He made two songs about Sarah so rotten Sarah is part 2 of Sarah, where he’s killed by the police when they arrive and he talks about his dead body laying next to sarahs
The thing is the girl could still be 18-19 when the song was written and Tyler himself could just not feel comfortable with the idea of being with a girl with 5-6 age gap. So the song represents how he mentally felt like a creep and a weirdo despite it being legal which is why he mentions having anxiety over police as it’s his fear of judgement
Thats so odd to me, yes i know his first 3 albums are a connected storyline and i love it but ive listened to a lot of horrorcore and bastard is way darker than stuff from brotha lynch hung, ganksta nip, and necro
@@night_snake6560 necro and brotha lynch are waaay darker then tyler tyler just says I think r word is fun necro gives the most elaborate and gory description you'll ever hear
tbh fucking young / perfect isn’t as edgy as old tyler but it definitely is dark but the story is obviously changed tyler changes stories that happened irl to better fit songs like the song “She” was actually real with tyler but not that bad and even his unreleased he does it alot
I listened to cherry bomb out of boredom since it was my first time giving the album a try and 'fucking young / perfect' i loved the song and beats but when i listened to read the lyrics yeah its pretty dark but its a banger tho
Love the dark music you’re review. However, please never refer to a minor you’re attracted to as “your favorite food you can’t eat without consequences.” For someone to have a favorite food they have to try and experience the flavor and have some sort of prior familiarity to know that it is there favorite. Relating that analogy to the “fucking young” song if it had to deal with feelings for someone you can’t express towards because of the legal repercussion infers that the writer had been with minors enough to know that it was a favored flavor to be able to write a song about the pain of not being romantic with one. Of course, my point can easily be thrown out the window with no concern if the fact of the matter is there’s no element of truth or real life experience in the lyrics.
From the information in this video, I believe that the girl wasn’t 15 or 16, cause Wolf released when Tyler was 23 and that’s when he started to write the songs. You’re really reaching in the part that the girl was 14/15 because the song isn’t about a child, it’s about a 17 year old girl who Tyler can’t be with cause she isn’t legal yet, and in the song he said how she’d be old enough by the time the song released, but he’d still feel dirty about it. If for whatever reason she was 15/16 I don’t think he would’ve done anything with the girl because he’s smart enough to know what situation he’s in and to try and avoid it. Some parts of the song could’ve been added to add to the dramatic-ness of it, but that’s just my thoughts.
@@VIIZZZYYrotten Sarah was based off of a real girl he liked named Raquel. the song(s) was him taking his anger out on her for rejecting him from prom. nothing ever really happened but still creepy. he really wanted to kill Raquel.
Yooo this has been my favorite tyler song for years im so happy to see someone, especially you, cover it? the video was great, loved it so much!! There was a lot i didnt know about this song so im glad you made this
Tbh, I have a friend who was dating a girl with a 1 year difference. The people at school who knew about started callin him a pedo. So a six year difference would definitely get the po po called on u. Even if I don’t think that’s the worst year difference, people r gonna think it is. So I see why Tyler would be nervous. I don’t think he’s a pedo.
they are especially the sarah trilogy LOL because sarah was a real girl tyler was obsessed with and he said he would always everyday drive by her window to check if the light was on and he based songs like She, Analog 1-3 and obviously the sarah trilogy
@Nigward 2k he was 16 when he wrote it 😭😭 and like i know it isn’t real and he’s just doing it because he wants to recreate like horror movies but into music form but the fact that he wrote this and other songs based on a real girl he was crushing on is crazy
@@VIIZZZYY raquel, his high school crush at the time who turned down his prom offer he has stated that sarah was made out of anger towards her and was about her, he used to tweet about her alot in the early days
always knew that tyler's albums (before flower boy) were dark and because of the video im going to try cherry bomb now. (I just finished the wolf trilogy). nice job bbno$!
I can't lie I'm a massive Tyler fan, I love all his tapes, even his unreleased shit, and I do like Bastard and Goblin, despite its gross content, but fucking young / perfect is the ONLY song by Tyler that isn't liked on my spotify, and I don't listen or like it. Idk something about it rubs me the wrong way in a way different way to both the Sarah songs
First to come to mind on "Darkest" would have been something like Pigs or Tron cat, hell, even Assmilk has some crazy lines, but fucking young is something i would never had thought about
no way 😭😭 this whole time I he no idea fucking young was about THAT. As a kid (middle school) I thought it was just like “oh no I’m too awkward for this girl so embarrassing” 💀
@@willstillplys bro he cannot be the next Drake otherwise I’m tying myself to the tree with a belt like he talked about in the song 😀 tbh this was worse than Sarah and Tron Cat for me 😀😀😀
I personally think the song is a embellished truth yeah Tyler prolly was fucking with a girl 6 years younger but it was probably legal but still made him feel weird and creepy so he changed ages around and shit and made the song itself different that or it’s all fake knowing Tyler that also wouldn’t be that crazy side note I really think it’s cool how amazing the song is and sounds but the lyrics or inside of the song sucks like a lot of pedos yk they look normal hell sometimes like good people but tear off the layers and beneath is something fucked
I think it is just because it’s a real life thing vs a fictional story, feel me? If the songs off bastard where real stories then hell yeah they’re darker
@@VIIZZZYYadicals is so dark that Tyler had to put a warning to not do anything said in this song.The chorus reapeats „Kill pepole, burn schools"...But is definetly Rotten Sarah from his unreleased album Zombie Circus. It is amolst the same as Sarah but the song is about kidnapping Sarah, killing her and eating half of the body. The istrumental is also really low quality. This song got me f***ed up for like 3 days when I firstly listend to it...
i respect your opinion but i have to disagree. when i heard sarah for the first time my stomach actually went cold and it's still difficult to listen to
Well kinda, the story is *kinda* true but it was about a girl that was not named Sarah but rather Raquel and Tyler liked her but she didn’t, so Tyler had visions of killing her because he was mad at her, there you go that’s what it’s based off of (according to a video I saw)
I mean, I get the point, but I have a genuine doubt tho: Why is it safe to assume that he was 21-22 y/o when he recorded it? It's not shade whatsoever btw, loved the video and u got a new sub my friend hahaha, I do have that honest question :)
yeah he definitely stretched about the 21-22 most likely she was 17 and he was 23, kinda fucked up to assume Tyler was singing about crushing over a 15-16 year old
Thanks dude! To answer your question, most artists take a few years to drop a song. And the writing process alone (especially for someone like Tyler that takes emense pride in his work AND drops Hella songs per album) takes months to years as well. If he drops an album every 2 years it's safe to assume the writing process either starts at the ending of an album push or after it
@@fluttershy69 yes lmfao those arent as bad as sarah, blow is getting there but sarah is the worst out the bunch, and dem hoes isnt even that bad idk how you could even think its relatively close to sarah on extremeness
My other videos are better then this, go peep.
I like these kinds of videos, do more!
bet
The funny thing is Sarahs voice is just a pitch-shifted recording of Taco
Lol
@@acecross9625i definitely knew it taco
@@ShadowGamer2549-k5kmhm
I didn’t. That’s cool, something knew I learned, thanks
Who's Taco
words tyler and darkest song makes me instantly think of the line: "dead body layin' next to sarah, we're finally together"
really puts the lyric "we can finally be together" from new magic wand into a different perspective when you realize it might be a ref to that
Yeah that’s definitely a disturbing one
that's not a real song, it's made with AI
@@WarewolffDB lmao yes it is, im deep in the tyler unreleased shit and that leaked in may of last year before all the voice cloning began
"truthfully i kind of like this a little better"
I thought the title was about rotten Sarah but I guess I was wrong
i was thinking about that too lmao
He made two songs about Sarah so rotten Sarah is part 2 of Sarah, where he’s killed by the police when they arrive and he talks about his dead body laying next to sarahs
@@adrianagerardo955 I thought he shot himself at the end
i mean that’s not the darkest either imo
Same
Tron cat is Tyler’s most wholesome song I recommend listening with your parents
Hahahaha same
thanks for the recommendation!! i got disowned 😘
ESPECIALLY if ur mom is pregnant
@@luvlettrzzespecially ESPECIALLY if your mom is a fetus
@@luvlettrzzTAHTS WILD 😭😭😭😭😭😭
The thing is the girl could still be 18-19 when the song was written and Tyler himself could just not feel comfortable with the idea of being with a girl with 5-6 age gap. So the song represents how he mentally felt like a creep and a weirdo despite it being legal which is why he mentions having anxiety over police as it’s his fear of judgement
And then he went on to date a 20 year old when he was 30 lmao
Tyler has said he doesn't like his older music being compared to horrorcore. Great video loved it!! Keep it up
Thats so odd to me, yes i know his first 3 albums are a connected storyline and i love it but ive listened to a lot of horrorcore and bastard is way darker than stuff from brotha lynch hung, ganksta nip, and necro
@@night_snake6560 Necro got some shizzy tho
Thanks brother
@@night_snake6560 necro and brotha lynch are waaay darker then tyler tyler just says I think r word is fun necro gives the most elaborate and gory description you'll ever hear
he doesn't like it but the fact that he attracted horrorcore fans means it's not really up to him if it gets compared.
"A six year difference is a 10 year sentence"
imo Sarah (and Rotten Sarah) is a whole lot darker than fucking young
Yeah he knows but that is not the point
No cause this might be a true story
Yeah I always wondered the story behind this, perfect is such a great ending. Dope video!
Means alot brother thank you 🖤
sarah has a super fire beat but a horrifically terrifying lore
tbh fucking young / perfect isn’t as edgy as old tyler but it definitely is dark
but the story is obviously changed tyler changes stories that happened irl to better fit songs like the song “She” was actually real with tyler but not that bad and even his unreleased he does it alot
What i don't know
@@itsclownette what
I listened to cherry bomb out of boredom since it was my first time giving the album a try and 'fucking young / perfect' i loved the song and beats but when i listened to read the lyrics yeah its pretty dark but its a banger tho
i was thinking the same thing. he could have said 6 to make the listener understand why he was scared, but it actually was 5. who knows
@@thecadet777 most likely
What if the “girl” is just jaiden smith
bruh 💀
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The girl is taco Bennett
@@HORACETREX and of course Lucas
Jaden was around 17 18 when Cherry boom was released so that make sense💀💀💀
This video started picking up traction lately and clearly yall like it. Who should i do next?
more dark music
Wolf 2010 lost album
Love the dark music you’re review. However, please never refer to a minor you’re attracted to as “your favorite food you can’t eat without consequences.” For someone to have a favorite food they have to try and experience the flavor and have some sort of prior familiarity to know that it is there favorite. Relating that analogy to the “fucking young” song if it had to deal with feelings for someone you can’t express towards because of the legal repercussion infers that the writer had been with minors enough to know that it was a favored flavor to be able to write a song about the pain of not being romantic with one. Of course, my point can easily be thrown out the window with no concern if the fact of the matter is there’s no element of truth or real life experience in the lyrics.
From the information in this video, I believe that the girl wasn’t 15 or 16, cause Wolf released when Tyler was 23 and that’s when he started to write the songs. You’re really reaching in the part that the girl was 14/15 because the song isn’t about a child, it’s about a 17 year old girl who Tyler can’t be with cause she isn’t legal yet, and in the song he said how she’d be old enough by the time the song released, but he’d still feel dirty about it. If for whatever reason she was 15/16 I don’t think he would’ve done anything with the girl because he’s smart enough to know what situation he’s in and to try and avoid it. Some parts of the song could’ve been added to add to the dramatic-ness of it, but that’s just my thoughts.
yes but everyone still calls you a pedo if you like a 17 year old and your only like 20 , not dark but stil fuked up its a 50/50 some
Didn't Tyler say this song is based on a bad dream? I don't think it's real
Tyler was working on cherry bomb while he was working on wolf and he dropped wolf when he was 22... It's more likely that the girl was actually 15-16.
I think when Tyler talks about a tree and a belt he’s taking about being killed and not killing himself
this was a bar🔥🔥
I believe he was actually 23 at the time of writing the song and the girl was 17, I remember reading it somewhere bur I could be wrong
Scott Pilgrim
His darkest song is rotten Sarah, which is about him rotting next to Sarah’s half eaten dead body
he has worse songs
Definitely dark but it’s not a real story, ya know what I mean?
@@VIIZZZYYrotten Sarah was based off of a real girl he liked named Raquel. the song(s) was him taking his anger out on her for rejecting him from prom. nothing ever really happened but still creepy. he really wanted to kill Raquel.
keep the music content coming this was great.
Hell yeah! Thanks for the support homie 🖤
why is bro looking away before every transition
Yooo this has been my favorite tyler song for years im so happy to see someone, especially you, cover it? the video was great, loved it so much!! There was a lot i didnt know about this song so im glad you made this
Tbh, I have a friend who was dating a girl with a 1 year difference. The people at school who knew about started callin him a pedo. So a six year difference would definitely get the po po called on u. Even if I don’t think that’s the worst year difference, people r gonna think it is. So I see why Tyler would be nervous. I don’t think he’s a pedo.
He says in the song that he is 23 and she’s 17
Where lol
It’s been 9 months please lol
Holy fuck, the amount of depth that you have gone into and brought to this topic, IS A M A Z I N G, thank you.
It reminds me of hey ya which is a song that is catchy but has
Some stuff in the lyrics
Amazing video made me think a lot deeper into a song id just been enjoying for the past couple years
I'm not a Tyler fan but to me the other songs you mentioned at the beginning sound way more disturbing than fucking young tbh.
they are especially the sarah trilogy LOL because sarah was a real girl tyler was obsessed with and he said he would always everyday drive by her window to check if the light was on and he based songs like She, Analog 1-3 and obviously the sarah trilogy
@Nigward 2k he was 16 when he wrote it 😭😭 and like i know it isn’t real and he’s just doing it because he wants to recreate like horror movies but into music form but the fact that he wrote this and other songs based on a real girl he was crushing on is crazy
@Nigward 2k frr
@@tf2nico wait there’s an Analog 3? Also Sarah TRILOGY?
@@ultraisaiah7859 Yes but analog 3 is only a instrumental sadly and the trilogy for sarah is: F*ck Love, Sarah, Rotten Sarah.
Bro I love this song but the subject matter always weirds me out every time I listen to it
Yeah dude it’s super conflicting, i like the song but I don’t want to like it hahaha
I didn’t know people were deaf. I knew the meaning the first time I listened to it!
😂😂
Same
Tyler wasn’t gonna get caught being edp
True. But Sarah + Rotten Sarah was based on a real woman.
I didn’t know that, do you know who she is?
@@VIIZZZYY raquel, his high school crush at the time who turned down his prom offer
he has stated that sarah was made out of anger towards her and was about her, he used to tweet about her alot in the early days
And yet the whole time, Johnny sins watches us
Dark meaning, great song. An EDP commentary video was recommended under this LMAO
LMFAO
EDP is my videos competition smh
@@VIIZZZYY LOLOL
always knew that tyler's albums (before flower boy) were dark and because of the video im going to try cherry bomb now. (I just finished the wolf trilogy). nice job bbno$!
BBNO$ IM DEAD LMAO
0:11 that’s actually his friend Taco lol
The audio?
@@VIIZZZYYyup
I always viewed this song like it’s from a character’s perspective, like with Sarah or Tron Cat
WHY DOES THIS MAN KEEP LOOKING OUT THE GODDAMN WINDOW
Hahaha I was looking at my second monitor to read the script
The blinds wide open haha
I can't lie I'm a massive Tyler fan, I love all his tapes, even his unreleased shit, and I do like Bastard and Goblin, despite its gross content, but fucking young / perfect is the ONLY song by Tyler that isn't liked on my spotify, and I don't listen or like it. Idk something about it rubs me the wrong way in a way different way to both the Sarah songs
Word dude, it’s because it’s a REAL story ya know?
The voice of the woman on sarah actually made me feel sick
It’s a recording of his friend, taco
I actually love the sarah beat
I’ve been wondering to this day how no one has ever questioned this song🤣 still a really good song though
I mean I felt weirded out by liking someone a year younger than me so I can see why he’d feel weird and paranoid abt a 5 year difference
Before the song is said im guessing F*cking Young hes already mentioned Sarah and Tron Cat
First to come to mind on "Darkest" would have been something like Pigs or Tron cat, hell, even Assmilk has some crazy lines, but fucking young is something i would never had thought about
I always thought this was crazy too 😭
Thank god I’m not the only one lmao
no way 😭😭 this whole time I he no idea fucking young was about THAT. As a kid (middle school) I thought it was just like “oh no I’m too awkward for this girl so embarrassing” 💀
More music content please 🙏🙏
Yes sir! Thanks for watching!
Ephebophilia is the primary sexual interest in mid-to-late adolescents, generally ages 15 to 19. Tyler wouldn't be a pedophile, he'd be a ephebophile.
Bro 😭😭😭I’m scared of Tyler after listening to this video 😭😭
@@hellotherefifteen valid
@@willstillplys bro he cannot be the next Drake otherwise I’m tying myself to the tree with a belt like he talked about in the song 😀 tbh this was worse than Sarah and Tron Cat for me 😀😀😀
we ain’t gonna talk about lucky charms on wolf 2010
I had a feeling it was fucking young😭 it’s so catchy but I can’t get over how questionable the lyrics are
Thats tough Its crazy you made it trough that
Fantano commented on the lyrics when it came out and during the album review and during a lets argue
I gotta check that out, got a link?
I personally think the song is a embellished truth yeah Tyler prolly was fucking with a girl 6 years younger but it was probably legal but still made him feel weird and creepy so he changed ages around and shit and made the song itself different that or it’s all fake knowing Tyler that also wouldn’t be that crazy side note I really think it’s cool how amazing the song is and sounds but the lyrics or inside of the song sucks like a lot of pedos yk they look normal hell sometimes like good people but tear off the layers and beneath is something fucked
you kinda look like latino moist critical, and i dig it
like a mix between moist critical and faze temperrr
fucking young/perfect is definitely NOT his darkest song comparing to songs off goblin or bastard
I think it is just because it’s a real life thing vs a fictional story, feel me? If the songs off bastard where real stories then hell yeah they’re darker
@@VIIZZZYYadicals is so dark that Tyler had to put a warning to not do anything said in this song.The chorus reapeats „Kill pepole, burn schools"...But is definetly Rotten Sarah from his unreleased album Zombie Circus. It is amolst the same as Sarah but the song is about kidnapping Sarah, killing her and eating half of the body. The istrumental is also really low quality. This song got me f***ed up for like 3 days when I firstly listend to it...
i respect your opinion but i have to disagree. when i heard sarah for the first time my stomach actually went cold and it's still difficult to listen to
Word Tyler’s definitely a good story teller, thanks for checking it out!
Idk bruh golden & nightmare is DARK
this was so good ,,,make more >.
Sarah was a true story
Wait what?!!!???!!
Wait what
This guys probably lying but regardless this kind of stuff happens to people everyday so
Well kinda, the story is *kinda* true but it was about a girl that was not named Sarah but rather Raquel and Tyler liked her but she didn’t, so Tyler had visions of killing her because he was mad at her, there you go that’s what it’s based off of (according to a video I saw)
Well that’s just a summary of the story
bro this is the age gap between my parents.
Tyler's darkest song has to be Sarah
bruh how i predict what song it was before the song was announced
I SWEAR. I always wondered why NOBODY was talking about this song and then someone FINALLY DID!! thanks
Dude it was something i couldnt stop thinking about lmao
actually his darkest song is rotten sarah
Word I can see that, the beat makes it a dark atmosphere on top of disturbing lyrics
Tyler turn into freddie dredd in this songs
😂😂
one word: fish
I was looking for this
Before I hear it’s gotta be TRON cat
I'd agree, but since the OP is basing it off an irl incident and not a horror story, then it would technically be darker than TRON cat
Y’all forgot about pigs
New Tyler fans are so sensitive bro
If you’re implying me I’ve been listening to him for 10+ years
"heh.. these new tyler fans dont know anything!" *snort * "they are so sensitive!"🤓
my fav song
eh tyler literally kills a girl in sarah
Tron cat is much darker than Fucking young and it’s not even close
💀💀Sarah is way darker than this what💀💀
In my opinion Sarah is more disturbing as a story, vs this being a real life problem he had to deal with
@@VIIZZZYY nah you right, didn’t think about that
Window gotta be the darkest
Rotten Sarah 💀
it’s so fire though but sad asf
@@cherrybethebomb That song is a fucking masterpiece. The outro gives me chills every single time
I’d have to say 48 because of how it shows how drugs ruin people’s lives
I mean, I get the point, but I have a genuine doubt tho: Why is it safe to assume that he was 21-22 y/o when he recorded it?
It's not shade whatsoever btw, loved the video and u got a new sub my friend hahaha, I do have that honest question :)
yeah he definitely stretched about the 21-22
most likely she was 17 and he was 23, kinda fucked up to assume Tyler was singing about crushing over a 15-16 year old
Thanks dude! To answer your question, most artists take a few years to drop a song. And the writing process alone (especially for someone like Tyler that takes emense pride in his work AND drops Hella songs per album) takes months to years as well. If he drops an album every 2 years it's safe to assume the writing process either starts at the ending of an album push or after it
Heres the thing you cant use tylers name being in it making it automatically true because in bastard the main charector is also just named tyler
Such a solid point 😂
pretty sure hes named ace tho too
I swear one of these days Tyler is bouta get caught with some shit like this🤣 (hopefully not)
this was cherry bomb when he was in his early 20s tyler is 32 now
Have y'all heard pigs? Its from wolf
saw the portuguese flag and knew i had to instantly subscribe
Thanks for the love ❤ 🇵🇹
Tyga and Kylie
Great content, keep it up
Thanks brother means alot
This man is trying to have Tyler catch a charge. Boo this man.
what's with the censorship?
Lmfao I fucking love this song
Tyler is soooo scary
Amazing flag you got there
Thanks brother 🇵🇹
personally i like these
Thank you brother 🖤
Who’s that on the bottom left corner.
My dad
@@VIIZZZYYmine too
Sarah
Yamaka?
its still fucked up
I like your profile picture
Unironically one of his best songs 😂
yall not talkin abt kim by eminem tho
Songs probably about bella hadid, probably when she was 17. yw
I’m only like half way through your vid but you said she’s a child but he’s only talking about a 17 year old girl when he was like 23 (I think)
Thought this was gonna be about Tron Cat or Assmilk😅
Assmilk is such a slept on song
assmilk is NOT dark
I thought this was going to be “she”
Na, but that song is sooo good
he has a bit of darker songs than sarah😭
na sarah is the darkest
@@sk4ras definitely not. have you heard rotten sarah, you’re drunk, blow, or dem hoes?? lmao
@@fluttershy69 yes lmfao those arent as bad as sarah, blow is getting there but sarah is the worst out the bunch, and dem hoes isnt even that bad idk how you could even think its relatively close to sarah on extremeness
@@sk4ras you didn’t even mention the other two😭
@@fluttershy69 i literally said “THOSE arent as bad as sarah.”
PORTUGAL CRLH