Criticising the monarchy and horse use on live TV

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 апр 2023
  • 🌱 If you find my work valuable, you can become a regular supporter or make a one-off contribution through the following link (thank you!): earthlinged.org/support
    📚 Order my best-selling book This is Vegan Propaganda (& Other Lies the Meat Industry Tells You) here: earthlinged.org/orderbook
    🎤 Organise a speech at your workplace or university: earthlinged.org/contact
    ♻️ Shop my ethical clothing brand I.D.E.A. Studios: weareideastudios.com/
    TODAY'S VIDEO:
    In today's video I rejoin Patrick in the GB News studio to debate the royal family and their use of animals for the coronation of King Charles. In particular we discuss Camilla's ivory sceptre and their use of horses for the event. Is this all just woke liberal outrage or is there a deeper issue at play that isn't political or even just about the royal family, but is instead about tradition and how we view animals more generally?
    MY PRODUCTION SET UP:
    How I get my copyright free music (get 2 extra months free): bit.ly/3DASdmH
    Where I get aesthetic copyright free footage (get 2 extra months free): bit.ly/3S8NA7t
    ☄️ Connect:
    Instagram: / earthlinged
    TikTok: / earthlinged
    Facebook: / earthlingedpage
    🎙️ Full Disclosure Podcast:
    / earthlinged
    #GBNews #Woke #RoyalFamily

Комментарии • 757

  • @ed.winters
    @ed.winters  Год назад +296

    In today's video I rejoin Patrick in the GB News studio to debate the royal family and their use of animals for the coronation of King Charles. In particular we discuss Camilla's ivory sceptre and their use of horses for the event. Is this all just woke liberal outrage or is there a deeper issue at play that isn't political or even just about the royal family, but is instead about tradition and how we view animals more generally?
    - If you find my work valuable, you can become a regular supporter or make a one-off contribution through the following link (thank you!): earthlinged.org/support
    - Order my best-selling book This is Vegan Propaganda (& Other Lies the Meat Industry Tells You) here: earthlinged.org/orderbook

    • @ReverendDr.Thomas
      @ReverendDr.Thomas Год назад

      Any system of government, other than MONARCHY, including democracy (and, of course, socialism) is the most pernicious institution in the history of the planet.
      Email me for the explanation (my address is on my RUclips homepage). 📧

    • @joshuataylor3550
      @joshuataylor3550 Год назад +5

      I think he agrees with you.

    • @v.a.n.e.
      @v.a.n.e. Год назад +1

      we all know where ivory comes from, but elephants? there are no elephants of UK origin. why doesn't Ed address that question?

    • @LouisGedo
      @LouisGedo Год назад +7

      *Create a Better 🌎 and a Better You by.................Living Vegan* 💜

    • @LouisGedo
      @LouisGedo Год назад +4

      Awesome discussion......... SHARING

  • @matthiashavrez
    @matthiashavrez Год назад +715

    I think it's cool that you have the opportunity to talk about veganism on tv, and with a host that frames it as an interesting discussion, rather than being dismissive and insulting (yeah, I'm referring to Morgan)

    • @garibaldi54
      @garibaldi54 Год назад +30

      He's not though, they're using petty issues such as this to distract from the real issue of 80bn animals suffering in farms and slaughterhouses.

    • @Johny40Se7en
      @Johny40Se7en Год назад +19

      Yeah, Patrick Christys seems like a decent news presenter. Respectful and willing to just have an open discussion without any bullshit. The way he asks questions to Ed too, it allows Ed to speak more freely about the important stuff. Clever.

    • @discursion
      @discursion Год назад

      Can we even call Morgan a host? He’s just a shill for shitty industries.

    • @cazzawazzadingdong5139
      @cazzawazzadingdong5139 Год назад +20

      @@garibaldi54 Calm open discussions is how Ed is able to plant seeds. Notice how Ed said animals (mostly) and not elephant. I do not share your idea that elephant ivory is a "petty issue" nor do I see every fish or chicken, cow or pig having their heads cut off as a petty issue either. Each animal should be fought for.
      OP. mealy stated that it's great that ED has such a great platform, and then compared patrick to other presenters...Yes, Patrick defaults to the programming that 99% of vegans also had prior to becoming vegan. The difference is that contrary to Morgan who gets defensive, cuts Ed off, shouts over the top of Ed, belittles Ed, and justifies his fallacy is fact, Patrick is calm and composed and allows for an open discussion and the planting of seeds.... Big difference!

    • @garibaldi54
      @garibaldi54 Год назад +2

      @@cazzawazzadingdong5139 It is a petty issue, many people would be open to the discussion of 80bn sentient lives suffering and being killed (although many also wouldn't). But in comparison the average person would think that a woman holding a ceremonial object thats centuries old, or even guards men using horses in a once in a lifetime traditional ceremony is not a big deal. Certainly not something important with the current state of things in the world.
      Its basically GBnews trying to say 'look at these stupid vegans getting upset over the slightest little thing concerning animals'.
      Its the same as with the 'screaming tomatoes' they wanted to downplay the whole issue and make it seem ridiculous.

  • @garethholmes
    @garethholmes Год назад +408

    Patrick has been refreshingly open in each interview you’ve done with him. I’m pleasantly surprised that he has taken the time to ask useful questions and considers the answers.

    • @JP-sm4cs
      @JP-sm4cs Год назад +12

      Given he's a GB news presenter that just makes me suspicious

    • @chriscrumly
      @chriscrumly Год назад

      @@JP-sm4cs Patrick - The vegan mocking GBNews presenter previously seen swigging down his pint of milk in the face of the PETA activist. Even if it was just done to please their far right, antivegan, 'antiwoke', (etc) viewership - I agree that your quite right to be suspicious. Back pedalling to try and save their channel maybe?

    • @ThepPixel
      @ThepPixel Год назад +14

      ​@@JP-sm4cs I think GB News are actually pretty good at getting opposing views on the show, Im a staunch corbyn supporter who usually watches Novara Media but I think the fact GB News gets people on like Ed or Aaron Bastani etc and gives them fair time to speak is commendable. Its a shame people like Dan Wooton are on the channel because hes an absolute slime ball in my opinion, but some of the other presenters are at least sincere and willing to hear opposing views.

    • @unvaccinated6467
      @unvaccinated6467 Год назад

      @@ThepPixel what's wrong with Dan Wotton?

    • @ThepPixel
      @ThepPixel Год назад

      @@unvaccinated6467 hes a fucking slime ball...

  • @d-k-1
    @d-k-1 Год назад +276

    Not gonna lie, Patrick is pretty rational and is totally unlike other mainstream media.

    • @51gan788
      @51gan788 Год назад +25

      He's only acting reasonable because he knows hes talking to someone who knows what they're talking about

    • @gamegirl949
      @gamegirl949 Год назад +43

      I just don't see it. He seems to act like any other host: Going for the baiting, sensationalist questions like 'do you dislike the royal family,' and 'do you think using ivory makes someone a bad person?' Then, when presented with Ed's question of 'does tradition make morality?' he doesn't answer it at all, and instead, ignores the entire premise of the scepter controversy, which is the symbology, and says basically, 'it's just an old object, why should we care?' In this context, he also comes off as the type of person who won't absorb new information and change his stance, despite how articulate the opposition is, as evidenced by his last bit to Ed: 'the oil used happens to be vegan! Does that negate everything you've argued against today?'
      In my opinion, the only thing that distinguishes him from someone like Piers Morgan is that he actually gives Ed a chance to talk without interruption, which should be the bare minimum of human decency. I don't think it makes him particularly exceptional. If anyone deserves praise, it's Ed for making a public stand for a position that is vilified by society, and does it in the kindest, but impactful way.

    • @Tofu_va_Bien
      @Tofu_va_Bien Год назад +9

      I'll admit, he's pretty good at his job as far as interviewing is concerned, but at the end of the day, his job is still to be the mouthpiece for a very right-leaning news network. Most of the time news anchors and the like aren't earnestly expressing their own opinions about a given figure or event, the statements they make and the questions they ask are planned in advance by the network. For example, Tucker Carlson is privately very anti-Trump but you'd never know this if you only ever watched his show.

    • @slandersir7255
      @slandersir7255 Год назад

      He's a fascist propagandist and apparently, it's working on you.

    • @peacelovevegankpop
      @peacelovevegankpop Год назад +1

      He is really good at avoiding questions though

  • @Taiyedman
    @Taiyedman Год назад +117

    I love the interviews between you two. He seems open towards these talks.

  • @amanvermalh
    @amanvermalh Год назад +57

    This guy is a living embodiment of morality and compassion. Everytime he debates with someone, I have never heard anything other than just the perfect answers from him. Thank you so much for what you do for animals.

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      He failed to prevent pork chops 🥩🍖🥩🥩🥩🥩🐖🐖🐖🐖🐖🐖 and chicken drumsticks 🍗🐓🐔🍗🍗 from appearing on my plate he is a looooooooooooooooooooooooser.

  • @wilmavuokkoramone
    @wilmavuokkoramone Год назад +73

    You two should get a regular segment on air! Can't wait for the inevitable day when Patrick turns vegan because of being around Ed.

    • @Loveartmusic123
      @Loveartmusic123 Год назад +4

      💯Totally agree & have been thinking the same🙏🏼

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      While 8 billion people living worldwide have high demand on animal meat 🥩🍖🥩🐖🐖🐖🐖🐖.

  • @cIeetz
    @cIeetz Год назад +175

    The fact that they are willing to have You back in the studio just shows they know You are the truth. Alot of people who work at networks like this dont even want to be unjust and bear false witness, they just got tied into something that was over their head and now they are in too deep. Letting people like You speak on their platform I would imagine is a means for them to do right and pave a way for positive change. Maybe I'm naïve in thinking so, but I do like the thought.

    • @slandersir7255
      @slandersir7255 Год назад

      GB News do not have people on because they know they're speaking the truth.

    • @garibaldi54
      @garibaldi54 Год назад +2

      You are naive, when are they going to give him the same platform to discuss the real issue here?

    • @fairystride449
      @fairystride449 Год назад +6

      @@garibaldi54 well that’s rude. Baby steps. Yes it sucks he’s not focusing on the main issue, although he did the last time technically, but he’s able to nudge into it still, and it’s a possibility for the future.

    • @shermansadventure1151
      @shermansadventure1151 Год назад +4

      Usually it's the exact opposite of that - if somebody is a proponent for truth, they are not allowed anywhere near mainstream media outlets.

    • @ivanmalinovski7807
      @ivanmalinovski7807 Год назад

      Nah fam, they are willing to bring him back in the studio because he garners views. Whether he's right (which he is) is irrelevant.

  • @TomFegredo
    @TomFegredo Год назад +7

    Absolute solid balls of steel going on GB News to have this conversation. I'd absolutely bottle it

  • @rubyflowersx
    @rubyflowersx Год назад +71

    'Tradition is the enemy of progress' 💚🌱💚

    • @sofnaji
      @sofnaji Год назад +2

      In its extreme yes. In small doses it can inspire progress. For example in preserving cultural artefacts (music, art, etc.) from tradition. But I see his general point and I agree in general. Not that my opinion matters lol.

    • @discursion
      @discursion Год назад +2

      In that context. Not in every context.

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      In your dreams.

  • @Gaming_Vegan_Ape
    @Gaming_Vegan_Ape Год назад +98

    Ed, you never disappoint. You're always getting what we're thinking across so articulate.

    • @rondarkman.
      @rondarkman. Год назад

      She is good

    • @youtubehatesfreespeech2555
      @youtubehatesfreespeech2555 Год назад

      But he doesn't care about the cruelty of Nature! He cares about humans who are causing suffering although humans evolved from Nature. It's not my fault my interests are in conflict with the interests of other humans or animals. Isn't that Nature's fault? Why should the person liking Ivory be bad? Because we exploit animals? We exploit one another all the time, we all use everything we can so we can advance our interests. That's the fundamental principle of Nature. Why does he choose to blame people considering that's a symptom, it's not the cause of the problem? Does he want to address the problem or does he want to point fingers? Nobody chose to have the interests they have.

  • @dalnoke9928
    @dalnoke9928 Год назад +55

    Wow, you nailed every sentence in this quick-paced no-room-for-hesitation format (I would be so stressed)! I‘m very proud and happy that we have you to represent the vegan community. Thank you, Ed, and well done! 👏🏼💚

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      Nailed it or failed to convert carnivores into Veganism 😆🤣🤣.

    • @dalnoke9928
      @dalnoke9928 Год назад +2

      @@donolonisa5787 is this what you do all day? What a sad life

  • @leeduli
    @leeduli Год назад +153

    Earthling Ed has been instrumental in teaching me about veganism and ethics. Keep up the great work!

    • @rondarkman.
      @rondarkman. Год назад

      She is also a great representative for the trans community

    • @youtubehatesfreespeech2555
      @youtubehatesfreespeech2555 Год назад

      That's very bad!
      But he doesn't care about the cruelty of Nature! He cares about humans who are causing suffering although humans evolved from Nature. It's not my fault my interests are in conflict with the interests of other humans or animals. Isn't that Nature's fault? Why should the person liking Ivory be bad? Because we exploit animals? We exploit one another all the time, we all use everything we can so we can advance our interests. That's the fundamental principle of Nature. Why does he choose to blame people considering that's a symptom, it's not the cause of the problem? Does he want to address the problem or does he want to point fingers? Nobody chose to have the interests they have.

    • @meowinde
      @meowinde 8 месяцев назад

      @@youtubehatesfreespeech2555 lol you trolls

    • @youtubehatesfreespeech2555
      @youtubehatesfreespeech2555 8 месяцев назад

      @@meowinde that's usually the reply people give when their religion is challenged in a way they can't respond.

  • @therebelle66
    @therebelle66 Год назад +38

    It's rare to see such nice discussions on tv, great job Ed

  • @SweetPotatoTyler
    @SweetPotatoTyler Год назад +27

    Dude how is Ed so on point with his responses?

  • @MattyJTri
    @MattyJTri Год назад +244

    Such a well spoken individual, what you do for animals is truly unprecedented. Logical reasoning wins every time, thank you Ed 🌱

    • @rondarkman.
      @rondarkman. Год назад

      Eating the animals saves them

    • @peachesmcgee4795
      @peachesmcgee4795 Год назад +7

      ​@@rondarkman. grow up

    • @youtubehatesfreespeech2555
      @youtubehatesfreespeech2555 Год назад

      But he doesn't care about the cruelty of Nature! He cares about humans who are causing suffering although humans evolved from Nature. It's not my fault my interests are in conflict with the interests of other humans or animals. Isn't that Nature's fault? Why should the person liking Ivory be bad? Because we exploit animals? We exploit one another all the time, we all use everything we can so we can advance our interests. That's the fundamental principle of Nature. Why does he choose to blame people considering that's a symptom, it's not the cause of the problem? Does he want to address the problem or does he want to point fingers? Nobody chose to have the interests they have.

    • @rondarkman.
      @rondarkman. Год назад +2

      @@peachesmcgee4795
      I did nice and strong from animal products

    • @uhjeff3651
      @uhjeff3651 Год назад

      @@peachesmcgee4795 drink your milk and you'll grow up to be strong and seksy like me

  • @officialasa
    @officialasa Год назад +144

    Hopefully ppl keep getting you on these big platforms. You’re probably the best representative for the vegan movement I’ve ever seen.

    • @rondarkman.
      @rondarkman. Год назад

      A malnourished trans woman ?

    • @TryingtoTellYou
      @TryingtoTellYou Год назад

      Yes, he is a compelling reason NOT to be vegan lol.

    • @A_Foolish_Arrangement
      @A_Foolish_Arrangement Год назад +7

      ​@@TryingtoTellYou why ? Because he is articulate, polite, respectful and right ?

    • @TryingtoTellYou
      @TryingtoTellYou Год назад

      @@A_Foolish_Arrangement He certainly is polite. He's not right lol.

    • @childno.5-199
      @childno.5-199 Год назад +2

      100% Asa, Ed is the best advocate for veganism I have ever come across too.

  • @citruscomb
    @citruscomb Год назад +32

    You handle yourself so incredibly well. I could spot so many times I would have stumbled over, so many questions that are easy to fall into a trap with, but you navigated all of it absolutely seamlessly. Your way of conducting yourself is so impressive to me.

  • @BringYerOwnBomb
    @BringYerOwnBomb Год назад +25

    The royal family using ivory signals it as a symbol of power and prestige, which is exactly what fuels demand for black market ivory.

  • @davidcrosier2761
    @davidcrosier2761 Год назад +14

    Great that Ed was invited back. With the screaming tomatoes topic I had the impression that they thought they would be able to mock vegans with some stupid arguments about plants suffering just like animals... But Ed turned the tables in that discussion.
    This time it was much more respectful from the start, which is quite an achievement for this TV station...

  • @30daymissionman
    @30daymissionman Год назад +45

    Ed needs to be a regular on that channel

  • @Pjvenom1985
    @Pjvenom1985 Год назад +53

    Great job Ed, solid points an eloquently put fair play.🌱💚🐘🌅☘️

    • @ReverendDr.Thomas
      @ReverendDr.Thomas Год назад +2

      Great and lowly are RELATIVE. 😉
      Incidentally, Slave, are you VEGAN? 🌱

    • @Pjvenom1985
      @Pjvenom1985 Год назад +2

      @@ReverendDr.Thomas I am indeed.🌱 Have a wonderful weekend.🌅

  • @worsey55555
    @worsey55555 Год назад +10

    Let’s not forget the bear skin hats that the guards wear! Disgusting

    • @sugarplumk2381
      @sugarplumk2381 Год назад

      Are they still, or faux?

    • @worsey55555
      @worsey55555 Год назад

      @@sugarplumk2381 according to Google yeah!

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      The battle of Waterloo will always be remembered by the guards outfits.

  • @BeeCHee87
    @BeeCHee87 Год назад +12

    Ed, you are a gift to all us vegans. We are so lucky to have someone so erudite, thoughtful, and intelligent representing us!

  • @StarWonder
    @StarWonder Год назад +17

    The vegan argument is inarguable! All paths of kindness, peace, compassion, love, affection, gentleness, happiness, enlightenment & enjoyment lead to Vegan

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      Can he prevent lamb chops 🥩🍖🥩🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑 from appearing on my plate.

  • @JL-zm6md
    @JL-zm6md Год назад +9

    Wow it's great to see they wanted you back on for another productive interview. Hope this continues!

    • @garibaldi54
      @garibaldi54 Год назад

      Hmm, not really, they dont want to discuss the real issue here, they're using these topics to distract from that and make vegans look petty.

    • @Loveartmusic123
      @Loveartmusic123 Год назад

      💯❤️🙏🏼🌱🌏🌟

  • @BlueSkyLtd.
    @BlueSkyLtd. Год назад +7

    Important topic! 🕊 Thank-you for this interview! Thank-you to your guest!
    PROTECT ANIMALS FROM EXPLOITATION🕊

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      Ed failed to prevent roasted Chickens 🍗🐓🐔🍗🍗🐓🐔🍗🍗 from appearing on my plate.

  • @ReasonMakes
    @ReasonMakes Год назад +6

    That host is a breath of fresh air

  • @clarecurtis36
    @clarecurtis36 Год назад +16

    Thank you for this really great discussion. Ed, you are such a calm, vegan educator and I really appreciate the host Patrick for being open and willing to listen to different points of view than his own. This is progress in my mind.

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      A progress that failed to convert 8 billion Meat eater's worldwide into Veganism.

  • @GoVeganForTheAnimal
    @GoVeganForTheAnimal Год назад +10

    Very much agreed, it is outdated to exploit animals for some trinket, the elephants wish to keep their ivory and not be murdered for someone to have a scepter. No reason to continue using something that reminds everyone how cruel the monarchy has historically been to animals.
    Time for a new future for the monarchy, one of good moral values. A monarchy that respects all life whether human or nonhuman.

    • @v.a.n.e.
      @v.a.n.e. Год назад +1

      are you also in favor of restoring independence for all the fourteen countries that are still under the control of the monarchy?

    • @GoVeganForTheAnimal
      @GoVeganForTheAnimal Год назад +5

      @@v.a.n.e. I don't see why not, I don't know much about them except that they regularly abuse animals for tradition and entertainment

    • @v.a.n.e.
      @v.a.n.e. Год назад

      @@GoVeganForTheAnimal
      I just wanted to make sure if you are one of the colonizing heirs. it seems that some members of noble families fight against the exploitation of animals, but not for the enslaved countries. so, you're something else; you nevertheless chose to abuse a different species of life

    • @Shsjier
      @Shsjier Год назад +1

      ​@@pacmanmcgavin7034 aww you learnt some big words. Well done

    • @Shsjier
      @Shsjier Год назад +1

      @@pacmanmcgavin7034 sorry I didnt realise you're literally a child.

  • @sunwukong6897
    @sunwukong6897 Год назад +9

    That bit about the anointing oil was cute

    • @Shsjier
      @Shsjier Год назад

      It was fcking stupid

  • @WeTheVegans
    @WeTheVegans Год назад +15

    Articulate and impressive. I’ll say it again, well done Ed. Thank you.

  • @ElliottPiano
    @ElliottPiano Год назад +9

    Turned me vegan and my girlfriend 3 years ago.
    Best decision ever

    • @unvaccinated6467
      @unvaccinated6467 Год назад

      I started eating meat again 3 years ago, my 2nd best decision ever

    • @kayleemarie1901
      @kayleemarie1901 Год назад

      @@unvaccinated6467 ok….? Good on you for going back to abusing animals I guess?

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад +1

      Being vegan was a big mis steak 🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩 😆😆🤣🤣😆🤣😆🤣🤣🤣😆.

  • @elliotfowler654
    @elliotfowler654 Год назад +1

    Earthling Ed once again answers every question in a calm, informative, and eloquent manner, to the likes of which I can only dream. Respect to Patrick also. It's refreshing to see Ed debating with a host that allows him time to respond rather than interrupting with a shotgun blast of questions.

  • @Ds92817
    @Ds92817 Год назад +5

    Jeez Ed, you’re an absolute superstar.
    Thank you, for being our voice. I’m happy to say I love you like a brother, please never stop doing what you do.
    Edited also to add; Patrick is really open and helpful to these conversations. He clearly doesn’t know as much about the subjects as Ed, as he’s often looking at his laptop, but that’s to be expected given how much he has to cover each day. I just want to applaud and appreciate him for giving Ed a chance to speak and be our voice. Thank you both x

  • @lemonyknit8509
    @lemonyknit8509 Год назад +4

    I love, love love listening to this guy. He is a drop of pure common sense in a sea of absurdity. Calm, polite, sensible and ethical, we need more like him. Give him his own chat show please.

  • @yanamclaughlin1644
    @yanamclaughlin1644 Год назад +9

    This television announcer is funny, I like him. Every time I hear about the screaming tomatoes I crack up. Also Ed Winters FOREVER!!!

  • @therebelle66
    @therebelle66 Год назад +25

    Thank you from the bottom of our hearts for everything you're doing as part of the vegan movement
    Ed you're truly an inspiration to us all

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      An inspiration that failed miserably to convert 8 billion people worldwide into Veganism.

  • @leaderence3290
    @leaderence3290 Год назад +6

    There is no time to waste. Our planet is being destroyed and animal agriculture is the main cause of just about every issue we face from deforestation to world hunger. Even researchers at Oxford University, after doing an extensive study of over 40,000 farms, concluded that animal agriculture is so environmentally destructive: GOING VEGAN IS THE BEST WAY TO SAVE THE PLANET.

  • @redpenink12
    @redpenink12 Год назад +9

    Good to see you back on that show again!

  • @kieranstyx3633
    @kieranstyx3633 Год назад +2

    This interviewer is extremely refreshing when it comes to veganism. Doesn't waste you or his viewers time with rediculous theatrics or insults and actually engages honestly with genuine interest and legitimate questions.

  • @sarahbenn1792
    @sarahbenn1792 Год назад +3

    Whenever I am in the depths of despair at man's cruelty, selfishness and stupidity, I take comfort from Ed showcasing the very best of humanity- compassion, humility, determination and the ability to articulate truth. Thank you once again Ed for all that you do.

  • @maiqueashworth
    @maiqueashworth Год назад +6

    You say "how it's viewed on the national stage" actually it's international. And I think this is a really important point. People with money across the world will look at these objects and think "that's nice, I want one of those, or I could make something even nicer". The world we live in is driven by influencers, and the royal family are huge influencers. If she carries this sceptre it will almost certainly drive the international ivory trade.

  • @Fit4life_71
    @Fit4life_71 Год назад +10

    Let's not forget Philip the kings father hunting elephants rhino lions etc in fact he's known to have personally wiped out thousands of animals and gloat and pose over at least one dead mother elephant by his gun for a photo
    ..with her baby nearby watching...

    • @rebelvgan4579
      @rebelvgan4579 Год назад

      Jesus Christ 🤢 they are a pretty vile lot.

    • @unvaccinated6467
      @unvaccinated6467 Год назад

      Animals also kill other animals while the rest of the herd watches, its nature deal with it, humans are also animals

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      Hannibal Barca left the chart.

  • @flyingfig12
    @flyingfig12 Год назад +4

    Happy to hear that the oil is vegan and seeing Earthling Ed
    asked to come back to comment... great job!
    donate the ivory to a museum already!!!

  • @Vegan_Gt
    @Vegan_Gt Год назад +12

    It is essential to obtain animal rights, only then will we be able to stop animal abuse.

    • @v.a.n.e.
      @v.a.n.e. Год назад

      even if the animals had all the rights, you have no right to stop anything

    • @v.a.n.e.
      @v.a.n.e. Год назад

      Hi, @@mariamerigold that's right, thanks for noticing! I actually like this pleasant ambient

    • @Vegan_Gt
      @Vegan_Gt Год назад

      @@pacmanmcgavin7034
      No seas idiota, nuestra dieta es consumir NUTRIENTES, te lo vuelvo a repetir 🔁 NUTRIENTES!!, necesitamos nutrientes y no carne 🥩 animal.
      Infórmate más...
      Y claro que es abuso, al menos que seas un subnormal.
      Un saludo.

    • @Vegan_Gt
      @Vegan_Gt Год назад

      @@v.a.n.e.
      Pues el futuro es vegano, y tarde o temprano conseguiremos sus derechos. Y cuando tengan sus derechos ya no será tan fácil abusar de ellos.
      Y claro que tengo derecho de parar un Abuso, si no fuera así entonces de que sirve ser racionales?

    • @Shsjier
      @Shsjier Год назад +1

      ​@@pacmanmcgavin7034 natural diet? You mean meat wrapped in plastic bought from a supermarket? 😂

  • @Lowequay
    @Lowequay Год назад +2

    Great to these open conversations about what’s often used as an inflammatory topic.

  • @FixdalOK
    @FixdalOK Год назад +6

    The interviewer is so sweet.

  • @sharoncrowley304
    @sharoncrowley304 4 месяца назад +1

    You are so eloquent Ed - thank you for everything you do for the animals. It’s not easy talking to a brick wall….bur somehow you keep going. 💚

  • @PooPooBanana2
    @PooPooBanana2 Год назад +4

    Ed, you continue to be an absolute HERO

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      A hero who failed miserably to prevent pork chops 🥩🍖🥩🐖🐖 and chicken drumsticks 🍗🐓🐔🍗 from appearing on my plate.

  • @kennethsmith5309
    @kennethsmith5309 Год назад +4

    Ed- you walk the line well and I think you come across quite likeable to the average person on this broadcast. No doubt planting countless seeds!
    Well done and I hope they continue to have you on their program.

    • @Loveartmusic123
      @Loveartmusic123 Год назад

      🙏🏼🌱🙏🏼🌱🙏🏼🌱🙏🏼🌱🙏🏼

  • @diesusi3844
    @diesusi3844 Год назад +2

    My respect to both of you 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

  • @minaariel8288
    @minaariel8288 Год назад

    I love it that you are invited again , BUT not surprised . You speak with knowledge , elegance and fluency . There is not a trace of defensiveness . Truly a master ! You bring only pride to all of us vegans. Patrick is smart for inviting you again, you make the show worth watching .

  • @fran.mateus
    @fran.mateus Год назад +9

    Hey Ed, may I ask how did you learn and became so proficient in stating your points and arguments, because it always impresses me how well you articulate your points. Was it all experience or were you taught? And how can we be better at debating too?

    • @Maccalad
      @Maccalad Год назад +2

      He said he wasnt much of a public speaker or debater in school but hes in coming up on 10 years of like daily practice at this point 😂 love Ed and his way with words

    • @najsmusic7611
      @najsmusic7611 Год назад +1

      It comes with consistent practice and reading well-written literature, I think.

  • @ronpepoli37
    @ronpepoli37 Год назад +1

    Glad Eds getting a platform
    Tradition is no excuse for animal abuse/use 💚

  • @fionamacleod30
    @fionamacleod30 Год назад +1

    So happy to see Patric invited earthling Ed back. Thank you GBNews!! The way Ed calmly and rationally debates and educates his interviewer and the public makes him the best advocate and ambassador of veganism. The way he quietly makes us stop and think is a refreshing change to the usual shouting and screaming that happens on debates and discussions these days. 👍

  • @egidijus6973
    @egidijus6973 Год назад +27

    I agree, horse use is abuse.

    • @ReverendDr.Thomas
      @ReverendDr.Thomas Год назад

      Good Girl! 👌
      Incidentally, Slave, are you VEGAN? 🌱

    • @egidijus6973
      @egidijus6973 Год назад +2

      @@ReverendDr.Thomas Girl? Slave?

    • @Candyshopowner
      @Candyshopowner Год назад +3

      @@egidijus6973 lol don't mind him

    • @watch-Dominion-2018
      @watch-Dominion-2018 Год назад +6

      @@ReverendDr.Thomas you're the Christian who believes in a fake sky daddy who will be angry at you for using mushrooms, so who's the slave?

    • @egidijus6973
      @egidijus6973 Год назад +2

      @@Candyshopowner Oh, ok. thanks for the advice.

  • @kubey88
    @kubey88 Год назад +6

    Your replies in this interview were top notch. You are a fantastic vegan advocate Ed! Thank you for what you do.

  • @vinwillcock612
    @vinwillcock612 Год назад +1

    Magnificent and very persuasive. I like the conversational style opposed to debate!

  • @36ELRIC
    @36ELRIC Год назад +18

    Amazing work again Ed. I don't know how you do it. I like that presenter, he's quite funny. He is also asking good questions and accepting the answers instead of ignoring them, like most presenters do.

    • @GrantH2606
      @GrantH2606 Год назад +1

      @@pacmanmcgavin7034 Source?

    • @GrantH2606
      @GrantH2606 Год назад +1

      @@pacmanmcgavin7034 That vegan channels are slowly going into decline

    • @static_kitten
      @static_kitten Год назад

      @@pacmanmcgavin7034 the horses being hurt or not is not the point ... why are you here if you don't listen

    • @kayleemarie1901
      @kayleemarie1901 Год назад

      @@pacmanmcgavin7034 if the horses didn’t have metal bits shoved into their mouths maybe it would be fine. I’m a vegan and am fine with riding horses as long as people know what tf they are doing and don’t rely on pain and force to communicate with their animal

    • @doggodoggo3000
      @doggodoggo3000 Год назад

      @@pacmanmcgavin7034 im not even vegan, im here because of the horses being treated like crap.
      The horses are shoed and have large bits shoved in their mouths, whips and spurs are still used, and they are made to walk around in the heat on concrete and stone all day....for no reason.
      People have ZERO idea of what horse abuse is. Even in horse racing when they are freaking ran to death on camera, people dont think that is abuse.
      Out of all animal people use, horses have it the worst.I worked in dog racing and that is curel af, but horse racing is much more popular, widespread, and deadly.

  • @janetrobison2765
    @janetrobison2765 Год назад +1

    You are always so well spoken. It shines a very positive light on vegans in general. Well done.

  • @scottreutter
    @scottreutter Год назад +3

    So good! Love that you’re a regular on the show now 😊

  • @jjradV
    @jjradV Год назад +2

    Excellent interview, please do more videos of these very important topics !
    Great conversation, everyone should be giving much thought to the violence against animals.
    All Animals are sentient beings just like us, they must be recognized as sentient and given rights to protect them from humans who willingly abuse and kill them for profit or/and fun.

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      Meat is delicious 🍖🍗🥪🦪🥪🌭🍔🐔🐓🐖🐓🐖🐓🐖🐓🐖🐓🐖 so deliiiiiiiiiiiiciouuuuuuuuus.

  • @discursion
    @discursion Год назад +2

    Great intervention, Ed. Nailed it in every possible way.

  • @the_alpha_not_male
    @the_alpha_not_male Год назад +2

    I'm not a UK citizen, but it's kinda absurd that a royal family still exists, but I don't know please someone from the UK can explain that to me... 🤔

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      I wish King Alfred the Great would think the same.

  • @lynnwiltshire6220
    @lynnwiltshire6220 Год назад +2

    Wonderful to be having discussions about this because it gets people thinking. Well done Ed ❤

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      It gets 8 billion people worldwide increase their demands on animal meat 🥩🍖🥩🐑🐑🥩🍖🍗🥪🌭🍔🐔.

  • @ediem4222
    @ediem4222 Год назад +4

    Disgusting! Animal abuse must end.

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      Then tell Ed to prevent animal meat 🥩🍖🥩🐖🐓🐠🐟🐔🍔🌮 🍗🍖 from appearing on my plate.

  • @roswithaonline6961
    @roswithaonline6961 Год назад +1

    My very first thought: Why not just donate it to a museum and put the item and it's cruel History into perspective? Just as they should do with the confederate statues in the USA:
    Put them into museums and say, what a bad time they represent and why it is so important to work on those times never coming back.

  • @Loveartmusic123
    @Loveartmusic123 Год назад

    Great session! Love & appreciate you @EarthlingEd for your calm,Collective,kind, respectful, wholistic & brilliantly compassionate responses to every question, surely, like us all the animals love & adore you & are thankful to have you. Patrick, It’s so wonderful & refreshing to see you show respect & honor to Ed who surely deserves it. Please need you to have him come back on your show on regular bases to have genuine, healthy, Compassionate & respectful conversations… truly enjoyable sessions🙏🏼 Looking forward to seeing more of the two of you on this Channel🥰🙏🏼🌱🌏🌟

  • @NeneChan203
    @NeneChan203 Год назад +3

    They should make the sceptre with their own teeth

  • @amateurwizard
    @amateurwizard Год назад +1

    I was hanging out with some poachers the other day and they said "well if the royal family aren't doing it, I'm not going to either" 😂

  • @jillianroberts9297
    @jillianroberts9297 Год назад +1

    Love what you say during these interviews Ed. Thank you ! ❤️

  • @richardhunter132
    @richardhunter132 Год назад +4

    why do people think ivory is valuable? it's because we have things like this ivory sceptre that is being used as a symbol of power and wealth. so yes it's a very small thing, but it's still the right thing to do not to use this sceptre as part of the coronation

    • @gear2902
      @gear2902 Год назад +1

      It's not seen as valuable because of the sceptre. It's valuable because it's rare and hard to get.

  • @user-tf4bl6no6g
    @user-tf4bl6no6g Год назад

    I have really enjoyed these interviews with Patrick. Polite and civilized and to the point.

  • @templeofleila
    @templeofleila Год назад +2

    You're a great spokesperson for this movement Ed!

  • @MacFlytrap
    @MacFlytrap Год назад +9

    You are doing so great ❤

    • @ReverendDr.Thomas
      @ReverendDr.Thomas Год назад +1

      Great and lowly are RELATIVE. 😉
      Incidentally, Slave, are you VEGAN? 🌱

    • @watch-Dominion-2018
      @watch-Dominion-2018 Год назад +1

      @@ReverendDr.Thomas you're the Christian who believes in a fake sky daddy who will be angry at you for using mushrooms, so who's the slave?

  • @biancat.1873
    @biancat.1873 Год назад +1

    I love seeing you become a regular on TV :D

  • @hollysquietspace
    @hollysquietspace Год назад +3

    A lot of things that happened in the past, including traditions, weren't necessarily right or ethical, which is why we don't do them anymore. We have evolved and continue to evolve. Using Ivory today because it was used in the 1600s doesn't make it right.

  • @cvdinjapan7935
    @cvdinjapan7935 Год назад +1

    Perfect answers to every question.

  • @Dagmar_R
    @Dagmar_R Год назад +1

    I adore your skills to communicate questions and topics like these ones. I am #veganforlife since 2013

  • @terryelizabeth2841
    @terryelizabeth2841 Год назад +1

    Add, is a very articulate representative for the point of you of being more humane with animals. Veganism is a way of eating that is much more gentle on the Earth, and on other animals that inhabit it.

  • @dco_
    @dco_ Год назад

    I think your comment about putting these types of items in museums as relics to look at the past makes so much sense. And it is an opportunity to do that with all types of animal products.

  • @DaraParsavand
    @DaraParsavand Год назад

    Man this guest is sharp. I’m very happy to have him represent my point of view.

  • @priamalyath6056
    @priamalyath6056 Год назад +1

    Ed you speak so well and state the truth always

  • @jessH090
    @jessH090 Год назад

    Nice to see an interview about this from an interviewer not just shouting down Ed. Makes for a far more pleasant debate.

  • @vnessa01
    @vnessa01 Год назад +1

    Always good to hear your arguments, Ed. The point about giving it to a museum instead is such a good one

  • @hellentavora2046
    @hellentavora2046 Год назад +1

    Again this journalist treated you with respect, allowing you to actually answer questions. Not bad at all.

  • @bazza5699
    @bazza5699 Год назад +1

    great work ED>. such a shame these kind of debates aren't happening on other more mainstream media channels.. looking at you BBC

  • @LisaCooper-thevegan-123
    @LisaCooper-thevegan-123 Год назад +1

    God I love you Ed! People seriously need to stop and think where these things come from!.. animals deserve kindness and care and compassion 🙏🙏👏♥️♥️♥️

    • @donolonisa5787
      @donolonisa5787 Год назад

      Animals deserves to become pork chops 🥩🍖🥩🥩🥩🐖 🐖🐖🐖🐖, lamb chops 🥩🍖🥩🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑 and mince meat 🥩🍖🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩 for me to eat, mmmm delicious.

  • @collectionofatoms1876
    @collectionofatoms1876 Год назад +3

    Fan favorite! I love that your perspectives are becoming more popular Ed. I'm ludicrously proud of your achievements and grateful for how well you advocate for veganism.

  • @HideoGojira
    @HideoGojira Год назад +1

    You are so amazing at what you do Ed. Thank you.

  • @roselaura-gracesing4968
    @roselaura-gracesing4968 Год назад +1

    Great talk! Love learning from you, Ed!

  • @nataliem3504
    @nataliem3504 Год назад +1

    You are wonderful Ed! I am always amazed by your calm and fabulous debating skills! Thank you for speaking for us about the animals ❤

  • @RatsPicklesandMusic
    @RatsPicklesandMusic Год назад +1

    I've been vegan for only one week and you're a bit part of what got me here, Ed!! Thank you for being so kind and rational!

  • @Veegan4theanimals
    @Veegan4theanimals Год назад +2

    Great! Well done Ed!

  • @missapippin9020
    @missapippin9020 Год назад

    Ed you are so eloquent and you have the right answers to the questions. I wish I could be more forthcoming when questioned. Thank you for all you do Ed.

  • @perplexetic
    @perplexetic Год назад

    Amen! Think about the one being exploited and whats in their best interest, have compassion. Its honestly not even difficult to do

  • @spiral-m
    @spiral-m Год назад

    Ed's on a roll. Amazing he got this opportunity so quickly again!

  • @iqui
    @iqui Год назад +1

    You're such a good speaker, I love what you do!

  • @jiinglesgreen3869
    @jiinglesgreen3869 Год назад +1

    This anchorman seems to love you Ed. Good job, great discussion.❤