlefront II).
Finn _was_ a stormtrooper and Poe is a pilot. Han is a pilot. Luke is a pilot. Rey is a pilot. Chewy is a pilot. Anakin is a pilot. Obi Wan is a pilot...
@@Balthazar2242 Then a stormtrooper that *doesn't betray the Empire*
TIE Fighter (1994)
@@nachoolo I know, I was just saying they got pretty darn close. I actually love the way TFA humanizes the Storm Troopers and makes them scary instead of bumbling idiots.
Yeah there's a theory out there that the Star wars movies are just propaganda videos for the rebels. So everything slanted to make the rebels look good. When in reality the empire is still a republic and the rebels are a terrorist organization.
This is why I want Mimban is a playable map in Star Wars Battlefront 2. It would be so sick.
Omg people need to upvote this, I've never thought of this but holy crap would this be great
Trench warfare in star wars sends shivers to my spine
It be a great map
With imperial infantry skins. I love the stormtrooper skins, but I wanna see the imperial side.
Lmao right and i hope it’s too foggy for the snipers tho cause that would just turn into another crait
At the mean time, Obi Wan Kenobi is busying rescuing Leia in planet Daiyu.
Kind of puts into perspective the Han/Leia age gap
it was already obvious in the OT
This takes place in 13-11 BBY, kenobi takes place during 9 BBY
and Cal is um... restarting the Jedi order... with Merrin
Merin Trant?
Man this scene makes me want to watch a movie from the empires prespective rather than the standard rebels.
one of the reason why many people liked the clone wars.because that was the closest we could get
That's right
MenderSlen579 clones are way dopper than storm troopers. FOR THE REPUBLIC!
I didn't like it because it was close to being the Empire, I liked those films because they put the 'War' in Star Wars (awesome expression I stole from someone else in these comments lol)
Go play Tie Fighter. Whole classic Star Wars game from the Empire’s perspective.
Name one time. We have seen the rebel soldiers perspective. 80% of the movies is imperials talking.
"Captain? I'm Han."
"Nobody cares."
underrated line, a great reminder than han solo in the beginning of this movie has absolutely no reputation.
And he is an absolutely novice. He still doesn't get that the captain isn't the actual captain even though his armor has holes in his chest.
@@kungolaf4499 I got that he did know and was just playing along to potentially GTFO. He even goes to ask a final question only for Woody to shut him down as if "you want to live? Then shut it" is a subtle way of saying "say nothing and I don't kill you too".
Sadly, that line is more true than the writers intended.
The movie failed. No one cares to watch a movie about Han Solo.
@@AgentMorbid i loved the movie
@@oatmeal8673 me too
Han's imperial service and Rogue one are the best things to come out of the current Star Wars movie franchise.
Yes, you're right
LKVideos current*
rogue one is so bland though, people only like it because of scarif and the darth vader sequence.
I agree
If this was the movie I would have went to see it.
The recruiting officer making up "Solo" is 100% something that all military recruiters would do. Pull a name out of thin air and make it stick.
Any examples irl? Any cool names
@@comradekenobi6908 grog Johnson
@@solidsalt3412 any shorter ones
@@comradekenobi6908 harriet esposito sinclair
@@solidsalt3412 lol
I know its Star Wars, but this is probably the closest we'll get to a Warhammer 40'000 Imperial Guard movie
I have wished for warhammer40k movie for years. Atleast we got helsreach.
2:15 the way the AT ST drops down reminds me of 40k
@@ximbabwe0228 The only thing we're really missing, is that when they go over the top and out of their trench, someone needs to yell *"FOR THE EMPEROR!!!"*
Exactly what I thought.
@@nitram7410 and I'm a Tau player :'( don't kill my gunline screen... actually... do!
0:05 : Imperial Officer : "I'm about to Start this man's whole career."
@@Miq__06 Miquel Is sus
@@benitoperez8884 No it's not me!. I saw red vent!! Pls
@@Miq__06 Wait Did you Edit your comment recently or did you Play Among us 4 Months before it was Popular?
@@Miq__06 oh , so you are imposter?
*name every vent*
@@benitoperez8884 ok.
Cafeteria, Admin, and the hallway above shields are adjoined with vents.
MedBay, electrical, and security are adjoined with vents.
Weapons and shields are interconnected with vents.
The Upper Engine and the Lower Engine are connected to the reaction with vents.
There are a total of four vent connections available on Polus, which are:
Electrical, Security, and O2 are connected through vents
The North-West and North-East Corridors are connected through vents
Laboratory is connected to Admin and the South Corridor through vents
Storage, Communications, and the South Corridor are connected through vents.
All the vents in Mira HQ are interconnected, which means that an imposter can perform much more efficiently while using vents and appearing almost anywhere they want to on the map.
Imagine a clone wars live action movie with this type of action
Battle of Umbara. Landing at Point Rain.
If they did on focused on the tour of duty of a stormtrooper or even a imperial infantryman that would be cool plus make it rated R and it would be perfect.
@@spirz4557 Yes those were great but for live action they could do an updated First Battle of Geonosis, the Battle of Sarrish, the Battle of Boz Pity, Jabiim, Kamino, Coruscant, etc. So many opportunities.
Republic Commando: Gunship down
Bad batch right? Although I did hear about them possibly cancelling that
Props for that major, recognizing a foot soldier mid battle chaos by name, leading the charge himself and all the while encoraging his troops!
I'm so glad they decided to finally show Imperial Army troops, and not just naval troops and stormtroopers, even if they do call them swamp troopers.
AshTT mud trooper*
@@hunter70558 that was what the republic called them. The empire called them swamp troopers
Edit: Just found out the rebuplic mud troopers were called mud jumpers sry
@@hunter70558 swamp troopers you mean?
Imagine In WW1. The Mimban tactics is to send the attack wave up and up. Similar to 100 years old tactic which almost everyone of them are swamp troopers and some from 224th armored division. They are like Strom troopers but just work on September dirty place
@@Sillytommysadventure It’s Mud Trooper and Mimban Trooper
I like how Beckett isn't a real trooper but he is actually a good captain 😂
*_IRONIC_*
2:38 Huh didn't know that Spongebob character was an Imperial soldier
Fred
Gahahaha lol
*”MY LEG”*
Huh. I could have swore he said forward, as in to tell the troopers to keep advancing.
HIS LEG
"Troopers forward your Empire needs you!" Brings back 40k Warhammer memories.
“GLORY FOR THE FIRST MAN TO DIE , CHARGE”
Almost like its based on ww1 tactics...
The price of peace and stability is cannon fodder.
When you're a new player in star wars battlefront and meet veteran players
*A classic*
This is sooo fucking true
"ez GG"
I got my ass whooped as Vader in Heroes Vs Villians and got absolutely flamed
@@Miq__06 How do you get the rights I need help because I can’t use any stuff for my videos from Solo I’ll just say copyright
Why the hell did they cut the flight school part?
Jeez
Time mostly, not time as in the over all length of the movie but because they had to get the movie done by a certain time. An you can see that some of the walkers, art wise, were not as well done as the parts that made it into the movie.
no, its because of pacing issues. they didnt want to make the same mistake Rogue One did on the first third of the movie! dont change locations too often this early in your movie!
Was unnecessary. Showed how little the empire truly cared about what people request to be assigned to. Also was funnier.
Too much like Top Gun.
@@mrpancake8888 Right, in the original I took it as recruiters telling people they can be whatever but in reality you go to the infantry.
I'm kinda tired of all the jedi things, I just want a true War movie set in the Star Wars Universe .
Rogue one was dope.
Rogue one
There are so many possibilities for plots that could be extracted from the SW universe without even mentioning jedi or the force.
Some would say, at least a bit of force presence is necessary for a story to be true Star Wars, but RO would've also worked without Darth Vader in action or the "I'm one with the force" thing. Imagine a small planet just rebelling against the empire or Coruscant underworld stories. I love the force and lightsabers but watching a simple being fighting in a world actually dominated by overpowering "higher beings" provides an attraction.
It also would feed the circumstance that at least in GCW and afterwards the force and the jedi are just myths...
notobiwan holy shit finally someone who realises the potential for the coruscant underworld
wetzin alvarado Rogue One sucks
2:05 calmest day at malevelon creek:
I’ve realised how many people focused on the creek and never cared for the other planets!
“ooOoH sPaCe vIeTnaM” like dude, stfu, focus on the darn objectives instead of being a creek crawler
@@Hugh_Mannn bruh damn, I was just hopping on the meme. I wasn't a creek crawler. I actually agree with you but there's no reason to be that upset.
To be fair, when the player base was bigger , I didn't mind seeing a few failed orders here and there, just added to the narrative of having to win the next one. The Creek Divers is a cool established lore by the players, my friends and I would start with a game on the creek and end the night on the creek after doing the Orders @@Hugh_Mannn
@@CSTITAN576I wasn’t exactly getting pissed at you, I was getting pissed on the people who just focused on Malevelon because if the amount of content on it. . .
@@Hugh_Mannn people when other people play how they want to: no you cant do that you bought this game so you could listen to meeeeee😭
This scene & Rogue One are the closest we will ever get to my dream film of a gritty war drama like Saving Private Ryan, Band of Brothers or Dunkirk set in the Star Wars universe.
Well there is the battle scene in Attack of the Clones
How do you know? They could make a whole movie like that.
@@IuIianos because Rogue One was supposed to be a really gritty war movie and Disney re-shot it to be more lighthearted. While disney have the rights all Star Wars content will be tame
don't worry I expect there to be a retcon of the new sequel trilogy and a fan taking Star Wars as a director for a new set of movies and new younger cast to continue where we left off after the Battle of Endor with the storyline of the Expanded Universe comics.
@@DirtyDozen6612 please elaborate on this.
This one scene literally puts the War in Star Wars, we really need a movie centred around an imperial squad. I also hate how Disney is handling the First Order. They are making them out to be a joke.
The most likes I’ve ever gotten thanks y’all
They're actual Nazis and they don't bother going any deeper into it. It's the complete opposite of the open mindedness they preach. If they truly were open minded they'd have a large enough brain to give the First Order a solid backstory.
the new movies all suck, they just happen to have decent scenes like this
Disney made star wars a joke
@@FullCircleStories they can't even do the Nazi thing right, there were greater metaphorical meanings behind the og trilogy but Disney ignores it all. Shoot they didn't even keep the all white, male driven cold military symbolism the empire was supposed to represent
@@robertogurrola7465 The og movies were not that deep.... The closest to really deep meanings are in the prequels, which people hated, until they needed an excuse to hate the newer movies. Why cant people just enjoy star wars? Also, the originals didnt treat storm troopers or the empire any better? If anything, they're weaker and dumber.
THIS IS WHAT WE NEED. A gritty Stormtrooper movie focusing on one Stormtrooper in his platoon. It shows them conquering different planets. AND NO DISNEY HE DOES NOT TURN TO THE REBELLION AT ALL HE IS LOYAL TO THE EMPIRE.
I'm still salty about Battlefront 2 because of that.
Matt .Colwill Believe me man I am too.
Can’t because Twitter says the Empire is space nazis and Disney won’t make a movie about literal space nazis
Twib but they are space nazis, that’s what they were based on
@@Colgate_supreme they have been massively fleshed out since 1977
Just look at the story of Thane Kyrell and Ciena Ree
I love how this short scene is just so perfect.
It shows the Army as a combined arms warfare machine which air assaults in armored fighting vehicles with support of infantry while close air support missions are being conducted. The one real officer we see before dying recognizes Solo despite the chaos of battle immediately and motivates him and his unit with positive reinforcement.
Lore wise, Vader and more competent Imperials favored Generals over the Admirals, as the Army and General Staff didn’t enjoy the overwhelming funding and support of the Navy, which resulted in a pragmatic and efficient fighting force which favored effectiveness and competency above all else. Compared to the Navy which never struggled and grew complacent and heavily rigid, where Solo is instantly sacked for disobeying an order which would have gotten him killed, the Army awards outside the box thinking and the ability to take action without a crippling chain of command.
I was expecting the guy who yelled: "Your empire needs you!"
to yell "Fear ensures loyalty" before shooting one of the troopers.
DID I GIVE YOU PERMISSION TO DIE!?
"Fear me but follow!"
@@LAV-III GLORY TO THE FIRST MAN TO DIE!
I WILL HAVE SOMEONES HEAD FOR THIS
If you will not serve in combat, then you will serve on the firing line!
Solo: I do not have a name
Empire: I'm about to create for this man a career.
XD
Isnt solo alone in spanish, so Solo got his name from a spanish word meaning there are spanish people in star wars? Meaning English is up my butt
@@John-kk8gi Solo's also a word in Italian I think. It's shared by multiple languages.
@@theevildrummingsithlord1492 "Solo" means "alone" in Spanish.
@@condedooku9750 True.
I love how this scene has a Warhammer 40K Imperial Guard feel to it. It has human wave tactics, Commissars , high casualties and everything!
The Stormtroopers might be the scalpel of the Emperor while the Imperial Army is his hammer
Someone hasnt heard of WW1
Despite that it seems this movie had lower reviews than a lot of the newer star wars films, it's one of my favorite star wars movies in general. There's a lot here that's very underrated.
Ironically, the best infantry leader the Empire ever got was a crook bluffing his way through.
Nah, it was the major guy he was more a hero then Solo would ever be "VICTORY IS ASSURED"
Probably because the crook cared about these men. The other was just doing a forward assault.
@@exodustimes4266 The Major too seemed to be a great leader, knowing his troops by name and motivating them in battle. Shame he died.
This should honestly be a map in Battlefront II. Along with Umbara.
yea right like a big open field with small trenches, dark lighting and foggy weather makes foor a good map
that would b awesome. and for Umbara they should have the dangerous plants and animals as hazards to worry about besides the other team
@@jeremybk54 Minban would've been cool for the Solo dlc. I wonder why it wasn't included.
@@cqb3814 EA probably realized people would enjoy the game if it was added in
@@jeremybk54 eA bAd
"This next one goes out to the Mud-Jumpers of the 224th, slugging it out on Mimban.
Is that quote from the holonet from the Clone Wars episode "Rookies"?
@@samremfry3186 Yep! Also if you play Empire at Wars Republic mod they have that radio broadcast as the intro.
I like the implication that the battle of Mimban just never ended
@@DarthAnimal If I understand, just like many worlds they were betrayed by the Republic/Empire. Countless worlds who had been fighting the Separatists alongside the clones found themselves being subjugated when the clone war ended. This happened on Kashyyk and Mon Calamari and many other systems. The Empire tried to do too much and was too tyrannical. This is why Palpatine wanted the Death Star. The Empire couldn't keep up with the non stop rebellions. The outer rim especially is basically impossible to hold. To quote Leia, "the more you tighten your grip the more systems slip through your fingers"
@@firingallcylinders2949 that's probably why Palpatine had the death star built twice. A weapon of that scale being used to control and mitigate rebellious systems. Tarkin said "fear will keep the local systems in line, fear of this battle station" the empire put all their eggs in one basket. Their arrogance That everyone would cower after alderaan was hilarious
It was actually awesome to see the empire struggle to take a planet as much as the Republic did.
I like that not just cause it's a stablished military power, means they can take everything easily, even storm troopers would have struggled here.
It doesn't make sense
@@firebottle8402 Why? from the onset there were planets that immediately refused to join the Empire and had to be subjugated. Yeah you could just bombard the planet from orbit with your fleet but then that's not going to win you any brownie points with the rest of the systems, if they think their only options are death or join, then many will rather risk choosing death cause of such an overbearing Empire, but if they think their options are join or a normal defeat followed by subjugation, not mass destruction...that's different, some will fight but part of the reason they are fighting is because they know "it can't get any worse than this once we lose", they are brave enough to fight because they think they have a chance and don't expect to be bombarded from orbit...and they won't be because it would make turning other systems to your side if they see you in a bad light and increase the chances that they join together against you. So you gotta play politics and appearances a bit as the Emperor.
If you meant something else then sry.
@@firebottle8402 It does make sense though. If the planet has resources that have to be captured and the Empire can't just orbital bomb them into submission, then they are forced to undertake a ground-based campaign which (against an experienced military opposition like the Mimban locals) is going to be a slow and bloody slog no matter how you slice it. When you have to capture locations intact without wrecking them completely it's going to devolve into a firefight, where the defenders have the advantage of digging in and waiting for you to come at them. Even though it's likely the Empire will eventually win since they can pull in troops and resources from all over the galaxy, while the defenders only have their local resources and population, it's going to be an absolutely miserable time for the soldiers and leaders on the ground.
Did you really type a stablished instead of established lol
Well in Andor it is relieved that Mimban was a front they sent incurant recruits and prisoners to die. And they would often pit Imperial forces against each other without the troops knowing this beforehand.
"I don't have people, I'm alone."
"Han...Skywalker."
"Wait what the fuck."
Well he married Leia so he actualy is a Skywalker lmao
@@harolchi18 what about rey?
@@Demicleas she has BB 8 (wich is still poe's droid)
@@Demicleas RREEEEEEEEEEYYYYYYYYYYHHHHH
@@Demicleas who? That doesnt exist
3:01 I love that line "well this aint a quick job its a war!"
Apparently Putin didnt get the memo...
Russians realising that this won't be a three day operation
@@Spudtron98😂
@@Spudtron98shut up
@@Spudtron98 This was the first thing I thought, too.
2:17
I hope I’m not the only one who just LOVES the Major’s patriotism.
“Your Empire needs you!”
yeah but its to facists so fuck him
@Palmer Hicks fuck them still
@@jamesduffy7549 The mindless and completely ruthless droid armies lead by General Grievous invaded countless Mid Rim worlds and the Republic didn't have sufficient forces to defend them. Planetry defense forces fended off for themselves long and were supported by the Galactic Republic.
After the war ended and The Galatic Republic became The Galactic Empire, much of these planetery forces were integrated in to the Imperial Army. That Major was most likely a part of those planetary forces who became extremely patriotic for the Empire for its efforts to include its citizens in its executive and military branches. The Empire and its military branch to those worlds were much more humane and closer to them that the distant corrupt Senate and the self-serving Jedi Council of the Old Republic ever were.
There are heroes on both sides.
He seemed to be exploding with enthusiasm, especially at 2:26
Omar Ramirez FORWARD FOR THE EMPIRE!
This still pretty much takes the cake as the grittiest combat sequence in all of Star Wars. Definitely inspired by WWI trench warfare
Wow, what idiot decided to cut this court martial scene from the film? It would've made the movie so much better, especially the flight school scene. I love the semi-comedy interaction with the Imperials.
matt mack mack anti violence Disney...
tbh I prefer the pacing of the cut we got, but i'm glad we got to see the spectacle of it in a deleted scene
I knew something was missing from the movie. They should have kept this scene, the movie just feels all over the place without scenes like this.
@@cryptosporidium1375 what? The final cut has tons of violence regardless of this scene. Do you remember Kessel? Oh wait, you didn't watch the movie did you?
Cryptosporidium 137 anti violence? This was a very violent movie. They cut it for time and pacing. Rogue One changed locations way too often in its first half which was a problem. They’re trying not to do that too much in this one unless it’s necessary.
“Mom can I fly?”
“We have flying at home”
Flying at home: 2:05
HAHHAHAHHA FUNNY
They fly now?
They fly now
*Mom yeets child*
"Now that's Pod Racing!"
(Actually it isn't)
Cadet solo took the last tie fighter that doesnt explode immediately when it touches something
Given he apparently had gone after a head hunter that was likely a relic at the time or a piss poor pirate piece of junk its likely his fighter was well suited for the situation and did exactly as it was supposed to do for the pilot. Tie-Fighters at least the earlier models before the Tie-Interceptor were likely just glorified patrol ships with some decent anti-pirate capabilities. Later models like the Interceptor, The Defender, the Advanced, the Bomber, the Assault Gunboat (Screw anyone that thinks its not cannon) Were geared for all out war.
@@Quetzalcoatl_Feathered_Serpent The TIE fighter was very capable and designed for dogfighting and ship screening during the republic era, but it started to become outdated when we got to episode 4.
Technology advanced very quickly and because of the vast military expansion, TIE fighters could not easily be replaced. It is a shame because the Empire had the best pilots.
90% of the TIE fighters got no shield compared to other Starfighters
Capable for Dogfighting sure but one slip and it will get wrecked
@@bakersmileyface But it seems like Thrawn tried to develop better ships, but we all seem Rebels :c
@@MsAmber82 Haven't seen rebels. No.
He developed the TIE Defender. Faster, it had shields and torpedoes. They were awesome fighter bombers. But unfortunately the rest of the Imperial Navy had no interest in them due to the idea that they would be costly to mass produce and they placed higher priority on the Death Star. Despite Thrawn's warnings that it's best not to allocate too many resources on one object. Putting your eggs in one basket so to speak.
Though the TIE defender was picked up after the Empire's collapse by various warlords and Thrawn's own faction.
2:05 this entire scene is just your first time going to Malevelon creek in Helldivers 2
3:18 you can actually see the leg of the guy that was screaming' " my leg!" It is by Solo
Sh*t
No it isn’t
@@howardthealien2606 it is right next to solo's feet look closely
@@liamostheimer I read it wrong I thought you said that Solo was the one screaming
@@howardthealien2606 oh alright
director: how should the battle look like?
guy who got A+ in history: i think i have an idea!
battle: literally star wars battle of the somme...
Guy who has an A+ in histpry and an Warhammer Imperial guard Army at home
@Hans C.P.N I mean this is basically as close to a live action ig movie as we'll ever get.
@@jamesliu8095 Only thing missing is the Imperial Guard theme from DoW.
With terrible lighting.
@@Сайтамен Well, it was basically this.
"We'll have you flying in no time"
(gets sent to the Warhammer 40k universe)
*Guardsmen watching this video*
"Wow, these guys have it easy!"
"oh this? This is a lunch break back on Armageddon".
"Heh. In Catachan, this is what we do sleep-walking"
"Emperors balls, that reminded me when I was a white shield back on Cadia... When there was a Cadia"
"Pretty much what an Elysian dropper goes through. Except surrounded, and with even less support"
*Heavy breathing in Krieg*
@@utubrGaming while the sisters of battle giggle at these "manly" imperial soldiers
@@TheCajunTiger
Sisters if battle actually are (for the most part) appreciative of the Imperial Guards and apart from being skilled and well equipped in power armour and all, they are also an huge motivational boost to IG troops when they are on the field.
They are closer to how they are depicted in Baldermort’s video on them than how they are shown in Dawn of War
@@KalashVodka175 certainly, and I agree. I was mainly pointing out that the sisters of battle are more bad ass than these imperials in the video
Is this Malevelon creek?
I've noticed that every battlefield plan in fiction boils down to "You'll go left, I'll go right"
Just keep saying it and it scales up to the entire army.
@@Swarm509 Not necessarily
To some extent that’s how it is in real life. At least with advancing....the other option is everyone goes forward except left half, you stay and provide cover fire....then right get down and provide fire so left can go a bit more forward.. and it goes on like that until the objective is taken... or everybody goes at once.
"Take it easy, I'm on your side! Get it? *Your* *Side?* HAH?!
@Noobfromafar Anibal invented that to fight the romans.
Just seeing this makes me think Solo alone could've been a trilogy instead of the quick Han Solo checklist it was.
Movie 1: Escaping Correlia, fighting on Mimban, meeting Chewy and leaving the Empire
Movie 2: Han and Chewy have spend a year scouring the Galaxy for things to do and eventually join Beckett and his crew, overall plot is similair to Solo except the Kessel Run isn't a part of it. They make a deal with Crimson Dawn but the deal goes south
Movie 3: Crew is at war with Crimson Dawn and destroys it at the end of the movie (Maul goes on the run --> Rebels)
Wow, that was thought out really well lol
Nice idea
It shouldn’t have been a “Han Solo” film. It should have been a standalone film based in the Star Wars universe.
@@groovyraffraff5300 my biggest complaint was just how it was way too much of a Han Solo checklist. The movie was still great but they shouldnt have shoehorned all "Han Solo things" into the movie
Sounds like they should have just adopted the old Han Solo trilogy then.
Please star wars, all I want is Band of Brothers Imperial Edition! We're not bad guys!
Same here.
*the empire did nothing wrong*
There's a game called "Empire at War", that's basically what you were asking for.
Band of Brothers? I want some Tanith or Ciphas Cain style shit.
@@kabob0077 ah yes, Saint Cain
We need MORE of the Imperial army. They add so much to the empire. Just conscripts, regular people with less zealotry than the Stormtroopers. They show life under the empire from a POV we don't often see.
"Your Empire needs you! Troopers forward!"
Yes, commissar! FOR THE EMPEROR!!!
so badass
the emperor protects
badass - 🤓
*ALL HAIL EMPEROR THE SENATE!*
For the Empire
Ignore some references and it could be just another glorious day in the Astra Militarum. Also, the deleted scenes were probable cut for pacing issues.
Just another day in the Guard... Shame the Commissiar got hit though, probably be a while before we get another one like that.
WTF? Why delete this scene???
It adds so much to both Solo's character here and to the Empire's lore.
Blame the executive producers
Probably because from a movie making standpoint it does little to advance the plot, and it does drag a little bit towards the middle/end, I certainly would have liked to have seen a bit more of this in the film but I don't think the whole thing.
The battle scene is still in the movie? I just rewatched it today.
@@dexter-_-8863 I think they mean some of the extended parts.
@@dexter-_-8863 the battle scene is in the movie but the scene before it where he crashes the tie fighter and gets reassigned is deleted
2:05 POV you just dropped in Malevelon Creek
Actually, my squad of commandos dropped in behind enemy lines unnoticed and proceeded to destroy the droids' supply chain.
HEART
STEEL
WE
KILL
STEEL
HEART
ON TO WAR
@@Снайпер_Хренов report to the nearest democracy officer
OFF pfp, Helldivers II comment, what a combo
@@Ironwolf-pm7zs I enjoy based games only
"I promise, I won't get all political just because I've had a drink"
*2 pints later*: 2:16
XD
Lmao
Thats me when I get into SWtOR again
4:28 Flak 37. Still in service.
Good ol' 37
lol at the muzzle flash
@@misterrex684 Muzzle flash? Or intricate expanding muzzle brake to disperse non-luminous tibanthiam gas build up? The writers for the toy boxes will decide!
Yep, that’s literally what it is. They stuck one on an AT-ST’s legs.
If It's not broke don't fix it
Damn it sucks to be a loyal imperial. Just being an innocent dude only to be painted as the bad guys.
That's DA REAL 🌎
Blame Palpatine and guys like Tarkin.
Andrew Brigmond :(
@@andrewbrigmond8784 hard to stay mad at a man as classy as Tarkin
@@andrewbrigmond8784 eyy for all of tarkins bad deads he reduced the unemployment to 0 on alderan
Average day fighting for Managed Democracy
MY LIFE FOR SUPER EARTH🫡
@@pelopidas4283AH HAHAHAHAHAHAAA
SWEET LIBERTY MY LEG!
HAVE A CUP OF LIBER-TEA!!!
It isnt a war unless someone is screaming "MY LEG!"
Just like Fred the Fish.
Rev up those fighters 'cause I am sure ready for one- Help! HELP!
(gets thrown into the front line)
*MY LEG!*
It a epic if they shout “my balls where a re my balls!?
I say they should do a movie with the feel of this scene, and with a totally loyal Imperial lead. They can probably set it around the Empire’s early years when people were still on board with it, with our protagonist joining a squad of Stormtroopers to repress any acts of terror in this transition period.
It would be a good look into the earliest days of the Empire, and...if they made the protagonist a Stormtrooper, it could totally bring a fresh new perspective of the idea that was introduced with Finn in the sequel trilogy.
Star Wars has always been about the great fight between good and evil, but it would be extremely fresh and nice to see the wars fron the perspective of the common people like this.
I think it would be great if they showed extremist rebel groups like Saw Guerrera's, commiting war crimes as to further convince the main character that they are right fighting for the Empire. In the early days of the Empire, there was no official Rebel Alliance, just different rebel groups, not all of them were good.
@asd asd if Disney wants to stick to “the Empire are just space Nazis” this could be a really powerful way of showing it without being too preachy. Show a citizen of the empire see a rise in terrorism around the galaxy (the Rebel empire forming) and they want to do their part to stop it. Goes from a simple patriotic peace keeper to actual concentration camps and genocides happening for “the greater good”. I’m not too familiar with the lore, but maybe the climax of the movie could be when the rebels help rescue the Wookiees and our Stormtrooper dies during the battle or gets captured.
This is set actually in 10BBY, bu yeah i agree
Except the empire is explicitly villainous and terrible from the start
"MY LEG" - Fred
FRED'S LEG!!!
Literally thought that from the moment I saw it in theatres which was funny but also took me out of the scene
That guy did it on purpose.
It sounded like Fred too
Bruh! I went dead when I heard that. 😂
It's amazing how this deleted scenes change the dynamic of the movie so much, it adds a lot more personality and context to, really everything.
“Beckette you said we were hear to pull a quick job!”
“Yeah..”
“Well this ain’t a quick job, it’s a WAAAR!!!”
*Imperials slaughtering rebels and getting blown away in the background”
One of my most favorite scenes in Star Wars
Mine too
They’re not slaughtering rebels tho.
They’re actually fighting the local inhabitants of the planet who are getting invaded by the empire.
@Doctor Tophat Too much rebellions happening in this sector lol
Doctor Tophat but they’re not rebelling.......they’re protecting their home.
A rebellion is a movement against an established ruling.
Rebels would be if the natives fought the natives and the empire took a side against the rebelling force.
@@JOSHCHIMICH Welp, there goes my terrible joke
1:16 nice mention of the Z-95 headhunter
good catch
Those are viscious little bastards
"I'm han."
"Nobody cares."
Haha.
I don’t think enough people realize that The Empire has an Army. This is their Army. Stormtroopers are basically Marines. They sort of kinda have an air force if you count airbases like the one on Aldhani.
Starfighter Corps is under the Navy.
I'm sure a lot of us would love to see a Star Wars movie from an Imperial perspective that shows both the benefits and flaws of both Imperial and Rebel ideology. Having extremists like Saw and his men mixed with the draconian doctrine of the Empire but understanding that life under the Empire can be a drastic improvement to life during the Republic. Maybe in the end the main character could die fighting for the Empire and protecting their family and loved ones or innocents in general from a rebel extremist attack, an attack so severe that it is what causes the Rebels to change their tactics to what we know of the modern Rebel Alliance.
So a Thrawn movie? I'd go for it. No really Thrawn was everything the Empire preached it was from his military command, treatment of his personal and prisoners, against the enemy in battle and what ever control he had of any planets under his influence.
Read _Lost Stars._
But the rebels were always the bad guys right....right? just me?
@@polskastrong8558
No, frustratingly, it's not just you.
That's way too creative. Disney would never do that.
The Warhammer 40k vibes are very strong here.
That "the empire needs you" is definitely a Commisar without the hat.
Much reminds me of the imperial guardsmen
i think everyone should appreciate this rare moment in star wars when the audience is shown that they’re still at war and war is no different on foreign planets than it is on Earth
I really wish they showed more of this in Star Wars it just makes the troopers more understandable and really lets you see the humanity in the troops.
I love the imperial uniforms
*Ïmperial GERMAN uniforms* there, fixed it for you lol
@@strikeone7803 ha ha ha....your comment made me smile, cheers.
Design by Hugo Boss (almost)
@Pferd Schild I don't care
@Pferd Schild Hugo Boss is the company that made the uniforms, not the ones who designed them.
I wish there was more units shown in Star Wars like this, as in the standard Imperial trooper, and the Stormtroopers being elite, not goofballs flying around like ragdolls. Then you would actually have an intimidating antagonist again, if the rebels are just “sooooo badass" ALL of the time then them destroying anything imperial doesn't feel earned or have any weight to it.
Andor moment.
Coric said it already but I wonder how much you liked Andor.
Gez, this battle scene does not get the appreciation it deserves. I just want a entire movie like this.
Yeah just saving Private Ryan star wars edition. This was probably the closest you'll get to what actual warfare is in this world.
When this movie was released, it was the only scene in the Star Wars franchise that showed you the Empire in the midst of invading and subjugating a planet. I would love to see more of this in the future.
Just another day for the Astra Militarum.
Wait
This isn't Cadia... How by the Emperor's Balls did we end up here?
@@kabob0077 some sort of malfunction sir
@@lordoblivion8038 Find out what happened beyond a malfunction, I'd like to get to Cadia soon.
Armoured Productions That’s what happens if you don’t use your Gellar Shield when going trough the warp
@@xekon14 Well it could've been worse. At least some demons didn't pop out our ches---Ughhhhh Ahhhhh!!!!!
OK, guys. If you're a Warhammer 40k fans, you could imagine this as a battle of Imperial Guard. XD
All that's really missing, is that when they go over the top, someone needs to yell *"FOR THE EMPEROR!!!"*
When I literally heard the officer shouting about the soldiers fighting for their Empire, the first thing that came to mind for me was that the Empire had hired Imperial Commissars lol.
@@georgelabe-assimo4365 To be fair, the Empire kinda does have a Commissariat in the form of the ISB
All equipped with las guns.
Siege of Vraks to be exact
Me: *playing with legos*
What my mom saw: *pieces of plastic*
What I saw: 2:05
Same
this
Same
Dude I create a fucking city battles with legos. It was a enjoyable acticity for creative kids.
“Oh, we’ll have you flying in no time.” *_*IS LAUNCHED 6 FEET INTO THE AIR BY MIMBANESE SHELLS*_*
"Cadet Solo. Still can't decide if you're brave or stupid"
Me: Is it too much to ask for both?
Chatnawat Narakol You are very clever
@Retarded BLU Soldier [TF2 AA] Or just reckless and cocky. XD
2:44 If they had more of this man the Empire would've won.
The Empire would have won if it was unified. It fell because the imperial officers were more concerned about power than anything and fell to infighting.
@@zandrmandr8300 and the Frakking Sith kept offing honest, competent officers trying to do their jobs while favoring moronic suck-ups.
If you see the Empire is Full of Badass people More than the Rebels Xd
The Empire had no reason to feel unified, they weren’t really fighting for a cause other than power and what they liked to call “peace”
What I imagined Rogue One would be
Noobfromafar definitely
This is genuenly a battle, props to these 4 minutes for showing an actual battle in a franchise called "star wars"
Yeah lots of stars but not many actual wars. The closest you'll get to a solid ground war that isn't movie bullshit is the battle of hoth. Although it wasn't really a battle it was a defense against an onslaught
A prequel about Beckett assembling his team and running jobs that lead up to this battle. But have the “Rogue One” production team film and direct it.
"Just over that last ridge, victory is-"
Famous last words.
Theatrical cut is so much better. "We'll have you flying in no time." Then he's flying through the air from an explosion. Genuinely funny moment.
This entire scene is giving me some ww1 trench warfare vibs, the pain, the mud, the scorch land, the battle
I would just love to see these types of battles, just the pure chaos of actuall ww1 and ww2 vibes makes it so real yet so reletable to our worlds warfare
Yeah exactly this is the closest you'll get to what real warfare is in this universe
Can we get a movie that follows the conventional army more? Not some made to be hero, or Jedi or what have you.
Just a soldier and his squad, company, etc, getting through conflicts on various planets.
It doesn't even have to be a movie, a TV show would do fine, especially if it were structured kinda like band of brothers, I think that'd be pretty cool.
Band of Brothers would be a good one to follow but since its about the empire I think the Russian film 9th company would be more fitting
This would be perfectly like the Battlefront 2 (2005) storyline.
Watch Generation Kill
I want to see the subjugation of Naboo and Vader standing over Padme's grave...and then how the Empire brought down the first Wookie Rebellion.
Andor apparently is this
Everyone talking about 40k, but nobody's paying attention to how beautiful that AT Walker at 2:16 sounds.
General_Lagarto I remember audibly saying “oh yeah” in the theatre when that walker dropped.
I wish the movie had ended with Han fleeing as the Crimson Dawn is suddenly on the receiving end of an Imperial attack like this. If Han saw how the Imperial Army was made of men just like him, seeing it afar and faceless should have been what made him the man we knew in Episode IV. He would remember what it was like to be confused and terrified in all the dust and laserfire. So maybe when Han and Co. are making a break for it as the Crimson Dawn is distracted by the planet's sparse Imperial garrison...the sky flickers, and a Star Destroyer exits hyperspace. We get to see Vos' face go from irritated to shocked to nervous as he realizes that he bit off more than he could chew by killing that Imperial official at the start of the film, however minor the guy may have been.
Imagine how Han would be if he got such an amazing example of how the Empire _always_ gets the last word. Dryden Vos has more power and influence than Han could ever think he would achieve, but imagine how that would inform seeing a _single_ Star Destroyer tear down everything Vos had ever built for going one step too far. And as Han watches the TIE fighters strafe Vos' men and landing crafts deploy Imperial soldiers, he'd also realize that his own experience wasn't special. He didn't have some uniquely-traumatizing experience that would undo the Empire if only more soldiers endured and survived it. We could even end with a shaken Han (and Chewie) in some distant bar, looking up to a broadcast of an inspiring Imperial news report about the defeat of the Vos-branch of the Crimson Dawn.
The empire allows criminal syndicates to exist as long as they get a cut.
Honestly that ending sounds so cool
@@pale_lad1252 True, though it never hurts to have a scene where The Empire actually takes action against em the moment they step out of line. They typically let em exist but the moment they overestimate themselves, The Empire always exacts judgement right then and there with the will of remorseless agents and the might of a single star destroyer
Andor and Solo did a good job reminding people that the Empire’s army isn’t just Stormtroopers
Although they are a part of it.