It is so dificult to maintain a meletry like india in future whitout indigenous engines in every sector wither it is marine engine or jet engine or tank and inv engine so it is necessary for our resurch organisations to wark hard on it and make our country indipendent form import such machine like this 😊❤ as an indian my all good wishes are with our all resurch organisations ❤ JAY HIND ❤
Sir, recently I had got news that indigenous engine for frcv was test fired as well as indigenous engine of future infantry vehicle had complited it's 100 hours. So definitely we will have our own engines in both segments till 2030? What's your opinion sir?
भाई साहब, भारत से ही कैटरपिलर इंजन की बॉडी एक्सपोर्ट होती है और सभी प्रकार की क्रैंकशाफ्ट भी बनाते हैं, सिर्फ निर्णय लेना है, बड़े इंजन के डेवलपमेंट का... कमिंस बड़े डीजल इंजन भी बनाती हैं
I am still confused why Govt of India not sitting separate funds for Engine R&D. It must continue till will achieve the end result. Waking up last moment is night mare for everyone.
Soon Bhaarat will be the world leader in all spheres of Engine Engineering due to massive need based focus both in public and private sectors with enormous highly talented pool of manpower.
@@AlphaDefenseHindi Haan... Me bhi yahi soch raha tha ki jo AMCA ke liye engine banaya ja raha,usi ka derivative hona chahiye.... Tabhi zyada power milega
@AlphaDefense Which company will produce these engjnes? Do they have some experience in Engine development? Is there a chance of sabotage by US ? please reply
@@ksh19 barc ( Russian assistance should be linked to chakra3 nuke lease deal). But bro india is also in talks with France for their reactor which is based on low enriched uranium.
Indian sea condition and atmosphere conditions mein normally *“kitne percent tak ki girawat”* aati hai kisi bhi respct. Marine and Aircraft engine ke performance mein compare to universal decided sean and atmospheric conditions ?????
Better make everything make in India for better Dependance and also it Increases the Jobs provided in India.......maybe we will not have better products at the start but as the time goes and Experiences , Techniques evolve we will 💯% get better products.
अवश्यकता ही अविष्कार की जननी है। चलो अच्छा हुआ। लेकिन मैं कहूंगा कि इंडिया सिर्फ snecma के साथ nhi बल्कि RR के साथ भी इंजन प्रोजेक्ट रन करे। और एक पीएसयू बनाए इंजन मैन्युफैक्चरिंग कॉर्पोरेशन के नाम से जिसमे पिस्टन इंजन से लेकर जेट इंजन सभी पर काम हो एक PPP मॉडल टाइप। जिसमे फॉरेन पार्टनर हो और इंडियन प्राइवेट पार्टनर साथ ही PSU की पार्टनरशिप हो।
Ye marine engine bannte rahenge aur testing hote rahenge indefinite time tak. Best way is to buy rr engine and not to depend on US engines as already tejas programme has come in jeopardy due to US flipflop on engines
India need to develop and use Indigenous Engines for Fighter Jets, Warships, Infantry Combat Vehicles and Main Battle Tanks. We can't depend on Hypocrite Westerner Countries for Engine Requirements.
If u r successful in making marine Gas turbine engine.. U would be able to make jet engine within a decade with required thrust. Only issue with jet engine would be to decrease weight and increase thrust to weight ratio.
Gas turbines are manufactured by BHEL for industrial applications. Why can't we just borrow the technology and make our own engine? Or rather ask BHEL to do it for us. Naval application engines are well with the reach of BHEL IMO.
sir, what is the importance of marine gas turbine engines to atomic-powered marine engines? what is the progress in the development of atomic-powered engines, if we are making one? and can that atomic-powered engines be used throughout the entire fleet, right from carriers to frigates? , are atomic propulsion systems in submarines different?
You have hits a bull's eye. India is dependent for all kinds engines be it fighter jets, MT engine, drones, Engines for Transport plans. PMO must make task force to push the projects which are specific to engine technologies. I don't understand why we Indians are going after reverse engineering option, atleast where we are stucked and wasting valuable time, may be we get some quick break through. That's why India arms acquisition is getting hampered.
All they see is how much is the budget and what the immediate outcome after spending that money. Nobody seriously understands the defence R&D, ecosystem in New Delhi and those who do, either they're somewhere else or they'll not be listened to. If somebody at the highest level had some understading, they would not have stopped budget for kaveri engine then. Now after all these years, when Ukraine is in cricis and US showing nakre as usual we're remembering kaveri engine. This syndrome of either letting down projects mid-way or not timely upgrading inducted indigenous weapons is common. Arjun MBT, INSAS small arms, Abhay ICV, Arjun catapult gun God knows how many more. Atleast now this has to change. If not Atmanirbhar Bharat in defence would become a joke.
It's high time that we develop a better technology for sea mobility. Fine, we can't develop gas turbines, but, are we developing anything that can use some other fuel? We should be taking a look in that direction. Gas turbines come with inherent problems. Can't we develop a system with higher fuel density and low weight that goes beyond gas turbines. Probably Hydrogen pellets or something? Also, Rajput class destroyer case has some different outcomes. It was a decommissioned ship that was quite old and was hit by a torpedo. I don't think it had anything to do with engine.
Well if we are talking about Kaveri marrine engein then its possible because last time this enngein was able to produce 12mw power and working was proper.
This is the problem with our country. We claim and plan to make newer and much more effective military hardwares with more indegenization, but cannot even make a powerplant i.e., engines or batteries to power the very hardware itself. We need fighter jet engines, drone and helicopter engines ship turbines, armoured fighting vehicle engines and what not from other countries. What use would be Uttam AESA radar or Brahmos missile if the ship or jet cannot get a damn engine to power itself and run? We need to be self-reliant on engine and powerplant sectors to speed up acquisition and design processes of our hardwares. If we can provide for our own engines, we won't be at the mercy of other countries for the engines or incorporate design changes to fit their engines and possibly compromise on the optimal performance of our hardwares
*Absolutely Excellent Job by GTRE to Design and Develop Kaveri Marine Gas Turbine Engine Indigenously*
Hope they are successful this time
SINCE 1986, GTRE IS DEVELOPING BUT NO RESULTS BECAUSE NONE RESPONSIBLE FOR SUCCESS OR FAILURES.
Bohot badi baat hai agar hum Marine engines ke segment mei independent ho sakey toh. Game changer for IN to become global force IF THIS SUCCEEDS
Making indigenous engines is more important right now than sending men in space .
Jai Shree Radhe Krishna 🙏🙏🧡
Jai Bharat Rashtra 🙏🙏🧡
We should have a SPV Engine India limited where all type of engines should be develop and manufacture either with DRDO, JV or self grown technology.
It is so dificult to maintain a meletry like india in future whitout indigenous engines in every sector wither it is marine engine or jet engine or tank and inv engine so it is necessary for our resurch organisations to wark hard on it and make our country indipendent form import such machine like this 😊❤ as an indian my all good wishes are with our all resurch organisations ❤
JAY HIND ❤
रूस ने ईरान से मिले शहद को मोडिफाई कर जेट पावर 2500km रेंज ड्रोन बना दिया क्या ऐसा भारत के अभ्यास के साथ संभव है
शाहिद.... शहद को खाते हैं।
@@puneet90 😂😂😅👍
@@bebyfun is ke intne range nahi hai
Kamikaze type drone ki 2500km range kuch jyada nai hai....?? 🙄🤔🤷♂️
@@deltaandD7516 🤣🤣🤣🤧🤧🫣🫣
If successful then this could be major milestone for GTRE & Indian defense ecosystem
Bahot achhi news dedi aapane.Thank you Boss.Jay Bharat.
Thanks for the update. :)
Sir, recently I had got news that indigenous engine for frcv was test fired as well as indigenous engine of future infantry vehicle had complited it's 100 hours. So definitely we will have our own engines in both segments till 2030? What's your opinion sir?
Much before that hopefully
Is there any update regarding the delivery of F404 engines from GE?
भाई साहब,
भारत से ही कैटरपिलर इंजन की बॉडी एक्सपोर्ट होती है और सभी प्रकार की क्रैंकशाफ्ट भी बनाते हैं, सिर्फ निर्णय लेना है, बड़े इंजन के डेवलपमेंट का... कमिंस बड़े डीजल इंजन भी बनाती हैं
I am still confused why Govt of India not sitting separate funds for Engine R&D. It must continue till will achieve the end result. Waking up last moment is night mare for everyone.
Please produce a video on aplication of 3D printing in defense equipment.
Soon Bhaarat will be the world leader in all spheres of Engine Engineering due to massive need based focus both in public and private sectors with enormous highly talented pool of manpower.
India buy 51% stack in Ukrainian gas turbine engine firm
It’s Indian unit which was crippling anyways
Thank you.
Subodh bhai... Aapko kya lagta hai,kya GTRE in engines ki power output ko atleast 20 mega watt bhi kar payegi? Reply please
For you MT30 category for ~22 MW you will need gas turbine of GE F414/EJ200 class
For ~30MW AMCA 110KN class can act as core
@@AlphaDefenseHindi Haan... Me bhi yahi soch raha tha ki jo AMCA ke liye engine banaya ja raha,usi ka derivative hona chahiye.... Tabhi zyada power milega
Ja sakta hai but these are high bypass engines
Bharat Forge acquire majority stake in Zorya Mashproekt India.
That's more of a marketing & MRO arm but let's see
0:14 zorya mayshprotek!!!...
.kyaaa!!!..? tik se sunai nahi diya 😂
Mashproekt hot hai 😅😅😅
One Question Subodh Bhai . 12MW can power which class of ships ?
JAI HIND 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
NICE 👍
Subodh vai...what is the overall weight of K6 SLBM and also what is the weight of it's warhead
am hearing bharat forge got 51% of share in the ukrainian company. is that so? if that is the case, is that a bigger development? can you explain?
Ye GTRE wale dream bahut dekhte hai . Bhagwan kare sach ho koi sabotage na kare
Engine Engine Engine! Bhai 4th largest economy he. Kya ek-aadh workable engine nahi bana sakte kya?
@AlphaDefense Which company will produce these engjnes? Do they have some experience in Engine development? Is there a chance of sabotage by US ? please reply
I don't the bidding has happened yet
After 2.5 yrs: pahle 1st batch ke do engines bnane ke funds to mil jaye...😂😂
Are we working on a small scale nuclear reactor to power IAC 3 in future or are we going to source that too?
we work on everything, we just arent capable of building whatever we work on.
@@Tomahawk1999 lol!
It will get the same 190mw nuke reactor meant for SSN & ssbn(s5). Ie 2*190mw
@@saras102 is it indigenous or sourced?
@@ksh19 barc ( Russian assistance should be linked to chakra3 nuke lease deal). But bro india is also in talks with France for their reactor which is based on low enriched uranium.
give GTRE engine to Adani and Kalyani. give them money and let them compete for a large order. that's how US defence industry works.
Subodh Bhai Aaj Sunday ko full charge ho?
Its good to see
Indian sea condition and atmosphere conditions mein normally *“kitne percent tak ki girawat”* aati hai kisi bhi respct. Marine and Aircraft engine ke performance mein compare to universal decided sean and atmospheric conditions ?????
Indian Defence Analysis ne yeh news 4 hours pehle break ki thi with industry partner being Bharat forge limited .
Okie ! We tweeted this yesterday; Article is on website but giving credit isnt Indian defence RUclips channel thing. :(
Good Luck to them
We have to specially opens our industrial corridors to meet our different types of engines need
Better make everything make in India for better Dependance and also it Increases the Jobs provided in India.......maybe we will not have better products at the start but as the time goes and Experiences , Techniques evolve we will 💯% get better products.
अवश्यकता ही अविष्कार की जननी है।
चलो अच्छा हुआ।
लेकिन मैं कहूंगा कि इंडिया सिर्फ snecma के साथ nhi बल्कि RR के साथ भी इंजन प्रोजेक्ट रन करे।
और एक पीएसयू बनाए इंजन मैन्युफैक्चरिंग कॉर्पोरेशन के नाम से
जिसमे पिस्टन इंजन से लेकर जेट इंजन सभी पर काम हो
एक PPP मॉडल टाइप। जिसमे फॉरेन पार्टनर हो और इंडियन प्राइवेट पार्टनर साथ ही PSU की पार्टनरशिप हो।
Does any ship in the Indian Navy have CODLAG or CODAG engine? If yes which class of ships; if no, why not?
the engine is a little bit trickery to develop for us but we are very good at making rockets and missiles
👍👍👍
Ye marine engine bannte rahenge aur testing hote rahenge indefinite time tak. Best way is to buy rr engine and not to depend on US engines as already tejas programme has come in jeopardy due to US flipflop on engines
US and UK are independent ? US cannot influence UK ? Just asking
Bro if somehow this engine gets developed,what all platforms can use this engine.
Subodh bhai, can the gun assembly system of ATAGS or MARG TC-20 be modified & developed into a 155mm naval gun ?
Not directly but ultimately those are arti systems and we could try making our own
@@AlphaDefenseHindi yeah both are used for indirect fire so i guess we could give it a try
India need to develop and use Indigenous Engines for Fighter Jets, Warships, Infantry Combat Vehicles and Main Battle Tanks. We can't depend on Hypocrite Westerner Countries for Engine Requirements.
🙏
👍
Sir how difficult and different technologically and metallurgically to make modern marine gas turbine engines from modern fighter jet engines
If u r successful in making marine Gas turbine engine.. U would be able to make jet engine within a decade with required thrust.
Only issue with jet engine would be to decrease weight and increase thrust to weight ratio.
Any update on Zorawar tank?
Your thaughts on 'Kinzal' missile found in ukraine will it affect the brahmos 2 programme which will be analyzed by nato and american scientists
Jai Hind
Would a 2x 12MW Kaveri derivative MGT & 2x Diesel engine combined cycle power plant be sufficient to power next gen destroyers of IN?
No
Gas turbines are manufactured by BHEL for industrial applications. Why can't we just borrow the technology and make our own engine? Or rather ask BHEL to do it for us. Naval application engines are well with the reach of BHEL IMO.
sir, what is the importance of marine gas turbine engines to atomic-powered marine engines? what is the progress in the development of atomic-powered engines, if we are making one? and can that atomic-powered engines be used throughout the entire fleet, right from carriers to frigates? , are atomic propulsion systems in submarines different?
Who is eligible industry partner?
Kalyani Godrej HAL
I don't think there is not a single sophisticated weapons that is developed and manufactured by India (100% made in India)
That dosent mean we should dump that and pick up a bowl for import
Engines ko le kar hume self reliant hona hoga . Private companies ko opportunity deni hai
You have hits a bull's eye. India is dependent for all kinds engines be it fighter jets, MT engine, drones, Engines for Transport plans. PMO must make task force to push the projects which are specific to engine technologies. I don't understand why we Indians are going after reverse engineering option, atleast where we are stucked and wasting valuable time, may be we get some quick break through. That's why India arms acquisition is getting hampered.
All they see is how much is the budget and what the immediate outcome after spending that money.
Nobody seriously understands the defence R&D, ecosystem in New Delhi and those who do, either they're somewhere else or they'll not be listened to.
If somebody at the highest level had some understading, they would not have stopped budget for kaveri engine then. Now after all these years, when Ukraine is in cricis and US showing nakre as usual we're remembering kaveri engine.
This syndrome of either letting down projects mid-way or not timely upgrading inducted indigenous weapons is common. Arjun MBT, INSAS small arms, Abhay ICV, Arjun catapult gun God knows how many more. Atleast now this has to change. If not Atmanirbhar Bharat in defence would become a joke.
lets guess, we are testing this in 2025 with user acceptance tests in 2028. this story was printed in 3024
It's high time that we develop a better technology for sea mobility. Fine, we can't develop gas turbines, but, are we developing anything that can use some other fuel?
We should be taking a look in that direction. Gas turbines come with inherent problems. Can't we develop a system with higher fuel density and low weight that goes beyond gas turbines. Probably Hydrogen pellets or something?
Also, Rajput class destroyer case has some different outcomes. It was a decommissioned ship that was quite old and was hit by a torpedo. I don't think it had anything to do with engine.
India should double down the efforts to design and build all type of engines. And adequate funding should be provided to Govt and private industries.
Yeeets
Plan bohot khubsurat lekin pata nahi implementation mein hi kya ho jata hai 😢
Pannu Munnu Nunnu 😂😂😂😂
1st comment ❤
😂😂😂 ban Gaya hum samajh Gaye aap log 2030 tak ye bol ke hutiya banaoge😅
Well if we are talking about Kaveri marrine engein then its possible because last time this enngein was able to produce 12mw power and working was proper.
Godrej would be making these?
Bhai km se km thumbnail bnane me chat gpt Mt use kro😢😢
This is the problem with our country. We claim and plan to make newer and much more effective military hardwares with more indegenization, but cannot even make a powerplant i.e., engines or batteries to power the very hardware itself. We need fighter jet engines, drone and helicopter engines ship turbines, armoured fighting vehicle engines and what not from other countries. What use would be Uttam AESA radar or Brahmos missile if the ship or jet cannot get a damn engine to power itself and run? We need to be self-reliant on engine and powerplant sectors to speed up acquisition and design processes of our hardwares. If we can provide for our own engines, we won't be at the mercy of other countries for the engines or incorporate design changes to fit their engines and possibly compromise on the optimal performance of our hardwares