Good ranking! Until I Feel Nothing is definitely my favorite from them and probably my favorite Deathcore album, but im biased as it was the fiest album of theirs that I heard and was one of several albums that sold me on Deathcore. It was also the beginning of the strong Black Metal influence that would define their sound from that point onward. Hell Chose Me is also an incredibly solid album. I'd probably put Until I Feel Nothing, Hell Chose Me, and Slow Death in S Tier. Either way, Carnifex is my favorite Deathcore band, they've just been so consistent in quality, and i can't wait for the new album
That was a great ranking. I started listening to them back when I was 15 (21 now) and slow death is hands down one of my favorite albums ever. If slow death didn't exist hell chose me or World war X would have taken its place.But you are right when it comes to ranking carnifex albums, I can't simply pick one...I enjoy all of them.
Thanks! Yes, it was tough for me to rank Slow Death below other albums because it really facilitated my love for Carnifex in a big way. It just didn't hold up as well over time to me at least. It is so very difficult to rank their albums and I put more thought into this video than any other ranking I've done.
Great video! I’ve got: S: Hell Chose Me, Slow Death A: Die Without Hope, WWX B: Until I Feel Nothing, Dead In My Arms C+: The Diseased & Poisoned D: Graveside Confessions I agree with a lot of your points, especially about Die Without Hope really growing on me (imo Where The Light Dies is their best song), but I still slightly prefer the slower, more blackened material on Slow Death. Totally with you on Hell Chose Me being GOATed though! I’m a massive WWX fan though- I don’t think the highs on that record quite hit the 3 records I’ve got above it, but it’s such a consistent and easy to listen to record that I always end up jamming it (the short runtime is a huge upside to it for me). Until I Feel Nothing has really grown on my over the past 6 months, but I agree some of the tracks blend together. I absolutely adore the pure MySpace br00tality on Dead In My Arms and The Diseased & Poisoned (the breakdowns and production DIMA are especially nasty), although I for sure prefer their later material. I can’t for the life of me truly get into the new record though. It’s got some absolute bangers but it’s way too long, the Korn cover is weird, the re-recorded songs are whatever, and most importantly to me the production/mix is really murky. I agree that Scott sounds incredible on it though. Had they cut down the track list and had it mixed better, it could have easily been one of their best.
Great list and great points bro! I agree Graveside Confessions needs to be waaaayyyy shorter and the re-recorded tracks need to have been cut. It is honestly kind of dumb they are included because the originals were good as they were... And yes the Korn cover of Dead Bodies Everywhere was also stupid. Many things I would have done differently for Graveside Confessions but the high points of the album always have me coming back! To me, I didn't want to put an actual album below a B because I personally feel like they are all SO close in quality. Scott probably sounds the best he ever has on Graveside Confessions which is why I had to put it ahead of others. Other than that, there are a lot of things that were screwed up on the album. Carnifex is hella consistent and they have a formula that works. Thanks for the thoughts and review!
It has its moments for sure. Maybe I could redo the list and post it in the comments or something with a brief summary of my thoughts. When I think of 2023 albums though, some of the first that come to mind for me are Ov Sulfur’s and Mental Cruelty’s however Carnifex’s album was very good too!
@@deathcoredude9922Yeah both Ov Sulfur and Mental Cruelty came out with awesome albums. I loved Zweilicht. Carnifex just gives me that nostalgic feeling because I’ve been a fan and have seen them live since their earlier days. Necromanteum is a fun step up in their catalog and expanding on their sound even more.
Good ranking! Until I Feel Nothing is definitely my favorite from them and probably my favorite Deathcore album, but im biased as it was the fiest album of theirs that I heard and was one of several albums that sold me on Deathcore. It was also the beginning of the strong Black Metal influence that would define their sound from that point onward. Hell Chose Me is also an incredibly solid album. I'd probably put Until I Feel Nothing, Hell Chose Me, and Slow Death in S Tier. Either way, Carnifex is my favorite Deathcore band, they've just been so consistent in quality, and i can't wait for the new album
That was a great ranking. I started listening to them back when I was 15 (21 now) and slow death is hands down one of my favorite albums ever. If slow death didn't exist hell chose me or World war X would have taken its place.But you are right when it comes to ranking carnifex albums, I can't simply pick one...I enjoy all of them.
Thanks! Yes, it was tough for me to rank Slow Death below other albums because it really facilitated my love for Carnifex in a big way. It just didn't hold up as well over time to me at least. It is so very difficult to rank their albums and I put more thought into this video than any other ranking I've done.
Great video! I’ve got:
S: Hell Chose Me, Slow Death
A: Die Without Hope, WWX
B: Until I Feel Nothing, Dead In My Arms
C+: The Diseased & Poisoned
D: Graveside Confessions
I agree with a lot of your points, especially about Die Without Hope really growing on me (imo Where The Light Dies is their best song), but I still slightly prefer the slower, more blackened material on Slow Death. Totally with you on Hell Chose Me being GOATed though! I’m a massive WWX fan though- I don’t think the highs on that record quite hit the 3 records I’ve got above it, but it’s such a consistent and easy to listen to record that I always end up jamming it (the short runtime is a huge upside to it for me). Until I Feel Nothing has really grown on my over the past 6 months, but I agree some of the tracks blend together. I absolutely adore the pure MySpace br00tality on Dead In My Arms and The Diseased & Poisoned (the breakdowns and production DIMA are especially nasty), although I for sure prefer their later material. I can’t for the life of me truly get into the new record though. It’s got some absolute bangers but it’s way too long, the Korn cover is weird, the re-recorded songs are whatever, and most importantly to me the production/mix is really murky. I agree that Scott sounds incredible on it though. Had they cut down the track list and had it mixed better, it could have easily been one of their best.
Great list and great points bro! I agree Graveside Confessions needs to be waaaayyyy shorter and the re-recorded tracks need to have been cut. It is honestly kind of dumb they are included because the originals were good as they were... And yes the Korn cover of Dead Bodies Everywhere was also stupid. Many things I would have done differently for Graveside Confessions but the high points of the album always have me coming back! To me, I didn't want to put an actual album below a B because I personally feel like they are all SO close in quality. Scott probably sounds the best he ever has on Graveside Confessions which is why I had to put it ahead of others. Other than that, there are a lot of things that were screwed up on the album. Carnifex is hella consistent and they have a formula that works. Thanks for the thoughts and review!
I wonder where you place Necromanteum… was in my top 5 albums of 2023. Great list 🤘🏻
It has its moments for sure. Maybe I could redo the list and post it in the comments or something with a brief summary of my thoughts. When I think of 2023 albums though, some of the first that come to mind for me are Ov Sulfur’s and Mental Cruelty’s however Carnifex’s album was very good too!
@@deathcoredude9922Yeah both Ov Sulfur and Mental Cruelty came out with awesome albums. I loved Zweilicht.
Carnifex just gives me that nostalgic feeling because I’ve been a fan and have seen them live since their earlier days. Necromanteum is a fun step up in their catalog and expanding on their sound even more.
@@deathcoredude9922 For me 2023 screamed Cattle Decapitation, To The Grave and Crown Magnetar as my top 3 favorite album releases.
Die withouthope is such a brutal album. The titletrack of that album was my first exposure,than i heard hell choose me and I was locked in.
My list would be the same except move the diseased and poisoned last in the b tier