Thanks to ANI for raising this issue.. Armed foces have to answer the genuine concerns of people.. They are not the Almighty.. They should be open to criticism..
Genuinely concerned public should also be aware of how things work within the military, military security systems, govt interference and Modern Warfare. Loos baby talk isn't genuine enough.
Yes kyun defence detective so raha tha.. Haan iss defence detective wale genius ko lagta hai iske paas zyada samjh aur contacts hain armed forces mein then Anil K Singh of ANI
The very fact that they signed that mou tells you a lot. Navy has already signed similar deal. Not only uber, but armed forces already have such deals with makemytrip, zepto, blinkit etc. How do we know if genrails arent getting kickbacks for providing lakhs and millions of potential customers to these companies? Whats next, Indian army genrails trading millions of potential customers with MacDonald, airliners, Amazon, ola, etc? Gov should put an immediate stop to this and also investigate people responsible for such deals, if they got some kind of kickback for it.
This is the exact problem with Indians generally. Instead of adapting with the times and embracing the inevitable we play catchup. Services like Amazon uber ola etc are ubiquitous now in armes forces families. 2 having these exclusive agreements helps with data protection and incentives these companies for local data management rather than treating this anyway they want. It is very difficult to understand for even some older military officers
I have been working in IT since last 10 yrs. This is unnecessary venture, armed force delve into. These things will definitely compromise security. They are directly opening the gates for terrorists into the armed campuses. This person only makes just videos. He doesn't know any thing about digital security. People should raise concerns and this is what Rangnathan is doing. I have worked closely with navy indigenous development firm, i don't want to name it. These people, even the technical one (upto the rank of colonel) don't have basic knowledge of how technology works. This isn't their fault. They have been evolved in that manner only. They better take advise from analysts belong to relevant fields before delve into such security prone decisions.
@PrashantSharma-vb3ib 1. An MOU is not a venture 2 by your comment it seems you don't seem to have any idea about the defence forces itself and how these apps are now ubiquitous
First of all, there shouldn't have been any MOU, the rest of the points are moot. It doesn't matter what Mechanism they formulate, Americans have thousands of ways to track you down if you use Uber. We have seen in the past how our so-called super smart Armed Forces officers have leaked top secret documents after falling prey to honey traps, the most ancient form of espionage technique. The criticism is absolutely fair but Language could be better. The very idea of MOU hints at the ineptitude of basic understanding of cyber security.
The kind of language used is secondary. Raising of the issue is primary. How procedures work is a secondary question. The primary question is why the MoU was signed in the first place? Thank God India has people who actually raise such questions to our armed forces. Otherwise who knows what will go flying under the radar. When national interest is the issue we should all strictly avoid becoming emotional.
Totally agree with Sushant, Anand, Tehseen Abhijeet & ANI were absolutely correct. The sadak chhap language as you alledged was very sobre. The cyber hiegne displayed by AF & Navy is aweful, they need to be taken to the task. Now these guys are trying to defends themselves thru their puppets. Instead of canxelling the MoUs and tendering public apology; these so called puppets/fans giving all kinds of trivial justifications. By the way these puppet websites themselves has lot of data on them with the grace of these forces for business purpose. These American companies (who spy for deep state) have penetrated our forces. Just give them freebees; you get an entry..
This person doesn't know anything rather than making videos. Everybody knows airforce and navy are going to do this blunder & foreign agency must be laughing somewhere in the corner.
You think IB/Raw is sleeping, they know everything, they will monitor it, why cry when forces are making money too or getting MoU done@@PrashantSharma-vb3ib
@@jessicaperry7549 please entertain us with your heavenly knowledge on cyber-security and data-breach concern. What happened in Kargil and gps issue? How does MoU ensure data-localization and data feed isn't sourced to servers outside. Exact locations ,your mobility preference your preferred drivers your stoppage timings your lags your patterns are tracked aided by maps😆 don't make people laugh those who are in domain of cyber-security /data-arch. Enemy states/non state actors need nothing more ,you are a sitting duck. Vomiting( emesis) is good , it removes the toxic elements from the body, any SAAS Co. start-up in India has better cyber-hygiene than Govt depts, IAF is no exception ; in the end its an arm under Govt of India nothing more and nothing less.
@@anitapadhi325 what kind of knowledge does the undergrad of Whatsapp University wants...specify..ever heard of nat grid...please type the following promt " NAT GRID India " on google ..im just this will help you in getting your graduation.
this is why we love right wing right wing doesnt care about gov or army we can speak freely which is needed , indian navy literally had england flag for 60 years , where were defense lovers xd
Even now the Indian military culture is like dogs of the British. Would you believe they use spoon and fork to eat even roti in the officer's mess once upon a time. They are so pathetic, they proudly showoff 'British heritage' in their training.
Just bullying some people into apologising is not going to solve anything. It will just assuage egos of veterans and defense brats. As for your friend AIM, he was pretty decent in his criticism.
@gamelover195 Yes. And our Subodh is still busy ridiculing audience that they don't know difference between MoU and Contract. But IAF themselves delete the post and now cancelling the arrangement with the taxi service. FWIW MoU is not a contract but many small arrangements run just on MoU when both parties want a semi formal arrangement.
Prof. Anand is a true nationalist and a decent person. We all must appreciate his gesture. However, it must be said that the way IAF official gave it publicity, it carried wrong impression and some immediate negative reaction was natural. Even if Uber is finally selected, data security and national interest are is a precondition.
I too heard some details regarding the word profiling or some kind of masked identity but these fine prints are risky. Especially with respect to collecting data of the families. with time they get more data about the families of armed forces which can be used against those families indirectly.
How data security will be a precondition? Uber store all data in USA. It will take years to make new data canter operational in India, if at all they are willing to invest such huge amount of money. Even then they cannot be fully trusted not to send data outside.
@@PritamC-r2z I agree with your view. As a lay person I can give my a crude solution. Best tech, and cyber savvy brains can come out with a solution. Ie instead of individual name, app should have user:employee belongs to one company/armed forces and only that company is booking that service provider with masked identity in which case they know he or she is member of armed forces just like CUG SIM incase of a company and employee has hired the services something like that. Hope tech and cyber unit will come out with a solution. Just a layman's view.
Dude this matter not should have gone till MOU. Airforce are supposed to be most technical folks they should help govt to come with measures protecting data. They are incompetent with matter of decision making and foresight. But will not question there work ethic valor and duty to the country. Also Aib and ss blabbering is what helped to bring this to foresight or it will be pushed under rugs. This video of urs defending poor decision of armed force is not great.
@hannanhub1717 brother it helps to create more detailed profile of the whole family and friends based on the interface. Yes true it's compromised but this is next level. Almost keeping window open for a house so any body can sneak in or peak. Once profile is built there is lot of ways to take advantage.
Subodh bhaiya they are right this time and if everything needs to be from west(from Iphone to Jet engine) why our podcasters can't criticise as people in United states do? Jai Hind
@@nandishcs yeah, I mean.. People in the United states criticise a lot heavy handed than people here.. And if we have an audience who is buying Iphone and Coldplay tickets.. I think we are ready for some Military criticism too just like in the United states.. Only Army Brats in my opinion feel offended even with a slightest of millitary criticism else not many people have got offended by that..
@debu98 dude I worked in HAL and I know how much airforce derailed the tejas project. Not defending Hal they are also at fault. I left hal seeing the process. Airforce f**k up also reading for re tender of 114 planes.
@@debu98 You are wrong about that only, military brats are offended, that's just your limited & clouded opinion. Many army brats, are open to criticism, just those unnecessary remarks like, pension, CSD/medical facilities etc.... by people who have no knowledge, is not taken kindly. Their parents have put their youth/life for the country, so its only reasonable they get some benefits, but at the same time they are also open to criticism, but it has to be a reasonable one. Infact many openly discuss such issues like this, of course there will be exceptions to these as well, as is the case with everything in this world.
Fully agree with you and respect to you, subodh. Constructive criticism can be done as a taxpayer but ultimately we are talking about people who chose to sacrifice thier life so that ours can be safe. I do not think people realise what a gift that is. The choice of language used was absolutely deplorable.
There is no dearth of people in India who can choose Armed forces as a career option.. This is not a 55000 USD per capita Nation.. People are literally dying to serve in the Armed forces.. Yeah the choice of language can be moderated by Miss Smita prakash but anyway.. I don't understand what to make out of the term GIFT you used😂 No offence! But that was not a group discussion for Job in the Armed forces.
@@debu98 lead by example ! we are right behind you. but no you would rather sit in your air conditioned office and mock the people who risk thier lives daily in & out for our safety. whether their jobs are few or numerous is not the question. all of them from the lowest to the highest rank are deserving of our respect. They perform a SERVICE to the nation. the salary they get is not compensation. No compensation is worth a life. Of course, as taxpayer we can and are entitled to have a constructive debate. but without reading the MOU and in some cases using snippets by the PIB , people have begun to belittle and abuse the ACM : a man who whose service has been nothing but exemplary and the IAF in general. you know, i think our greatest failure is not to take care of people with toxic mentality like yours. they very fact that you would insinuate the army personnel life is expendable and not worthy of respect, makes you the lowest of trash in our society.
Don't you think the retired generals need to grow some thick skin? Yes the language could have been better, but I have seen in other countries the criticism getting a lot nastier. Also criticizing one wrong decision is not same as questioning the entire armed forces.
Being Indian armed services fan's doesn't mean all their actions are justified. Putting the Navys security at risk by the top rung bureaucrats in the Navy, I suspect under pressure from the top officer's wives (NOFRA) is complete breach of national security. Please don't try and defend for the sake of defending. Don't we know what kind of politics happens in the armed services. Nothing is unaffected by selfish politics in India. We need accountability of the top level leadership in the armed services.
I agree the language used could have been better. But it is a valid point and concern. Questioning a decision of the armed forces does not mean anyone is disrespecting them. Questions are being raised because everyone has the best interest of India at heart. You shouldn't be defending a stupid decision even if it's an MOU.
Right wing kiss kah raha hai Jinne right wing kaha ja raha wo isse desh ke sahi deshbhakt hai Indian army mein koi bhar se alien nahi aata yahi log hote hai Sach kaha unnone Aise company ko involvement nahi hona chaiye jo national security ke liye threat hai
Right wing wale dum hilaye ya sar hilaye wahi apni defense force k liye v aage aate hai baki left wing wale jab Indian army ko galat bolte hai tab defense news expert left wing wala dum hilake yes saar yes saar karte rehte hai
With due respect "unconditional apologies" from Anand Ranganathan ji was not needed I stand with AR on this he has been open and neutral in letter and spirit It was bold of him to state it on smita ji show "MoU" says a lot yes technicalities will be there wrt data-localization but are the servers "local"? . It was first discussed on def-talks by Aadi Achint and Jaipur Dialogues by Major General Rajiv Naryanan- again a very upright person wrt views ,he keeps his personal bias wrt forces away which many do not, he spoke how "data-localization" can be a eye-wash, they could have gone for Ola instead if they were secured. Good that citizens have amplified it, people are paying taxes and with the trust that its in good-faith. Why do you have to bring Right-wing/ Left-wing /Nationalist etc😂😂 bjp ain't even right wing in true sense what are you smoking dude ,if politics ain't your forte ; do not get into it. As if there hasn't been a single corruption in any procurement ever in our history. A person with right mind ( Right wing or left wing or apolitical, neo-liberals , nationalist) etc does not matter, she/he will ask questions. PRs from " defence channels" do not help. No-one's asking for "top-secret" files from forces, its a simple question of accountability , and civilians are right in asking it. Aaj "manner" / "vyavahar" of questioning se problem he...kal jab anti- India forces/ enemy states ke pass exact location data live feed of officers/ soldiers/unke family ki hogi usse taklif nahi h... hypocrisy and irony died a thousand deaths.
Bhai aap ki technical knowledge bahut achhi hai. Politics ki knowledge kam hai. M college time se le kar ab tak neta ke aas pass hi rahta hu. Karib 30 saal se.
The fact that... Our officers are so dumb to not even realize this threat, is ALARMING. You never know how many deals and agreements have gone with Cyber security ignored. You may have problem with Your FEELINGS... if so, you need to grow up... I don't care.
Bhaiya apko apne subah wale video ka comment section padhna chahiye tha. Log is baat ke liye naraz nahi hai ki un logo ne podcast par kya bola, log is bat par naraz hai ki ye MOU he kyu hua jabki data security ke already itne concerns hai apne yaha.
Both of them are quite knowledgeable but they project too much authority over their knowledge than they actually have. As long as Sushant is speaking about Pakistani history I will listen to him. Abhijeet just has a horrible personality I cannot imagine ever having a serious conversation with someone like that.
@roshanchachane142 does it matter, US has thousands of sats in space with capability to read number plate of car in 90s. The thing with modern warfare is you cannot hide capabilities, what you can hide is intention.
I m unsubscribe this type of channel who doesn't take criticism, are forces above PM if PM is critise why not forces they Done nothing on tejas mark 2 ,amca sitting like duck waiting
It is so astonishing to see army babu's getting butt hurt bcoz some civilians called them DHAKKAN'S ignoring the primary issue of data security but only focused on the language issue while these same Officer's throw Maa Behen Ki Gali To the other rank Jawan's.
Bro, that kinda strong language was need for that absolute braindead move. Everyone supports the armed forces, which is why they criticize it. Saying people should only criticize in a good way is honestly a breach of the fundamental right of expression. YOU HAVE COMMITTED A MISTAKE AND YOU ARE GOING TO HEAR ABOUT IT, period. @Alpha Defense - Hindi please don't encourage complacency in the armed forces, we already know what it leads to.
I agree the Choice of Words were a Bit Harsh.........but tell me something do these people really want to Harm our National Interests or those Babus in Mod and Airforce who didn't even think for Once before Signing this stupid agreement
Why not allow only those service providers, who will have their data centers in India, and will have no data sharing with any other data center abroad. If there is none, either they setup one exclusively for Indian armed forces, with firewalls meeting all Indian armed forces protocols, or, they disqualify. If no one is ready, drop the plan - whether it is UBER or OLA.
A simple option is for the services to buy more vehicles and recruit more men. When we spend billions of dollars on defence, what's a few hundred more vehicles and men? Nothing. And what we get : Data security. And it's not just digital information. We don't know how much we talk in our cars. Most drivers know everything about their employers.
Thanks alpha defense for the views without any bias or hype. I never miss your posts. As you said there is hardly any privacy in this digital and social media era. Ofcourse we must take our precautions. Even without Uber lives of precious scientists and finest people of defense and intelligence personnel are not safe because of our own traitors who are on the payroll of enimical or rival forces. India by itself is an easy country for Geo politics players. Glad that this is issue is raised and will send the signal to top brass of our armed forces and policy makers. Regarding Anand Ranganathan, he is a frank person without any bias who's presence in social media and TV I never miss. Keep doing your good work Subodhji. Thanks alpha defense.
Respectfully disagree with you. When it comes to decision making (and only that) armed forces should be criticized in as harsh of a language as any other government service. Also your explanation sounds like a sarkari babu this time very unlike you.
Good one Alpha Defence !! Keep it up !!! Been following defence closely since last 25yrs n have seen on couple of occasions mainstream media doing stupidity like this…however this time around…social media (Ytube)is as powerful as mainstream media, if not more !
1. To be frank MOU clearly mentioned about 'personalised profiles' for IAF personnel, when it could have called for privacy and security in statement as well. 2. Indain Govt. Through rfi route is giving Armed forces to exert pressure and take swipe at big techs . Armed forces need to learn the craft , and not be in worship mode to Big techs and call out their facade Unabashedly. MEA has learnt the thing and so has I&B Ministry in their recent portrayal of Netflix Ic814 they called India Netflix head to warn and she came running tail tucked between legs . GOI banning UBER is overkill , armed forces needs to openly assert pressure that their platform should be secure given their past data breaches. Just like us state dept , uscirf take pot shots at Indian institutes and GOI. So should armed forces take pot shots at us firms for their shoddy track record especially for likes of UBER who are replaceable, problem is they are in obedient/ cordial mode while us firms and institutes get away with anything
Dont be so ultra sensitive about arm forces ... We all love our forces but from personal experience i can tell you top officials are inefficient & corruption specially in Army.
I only saw the Uber MoU headline, so I'm not familiar with the language you are talking about. The MoU worried me. I'm not an expert, and I can't say with certainty how the defence services operate. However, our government departments have poor cyber hygiene. And we need to fix it asap.
The whole Uber MOU thing only became a big deal once ANI covered it-before that, it was just a small discussion in a RW Twitter circle. Comparing this Uber MOU to the F-18 MOU feels pretty off. Manufacturing fighter jets is a massive deal, involving tons of restrictions and high-level government involvement. But the Uber deal? Way simpler in comparison, without nearly as many layers or complications.
@@whitelotus2960 If we don’t have it yet, it doesn’t mean we will never have it. It’s like saying ISRO shouldn’t be allowed to send Indians into space because they don’t have the technology for it yet. The government should talk to Ola, provide them with the requirements, and ask them to implement them. It’s not that hard.
It was a great video, I'm a RW myself and I completely agree with 100% of your video. But there has been instances in past and there will be instances in future where left wing supporters and political parties would discredit Indian Armed Forces again like they have in past and during that time I want you to use the same language you used against us RWs, I agree some of us were wrong but our intention wasn't but I would want to be assured that whenever any political party or LWs will discredit IAF again in the future you'll have to use the same tone and language which you haven't done in the past sadly. I hope you'll show some courage against them next time until then agreeing 100% with your video as you and RWs both want the best for the nation. Sorry for my English I know it's very very bad but I hope you understood what I wanted to say
this.. No doubt Alpha Defence produces great content. But the way they try to denigrate others is not so cool, this shows they are not really open to consider others point of view which isn't great for a channel like this and countering others opinions with a RUclips video which is one way doesn't make any sense. Nobody supports a disrespectful remark against the armed forces and absolutely no place here for abuses but we need to take into account their point of view about the actual subject too. There are smart people outside this channel also.
Armed forces cannot be above criticism. And anyways, it is not like there is no corruption in armed forces. Anyways, if Parikkar had been there, he would have unraveled many more. If alpha defence does not like criticism, it doesn't mean that they are always right. Any democratic process, should have constructive criticism.
Now I understand how such a big country like India remained a slave for thousands of years. Just because you are on a high position does not mean that you are honest. Your actions tell a lot.
@vermaarpit3579 Aree Bhai, tooo kya desh ke bech de , Jab tumhara Country ka wajood he nahi rahega to economy jishka dekhoge ye bolo . Paisa sabhi kuch nahi hota. Paisa Bazar me baitha ek Prostitute bhi kamata hai aur ek sadak pe jhadu lagane wala jamadar dono ke respect me difference hai.
@mrituanjaysingh8410 it's OK, I rest my comment you are as blind and ill informed of other economic ramifications that this can cause as much as @alphadefence. Bhais ke aage been bajane se kuch nahi hota hai you guys prove it 😉
I used to follow this Alphadefence chap for some basic info and upkeeping with the whereabouts. Iski aadhi information 2 or 3 rd source hoti hai waise bhi. So as per Alpha defence right wingers cannot raise questions on the dealing on MOD. Aadhi information isse khud nahi hai.
Ola doesnt save data on any of the 3 major american hyperscalers. Ie GCP, Azure or AWS. Instead they have thier own cloud Kritrum. Aadhi adhuri information ke saath kuch bhi vedio banado
Air force ka nahi hua toh kya, navy valo ka yeh agreement ho chuka hai. I just confirmed it with one of my buddy who is in navy that uber does provide this service
Hello Subodh, I saw your recent video on MRFA and have some questions. Firstly why is Saab gripen a contender, it is in the same weight class as LCA Tejas so other than saabs promised delivery schedule starting in 2027 is their any advantage in acquiring the gripen(can you do a comparison video of the two). Secondly the f15 ex and su35 are contenders which fall in the similar weight category of su30 mki. Wouldn't it be wise to acquire more su30mki in batches with every batch having more updates than the last (as super Sukhoi upgrade is going on and we can infuse the technology).
Mr. Subodh ... it is totally incorrect to say that there is no option at the time of tender for the government to put filters on vendors. Govt absolutely has the authority to create prerequisites and vendor filters based on national security concerns. US has this, and it is called FOCI. And they do this in all the DoD contracts. Strongly suggest you look that up. Regarding data, again govt has the authority to insist all data stay local in country, so that is not a problem either.
कहते हुऐ अच्छा तो नहीं लागता लेकिन हमारी आर्मी में भी कई पोस्टो पर बैठे हुए लोगों की निष्ठायं संदेहास्पद ही नहीं बल्कि स्पष्ट रूप से दूसरों के हाथ बिकी हुई हैं......!!
Raising concern is good by Anand sir i appreciate it.lets raise another concern are you make video on CM of state trying to break India in American soil,iss Desh me jabtak sadak chap language me nahi bolega koi sunta hi nahi hai tune kitni video banai unke bolne se pehle.
While the language used could be improved, it’s encouraging that this news is finally receiving the attention it deserves. Ar a time when pagers are being used and cyber attacks are rampant, openly discussing such a naive idea raises significant concerns.
korean company that supplied spare parts to GE for f404 went bankrupt in 2016 and HAL signed for engine in 2021 . GE had no engine when it signed deal with HAL
This is the exact problem with Indians generally. Instead of adapting with the times and embracing the inevitable we play catchup. Services like Amazon uber ola etc are ubiquitous now in armes forces families. 2 having these exclusive agreements helps with data protection and incentives these companies for local data management rather than treating this anyway they want. It is very difficult to understand for even some older military officers
America Hath ,pair , muh ,pet sab dhoke ke piche pad gaya Hai!! Defence me , Smartphones me, business me, AI me ,google maps me sab me bhai self sufficient keval Defence me nahi sab me hone hai😂😂❤❤
@@saurabhsuman4197 aaj to aur bhi bura haal hai..middle class ko gareeb banao high tax se aur us tax ke paise se gareebo me revadi baato..R&d budget hai hi nhi india me
@@abhi565b finally someone with a sound mind. people think middle class taxes are charity money that we are giving for the poor, fvcking idiots keep taunting "highway se gareeb ka problem solve hoga?, bullet train se gareeb jaa payega?". dont wanna be harsh but while we contribute the nation by paying taxes they are only contributing with more and more population. 😞
Like your channel and unbiased content. Just a view..You don't need to bash the right wingers.. Maybe some of them have foul language. But in essence these are the one in political domain who are inclined towards nation..they may be currupt/boorish but atleast not shrewd/nation loathing as Leftist/woke.
Thanks to ANI for raising this issue.. Armed foces have to answer the genuine concerns of people.. They are not the Almighty.. They should be open to criticism..
Genuinely concerned public should also be aware of how things work within the military, military security systems, govt interference and Modern Warfare. Loos baby talk isn't genuine enough.
Thanks you sir but a thanks to anand Sir and ANI team who first raise question on public
Yes
If not used that language no one cares about it.
@@GauravMishrabvkm2112 right
Yes kyun defence detective so raha tha.. Haan iss defence detective wale genius ko lagta hai iske paas zyada samjh aur contacts hain armed forces mein then Anil K Singh of ANI
The very fact that they signed that mou tells you a lot.
Navy has already signed similar deal.
Not only uber, but armed forces already have such deals with makemytrip, zepto, blinkit etc.
How do we know if genrails arent getting kickbacks for providing lakhs and millions of potential customers to these companies?
Whats next, Indian army genrails trading millions of potential customers with MacDonald, airliners, Amazon, ola, etc?
Gov should put an immediate stop to this and also investigate people responsible for such deals, if they got some kind of kickback for it.
Armed forces ke cyber security knowledge 0 hain. Linkedin profile kholke pura biodata dal ke rakhta hain.
What is your point? The question can be pn the process, but are tough saying defense establishment should not engage with private enterprise at all?
This is the exact problem with Indians generally. Instead of adapting with the times and embracing the inevitable we play catchup. Services like Amazon uber ola etc are ubiquitous now in armes forces families.
2 having these exclusive agreements helps with data protection and incentives these companies for local data management rather than treating this anyway they want. It is very difficult to understand for even some older military officers
I have been working in IT since last 10 yrs. This is unnecessary venture, armed force delve into. These things will definitely compromise security. They are directly opening the gates for terrorists into the armed campuses. This person only makes just videos. He doesn't know any thing about digital security. People should raise concerns and this is what Rangnathan is doing. I have worked closely with navy indigenous development firm, i don't want to name it. These people, even the technical one (upto the rank of colonel) don't have basic knowledge of how technology works. This isn't their fault. They have been evolved in that manner only. They better take advise from analysts belong to relevant fields before delve into such security prone decisions.
@PrashantSharma-vb3ib 1. An MOU is not a venture
2 by your comment it seems you don't seem to have any idea about the defence forces itself and how these apps are now ubiquitous
First of all, there shouldn't have been any MOU, the rest of the points are moot. It doesn't matter what Mechanism they formulate, Americans have thousands of ways to track you down if you use Uber. We have seen in the past how our so-called super smart Armed Forces officers have leaked top secret documents after falling prey to honey traps, the most ancient form of espionage technique. The criticism is absolutely fair but Language could be better. The very idea of MOU hints at the ineptitude of basic understanding of cyber security.
RESPECT for Anand
what was anands previous comment and what was his apologetic comment , can you explain please?
@@rektttcodgameplay6757 I also have the same question
@@rektttcodgameplay6757I also have same que ?
@@rektttcodgameplay6757 watch ANI podcast
The kind of language used is secondary. Raising of the issue is primary. How procedures work is a secondary question. The primary question is why the MoU was signed in the first place? Thank God India has people who actually raise such questions to our armed forces. Otherwise who knows what will go flying under the radar. When national interest is the issue we should all strictly avoid becoming emotional.
Totally agree with Sushant, Anand, Tehseen Abhijeet & ANI were absolutely correct. The sadak chhap language as you alledged was very sobre. The cyber hiegne displayed by AF & Navy is aweful, they need to be taken to the task. Now these guys are trying to defends themselves thru their puppets. Instead of canxelling the MoUs and tendering public apology; these so called puppets/fans giving all kinds of trivial justifications. By the way these puppet websites themselves has lot of data on them with the grace of these forces for business purpose. These American companies (who spy for deep state) have penetrated our forces. Just give them freebees; you get an entry..
This person doesn't know anything rather than making videos. Everybody knows airforce and navy are going to do this blunder & foreign agency must be laughing somewhere in the corner.
You think IB/Raw is sleeping, they know everything, they will monitor it, why cry when forces are making money too or getting MoU done@@PrashantSharma-vb3ib
Agaye defend karne iaf ke balwas steps.I fully agree with Anand sir. People have the right to criticise.
Ys..true..Indians can't take Criticism..I can give 100's of examples..
If you have no knowledge then try to shut up..rather than vomiting useless opinions 😅
@@jessicaperry7549 please entertain us with your heavenly knowledge on cyber-security and data-breach concern. What happened in Kargil and gps issue? How does MoU ensure data-localization
and data feed isn't sourced to servers outside. Exact locations ,your mobility preference your preferred drivers your stoppage timings your lags your patterns are tracked aided by maps😆 don't make people laugh those who are in domain of cyber-security /data-arch. Enemy states/non state actors need nothing more ,you are a sitting duck. Vomiting( emesis) is good , it removes the toxic elements from the body, any SAAS Co. start-up in India has better cyber-hygiene than Govt depts, IAF is no exception ; in the end its an arm under Govt of India nothing more and nothing less.
@@anitapadhi325 what kind of knowledge does the undergrad of Whatsapp University wants...specify..ever heard of nat grid...please type the following promt " NAT GRID India " on google ..im just this will help you in getting your graduation.
@@jessicaperry7549puppet apna kaam karo
this is why we love right wing
right wing doesnt care about gov or army
we can speak freely which is needed , indian navy literally had england flag for 60 years , where were defense lovers xd
Even now the Indian military culture is like dogs of the British. Would you believe they use spoon and fork to eat even roti in the officer's mess once upon a time.
They are so pathetic, they proudly showoff 'British heritage' in their training.
U do know that the Armed Forces can't change already sign any agreement without Bjp's yes? Because bjp is the current ruler.
Just bullying some people into apologising is not going to solve anything. It will just assuage egos of veterans and defense brats. As for your friend AIM, he was pretty decent in his criticism.
@@sreeharsha1828 this how ecosystem of these people works but if I am not wrong IAF and Navy scraped the Mou today..
@gamelover195 Yes. And our Subodh is still busy ridiculing audience that they don't know difference between MoU and Contract. But IAF themselves delete the post and now cancelling the arrangement with the taxi service. FWIW MoU is not a contract but many small arrangements run just on MoU when both parties want a semi formal arrangement.
@@sreeharsha1828 Yeah. All for video purpose only no real concern here.
No need for apologies
Totally agreed with all the people in the podcast
Prof. Anand is a true nationalist and a decent person. We all must appreciate his gesture. However, it must be said that the way IAF official gave it publicity, it carried wrong impression and some immediate negative reaction was natural. Even if Uber is finally selected, data security and national interest are is a precondition.
I too heard some details regarding the word profiling or some kind of masked identity but these fine prints are risky. Especially with respect to collecting data of the families. with time they get more data about the families of armed forces which can be used against those families indirectly.
@@vivekmanjeshwar2039 Yes. absolutely. All the concerns are valid and Armed Forces should not hurry into this until all aspects are sorted.
How data security will be a precondition? Uber store all data in USA. It will take years to make new data canter operational in India, if at all they are willing to invest such huge amount of money. Even then they cannot be fully trusted not to send data outside.
@@PritamC-r2z I agree with your view. As a lay person I can give my a crude solution. Best tech, and cyber savvy brains can come out with a solution. Ie instead of individual name, app should have user:employee belongs to one company/armed forces and only that company is booking that service provider with masked identity in which case they know he or she is member of armed forces just like CUG SIM incase of a company and employee has hired the services something like that. Hope tech and cyber unit will come out with a solution. Just a layman's view.
@@PritamC-r2z In which case, Uber is obviously OUT!
Dude this matter not should have gone till MOU.
Airforce are supposed to be most technical folks they should help govt to come with measures protecting data.
They are incompetent with matter of decision making and foresight.
But will not question there work ethic valor and duty to the country.
Also Aib and ss blabbering is what helped to bring this to foresight or it will be pushed under rugs.
This video of urs defending poor decision of armed force is not great.
Arrey Bhai, humare air force officers kya Android ya fir iPhone use nahi karte kya, Uber use kare na kare, location toh pata chal hi jaega
@hannanhub1717 brother it helps to create more detailed profile of the whole family and friends based on the interface. Yes true it's compromised but this is next level. Almost keeping window open for a house so any body can sneak in or peak. Once profile is built there is lot of ways to take advantage.
My only question is this why even think about dealing with foreign country... That can easily record your movement
Subodh bhaiya they are right this time and if everything needs to be from west(from Iphone to Jet engine) why our podcasters can't criticise as people in United states do? Jai Hind
Exactly brother u nailed it
@@nandishcs yeah, I mean.. People in the United states criticise a lot heavy handed than people here.. And if we have an audience who is buying Iphone and Coldplay tickets.. I think we are ready for some Military criticism too just like in the United states.. Only Army Brats in my opinion feel offended even with a slightest of millitary criticism else not many people have got offended by that..
@debu98 dude I worked in HAL and I know how much airforce derailed the tejas project. Not defending Hal they are also at fault. I left hal seeing the process. Airforce f**k up also reading for re tender of 114 planes.
@@debu98 Justified criticism is the highest form of Patriotism.
@@debu98 You are wrong about that only, military brats are offended, that's just your limited & clouded opinion. Many army brats, are open to criticism, just those unnecessary remarks like, pension, CSD/medical facilities etc.... by people who have no knowledge, is not taken kindly. Their parents have put their youth/life for the country, so its only reasonable they get some benefits, but at the same time they are also open to criticism, but it has to be a reasonable one. Infact many openly discuss such issues like this, of course there will be exceptions to these as well, as is the case with everything in this world.
Anand Ranganathan is great person
Fully agree with you and respect to you, subodh. Constructive criticism can be done as a taxpayer but ultimately we are talking about people who chose to sacrifice thier life so that ours can be safe. I do not think people realise what a gift that is. The choice of language used was absolutely deplorable.
There is no dearth of people in India who can choose Armed forces as a career option.. This is not a 55000 USD per capita Nation.. People are literally dying to serve in the Armed forces.. Yeah the choice of language can be moderated by Miss Smita prakash but anyway.. I don't understand what to make out of the term GIFT you used😂 No offence! But that was not a group discussion for Job in the Armed forces.
@@debu98 lead by example ! we are right behind you. but no you would rather sit in your air conditioned office and mock the people who risk thier lives daily in & out for our safety. whether their jobs are few or numerous is not the question. all of them from the lowest to the highest rank are deserving of our respect. They perform a SERVICE to the nation. the salary they get is not compensation. No compensation is worth a life. Of course, as taxpayer we can and are entitled to have a constructive debate. but without reading the MOU and in some cases using snippets by the PIB , people have begun to belittle and abuse the ACM : a man who whose service has been nothing but exemplary and the IAF in general. you know, i think our greatest failure is not to take care of people with toxic mentality like yours. they very fact that you would insinuate the army personnel life is expendable and not worthy of respect, makes you the lowest of trash in our society.
Don't you think the retired generals need to grow some thick skin? Yes the language could have been better, but I have seen in other countries the criticism getting a lot nastier. Also criticizing one wrong decision is not same as questioning the entire armed forces.
Being Indian armed services fan's doesn't mean all their actions are justified. Putting the Navys security at risk by the top rung bureaucrats in the Navy, I suspect under pressure from the top officer's wives (NOFRA) is complete breach of national security. Please don't try and defend for the sake of defending. Don't we know what kind of politics happens in the armed services. Nothing is unaffected by selfish politics in India. We need accountability of the top level leadership in the armed services.
Corruption by Defence top brass will be targeted like this what Anand said.
I agree the language used could have been better. But it is a valid point and concern. Questioning a decision of the armed forces does not mean anyone is disrespecting them. Questions are being raised because everyone has the best interest of India at heart. You shouldn't be defending a stupid decision even if it's an MOU.
Right wing kiss kah raha hai
Jinne right wing kaha ja raha wo isse desh ke sahi deshbhakt hai
Indian army mein koi bhar se alien nahi aata yahi log hote hai
Sach kaha unnone
Aise company ko involvement nahi hona chaiye jo national security ke liye threat hai
Right wing wale dum hilaye ya sar hilaye wahi apni defense force k liye v aage aate hai baki left wing wale jab Indian army ko galat bolte hai tab defense news expert left wing wala dum hilake yes saar yes saar karte rehte hai
Jai Shree Radhe Krishna 🙏🙏🧡
Jai Bharat Rashtra 🙏🙏🧡
With due respect "unconditional apologies" from Anand Ranganathan ji was not needed I stand with AR on this he has been open and neutral in letter and spirit It was bold of him to state it on smita ji show "MoU" says a lot yes technicalities will be there wrt data-localization but are the servers "local"? . It was first discussed on def-talks by Aadi Achint and Jaipur Dialogues by Major General Rajiv Naryanan- again a very upright person wrt views ,he keeps his personal bias wrt forces away which many do not, he spoke how "data-localization" can be a eye-wash, they could have gone for Ola instead if they were secured. Good that citizens have amplified it, people are paying taxes and with the trust that its in good-faith. Why do you have to bring Right-wing/ Left-wing /Nationalist etc😂😂 bjp ain't even right wing in true sense what are you smoking dude ,if politics ain't your forte ; do not get into it. As if there hasn't been a single corruption in any procurement ever in our history. A person with right mind ( Right wing or left wing or apolitical, neo-liberals , nationalist) etc does not matter, she/he will ask questions. PRs from " defence channels" do not help.
No-one's asking for "top-secret" files from forces, its a simple question of accountability , and civilians are right in asking it. Aaj "manner" / "vyavahar" of questioning se problem he...kal jab anti- India forces/ enemy states ke pass exact location data live feed of officers/ soldiers/unke family ki hogi usse taklif nahi h... hypocrisy and irony died a thousand deaths.
Bhai aap ki technical knowledge bahut achhi hai. Politics ki knowledge kam hai. M college time se le kar ab tak neta ke aas pass hi rahta hu. Karib 30 saal se.
😂😂😂😂
The fact that... Our officers are so dumb to not even realize this threat, is ALARMING. You never know how many deals and agreements have gone with Cyber security ignored. You may have problem with Your FEELINGS... if so, you need to grow up... I don't care.
Thanks for clearing this confusion 👍
Bhaiya apko apne subah wale video ka comment section padhna chahiye tha. Log is baat ke liye naraz nahi hai ki un logo ne podcast par kya bola, log is bat par naraz hai ki ye MOU he kyu hua jabki data security ke already itne concerns hai apne yaha.
True. Address that
Sareen and Taklu only do RR and keep crying all the time. They invent reason to cry.😂😂
Both of them are quite knowledgeable but they project too much authority over their knowledge than they actually have. As long as Sushant is speaking about Pakistani history I will listen to him. Abhijeet just has a horrible personality I cannot imagine ever having a serious conversation with someone like that.
Loru if they don't raise how it could be a topic of discussion in higher level
OSINT just released tracking data of an IAF Personnel roaming inside an Air Force base, meanwhile, you keep crying about Language.
@roshanchachane142 does it matter, US has thousands of sats in space with capability to read number plate of car in 90s. The thing with modern warfare is you cannot hide capabilities, what you can hide is intention.
Bro❤
I m unsubscribe this type of channel who doesn't take criticism, are forces above PM if PM is critise why not forces they Done nothing on tejas mark 2 ,amca sitting like duck waiting
It is so astonishing to see army babu's getting butt hurt bcoz some civilians called them DHAKKAN'S ignoring the primary issue of data security but only focused on the language issue while these same Officer's throw Maa Behen Ki Gali To the other rank Jawan's.
IAF should have signed with Chinese if better deal is offered 😅
They could have approached a homegrown transport company like OLA for this. Uber should not have been allowed in the first place.
Oh no, our armed forces worship foreign shit like it is their God.
why do these guys need a discount on everything ? they get paid so much but want everything for free.
Bro, that kinda strong language was need for that absolute braindead move. Everyone supports the armed forces, which is why they criticize it. Saying people should only criticize in a good way is honestly a breach of the fundamental right of expression. YOU HAVE COMMITTED A MISTAKE AND YOU ARE GOING TO HEAR ABOUT IT, period. @Alpha Defense - Hindi please don't encourage complacency in the armed forces, we already know what it leads to.
JAI HIND. CARRY ON DOING BEST.
04:10 afterwards:- ह्रदय की गहराइयों से निकलती हैं ऐसी वाणी
Ola Cab's data is now kept in India in their Krutrim storage and cloud, so no issue of data security.
I agree the Choice of Words were a Bit Harsh.........but tell me something do these people really want to Harm our National Interests or those Babus in Mod and Airforce who didn't even think for Once before Signing this stupid agreement
I think "UDCHALO" IS BETTER OPTION
Why not allow only those service providers, who will have their data centers in India, and will have no data sharing with any other data center abroad. If there is none, either they setup one exclusively for Indian armed forces, with firewalls meeting all Indian armed forces protocols, or, they disqualify. If no one is ready, drop the plan - whether it is UBER or OLA.
I fully concur with you “ Baki bache 2 logo se mujhe koi umeed nahi hai”
A simple option is for the services to buy more vehicles and recruit more men. When we spend billions of dollars on defence, what's a few hundred more vehicles and men? Nothing. And what we get : Data security. And it's not just digital information. We don't know how much we talk in our cars. Most drivers know everything about their employers.
Thanks alpha defense for the views without any bias or hype. I never miss your posts. As you said there is hardly any privacy in this digital and social media era. Ofcourse we must take our precautions. Even without Uber lives of precious scientists and finest people of defense and intelligence personnel are not safe because of our own traitors who are on the payroll of enimical or rival forces. India by itself is an easy country for Geo politics players. Glad that this is issue is raised and will send the signal to top brass of our armed forces and policy makers. Regarding Anand Ranganathan, he is a frank person without any bias who's presence in social media and TV I never miss. Keep doing your good work Subodhji. Thanks alpha defense.
Respectfully disagree with you. When it comes to decision making (and only that) armed forces should be criticized in as harsh of a language as any other government service. Also your explanation sounds like a sarkari babu this time very unlike you.
I agree
His take of f18 mou bs doesn't make sense
Unsubscribed
Bhai ab faar right waalo ne kya kar diya?😂
Ye to mujhe bhi janna hai
China ka boycott cancel kr diya
@@AfridAhmed-mo6of kon bola ye tujhe koi kaan me aake bolne aaye
Corrupt kair force ofiicers apne bacchon ko set kar rahee hai 😢😢😢😢
Jai Hind 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
Good one Alpha Defence !! Keep it up !!! Been following defence closely since last 25yrs n have seen on couple of occasions mainstream media doing stupidity like this…however this time around…social media (Ytube)is as powerful as mainstream media, if not more !
1. To be frank MOU clearly mentioned about 'personalised profiles' for IAF personnel, when it could have called for privacy and security in statement as well.
2. Indain Govt. Through rfi route is giving Armed forces to exert pressure and take swipe at big techs . Armed forces need to learn the craft , and not be in worship mode to Big techs and call out their facade Unabashedly.
MEA has learnt the thing and so has I&B Ministry in their recent portrayal of Netflix Ic814 they called India Netflix head to warn and she came running tail tucked between legs . GOI banning UBER is overkill , armed forces needs to openly assert pressure that their platform should be secure given their past data breaches.
Just like us state dept , uscirf take pot shots at Indian institutes and GOI. So should armed forces take pot shots at us firms for their shoddy track record especially for likes of UBER who are replaceable, problem is they are in obedient/ cordial mode while us firms and institutes get away with anything
Dont be so ultra sensitive about arm forces ... We all love our forces but from personal experience i can tell you top officials are inefficient & corruption specially in Army.
same! ikr but he has bad rep for simping over incompetence of military.
Criticism of Every Institution is necessary. No one is holier than though
I only saw the Uber MoU headline, so I'm not familiar with the language you are talking about. The MoU worried me. I'm not an expert, and I can't say with certainty how the defence services operate. However, our government departments have poor cyber hygiene. And we need to fix it asap.
The whole Uber MOU thing only became a big deal once ANI covered it-before that, it was just a small discussion in a RW Twitter circle. Comparing this Uber MOU to the F-18 MOU feels pretty off. Manufacturing fighter jets is a massive deal, involving tons of restrictions and high-level government involvement. But the Uber deal? Way simpler in comparison, without nearly as many layers or complications.
Alpha defense now becomes American defense
@@user-ts9sy5gy2j They have become Beta defence!
Okay so list one uber like Indian company which is using and only Indian cyber security system or cloud system. We don't have any.
@@whitelotus2960 If we don’t have it yet, it doesn’t mean we will never have it. It’s like saying ISRO shouldn’t be allowed to send Indians into space because they don’t have the technology for it yet. The government should talk to Ola, provide them with the requirements, and ask them to implement them. It’s not that hard.
Mr. Ott Navy has already made deal with Uber of same magnitude, so IAF and NAVY officers keep playing promo code and offers
It was a great video, I'm a RW myself and I completely agree with 100% of your video. But there has been instances in past and there will be instances in future where left wing supporters and political parties would discredit Indian Armed Forces again like they have in past and during that time I want you to use the same language you used against us RWs, I agree some of us were wrong but our intention wasn't but I would want to be assured that whenever any political party or LWs will discredit IAF again in the future you'll have to use the same tone and language which you haven't done in the past sadly. I hope you'll show some courage against them next time until then agreeing 100% with your video as you and RWs both want the best for the nation. Sorry for my English I know it's very very bad but I hope you understood what I wanted to say
this.. No doubt Alpha Defence produces great content. But the way they try to denigrate others is not so cool, this shows they are not really open to consider others point of view which isn't great for a channel like this and countering others opinions with a RUclips video which is one way doesn't make any sense. Nobody supports a disrespectful remark against the armed forces and absolutely no place here for abuses but we need to take into account their point of view about the actual subject too. There are smart people outside this channel also.
Not agree tum defend kar rahe ho , mou hi nahi hona chahiye
Armed forces cannot be above criticism. And anyways, it is not like there is no corruption in armed forces. Anyways, if Parikkar had been there, he would have unraveled many more. If alpha defence does not like criticism, it doesn't mean that they are always right. Any democratic process, should have constructive criticism.
Now I understand how such a big country like India remained a slave for thousands of years. Just because you are on a high position does not mean that you are honest. Your actions tell a lot.
Jai Hind. Slow pace of public awareness Unless invited in Talkshows.
Cancel all Bilateral relationship with US and western and European countries. They are threat for India.
Hmm Economy Jo tank karegi uski bharpai aapke Taya ji ke khazane se hoga
@vermaarpit3579 Aree Bhai, tooo kya desh ke bech de , Jab tumhara Country ka wajood he nahi rahega to economy jishka dekhoge ye bolo .
Paisa sabhi kuch nahi hota. Paisa Bazar me baitha ek Prostitute bhi kamata hai aur ek sadak pe jhadu lagane wala jamadar dono ke respect me difference hai.
@mrituanjaysingh8410 it's OK, I rest my comment you are as blind and ill informed of other economic ramifications that this can cause as much as @alphadefence.
Bhais ke aage been bajane se kuch nahi hota hai you guys prove it 😉
Naman hai Alpha Defense ko for....... Itnee justification kay leya..... Bhai..... No comment.....
Thanks for the video 🙏
I used to follow this Alphadefence chap for some basic info and upkeeping with the whereabouts.
Iski aadhi information 2 or 3 rd source hoti hai waise bhi.
So as per Alpha defence right wingers cannot raise questions on the dealing on MOD.
Aadhi information isse khud nahi hai.
Ola doesnt save data on any of the 3 major american hyperscalers. Ie GCP, Azure or AWS.
Instead they have thier own cloud Kritrum.
Aadhi adhuri information ke saath kuch bhi vedio banado
You are right that defense ministry should take a policy decision in this matter. It’s not a hard or complicated decision.
❤❤
Air force ka nahi hua toh kya, navy valo ka yeh agreement ho chuka hai.
I just confirmed it with one of my buddy who is in navy that uber does provide this service
Gyi bhens pani me
Valmiki Should Marry Bhramin to Establish Hindu Unity....
Hindu Ekta Zindabad 💪🏻
Hello Subodh,
I saw your recent video on MRFA and have some questions. Firstly why is Saab gripen a contender, it is in the same weight class as LCA Tejas so other than saabs promised delivery schedule starting in 2027 is their any advantage in acquiring the gripen(can you do a comparison video of the two).
Secondly the f15 ex and su35 are contenders which fall in the similar weight category of su30 mki. Wouldn't it be wise to acquire more su30mki in batches with every batch having more updates than the last (as super Sukhoi upgrade is going on and we can infuse the technology).
IAF wants an aircraft that can carry 4 BVR, 2WVR and 2 Drop Tanks. ANything meeting that is allowed. MK2 will also be allowed if it comes out in time
Sir right wing people world is
arround beef
^
Hum Log ^DEFENCE FANS^ right wing wale Log Nahin...
Dhanyawad Sharmaji.
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Laage Raho Sharmaji.
Great & Gracias.
Mr. Subodh ... it is totally incorrect to say that there is no option at the time of tender for the government to put filters on vendors. Govt absolutely has the authority to create prerequisites and vendor filters based on national security concerns.
US has this, and it is called FOCI. And they do this in all the DoD contracts. Strongly suggest you look that up. Regarding data, again govt has the authority to insist all data stay local in country, so that is not a problem either.
Thanks young man happy to see you
MOU is mostly a public relations or political marketing. Its written in such a way that any outcome is possible.
True. There are not many options. Über issue is a needless controversy.
Absolutely right sir
कहते हुऐ अच्छा तो नहीं लागता लेकिन हमारी आर्मी में भी कई पोस्टो पर बैठे हुए लोगों की निष्ठायं संदेहास्पद ही नहीं बल्कि स्पष्ट रूप से दूसरों के हाथ बिकी हुई हैं......!!
Yeh woh Uber Flying Taxi se related hai? Tesla & Archer were going to jointly work on this for Uber.
Which video should i watch before this to understand this?
JAI HIND 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Again, language was wrong but concerns raised were right.
Raising concern is good by Anand sir i appreciate it.lets raise another concern are you make video on CM of state trying to break India in American soil,iss Desh me jabtak sadak chap language me nahi bolega koi sunta hi nahi hai tune kitni video banai unke bolne se pehle.
While the language used could be improved, it’s encouraging that this news is finally receiving the attention it deserves. Ar a time when pagers are being used and cyber attacks are rampant, openly discussing such a naive idea raises significant concerns.
Just explain why did the IAF delete the post?
korean company that supplied spare parts to GE for f404 went bankrupt in 2016 and HAL signed for engine in 2021 . GE had no engine when it signed deal with HAL
Anand sir is a great guy
Kya brother koi khabar nehi hai ka.
This is the exact problem with Indians generally. Instead of adapting with the times and embracing the inevitable we play catchup. Services like Amazon uber ola etc are ubiquitous now in armes forces families.
2 having these exclusive agreements helps with data protection and incentives these companies for local data management rather than treating this anyway they want. It is very difficult to understand for even some older military officers
What about the other software military purchased which they talked about on podcast
No need to blacklist Uber. A simpler way is to just add a clause in tender that only Indian based startup can participate. SIMPLE
Justin Tudu 😂😂
America Hath ,pair , muh ,pet sab dhoke ke piche pad gaya Hai!! Defence me , Smartphones me, business me, AI me ,google maps me sab me bhai self sufficient keval Defence me nahi sab me hone hai😂😂❤❤
Kuch nhi hoga, jab innovations ka time tha tab is desh me socialism ki aandhi chal rhi thi..
@@abhi565bAaj bhi vhi chal rhi hai
@@saurabhsuman4197 aaj to aur bhi bura haal hai..middle class ko gareeb banao high tax se aur us tax ke paise se gareebo me revadi baato..R&d budget hai hi nhi india me
@@abhi565b finally someone with a sound mind. people think middle class taxes are charity money that we are giving for the poor, fvcking idiots keep taunting "highway se gareeb ka problem solve hoga?, bullet train se gareeb jaa payega?". dont wanna be harsh but while we contribute the nation by paying taxes they are only contributing with more and more population. 😞
Yeh to halat hai hamare so called Intellectuals ki...batao...kuch bhi bak bak karenge, kabhi lagta hai isse to common Indian theek sochta hoga!!
MOU साइन करने का कोई मतलब ही नहीं है।
alpha defence is a spineless lost cause
Ola is the best, they have their own Map, ola maps and they are also working on their own data system. Storage capacities.
Proudly I'm user of 'Sandesh App' 😊
Why you even sign that MOU??
This is utter BS. What he raised is a valid point.. instead of focusing on the point you guys are focusing on language..
Like your channel and unbiased content.
Just a view..You don't need to bash the right wingers.. Maybe some of them have foul language.
But in essence these are the one in political domain who are inclined towards nation..they may be currupt/boorish but atleast not shrewd/nation loathing as Leftist/woke.
Ham log khud hi lad rahe hain
North East India mein Maryland banane ke liye US kam per lag raha hai😡
KUCHH DIN MEIN BIG NEWS BANEGA