We count on good people to pay for good journalism. Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/ This includes the link for subscription from overseas too.
भारत की लोकतन्त्र की चौथी स्तम्भ को गोदी की दीमग लगचुकि हे. अंदर से स्तम्भ खोखला बनचुकी हे लेकिन गोदिमीडिया ने उसपे पर्दा और रंगचढ़ा के ये बता रही हे के प्रजातंत्र की मंदिर नहीं गिरेगा. आज नौबत ये आगयी हे की दिमग बाकी की तीन स्तम्भ को भी गोदी की दीमग लगचुकि हे. अब पेंटिंग या पर्दा थोड़ी ही चार स्तम्भ के जरिये डेमोक्रेसी की छत हवा में रख सकेगा? देश बिक चुकी हे, बस इन्तिज़ार हे कौन सी देश की गुलाम बनेगी.अच्छे दिन आनेवाले हे बस इंतज़ार करो... नफरत और अत्याचार रोज़ बाबारूद बनके खून पसीने में दौड़ता रहता है, आँखों से आंसू की बस एक पुकार चिंगारी सी बिस्फोट लाता हे. सियाराम की नाम पे रावण की राज चलता हे, हाँ हाँ रावण की राज चलता हे, सुबह श्याम टीवीन्यूज़ चैनल में इनकी हिंसा और नफरत की आग जलता हे. कुर्सी की लालच में अँधा रोज़ दंगा करवाते हे, हिन्दू मुस्लिम और सिख इसाई को रोज़ आपस में लड़वाते हे. भारत की जनता को फेकू की मन की बात बहुत ही सस्ता लगता हे, गरीबों की खून पसीने की कमाई सिर्फ मन की बात सुनाने में, युहीं गोदी मीडिया पे करोड़ से लूटता हे. औरत और गरीबों की रोज़ मज़ाक़ उडाता हे, हाँ हाँ रोज़ मज़ाक़ उडाता हे, सच्चाई से कोसो दूर कहीं अख़बार में पीएम अबास की झूठी तस्वीरे छपता है. गंदे नाली की केडे हैं झूटे नेता लफ़ंगे बड़ी मक्कार हे इनसे कोई और बात ही करना बेकार हे, बेशर्मी की कोई हद नहीं इनकी समझ नौकरी दिलवाना एक ब्यापार हे और देश बेचना सर्कार हे.
India first salves of Turkish then Mughal (progeny of Turkish, Persian & Mongal) then Britisher came India got Independence after 700 years that a fact this rulers are not Indian Muslims or Christian
Please invest in teaching these some basics like pronouncing any non-Hindi names....pathetic guys....I hope Shri Shekhar Gupta says the names right....at least make a good effort
@ThePrint if you are really serious about paid subscriptions then please take a look at all the comments the viewers make for the interviews that this lady conducts. Its not an opinion of a single person but an overwhelming majority. Please introspect.
Jyoti Malhotra demonstrates why Lutyens will not understand why Modi keeps winning. She's working hard here to not understand the jacket professor. He says the Sangh is extremely reformist, which is why their base keeps growing. Or how the Sangh is non-conservative, even suggesting gay relationships should be accepted. She responds with some comment on Bajrang Dal. While that may be a separate question, did you understand what he said? I don't think you did.
I don’t know people will agree with me or not but I really want Modi to come back in 2024. India needs radical change and prachark like Dattatreya RSS needs. Great talk.
@@nimi8386 Muslims need to understand that RSS-BJP is in actually a very liberal Hindu Nationalist party and not some fascistic authoritarian regime. All the fear mongering needs to stop. You need to understand that the Islamophobic rhetoric is not something pedalled solely by the BJP. It has existed in India since centuries and became much expressive after the creation of Pakistan. Now that there's a Hindu nationalist ideology ruling India, the rhetoric has just amplified both by the right wing ecosystem and the accelerationist left wing. Indian Muslims need to put differences aside and accept the majoritarian reality and actually have faith in the naturally secular Hindu populace. If India will have a strong Government which isnt possible unless Hindus accept them,then we can't become the superpower we wish to be. Rest assured India has a glorious future and with her,Indian Muslims too.
@@nimi8386 i think you didn’t see the talk clearly idea of Hindu rashtra is completely different than nation run by islamic law or Catholicism. We all are one its a broader picture inclusive of every one this land is a land of sanatani and you can be muslim, christain, atheists or xyz but your identity is with the land and it is people living beyond sindhu river (new name hindu people)
I liked the talk. Jyoti sometimes doesn't like what Mr. Makarand says about RSS, but what he is saying is true about RSS whether people like it or not.
The only interest Jyoti has is just to know whether Modi will lead Hosabale or it will be other way round. It is such a poor understanding of the issue by her that all efforts by Makarand and Badri to educate her, seem to have failed completely. She is disappointed that there is no chance of any fissures between RSS and Modi. But anyway, that is Jyoti we know!!
High time Mdm Jyoti herself is reorientied in her behoviour and thinking as her one and only agenda is Anti Modi. She should be persuaded to join the RSS and sent to an RSS training camp for reorientation.
When a person has already carried a different approach towards someone when his/her view is already biased, even if you try 1000 ways you cannot change him/her view as long as s/he has not experienced the same.
@@sachin15194 They will never understand Santana Dharma even in a million lifetimes. Just mlechchas born in our own land to our own people, sadly. But that's the way karma works.
@@amitpadhye7509 Hey, I don't think wire can be compared to print. Wire, Caravan are all a different league altogether! Print tries more of monkey balancing!
Makrand had amazing clarity . Spot on. And true .every word. Jyoti misses the point. The vision is most important. The aim is supreme.individuals. who leads whom is inconsequential. It's beyond you jyoti .
Its funny to see that the anchor is hardly understanding anything, whereas Mr. Paranjape is very articulative and has a better understanding. I wish better questions could have been asked.
Jyoti is so hateful towards RSS and anyone who tries explaining it. You can see her restlessness again and again, she tries to be condescending, gets offended and attacks them as soon as they do not mimic her views. There is no need to be any of these things. She is the barkha dutt junior.
There is no difference, both are fringe and antithesis of the concept of Democracy, the Proletariat. Both are elitist construct, based on few ruling over many and many serving the few. This is already a archaic concept and Brahmanical and Punjaabi bigotries will be rid off soon from this god forsaken country.
@@hareshmehta1772 jaativaadi manuvaadi spotted. Krishna ji Yadav the, hum bhagvaan ke vanshaj hain, lulli choti hai toh kya huaa wet dreams toh sabhi dekh sakte hain!!! Manuvaadi saavdhaan, indian communism is all about the class struggle, nothing wrong with it. Jai bheem, Laal salaam! Indian Constitution is primary and is above all and will always stay.
Yet another fantastic conversation. Very well moderated and resourceful speakers 👍🏻 Looking forward to hearing Makarand Ji as a regular guest in upcoming episodes too.
where was the fucking sangh before 47 ??? termites like u r the product of sangh . Sangh and its followers has nothing to do the development of the country .there are many instances of past where power hungary sangh people wanted to divide the nation be it lala lajpat rai writing in The tribune or hedgewar , sawarkar who proposed two nation theory before jinnah or shamya prasad mukhherjee with partition of bengal in 1905 .they all power greedy people they from rss talked about divison of the country .
A strong RSS can provide a cultural anchor to the nation based on a strong identity of India and keep the nation United given the diversity and complexity of influences on our country
Jyoti Malhotra never imagined in her whole life that someday she would be interviewing the likes of Prof. Badri Narayan and Prof Makarand Paranjape😂😂😂Just look at her face 👌
Despite detailed explanation, that too in simple language, by both the men Jyoythi refuses to get the message. That is the tragedy of the Lootians. There is a paradigm shift in thinking that the RSS have brought in that the Lootians are perhaps not capable of.
Madam host kept trying to push words in and divert the discussion, continue to met a subtle reset! The guests were knowledgable and host was inane! And, is it Allahabad or Prayagraj? Shame!!
Wow! A veiled perfect slap on so called lutyen media by comparing them with one of the meaning of said word as it suggests लूटने वाला. Perfect comparison.
Professor Paranjape is a gem, so articulate with command over both English and Hindi , has clarity of thought with abundant wisdom and knowledge of the subject as well as the ability to read the intention(Agenda) of the interviewer.
Jyotiji, please learn to pronounce Dattatreya Hosabale. If unsure please give out a disclaimer like Shekharji and your fellow liberal hosts in West do. It looks pompuous n self centered the way you say the name currently. As somebody from South of the Vindhyas I can assure it's pronounced ದತ್ತಾತ್ರೇಯ ಹೊಸಬಾಳೆ /दत्तात्रेय हॉसबाळॅ .
@@AnuragSinha7 thanks for the correction Anurag. It's the same in Kannada n Marathi as it is in Hindi. It was typo from my end. I was just pissed off how some of our anchors can get the pronunciation of Afghan and Russian names right. While Indian names seem alien.
Jyoti have no concrete questions as she has no understanding of RSS or she hates it. The questions are jumping from Dattatreya to Rss-bjp relationship and without completing it she again comes back to Dattatreya and jumps to ground level happenings which we all know. Wasted oppertunity to learn higher up thinktank of RSS.
@Kumar Swarāj Ok ... I just wanted to understand what their vision is ... Is it a Hindu republic, On party rule, colonising other countries, world domination ... Because vaguely they want a strong India what it means idk. They are also not concerned about the well being of "Indians" it may or may not be a consequence of a strong India. You might recognise that the above is increasingly ridiculous. It is strictly for dramatic effect and not taunting. If someone can clarify these ambiguities it might be helpful for all. Ig the reason why people "hate/fear" RSS is because it refuses to have an open, mainstream conversation. We don't know what they want. And they are too structured to not have an endgame.
@Kumar Swarāj thanks, but still ... This is textbook and I get the feel. But what is the concrete agenda... Like Ram Mandir done, Article 370 done, Uniform civil code is on the horizon. What next ... India as economic super power, millitary state, AI and cyber specialist, theocratic state... What is the end game...
Jyotiji, discourse or debate does not need hypocrisy which you amply demonstrate. If 90% parliamentarians have an aastha in Vishnu, does it mean this is a vaishnavite polity?. You got old but don't seem to wisen up. You seem to paraphrase everyone you interview and 100% of them refute your version. Pathetic interview technique.
Congrats Jyoti Malhotra. One more sign of your independent journalism. Even though you personally don't approve of RSS, you still wish to present them to your viewers so that the viewers can have another spectrum of ideology. I think you are the only journalist who is truly independent and not guided by personal views.
India is blessed with a selfless Patriotic Indian Leader PM Modi Ji 🇮🇳Jai Bharath 🇮🇳Jai Hind Educating people on issues such as international conspiracies to destabilize India, the NGO Money etc And to cultivate Patriotic sense , if happens in every state in every linguistic environment may bring change for the good of future generations
'Just because Sangh supports LGBTQ rights.... ' i mean she uses just because!! Conveniently forgetting the overall world context, especially religious or cultural bodies vehement and many a times violent opposition to LGBTQ rights! Really, Print has started showing its true colours👍
Few days ago I met a sanghi who is 89 years old and has been with RSS for last 60 years.I asked him to share his thoughts on RSS. He said that he is still studying RSS idealogy and these three people with basic and critic mindset are trying to talk of RSS. How come Dalit issue came while talking of new team ? They tried to emphasis that RSS has bigger role in BJP. They should study why Bajrang dal and VHP was born ?
Prof Badhri ji is really a soft spoken and very decent person to the extent conversation in a debate is concerned. I sort of like this sort of behaviour ... I shall surely try to learn and modify my behaviour.
Hinduism is an evolving way since 15000 years and Hindutva too is steeped in the same mould. It intends to build it values with inspiration from its HERITAGE WHILE ALLOWING ALL ideas across the world to deep its forecourt. EVERY human in the sucontinent have Hindu heritage.
Jyoti Malhotra is in a net shell the entire left ecosystem, who cannot listen to anyone with a different opinion and are as intolerant as they accuse the other side to be. I want her to hide her ideological bias and conduct the interviews from neutral point of view and leave it to the public to make their own perceptions based on the answers given by the guests.
Personally from what I understand about Sanaatan Dharm, it is a beautiful attitude. I know I will end up either disliked or mistrusted, but it is ok: I speak my heart with nothing but affection for all creatures ... and in any case I won't live forever. Death shall put me into oblivion, hatred shall never get me as its followers. May sorrow get minimised and if some sorrow be unavoidable then may it be melodious and humane instead of being ugly and stone-faced.
Firstly Makarand ji and Badri ji were so good, Jyoti looked like a kid (knowledge wise) around them. Clearly she does not by far qualify in any respect for hosting these great minds. She was limiting the discussion to find sensational elements. Kept interrupting whenever the discussion was about the idea of Sangh. She herself is part of the Lutyens group. Need someone really good in such interviews
As you people think, there's no lateral entry in Sangh. Maananeeya Dattaatreya Hosabaale ji is a Swayamsevak from his childhood, infact He went to Shaakhaa when he was 13years old, but from his college days he worked with and for ABVP which is the Sangh students wing.
Madam Jyoti is the same journalists who use to ask for donate money for ' the print ' in you tube videos but never reveals what salary salary actually she charges.
since INdependence This INDIA cannot come to our original ( always these people ensure projecting hindu sanskriti as very low// untolerable ) whereas entire world society is worst than INDIA These PRINT like people are planters of Christian missionary // may be petro dollars // ofcourse china factor is very much possible They have succeded sofar to ensure narative that victimising of others happening in all forum including international && make India poor or demonised BUT LORD SHIVA will rescue sanatana when right time arrives Till such time we have to silently pray
Why is Indian media giving into western notion of Hindu society along the lines of other religions. Hindus don’t force any particular belief. Entire western world now sees vegetarianism, meditation and yoga as enlightened way of living. What’s so wrong with Hindu society or Hindu republic?
The day bold expressiveness against secular and also expressing Hindu rastra are more bold even un known persons who are ambitious and intelgent engineers definitely make more appealing transform s among mild followers to strong follwers
Correct word for Hindu what RSS mean is all hindu, muslim, christian, sikh, etc who accept their ancestry. Keep India above religion. Don't think they are relatives of Abdali, and Suri. Not dependent of pope or babber khalsa. Who are flexible in saying jai shri ram, allah hu akbar, may god bless you, waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatah, and vande Mataram, all of them without bringing in religion, and trying to stand out. Who know sensitivities of each other, In one line who believe वसुधैव कुटुम्ब, which mean who are truly secular in Indian sense, i.e. done be away from religion while respect and celebrate all religion. Just think if this happen then India will be festive in whole year.
The Thing is that Sangh paves the way for BJP to win elections ,and vice versa RSS enjoys power at different places . But real thing is that , if Modi looses election , Sangh will be very much devastated .So they try to work united. Take for example , Kisan Protests , RSS kisan wing " Kisan Sangh " is parting away from Farmer crisis , which earlier used to protest .
Jyitiji, Please try to open the windows so that fresh air enters. J Krishnamurty said, every normal person is conditioned in thinking, because of impressions and experiences registered in the mid. If any one wants to get liberation he is to unchain himself from the shackles of conditioned thinking. I find in the comments you are rated as a person with poor Knowledge of RSS. If you want to evolved please open up your mind.
Regarding Sindhu to Hindu theory originally coined by Max Müller and repeated here by Prof. Paranjape, how could the Persians pronounce "Avesta" or names of so many places ending with "stan" if they could not pronounce "S" and pronounced it as "H" instead?
Wonderful Jyoti madam, you are demonstrating to the journalist fraternity that to be a good journalist, one doesn't have to be snobbish like Karan Topper are scream like Arneb. You challenged them with all the tough questions without intimidating or provoking them.
We count on good people to pay for good journalism. Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/
This includes the link for subscription from overseas too.
भारत की लोकतन्त्र की चौथी स्तम्भ को गोदी की दीमग लगचुकि हे. अंदर से स्तम्भ खोखला बनचुकी हे लेकिन गोदिमीडिया ने उसपे पर्दा और रंगचढ़ा के ये बता रही हे के प्रजातंत्र की मंदिर नहीं गिरेगा.
आज नौबत ये आगयी हे की दिमग बाकी की तीन स्तम्भ को भी गोदी की दीमग लगचुकि हे. अब पेंटिंग या पर्दा थोड़ी ही चार स्तम्भ के जरिये डेमोक्रेसी की छत हवा में रख सकेगा?
देश बिक चुकी हे, बस इन्तिज़ार हे कौन सी देश की गुलाम बनेगी.अच्छे दिन आनेवाले हे बस इंतज़ार करो...
नफरत और अत्याचार रोज़ बाबारूद बनके खून पसीने में दौड़ता रहता है,
आँखों से आंसू की बस एक पुकार चिंगारी सी बिस्फोट लाता हे.
सियाराम की नाम पे रावण की राज चलता हे, हाँ हाँ रावण की राज चलता हे,
सुबह श्याम टीवीन्यूज़ चैनल में इनकी हिंसा और नफरत की आग जलता हे.
कुर्सी की लालच में अँधा रोज़ दंगा करवाते हे,
हिन्दू मुस्लिम और सिख इसाई को रोज़ आपस में लड़वाते हे.
भारत की जनता को फेकू की मन की बात बहुत ही सस्ता लगता हे,
गरीबों की खून पसीने की कमाई सिर्फ मन की बात सुनाने में, युहीं गोदी मीडिया पे करोड़ से लूटता हे.
औरत और गरीबों की रोज़ मज़ाक़ उडाता हे, हाँ हाँ रोज़ मज़ाक़ उडाता हे,
सच्चाई से कोसो दूर कहीं अख़बार में पीएम अबास की झूठी तस्वीरे छपता है.
गंदे नाली की केडे हैं झूटे नेता लफ़ंगे बड़ी मक्कार हे इनसे कोई और बात ही करना बेकार हे,
बेशर्मी की कोई हद नहीं इनकी समझ नौकरी दिलवाना एक ब्यापार हे और देश बेचना सर्कार हे.
India first salves of Turkish then Mughal (progeny of Turkish, Persian & Mongal) then Britisher came India got Independence after 700 years that a fact this rulers are not Indian Muslims or Christian
Please invest in teaching these some basics like pronouncing any non-Hindi names....pathetic guys....I hope Shri Shekhar Gupta says the names right....at least make a good effort
@ThePrint if you are really serious about paid subscriptions then please take a look at all the comments the viewers make for the interviews that this lady conducts. Its not an opinion of a single person but an overwhelming majority. Please introspect.
@@SunilKumar-nf7ft I Support u brother
I am from rss family associated with
For past 60yrs guruji golwalkar is
Our family friend for decades
Grateful to listen to Makarand Sir. Amazing talk.
Jyoti Malhotra demonstrates why Lutyens will not understand why Modi keeps winning. She's working hard here to not understand the jacket professor. He says the Sangh is extremely reformist, which is why their base keeps growing. Or how the Sangh is non-conservative, even suggesting gay relationships should be accepted. She responds with some comment on Bajrang Dal. While that may be a separate question, did you understand what he said? I don't think you did.
I don’t know people will agree with me or not but I really want Modi to come back in 2024. India needs radical change and prachark like Dattatreya RSS needs. Great talk.
Agree with you. This country needs strong leadership and development. Only BJP can deliver. M a Christian from northeast and I support bjp
would you be saying the same thing if you were a muslim ??
@@nimi8386 I would say the same if I wasn't brainwashed and indoctrinated with hate like the majority of this community
@@nimi8386 Muslims need to understand that RSS-BJP is in actually a very liberal Hindu Nationalist party and not some fascistic authoritarian regime. All the fear mongering needs to stop.
You need to understand that the Islamophobic rhetoric is not something pedalled solely by the BJP. It has existed in India since centuries and became much expressive after the creation of Pakistan. Now that there's a Hindu nationalist ideology ruling India, the rhetoric has just amplified both by the right wing ecosystem and the accelerationist left wing.
Indian Muslims need to put differences aside and accept the majoritarian reality and actually have faith in the naturally secular Hindu populace. If India will have a strong Government which isnt possible unless Hindus accept them,then we can't become the superpower we wish to be. Rest assured India has a glorious future and with her,Indian Muslims too.
@@nimi8386 i think you didn’t see the talk clearly idea of Hindu rashtra is completely different than nation run by islamic law or Catholicism. We all are one its a broader picture inclusive of every one this land is a land of sanatani and you can be muslim, christain, atheists or xyz but your identity is with the land and it is people living beyond sindhu river (new name hindu people)
I liked the talk.
Jyoti sometimes doesn't like what Mr. Makarand says about RSS, but what he is saying is true about RSS whether people like it or not.
The only interest Jyoti has is just to know whether Modi will lead Hosabale or it will be other way round. It is such a poor understanding of the issue by her that all efforts by Makarand and Badri to educate her, seem to have failed completely. She is disappointed that there is no chance of any fissures between RSS and Modi. But anyway, that is Jyoti we know!!
High time Mdm Jyoti herself is reorientied in her behoviour and thinking as her one and only agenda is Anti Modi. She should be persuaded to join the RSS and sent to an RSS training camp for reorientation.
When a person has already carried a different approach towards someone when his/her view is already biased, even if you try 1000 ways you cannot change him/her view as long as s/he has not experienced the same.
@@sachin15194 They will never understand Santana Dharma even in a million lifetimes. Just mlechchas born in our own land to our own people, sadly. But that's the way karma works.
How are you expecting unbiased discussion on The print, wire types
@@amitpadhye7509 Hey, I don't think wire can be compared to print. Wire, Caravan are all a different league altogether! Print tries more of monkey balancing!
Makrand had amazing clarity .
Spot on.
And true .every word.
Jyoti misses the point.
The vision is most important. The aim is supreme.individuals. who leads whom is inconsequential.
It's beyond you jyoti .
Its funny to see that the anchor is hardly understanding anything, whereas Mr. Paranjape is very articulative and has a better understanding. I wish better questions could have been asked.
Jyoti is so hateful towards RSS and anyone who tries explaining it. You can see her restlessness again and again, she tries to be condescending, gets offended and attacks them as soon as they do not mimic her views. There is no need to be any of these things. She is the barkha dutt junior.
Burqa Dutt?
Well said. I couldn't disagree with you anymore!!
Print is filled with these biased journalist while Shekar gupta claims to be non partisan
Agree
Her credentials to work in The Print is She is so hateful towards RSS...
It is not RSS that is fringe, it is Lutyens that is fringe.
😁😁😁really a good one
There is no difference, both are fringe and antithesis of the concept of Democracy, the Proletariat. Both are elitist construct, based on few ruling over many and many serving the few. This is already a archaic concept and Brahmanical and Punjaabi bigotries will be rid off soon from this god forsaken country.
@@bharatvassee237 a commie spotted. Good morning. It is already morning, so I wish you wet day dreams
@@hareshmehta1772 jaativaadi manuvaadi spotted. Krishna ji Yadav the, hum bhagvaan ke vanshaj hain, lulli choti hai toh kya huaa wet dreams toh sabhi dekh sakte hain!!!
Manuvaadi saavdhaan, indian communism is all about the class struggle, nothing wrong with it. Jai bheem, Laal salaam!
Indian Constitution is primary and is above all and will always stay.
@@bharatvassee237 😂😂😂. Aapne sahi kaha! Wet dreams toh aap dekh hi sakte hai. Enjoy. Chahe toh burnol bhi de doon.
Thank you for open and positive discussion about RSS.
Post- independence India shall forever remain indebted to RSS !
Yet another fantastic conversation. Very well moderated and resourceful speakers 👍🏻
Looking forward to hearing Makarand Ji as a regular guest in upcoming episodes too.
Rss Shakespeare are hardworking,and go into the grass roots levels.Great work RSS.
Yes. Dattatreya Hosabale has a Masters degree in English literature. I am sure he is familiar with Shakespeare’s works.
Jyoti gives a sarcastic laugh for a erudite answer. She is so biased and not able to accept her long based lutyen media defeat
The anchor is "tourist" and the guests are the "travellers";
- The tourist sees what he has come to see, the traveller sees what he sees.
💯
The Sangh is the savior of Bharat, the dynamo that powers the next generation of Bharatiya nagrik
where was the fucking sangh before 47 ??? termites like u r the product of sangh . Sangh and its followers has nothing to do the development of the country .there are many instances of past where power hungary sangh people wanted to divide the nation be it lala lajpat rai writing in The tribune or hedgewar , sawarkar who proposed two nation theory before jinnah or shamya prasad mukhherjee with partition of bengal in 1905 .they all power greedy people they from rss talked about divison of the country .
@@damn738 terko kya problem hui aaj tak sang se ?
@@nostalgicfact3806 nostalgia Fact
RSS Shakas are hard working
A strong RSS can provide a cultural anchor to the nation based on a strong identity of India and keep the nation United given the diversity and complexity of influences on our country
What a wonderful discussion- wish it could have gone on for much longer - it was fascinating to learn about the RSS
Jyoti trying very hard to make RSS into monsters but miserably failing to comprehend
Makarandji, in English, gave excellent, explanation & history & functioning of SANGH.
Jyoti Malhotra never imagined in her whole life that someday she would be interviewing the likes of Prof. Badri Narayan and Prof Makarand Paranjape😂😂😂Just look at her face 👌
She might not have imagined but she came prepared with her agenda, Makarand chutia came prepared to promote himself
@@vv18268 don't call him chutia atleast.....Sabka apna tarika hota hai
Makarand sir is absolute gem.
Second time this week, and I still keep reading Dattatreya as Dattebayo.
Ah, I see you're a man of culture as well
Nani ???
Sugoi✌🏼
Rasengan 🌀
what is dattebayo?
Despite detailed explanation, that too in simple language, by both the men Jyoythi refuses to get the message. That is the tragedy of the Lootians. There is a paradigm shift in thinking that the RSS have brought in that the Lootians are perhaps not capable of.
News flash! Allahabad has been renamed as Prayagraj for quite some time now. Perhaps the news did not reach Lutyens or they refuse to accept?
Nice discussion, but print should get rid of such anchors who are extremely biased, rigid and almost clearly appearing 'dumb'.
Madam host kept trying to push words in and divert the discussion, continue to met a subtle reset! The guests were knowledgable and host was inane! And, is it Allahabad or Prayagraj? Shame!!
Jo Mo cant even respond to the Namaskars from the two guests. Rude. All she is looking for is some dirt on RSS.
Jyoti has absolutely no general awareness, she is a perfect example of Khan Market club..
Wow! A veiled perfect slap on so called lutyen media by comparing them with one of the meaning of said word as it suggests लूटने वाला. Perfect comparison.
Absolutely fascinating discussion. I would have loved to hear more of Badriji
Beautifully explained.Theprint deserves the praise for this interview.
Most Misunderstood and underrated organisation. Thx Print for giving some insight of the same.
Sorry for jyoti ji
biased and misinformed about rss
I think you acting like big bro of the wire or the liar
Professor Paranjape is a gem, so articulate with command over both English and Hindi , has clarity of thought with abundant wisdom and knowledge of the subject as well as the ability to read the intention(Agenda) of the interviewer.
Is jyoti a private equity investor in print ?
Can't think of any other reason why she is tolerated .
You have relieved me of a most baffling puzzle 😂
I love Rss I studied in sarsawati vidya mandir
Jyotiji, please learn to pronounce Dattatreya Hosabale. If unsure please give out a disclaimer like Shekharji and your fellow liberal hosts in West do. It looks pompuous n self centered the way you say the name currently. As somebody from South of the Vindhyas I can assure it's pronounced ದತ್ತಾತ್ರೇಯ ಹೊಸಬಾಳೆ /दत्तात्रेय हॉसबाळॅ .
Dear he is a kannadiga madhwa brahmin proud of his achievment jai rss jai bjp
X
@@AnuragSinha7 thanks for the correction Anurag. It's the same in Kannada n Marathi as it is in Hindi. It was typo from my end. I was just pissed off how some of our anchors can get the pronunciation of Afghan and Russian names right. While Indian names seem alien.
Jyoti have no concrete questions as she has no understanding of RSS or she hates it. The questions are jumping from Dattatreya to Rss-bjp relationship and without completing it she again comes back to Dattatreya and jumps to ground level happenings which we all know.
Wasted oppertunity to learn higher up thinktank of RSS.
RSS want to restore Bharat to a glorious past ... Am I correct?
@Kumar Swarāj Ok ... I just wanted to understand what their vision is ... Is it a Hindu republic, On party rule, colonising other countries, world domination ... Because vaguely they want a strong India what it means idk. They are also not concerned about the well being of "Indians" it may or may not be a consequence of a strong India.
You might recognise that the above is increasingly ridiculous. It is strictly for dramatic effect and not taunting.
If someone can clarify these ambiguities it might be helpful for all.
Ig the reason why people "hate/fear" RSS is because it refuses to have an open, mainstream conversation. We don't know what they want. And they are too structured to not have an endgame.
@Kumar Swarāj thanks, but still ... This is textbook and I get the feel. But what is the concrete agenda... Like Ram Mandir done, Article 370 done, Uniform civil code is on the horizon. What next ... India as economic super power, millitary state, AI and cyber specialist, theocratic state... What is the end game...
@Kumar Swarāj Sounds very romantic but not pragmatic...
I was more interested in the pragmatic plans of RSS.
Makrand ji is always wonderful to hear
Jyotiji, discourse or debate does not need hypocrisy which you amply demonstrate. If 90% parliamentarians have an aastha in Vishnu, does it mean this is a vaishnavite polity?. You got old but don't seem to wisen up. You seem to paraphrase everyone you interview and 100% of them refute your version. Pathetic interview technique.
Organisations around world dream of accomplishing what RSS has accomplished
#Respect Makarand Paranjape....
Congrats Jyoti Malhotra. One more sign of your independent journalism. Even though you personally don't approve of RSS, you still wish to present them to your viewers so that the viewers can have another spectrum of ideology. I think you are the only journalist who is truly independent and not guided by personal views.
India is blessed with a selfless Patriotic Indian Leader PM Modi Ji 🇮🇳Jai Bharath 🇮🇳Jai Hind
Educating people on issues such as international conspiracies to destabilize India, the NGO Money etc And to cultivate Patriotic sense , if happens in every state in every linguistic environment may bring change for the good of future generations
Jyoti had deep bias towards RSS or poor information. Requires improvement.
'Just because Sangh supports LGBTQ rights.... ' i mean she uses just because!! Conveniently forgetting the overall world context, especially religious or cultural bodies vehement and many a times violent opposition to LGBTQ rights! Really, Print has started showing its true colours👍
listening good about RSS will give burning in the heart of Jyoti
Few days ago I met a sanghi who is 89 years old and has been with RSS for last 60 years.I asked him to share his thoughts on RSS.
He said that he is still studying RSS idealogy and these three people with basic and critic mindset are trying to talk of RSS.
How come Dalit issue came while talking of new team ?
They tried to emphasis that RSS has bigger role in BJP.
They should study why Bajrang dal and VHP was born ?
Prof Badhri ji is really a soft spoken and very decent person to the extent conversation in a debate is concerned. I sort of like this sort of behaviour ... I shall surely try to learn and modify my behaviour.
Dattatreya Hosabale is an unique personality who knows the way, shows the way and goes to way.
Hinduism is an evolving way since 15000 years and Hindutva too is steeped in the same mould. It intends to build it values with inspiration from its HERITAGE WHILE ALLOWING ALL ideas across the world to deep its forecourt. EVERY human in the sucontinent have Hindu heritage.
I am surprised they invited Makarand paranjape.
It's to see makrand paranjape sir after a long time
Jyoti Malhotra is in a net shell the entire left ecosystem, who cannot listen to anyone with a different opinion and are as intolerant as they accuse the other side to be.
I want her to hide her ideological bias and conduct the interviews from neutral point of view and leave it to the public to make their own perceptions based on the answers given by the guests.
You couldn't have put it better
Very informative debate👍👍
Personally from what I understand about Sanaatan Dharm, it is a beautiful attitude.
I know I will end up either disliked or mistrusted, but it is ok: I speak my heart with nothing but affection for all creatures ... and in any case I won't live forever. Death shall put me into oblivion, hatred shall never get me as its followers.
May sorrow get minimised and if some sorrow be unavoidable then may it be melodious and humane instead of being ugly and stone-faced.
The best part is he's from Karnataka; love from west bengal
Invite Mr Pushpendra Kulshrestha in your show to have a Blunt and Better understanding .
Impossible leave it
Fantastic episode. Great commentary on the Sangh we don’t know much about. Reformist !! Period.
काश कांग्रेस में भी इस तरह की स्वतंत्र शाखा होती जो न केवल परिवार वाद से मुक्त होती बल्कि राष्ट्र सेवा में मूल्यवान योगदान देती
Firstly Makarand ji and Badri ji were so good, Jyoti looked like a kid (knowledge wise) around them. Clearly she does not by far qualify in any respect for hosting these great minds. She was limiting the discussion to find sensational elements. Kept interrupting whenever the discussion was about the idea of Sangh. She herself is part of the Lutyens group. Need someone really good in such interviews
Excellent and very insightful discussion
Jyoti's attitude when she was interviewing audrey trushkey says all about her personality.
I hope RSS starts think-tanks focusing on solving various problems facing India. They should start publishing and appearing on foreign media.
Yes, that would definitely bring down some of the propaganda done on RSS
Only watched for Prof Makarand Paranjape
नमस्ते सदा वत्सले मातृभूमे।
I like everything about the episode except for the anchor 😅
Independent organisation routed to Bharath ethos and culture...Without which India would have been Muslim country by now ...Jai RSS... Jai Bharath
As you people think, there's no lateral entry in Sangh. Maananeeya Dattaatreya Hosabaale ji is a Swayamsevak from his childhood, infact He went to Shaakhaa when he was 13years old, but from his college days he worked with and for ABVP which is the Sangh students wing.
Very pragmatic views and discussion .
Anchor is too quick to put words into the commentators’ mouths.
Jyoti ji, your NDTV-ish views are very perceptible. You must belong to the same stable
Madam Jyoti is the same journalists who use to ask for donate money for ' the print ' in you tube videos but never reveals what salary salary actually she charges.
Print team please upload videos with English subtitles when guests are speaking in Hindi for South People.
Super interview. Gives a great insight in the thinking and working of RSS. Thanks...
Sangh is keeping it's stance nicely. We must become progressive Hindus.
since INdependence This INDIA cannot come to our original ( always these people ensure projecting hindu sanskriti as very low// untolerable ) whereas entire world society is worst than INDIA These PRINT like people are planters of Christian missionary // may be petro dollars // ofcourse china factor is very much possible They have succeded sofar to ensure narative that victimising of others happening in all forum including international && make India poor or demonised BUT LORD SHIVA will rescue sanatana when right time arrives Till such time we have to silently pray
Pardon me .. but given the current state of affairs in India be it economic, strategic or even politics this is a privileged discussion
The anchor was no match for these two giants.
Bahut hi badiya
Great analysis by makrande sir ..Sangha is a wide organisation ..BJP is a primary part of Sangha ..that's all ..
Why is Indian media giving into western notion of Hindu society along the lines of other religions. Hindus don’t force any particular belief. Entire western world now sees vegetarianism, meditation and yoga as enlightened way of living.
What’s so wrong with Hindu society or Hindu republic?
The day bold expressiveness against secular and also expressing Hindu rastra are more bold even un known persons who are ambitious and intelgent engineers definitely make more appealing transform s among mild followers to strong follwers
Jyoti ji should come on the print without prejudice... Otherwise it's a injustice to journalism
Plz do a hindi podcast with badri sahab he is gem plz maan
Interesting points presented, to put it mildly
It's not Allahabad it's Prayagraj 🇮🇳
RSS is an amazing organisation which vampamthis will never acknowledge and understand.
Correct word for Hindu what RSS mean is all hindu, muslim, christian, sikh, etc who accept their ancestry. Keep India above religion. Don't think they are relatives of Abdali, and Suri. Not dependent of pope or babber khalsa. Who are flexible in saying jai shri ram, allah hu akbar, may god bless you, waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatah, and vande Mataram, all of them without bringing in religion, and trying to stand out. Who know sensitivities of each other,
In one line who believe वसुधैव कुटुम्ब, which mean who are truly secular in Indian sense, i.e. done be away from religion while respect and celebrate all religion. Just think if this happen then India will be festive in whole year.
The Thing is that
Sangh paves the way for BJP to win elections ,and vice versa RSS enjoys power at different places .
But real thing is that , if Modi looses election , Sangh will be very much devastated .So they try to work united.
Take for example , Kisan Protests , RSS kisan wing " Kisan Sangh " is parting away from Farmer crisis , which earlier used to protest .
Jyitiji, Please try to open the windows so that fresh air enters. J Krishnamurty said, every normal person is conditioned in thinking, because of impressions and experiences registered in the mid. If any one wants to get liberation he is to unchain himself from the shackles of conditioned thinking. I find in the comments you are rated as a person with poor Knowledge of RSS. If you want to evolved please open up your mind.
I guess Sekhar Gupta needs to choose between Jyoti and paid subscriptions.
Perfect example of Lutyens media and Khan market gang
Regarding Sindhu to Hindu theory originally coined by Max Müller and repeated here by Prof. Paranjape, how could the Persians pronounce "Avesta" or names of so many places ending with "stan" if they could not pronounce "S" and pronounced it as "H" instead?
She is only interested in relationship between Sangh and BJP. At the end of every point she is asking the same question.
Wonderful Jyoti madam, you are demonstrating to the journalist fraternity that to be a good journalist, one doesn't have to be snobbish like Karan Topper are scream like Arneb. You challenged them with all the tough questions without intimidating or provoking them.
The other two people in this interview were also very knowledgeable and answered with clarity.
It's not proper to use word "character" for a person, it would be better if used a word "personality"