Myths You Shouldn't Believe About The Challenger Disaster
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 июн 2024
- The deadly failed launch of the Challenger space shuttle was one of the most shocking disasters in American history, but it didn't come out of nowhere. From faulty equipment to the fates of the astronauts, keep an eye out for these misleading myths.
#Myths #Challenger #Shuttle
Background information | 0:00
How they really died | 1:03
The explosion that wasn't | 1:55
Warning signs | 2:59
Asbestos ban | 4:10
The Reagan rush | 5:04
Main engine malfunction | 5:41
Ejection seats | 6:27
More than cold | 7:30
The astronauts were there | 8:23
Voiceover by: Tim Bensch
Read Full Article: www.grunge.com/1571634/myths-... 
Развлечения
![Moneybagg Yo - WHISKEY WHISKEY [feat. Morgan Wallen] (Official Audio)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kJamyq0WplE/mqdefault.jpg)
Rest in peace to those who died in the Challenger disaster.
This video inaccurately depicts what caused the breakup. The side mounted boosters were solid fuel rockets. The fuel inside them had the consistency of an eraser. This is not fuel that can leak. There was no fuel leak from three solid rocket booster. Rather the failure of the O rings allowed rocket exhaust to leak out the side like a blow torch and damage the mounting strut that attached the booster at the bottom allowing it to swing and thus tear the shuttle stack apart. Furthermore, the O rings were not "faulty," they were simply not designed to properly seal outside their designed temperature range. It was too cold. Morton Thiocol engineers knew that and they pleaded with NASA not to launch. NASA coerced Morton Thiocol management to sign off in the launch.
This is inaccurate, nobody signed off on the launch. The booster didn’t tear anything apart, aerodynamic pressure did. The fuel leaked while ignited. The tolerances of the joints were outside of the design. The booster leak punctured the tank causing the cryo fuel to loose pressure and the tank collapsed. You don’t know.
@@LTV_incrather than insult someone wouldn’t a real life discussion be sharing ideas and working to a shared understanding?
How’s anything made in this time period that even implies anything other than those o rings? Should be pulled for inaccuracy.
I was in 6th grade. A classmate was in the principals office and watched it live . He told us about it when he walked into the classroom, our teacher was in tears. I had to see it later that day to really believe it.
An now you're grown enough to know that you watched a movie on tv
They wheeled a television into my classroom. The whole school did this. We watched it live, and I'll never forget it.
It wasn’t just children watching it live on television, MANY children took a field trip to the beach to watch the launch. I had a boyfriend years ago who lived in Titusville and watched it from the beach. I’ve always wondered what kind of effect that would have on people.
Most schools had it on due to there being a teacher on board
Not a fuel leak; SRB exhaust gases leaked through the compromised o-rings and burned a hole in the external tank.
SRB exhaust gases indeed but the picture is complicated. The story I heard was that initially the exhaust gas residue, one component of which was aluminum oxide, formed a glassy seal over the leak which for a while contained the booster combustion pressure. Wind shear as the vehicle continued rising broke that seal, which had no flexibility, and caused the plume to blow out of the booster casing and impinge on the external tank and the strut holding the booster.
no....the plume from the failed SRB joint burned through the lower strut supporting the lower part of the booster....when the strut failed, the booster upper section punctured the tank causing the fuel to leak and create the big fire ball.
Richard Feynman confirmed this using a piece of O ring in ice water
"relatively few people tuned in live as it was actually happening"????
Practically every school age child in America watched it happen while in school. My entire school was gathered in the auditorium. It was a huge thing for NASA to coordinate with schools for children to watch this launch live
Especially with a teacher involved.
EXACTLY! I was one of those school kids, but we had early release that day for my grade. I remember watching this in the kitchen with my Grandmother and Sister, and the horror of what happened. My grandmother started crying. My sister was too young to understand. I'll never forget watching the explosion/break-up happen in real-time).
Anyway, this video has its own inaccuracies.... I'm surprised almost a month later is has a mere 41,243 views with 800 likes & 22 dislikes... people don't have time or the attention span for anything anymore. Instead of research and fact checking they spend time arguing on 'teh internets'... Even read through the comments on this video. There's people saying xyz in the video is wrong, then someone else replies and says no THEY are wrong about 123, and then someone else replies and says no you're both idiots; rinse & repeat.
Yay for the human race. (yeah this kind of turned into a rant... oops. Oh well).
I watched this live in 3rd grade when i lived in Idaho. Won't forget...
@1:55
Thank U for covering this. It’s always bugged me that the Challenger Disaster is continually described as an explosion. 💥
Seen it live in person on the playground at school..Then was forced to rewatch it a few dozens times on TV once we went back into the classroom..as they just continued to replay it over and over for the rest of the day..
You forgot to mention that you were forced into the indoctrination that anyone was on that model tou
While attending Mission San Jose Elementary school in Fremont, California, I can confirm that my school watched the launch on television via CNN and we saw it happen live after the explosion. The teacher immediately turned off the TV. We were ushered outside and we were sent home for the day.
I remember reading in Time magazine years before the accident that "it was an accident waiting to happen " US airforce safety report on the shuttle
The only crewed launch vehicle with zero abort or escape possibility.a thousand potential failure points that can only lead to complete catastrophe.
It should never have been considered an operational, production craft, but a highly risky experiment.
It held us back from getting anything happening in space, and is still holding us back with the SLS boondoggle.
I was in Kindergarten at Encanto Elementary School(San Diego Unified School District) in San Diego, CA when this disaster happened. After the explosion the tv was turned off and we were ushered outside to the playground. Neither me nor my classmates understood why the teachers were crying. All we understood was that it was time for recess. After seeing the events of 9/11 I fully understood the feelings of the teachers.
Thanks for sharing your memories with us, it must have been great growing up in San Diego.
Watched live on TV, very horrifying!
Very fake
@@David-cv1se what was very fake!?
@smadas4192 Isn't it obvious that no one was on that controlled explosion & neither you nor anyone else can physically prove otherwise
@@David-cv1se 🤡 🤡 🤡
@@David-cv1se ok david
My school was one who was showing a live broadcast, but I wasn’t watching it at the time it aired and heard about it right after it happened. Incredibly sad and we were all so excited for Christa to be part of the space mission. Rest in peace
We all watched it live on tv at my school. Many watched it live on tv.
I dont know your source for this video but im saying that they are wrong, and im sure your comment section will prove me correct
Funny, I just saw Dr Kirwin last week at a conference.
I was on 3rd grade watching in class and when the explosion happened my teacher walked over and turned the TV off and said nobody speaks yet we're going to pray for the souls of those folks and for their families then we can see what's happened. We did and she turned the TV back on and said anyone who wants to can go sit in the hall and read if their uncomfortable and not one of us moved. She did her best to try to explain what was going on as best she could and after awhile she said this has been a heavy day kids maybe we should go outside and write our thoughts out for a bit and then we can share them. We were kids we knew that we just watched people die most of us it was something we'd never experienced we had watched a bunch of live interviews that christa had done so it was like we kinda knew her and so it was a strange feeling. But Mrs Dumas handled it awesomely. One day I'll remember till I forget it
We were all watching"live" in the choir room. To say we were devastated would be a gross understatement. RIP
That wasn’t a photo of Mike Smith, and the pole and parachutes were adopted AFTER the Challenger accident.
I was in the 4th grade and we watched it live. As a boy I didn’t fully realize what had happened until my teacher explained it. A real shame that those kids had to watch their teacher pass like this. Additionally, it’s a real shame that NASA, One of the worlds most respected scientific organizations in the world would push aside and ignore such glaring warning just to push the launch through, sacrificing those brave people on the Challenger. It sadly shows what the government thinks of its people. R.I.P. to all of them.
I was in an Indiana elementary school and our school watched it on T.V sooooooo……..
Me too. I was in 1st grade in Indiana. Mrs. Underwood class.
I was one of the children that saw it live. Same with the twin towers (but that was on the news before I went to school when I saw it). Ya know, it just wasn’t easy being schooled back then.
I remember that day very well was in my senior year of high school we had a snow day off that day watching breaking news
I was at a laundry mat. Worse thing i ever watched. RIH
At the time I was a USAF active duty Range Control Officer (RCO). I remember it well. It was a very sad day. Think of the SRB segments like coke cans place one on top of the other only with a tang and Clovis. Take your right hand and make a V shape between your fingers and thumb. that’s the clevis. Place your thumb against the fingers on your left hand. That would be the tang that mates with the clevis. The stack is not rigid and it does flex during the launch sequence. When the SSMEs ignite the entire stack “kicks back” about 12 inches as I recall. When the stack swings comes back to about 12 O’clock, the SRBs ignite and off it goes. The SRB segments flex some during all this.
I was at home sick for some reason and watched it live. I just remember crying pretty much all day. So incredibly sad.
Watched live in school.
I was in VT grade school,
We all were loaded into the cafeteria and watched it on a VCR TV from the library,
They quickly huddled us back to the classroom to get back to school work to make us forget about what we saw.
Contrary to what this narrator is saying,
I was told many times this was one of the most watched shuttle launches because of the civilian teacher on board.
So, what you're saying about the O-rings is that they weren't defective, they were just being used in conditions that they weren't designed for. Also, it was an exhaust leak, not a fuel leak.
I was in kindergarten, the teachers had rolled one of those old tv’s into the room. I remember the horrified looks on all the teacher’s faces. And a bunch of young children that really had no idea what they were seeing. Crazy
I’m not aware of any mythos surrounding the Challenger disaster.
Most of the northeast US had a snow day that day. I feel like the numbers that watched it live are legit. The same cold fron that affected Florida dropped snow on the eastern seaboard
There were several different temperature criteria for the SRBs. Any analysis of a disaster tends to allow hindsight bias to creep in.
One little known fact is that the Challenger shuttle carried scientific equipment to observe Halley's Comet that year and since they didn't launch the next shuttle until years later, they missed that opportunity to get that data. Even though the comet was not as close as it has been for past trips around the sun, they would have had some great data from it had they not had the disaster. Now the next time Halley comes around will be in 2061 for those that are still around and this time it will be much closer to Earth than it was in 1986.
i was 13 at the time this happened. i was home from school that day. Where i lived all i had to is just walk outside my front door & watch it go up. for some unknown reason my brother was acting like an a-hole that day & refuse to let me go outside & watch it go up. later my mom called us & told what had happen. i was very pissed at my brother that day
Anyone have any idea how dangerous being an astronaut is? Just one little problem can lead to a disaster.
Well there have been three separate incidents where astronauts have died: the 1967 Apollo 1 fire which killed three astronauts, the space shuttle Challenger disaster in 1986 which killed seven astronauts, and the space shuttle Columbia incident in 2003 which killed seven astronauts. There's also the notable Apollo 13 incident where the crew almost didn't make it back. If one thing goes wrong with these spacecraft, whether it's a big or small issue, that could potentially lead to several things going wrong which could result in a catastrophic failure. Although being an astronaut today is safer to an extent, there's still a lot of risk involved. The environment of space is lethal without appropriate protection: the greatest threat in the vacuum of space derives from the lack of oxygen and pressure, although temperature and radiation also pose risks. The effects of space exposure can result in ebullism, hypoxia, hypocapnia, and decompression sickness.
Yet they wouldn’t have it any other way.
That one guys brother had an awesome name
Watched it live in class… watched it fall too long.
It was not fuel, but hot gasses that leaked from the starboard SRB.
I watched it live in my class 3rd grade we went wow nice fireworks
I have seen the data for all previous shuttle launches regarding the solid booster o-rings. Proper analysis clearly indicates the low temperatures were a major issue. The decision process used a subset of the data that gave an incorrect conclusion. Very sad.
A “Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly” or RUD
This was mostly the best video I have seen on this event. I was actually living on Merritt Island and I was sick and home from school. I went out to feed my rabbits oblivious of the launch and heard a neighbor Gasp in an adjacent yard. I turned to look and seen her looking behind me. I turned to see the Big round cloud with 2 rockets flying off. I thought to myself what a weird way to launch a rocket and I went in the house. When I got in the house My Mom, Dad and Brother were all looking at the tv screen with their mouths open. I got so I could get in view of our Hitachi TV in time for a replay. Then I knew what was happening. I noticed the nose of the shuttle coming off and quickly pointed it out. But being this close to the Space center I have had people close to the situation (mind you this was around 30 years ago and I have no way of connecting with them again as I have moved numbers changed and honestly only remember one name and he has passed) That they were friends of the dive team tasked with bringing the nose cone up. That the astronauts were out of their seats and they had not been ripped apart, The other disturbing thing was they were ordered to cut the nose cone up. But I do not remember hearing any explosion.. I remember a Delta that exploded over the launch site years later, I went out to see the launch and upon opening the door it got blown back by the shockwave of its explosion . So thinking back to that day .. I do not remember even a rocket rumble. But thank you for not ever saying the shuttle blew up you actually told it like it was.
Shame this kind of stuff is very dangerous risky business. But that's the fact of it at the end of the day. RIP
I was in high school symphonic band, and the announcement came over the PA system. Almost immediately our director insisted that we pick up our instruments and start playing again. There’s a reason we called him Mr. Potatohead. grrrr.
The shuttle design required it to be able to fly out of SLC-6 at Vandenberg Air Force Base, where the ambient temperatures are frequently below that at KSC on that day. During the final review before launch, NASA management SPECIFICALLY asked the booster manufacturer if their product met the requirements. They insisted it did. And this was BEFORE cell phones so the Thiokol engineers had no way to communicate with their management in the meeting.
Practically everything you said is wrong. The cold temperatures in Florida were record breaking lows that were not normal, and it is even less likely for the temperatures to get that low along the California coast. Morton-Thiokol discovered the problem with the o-rings over a year before the accident. They immediately brought their concerns to NASA. NASA engineers had several large presentations where the problems were openly shared with several different NASA divisions including upper management. NASA even degraded the O-Rings from a fail-safe component to a Critical-1 component meaning that a failure could lead to a catastrophic fatal accident, but NASA kept accepting the additional risks. The night before the launch there was a conference call between NASA management, Morton-Thiokol management, and engineers from both in which basically everyone except the upper management refused to sign-off on the launch. NASA management refused to accept the evidence as conclusive and basically bullied Morton-Thiokol management to sign off on the launch despite them specifically trying to stop the launch.
@nocalsteve- you are correct. I worked for Morton Thiokol chemical division and had heard about the problems with the boosters.
to had they didnt have pressure suits mightve a small change bailing out.but what would be worser bailing out or getting hammered withdiebry
Wow, no mention of Roger Boisjoly, who had he been able to prevent Challenger's launch, would have gone down as a national hero. Shame on you for omitting his name.
Here's a fact ill never forget
The Chicago bears was supposed to visit the white house that day after winning Superbowl 20
Rest in peace
You forgot the myth that NASA is professional, competent and knows what it's doing. It is a myth that the o-rings were faulty. They did their job under the stipulated conditions.
The biggest myth that I am getting sick of hearing is that the crew is still alive. What brain-dead conspiracy theorist (hmmm, isn't that a redundancy?) came up with that one?
Not only is it patently ridiculous, it's horribly disrespectful toward the astronauts' families and terribly intrusive to the real people who keep being hounded by morons with questions like, "Weren't you on the space shuttle?"
It was rocket blast not fuel that leaked.
I watched it live at home I was 10 years old when it blew up I said what a piece of crap and changed the channel to watch looney tunes cartoons
I remember whatching it on tv in newzealand , diffently a oh shit moment for every one across the globe interested and or invested the space race ( for want of a better word)
Very sloppy writing.
There's no "liquid fueled rocket" in the STS stack. There's a fuel tank, and that feeds the main engines on the orbiter.
And the accident wasn't caused by a fuel leak. It was caused by exhaust gasses from the solid rocket boosters burning through an o-ring, and then destroying the lower mounting point for the SRB. When that came loose, the SRB crashed into the external fuel tank, and that's what made the "fireball".
The 'o' rings were NOT faulty. They were used improperly.
NASA knew there was a issue during accent snd could have aborted but didnt
What myths???
How could you get so much, so wrong?
Fuel leak from the SRBs?
Ni, there never was thought of shutting them off mid-use. It wasn't and isn't possible. There is no abort possible while those boosters were firing.
Where did you get that nonsense?
wtf? Those orings were not faulty. They operated ass intended. They operate above a temperature at a minimum of 39 degrees. They exceeded tolerance therefore they used components outside of there design tolerance that’s NASA issue. Don’t say faulty orings.
The rings were not, "faulty". Just one of the many stupid errors in this video.
Good thing that Big Bird didn’t die!
You didn’t see the two UFOs I did
Both Challenger and Columbia were cursed missions.
Yes is it
Not a terrible video from one of these generic looking channels. That doesn't happen often
You talk about all the conspiracies that are out there. And that's all you're doing, just one more person adding to the pile of conspiracies, bringing it as facts just like everybody else Thanks..
More lies
@8:58 "generates a new mystery regarding the whereabouts of original Claude" - fuck me, never underestimate the ignorance and stupidity of conspiracy theorist, cult members or anyone or anything MAGA.
121st
Actually they all survived. Before they censored RUclips they actually found the people and they talked to them four of them said it was their identical twin that was on that plane craft..whatever.
Lies. Why would they have twins instead of the actual person? And what would RUclips or its censors have to do with any new organization just going and interviewing them?
I mean, you just claimed they are living their lives out in the open, right?
@@kitcanyon658 what would the chances be of four of them even having identical twins is my point. Look into the censorship of RUclips and things that used to be on it if possible there was a lot of evidence about a lot of different things
@@Mike-cc3jw : But the videos you choose to get your information are lying to you. None of them had identical twins.
Be harder not to be fooled.
As I said before, RUclips isn't the only source of information. Who told you that it is?
@@kitcanyon658 I know they didn't... That's what they said when the people were found. Look up Judith resnick that was the teacher
They had to come up with something so I guess that was the best excuse they could come up with
The state of union was delayed due to the challenger accident. Christa McAuliffe was scheduled to have a call with the president during the state of union later that day from space. Only after the accident happened that Reagan delayed it by one week.
How much did the president and the state of union affected NASA’s decision to launch that morning?
I don’t know but it was definitely in NASA manager’s mind when they decided to overrides the engineer and launch that morning.
If you are to make a factual video about a significant topic I suggest you do your research properly first… this video contains so many inaccuracies it is painful to watch
Oi you! A video to dispel myths but your wording "Faulty O Rings" is erroneous. Following that gaff you then finish with -....."made by Morton Thiokol." That is truly insulting and highly disrespectful. It's also really lazy, at best. That is all. Hopefully.
Learn to write.
what would be weird, and kinda cool is .....
...... with all this "mandala effect" stuff going around ........
......... to find out that the shuttle was not manned at all ......
..... and maybe THAT was why it exploded ..
... no one aboard, to adjust the fuel pressure,
and thrust over pressure, to compensate for
..... something ....
..... and because of that ......
... boom!
💥
or better still
it never actually happened
it was a AI / CGI experiment
(fake news)
🙂🙃🙂
😁
🤣
Capricorn one