My desert island Stones album. Their first with Jimmy Miller. And Nicky Hopkins if I remember correctly. Brian Jone's slide guitar on No Expectations was his last gasp with Keith and MIck.
I played this song at my wifes funeral...she was a factory girl . I loved her for almost 50 years, we raised a family. This song was always about us. RIP robin I'll see you on the other side.
Of all the Stones albums this one is my favorite. I love the simplicity and the down home style of strumming the guitar. I've waited for factory girls back when I lived in Cleveland. One girl I knew got a $25 bonus one Christmas and we went out and had a ball on it. Life's little pleasures are seriously underrated.
Yes this song is truly a real gem The first time I heard it I fell right in love with it In 1997 I seen the Stones at Giants Stadium and they played this song on the middle stage and it blew me away What a surprise that was
Love this song, the music and melody, and hilarious lyrics. I can just see Mick and Keith writing the lyrics to this, laughing louder and louder. Beggar's Banquet is a masterpiece of an album.
Some people call this country filler, but not me! The guitar riff behind the melody is unmistakably awesome and really puts it above the filler status.And don't let me get started on the fiddle! One of my favorite Stones country excursions!
Yeah, that was Brian Jones, always on the outskirts of the music with tastefully tasty mandolin or guitar among ouds, etc...the deep end takes us all eventually and remember, only the good die young...
If you just listen to band's hits, especially great ones, you miss so much. I have a friend who knew about Zep and thought he had them pretty much sussed, but when I gave him all the albums and told him to listen, take your time, he came back all wide eyed and short of breath: this shit is good! Same can be said for the Stones.
I think beggars banquet was one of their best,that and let it bleed. Those are my favorite stones albums, not that I dnt love them all lol but they got exile rated to high lol in my opinion!
I serve many factory workers. They are kind, gratuitous folks and supported my small business ALL THE WAY THRU C0VID! Thank you! A Salute to the Salt of the Earth💖
Brian wrote this one about one Ms Benson, who worked in a, where else, factory. His crisp rhythm guitar, fingerpicking, and mandolin are prominent as well. Gone much too soon.
@@fuchsiaswing8545 Nope, Brian had girlfriend that worked in a factory, Keith didn't. His death was faked too, does that tell you anything? The Stones went way downhill without him.
I didn't become a Stones fan until college. Somehow this song escaped me. I like all of the percussion. The Stones have been experimental over the years, which is why they are still around.
What a truly fantastic song How they got the sound for this song is amazing I seen The Stones at Giants Stadium in 1997 And they played This song on the center stage And it blew me away Great Song
I've listened the Stones most of my life, since Satisfaction at least. They produce some of the best Rock ever Gimme Shelter, Sympathy for the Devil, Paint it Black, Miss You. Too many to name here. They also produced some really mundane music. That was their way always experimenting, but hidden in the detritus was gold like Factory Girl. I was always glad I lived through that time.
This WAS the Stones country album. Even the so-called rock songs - Sympathy For The Devil, Street Fighting Man, Stray Cat Blues - have a little country twinge to them. The Stones have tried to slip in a country song here and there on other albums, this album is one of the most satisfying of their long career.
The Rolling Stones are probably at their best when they are not being the Rolling Stones. The Infatuation with Country style music makes them even more endearing then their standard pop rock songs........
Yes one of my favourites. I was on the bus from the police training school in the South of Hong Kong Island to Central in the North. These were rickety old double decker buses bought 2nd hand from the UK. Standing capacity was how many could cram through the entrance door. The bus went on a winding route taking in the northeast of the island which from around Chaiwan to Quarry Bay is crammed with an assortment of factories and very low cost high rise apartment buildings. Housing developments like takooshing built I think on the site of some docks were starting to middle classify quarry Bay but further east it was a teeming Warren with even squatter towns perched on hill/mountain sides. There is a whole other story in the last sentence. Anyway I was on the top deck of the bus at the front and right what we called the drivers seat at school... Drinking in the noise and smells and sights. The bus was rapidly filling up so I shifted to the right to leave space for someone to have a seat. But me being a gwailo the chinese would naturally leave me the whole seat even though it meant they would have to stand. The bus stopped outside a factory and as many of the girl workers crammed onto it as possible. A few went upstairs even though they still had to stand. Anyway one of the girls sat next to me. Dirty hands, dirty clothes etc after a full shift of some unknown duration doing whatever for probably less money than I spent on alcohol which isn't much as you know. What glimpses I could get of her without turning around and staring she had the usual cute face but covered in grime not makeup. And the rest matched. Then she started nodding off to sleep and her head kept touching my shoulder then she would jerk it back and then finally she fell asleep and her warm little head was rested on my shoulder. I hardly moved because I didn't want to wak her. Meanwhile the bus was jolting along the road stopping and starting in the as normal roaring and hooting traffic jam that is Hong Kong. So she slept for I don't know how long until she suddenly woke up, got up and got off the bus at the next stop.
Fantastic Album. Listen to it this way. Throw out 2 songs - Sympathy for the Devil (so sick of that) and great rocker Street Fighting Man (great song but it doesn't but doesn't belong on this album). That leaves 8 songs that are Keith and Mick's Country and Blues masterpiece. Brian was too stoned, drunk and nearly dead to contrubute anything. That's the way I love Beggars Banquet.
My additional verse. Alas, a sad ending showed up. 😥 Waitin' for a girl, and we'll ride the bus to town Waitin' for a girl, and we'll laugh and hang around, Smiles always turn into frowns, Goodbye my factory girl
Good Robot Media Brian only plays slide guitar on No Expectations and acoustic which is almost inaudible on Sympathy but you can just faintly hear it near the beginning during the first verse if you strain your ears. On Dear Doctor, Parachute Woman and Prodigal Son he plays harp. On Jigsaw Puzzle, and Stray Cat Blues he plays mellotron and Street Fighting Man he plays the sitar. All the other guitars were played by Keith except on Prodigal Son were it is said that Dave Mason of Traffic plays also,
Tony C. There is no definitive answer as there are two harps. The one that plays throughout the song and the one at the end. I think the one at the end sounds like Brian as it wails. Something Mick has never done. Mick has never wailed on harp like that. But no one knows because Mick has never said.
Esperando a una pelada Que tiene churcos en el pelo Esperando a una pelada No tiene plata por ningún lado Cojemos buses a todas direcciones Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica Esperando una pelada Sus rodillas son muy gordas Esperando una pelada Viste bufandas en vez de sombreros La cremallera rota por la espalda Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica Esperando una pelada Que me mete en peleas Esperando una pelada Nos emborrachamos viernes por la noche Ella es una vista para ojos irritados Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica Esperando a una pelada Tiene manchas en el vestido Esperando a una pelada Mis pies ya están mojados Ella no ha salido todavía Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica.
Always found it funny when a bunch of Southern English lads tried to sound like a bunch of US cowboys. One day maybe an American band will sing in a cockney accent about goin' down the Old Kent Road.
At some point, the Beatles turned away from songs with true emotion toward gimmicky songs like Yellow Submarine. That is about when the Stones came out with "Sympathy for the Devil", "You can't always get what you want", etc. That is when the Stones became far superior.
video thank you Lucy, Tom and all at YES, thank you Julian and Robin and all at ABKCO and all not named and thank you Lads, Video is Great Great, love all, big
Tony C. There are photos of Brian playing harp at the sessions. Mick was certainly proficient but not enough to play ropey sounding country harp that sounds great as can be heard on Dear Doctor and Prodigal Son. Also if Mick was playing harp on those 2 songs it would most likely have been mixed higher rather than in the background so as to be decorative. It is documented in One Plus One that Brian plays acoustic on Sympathy and sings the woo, woos. Although his mic was turned down his guitar can just be heard during the first verse and was also picked up louder by the film crews cameras. See (The Brian Jones Resource) RUclips page for the film crews recording. That leaves Jigsaw Puzzle and Stray Cat Blues which clearly have mellotron which nobody else but Brian would be playing and Street Fighting Man where his sitar can be heard. Parachute Woman may be Brian at the end and it may be Mick. There is no definitive answer. I personally think it sounds more like Brian but I may be wrong, Brian does not play on Factory Girl as it is documented that Ric Grech of Family plays the fiddle and Dave Mason of Traffic is playing the mandolin. Salt Of The Earth features Keith playing all the guitars. The only doubtful track then is Parachute Woman. It is much more difficult than The Beatles when it comes to The Stones to say definitively who played what as logs were not kept by Decca or Olympic Studios unlike EMI who seemed to be meticulous. So all we have to go on is the printed word with peoples recollections or we have to piece it together from all available sources. I am in no way saying I am 100% correct about the harp players but the evidence points me to think that Brian played harp on Doctor Doctor, Prodigal Son and possibly the end of Parachute Woman. You of course have your own opinion.
4 года назад+1
@@BigSky1 Well, my opinion is that it's perhaps the best Stones album!
je suis bluffé par le trucage: d'un côté, il y a une prise de vue à "plein d'images pas secondes" (le côté film, avec la caméra qui se déplace sur le mur), de l'autre une prise de vue à "une lettre par photo" (le côté "homme invisible, qui écrit des graffitis sur le mur") ... Ce qui me bluffe, au fond, c'est qu'analogiquement, c'est un sacré boulot, quand même... Un truc à la Garcimore. Là, en plus, je trouve que le tout entre dans la catégorie "beaux arts", "arts graphiques". Cela souligne mes limites intellectuelles, au fond: "mais comment fait il ?" Me demandé-je ! Philosophiquement, cela nous révèle au fond quelque chose que nous savons intimement: nous sommes dépassés, plus que jamais, nous sommes dépassés par l'intelligence collective, autant que par sa commerie.
This was the album that made me start loving the Stones. Beggars Banquet is a masterpiece mix of blues and rock, and every cut is a joy to hear.
Same
Me too. And for its still their best.
My desert island Stones album. Their first with Jimmy Miller. And Nicky Hopkins if I remember correctly. Brian Jone's slide guitar on No Expectations was his last gasp with Keith and MIck.
The stones at their best ! No expectations, stray cat blues. Love that album !
You got that right ✅️
I played this song at my wifes funeral...she was a factory girl . I loved her for almost 50 years, we raised a family. This song was always about us. RIP robin I'll see you on the other side.
My sincere condolences. Great choice in song.
I'm so sorry. That's sweet.
good bless brother. I know. so many love you...
I feel happy for your faith, sir.
Well done brother
Of all the Stones albums this one is my favorite. I love the simplicity and the down home style of strumming the guitar. I've waited for factory girls back when I lived in Cleveland. One girl I knew got a $25 bonus one Christmas and we went out and had a ball on it. Life's little pleasures are seriously underrated.
So True
GREAT COMMENT! I too have waited for factory girls, on the corner of the street - this such a great tune i'll wait forever ...
Gram Parsons influence on the band.
Greetings from Cleveland!
Nice post, with great memories.
I have LOVED this tune since the first time I heard it over 52 years ago! What a hidden gem for most folks to discover.
Yes this song is truly a real gem The first time I heard it I fell right in love with it In 1997 I seen the Stones at Giants Stadium and they played this song on the middle stage and it blew me away What a surprise that was
The fiddles and mandolin on this give it a distinct turn of 19th century feel. They were genius even when not setting out to be.
Probably Brian's idea.
Love this song, the music and melody, and hilarious lyrics. I can just see Mick and Keith writing the lyrics to this, laughing louder and louder. Beggar's Banquet is a masterpiece of an album.
This song is such a classic. When I first purchased this album, I listened to this song non-stop. I still love "Factory Girl" to this day. LOVE IT.
Anyone who doesn't love Factory Girl is dosent love great music
Mick's voice rules.
An almost forgotten masterpiece ❤
I think this is my favorite song right now. I'm waiting more for God than a factory girl tho.
This song is criminally underrated, facts🎉🎉
it is a beauty eh...
The album which tweaked the Stones interest into country. One of the 4 best Stones albums.
I love the bluegrass/Celtic vibe.
this is timeless classic
Some people call this country filler, but not me! The guitar riff behind the melody is unmistakably awesome and really puts it above the filler status.And don't let me get started on the fiddle! One of my favorite Stones country excursions!
I would love it if you are Clint Eastwood, the movie actor! I am a big fan! Carolx
Right 😙👌
@@carolcollins4878 It is not. Just one more person afraid to show their real name, cowards. You dont want to know any of them
Yeah, that was Brian Jones, always on the outskirts of the music with tastefully tasty mandolin or guitar among ouds, etc...the deep end takes us all eventually and remember, only the good die young...
@@michaelcraig9449no. We just like our privacy and don't want big brother or any company looking into our business!
If you just listen to band's hits, especially great ones, you miss so much. I have a friend who knew about Zep and thought he had them pretty much sussed, but when I gave him all the albums and told him to listen, take your time, he came back all wide eyed and short of breath: this shit is good! Same can be said for the Stones.
All the Stones albums have great gems like this.
In my opinion, bb is the best stones album ever !
Criminally underrated song..Appalachian music and the Stones kept it real...same goes for “Prodigal Son”
"...her zip broke down the back.... .. & her knees are much too fat .. " love this song! Beggars Banquet is a masterpiece !
I think beggars banquet was one of their best,that and let it bleed. Those are my favorite stones albums, not that I dnt love them all lol but they got exile rated to high lol in my opinion!
For tonight's fare I listened to Dear Doctor first. It's a mood that chooses which song hits first.
@William Ruddock Appalachian music is Irish and Scottish music blended with english ballads.
Doesn't do a whole lot for me. Probably like Sticky Fingers era Stones the best. I like the rock stuff more than the blues/folk/country.
THE ROLLING STONES FOREVER!
One of the coolest songs ever composed!
Without a doubt.
I dated factory girls in the old days and was a factory guy. All good, our anthem.
Yeah so did I , Even wrote poetry for them ….silly boy
Aah
I serve many factory workers.
They are kind, gratuitous folks and supported my small business ALL THE WAY THRU C0VID! Thank you!
A Salute to the Salt of the Earth💖
Brian wrote this one about one Ms Benson, who worked in a, where else, factory. His crisp rhythm guitar, fingerpicking, and mandolin are prominent as well. Gone much too soon.
brian had nothing to do with writing this song and didnt play on the recording
@@joejones9520 Sorry to burst your bubble.
@@bsorryrthatsit7055 silly
What are you talking about? Brian had nothing to do with the writing of “Factory Girl.” Keef wrote the music.
@@fuchsiaswing8545 Nope, Brian had girlfriend that worked in a factory, Keith didn't. His death was faked too, does that tell you anything? The Stones went way downhill without him.
THE ROLLING STONES ARE THE BEST ROCK AND ROLL AND BLUES BAND EVER AND FOREVER. ALSO CAN PLAY COUNTRY, REGGAE, GOSPEL. I LOVE THEM. ❤👍
Yeah, but the Beatles, well, make a little trouble, but everyone have there's opinion
the rolling stones are gross
I concur!
whats a good reggae stones song?
@@jmackman Cherry Oh Baby! UB40 also covered it.
I didn't become a Stones fan until college. Somehow this song escaped me. I like all of the percussion. The Stones have been experimental over the years, which is why they are still around.
All these years I was singing it wrong. Love this version- his howling voice and sparse instrumentals are perfect!
I was a factory girl for a very longtime I really appreciate and love it Love the drums
What a truly fantastic song How they got the sound for this song is amazing I seen The Stones at Giants Stadium in 1997 And they played This song on the center stage And it blew me away Great Song
Flew in from Florida is I for that show. Epic.
Grew up in the country, middle of PA, USA. Have always loved this song.
she's a sight for sore eyes beggars one of the greatest productions of the 20th century
masterpiece of an album. great song!
I've listened the Stones most of my life, since Satisfaction at least. They produce some of the best Rock ever Gimme Shelter, Sympathy for the Devil, Paint it Black, Miss You. Too many to name here. They also produced some really mundane music. That was their way always experimenting, but hidden in the detritus was gold like Factory Girl. I was always glad I lived through that time.
My favorite Stones album.
Gives a whole NEW meaning to " Rosie the Riveter " !!!
such a brilliant album. I've listened to it so many times over the years. in college i listened to it endlessly
This is a honey of a song.
One of my favourite Stones albums. BTW these lyric videos are superb.
hail to the glimmer twins the greatest song writers in rock and roll history
Lennon n McCartney take that accolade
Dave Mason (Traffic) on mandolin. Beautiful song
Actually Ric Grech from Blind Faith
@@johnr8820 Violin and fiddle
Rob B right...Ry Cooder on mandolin
almost as good as ron wood...
...if you play like Mr. Keith, you'll never get tired of strumming the guitar. Never.
This WAS the Stones country album. Even the so-called rock songs - Sympathy For The Devil, Street Fighting Man, Stray Cat Blues - have a little country twinge to them. The Stones have tried to slip in a country song here and there on other albums, this album is one of the most satisfying of their long career.
The most country sounding english song I've ever heard
American as it gets
Ever hear Dead Flowers?
Parece una canción china
Rocky Raccoon by the Beatles. Love the Stones but they did tend to be influenced by the Beatles.
Muswell Hillbillies, the Kinks
Fantastic Music seldom heard these days❤
Long live the memory of the late, great Brian Jones. xoxo The Clarences
- Vocal: Mick Jagger
- Acoustic Guitar: Keith Richards
- Mandolin: Dave Mason
- Violin/Fiddle: Ric Grech
- Congas: Rocky Dijon
- Bass: Bill Wyman
- Tabla: Charlie Watts
₩⁰)⁰₩₩₩
Would have loved to see Brian on there somewhere, the guy was really gone
Why in heavens you don't mention Brian Jones, the soul behind this album.... Which by the way is stones best 3
Thanks for posting the lyric video ABKCOVEVO: love it. Love this song too. Happy Birthday today(July 26) to Mick Jagger. Cheers!
Percussion are awesome on this song
Rolling Stones: patrimonio dell'umanità!
I.ve been waitin' for a GiRL like THat aLL my Life.Love This meGa-MAsTeRPIeCe.THAnK you RoLLinG STones.
The Rolling Stones are probably at their best when they are not being the Rolling Stones. The Infatuation with Country style music makes them even more endearing then their standard pop rock songs........
Easy to sing it & adorable
_Fiddle sound_ 🎻🎶🎶🎶...
One of those great folk 🎶 c moments grom krith snd mick.
Oh my God it's been so Long.God Bless you all!
I love Ringo Watt's drumming on this.
always reminding me of one certain factory girl I once knew
Love it
I did a lot of street music in the late 80ties and I played that song lot,and broke most of the time a string
underrated stones song
la meravigliosa factory girl, i beatles fecero Girl, i rolling stones una ragazza di fabbrica
Just a little diddy of a song love it!
Genius animation
My best frn recommend this song 💜
Yes one of my favourites. I was on the bus from the police training school in the South of Hong Kong Island to Central in the North. These were rickety old double decker buses bought 2nd hand from the UK. Standing capacity was how many could cram through the entrance door. The bus went on a winding route taking in the northeast of the island which from around Chaiwan to Quarry Bay is crammed with an assortment of factories and very low cost high rise apartment buildings. Housing developments like takooshing built I think on the site of some docks were starting to middle classify quarry Bay but further east it was a teeming Warren with even squatter towns perched on hill/mountain sides. There is a whole other story in the last sentence. Anyway I was on the top deck of the bus at the front and right what we called the drivers seat at school... Drinking in the noise and smells and sights. The bus was rapidly filling up so I shifted to the right to leave space for someone to have a seat. But me being a gwailo the chinese would naturally leave me the whole seat even though it meant they would have to stand. The bus stopped outside a factory and as many of the girl workers crammed onto it as possible. A few went upstairs even though they still had to stand. Anyway one of the girls sat next to me. Dirty hands, dirty clothes etc after a full shift of some unknown duration doing whatever for probably less money than I spent on alcohol which isn't much as you know. What glimpses I could get of her without turning around and staring she had the usual cute face but covered in grime not makeup. And the rest matched. Then she started nodding off to sleep and her head kept touching my shoulder then she would jerk it back and then finally she fell asleep and her warm little head was rested on my shoulder. I hardly moved because I didn't want to wak her. Meanwhile the bus was jolting along the road stopping and starting in the as normal roaring and hooting traffic jam that is Hong Kong. So she slept for I don't know how long until she suddenly woke up, got up and got off the bus at the next stop.
Fantastic Album. Listen to it this way. Throw out 2 songs - Sympathy for the Devil (so sick of that) and great rocker Street Fighting Man (great song but it doesn't but doesn't belong on this album). That leaves 8 songs that are Keith and Mick's Country and Blues masterpiece. Brian was too stoned, drunk and nearly dead to contrubute anything. That's the way I love Beggars Banquet.
I was going to say this is the Stone's tribute to the American South, but then England was 'there' centuries ago...
With help from Gram Parsons the American from the South.
0:18 Kilroy was here
That’s a Roy Wood song from The Move
who was kilroy
Bill wyman loves us❤
Waiting for the warm girl outside the damp factory.......
❤️ love this
Almost perfect 👌
Kind of a bluegrass, Indian Raga....🤤🤘
My additional verse. Alas, a sad ending showed up. 😥
Waitin' for a girl, and we'll ride the bus to town
Waitin' for a girl, and we'll laugh and hang around,
Smiles always turn into frowns,
Goodbye my factory girl
I'm reading that Brian wasn't involved in this recording, a shame, it's full of Brian-like sounds
Well, the Stones are not naive. At that time Brian brought very good sounds. They did not want to feel his absence.
Brian does not appear on this or Salt Of The Earth from Beggars Banquet. He plays on all the others.
@@BigSky1 - On Beggars Banquet, the last album the Stones released during his lifetime, Jones plays guitar on only four of the album’s 10 tracks.
Good Robot Media Brian only plays slide guitar on No Expectations and acoustic which is almost inaudible on Sympathy but you can just faintly hear it near the beginning during the first verse if you strain your ears. On Dear Doctor, Parachute Woman and Prodigal Son he plays harp. On Jigsaw Puzzle, and Stray Cat Blues he plays mellotron and Street Fighting Man he plays the sitar. All the other guitars were played by Keith except on Prodigal Son were it is said that Dave Mason of Traffic plays also,
Tony C. There is no definitive answer as there are two harps. The one that plays throughout the song and the one at the end. I think the one at the end sounds like Brian as it wails. Something Mick has never done. Mick has never wailed on harp like that. But no one knows because Mick has never said.
Epic
We all had a factory girl at some time.
Esperando a una pelada
Que tiene churcos en el pelo
Esperando a una pelada
No tiene plata por ningún lado
Cojemos buses a todas direcciones
Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica
Esperando una pelada
Sus rodillas son muy gordas
Esperando una pelada
Viste bufandas en vez de sombreros
La cremallera rota por la espalda
Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica
Esperando una pelada
Que me mete en peleas
Esperando una pelada
Nos emborrachamos viernes por la noche
Ella es una vista para ojos irritados
Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica
Esperando a una pelada
Tiene manchas en el vestido
Esperando a una pelada
Mis pies ya están mojados
Ella no ha salido todavía
Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica
Esperando a la pelada de la fábrica.
Always found it funny when a bunch of Southern English lads tried to sound like a bunch of US cowboys. One day maybe an American band will sing in a cockney accent about goin' down the Old Kent Road.
Good job
This is where I started out. Got out pretty quick.
Country rock before there was...
The Stones, I’ve finally decided, are way better than the Beatles.
At some point, the Beatles turned away from songs with true emotion toward gimmicky songs like Yellow Submarine. That is about when the Stones came out with "Sympathy for the Devil", "You can't always get what you want", etc. That is when the Stones became far superior.
Mark Hollingsworth that was one song lol... the beatles had problems of their own but created some magnificent music. i love both equally lol
@@uu8634 , Ha! Well there are more, but if you like them you are not alone. Enjoy!
PS. How many holes does it really take to fill the Albert Hall?
@ddjdd wfgggb You make a good point. I like them both.
@@factChecker01 Your opinion.
My favorite song.. But many more..
video thank you Lucy, Tom and all at YES, thank you Julian and Robin and all at ABKCO and all not named and thank you Lads, Video is Great Great, love all, big
A great tune by the Stones. Try to give a listen to the version by the band Treat Her Right.
Great song, also last album with Brian Jones
kpax45 ...although Brian does not play on Factory Girl or Salt Of The Earth.
Tony C. Possibly not Parachute Woman but also possibly. Brian is on all the others playing something.
Tony C. There are photos of Brian playing harp at the sessions.
Mick was certainly proficient but not enough to play ropey sounding country harp that sounds great as can be heard on Dear Doctor and Prodigal Son. Also if Mick was playing harp on those 2 songs it would most likely have been mixed higher rather than in the background so as to be decorative.
It is documented in One Plus One that Brian plays acoustic on Sympathy and sings the woo, woos. Although his mic was turned down his guitar can just be heard during the first verse and was also picked up louder by the film crews cameras.
See (The Brian Jones Resource) RUclips page for the film crews recording.
That leaves Jigsaw Puzzle and Stray Cat Blues which clearly have mellotron which nobody else but Brian would be playing and Street Fighting Man where his sitar can be heard.
Parachute Woman may be Brian at the end and it may be Mick. There is no definitive answer. I personally think it sounds more like Brian but I may be wrong,
Brian does not play on Factory Girl as it is documented that Ric Grech of Family plays the fiddle and Dave Mason of Traffic is playing the mandolin.
Salt Of The Earth features Keith playing all the guitars.
The only doubtful track then is Parachute Woman.
It is much more difficult than The Beatles when it comes to The Stones to say definitively who played what as logs were not kept by Decca or Olympic Studios unlike EMI who seemed to be meticulous. So all we have to go on is the printed word with peoples recollections or we have to piece it together from all available sources.
I am in no way saying I am 100% correct about the harp players but the evidence points me to think that Brian played harp on Doctor Doctor, Prodigal Son and possibly the end of Parachute Woman.
You of course have your own opinion.
@@BigSky1 Well, my opinion is that it's perhaps the best Stones album!
Tony C. On that we can both agree.
Daym good
Proletariat anthem of simple working folk.
Dad was a factory boy and mom was a factory girl.
ric grech on fiddle. RIP
should've added the whooo lyric at 2:00
1:12 xxx
Bob Dylan
Dream
RIP Charlie
It's Charlie watts on tabla. Gee how would have thought of that? Brian Jones. Good job Mr. Watts. Mr. Jones?
I'm waiting for a factor girl
je suis bluffé par le trucage: d'un côté, il y a une prise de vue à "plein d'images pas secondes" (le côté film, avec la caméra qui se déplace sur le mur), de l'autre une prise de vue à "une lettre par photo" (le côté "homme invisible, qui écrit des graffitis sur le mur") ... Ce qui me bluffe, au fond, c'est qu'analogiquement, c'est un sacré boulot, quand même... Un truc à la Garcimore. Là, en plus, je trouve que le tout entre dans la catégorie "beaux arts", "arts graphiques". Cela souligne mes limites intellectuelles, au fond: "mais comment fait il ?" Me demandé-je ! Philosophiquement, cela nous révèle au fond quelque chose que nous savons intimement: nous sommes dépassés, plus que jamais, nous sommes dépassés par l'intelligence collective, autant que par sa commerie.
The Rolling Stones could do anything this is the countriest of the countriest and I say that as a southern boy
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Chicago Waiting for Farm Girls and a Factory Girl
she's a sight for sore eyes
Robert Ryan: Doesn't it bother you, working in the cannery?
Marilyn Monroe: What SHOULD I work at?
- Clash by Night
Beggars Banquet to Exile the Stones best