Gotham Central Omnibus (2022 edition) Overview & Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024

Комментарии • 117

  • @franciscoj.t.t.5094
    @franciscoj.t.t.5094 2 года назад +72

    From Ed Brubaker's newsletter: "My old friend Marie Javins is the EIC of DC Comics now, and so when I found out they were doing a new printing of the GOTHAM CENTRAL OMNIBUS, I asked her if we could finally correct the minor errors of the previous reissues. Since Marie is the best, she let me and Greg Rucka and Michael Lark proof the new book, and we now finally have a DEFINITIVE Gotham Central hardback. Including the missing layers of snow from the first chapter of our big Joker story. This book was done back in the old days, and Michael had made an actual separate layer for the falling snow and while it printed in the single issue, it somehow got left out of all the trades and hardbacks until now. (Also a few lettering mistakes were fixed this time, and a joke that we couldn't get past the censors back then has been added back in because it's 20 years later). Seriously, as a total control freak about my books, it drove me crazy for years that there's a scene where Driver is commenting on the snow fall and even holding out a hand to feel it, and there was NO SNOW. Now this is fixed and I am a happy camper.
    Plus it was fun to read it all again, I think Gotham Central was ahead of its time, really (we started it before The Wire was on TV but we were highly influenced by HOMICIDE, David Simon's book from the 90s). "

    • @NearMintCondition
      @NearMintCondition  2 года назад +25

      I read that this morning. I’ll be honest I recorded the video Monday and didn’t notice the snow lol, but I did notice the binding being so much better in this version. So glad to hear they got this looking the way he intended it.

    • @vincentimbesi3947
      @vincentimbesi3947 2 года назад +6

      Oh no! Now I’m going to have to upgrade the omnibus I have! 😑

    • @YouShallNotPazz
      @YouShallNotPazz 2 года назад +4

      Damn it, I have the first printing and now I’m really thinking about getting the new edition. Ugh lol.

    • @newspooiechannel
      @newspooiechannel 2 года назад +2

      Does anyone know what the joke is or which issue it is in?

    • @vincentimbesi3947
      @vincentimbesi3947 2 года назад +1

      @@newspooiechannel I was wondering the same thing! LOL

  • @paulioscorchio
    @paulioscorchio 2 года назад +64

    Just got Brubaker’s newsletter. They’ve corrected some printing errors for this edition and added a new joke that was censored when the original issues were released. Good stuff.

    • @johnnieriot13
      @johnnieriot13 2 года назад +5

      I was just writing this. You beat me to it.

    • @Chandasouk
      @Chandasouk 2 года назад +3

      Excellent news

  • @Adam_XVII
    @Adam_XVII 2 года назад +38

    Man u always have the best overviews, exactly what i look for when wanting to buy a new book.

  • @jearl75290
    @jearl75290 2 года назад +4

    Picked mine up yesterday. There was one left on the shelf the clerk was eyeing it pretty hard.

  • @thebandwagonfanpodcast
    @thebandwagonfanpodcast 2 года назад +15

    I've heard a lot about this one but have never actually gotten around to reading it. The creative team and dope and I love me a good omni! My wallet is starting to sweat while watching this video.

  • @Fredsinator
    @Fredsinator 2 года назад +1

    Got my copy yesterday. Super excited to read this. Omar's recommendations never fail

  • @RockaRolla69
    @RockaRolla69 2 года назад +4

    So excited to get this along with the 5 new omnis on the way from this week

    • @jearl75290
      @jearl75290 2 года назад +3

      The passenger seat in my car was stacked high with omnis yesterday.

  • @joshuatehhonguan
    @joshuatehhonguan 2 года назад +1

    Pre-ordered this last year because of your high recommendation, can't wait to dive in. Thanks, Omar!

  • @arthurwoo6082
    @arthurwoo6082 2 года назад +1

    Just purchased this yesterday and really looking fwd to reading and owning this. Been waiting for a reprint of this for the past few years and thrilled to be finally getting it! Great review making me even more excited!

  • @notorious.k.i.p.
    @notorious.k.i.p. 2 года назад +1

    Great overview Omar! This is one of my favorite omni's and i'm jealous of everybody who gets to read this for the first time. I think it's time i read this again!

  • @Pastrybfs
    @Pastrybfs 2 года назад +1

    Awesome that they finally reprinted this. I bit the bullet and bought the trades a while ago, but still. Amazing story.

  • @OrangeGeemer
    @OrangeGeemer 2 года назад +2

    Glad yo see it doesn't say "2022 edition" all over the dust cover.

  • @CS11
    @CS11 2 года назад +1

    Been anticipating this for awhile and it’s finally here! Ordered my own and just waiting for it to be dispatched so i can finally read this

  • @ReaperXC
    @ReaperXC 2 года назад +3

    The book block of your first copy hangs past the hardcover.
    Have a look at supporting your omnibus book blocks when you store them traditionally (vertical).

    • @terskatti4994
      @terskatti4994 2 года назад +3

      Books are meant to be read, wear and tear happens.

  • @bobbehers1625
    @bobbehers1625 2 года назад

    Ordered my copy when they first announced it. Missed it the first time around. But after reading a few of the paperbacks, I was sold! Thanks Omar!

  • @studleytrey
    @studleytrey 2 года назад

    Just checked and my pre-order arrives on Tuesday. Perfect timing for this video to work up my excitement-cheers!

  • @balkthor
    @balkthor 2 года назад +1

    My original copy is in great shape, but I fully admit I have definitely NOT read it as much as the book deserves, I've still only read it once. I'm sure once I burn through it a few more times it'll start to show some love marks.
    By the way, if anyone is wondering, this is another one of those books EVERYBODY should buy. I don't care if you're a Batman person or not, this book is the magnum opus for each one of these creators IMO.

  • @jacobsawyer6467
    @jacobsawyer6467 2 года назад +2

    My order is on the way been waiting a long time for this, The Question Omni can't get here soon enough though

  • @bradparsons6419
    @bradparsons6419 2 года назад +1

    I pre-ordered it from Cheapgraphicnovels. This will be my first time reading it. Your review has me pretty excited, I can't wait!

  • @kevinluther8373
    @kevinluther8373 2 года назад +1

    I’m happy this was one of the few books I just never got to buying lol. Worth a few years wait to get this with the few small changes and better binding. I just wish it didn’t have those bland black boards. They just don’t feel nice to touch either.

  • @austinparral
    @austinparral 2 года назад

    I ordered mine from IST yesterday I can't wait for it to arrive. The retroview you did on it is what put it on my radar and I'm excited to finally get to read it.

  • @robertw5391
    @robertw5391 6 месяцев назад +1

    I love it. I wish there was more.

  • @astrostar49
    @astrostar49 2 года назад +1

    Thanks for the spotlight. I've wanted to read this for a while, and I'd definitely order it if it wasn't for my wallet already having turned crispy.

  • @purplerain225
    @purplerain225 2 года назад +1

    Ed Brubaker say no more. It just arrived added to my reading pile for 2022

  • @benjamin_parry
    @benjamin_parry 2 года назад +2

    I have this on pre order based on one of your recent anniunments about it the other week. Can't wait to get it. And it will be at the top of my reading list right after I finish House / Powers of X. I actually bought this with the money that would have gone towards the X-Men by Jonathan Hickman Omnibus follow up of House / Power of X. I'm sure this is the correct decision.

  • @litewait633
    @litewait633 2 года назад +2

    This is a great book, and I’m glad it got reprinted for those who need it.

  • @Darklantern2984
    @Darklantern2984 2 года назад +1

    That fall of the mutants omni I'm the background 👀👀

  • @anthonyufert8477
    @anthonyufert8477 2 года назад

    I got this one last Friday & I could not put it down. I have to say this is one of the best comics I have ever read. It’s great how it mixes police work, Gotham, the rogues gallery of villains & the amazing characters. I can not recommend this enough.

  • @hamzadawud
    @hamzadawud 2 года назад +1

    I preordered this one based mostly on your recommendation, so I hope it lives up to the hype!

    • @benjamin_parry
      @benjamin_parry 2 года назад +2

      Same here. But I'm a massive Ed Brubaker fan, so I'm sure I will love this.

  • @smd1671
    @smd1671 2 года назад

    Pre-ordered my copy right after watching this. Can't wait to read it for the first time. Thanks Omar 👍

  • @warrenweaver6664
    @warrenweaver6664 2 года назад +1

    Not a Brubaker fan by any means but I’ve read the trades to this series and loved em so I might get this.

  • @simon9146
    @simon9146 2 года назад +6

    This is probably my favourite comic of all-time. My copy of this printing arrived yesterday as I sold my first printing last year for an awful lot of money as soon as the new printing was announced.

    • @simon9146
      @simon9146 2 года назад +2

      I should add, my copy was in the same condition as Omar’s after I had read it multiple times, which was another good reason to sell it as it wouldn’t have lasted much longer.

  • @Almighty_Mage
    @Almighty_Mage 2 года назад

    I was just looking for this video. Great timing.

  • @Rtombooksart
    @Rtombooksart 2 года назад +1

    just got ed brubakers newsletter informing about this book and bang omar puts it up , snap.

  • @FreakyFraser1
    @FreakyFraser1 2 года назад +1

    Definitely my favorite Omni.....read this while rehabbing from knee surgery and crushed it in a couple days. Homicide Life on The Streets on the page. Fantastic!

  • @jocool7370
    @jocool7370 2 года назад

    Knock knock!
    "Hello, I just followed you home. I like your house." 😲😲😲

  • @blurjose
    @blurjose 2 года назад

    Ordered mine on CGN just now. Thanks for the reminder. I can't wait to dig in.

  • @UnknownPriorityTwitch
    @UnknownPriorityTwitch 2 года назад

    Thanks for the overview! Love your videos man, you deserve so many more views.

  • @jeffsuter344
    @jeffsuter344 2 года назад +1

    I ordered this book due to your recommendation Omar.

  • @robertday4390
    @robertday4390 2 года назад

    I am grateful DC are reprinting many of their OOP omnis and these new printings can make up for any binding or QC issues. I thought too that the boards would have artwork on them but if that’s my only concern then I’m a happy collector. Thanks Omar, I’m just about to crack open my copy!

  • @comicsguru2574
    @comicsguru2574 2 года назад

    Gotham Central is an absolute CLASSIC, I’m getting this omnibus asap.

  • @17klop
    @17klop 2 года назад

    I've been hunting for this book since I started collecting editions I'm so happy this got reprinted.

  • @bigboibenny1609
    @bigboibenny1609 Год назад

    I was very moved by the story about Montoya being outed. It was such a powerful story and it made me fall back in love with her character (I was not a fan of her characterization in New gotham and Officer down and this made me appreciate her again). It was especially moving as a Christian, and it makes me think about how the church reacts to situations like hers, and how there are alot of real people who are in very similar situations. It was an eye opening and heart wrenching read.

    • @PlayingWithWilson
      @PlayingWithWilson 11 месяцев назад

      Thanks, I'm avoiding all gay stuff and you just saved me from wasting money on this. FYI gays are not Christians because they don't believe in Christianity, you can't believe in something you don't believe, claiming you do is disrespectful to not only Christianity but all religions.

  • @projektvyking7521
    @projektvyking7521 2 года назад

    Sweet, sweet Brubaker goodness. Need to follow this release up with New Gotham through Fugitive Omnis

  • @boomjch
    @boomjch 2 года назад

    One of my favorite comic runs. Ordered a copy but living on a island usually means I wont get things till a week later!

  • @borburison_mcoc
    @borburison_mcoc 2 года назад +1

    If I'm not misatken, Kano is José Ángel Cano López, a Spanish artist.

  • @toeknee1505
    @toeknee1505 2 года назад

    I like your overview of Gotham Central omnibus. Enjoyed the video!

  • @JClif
    @JClif 2 года назад

    I have mine on the way. I can not wait to read it. I have been wanting it for years.

  • @tphoto10
    @tphoto10 2 года назад

    I love Brubaker but I haven’t read much of his work for hire. This seems like everyone loves it, so I ordered up a copy!

  • @greenlanternakaparallax6550
    @greenlanternakaparallax6550 2 года назад

    I might read this now. Seems pretty cool. Thanks for the recommendation Omar.

  • @frankwhitebean2649
    @frankwhitebean2649 Год назад

    I have no eye on my copy so i'm trying the butter knife technique to try & lift it

  • @HiCon37
    @HiCon37 2 года назад

    Got this from Organic Priced Books for 60 bucks. Can't wait to dive in once it comes up in my Batman reading order.

  • @sicksabrestyle4357
    @sicksabrestyle4357 2 года назад

    Ordered mine this week. The old man comes with me to comic conventions but doesn’t read comics. He can’t follow the art and world bubbles. (Probably shouldnt have made him read vol 1 of Manifest Destiny, Dingess/Roberts for his first in 45 years🤣). i showed him the interior of Fatale and he said he’d be down to read something presented like that but never could grab those hardcovers $$$, so I’m hoping this will do the trick😬😀. Really excited to read it myself but more excited to see if he goes for it 🤞. Take care and god bless

  • @Chandasouk
    @Chandasouk 2 года назад +2

    Just placed my order ya'll. Got that Ham!

  • @Kimota82
    @Kimota82 2 года назад

    Wow, glad I pre-ordered a copy and grabbed it today! Love me some Brubaker!

  • @kawaiihaki2480
    @kawaiihaki2480 7 месяцев назад

    just wondering how come all this omnis pages are warped like that, they look like waves

  • @Rodimusprimerib
    @Rodimusprimerib 2 года назад

    Waiting for my copy to arrive from OPB. This is one of my top wants of all time!

  • @mathewguglielmi8451
    @mathewguglielmi8451 2 года назад

    I pre ordered this. Not all of the trade paperbacks are available to buy. The omnibus is cheaper to buy than the trade paperbacks. Looking forward to reading it.

  • @Mark-pl3bv
    @Mark-pl3bv 2 года назад

    I'll keep my trades as I don't adore this run enough to buy the omnibus, but man this edition is nice to look at!

  • @jesusmetal92107
    @jesusmetal92107 Год назад

    Finally got my copy. Been on an Ed Brubaker kick.

  • @geminisundone
    @geminisundone 2 года назад

    Can't wait to read this for the first time!
    It's in the post, making its way to me right now :)

  • @SuperMtheory
    @SuperMtheory 2 года назад +1

    Do you think DC will ever print an Omni of New Gotham by Rucka?

  • @tyler-reecepaige7040
    @tyler-reecepaige7040 2 года назад +1

    Omar can you please do a top 10 omnibuses for Batman/batfamily

  • @Spiderweb444
    @Spiderweb444 2 года назад +2

    Dude i am so excited to read it!

  • @spencer_a_d_
    @spencer_a_d_ 2 года назад

    Just received mine yesterday, so pumped!

  • @TheComicBookLowdown
    @TheComicBookLowdown 2 года назад

    Man I’ve got the 4 trades of this collected. I’d be tempted to get the omnibus but the extras are the same that are printed in the trades. It’s a great book though, absolutely love Brubaker stories.

  • @jrson5000
    @jrson5000 2 года назад

    Had mine preordered. Cant wait to read it

  • @markzimmer5467
    @markzimmer5467 2 года назад

    Hey Omar; it probably would be good in the comparison to show the new printing with the correction that adds the snow layer that was missing from the first one; people talk about snow but it’s not there in the original printing of the omnibus But was in the floppies.

    • @NearMintCondition
      @NearMintCondition  2 года назад +1

      I didn’t even notice, brother. Filmed this on Monday and I was focused more on the binding.

  • @MPSFilmsOfficial
    @MPSFilmsOfficial 2 года назад

    Unfortunately, that Gotham PD HBO Max show isn't happening anymore, but they're doing an Arkham Asylum show instead, which'll be really interesting!

  • @okja1942
    @okja1942 2 года назад

    Hey Omar! Just finished reading this, and fell in love. First time reading DC! What would you recommend reading straight after this omnibus??

    • @BackwardsBass
      @BackwardsBass 2 года назад

      Not Omar obviously, but I'd go with Batman: The Man Who Laughs, it's Batman's first encounter with the Joker and also written by Brubaker, and if you enjoy that it will put you in a good place to read Batman's origins, so go with Batman: Year One, then follow a Batman reading order, Omar has a few excellent videos on it.

  • @Brovlawski
    @Brovlawski 2 года назад

    Please get some sort of shipping deal for Canadian customers at CGN. Shipping costs are ridiculoussssss, lol.

  • @bigstewinorlando7059
    @bigstewinorlando7059 2 года назад

    This book is in my Next Shipment from DCBS 👍😃Great Video Omar 👍 🤩

  • @gqd1975
    @gqd1975 2 года назад

    Great series. I have the 4 HC's but should read this again.

  • @newspooiechannel
    @newspooiechannel 2 года назад +1

    When I first got into omnis, the two out of print releases that I most wanted were this and Untold Tales of Spider-Man.
    Now both have been reprinted.
    Mwahahahahahahahahahaha.........................!

  • @fireboy312002
    @fireboy312002 2 года назад

    Going to get it. Always wanted it and you do good work...grumble

  • @edy1398
    @edy1398 2 года назад

    Just got it today. Also have the old printing and the TPBs. : D

  • @djsuth7727
    @djsuth7727 2 года назад

    Got my copy last week. Glad it got a reprint ... was probably my biggest whale !

  • @Qwarky
    @Qwarky 2 года назад

    Can't wait for mine!

  • @ge3045
    @ge3045 2 года назад

    Hmm. If your choice were between the Gotham Central omnibus and The War of Realms omnibus which would you choose?

  • @abc98114
    @abc98114 2 года назад +1

    Age rating please?

  • @ComicSwag
    @ComicSwag 2 года назад

    (Jay RoC) powers comic is exactly like law & order but with super power crimes .. the creators of Law & order should have worked on powers.. the wire was a great show but a completely different style of story telling from law & order

  • @casparrasmussen7642
    @casparrasmussen7642 2 года назад

    Can you do a complet complet Reading order of dawn of x Regin of x with al the tie ins a complet cronalgial order with everthing i been looking al over and cant find a complet list i watch your vid on the Reading order but its not complet please please it would mean alot PS sorry bout the spelling

  • @sazmurph540
    @sazmurph540 2 года назад

    So will you be doing a video on the pros and cons of wearing gloves while handling omnis? JK! I've got this ordered and can't wait to read it based on all of the good things I've heard about these stories.

  • @mdb9920
    @mdb9920 2 года назад

    Any chance this would ever be an Absolute edition?

  • @graceypatrick
    @graceypatrick 2 года назад

    Can you do a video on all of the marvel epic collections I am so confused as a new collector

  • @chitownbud4769
    @chitownbud4769 2 года назад

    👍

  • @mrrehino
    @mrrehino 2 года назад

    Got mine ordered

  • @zachi70
    @zachi70 Год назад

    Gau-di-AAno. LOL 😂

  • @JustJerryPodcast
    @JustJerryPodcast 2 года назад

    Is there a batman omnibus that has most of the stories for the batman animated series

    • @NearMintCondition
      @NearMintCondition  2 года назад +1

      Not yet. What you want are the Batman adventure trades.

    • @Faith4vincera
      @Faith4vincera 11 месяцев назад

      They JUST came out with it! Omar has a recent video now 😊

  • @rayshawnwilliams5405
    @rayshawnwilliams5405 2 года назад

    They make an omnibus for the birds of prey

  • @gab7809
    @gab7809 2 года назад

    They are not doing a gotham PD tv show anymore they are doing a Arkham Asylum tv show instead

  • @ST-ko6xb
    @ST-ko6xb 2 года назад

    Fat Omni, in a little coat…

  • @jonkay194
    @jonkay194 2 года назад

    the embossed title is cool and but come on 🤦‍♂️