Ungrateful Millennial listens to Pink Floyd for the FIRST TIME - Music Share Stream Reaction
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 авг 2024
- Please like, comment and subscribe for more content!
Video: • Pink Floyd - Time (Off...
Stream highlight from 9/11/2022. Listening to Time by Pink Floyd
Streaming on Mondays and Thursdays at 5pm EST and Sundays at 10am EST over at / keyofweird
Join our Discord to share your music! / discord
Follow me at / keyofweird for my terrible humor and even worse takes!
OR following me on Instagram for my fitness journey
/ keyofweird
0:00 -
We all can’t wait to not hear the music you put out!
Already have a video: ruclips.net/video/09HXef5vUaM/видео.html
Here's the band's SoundCloud: m.soundcloud.com/theninechoirs
@@keyofweird I figured I would go away, listen to this and then come back and trash it.... but I quite enjoyed your music. Second song gave me Kings of Leon vibes at parts. Crowning the Hangman reminded me a bit of something I would hear from A Perfect Circle. Anyway, wish you and the band all the best going forward :)
I think you would have gotten less hate from us PF fans if you had not went into the reaction video already clearly dismissing it before you had heard it. And then actually paying proper attention to it rather than playing with your own guitar.
I appreciate you taking the time to listen to it. Unfortunately, the band broke up shortly after we finished up the demo 🤣
Also, what you guys see as clearly dismissive is actually a joke about how my viewers think I'm weird for not having listened to a lot of popular music growing up. In my chat on the top left corner, you can see one of them say, "Time to culture your ass" because they brought the song to the stream to have me listen to it. I'm not actually dismissing the song before I listen to it. I'm being facituous. It's an "unfortunate" by-product of these reactions. Some of the context is lost between the live stream Music Share and the edited video that gets uploaded to RUclips. Hopefully that clears things up.
A true Legend in his own mind.
You are a great example of why people don’t like millennials.
Because we're so cool and vibrant and full of youthful exuberance?
@@keyofweird Nope. Because you're so full of yourself!
Jacques coming out the shadows with the 3 point dunk!
No, It’s because they’re arrogant and think they know everything.
@@keyofweird Hahahahaahaahaahaahaa, more like a fashion cliché.
Never was a happier to see someone's content come to an end.
Wow, even Hitler?
You do realize that most people coming here know and love Pink Floyd, right? Good luck growing your chanel with this attitude! 🤣
Thank you Mr. Bengiskhan for illustrating a point I'll be making in my next video.
This channel is garbage.
🗑️👎🏼👎🏼
Listen to it in 10 years time. Then 20 years time, then 30 years time.. You'll eventually get it.
It's funny you say that because I love doing that. It's cool to hear music during different portions of your life and seeing how it bounces off in new ways. Although, I'm not sure what "getting it" means. Chances are I'll still like similar music to what I like now with maybe a little variation if I don't stay stagnant. Prog Blues just isn't the thing I normally vibe to. Now Prog Latin Rock, that I can get behind.
It’s the truth. I’ve been hearing this song since birth. I’m 40 years old and only fairly recently has it really really sunk in. I can just imagine listening to it as an old man.
It be like that sometimes.
An extremely painful watch through and through. From the wrong-note playing all over the recordings, to not even being able to finish a song without being distracted by random bullshit, to the L take after L take. Like this dude with 771 subscribers called lord of the rings and pink floyd "quaint" lol
By this guys logic "Beethoven was doing some cool lil stuff but its just so old and boring like just play a different groove don't do what youre doing"
Not to mention Imagine being a guitarist and having zero appreciation for one of the GOATS of guitar David Gilmour.
Next he'll be like oh yea zeppelin is too bluesy lmfao
Like no shit. It all came from the blues.
Gonna have to agree with everybody else in the comments you are in no proper headspace to even begin to comprehend/enjoy Pink Floyd.
Hi Joseph. Going off your picture, it looks like you're a younger dude so I can finally take my frustrations out on someone in this comment section without feeling like I'm committing elder abuse. Thank you for your contribution to my mental well being.
Yes, I was playing the wrong notes. I don't have perfect pitch. People without perfect pitch tend to need some time to figure out the chords.
Yes, I pause, rewind, and talk during these as they're from a stream because 1, I'm talking to my viewers and 2, it makes it easier for the VOD to not get muted.
Yes, I have 771 subscribers. I don't know why it matters to you. If I had a million subscribers, would that make me more correct?
Yes, by my logic Beethoven did do some pretty cool things and I would get bored after about a minute. I know because I've had to listen to it.
In the video, I literally say I appreciate the band for what they contributed to music.
While Zeppelin is definitely Bluesy, Bonham was an absolutely groovy motherfucker who brought out a lot more than just Blues.
And lastly, Joseph, I couldn't give one less of a shit about all the people in these comments (other than the fucking sweet ass engagement). The video is the most milquetoast "criticism" of Pink Floyd imaginable and you guys are incapable of even imagining that someone, somewhere doesn't like SOME aspects of one, singular Pink Floyd song.
You didn't write the song and you aren't in Pink Floyd and even if you were this isn't an attack on your personhood, your mental state, your past, or any music you've made past, present, or future. ✌️
he's mentally ill..period.
Actually true.
@@keyofweird do you ever do anything else .get a real life.
Dude you get to just listen to appreciate the greatness of this band. Your generation has no clue at all
What?
we had longer attention spans back then..... no auto-tune either... no internet and no digital industry
And the black death, segregation, and multiple world wars. Funny how things change.
@@keyofweirddude, are you okay up there? Wow. 🤦🏽
@@yubnub420gaming My guy. Did you really dislike my content and then go find more content to dislike and then ask me if I'M OKAY?!
I’ve listen to many reaction videos to Pink Floyd… You’re certainly entitled to your opinion… But your reaction, was surprising to me
Now that's a stellar review.
Ngl, I keep coming back to this video just to look at all the salty comments.
My man! ❤️
You chose an appropriate name for your channel dude.
Believe it or not, my channel name before this was way better.
most of the music you listen to now has been influenced by this band, one way or another. They were ground breaking, creative and fearless of critisism. Good luck with hearing any creativity in 2023
Yikes, Carol. Yikes.
@@keyofweird Sorry, sir, didnt mean to sound harsh. just hanker for a simpler, free world, were people could express themselves
@@keyofweird and people will still be listening to their music in millenia to come, they are timeless, many think futuristic, always touching the soul of man
@@carolynkehoe4119 sure you can express yourself, but there are still many creative bands in 2023 they just aren't mainstream mostly. Pink Floyd did influence alot of bands, just because they tried out new stuff and made others try out new stuff too.
@@Z_E_B_O prove it. What artist in 2023 can match up to Pink Floyd? No joke, I'm gonna need some evidence. 😂
masterpiece wasted on this guy .......next!!
Are you typing "next" in hopes that the magic box in front of you will play the next video? It doesn't work like that. You have to take the mouse and click on it for it to play.
Hope that helps!
Listen "one of these days", but it's nothing personal😂😂
Just listened. I actually kinda dig it. The delayed bass line is funky as fuck and infectious.
not sure why you are showing us a guitar you cant even play
I'm not showing you my guitar. I'm playing it on stream. Duuuuuuuh
Perfect! The brain has exactly one center for listening! If you're listening to your internal dialogue, you stop hearing what's going on around you. So while you're noodling on your guitar, you miss what's going on in the music. So we got to watch you react to yourself not paying attention. I can't wait to see your other reactions to what you don't listen to.
Can I ask you a genuine question? Do you think you'd be leaving a similar comment if I did everything the exact same way but, instead, only said good things about the song?
Exactly. 💯
He doesn't understand the meaning, nor the definition of music apparition. To actually sit and listen to it and make a fair and honest judgment at the end, instead of bashing and dismissing it before even giving it a chance. It's sad that my own generation has such a low attention span. 🤦🏽
It's obvious that it's just a joke to him and he's not really reacting to anything at all, especially if he's to putting his attention toward playing an instrument while supposedly reacting to a song for the first time. The truth is that at the end it's a nun genuine reaction. The Kid isn't ready to the possibility of having his mind changed, thus; coming in with the same simpleton attitude and ignorant judgment he ends in. 😑
@@yubnub420gaming I did make a fair and honest judgement. You just don't like the conclusion and are too emotionally immature to take it so you invent reasons as to why I didn't get it. It's the same whiny, cry-baby bullshit that everyone else said in these comments.
I'll ask you the same exact question. If I had done the same exact video but only said positive things about Opeth and Pink Floyd, would you still be lambasting in my comments?
@@keyofweird Okay, it took me some time to formulate a response that wasn't a simple knee-jerk reaction to your response. So as a musician, let me ask you a question. I come into your performance, specifically to give you feedback on your music. While you're performing, you notice that I'm talking to people at the bar, scrolling through my notebook and talking on my phone. At the end of the performance, you ask me how I liked your music. I say "Oh, uh, it was good. Real good." Now, I ask you, is that a valid assessment of your performance? It was, after all, positive, right? So whether you liked PF or not, your review lacked authenticity. One other person on here listened to some of your work, and by his own admission, was ready to rip it. He, instead, found quality and expressed as much. Now that's a valid critique.
_Okay, it took me some time to formulate a response that wasn't a simple knee-jerk reaction to your response._
Hey dude! I know we're at opposite sides of this but I sincerely do appreciate you taking time to think about my question and coming back in with a level head. Much respect.
_So as a musician, let me ask you a question._
Shoot.
_I come into your performance, specifically to give you feedback on your music. While you're performing, you notice that I'm talking to people at the bar, scrolling through my notebook and talking on my phone. At the end of the performance, you ask me how I liked your music. I say "Oh, uh, it was good. Real good." Now, I ask you, is that a valid assessment of your performance?_
I'm not exactly sure what you mean by valid. Valid, in this case, seems to imply "thorough" or "well thought out" so if that's the case, then I would say no, that wasn't a thorough or well thought out assessment. However, to me, every opinion is technically valid, but, I care more about who the person is and why they're saying what they're saying. For example, I have no idea who you are or what you do so I wouldn't put much stock into your assessment, positive or negative, though it would make me feel good about myself. However, if we use the same scenario but swap you out for a touring drummer who I admire, that assessment may mean the world to me.
_It was, after all, positive, right?_
Yes, it was positive but I have a feeling we aren't talking about the same thing anymore.
_So whether you liked PF or not, your review lacked authenticity._
So "valid" means "authentic"? How can you reliably test for that? How do you know what authenticity from me looks like?
_One other person on here listened to some of your work, and by his own admission, was ready to rip it. He, instead, found quality and expressed as much. Now that's a valid critique._
I don't understand how this is a valid critique. They said one song sounded like Kings of Leon and the other like A Perfect Circle and nothing else. Here, it seems "valid" no longer implies "thorough" or "authentic." Now it seems like "valid" means, "Thought one thing but came out with a different conclusion."
Your scenario isn't analogous to what I asked and doesn't answer my initial question. You left a negative comment insinuating that since I was doing other things, there's no way I was listening to the song. My question wasn't "Do you think a positive reaction would make it more of a valid assessment?" My question was, "If I sat there and played my guitar and paused a whole bunch but only said positive things about the song, would you feel it necessary to still write your comment?"
This is why I'm working on a video about music reactions. It seems to me that people, and I mean no offense, care more about a sense of validation and community when they watch music reactions. Much like showing a friend a new song you know they'd like, people come to these videos to find another person who also likes what they like to feel something like that. That's why despite calling this a reaction and voicing some critical, yet specific criticism, I'm told I wasn't thorough enough or just don't understand what I'm listening to. This isn't meant to be a full critique of the song, album or band. It's a reaction that I had during a Music Share stream where people come in and share music with me and other viewers. I say what I say, try to give my best guess at why I'm feeling how I feel, add information when possible and try to stay away from certain language like "good" and "bad" while using "I feel" statements.
Best band ever
I'm glad you like them!
100%
Is there any way I can take my view back from being counted? I wonder what you'll be listening to in 50 years? Taylor Swift? In 100 years people will still be listening to PF. Everyone is wrong I guess
You're an older gentleman so I'm not sure if that's a joke or not. But, just in case, no Mr. Farha, you cannot take your view back. It's mine forever. I'll hold it close to my heart.
Also, I'm not sure what I'll be listening to in 50 years. It might be Pink Floyd for all I know.
"ungrateful" fits
Yes, I am really good at RUclips titles
@@keyofweird
pointing out the obvious can have the makin's for a good title, I guess.
Made you click, didn't it? 😘
@@keyofweird
Yes, it did.
Clicks over likes, eh?
Is that how it's done?
On RUclips? I think both are good? Views are a good number to show but likes and comments show engagement which is also pretty good.
You found 771 subscribers?
18 pussies
Dude rhis is one song from an immense catalog. This was written in 1972 and was groundbreaking at the time. Some Pink Floyd you need to have patience for. Try The Wall. I think that’s a better fit for your attention span.
sure, it's a shame to not listen to the wall or DSOTM in full as its supposed to be listened to. Listening to time after "on the run" just hits harder than listening to it on its own.
but this is a clip from a music share where the discord requests are gone through, so theres a limit of 10mins and its a mush of genres.
Look at my homie coming to defend me 😭😭😭
Got 6 minutes in, I'll never get it back. Good luck on your channel, you will need it.
Appreciate you, dawg. This is just a fun thing to do, not a career I'm trying to make. Hope you manage to find those 6 minutes again.
Obviously, this music goes over your head...:(
Obviously.
You are supposed to listen to the full album in one sitting with your eyes closed. Then you’ll understand Pink Floyd man.
I think I get them. I just wasn't, and still not, in the head space to enjoy it all that much. Maybe in a few years I'll really be into Blues and will wrap back around to this song and enjoy how they play in the genre.
@@keyofweirdman listen to the song dogs. Really listen to the lyrics and how it tells a story. I appreciate that you are honest and don’t cater to anyone, but please give them more of a chance. This isn’t their only good album. Throw a dart at a wall of Pink Floyd albums from the 70s and you’ll land on a work of art.
Mid 80's ha, that puts them at least 10 years ahead of the pack. Current stuff is more experimental, wtf, these guys were creating loops by measuring actual tape and running it around the studio, not sitting at a computer console with a mouse.
I'm not entirely sure what you're getting at. Technology changing means experimenting comes from different avenues. We don't need to create loops by measuring out tape anymore. Instead, we now use DAWs and plug-ins to combine different types of sounds which is experimental, even if it doesn't meet your standard.
Furthermore, I don't understand this obsession with calling out one particular portion of the music sphere and using it as a metric for the rest. There are still plenty of musicians who use real instruments in unique ways and who are constantly pushing virtuosity. There's more music than just what's on the radio or on the Top 100.
Pink Floyd isnt for everyone. I prob dont like your music either.
But they were one of the top selling bands of all time, hard to argue that. Not one, but two albums on the all time charts.
You're right, Pink Floyd isn't for everyone and you probably wouldn't like my music either. Glad we could come to an agreement.
And you're correct, there is no arguing with how many albums were sold. We seem to keep good track of that.
If that doesn't rock your boat, try( Echoes ) live in Pompey. I get goosebumps every time.
Appreciate the chill comment, boss. Next time I'm in the mood, I'll make sure to keep it in mind.
Hope you have a good day.
Hey man! I feel sorry for ya! Please pay attention to the lyrics! It is the story of everyone´s life. Yes! Yours too.
Hey Jose! I appreciate the chill comment.
In all honesty, I don't care about lyrics, like, 90% of the time. The way my brain works, lyrics are separate from the music and I usually only care about the music portion of the song. I know it sounds weird but it's just how it happens up there.
@@keyofweird you should really listen to the lyrics, or at least read them on google or something.
For some songs, particularly rap songs, I'll have the lyrics up but, again, I just don't seem to care most of the time.
@@keyofweird Ok pal! I respect your way of listening ... songs? I enjoy music the most but lyrics are important too.
That 12 minute comment hurt, especially considering their discog since they have a lot of longer progressive songs. Also, the whole dark side of the moon album is a concept album with many songs leading into one another, the wall being an overarching narrative, animals being 3 long songs loosely based on Orwellian ideas. Some of their older work around Syd Barrett’s time sounds very unique among their discography, as well.
There are also lots of bands, like Yes, Jethro Tull, Caravan, who have multiple 20-40 minute songs with interesting structures coming out of the 70s. Just in case longer music interests you!!
Pink Floyd´s music is great! Think about this... They started in the late 60´s doing music but the main thing is not how they play, is what they tell you in the lyrics also.
You sure find yourself entertaining, do you spend a lot of time practicing in front of a mirror?
Your mom's mirror mostly.
Pink Floyd is Legendary, they are an Experience! They ARE a Blues based band, like virtually every other Rock & Roll bands to come out of England in the 1960s. In fact, they took their name from two old time American Blues guitarists from the mid 1900,...
.... PINK Anderson, and FLOYD Council.
They are in the top 3 GOAT Rock Bands, millions of
Man, please don't react to Pink Floyd with your Stratocaster in hand, trying to find the chords! We can hear your guitar and all the wrong notes you're hitting, over the recording, trying to find those chords, LMFAO!!
In fact, you shouldn't react to Pink Floyd at all really, haha, you probably shouldn't even listen to them, you're not ready, you don't have the right frame of mind, lol!
I'm a 66 year old Baby Booming Rock guitarist, that has been a PF fan since the release of their epic "Dark Side of the Moon" album in 1973. I've seen virtually all the great Classic Rock bands from the late 60s and 1970s in my younger days.
Not that that makes any difference to anyone, I just want whoever reads this, to know I'm not a young, ignorant, petulant little child, like many millennials are these days, Ha.
I still gave you a like to help you out man.
Have a nice day!
Remember to wipe down the keyboard when you're done. Wouldn't want to keep it sticky for the next time.
Haha!
@@scozz6139you called it when you said that he definitely isn't ready and isn't in the right frame of mind. 😂
As a millennial, I'm embarrassed of the simpleton attitude and attention span of my generation, and the lack of appreciation for great music and artist.
I personally love Pink Floyd. My favorite album til this day is still, Wish You Were Here.
KEY, now I can't really say that I'm agreeing with your reactions or points of view, but I still recommend to listen to the album off camera without pause or distraction. The Wall, and Dark Side of the Moon are also phenomenal albums I recommend to listen to from beginning to end, again without pause or distraction. Now go use that ADHA of yours to hyper-focus for once. 😂
This guy has a very simple mind
Thanks for clicking on the video, Alan!
@@keyofweird oh I did not watch it all not even half.
🤣🤣🤣 It's a good thing you stopped when you did. You would've found out that I actually liked a portion of the song and then you wouldn't have anything to get mad at. Phew
OMG... I'm surprised you didn't have your phone out
It's on the side. Your mom kept texting me.
The deaf leading the deaf
The irony is palpable.
@@keyofweird the “Pink Floyd is mid tier boomer rock” is the most boring kind of pretentious. But I’m sure you’ll gain traction any day now
You really don't see the irony in leaving a comment like, "The deaf leading the deaf" to a video where I said I enjoyed parts of it and didn't enjoy other parts of it?
Also, I never said they were "mid tier boomer rock." I read a viewer's message and didn't even agree with them but I guess you think that's all of us even though the vast majority of the messages were positive?
These are highlights from a stream, doofus. And those have been gaining traction despite the Salty Sallies in my RUclips comments. I understand that you clicked on this video in hopes of finding some sort of validation. My sincerest apologies for your bruised ego. I hope you find what you're looking for.
I actually didn’t watch the whole video. It was mid lol
@@keyofweird but don’t worry, I’m sure you’ll be the next brad taste in music
I've come across people like this in my lifetime. They are compelled to be contrarian to things that are popularly enjoyed.
Do you sincerely think that every single person who doesn't like something popular is just a contrarian? Are you so self-absorbed that someone saying, "I like the chord progressions and melodies but got bored at the slow, bluesy rhythm" makes you think they're being compelled to hate it? Did you even bother to watch the video or did you scroll down, see the comments, and just make an assumption?
@Key of Weird No, it's an observation of this person and how and why "he" explained his reasons. Which were arbitrary. So get over yourself. Typical, low brow. I never said "everyone" who didn't like anything was wrong. You interjected that because you only thought it halfway through.
@@keyofweird I wonder who made the assumption.
You said "I've come across people" and "They are compelled" and then you lumped me into that.
What in the fuck is arbitrary about not enjoying slow, bluesy rhythms? Rhythm in music isn't arbitrary.
@Key of Weird Exactly what I said, just because I said people you thought I meant everyone. I said "people like" immediately followed by this. You picked out words that could mean inclusive and forgot who the statement directed you to. I was clearly talking about you. You described your reason for not completely liking this or something else because of its relative placement in time from the present. That's arbitrary. I don't care what you like or don't like, but I did want to point out your arbitrary reason for not. You are awfully thin-skinned for someone posting videos and expecting comments. You should limit your viewership to people who will reinforce your talking points and away from people making observations based on their anecdotal experiences. Keep on keeping on.
Your point is that this music is 50 odd yrs old and you are what 20 something. Well when I was 20 in the sixties listening to 50 yr old music would have been shit. This music though was ahead of it's time.
We all hear things differently.
Very true! ❤️
(4:00) Stops during historic guitar solo on the greatest album ever recorded ... to read comments and sneeze.
Lmao
Pink Floyd plays music. Man dares to exist.
Good luck with your attitude
Thanks! You too!
Glad you can at least said you can appreciate this. Modern music sucks. Nowadays feels like it's all cut, copy, and paste. There is nothing new out there that is unique. Pink Floyd is the definition of unique.
This is just untrue unless your eyes are glued to the Top 40.
Cast pearls amongst Swine
It's "Casting pearls before swine"
Yes, it's old but it's one of the most famous albums of all time for a reason. What's new that's better? I can't think of any band today that is remotely close in talent. Even worse are "artists" who only use a laptop to create music.
What's new that's better? I can't say for sure until we put down parameters that we can measure bands against.
Also, I used to be a lot like you. I would dismiss musicians who made their music on computers because I would think that the art is in the instrument but my perspective has shifted over time. The computer is the instrument and there's nothing wrong with that. There are things that those musicians can do that I can't and vice versa. Also, not for nothing, but Pink Floyd is an experimental band and, if I had to hazard a guess, I would assume they would have no problem with using laptops to make music.
I love your stuff papi chulo!
Took me a hot second to know who this was lmao
It’s classical rock.
True!
Or if you want something that gets a bit funkier
Pink Floyd "Echoes" (Part 1) live at Pompeii 1972
Maybe this song is not for you and if you need something more hard-edged by Pink Floyd you should try something from their Animals album. Maybe the song "Sheep"! I guarantee the production is off the charts!!!!
The album's loosely based off of George Orwell's animal farm with human behavior attributed to different animals!
I do like the sound of that. Thanks Jon! I'll make sure to keep it in mind when I'm rolling through the Pink Floyd discography.
I prefer you say you don't like rather than pretend you do.
I didn't pretend?
just what i would expect from a close mined millennial cause you need a open mine, 743 wks on the charts P.F is not music you just hear you have to LISTEN to it
That's a super original idea you have there. You must be right.
Both pink floyd and TOOL will always get alot of views. I highly recommend checking out. Sober by TOOL
Oh God. _And_ you're a Tool fan?
@@keyofweird lol anyone that isn't a TOOL fan hasn't really listened to them
Did you READ the Hobbit and the rest of the books, or just going from a convoluted movie ? Man buns have come and gone sonny.
Try listening to Jethro Tull's THICK AS A BRICK if you think that this was too tame for your taste. Same time period, try something difficult for your sensibility as a master musician such as your self. You talked all the way through while reading. If you didn't like it at the end more power to you, everyone has an opinion, they're like ass holes. You knew before you started you weren't going to like it, and I truly hope you have a good day anyway.
I watched the director's cuts of the OG Trilogy.
Also, thanks for the man bun comment, gramps. You're the first one.
@@keyofweird by the way, my hair and beard are much longer than yours and the gramps thing isn't a dig to me, I am. If you're not going to actually listen to the music and fuck around while saying that you're listening, you probably won't get many more subs than you have. Again have a good day anyway, kid.
Oh that's cool! My beard sorta stalls out around this length unless I want to look more homeless than I already do. If your hair is longer, then you should understand why I have it in a bun, my dude. Why the personal attack?
As for my subs, I think I'll be okay. I've gotten 4 since this video came out so it looks like it resonates with at least some amount of people. Thankfully, music reactions aren't the only content I make or plan on making in the future so while I appreciate your absolutely not sarcastic and well meaning suggestion, I think I'm doing just fine.
Thanks again, old timer.
You updated the comment since the first time.
I'll check out Jethro Tull. I've always liked the name so it'll be fun to put a face to the name, so to speak.
I never claimed to be a master musician. Even if I was, it wouldn't matter. An opinion is an asshole, right?
I didn't know I wasn't going to like it. I know the general Pink Floyd vibes but I've never listened to a whole song before. In fact, I have another video on my channel where I tell a viewer that my only real connection to Pink Floyd is a cover of The Wall by Korn from a few years back.
@@keyofweird I apologize, about the personal attack, really didn't mean anything by it. But sonny, ya did drop the ball on " listening " to the music. If you don't like it at the end that's fine, but really need to listen to the music. Bcuz you seemed so uninterested in the beginning of the reaction. Which came across as , well, to be honest kinda dick headed.
Like I had mentioned try Thick as a Brick by Jethro Tull. I've watched classical composers that were amazed by the music of the TULL band. Have a good day, kid ! In fact if you have the patience, just give it a listen on your own, without reaction.
I'd give anything for you to listen to the lyrics of Hank Williams Sr song, I'm so lonesome I could cry.
The worst thing in the world is to let yourself pigeon hole yourself into one type of music. You will miss so much beautiful music that way.
When I was growing up my folks would listen to big band and country, didn't have much to say about it. It was a pretty big deal to watch the Beatles on Ed Sullivan I was 10.
You either got to enjoy what was on or cry and whine about it. And there was no whining in my house.
The only music that I don't like is polkas. And with a last name like mine, I heard plenty of that too. Being your age you have everything practically at your finger tips, actually you do.
PATIENTS IS THE NAME OF THE GAME. Have a good one.
Why even react to it? You went it to it for the sole purpose of mocking it. It was obvious and sitting there with your guitar not being able to figure out what is being played all the while complaining it's old. 🙄
This is a highlight from a stream where my viewers share music with me and the rest of the community. I don't ignore songs just because I feel like I may not be in the mood.
Also, you're like the 5th person to mention the guitar thing. I paid for it with my own money and I'll play it when I feel like it.
Plank .
i liked you and then I didn't
Eric, my boy. Say it ain't so.
Weona la weá! nunca habrá wea más wena!
Aguante Pink Floyd y al que no le gusta lo paso por el borde!
Sorry for you
Honey, imma need to you add a few extra words for this to qualify as a sentence.
Get over yourself. ...you might learn something.
What do you think I'd learn? I hope it's something cool like Japanese or trigonometry.
Maybe its not your thing, (a bit like being colour blind, no use explaining)
Omg you're *so* funny. What are you doing in my comments, cutie? Shouldn't you be in my DMs?
You seem to think everything should be the same.
I don't.
You have yet to find your calling. This is not it. Your simple, inexperienced mind is incapable of absorbing complex and beautiful music. You did not even try. What does “Lord of the Rings” have to do with music?
Did you ask me a question about the video where I give an explanation of the comparison between LotR and Pink Floyd in the same comment where you said I have a simple, inexperienced mind?
heyo. its kinda been a while, stuff has happened but im back. i may even tune into streams again.
also i really like pink floyd but i really dislike the dark side of the moon album.
they did make muuuch slower songs than this and i really like them. for example shine on me crazy diamond but obviously i could see why people thinks its faar to slow for them
shine on me crazy diamond is like.. i think 40minutes long and i think just 6minutes are actually singing sections
anyway. hope ur doin well man. take care
oh they do like their long intros. they basically always do those and i actually like it
Pindo, my dude! Great to see you around again!
Despite the title and a few dull moments, I actually enjoyed it. Pink Floyd has always been on the music bucket list and this helped me understand what they sound like and it's something I'm still looking forward to exploring.
Honestly, I don't have a huge problem with long intros. It might just be a product of the Music Share format where I feel a need to get through as much music as possible so everyone can get a chance. Definitely something I'll need to think about.
@@keyofweird i mean.. to be fair
atlest for me. the long intro is just kinda the, ok we r goin chill sudo depressed deep mode now. Maybe im weird for that. But most of their songs cover mental health and stuff so jeah..
Maybe you could listen to High hopes by them. It starts much quicker. but you really dont need to make me feel like you like the songs when u actually dont.
well.. atleast i hope ur not
BUT if u really want to u could give it a listen
Also, same goes to you
nice to see u on my feed again
Have a goodone
"Money" would have been a better first Pink Floyd track😉
Phil, you are a gentleman and a scholar. I appreciate the recommendations. I've gotten a few from my audience as well. I look forward to listening to Money.
I realize it's not like what you're used to listening to like " girls just wanna have fun" and probably some rave techno garbage. Definitely trolling for views. Subbing would be a joke woke.
Girls Just Wanna Have Fun is a fucking bop and will not have this slander in my comments section. You'll keep Ms. Lauper's good name out of your fucking mouth if you know what's good for you.
hears one song and assumes PF is predictable
Can I ask where in the video I said that?
@@keyofweird where u think all PF has some kinda bluesy to it
@@keyofweird 11:52
Checked it out and I can see why you think that. Sorry for the confusion.
I didn't mean "all of Pink Floyd's discography is predictable." I meant "they", as in the band members are all playing like they're in an old blues band, which, to be fair to them, makes sense since Pink Floyd took a lot of influence from blues music of that era.
@@keyofweird ok thanks for clarifying this, i do like the fact that u addressed that they are prog rock them being one of the originators of the genre.
I love that your honest, props for that, most youtube reactions are fake AF.
There are huge bands that I don't 'get' and have been questioned for, to each their own I say, however...
....you don't need to be a d1ck about it.
That might be why you are getting sh1t in the comments, your opinion would be more respected if you presented that opinion with a little respect.
Can you please tell me where I was a dick about it?
@@keyofweird well that was the impression I was getting .... and it seems I'm not alone....
For instance, you are suggesting ways to improve the song, to me thats like saying " I kinda like the Mona Lisa, but if it was me, a nobody who has never painted before, I would make her smile more and then I would really like it "
These guys have sold a quarter of a billion LPs, not downloads or streams, physical LPs, LPs that you had to drive into town to buy with 10% of your weekly wage...
...and your telling us/them how you would improve that?
GTFOH.
I'm not suggesting ways to improve the song. I'm giving reasons as to why I don't enjoy portions of the song and what I would do instead. There's nothing to fix here. You can't fix music.
There's literally nothing wrong with giving an opinion on art. It doesn't matter how old it is, who made it, or how many people like it. None of that is relevant. If someone looks at the Mona Lisa and they think it'd be cooler if she smiled more, that's fine, regardless of their skill level. They're allowed to have their opinion.
And for fuck's sake. Just because a whole gaggle of retards decided to show up to my video and shriek at the top of their lungs because someone had the most mild of "criticism" to a song they like, doesn't make them right.
Well it was nice knowing you ,each there own ,.so sad 🤡
You knew me? Did you know the others?! Where have they gone?!
@@keyofweird so sad , nothing wrong with your own opinion,what a waste .have a great life 😭
If there's nothing wrong with my own opinion why would it be a waste? Chris, have you been hitting the sauce again? Your mom and I already spoke to you about this. When was the last time you went to a meeting?
@@keyofweird you would have to be great to talk to my mother,she died an horrendous death seven years ago .stop trying to be something you are not .no shame in being yourself .and that's what makes a good utube reactioner .🤗
Then who have I been talking to this entire time? Oh fuck. Chris! It's in the house! Run, Chris! Ruuuu....
this man is just silly
I identify as a Silly Goose so I'm glad I'm halfway there.
Dude 😂 Can't stop laughing at this comment section.
Can't believe people are taking so much offense.
DSOTM is probably on my top 10 favorite albums and i'm PARTICULARLY obsessed with Time lately, for no reason.
I think your first reactions are pretty genuine and the stream layout is awesome. Happy that your channel might be gaining some traction now, at least lol
Looking forward for more
My friend, I would like to thank you for keeping an open heart and watching the video. A lot of people in my audience seem to really like Pink Floyd and I can see why. Despite my need for more spastic rhythms, Pink Floyd has a way of dancing around chords and melodies that I enjoy.
I appreciate you taking the time to write the comment. It really means a lot. I hope to see you around. 🙏
really..this guys a total moron.
Now, Nicholas, other people are allowed to like me even if you don't. It's gonna be alright, sweetie.
Maybe you will appreciate it some time in the future when you grow up?
That's not out of the realm of possibility for me. I stuck to Metal when I was a teenager but ventured off into different genres the older I got.
Ignorance is blissfully ignorant.
Lol nailed it.
Lol. Ed Sheeran or whoever you enjoy is not prog. Worst generation ever :(
How about The Mars Volta? Coheed and Cambria? Tesseract? Porcupine Tree? Karnivool?
@@keyofweird how about being stuck in a tiny bubble that wasn't really that good to be begin with? Frances the mute was fire though :)
Hey, would you look at that? You're only half as brain dead as you type.
@@keyofweird brain dead lol. Your generation is the only one so far that lost the ability to think critically for themselves. I'm sure there will be some tiktoks or IG posts that will tell you what is cool or not :)
Homie, you're still yelling at clouds over here? Don't you have a rocking chair to sit in or minorities to yell at?
I guess I don't understand the concept of "old" when it comes to great music. Why don't you go ahead and bring your best representative sample of better, more contemporary music and show us what you mean. Regardless of what you bring to the table, here is my prediction: 9 out of 10 people will prefer PF to your pick, with proper presentation, and you will fail in trying to convince anyone that there is some sort of evolution of music that makes it better over time. Why do you try so hard to hate them, instead of actually listening to the performance the way it was designed to be heard? Your ignorance of this band exposes your arrogance.
Sure, I could explain it.
In music, and probably art in general, there's a constant forward momentum. Artists make things, new artists come along, grow up and learn those things and create new ideas. Because I'm 31 and grew up mostly listening to the modern music of my time, I have my own tastes which usually skew towards more modern music, in particular, I really enjoy music that demonstrates a certain level of technicality in an instrument, though as of recent, I've also taken to technicality in production and engineering as well. Most older popular music has the blueprints for a lot of what I've heard from artists today. It's why I said that while I don't necessarily enjoy all of it, I can still appreciate the song for what it's given to the music I listen to today, especially Pink Floyd's penchant for key changes that I love.
The most reductive way I can put it is I tend to enjoy music with more notes. That isn't to say that songs that don't do that are "bad" in the sense that they are morally bad or that the musicians don't have great technical ability, just that I don't usually prefer it. I do have slow songs with less notes that I do like but even those tend to be of a certain flavor.
As for the rest of what you said:
I can give you the most recent songs I've listened to but I wouldn't call it better, just different. Also, like you so quickly mentioned, you wouldn't actually care because you're not interested in hearing it in an attempt to learn about me. You, like the vast majority of commenters, had their egos bruised and want the music I listen to so you can throw it back at my face and tell me it's shit, expecting me to stamp my feet and cry. I don't care about convincing you or anyone. This is the way I currently see music. That may change in the future and I'm okay with that.
I'm not trying to hate it because I don't actually hate it. I'm allowed to listen to music however I see fit. That's the fun part about music and art. I can consume it in my way and it isn't wrong. Just different.
@@keyofweird No, KOW, I never said nor intimated I would hate anything and I never would. What I wrote was that you would fail to prove any evolution produced "better" music. You did explain yourself, that you recognize "better" is not the right adjective, and you give PF some appreciation. The issue I have is that you are completely unaware of the intent of the production as a work of art and are parcing it and comparing a piece of it to the current version of short, cropped and neatly packaged bite sized compositions. Again, no worse or better, but you pretend you understand "Time" without knowing all the other songs on DSOTM and you have no clue that the last part you admitted to liking was actually a different song and represented another shift in evolution of the album through philosophical meditations.
I understand that there is a story to this album but that typically doesn't help me enjoy one particular song. I didn't say I understood the song to its fullest extent. I simply said what the song was making me feel and why I think I was feeling that way. That's literally it. My opinion on this one song in this one span of time is all I'm giving you. The rest is being inferred by others. I don't think the rest of the album is "bad" just because I had a lukewarm experience with this song and I'm still looking forward to marking off "Listen to the Pink Floyd discography" from my bucket list.
Can you please stop misusing the word ‘like’ it’s like really like annoying like for someone who like criticises like authors and like lyricists like. Thanks
I didn't criticize authors or lyrics so, like, fuck off.
I spent 40 years racing motorcycles and mountain bikes. I don't look at the guys who are making $30,000,000 or more a year as world champions and criticize them. I look up to them and try to better understand how they are doing what they are doing so greatly. That's how we better ourselves.
You look up to all people who make 30mil? And you have no criticism of what they did? What if they're a mob boss and got their money by selling drugs and murdering people?
@@keyofweird Yamaha paid Rossi $30,000,000 a year to leave Honda. I'm not sure if either company is owned by drug dealers or murders. We really never know. Anyway, wisdom is paid for with pain and suffering and is the result of stupidity, not intelligence. Consequently ( and luckily) I have accumulated much wisdom in my long life. Whether or not you like Pink Floyd is inconsequential. Whether you look at something new to you objectively and judge it that way instead of with prejudice is what will determine how successful and happy you are with your life.
Do you truly think anyone is capable of experiencing life without prejudice? From the moment you're born, you have experiences that shape your life and mind.
Am I truly without prejudice if I said nothing but good things about the song? Does prejudice start at the mind or the lips?
Well, we all need help understanding. I can't be offended, only corrected. I try hard to not be judgmental and if someone has a different opinion from me, I try to understand why. There is no person on this Earth that hasn't had different life experiences from me and doesn't know stuff that I don't. We all can learn from each other. Never assume they are wrong until you sit back and really think. Sure makes life fun and new knowledge is always just around the corner for all of us. I actually love life and it's adventures.
I'm not sure that necessarily answers my questions. I'll try to tie it back to your original comment.
Personally, I don't believe people can be without prejudice. The most we can do is withhold that judgment until we make ourselves feel a different way or, like most, just ignore it and move on. That may be polite, maybe even selfish, but it's not real. Music is art and art is subjective. You aren't going to like everything and that should be okay to say.
This video is actually a highlight from a live stream that I do. Specifically, every Monday, I run a Music Share Night where viewers drop links to songs they want to share. I play the song and I say what I'm thinking with as little as filter as possible. From that, I get these reactions. Messy, incoherent, wishy-washy, sometimes down right mean, but genuine reactions. I understand that the average RUclips reaction channel isn't like this but instead of planting myself on the other side of those reactors and join the "cool kids" who hate everything, I stand in the middle.
In music, I try to find things I like and dislike. To me, no song is a masterpiece the same way no song is unlistenable. I hope that clears things up.
You’re so far ahead? Todays music absolutely sucks! There is no comparison. Pink Floyd were true artists. Maybe prog. Metal is more your speed? Check out Panic attack by Dream Theater. That’ll loosen your sphincter!
Or maybe The Spirit of Radio by Rush. Not prog. Metal but Prog. None the less.
Leave it to a Pink Floyd fan to hear something that wasn't there.
Can you point me to the time where I said that I was so far ahead? I'm pretty sure I said we, as in the collective world, are 40-50 years away from the peak of Pink Floyd. With the way that music works, people hear something, emulate it, then make their own version of it, creating something new.
Thanks for the recommendation. I've actually already listened to Panic Attack as well as my fair share of Dream Theater.
The level of your rude incompetence is breathtaking.
But I wasn't rude?
Nice reaction! Disgusting/10
That sounds like a pretty good score to me, bruv
Lame...Anyone got some wet paint I can watch dry?
Just listen to the intro of Time on repeat.
Also, why did you edit the comment? It looks like you wanted me to mention bands more talented than Pink Floyd? Should I still do that or are your feelings already hurt at the mere thought that another person on this planet could have a difference if opinion?
Don't worry bud. I'm sure your music is wayyyyy better than Pink Floyd
It's not. In music, there isn't better. There's different.
@Key of Weird lol wow you are sooo deep. Lol there is definitely better in music
Nah, it's not deep. It's what it is. Like I said, you're probably one of the dumbest people in these comments.
@@keyofweird lol @ you getting smoked on your own page by the comment section
Yup, I am absolutely getting smoked. I would expect for you to believe that.
this flower is beautiful but WHY THIS ONE HAS SO MUCH RED ON IT!
Ah yes. Comparing a rose made by nature to a song made by people. It's the same thing.
Why is he trying to play over the song? Annoying.... we know you play dude... don't need to prove anything
I'm clearly trying to learn the song. If you want to hear the actual song, nothing is stopping you from doing so.
Clearly he has not listened to ECHOES...
What gave that away? 🤔😂
There were a number of things you said at various times in the music that proved it.@@keyofweird
Lmao fair enough
Try Echoes. Listen closely when you do. You'll find many elements of the composition in Dark Side. and that it also is very experimental in the middle. All with their instruments, no computers Etc.
@@keyofweird
Yikes
Yikes indeed, Robbie.
@@keyofweird you do you man I'm out
Thanks dude. Have a good one.
👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
👌🤘✌️
You apparently don't have a clue on PF or music in general!
The title literally says I listened to Pink Floyd for the first time.
Get a job
Literally at it right now
"They left the metronome on"... 😂😂😂 What a fragment.