She has memories, in fact the memories K has are literally hers. She got sick later in life, but it was mainly a way to make sure no one could touch her having her in a bubble.
The replicant’s/Deckard fabricated her records so it would state she had Galatian’s disease to prevent her from leaving Earth and also hiding her from Wallace so they could use her for their revolution. She doesn’t know she isn’t actually sick.
It's by Denis Villeneuve, and he did not make a single bad film to this day. E.g. watch Prisoners, Sicario, Arrival and ofc Dune. You won't regret a single minute or even want to watch it a second or third time.
@@LinusAndKiba Was it really that bad received? I never understood the hype about the original and liked 2049 more. As with the new Dune, which i like moch more than the old one. On a tangent, for comparison, I like Alien 1&2 more than the new stuff (still love the visuals of Prometheus & Covenant) or very much like 2001 Space Odyssee. So for me it's not old vs new in general.
@@jonathanwalther As for the original, it was an extremely cool looking movie but I found it incredibly slow and dull in between the few iconic scenes 😅
So… if there are 7 candles on the cake, and we know she was locked in a sterile chamber at 8, it may imply she was creating the memory of her last birthday party to give it to a replicant.
@@maroonblood151the beauty of her acting is in its subtlety: you can see her innocence and purity and the deep deep sadness in her due to having been locked up her whole life, but you can also see her childlike hope, her fragility, mixed with a very subtle rebel streak and sense of right and wrong, she won’t sell her company even though she likely knows that’s extremely dangerous but she also knows her product is so good it will protect her while also maybe low key hoping they take her out because it’s not really living. It’s all in the subtlety and subtext. She has a frail and shakey subdued voice because she likely rarely speaks. She also has the quiet brilliance of what is likely a gifted child due to the implication that’s she mastered this craft quite young. You’re right it’s all a mater of perspective but in my view this is some brilliant acting, writing, and character building. The sad part is such roles rarely get awards because they are background flavouring but her character is essentially the emotional and narrative linchpin of this whole movie. Remove her and the story falls flat
He thought he was human because the memory was real. The memory was implanted and it was from someone else. But for him it felt like his. She did not lie. The event happened. Later he finds he is not human but he lived like one. And that was all that mattered.
@@chocolatefigure01 He knew he was a replicant only until he found out the memory was real. Then he thought he was Deckard's son and human. Then he found out he was only a replicant again. Really crazy stuff.
Ironically the story tells that Replicants are in fact humans, just altered (and bred) to be slaves. That was the whole motivation behind the stories antagonist; if replicants discovered they were just altered human slaves, they'd probably rebel in violent fashion! and some of the public would probably also not be happy about the deal (SOME). I think one day soon slavery will make a VERY strong comeback. Thought probably not specifically racially focused like past examples.
He thought he was the first born replicant, not human. My favourite movie. I wish there was more. It's a long movie, but I always wished it left things to be sequalised. However another movie within this universe would still be great.
It was a interesting (and the correct) stylistic choice to have the memory scanner not have a bunch of flashing lights and moving parts that surround the head, but to just sound like a modern medical MRI machine. It keeps the focus on the faces and emotions.
Hm. True. I never really thought about that. Other sci-fi movies would probably have some holographic scanner or something that buzz and whizz away. But this decision allows for the emotions to be highlighted.
So much is going on in this scene, especially the end... him feeling like he has to refute everything he thought was true about his own nature... her recalling this memory, and witnessing how much suffering K is in for being the carrier, like an injustice, like he’s been sacrificed. All of it beautifully set up by the very intimate setting and conversation just before. It’s very, very moving.
It's an extremely ADHD thing to do. And the number of people I know who have rare or rare-ish disabilities - ones you cannot see - who are *also* ADHD or autistic? Like the stars. I couldn't begin to count... AND K GETS IT. There's definite empathy there, on both sides of the glass. An empathy sadly far too lacking among humans these days.
i feel as though she wants to appear interesting. given how lonely she is i imagine you would take any opportunity to entice someone to want to stay longer or return, or simply to connect.
I would have done the same. I do best with a certain level of complication or my mind wonders. If a meeting is boring I will doodle to keep me focused. For instructional videos I speed them up, and then I am fully attentive.
That technology tho! Being able to create anything with the push of a button and it plays like a movie but three dimensionally! The dream right there! My dream job!
There is the moving "wetlands" (Feuchtgebiete) where she is hospitalized for a hemorroid she opened while shaving her butt and where she orders a pizza by people who jerked off on it :)
@@papaemeritus5842To anyone reading this: Please god, don't. That role is such a stark difference from this one in 2049. If Francine and Denis watched _that_ movie as their only reference for Carla's acting, they really took a swing when casting her as Ana. 😂
When watching it for the first time I thought it might be Even Rachel Wood or probably Elizabeth Lail, but oh boy I was so wrong lol! It's actually Carla Juri, and I hadn't heard of her before this film. The resemblance of each of these 3 actresses I mentioned here are absolutely UNCANNY!
That scene right there shows why Ryan Gosling is a top Hollywood actor. Is not just about the beauty or sex appeal (there are thousand good looking actors in the world), but is a very very fine actor. Congratulations and thanks for this scene.
Ryan Gosling has a smirk on his face within every scene. Cant take him seriously. Guy looks like he's about to jump head first into a pile of shit. hence the shit eating grin
Oh my god, the music blends in so beautifully from 5:20 till the end. It's so subtle yet so fulfilling. You almost instantly associate this score to similar events that have happened in your life, and that is just too powerful. For anyone wondering what the music was, its titled "Someone Lived This" by Hans Zimmer and Benjamin Wallfisch.
I just realized something. Not sure if anyone else has pointed it out. But if you look in the reflection when the camera pans to the memory maker in the scene where she views her memories, Officer K stands behind the memory maker which could reference the fact that the memories being recalled are hers, hence why in the reflection he is directly standing behind the Memory Maker since he's viewing her memories. When the camera is back on Officer K, there is no reflection at all showing that Officer K has no real memories, they were all hers.
I think she doesn't just use her own memories. She crafts them as needed, but uses one real from her as "signature". As replicants intellectually know them as manufactured memories they never think about verifying them.
The interesting thing about this scene is that K's memory involving the toy horse he hid was actually hers - she was placed in the orphanage he "remembers" disguised as a boy... And another bigger irony is that Niander Wallace is looking for the "miracle", the child born of a replicant and a human - or of two replicants, as he believes Deckard and Rachel might both have been created as part of an experiment - and he does not realize she's there, under his eyes, working as one of his subcontractors. And she must have steely qualities if she resisted being bought out by such a powerful industrial magnate.
What if Replicant-born is somebody else? Still it will be good for Deckard to believe his daughter is compassionate, gentle and successful because of those traits. Maybe she isn't Rachael's child, but she should be.
People who refuse to look at the darkness cannot see how bright the light can be which is why these movies have major themes of the Blade Runners being able to be more human than human they actually engage with the more morbid aspects of life and in so doing can appreciate the joys and beauty even more. This is shown when he is able to have a real deep connection experience with Joy herself. Also Wallace depends so heavily on these types of people to run his organization just goes to show that no matter how enigmatic, and powerful and Steve Jobs like he might be he still depends deeply on the work and creativity of free thinkers. There is always someone within these corporations Walter Mitty people who are allowing these flashy giant machines to run. Without them the entire edifice simply crumbles.
It's very cruel. Officer K sets out to find his family and discovers that he is not their child. But it's just someone who was tricked into inserting someone else's memories.
All of Ks anger culminated right there. Not only cause of the late revelation and not directly cause of his whole existance, life and purpose has been turned upside down..But I think mostly because he already accepted what he used to be. He accepted to be mistreated and used, to be an obedient tool for not being born, not having a soul. His place in society was predetermined.. Unjustly. But what makes his character amazing is that he never thought of revenge..In the end it didnt matter if he was human or not. He feels what he feels. His memories shape his existance, his purpose and actions. It doesnt matter what believes we have, if our thought are good or evil. It all depends on what we decide to do..Our actions. And K took action and died for the right cause and did the most human thing.
I see this scene as a euphemism referring to the movie itself. The movie, although obviously fictional, is presented in such a way that it felt genuine. The people creating this movie were secretly referring to their own work.
not to mention the layers of self-references when you consider this, it's an original work/story that's a sequel to another work/story that was adapted from another medium, the original novel that was the source material to it all
Note that she finds pride in her work, despite she's not human at all. A very human response, and yet hinted at not being exclusively human at all. But an organically sprung emotion, one derived from context and not form. One that anything is capable of feeling, if the capacity for it is there.
It's most fascinating. She has real memories. She loved an entire life. The first replicant to ever do that. And the idea of the test they do is to find if the empathy response is real. The best way to have that is to live an entire life of experiences. The way to be real is to live. But she barely saw the world. She was immunocompromised. Not so long after living in the real world she had to go live in a little cage. But through technology she is the very person who creates memories. The person, born yet not born a homo sapien, living yet outside the world, she is the one who creates other people's lives.
@@freshtoast3879 "If you have authentic memories you have... real human responses" Ana has authentic memories of real life. She can remember them and thus relive her perspective, so that's empathy for herself. But she also had an entire lifetime of practicing the empathy response in real situations towards others. This makes her fully human. She's so good that she is the very person who is the expert on making human lives in the form of creating the memories that give replicants the capacity to function socially and intuitionally.
Always thought it succinct but perfect detail by the director that his reflection and her image (or vice versa) are always present at a single time in the close up shots. In some segments it appears his image follows slightly after hers - as a nod to the eventual reveal ;)
@@jonathanwalther basically, in the movie, the character K is not actually real and instead he is played by the famous actor Ryon Gosling. Blink and you'll miss it.
The only criticism of this scene is that the sound of the chair being kicked should have been quicker and more violent - this is a _strong_ Replicant having a uncontrolled outburst …that chair should impact the wall immediately and break into pieces.
The amazing thing about this scene is that it works entirely by itself. You don't need any context, you don't any context, backstory or explanation, you don't need to have seen the rest of Blade Runner 2049 or know anything about the original Blade Runner. The story the scene tells is complete - everything you need to know about the characters, who they and the world they live in is complete.
Nothing for me compares to K/Gosling shout. In a role void of emotions he is overwhelmed by a multitude of emotions (sadness, anger, grief, disappointment, hopeless, fear) which seems to go against Ks designed purpose. Its so powerful and makes me want to give K a hug so much. This movie is better than Dune im sorry. My biggest argument for this is the fact that this story is original while Dune is following an already famed story.
Because of the snow in the end, you can see that the whole story between the scenes where she appears is just something she tells herself. Just a fiction she created.
@@terrathaw The moment K dies, snow is starting to fall, the moment immediately after that you see that girl working on some memory with snow, which could indicate that whatever happened between her meeting with him and this moment is just her playing to imagine what happened outside. Remember she said she likes to play to create stories since she can never go out. I don't know if this is what is supposed to be understood but I think the snow thing is a crazy coincidence between K dying under the snow and her working on some memories with snow. Plus see the shift between the beginning where K is supposed to be the missing child and whatever happens after her meeting with K, where we discovered that she was the child, the important person of that story.
@@geraltofrivia9424 There are many assumptions in your comment. You don't actually know if any of that is true Plus it's never shown if he dies when he laid in the snow, it's left ambiguous
@@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess Of course, it's a theory. But isn't it intriguing that at the precise moment you see the guy (probably) dying under the snow, we switch to a scene where the woman is working on some memories related to snow? I'm not saying I'm right, I'm saying this idea makes sense and can explain that odd coincidence.
Philip K. Dick had a twin sister who died shortly after their birth. Seems she became an "invisible friend" in his childhood. Ultimately, the question why he should be "real" while she was "artificial" (made up) would become his novel "Do Androids dream of Electric Sheep" which was loosely adapted for the original Blade Runner movie. She must have seemed pretty real to him to get him to even ask this question. Btw. the K. in his name means "Kindred", which was his mother's maiden name.
Perhaps. Maybe that, and also because she knows this replicant with her memory is in distress, and thinks it's his- and she has empathy with him. A bit of both maybe?
So to my understanding, she has to be half human, half replicant, mother-rachel, father-deckard, a unique set of genes, dna, and cell structure, with a life span of what?
If she was born in 2020 that would make her 29. Maybe she was Deckard's child, maybe not, but she is someone anyone would be proud to have in their family.
@@ggeerrppeess Did you not watch the movie? She is the child of Rachel and Deckard, a child of replicant origin. Everyone is looking for her; the police because they want to eliminate any trace of this miracle lest the other replicants find out and start rebelling; the other replicants because she is quite literally the Messiah in their eyes, and Wallace because he wants to harvest her biological makeup to make more replicants that are self-reproducing, as a magnifier of his slave production. By keeping her identity a secret, she is safe from all these groups who all want a piece of her.
Also a little confused on why she used her own memories as a product? Even though it is illegal. Just had a bad day and thought using one wouldn’t hurt.
"this is the most interesting thing that I have been offered to help with in ages..." ;; "DO you mind if I work while you talk?"..... She is not only good at making artificial memories, but also good at being sarcastic :)
Not sarcasm, I'm afraid. Just not the usual emotional/rational way of navigating life and interacting in interpersonal contexts. I wouldn't expect any different from someone in her position, living in that environment alone for so long.
The thing that is confusing is that I remember how Blade Runner ended originally if I remember correctly at all and considering I’ve had a blow to the head it’s a question the way I remember it is you see him driving off with the female android that people have a hard time telling if she’s human or android, but he knows she’s an androidso how is it? This happens at all this new movie I don’t understand.
It is crazy that they can read memories now, in detail. Not literally 'read' them, but cross-reference brain patterns with a library of sounds and images so vast that they are functionally reading memories, and hearing your inner dialogue, seeing your mind's eye...anything. The sci-fi future is here, and a lot earlier than 2049, as regards neuroscience. Now what we choose to do with it...is up to us. It's easy to fearmonger about this technology and talk about Big Brother and mind control etc., but similar or the same technologies that could treat millions of people with mental disorders, chronic pain or addiction whose lives are being destroyed like mine was, for 30 years, with OCD, could and are being really helped by this tech right now. So think of the huge social cost of their suffering, not to mention the individual cost, and weigh that against the dangers. Every technology is like this. But in this case, the stakes are even higher. Huge risks, HUGE potential.
The person who makes the best memories is also the same person who barely has any.
The sad irony in that.
Underrated comment
She has memories, in fact the memories K has are literally hers. She got sick later in life, but it was mainly a way to make sure no one could touch her having her in a bubble.
@@Jalbesbe she may not be sick. that may be just a cover . her parents didn't go off world.
So she wouldn't be actually be good at making memories. Besides those of a child perhaps
The replicant’s/Deckard fabricated her records so it would state she had Galatian’s disease to prevent her from leaving Earth and also hiding her from Wallace so they could use her for their revolution. She doesn’t know she isn’t actually sick.
A very worthy successor to the original imo.. they could’ve completely f***ed this up but it’s a superb film.
It's by Denis Villeneuve, and he did not make a single bad film to this day. E.g. watch Prisoners, Sicario, Arrival and ofc Dune. You won't regret a single minute or even want to watch it a second or third time.
Unbelievable how poorly it was received, I personally LOVE this movie!
@@LinusAndKiba Was it really that bad received? I never understood the hype about the original and liked 2049 more. As with the new Dune, which i like moch more than the old one.
On a tangent, for comparison, I like Alien 1&2 more than the new stuff (still love the visuals of Prometheus & Covenant) or very much like 2001 Space Odyssee. So for me it's not old vs new in general.
@@jonathanwalther yeah it pretty much was, by the press at least. I think it got redemption over at IMDb though!
@@jonathanwalther As for the original, it was an extremely cool looking movie but I found it incredibly slow and dull in between the few iconic scenes 😅
So… if there are 7 candles on the cake, and we know she was locked in a sterile chamber at 8, it may imply she was creating the memory of her last birthday party to give it to a replicant.
What a beautiful present, to give your best moments on to a enslaved people
@@Canonfudder to en-slave suggests they were not slaves but that status changed. They were bred chattel.
good catch
100%@@darthkek1953
then she broke the law...
This actress was perfect.
She brings a lot of warmth to the movie for the small screen time she has
Both are great actors and this was the most underrated movie of that year
I recognised her immediately from a German movie where she puts disgusting things in her vagina, look it up dude
Interesting how perspectives work. I thought she was mid. Not terrible just mid. But that’s the beauty of opinion.
@@maroonblood151the beauty of her acting is in its subtlety: you can see her innocence and purity and the deep deep sadness in her due to having been locked up her whole life, but you can also see her childlike hope, her fragility, mixed with a very subtle rebel streak and sense of right and wrong, she won’t sell her company even though she likely knows that’s extremely dangerous but she also knows her product is so good it will protect her while also maybe low key hoping they take her out because it’s not really living. It’s all in the subtlety and subtext. She has a frail and shakey subdued voice because she likely rarely speaks. She also has the quiet brilliance of what is likely a gifted child due to the implication that’s she mastered this craft quite young.
You’re right it’s all a mater of perspective but in my view this is some brilliant acting, writing, and character building. The sad part is such roles rarely get awards because they are background flavouring but her character is essentially the emotional and narrative linchpin of this whole movie. Remove her and the story falls flat
He thought he was human because the memory was real. The memory was implanted and it was from someone else. But for him it felt like his. She did not lie. The event happened. Later he finds he is not human but he lived like one. And that was all that mattered.
Very allegorical
He knew he was a replicant, he thought he was a special one for being the Child of deckard.
@@chocolatefigure01 He knew he was a replicant only until he found out the memory was real. Then he thought he was Deckard's son and human. Then he found out he was only a replicant again. Really crazy stuff.
Ironically the story tells that Replicants are in fact humans, just altered (and bred) to be slaves.
That was the whole motivation behind the stories antagonist; if replicants discovered they were just altered human slaves, they'd probably rebel in violent fashion! and some of the public would probably also not be happy about the deal (SOME).
I think one day soon slavery will make a VERY strong comeback. Thought probably not specifically racially focused like past examples.
He thought he was the first born replicant, not human. My favourite movie. I wish there was more. It's a long movie, but I always wished it left things to be sequalised. However another movie within this universe would still be great.
She saw him and was like, "That's literally me."
Underrated comment
@@Arany-Csillag I doubt many people saw the movie. Many people just saw the memes.
Brilliant.
I UNDERSTAND THE REFERENCE
"Someone" has lived this.
Reminded me of the Cthaeh.
She knew that she lived it... But something was very strange for that memory to be implanted into him so she didn't dare reveal the source
@@sciencefarmer also illegal to use real memories
Her voice is amazingly peaceful
Reminds me of Luna Lovegood from Harry Potter
Horny* She is willing to die to f once
and also borderline incoherent. they should have hired someone who can actually speak english.
thank you for that, just realized that.
It was a interesting (and the correct) stylistic choice to have the memory scanner not have a bunch of flashing lights and moving parts that surround the head, but to just sound like a modern medical MRI machine.
It keeps the focus on the faces and emotions.
Hm. True. I never really thought about that. Other sci-fi movies would probably have some holographic scanner or something that buzz and whizz away. But this decision allows for the emotions to be highlighted.
It's actually not the machine you're hearing, I believe it's the memory of the child running through the ruined factory.
@@jonathanjones2722 The best cgi is that, that is not central, but is used carefully, scarcely, with a sort of minimalism
Memory maker is a really beautiful human being.
This scene is so very precious.
man that anger voice before he scream
is really natural
He's had good memory implants - his reactions are almost human.
1:47 that subtle wipe of a small tear 🥲. Amazing film, actors, director and cinematography etc
So much is going on in this scene, especially the end... him feeling like he has to refute everything he thought was true about his own nature... her recalling this memory, and witnessing how much suffering K is in for being the carrier, like an injustice, like he’s been sacrificed. All of it beautifully set up by the very intimate setting and conversation just before. It’s very, very moving.
**Solaris** 1972(dir;Andre Tarkovsky)
plus it plays back completely different on a second viewing, with different complexity
“That’s the most interesting thing i’ve been offered to help with… in ages”
Immediately proceeds to return back to her own work.
Some people can focus better when they have something routine to do
It's an extremely ADHD thing to do. And the number of people I know who have rare or rare-ish disabilities - ones you cannot see - who are *also* ADHD or autistic? Like the stars. I couldn't begin to count...
AND K GETS IT. There's definite empathy there, on both sides of the glass. An empathy sadly far too lacking among humans these days.
Lol true
i feel as though she wants to appear interesting. given how lonely she is i imagine you would take any opportunity to entice someone to want to stay longer or return, or simply to connect.
I would have done the same. I do best with a certain level of complication or my mind wonders. If a meeting is boring I will doodle to keep me focused. For instructional videos I speed them up, and then I am fully attentive.
That technology tho! Being able to create anything with the push of a button and it plays like a movie but three dimensionally! The dream right there! My dream job!
You could start learning to draw or some 3d software to start
@@akiraperu1
Yeah but it ain't gonna all be perfect with a single button push. That's the joy of fantasy that this movie shows
openai sora
Buddy choses the cowards option
download blender.
Honestly I think she looks beautiful. No idea if I've ever seen her in other films.
I couldn’t agree more. She has a manner that reminds me of the girl I loved in High School.
There is the moving "wetlands" (Feuchtgebiete) where she is hospitalized for a hemorroid she opened while shaving her butt and where she orders a pizza by people who jerked off on it :)
Try the German Movie: „Feuchtgebiete“ if you want to see MORE of her!😅
@@papaemeritus5842To anyone reading this: Please god, don't. That role is such a stark difference from this one in 2049. If Francine and Denis watched _that_ movie as their only reference for Carla's acting, they really took a swing when casting her as Ana. 😂
When watching it for the first time I thought it might be Even Rachel Wood or probably Elizabeth Lail, but oh boy I was so wrong lol!
It's actually Carla Juri, and I hadn't heard of her before this film.
The resemblance of each of these 3 actresses I mentioned here are absolutely UNCANNY!
That scene right there shows why Ryan Gosling is a top Hollywood actor. Is not just about the beauty or sex appeal (there are thousand good looking actors in the world), but is a very very fine actor. Congratulations and thanks for this scene.
You’re correct about something. He is fine….
Ryan Gosling has a smirk on his face within every scene.
Cant take him seriously.
Guy looks like he's about to jump head first into a pile of shit.
hence the shit eating grin
@@Prof.Pwnalotthat’s the whole point. He’s a replicant cyborg. Did you even watch the movie?
This girl is so serene and beautiful.
Oh my god, the music blends in so beautifully from 5:20 till the end. It's so subtle yet so fulfilling. You almost instantly associate this score to similar events that have happened in your life, and that is just too powerful. For anyone wondering what the music was, its titled "Someone Lived This" by Hans Zimmer and Benjamin Wallfisch.
I just realized something. Not sure if anyone else has pointed it out. But if you look in the reflection when the camera pans to the memory maker in the scene where she views her memories, Officer K stands behind the memory maker which could reference the fact that the memories being recalled are hers, hence why in the reflection he is directly standing behind the Memory Maker since he's viewing her memories. When the camera is back on Officer K, there is no reflection at all showing that Officer K has no real memories, they were all hers.
I think she doesn't just use her own memories. She crafts them as needed, but uses one real from her as "signature". As replicants intellectually know them as manufactured memories they never think about verifying them.
The interesting thing about this scene is that K's memory involving the toy horse he hid was actually hers - she was placed in the orphanage he "remembers" disguised as a boy...
And another bigger irony is that Niander Wallace is looking for the "miracle", the child born of a replicant and a human - or of two replicants, as he believes Deckard and Rachel might both have been created as part of an experiment - and he does not realize she's there, under his eyes, working as one of his subcontractors. And she must have steely qualities if she resisted being bought out by such a powerful industrial magnate.
What if Replicant-born is somebody else? Still it will be good for Deckard to believe his daughter is compassionate, gentle and successful because of those traits. Maybe she isn't Rachael's child, but she should be.
People who refuse to look at the darkness cannot see how bright the light can be which is why these movies have major themes of the Blade Runners being able to be more human than human they actually engage with the more morbid aspects of life and in so doing can appreciate the joys and beauty even more. This is shown when he is able to have a real deep connection experience with Joy herself.
Also Wallace depends so heavily on these types of people to run his organization just goes to show that no matter how enigmatic, and powerful and Steve Jobs like he might be he still depends deeply on the work and creativity of free thinkers. There is always someone within these corporations Walter Mitty people who are allowing these flashy giant machines to run. Without them the entire edifice simply crumbles.
In this case you are true but they forget most important thing - this is spiritual, 7 bodies in one visible!!! 💯 💖 👨🚀 😇 🙏 🍀 🎉 🎉 🎉 🥂🥂🙋♂️🙋♂️🇷🇸🍀🙏😇🕊️🌍
And the blood sacrifices and other things that we don't know... wow
Most Humans fear darkness naturally because it's the unknown, to me it's nothing but a chance of adventure, to find and feel something else.
@GodNotReal lmao you trippin bruh 🤣💀
But Andre Tarkovsky **Solaris** did this in 1972 (based on the Stanislaw lem book)
The boy who went to search for his parents thanks to these memories, only to find out the dad you wanted to see wasn't your dad.
It's very cruel. Officer K sets out to find his family and discovers that he is not their child. But it's just someone who was tricked into inserting someone else's memories.
Goodness, this scene, this movie, the depth in the plot... what a fantastic piece of cinema.
All of Ks anger culminated right there. Not only cause of the late revelation and not directly cause of his whole existance, life and purpose has been turned upside down..But I think mostly because he already accepted what he used to be. He accepted to be mistreated and used, to be an obedient tool for not being born, not having a soul. His place in society was predetermined.. Unjustly.
But what makes his character amazing is that he never thought of revenge..In the end it didnt matter if he was human or not. He feels what he feels. His memories shape his existance, his purpose and actions. It doesnt matter what believes we have, if our thought are good or evil. It all depends on what we decide to do..Our actions. And K took action and died for the right cause and did the most human thing.
I see this scene as a euphemism referring to the movie itself. The movie, although obviously fictional, is presented in such a way that it felt genuine. The people creating this movie were secretly referring to their own work.
not to mention the layers of self-references when you consider this, it's an original work/story that's a sequel to another work/story that was adapted from another medium, the original novel that was the source material to it all
this movie, shrek 2, and dark knight are some examples of perfect sequel
The Godfather 2 and The Empire Strikes Back as well.
don't forget puss in boots the last wish!
Watching Aliens in the theater was Epic!
Shrek 2 was really compelling. Hard night after watching in the theater
Note that she finds pride in her work, despite she's not human at all. A very human response, and yet hinted at not being exclusively human at all. But an organically sprung emotion, one derived from context and not form. One that anything is capable of feeling, if the capacity for it is there.
Dude you make 0 fucking sende
It's most fascinating. She has real memories. She loved an entire life. The first replicant to ever do that.
And the idea of the test they do is to find if the empathy response is real. The best way to have that is to live an entire life of experiences. The way to be real is to live.
But she barely saw the world. She was immunocompromised. Not so long after living in the real world she had to go live in a little cage. But through technology she is the very person who creates memories. The person, born yet not born a homo sapien, living yet outside the world, she is the one who creates other people's lives.
@@pseudonymousbeing987 so what is she explain
@@freshtoast3879
Human.
@@freshtoast3879
"If you have authentic memories you have... real human responses"
Ana has authentic memories of real life. She can remember them and thus relive her perspective, so that's empathy for herself. But she also had an entire lifetime of practicing the empathy response in real situations towards others. This makes her fully human. She's so good that she is the very person who is the expert on making human lives in the form of creating the memories that give replicants the capacity to function socially and intuitionally.
This scene is even better when you watch the film for the 2nd time.
This film just gets better on every rewatch!
5th
Always thought it succinct but perfect detail by the director that his reflection and her image (or vice versa) are always present at a single time in the close up shots. In some segments it appears his image follows slightly after hers - as a nod to the eventual reveal ;)
Look closer. There's more.
Her reflection is consistently inside his image, while his reflection is next to her or looking over her shoulder.
That's lovely :) @@EGRJ
All the best memories are hers...
Shit, i remember this scene :'( ...
These are the kind of scens that make a movie great. Not the fast paced action scenes. The story in this movie was deep and very well portrayed.
that's basically the whole movie lol
If you look really closely at 02:05 you can see that Ryan Gosling is actually an actor.
Can you explain?
@@jonathanwalther basically, in the movie, the character K is not actually real and instead he is played by the famous actor Ryon Gosling. Blink and you'll miss it.
@@fredmeister Nice one. Who would have thought. Haha!
This is REALLY well acted!!!!
He knows he is a replicant. Now he thinks he wasnt made like he was now.
He thinks he was the miracle childbirth of two replicant.
Not by two replicants. Human and replicant. Born from replicant.
Harrison Ford was definitely her father, it wasn't determined he wasn't human. Although he seem have a handler within Police Dept.
The only criticism of this scene is that the sound of the chair being kicked should have been quicker and more violent - this is a _strong_ Replicant having a uncontrolled outburst …that chair should impact the wall immediately and break into pieces.
The only thing between Ryan and his Oscar is his nominated role that has not been written yet
Watch "Lars and the Real Girl"..he is capable of an award-winning role
What a beautiful scene
The amazing thing about this scene is that it works entirely by itself. You don't need any context, you don't any context, backstory or explanation, you don't need to have seen the rest of Blade Runner 2049 or know anything about the original Blade Runner. The story the scene tells is complete - everything you need to know about the characters, who they and the world they live in is complete.
Agreed, it almost works as a self contained short film.
this film is on my top 5
less punching and killing
more ideas and backgrounds
Such performances should qualify for an Oscar nomination, even if they are short.
Best film ever
Powerful scene! Thank you :)
Tragedy unfolded
Nothing for me compares to K/Gosling shout. In a role void of emotions he is overwhelmed by a multitude of emotions (sadness, anger, grief, disappointment, hopeless, fear) which seems to go against Ks designed purpose. Its so powerful and makes me want to give K a hug so much. This movie is better than Dune im sorry. My biggest argument for this is the fact that this story is original while Dune is following an already famed story.
It is better than Dune. K is more sympathetic than Paul, and his character arc is more satisfying.
@@Naberius359Leto 2 and Ducan Idaho is a tragic character.
6:32 GAWD! DAMMIT
Best scene ever!
Because of the snow in the end, you can see that the whole story between the scenes where she appears is just something she tells herself. Just a fiction she created.
Elaborate?
@@terrathaw The moment K dies, snow is starting to fall, the moment immediately after that you see that girl working on some memory with snow, which could indicate that whatever happened between her meeting with him and this moment is just her playing to imagine what happened outside. Remember she said she likes to play to create stories since she can never go out. I don't know if this is what is supposed to be understood but I think the snow thing is a crazy coincidence between K dying under the snow and her working on some memories with snow. Plus see the shift between the beginning where K is supposed to be the missing child and whatever happens after her meeting with K, where we discovered that she was the child, the important person of that story.
@@geraltofrivia9424 There are many assumptions in your comment. You don't actually know if any of that is true
Plus it's never shown if he dies when he laid in the snow, it's left ambiguous
@@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess Of course, it's a theory. But isn't it intriguing that at the precise moment you see the guy (probably) dying under the snow, we switch to a scene where the woman is working on some memories related to snow? I'm not saying I'm right, I'm saying this idea makes sense and can explain that odd coincidence.
@@geraltofrivia9424 welp then this whole movie can just be her making her own imaginary story...
Best scene of the movie
Philip K. Dick had a twin sister who died shortly after their birth. Seems she became an "invisible friend" in his childhood. Ultimately, the question why he should be "real" while she was "artificial" (made up) would become his novel "Do Androids dream of Electric Sheep" which was loosely adapted for the original Blade Runner movie. She must have seemed pretty real to him to get him to even ask this question.
Btw. the K. in his name means "Kindred", which was his mother's maiden name.
*She is THEE true queen of asmr❤️😱💥*
ᴴⁱ ᶜˡᵒˢᵉ ʸᵒᵘʳ ᵉʸᵉˢ ˡⁱˢᵗᵉⁿ ᵗʰᵉ ⁱⁿᵈᵘˢᵗʳⁱᵃˡ ʳᵉᵛᵒˡᵘᵗⁱᵒⁿ ᵃⁿᵈ ⁱᵗ'ˢ ᶜᵒⁿˢᵉqᵘᵉⁿᶜᵉˢ
If you watched this movie, watch Westworld next.
6:32 when the topic I didn't study for the exam comes out.
this scene is so unfathomably sad
She cryed why is her real memory...
6:22 " He's a god damned slaughterhouse,that's what he is"
Cpt Bryant,Blade Runner 1982
The one time in the movie he lost his cool.
Unreal engine 6
She is so sweet! 😍
Is she crying because it is her memory ?
Perhaps. Maybe that, and also because she knows this replicant with her memory is in distress, and thinks it's his- and she has empathy with him. A bit of both maybe?
yes
6:33 literally me
So to my understanding, she has to be half human, half replicant, mother-rachel, father-deckard, a unique set of genes, dna, and cell structure, with a life span of what?
If she was born in 2020 that would make her 29. Maybe she was Deckard's child, maybe not, but she is someone anyone would be proud to have in their family.
If Mary's Room was a person:
Absolute gold.
Rewelacja!
Ayo polskaaaa
His memory was of the Avatar logo.
Those last few seconds are exactly how I react whenever Chik Fil A forgets to put pickles on my sandwich.
She wrote “shen-gue Kai-le (Happy Birthday)in Mandarin- I think. Does anyone know for sure?
Who does her hair inside her cage? It's very nice. The hair, I mean.
Her loneliness, is so palpable.
Interesting parallel - the "key designer" in both movies has a condition that keeps them on Earth - JF Sebastian had premature aging.
K was for Ken right?
A copy of a copy, and yet more authentic than everything else.
6:04 is what I call exceptional performance. 🎭
They screwed up so many sequels that I half expected this movie to be bad. Boy was I wrong and I'm so happy to admit it.
I saw the lying on the stairs meme before I saw the movie 😂
reminiscent of _dark city_ about swapping around memories to distill the soul
what was the memory of, I wonder
ruclips.net/video/B8RjHcTS55g/видео.htmlsi=agHps2oonV8rAo_1
1:45
she wants company... i don't think that wiping tears gesture is intentional
Damn!!!!
Why didn't she go like 'oh wow those are my memories, thanks for bringing them back!'?
Because she wants to keep it a secret.
@@EGRJ why?
You didn't follow the movie? @@ggeerrppeess
@@ggeerrppeess Did you not watch the movie? She is the child of Rachel and Deckard, a child of replicant origin. Everyone is looking for her; the police because they want to eliminate any trace of this miracle lest the other replicants find out and start rebelling; the other replicants because she is quite literally the Messiah in their eyes, and Wallace because he wants to harvest her biological makeup to make more replicants that are self-reproducing, as a magnifier of his slave production.
By keeping her identity a secret, she is safe from all these groups who all want a piece of her.
Also a little confused on why she used her own memories as a product? Even though it is illegal. Just had a bad day and thought using one wouldn’t hurt.
"It's nice."
he just like me fr
the way he explodes at the end.. i have been that angry and frustrated before.. and it was a great expression.. really sold the scene.
0:31 scared the living crap outta me in the movies! 😂
BR2 could never have surpassed the original, so it did not try. This is a beautiful movie.
Ana De Armas has a face u could kiss for a million yrs
"this is the most interesting thing that I have been offered to help with in ages..." ;; "DO you mind if I work while you talk?"..... She is not only good at making artificial memories, but also good at being sarcastic :)
Not sarcasm, I'm afraid. Just not the usual emotional/rational way of navigating life and interacting in interpersonal contexts. I wouldn't expect any different from someone in her position, living in that environment alone for so long.
I think the working is her comfort zone and beeing occupied helps her concentrate as looking him in the eyes would discomfort her.
I felt bad for him and her cuz she knows it’s not real memories
They are real. Their origin is synthetic, but for K and other replicants they are their own memories.
I can honestly say I couldn’t understand a thing the memory lady said, this is why Prometheus just dived
Memory reboot
she is the alpha omega male miracle... with compromised immune system
This girl would've been a very successful ASMR artist.
She cheated, no real memories could be used.
The thing that is confusing is that I remember how Blade Runner ended originally if I remember correctly at all and considering I’ve had a blow to the head it’s a question the way I remember it is you see him driving off with the female android that people have a hard time telling if she’s human or android, but he knows she’s an androidso how is it? This happens at all this new movie I don’t understand.
No, people have a hard time trying to figure whether Deckard in the first one was a replicant or human.
@@velocitymgHe was human. He had become as "soulless" as replicants were.
Why she didn't tell him that those were HER memories right there? Would've saved a lot of movie
Because she had to stay in hiding from Wallace. Did you watch the movie? No one knows she’s Deckard’s kid.
@@qthestruggler2715That is not confirmed either, but it is plausible.
Didn't watch this movie,,,,, i think should be to
не пожалеешь, Алексей Антонович
You definitely should. Watching the first one before would be better ofc but still great even by itself
La cena conversando con su hermano gemelo hijo de deckard y Rachel
6:01 When I'm beating bro in a 1v1 and he pulls out an Al generated voice message of her voice giving me the apology I never got
It is crazy that they can read memories now, in detail. Not literally 'read' them, but cross-reference brain patterns with a library of sounds and images so vast that they are functionally reading memories, and hearing your inner dialogue, seeing your mind's eye...anything.
The sci-fi future is here, and a lot earlier than 2049, as regards neuroscience. Now what we choose to do with it...is up to us.
It's easy to fearmonger about this technology and talk about Big Brother and mind control etc., but similar or the same technologies that could treat millions of people with mental disorders, chronic pain or addiction whose lives are being destroyed like mine was, for 30 years, with OCD, could and are being really helped by this tech right now. So think of the huge social cost of their suffering, not to mention the individual cost, and weigh that against the dangers. Every technology is like this. But in this case, the stakes are even higher. Huge risks, HUGE potential.