I think the music doesn’t fit because players would have an idea of what’s about to go down, this moment was so amazing on the first playthrough because we had zero idea John was gonna die, it seemed everything was going so well and this hits us in the face like a brick… true subtlety can go a long way
@@fernandom.varela1109 I think it would've been better if you played the music right after John collapses to the ground or at least when he falls to his knees. That way you keep the shock of his death intact while still using the song in a fitting way with the *"Guess I got, what I deserved"* line.
The song with John's demise here gives it a more heroic and inspiring context than a *"satisfaction with little well done in a life of wrong"* feel that Walt's or the edits with Arthur's death have. I would've had it play tho after John collapses to the ground (mirroring BrBa) or after the initial shock of John getting shot and falling to his knees.
That was such a heartbreaking moment! But I think the scene where Arthur said "you did it Micah, you survived this gang and even myself. Now I'm gonna find peace at my deathbed... You could say this is my Red Dead Redemption 2"
Yeah, I made this video after watching Breaking Bad's finale and I thought: "hey, this reminds me of something" and then I just put the pieces together.
@@spider-manunknown9193 I disagree, I think it fits very well. If anything, I think his death is more similar to Breaking Bad's ending with him going out redeeming himself while knowing he got what he deserved.
"Guess I got what I deserved Kept you waiting there too long, my love All that time, without a word Did you really think that I'd forget And regret The special love I have for you My baby blue" It's like it's describing John.
when I first beat the game, I knew it was the ending when I saw multiple soldiers with guns outside through the crack of the barn door. Very sad ending.
Very sad indeed. I thought I could kill them all, like I have been doing up until that point. Definitely the game knows how to play with the player's feelings
For years I've wondered why the name of the game was read dead redemption. Now I realized it. John redeemed himself, died and ended up completely red cause of blood loss.
Yup, it's a curious change, because in red dead revolver, it's more like "red's revolver kills a lot of people", and then we have these deep meaning names that we won't catch at the first time
The crazy thing about the ending is that it was so unexpected especially with the army lighting up john like a Christmas tree, i thought he would surrender and get hanged in Blackwater 😢
@@W_Coruix That's exactly it. A lot of people still think John's fate was a matter of *"if only he could do this or if he shot them faster"* no John went out there meaning to sacrifice himself so his family is left alone.
@@jpiny4854 That's true, I suppose what really pisses me off is when John actually shoots someone, I prefer to have him try to aim for everyone only for him to die without even killing one of them, gives it a bit more drama I suppose.
I didn't like the rdr ending, I think it would be better when John got shot he said "My wounds are red just like my heart, unlike your heart Ross, yours is black. And then with tears in his eyes, Ross says "John. Being a Black Alive Damnation is better than being Red and Dead. Finish him boys" But before the army can fire a shot, Charles and Sadie from rdr2 come back and kill everyone. Then they pick up John and Ross says "How is this possible?" And john replies "I don't know but, we are the Red Dead Redemption, and you are done." Then they kill Ross and they take John to a doctor and they all live happily ever after
It's difficult. I like Arthur because I played rdr2 and I know what he went through. But John has gone for a different but yet similar kind of pain; having to hunt down some old friends in order to get your family back. But, I personally like Arthur more.
@@fernandom.varela1109 Yeah,both had pretty compelling stories but I would also say Arthur because he literally gave all he had to make sure John could escape with his family.
![Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang Members' Deaths (from Davey to Abigail) [PC, 4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5gjVpYQ9DWQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I loved the part when John Marston said "This is my Red Dead Redemption" and then started redempting all over the place.
Truly one of the moments of all times
truly the moment of all time
High Honor Arthur in Chapter 6.
Truly one of the
I loved the part where Arthur said "IT'S TIME FOR MY RED DEAD REDEMPTION TOO" and then started Redeeming all over Micah
"guess i got what i deserved" fits so well with johns story
This song fits any anti hero’s death perfectly
"JOHN. JOHN I HAVE TUBERCULOSIS. WE NEED TO REDEMPT." - Arthur White
Possibly the best comment here
oh it's redeeming time
Yo Mr white I got shot by by the us millitary Mr white
Redempting Red
I loved the part where Arthur stepped in and said "I have tuberculosis" and started coughing all over the place
☠️☠️☠️
🗿
💀 (arthur emoji)
LMAO
Jajajjajaja
I loved the part where John said "It's Marstoning time" and Marstoned all over the place
Truly one of the scenes of all time
I loved the part where Dutch said “I have a plan” and then started planing all over the place.
Truly one of the moments of all time
put this music on any death and it becomes 1000x more sad
True
Nope 👎
@@spider-manunknown9193 ok 👁️👄👁️
Waltuh put this music away waltuh i not dying right now waltuh
@@cullectmypages I AM THE ONE SUFFERING FROM CANCER AND BLOOD LOSS
0:32 I love how you can hear siren blaring in the distance, *the impending doom approaches*
Why does it fit so perfectly 😭😭😭
It fits even more with high honor go for the money ending in rdr2
@@quandaledingle9263 true
@@quandaledingle9263no it doesn’t.
It does fit perfecly in the scene
I think the music doesn’t fit because players would have an idea of what’s about to go down, this moment was so amazing on the first playthrough because we had zero idea John was gonna die, it seemed everything was going so well and this hits us in the face like a brick… true subtlety can go a long way
True, It was really shocking. But i wanted to try and combine one of my favourite games with of my favourite shows
Its just an edit, it doesnt have to fit in the original product
@@fernandom.varela1109 I think it would've been better if you played the music right after John collapses to the ground or at least when he falls to his knees. That way you keep the shock of his death intact while still using the song in a fitting way with the *"Guess I got, what I deserved"* line.
@@themadtitan7603 that's a good idea, this Is how these types of videos are now
@@fernandom.varela1109 Yep, like those videos that used the song with Arthur's death that got popular.
Double nostalgia at the same time
I loved the part where Uncle said “I have Lumbago” and started relapsing on the porch
The song with John's demise here gives it a more heroic and inspiring context than a *"satisfaction with little well done in a life of wrong"* feel that Walt's or the edits with Arthur's death have. I would've had it play tho after John collapses to the ground (mirroring BrBa) or after the initial shock of John getting shot and falling to his knees.
Play video games with a Spotify playlist on, you'd be surprised by how much emotion is added sometimes.
I loved How this man arranged musicians to play Baby Blue before even knowing that he is going to die.
This is the moment Red Dead Redemption became Dead. Bravo Dan.
"I guess i got, what i deserve"
oddly more fitting than I expected. John pushing open the doors a bit reminded me of Walter placing his hand onto that machine before he collapsed.
"You won, agent ross. After all the blood and death, I finally found peace... This is truly Red Dead Redemption."
That was such a heartbreaking moment!
But I think the scene where Arthur said "you did it Micah, you survived this gang and even myself. Now I'm gonna find peace at my deathbed... You could say this is my Red Dead Redemption 2"
Well, this is my Red Dead Redemption ™️
I loved the part when Jack said "it's jackin' time" and jacks all over
wait a minute...
Skeet skeet
💀
Ayo what
🤨
This fits incredibly well within the context of the game.
Yeah, I made this video after watching Breaking Bad's finale and I thought: "hey, this reminds me of something" and then I just put the pieces together.
My name is Abigail Marston yo
My husband's John Marston yo
I watched a 20 second long unskippable ad for this shi 😭😭😭
@@daveSUStaine31 nice I've come to love this one
Bro think he Walter white
This came out before Felina.
@@themadtitan7603 whats up
@@2minutesofrdr2234 Hey
@@themadtitan7603 u still active as always?
@@2minutesofrdr2234 I guess.
Bro the lyrics make complete sense with the game
That's what I thought
@@fernandom.varela1109 can't believe you responded even though you posted this vid 2 years ago
@@averyboredcam it's the least I can do to thank people for watching the video.
@@fernandom.varela1109 W vid W reply
@@fernandom.varela1109what a chad ❤
0:43
You know why Edgar Ross can't be marked
plot armor
This song fits very well with this scene.
It does.
Happy new year
@@fernandom.varela1109 happy new year
I’ve never played the first game yet this still hits me so hard every time I watch it. I love John Marston dammit
Same, I wish I could play the game without having to buy another console.
@@fernandom.varela1109luckily my dad had a ps3 down in the basement I was able to play it on!
When I first saw this scene, this song immediately played in my head
The line “guess I got what i deserved” hit different.
i guess the real red dead redemption were the friends we made along the way
The part that hurt the most for me was when he said "I am Red Dead Redemption" and he dies...
Any video game death with this song makes it so much better nice video btw 👍🏻
And this Is a fact
Rightt i made one similar to this but with joker's death in arkham city
@@gamerghost1540 i Will check your video
This is the moment where John becomes Marstonberg
Really well done 👌🏻
I watched Arthur's death with this and Johns fits way better
Love it
Arthur death wouldn’t fit with this music.
Meddl
@@spider-manunknown9193 I disagree, I think it fits very well. If anything, I think his death is more similar to Breaking Bad's ending with him going out redeeming himself while knowing he got what he deserved.
"Guess I got what I deserved
Kept you waiting there too long, my love
All that time, without a word
Did you really think that I'd forget
And regret
The special love I have for you
My baby blue"
It's like it's describing John.
Red Dead Redemption: Exists
Kid named Dead:
Johnuh, put your gun away
Bro the best part was when john said "john" and started johning everywhere truly the moment
I like the part where micah said "Its rattin time" and statrted ratting all over the place
Many thanks to everyone who Is watching the video right now, i didn't expect this to go viral after almost two years. Many many thanks
when I first beat the game, I knew it was the ending when I saw multiple soldiers with guns outside through the crack of the barn door. Very sad ending.
Very sad indeed. I thought I could kill them all, like I have been doing up until that point. Definitely the game knows how to play with the player's feelings
at 0:08 when the singer said "and i got what i deserved" i was rollin yo
I want this song being played at least once at my funeral.
Same
Bro think he walter white
This is the moment John marston became rip van winkle
RIP Van Winkle 💀
@@fernandom.varela1109 fly high mr Milton 😔 ✊
I love how you used a sound clip from Breaking Bad’s final scene rather than just use the song itself
You got me ✋🙂✋
I couldn't find a short version of the song and I just used the audio from the Breaking Bad clip. Have a good day 😁👍
@@fernandom.varela1109 I think its kind of funny, actually
I loved the part where the military said "Its militarying time" and then starting militarying all over the place
Military things
This song futs everywhere
Bravo Dan Houser
"i had, a goddamn PLAN"
You always had a plan dutch
😭❤️❤️
Yo te conozco.jpg
Xd
For years I've wondered why the name of the game was read dead redemption. Now I realized it. John redeemed himself, died and ended up completely red cause of blood loss.
Yup, it's a curious change, because in red dead revolver, it's more like "red's revolver kills a lot of people", and then we have these deep meaning names that we won't catch at the first time
Bro think he Arthur 💀
He was trained by Landon Ricketts
Uncle named Finger
hes better
Bro thinks he's Walter White 💀
Bro really thought he was Walter White 💀 💀 💀
*Bruh*
POV: You are Jesse looking at Walt get hit by his own special redstone contraption
"redstone contraption" nahhh bro
"Todd, I think I have another job for Uncle"
"there are some inmates in sisika that need to be silenced"
My baby red
The crazy thing about the ending is that it was so unexpected especially with the army lighting up john like a Christmas tree, i thought he would surrender and get hanged in Blackwater 😢
Me:gotta watch felina
Brother:k im gonna play red dead 1
Watching felina and playing red dead be like: 0:38
Brother:what is going on?
Lol
I remember literally begging the tv for a fail screen
Same thing.
The same happened to me in rdr2 during the bank heist mission on Saint Denis
"Live by the sword, die by the sword."
"Live by the revolver, die by the red dead"
-something that John Marston never said
if that was me i would have gone to the corners of the back exit and start shooting them from there, i wouldve gotten more of them that way
John went out of the barn knowing he was gonna die. His plan was to die so his family could continue living a normal life
At least That's how I see it
@@W_Coruix That's exactly it. A lot of people still think John's fate was a matter of *"if only he could do this or if he shot them faster"* no John went out there meaning to sacrifice himself so his family is left alone.
@@themadtitan7603 Exactly, it kinda pisses me off when people still try to shoot some soldiers knowing they'll die anyway.
@@nightmaremono7363 John wouldnt go down without some fight.
As Jack said John never stoped shooting.
@@jpiny4854 That's true, I suppose what really pisses me off is when John actually shoots someone, I prefer to have him try to aim for everyone only for him to die without even killing one of them, gives it a bit more drama I suppose.
Bro thinks he’s Walter white💀
this was the moment when JohnMarston RedDeadRedempion thought he was WalterWhite BreakingBad
I loved the part where the pinkertons said "It's pinkerton' time!" and shot John over 20 times.
"Breaking Dead" 💀
Das Ende von John Marston hatte mich am Silvester 2014 oder 15 total Geschockt.😱
thats 16 guys, all he had to do was dual wield 1911s.
Bro thinks he is Walter White
Rip Van Winkle
Bro think he Walter white 💀
Redemption Bad
Breaking red
@@fernandom.varela1109 I was literally about to say this. Good one
Bro Thinks He Is Walter White💀💀💀💀
bro thinks he walter white💀
Bro thinks he's Walter White
como anillo al dedo
Concuerdo
bro thinks he's Walter White
😩
bro think he walter white 💀
I didn't like the rdr ending, I think it would be better when John got shot he said "My wounds are red just like my heart, unlike your heart Ross, yours is black. And then with tears in his eyes, Ross says "John. Being a Black Alive Damnation is better than being Red and Dead. Finish him boys" But before the army can fire a shot, Charles and Sadie from rdr2 come back and kill everyone. Then they pick up John and Ross says "How is this possible?" And john replies "I don't know but, we are the Red Dead Redemption, and you are done." Then they kill Ross and they take John to a doctor and they all live happily ever after
bro thinks he is the one who knocks
Bro thinks he is the danger
Bravo Rockstar
This song makes everything a better ending
That's a fact
Is red dead redemption 2 a prequel cause johns alive and if he'd survived that damn
Yeah, Rdr2 it's a prequel. Undead nightmare has a mode where John comes back as a zombie
very fitting
Bro thinks he is Walter White 💀💀💀
bro thinks he's walter white
bro thinbkk he walter whit💀
its awsome
Thank you ❤️
@@fernandom.varela1109 thanks for making it
Bro thinks hes walter white 💀💀
Bro thinks hes walter white
This video is 2 year ago lol
I know the future 🧐
Realy Sigma
Murió como Santino en el padrino
Curioso que ambos murieron queriendo ayudar a su familia
Like a Tony montana
At least John saw it coming
Honest question,Arthur or John?
It's difficult. I like Arthur because I played rdr2 and I know what he went through. But John has gone for a different but yet similar kind of pain; having to hunt down some old friends in order to get your family back.
But, I personally like Arthur more.
@@fernandom.varela1109 Yeah,both had pretty compelling stories but I would also say Arthur because he literally gave all he had to make sure John could escape with his family.
I prefer it without the music is makes it much sadder.
True, the silence make his death more unexpected
Marston thinks he Walter White💀
bro think he Walter White 💀
bruh thinks he's heisenberg
bro think he walter white