Symphony X - When All Is Lost - LIVE NYC Irving Plaza 5/10/2022 The concert began at around 9pm New York City Irving Plaza
Комментарии • 168
3 месяца назад+10
The perfect voice. The perfect guitar player. The perfect drum player. The perfect bass player. The perfect keyboard player. The perfect songs. Symphony X.
Allen's voice is unreal. I couldn't believe my ears when I saw them. They're one of those rare bands that sound even BETTER live than on the album. I'm so pleased they're all still kicking and haven't missed a beat since the 90s. Incredible talent. I wish them all the best, and I'm gonna see them next chance I get.
So glad this song returns to the set list! Their best song since The Odyssey, along with Reign In Madness. Some of Pinella's best work (piano) is found on this one!
Just recently started listening to this band and HOLY SHIT, how have I not heard them play before? Instantly became one of my top favorite bands! I knew Russell from Mike Orlando's band Adrenaline Mob. So I heard them name years ago, but never got to listen. I'm doing a guest solo an a friends metal project and was looking for inspiration and some reason this band's name popped in my head (I think I was actually thinking of Racer X, but anyway). I was driving and asked Siri to play Symphony X and was hooked instantly.
I saw them back in 2008 - they were unbelievable then... they just got better. TSO tuned this mans voice even more... god i love this band. Will be seeing them in New Haven this year.
Certainly a never 'underrated' band apart from the folk who think they are. Anyone who is anyone knows how supreme Symphony X are in this genre and also in a world of spotify/applemusic/youtube etc - they can still produce the goods thanks to the sheer professional musicianship and effort, over time that they have invested into their craft - I applaud their magnificent career /,,/
How the hell drummer remember all those notes? I listened rock songs more than 15 years now and symphony x is always be the first in my mind to listen to. I have entire album of them and this is one of the song that I liked the most. It's just a masterpiece.
Gosh, thanks for uploading this. One of my favourite SX songs, and I doubt I'll ever have a chance of seeing this live - this is as close as it'll get. Magnificent.
He always has. I've seen them two times. Once opening for Blind Guardian in 2003 right after The Odyssey came out. I was impressed the live show was as tight at the album. Every note was there. I saw them in Albany in maybe 2008? Their encore was the entirety of The Odyssey. They played the entire song in a bar in front of maybe 120 people. They went THAT hard for that few people.
dude, the guy is a god damned kaiju-level monster on the guitar. mind blowing. he and the always amazing Micheal Pinnella did a cover of Rush's Analog Kid a long while back with no less than Jack Russel from Great White and freaking Mike Portnoy (Dream Theater), and they absolutely slayed that track. The solos in it are utterly face melting, he and Pinnella both.
@@shababrk LaBrie is tolerable, in studio. Live? Not so much. I've been listening since 1994, and have seen them twice, but never again. I wish Dream Theater had a singer like Russell Allen, or Nils K Rue, but it was never meant to be I guess.
@@Matts_Presentations yes live it’s horrible and it’s funny when fans try to defend him. I start thinking that dream theater fans have no taste in music haha
Yes, they should just get it done already! Reccommend the ancient roman theater in plovdiv, where Sons of Apollo and Devin Townsend did some great concerts with a symphony orchestra. This band is made for this, imagine the accolade, odyssey, divine wings, Communion, Through the looking glass with a full orchestra and choir... in a roman amphitheater, in the city founded by Philip of Macedon
Inmaculados sean y sean bendecidos por todos los Dios del reino del metal sus manos, sus dedos pieses y cuerdas vocales por los siglos y mileniuns AMEN !
Michael Kiske & Russell Allen são os dois vocalistas que ao vivo, fazem justiça as versões de estúdio. Ambos até quando estão com a voz cansada são superiores a média. Pude ver o Kiske ao vivo com a voz sem estar 100% e vou te falar, o cara cantou melhor do que a maioria dos vocalistas do gênero mais jovens. Sem dúvidas temos outros exemplos mas quer destacar esses dois. Viva a esses gigantes.
It's so difficult to stand out in progressive metal....they do it. And wonderfully. New album? 🙏 If it's in the cards. If not, I thank you guys for what you left us. Godspeed Love war of the worlds 2...👊
i believe MR said in a current interview on youtube that he did start writing new songs for the new symphony x album but that they were going to take some time to record it. But it definitely is happening!
Thank you for posting this. Was there at the show with you -- this is my favorite SymX song of all time, and it moved me to tears! Unforgettable night.
Especially for me, since I handed them my drawing. Their reaction was priceless. Although I wanted to jump on stage and play sea of lies, they already played it and I cant play any of their other songs because muchael romeo doesn't make any song easy. Was a great show, indeed
@@th3gimp17 thanks man. Also, I dont really like to be rhat guy who advertises their Instagram, but in this case I just don't know any other way I could show the drawings. If you want you can see what 5 drawings I gave them on my Instagram channel- mark_061110. Or you could wait, I will post a short video on youtube of all the 5 drawing in a few days.
@@user-cj1pe6zb9s oh yeah, I was just busy doing a video of ranking all their songs from worst to best but it got blocked becauee to many songs. I thought it would be demonitized but it got blocked. I will post the drawings soon.
I think the main reason why they don't play a lot of the older songs is that Russel can't sing them anymore (at least in the current tuning). A Fools Paradise has a lot of high notes in the vocals so I guess it would be difficult for him to sing those reliably.
One of my favorite bands ever, SyX and DT are my top, they are amazing and I enjoy everything on their performance, Russell Allen the best metal voice period. But... I just cant understand how being such an amazing composer and guitar player Michael Romeo makes sloppy mistakes, it seems like he doesn't care much and hits wrong notes, I don't care if he don't play exactly as the song was recorded but hitting off key notes is another thing.
The perfect voice. The perfect guitar player. The perfect drum player. The perfect bass player. The perfect keyboard player. The perfect songs. Symphony X.
They deserve much bigger stages!
Very hardworking guys
Hell no, nothing better than a small venue
Russell is still one of the very best vocalists out there. So so good!
100% he's easily one the best ever
Reminds me of Steve Walsh (Kansas)... Nothing bad with that!
Yes ! .
Great souvenir of their French tour in 2003 .
indeed... the guy is a legend!
he is perfect for Symphony X. No one could replace him.
Most underrated band ever... They are just the music perfection. The perfect balance between pasion, melody, metal, technical. I fucking love them...
Russell is the absolute best vocalist in the world
It was even better than the studio version. His vocals is breathtaking. Thanks for the upload
Allen's voice is unreal. I couldn't believe my ears when I saw them. They're one of those rare bands that sound even BETTER live than on the album. I'm so pleased they're all still kicking and haven't missed a beat since the 90s. Incredible talent. I wish them all the best, and I'm gonna see them next chance I get.
The most underated band of all time.
Very underrated vocalist. I'd love to see these gentlemen and Dream Theater tour together. Maybe add Kamelot
there's a video where Russell Allen sings cemetery gates with dream theater.
Possibly my fav song of all time
Russell sounds awesome as always the whole band is tight.
The best metal band in the world!
So glad this song returns to the set list! Their best song since The Odyssey, along with Reign In Madness.
Some of Pinella's best work (piano) is found on this one!
What is the full set list this time?
Yes! Indeed... Go listen to The Vampires Opera. Give that your ears for a few. 👍👍💎
Don’t forget paradise lost!
Wow!! Amazing singer!! Actually, the whole band!!
Great performance on live! Big fan of Romeo's humble nature 😃👍
Yup Russell Allen has legendary pipes :D. Romeo is a fringing guitar wizard extraordinaire. Rest of the band equally crazy talented.
Russell Allen is a beast. What a voice!
His voice is just always perfect
Like everyone else I'm so glad to find this video. Looking forward to a new album.
What a band and Russel is just stellar…
That's the most beautiful live bass tone I've ever heard.
Just recently started listening to this band and HOLY SHIT, how have I not heard them play before? Instantly became one of my top favorite bands! I knew Russell from Mike Orlando's band Adrenaline Mob. So I heard them name years ago, but never got to listen. I'm doing a guest solo an a friends metal project and was looking for inspiration and some reason this band's name popped in my head (I think I was actually thinking of Racer X, but anyway). I was driving and asked Siri to play Symphony X and was hooked instantly.
That great man, if you just got onto them I suggest their song divine wings of tragedy
@@markrus6712 Adding it now
@@timjonesguitar let me know what you think after because I’m my opinion it is their best song
@@markrus6712 I would agree on that! that was great!
I'm seeing them in 2 weeks! 1st time seeing them live. Dream come true! So hyped!
I have seen them a few times. they never disappoint live,,,,,, you'll be even more hyped while and after you see them
The sound really great, its like soundboard audio
Russell always kill it
Yeah dude, agree
This band This song This performance 🧘🏻♀️
como el vino esta banda, un verdadero placer oírlos.
I saw them back in 2008 - they were unbelievable then... they just got better. TSO tuned this mans voice even more... god i love this band. Will be seeing them in New Haven this year.
Incredible live band
best prog metal band
Symphony X live = magic! They always deliver 🤘🏼
I don't know why, but I thought they had quit playing together. I'm the happiest to know that they're still active, I simply love the band! 🤘🤘
Saw them on this tour. Jason Rullo is such a beast
fuck yeah he is. LEGEND
Certainly a never 'underrated' band apart from the folk who think they are. Anyone who is anyone knows how supreme Symphony X are in this genre and also in a world of spotify/applemusic/youtube etc - they can still produce the goods thanks to the sheer professional musicianship and effort, over time that they have invested into their craft - I applaud their magnificent career /,,/
just the ones who has lost everything knows what this song means, thanks S X \m/
25+ years strong... and still #1.
Really enjoyed this !
@@brandydynamite5877 Nice! I am glad you checked it out! I think you are a Symphony-X fan now!
How the hell drummer remember all those notes? I listened rock songs more than 15 years now and symphony x is always be the first in my mind to listen to. I have entire album of them and this is one of the song that I liked the most. It's just a masterpiece.
In my top five .... Pure talent.
The best metal band ever back!!!
sin lugar a dudas una de las mejores versiones en vivo de este temazo nada que envidiarle a la version estudio aguante symphony x
I know its only 30secs.. but that is one beutiful intro.. mind blown Pinnella❤
Russell is amazing...goosebumps 😮
suena todo bonitoooooooo !!!!!!!!!!! great
Gosh, thanks for uploading this. One of my favourite SX songs, and I doubt I'll ever have a chance of seeing this live - this is as close as it'll get. Magnificent.
Have Russel ever shown this consistency, hitting all the notes, before? Seems like he's been practising like hell, impressive as f*ck!
He always has. I've seen them two times. Once opening for Blind Guardian in 2003 right after The Odyssey came out. I was impressed the live show was as tight at the album. Every note was there. I saw them in Albany in maybe 2008? Their encore was the entirety of The Odyssey. They played the entire song in a bar in front of maybe 120 people. They went THAT hard for that few people.
Great song! One of my favorites
Russell is So so good
Oh man so glad to see this song is still in their setlist
Russell still.....perfect.
🎶🤟🎶🤟🎶🎼one of the best song of my life..thanks a Lot SX
Russell never ceases to amaze. Beautiful voice and great technique.
I really like the guitarist style. He's got a unique mind! 👍⭐🤟
dude, the guy is a god damned kaiju-level monster on the guitar. mind blowing. he and the always amazing Micheal Pinnella did a cover of Rush's Analog Kid a long while back with no less than Jack Russel from Great White and freaking Mike Portnoy (Dream Theater), and they absolutely slayed that track. The solos in it are utterly face melting, he and Pinnella both.
WE NEED THE NEW ALBUM RIGHT NOW !!
I love this band ! 🤘❤
thanks for the upload man! great quality!
You go see Dream Theater for the musicians, not the signer. But Symphony X, damn... they really are the power of Five.
Totally agree - what’s so stupid is dream
Theater fans (and I was once myself) actually think that Labrie is awesome lol
@@shababrk LaBrie is tolerable, in studio. Live? Not so much. I've been listening since 1994, and have seen them twice, but never again. I wish Dream Theater had a singer like Russell Allen, or Nils K Rue, but it was never meant to be I guess.
@@Matts_Presentations yes live it’s horrible and it’s funny when fans try to defend him. I start thinking that dream theater fans have no taste in music haha
James Labrie lipsyncs parts nowdays.
SENSATIONAL!
Amazing.
Meus preferidos!
Speechless....
,,,,,...hats off...............Michael Romeao..............still on top
Might be time for them to make that live DVD/Blu-ray soon? I mean, we've waited long enough by now. :p
We've only been waiting on the Edge of Forever for a damn live DVD. This show would've been perfect for one...
Yes, they should just get it done already! Reccommend the ancient roman theater in plovdiv, where Sons of Apollo and Devin Townsend did some great concerts with a symphony orchestra. This band is made for this, imagine the accolade, odyssey, divine wings, Communion, Through the looking glass with a full orchestra and choir... in a roman amphitheater, in the city founded by Philip of Macedon
You rule! Looking forward to see you here in Rio de Janeiro!
Inmaculados sean y sean bendecidos por todos los Dios del reino del metal sus manos, sus dedos pieses y cuerdas vocales por los siglos y mileniuns AMEN !
You must immortalize a blu-ray show my good fellas
Awesome! Romeo RULEZZZZ
These are not musicians, they are magicians.
Russell rulezzz
Wow, this video was shot from a phone, but the band sound studio good! East coast prog metal rules!
yep, that shows the quality of this band live
This song is like a love letter to Kansas.
This band is ridiculous. Is it legal to sound this good live? Everyone is amazing, but holy shit that singer.
Can't wait to see them next month @HELLFEST !!!!
Уникальная команда, сложнейшие размеры в живую при таком четком исполнении не многим дано...!)
согласен!
K buenos son!!!
Michael Kiske & Russell Allen são os dois vocalistas que ao vivo, fazem justiça as versões de estúdio. Ambos até quando estão com a voz cansada são superiores a média. Pude ver o Kiske ao vivo com a voz sem estar 100% e vou te falar, o cara cantou melhor do que a maioria dos vocalistas do gênero mais jovens.
Sem dúvidas temos outros exemplos mas quer destacar esses dois.
Viva a esses gigantes.
It's so difficult to stand out in progressive metal....they do it. And wonderfully.
New album? 🙏 If it's in the cards. If not, I thank you guys for what you left us. Godspeed
Love war of the worlds 2...👊
i believe MR said in a current interview on youtube that he did start writing new songs for the new symphony x album but that they were going to take some time to record it. But it definitely is happening!
Thank you for posting this. Was there at the show with you -- this is my favorite SymX song of all time, and it moved me to tears! Unforgettable night.
Especially for me, since I handed them my drawing. Their reaction was priceless. Although I wanted to jump on stage and play sea of lies, they already played it and I cant play any of their other songs because muchael romeo doesn't make any song easy. Was a great show, indeed
@@markrus6712 oh sheeeeet you were that guy with the drawing!! Amazing man, cheers 🍻
@@th3gimp17 thanks man.
Also, I dont really like to be rhat guy who advertises their Instagram, but in this case I just don't know any other way I could show the drawings. If you want you can see what 5 drawings I gave them on my Instagram channel- mark_061110. Or you could wait, I will post a short video on youtube of all the 5 drawing in a few days.
@@markrus6712 Do you still think you will have time to post the video of the 5 drawings
@@user-cj1pe6zb9s oh yeah, I was just busy doing a video of ranking all their songs from worst to best but it got blocked becauee to many songs. I thought it would be demonitized but it got blocked. I will post the drawings soon.
Great
💪🏾😍😍😍😍
6:25 im just start walking throught another kind of dimension
The Stage is always too small and narrow setting for the Band like SimpX 🤔
That's true... I feel their stage should be all wireless. But i guess they need more PR for that
Please come to Brazil!
Rusell is still ripping it!
W Mans
🎵🎵🎵
8:05
All the band memners are masters but Jason rullo is a human metronome really.
The lackings of dream theater is symphony x
💪😡🎸🤘
🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
did they play "The Sacrifice" in this gig....
i hope they will someday, a song that filled the big gap in my life
No, they didn't. They played-
Nevermore
Evolution
Sea of lies
Serpents kiss
Run with the devil
When all is lost
Without you
The Oddysey
@@markrus6712 I wish they would add Fallen to their setlist from the V...The New Mythology CD. Such a great groove to that song!!
Micheal Romeo looks like he's gonna sing or eat the mic while he's playing his guitar solo lol
I wish I would have known, I would have bought a ticket
They will be in NJ on July so you still have a chance to attend. They are having a tour around different states
I'm waiting for A Fools paradise but it is will never happen
I think you they will not play other old album songs other than the ones they play now. Unfortunate, I would like to hear some damnation game songd
That's a great choice, I want the 2 right after that, Rediscovery part 1 and 2
There's just too many killer Symphony-X songs to try and narrow it down to a 2-hour show.
I think the main reason why they don't play a lot of the older songs is that Russel can't sing them anymore (at least in the current tuning). A Fools Paradise has a lot of high notes in the vocals so I guess it would be difficult for him to sing those reliably.
@@Ducktapejesus Happens to all of them. Halford got to a point where he couldn't do "Painkiller" anymore.
Yeah but Elegy Labyrinth of dreams aagh 😁
Is that James LaBrie on bass lol?
Michael Lepond, beast of bass
Is it 5th October or 10th May?
It was may
is there a new drummer?
No, the drummer is jason Rullo. He joined them in the year 2000, I think.
@@markrus6712He has played with them since the 1994 self-titled album
Taylor Swift lol
One of my favorite bands ever, SyX and DT are my top, they are amazing and I enjoy everything on their performance, Russell Allen the best metal voice period. But... I just cant understand how being such an amazing composer and guitar player Michael Romeo makes sloppy mistakes, it seems like he doesn't care much and hits wrong notes, I don't care if he don't play exactly as the song was recorded but hitting off key notes is another thing.
I just realised how bad the dream
Theater singer is