People can complain all they want but I'd MUCH rather have people farming sturgeon than fishing them to actual extinction. Everytime
5 лет назад+721
And they farm them to actually prevent extinction. These sturgeon are prehistoric and I'd rather not see the species go extinct. Farming actually saved the species. At last, someone who gets it.
Meanwhile most the people complaining eat processed meats from grocery stores while having a poodle from a puppy mill. This is farming and there's no difference from their cheeseburger except price and pallets.
We eat what we farmed is ok for me, but hunting natural/ wild animals, fish etc to the point of extinction is quit disturbing. Mother nature will take revenge one day for our cruelty and greediness.
Same! I'm sure they also sell the bones-- fish gelatin can be used for sooo many things. I mean, I understand that a lot of people don't like the idea of animals being killed, but it happens and at least these farmers aren't like poachers where they let the meat and organs rot.
Does it seem that way? If that's how it comes off, I deeply apologize-- that's not the intention on my end at least. I'm just saying that it's reality in my opinion. I see vegans and similar as people who have huge hearts and don't like the idea of one animal murder another. I see the world differently and that's okay. If I upset anyone (vegan or not), I apologize.
@@tlaoltjenbruns9580 Aurora I give mad respect to you man, the fact that you were so respectful made me quite surprised in a good way, keep it up dude.
In a way it sounds like the adoption process in America. Kids are practically left in terrible conditions and the U.S. only care about fetuses that aren't born yet lol
I actually think the facility was clean, well kept and the sturgeon are swimming in their schools just like in the wild. This seems as humane as possible.
@@notsure1277 we'll, keep in mind that not only is it more ethical but it would be more efficient in terms of production. Surgical removal allows for multiple egg extractions. And as these fish grow they produce more eggs. Sturgeon can live for more than a century and at full size they produce A LOT of eggs.
Well I dont think I would call those small tanks that are that small only because of "convinience" (said in video) are exactly humane or clean. I would recomend watching video of facility in spain that Gordon Ramsay made. Thats a good looking facility. Clean spring water,... Here you go: ruclips.net/video/88aDJFdUjH4/видео.html
I worked at a fish farm for paddlefish caviar. We used a scalpal to score a small hole, then used a syringe to check the eggs. Otherwise, you may kill the fish without getting any eggs. Which would make the life of that fish and all the money going into it utterly worthless.
As a retired chef of 50 years I thoroughly enjoyed this video [and many others in the series] without getting in too deep regarding ethics or process. Each video tells it like it is. Videos are well made, well presented, entertaining as well as informative and about the correct length in time. 'How to make it' .. it does what it says on the tin.
As Chefs we don't always get to see first hand how are food products are prepared and handled. These fish are treated better than a lot of humans. All of the fish is utilized.
Martin No, veganism and vegetarianism are not white privileged things. I know people at my school who don’t eat meat or animal products because of their culture or religion, and even though they’re living in America, they are certainly not “white”. I can see how you might think it’s a luxury, but it really isn’t. Also, burgers are disgusting either way, whether vegan or not.
The electrocution doesn't hurt them, and the screwdriver thing is like getting a shot, yeah it hurts for like the first 2 seconds but ultimately they're fine.
My grandpa used to be a pilot in Russia and he had to fly workers from one workplace to another and once he had to fly fishers, who also produced caviar, to another town and they gave him two buckets with red and black caviar. Needless to say, we ate like royalty and it was delicious 🙈❤
RinceRice yeah they’ve got videos on RUclips. Was hoping people would’ve followed suit so they wouldn’t have to kill them so rich folk could enjoy their ovaries.
Mark The Nerd I’m sure both techniques will damage some eggs but at least the animal will still be alive and produce more eggs. I’d say if the folks could perfect the massage technique it’d be a more cheaper and safer way to enjoy the expensive ovaries people enjoy.
Its great that they are saving the species, and using the whole body. Just wish there was a more efficient way to harvest the eggs without killing them. They're doing their best though. I'd support them.
I can’t remember the company but I saw a video of a man massaging the eggs out with the fish staying alive so it is possible it’s just more time consuming
@@cerysm6293 that makes sense. Maybe we as a community can just make an effort to support that company more and raise reason for this one to change their methods to meet demand once we figure out this company's name. We technically have the power as consumers. That's awesome thank you.
If there was a way to harvest without killing, while still keeping quality standards up, don’t you think they’d do that? Obviously they’d rather not have to kill them and be continuously raising replacements for 7 years. Just from a cost perspective that doesn’t make sense if there was a good alternative. Farms like this are what will ensure the species survival when human eventually wipe them out in the wild. These farms could one day help restore wild populations if humans ever wise up.
Unless your a vegan, why would you call this inhuman? That burger you at last night was once a cow in a cramped area, the turkey you ate lived in a cage its entire life. Think about it, farmed caviar saves all wild sturgeon.
Brayden Karpinski I simply cant imagine it tastes the same as wil caught the problem with fish farms is that you keep so many fish in tiny spaces that you need to drown them in antibiotics or they get all kinds of sicknesses
Btterthanyu they used scientific evidence, your argument is “it doesn’t make sense”. Seems to me you’re the 11 year old here, especially since your username is “btterthanyu”. You seem younger than 11 to me.
Most of the people commenting are so disconnected from where their food comes from, every part of the fish is used. Unless you are vegan, where do you think your food comes from? Even the production of fruits and vegetables results in the death of animals.
Chris Dwyer I can agree what you say but people still eat it! That's the only source if we want to eat (meat from animals). Is people around the comment are too sensitive (animal abuse) or what? 😑
its just plain hilarous to see them commets 'like omg poor fish, this is animal abuse ' boi its food. now we growing food in places so we dont have to hubt like the old ages.
I've read sturgeon meat is best smoked. And given the meat is still very much the side product, it shouldn't be that expensive, especially if you live somewhere that has these caviar growers nearby. I live in eastern Finland, one small town south of us grows caviar. Just telling the owner of any grocery store that sells fresh fish that you would like some sturgeon meat and they get it for next day, price per kilogram not being a whole lot.
Just like a tuna meat. Sturgeon has a refined flavor and consistency. You can enjoy the charm of the fish meat by eating it as sashimi, sushi and marinading it. Even when boiled, you can enjoy the tender texture of sturgeon.
Officer- “did you *stab* the victim during the crime? Me- “ no officer...I was just preforming a biopsy with a screwdriver! I promise it was stress free” Officer- ...
If you really look at it, the word play is made so we don't feel bad for the fish. Examples like "farmed" "processed" "euthanized" are used instead of "kill" or "harvested" Rip stabby fish
Hit in the head with a hammer??? Yeah that’s really a good humane quick way to die. How many of them don’t die straight away while their being gutted 😔
Little Alie Pie what you have to understand is that they’re trying to be as humane as possible. I understand if that’s your belief and you don’t want these animals to die, but these fish aren’t human. It’s not cold blooded murder and you have to understand that. What some people don’t get is that there are two ways to harvest food that don’t hav to do with crops. One way is cold blooded killing them by letting them suffocate, or by using some means of force that doesn’t kill them instantly, or the second way is by making it quick and painless. Hitting in the head with a hammer, slitting their throats, dislocating their head... don’t get me wrong it sounds horrible, but if someone is gonna do it they should do it right.
MrDerpy17Y T unlike German when they say Fleisch like flesh instead of saying meat. Now there is a really high percentage of vegetarians there. Coincidence?
For anyone who is critcizing the living conditions and euthanizing methods at this farm, you should consider that these fish live considerably better than most livestock. Welfare standards at this farm in particular look acceptable. Animals raised for food are almost never raised in that great of a way. That’s just the truth. Even the biopsy would not have hurt as much as branding, dehorning and castration. So anyone who is calling THIS cruel better be a pretty f-in dedicated vegan as not to be a hypocrite.
It’s a fish not your mom, calm yourself. They also place the fish in water that has a mild electric field so they are sedated. Just like we sedate or anesthetize people to biopsy them.
Code Name Oh, yes. It feels so good to be mildly shocked in the water we’re submerged in. It’s more like being incapacitated so there isn’t resistance when being jabbed in the belly.
I’m actually glad that a place like the exist with high quality standards and uses the whole fish and not just the eggs. There are places that will just kill the fish for the eggs and throw the rest away which is a total waste with no quality control. Like others have said this kind of place is great as it doesn’t wipe a whole species of fish out as they are captive fish they use and wait till the fish itself is ready to be harvested instead of just snatching it up at the first sign of roe.
Well, is that a big difference? "Imagine living in that small tank for 7 years only to be killed when you lay eggs." I'd say not much difference in terms of the meaning behind.
Ok I don’t think they should make caviar cause it’s not a necessity and I would understand if like there was to many sturgeon but theirs not so it’s just sad and that after 7 years of living in a tank and then only being killed for your eggs and honestly that is just messed up
It’s not a matter of alive or not, it’s a matter of sentience and suffering. I don’t have any problem with using a brain dead mans body as dog feed if he chooses to do that.
Kenji I do agree with you 100% but this people are trying to sell the idea that the fish are not tortured, the biopsy part was like a ridiculous scene from family guy show.
3:05 ok Sabine is hilarious 😂😂😂 I don't know if I like caviar but I would like to work at the fish farm just to learn more about fish as I want my own ponds for my own consumption one-day
Well its not fertilized eggs i believe...Its more like someone putting you in a bath of ice and instead of stealing your kidneys, they take out your ovaries and harvest the eggs inside
“We use a electric current to calm the fish down” *starts stabbing the fish with a screwdriver*...... LOGIC RIGHT THERE LADIES AND GENTLEMEN Edit: GUYS IT WAS A JOKE! Calm downnn
It made me feel so uncomfortable when the lady shove the Iron needle thing up the Fishes unterus and sucked up some of her eggs like that must hurt like a damn saw movie in real life
Chinese just cut off shark fins and throw them back into the water to drown. Mind you deluded people will tell themselves anything to forgive themselves. Peasants used to just squeeze the eggs out.
It can be done, that is what we do here at KASPERSKIAN Caviar in Switzerland. Our sturgeon produce their caviar naturally over a long and healthy lifetime, not just once but many times.
Wow that's absolutely fascinating. I'm glad there are sustainable and environmentally friendly solutions to problems. The thing is, if you take away something like this, even worse happens to the environment long term.
People can complain all they want but I'd MUCH rather have people farming sturgeon than fishing them to actual extinction. Everytime
And they farm them to actually prevent extinction. These sturgeon are prehistoric and I'd rather not see the species go extinct. Farming actually saved the species. At last, someone who gets it.
Meanwhile most the people complaining eat processed meats from grocery stores while having a poodle from a puppy mill. This is farming and there's no difference from their cheeseburger except price and pallets.
Thank you
Same
We eat what we farmed is ok for me, but hunting natural/ wild animals, fish etc to the point of extinction is quit disturbing. Mother nature will take revenge one day for our cruelty and greediness.
I’m just glad they try to use every part so it doesn’t go to waste
Same! I'm sure they also sell the bones-- fish gelatin can be used for sooo many things. I mean, I understand that a lot of people don't like the idea of animals being killed, but it happens and at least these farmers aren't like poachers where they let the meat and organs rot.
Lol why does it seems like you are trolling vegans
Does it seem that way? If that's how it comes off, I deeply apologize-- that's not the intention on my end at least. I'm just saying that it's reality in my opinion. I see vegans and similar as people who have huge hearts and don't like the idea of one animal murder another. I see the world differently and that's okay. If I upset anyone (vegan or not), I apologize.
@@tlaoltjenbruns9580 Aurora I give mad respect to you man, the fact that you were so respectful made me quite surprised in a good way, keep it up dude.
They are idiots. There is a technology already to get the caviar and save life of the fish to get more caviar later... from THE SAME fish!
At least they use the whole fish. They don't throw away the meat like some farms
Luna Zwirlein oooh just makes it so much better ...not
@@astrorose2736 I'm just saying. No need to be snarky
Jack R good for you:)
@@astrorose2736 makes it a lot better actually.
So heroic
"They look exactly like they taste!"
Explains texture...nothing said about flavor...
jon jordan right? 🤦🏻♂️
jon jordan had to google what does caviar taste like 😂
it’s like a nut (pardon the pun) flavour, like a fresh salty fish taste that isn’t overpowering.
Serious Eats is 831 channels up from this channel. Over here we just get whomever is assigned to the story.
Its just salty
imagine living in a tank for 8 years just to get stabbed in the stomach and killed for eggs-
harsh 😢
In a way it sounds like the adoption process in America. Kids are practically left in terrible conditions and the U.S. only care about fetuses that aren't born yet lol
Allow me to judge you raw.
You sound like a vegan extremist.
:(
How soft, nobody care
I love how everyone is suddenly a fish expert
Wildboyz who says
Typical
Fish = yum
I = expert
Don’t need be an expert to comment on this
We are fish expert
I feel like a fish could be stressed out by being stabbed with a screw driver
Hammy Bean yeah ik
@Hammy Bean me also
it probably also does not enjoy being sliced open...
EXACTLY
😂😂😂😂😂
I actually think the facility was clean, well kept and the sturgeon are swimming in their schools just like in the wild. This seems as humane as possible.
With the exception that the fish is killed at the end. They could've used the surgery method, which doesn't kill the fish.
@@hodjaev_ruslan i dont see problem there since rest of the fish is used too
@@hodjaev_ruslan They are not just taking the eggs. They are using the rest of the animal as well.
@@notsure1277 we'll, keep in mind that not only is it more ethical but it would be more efficient in terms of production.
Surgical removal allows for multiple egg extractions.
And as these fish grow they produce more eggs.
Sturgeon can live for more than a century and at full size they produce A LOT of eggs.
Well I dont think I would call those small tanks that are that small only because of "convinience" (said in video) are exactly humane or clean. I would recomend watching video of facility in spain that Gordon Ramsay made. Thats a good looking facility. Clean spring water,... Here you go: ruclips.net/video/88aDJFdUjH4/видео.html
I am an INDIAN and for me they look like papaya seeds
Yea me too lol 😆
Lol
I'm Russian and the first time I saw a picture of papaya seeds I thought they looked like caviar...
Mohini Bakshi what does this have anything to do with u being Indian😂
@@SF-yh2ot cause papayas are very common in Asian and Indian countries. People actually have knowledge of the seeds.
10% of the comments: actually talking about the caviar.
90% of the comments: omg she stabbed the fish with a screw driver.
Ha lol
Facts
90% of us are in shock,lol.
Well, to be fair she literally did.
Good is different from bad.
“Let’s take a biopsy here.”
*Lifts screwdriver*
Ikr 😨
I worked at a fish farm for paddlefish caviar. We used a scalpal to score a small hole, then used a syringe to check the eggs. Otherwise, you may kill the fish without getting any eggs. Which would make the life of that fish and all the money going into it utterly worthless.
Do you know what biopsy means ?
@@JoeMama-iq8hy
Uh-huh.
Zackary Bullard it’s tissue being removed from a living specimen which makes this joke stupid
As a retired chef of 50 years I thoroughly enjoyed this video [and many others in the series] without getting in too deep regarding ethics or process. Each video tells it like it is. Videos are well made, well presented, entertaining as well as informative and about the correct length in time. 'How to make it' .. it does what it says on the tin.
As Chefs we don't always get to see first hand how are food products are prepared and handled. These fish are treated better than a lot of humans. All of the fish is utilized.
DOESN'T EVERYONE CLAIM TO BE A CHEF ?... YEAH RIGHT !!!.....WE CAN'T TELL !!!!
I promise everyone: these fish really don’t get mistreated that badly, compared to what your burger
or bacon goes through.
What about the burger? It comes from a box.
Same thing with farm animals
Martin No, veganism and vegetarianism are not white privileged things. I know people at my school who don’t eat meat or animal products because of their culture or religion, and even though they’re living in America, they are certainly not “white”. I can see how you might think it’s a luxury, but it really isn’t. Also, burgers are disgusting either way, whether vegan or not.
the less I know the better it is a luxury in 3rd world countries (developing nations)
Jens Kristian Moerkved true
This comment section is a fun place to play "Find The Vegan."
HÉHÊ what a clever joke, never seen that on any video related to animals ever 😒
HÉHÊ I FOUND ONE, ITS NAME IS LEMON PEELS
Andrew Kim I’m not vegan lmao
Hey, you found me 👉😎👉
nOw sToP kiLLinG aNimAlS beFoRe I eAt yoUr cHildRen
Legit doing that
The rollercoaster of this comment section is just darn too good lmao
Asterbel Ong
Lmao wtf is going on down here
Agreed. More entertaining than the fake news channel !
@@MeetTheSmythes there is no legit news
Damn... This is terrible...
**Takes a bite of KFC**
Lmao
Lmao
I mean it is what it is
@@elias-ml6eo Lmao
You break the chain
@@mrbreathing9647 It is what it is
That moment when your just swimming around then get stabbed by a screwdriver
I want to be a Lime it was is the electric water did you see it react to it no cause it doesn’t feel pain
I dream about yoi
#RELATEABLE
@@plink0642 I think we are alike
@@Clex- whats up there my sturgeon brother! Nice to see you here
Those tanks are crowded af.
No they actually aren’t even in the wild they would remain close together naturally crowded
😂😂😂
Like us?
They actually like to travel together and it's usually crowded like that too, so it's normal for them.
Looks like papaya seeds to me. 😂
Joanna Marie Segura 😅
Why people r cruel so much. Y ds dey becme vegitrians
Bet people would pay you the price for caviar even if you sell them papaya seeds instead.
Papaya seeds r gross, remind me of goat poo
@@binuvik648 wtf I didn't understand a word you said
"We try to keep out fish happy"
*Stabs its stomach with a screwdriver then proceeds to electrocute it*
You are so right
The electrocution doesn't hurt them, and the screwdriver thing is like getting a shot, yeah it hurts for like the first 2 seconds but ultimately they're fine.
@@underscore2736 I know that but it’s just the irony
😭
They did not electrocute it. Prior to the screw driver, they smashed the head with a hammer hence the cover on the head.
“ *for people that have not had caviar* “
So you’re speaking to 95% of the worlds population right?
It pops and is salty, it would go with things but I've only had a little spoon once but I liked it
@@B0nesS0up sounds like those little orange thingy they put on top of sushi
More like 99%, 1% of whole world population would be about 60million and that's considerably high number of people,still lol
Taste gud
Nah, just you.
My grandpa used to be a pilot in Russia and he had to fly workers from one workplace to another and once he had to fly fishers, who also produced caviar, to another town and they gave him two buckets with red and black caviar. Needless to say, we ate like royalty and it was delicious 🙈❤
Wow
Nice
Cool.
Honestly I'd rather have the money
What's so good about eating fish eggs
IEatClouds *fish eggs are yummy*
Ehh ive tried it before and its nothing id pay for personally
You could ask that question about literally any animal product.
IEatClouds Fish eggs (or caviar) are actually a delicacy in most cultures and very expensive
IEatClouds it’s delicious try it
Man I'm not vegan, but stabbing a fish with screwdriver sucks.
She looked misbrel the poor dear cant expani her grief just hammer them to death😑
it’s a fish wtf
@@shaquilleoatmeal6522 a fish with a LIFE
Trueeee
@@shaquilleoatmeal6522 id do it you and youd be fine when someone says its just one human wtf
“Biopsy” rams a screwdriver in it....
Standard procedure that is utterly harmless, that causes no pain due to the neurology (or lack thereof) in a sturgeon :)
Zakoo Hakoo thank you 😊
The sturgeon also owed her money.
Looks more like ice pick
Zakoo Hakoo
Painful to humans
So glad Amy Schumer found her true calling
arguably more annoying than Schumer
OMG right !!!
😂😂😂
Lamfao so true
😂😂😂😂😂
She protecc
She attacc
But most importantly
She coming for your egg sacc
😂😂😂
😂😂😥
Not funny to be honest
She stab your egg sacc
Bot :P shut up snowflake
Go back to the kitchen
There’s a massage technique used to extract the eggs. Wished everyone else did it.
AceHi808 without killing them? That would satisfy mother nature
RinceRice yeah they’ve got videos on RUclips. Was hoping people would’ve followed suit so they wouldn’t have to kill them so rich folk could enjoy their ovaries.
Unfortunately, it can yield damaged eggs, or none at all. It's very unreliable.
Mark The Nerd I’m sure both techniques will damage some eggs but at least the animal will still be alive and produce more eggs. I’d say if the folks could perfect the massage technique it’d be a more cheaper and safer way to enjoy the expensive ovaries people enjoy.
@@AceHi808 ..they're not ovaries.
Eating endangered species always tastes better, personally I like shaving some rhino horn on my caviar.
that’s the only way to do it!! While served on top of a green sea turtle shell. 👌🏽
justin van LMAOO
And a slice of fried elephant trunk.
Your obviously a liberal moron
@@brandond73 looks like someone isn't having fun. :(
Its great that they are saving the species, and using the whole body. Just wish there was a more efficient way to harvest the eggs without killing them. They're doing their best though. I'd support them.
I can’t remember the company but I saw a video of a man massaging the eggs out with the fish staying alive so it is possible it’s just more time consuming
@@cerysm6293 that makes sense. Maybe we as a community can just make an effort to support that company more and raise reason for this one to change their methods to meet demand once we figure out this company's name. We technically have the power as consumers. That's awesome thank you.
Keris Morris
Doesn’t really work, it affects the quality of the eggs, and the quantity, that’s why farmers don’t usually do it
In Russia they massaging the belly of the fish to get the caviar out
If there was a way to harvest without killing, while still keeping quality standards up, don’t you think they’d do that? Obviously they’d rather not have to kill them and be continuously raising replacements for 7 years. Just from a cost perspective that doesn’t make sense if there was a good alternative. Farms like this are what will ensure the species survival when human eventually wipe them out in the wild. These farms could one day help restore wild populations if humans ever wise up.
I guess you can say she performed *sturgery* on the fish
Josh Hsu oh my gawd u really out here making dad jokes 😂😂😂
Josh Hsu HOW IS THIS THE ONLY NON VEGAN COMMENT I FOUND!?
Lmfao im dying this is too good
DAD Stop with the dad jokes
Stop
Girl: takes a bite of the top caviar
Another girl who works there: you know that’s going to cost you thousands of dollars right
More like 5.00 dollars but ok
Damn she really just stabbed that fish
They don't feel pain there
@@Apple-qo3uw how you know?
@@Apple-qo3uw yeah, how do you know?
@@blenaanelb6173 it's called education?
Lol fish cant feel pain
Unless your a vegan, why would you call this inhuman? That burger you at last night was once a cow in a cramped area, the turkey you ate lived in a cage its entire life. Think about it, farmed caviar saves all wild sturgeon.
Brayden Karpinski I simply cant imagine it tastes the same as wil caught
the problem with fish farms is that you keep so many fish in tiny spaces that you need to drown them in antibiotics or they get all kinds of sicknesses
@@teakwondochest3287 not quite different with glass house tho
@@teakwondochest3287 one would assume such a farm uses at least an industrial sized filtering system.
You don't understand
Sturgeon are protected there isn’t a lot this place should make money in stocking wildlife waters
The "biopsy" is just stabbing them with a rod. Do these fish heal over those holes quickly or what? I imagine it is painful for them.
Joseph Lee they have no nerves there, and they do it while they are calmed by the electric current. They don’t feel anything until it’s already gone
Joseph Lee
Don't listen to the 11 year old saying that they "don't feel anything" that makes no sense
Btterthanyu they used scientific evidence, your argument is “it doesn’t make sense”. Seems to me you’re the 11 year old here, especially since your username is “btterthanyu”. You seem younger than 11 to me.
Fish don’t feel pain.
I never ate caviar and I don't think I ever will after watching this
Most of the people commenting are so disconnected from where their food comes from, every part of the fish is used. Unless you are vegan, where do you think your food comes from? Even the production of fruits and vegetables results in the death of animals.
Chris Dwyer I can agree what you say but people still eat it! That's the only source if we want to eat (meat from animals). Is people around the comment are too sensitive (animal abuse) or what? 😑
I dont wanna say it but its fact so i cant deny it only ignorant will do that so yeah theyre idiot.
Chris Dwyer I Agree but this is worse than killing them instantly. They’re imprisoned in such small tanks for 7 years. It’s just too cruel
they're not imprisoned, they're grown there and the conditions are such that its optimal for their growth.
its just plain hilarous to see them commets 'like omg poor fish, this is animal abuse '
boi its food. now we growing food in places so we dont have to hubt like the old ages.
We shouldn't complain about the ethics of these farms. They're the only real way to keep wild sturgeon alive.
There should always be concerns about the ethics of farming.
Farming can be done ethically though. They don’t have to be left in tiny tanks and force fed food for 7 years
Hahaha well we humans learned to exploit them ( not vegan )
@Ally Sah the moment people deem the ethical nonsense is too much they will just overlook thr caviar and the sturgeon will be hunted for extinction
Yeah but i think those sturgeons will prefer going extinct over living in a stupid mini pool atleast i would
These comments are 70 percent mad about the fish 20 percent about Amy schumer and 10 percent laughing about the comments themself.
Great observation other than the previous mentioned in your comment about percentages
She does kinda look like Amy Schumer tho. Also makes jokes like her. At least she isn't a self proclaimed comedian
I've never had caviar why am I watching a fish getting stabbed in her egg sack 😂
Tried to call a doctor but they said I needed a sturgeon
You know what.. I'm not even mad lmao
Your story sounds very fishy
lol
I must say that your story is eggcelent!😂 i'll walk myself out...
On The Bus Podcast will you need to get sturgery?
so yall just go around stabbing fish with screw drivers calling it a biopsy?
i know that’s crazy
Uh yes?
That's what im saying :/ doesn't feel right
They won't stop they make too much money
@@ivan.457 4:34.... ""its so nice to be a sturgeon""...
I'm kinda happy they use the meat as well and not just kill it for the eggs
They don't use the meat bro....
Marco Morales Actually, they do. They sell it as smoked sturgeon meat. I’ve seen them selling it at my local farmer’s market.
I got to get some
I've read sturgeon meat is best smoked. And given the meat is still very much the side product, it shouldn't be that expensive, especially if you live somewhere that has these caviar growers nearby.
I live in eastern Finland, one small town south of us grows caviar. Just telling the owner of any grocery store that sells fresh fish that you would like some sturgeon meat and they get it for next day, price per kilogram not being a whole lot.
Just like a tuna meat. Sturgeon has a refined flavor and consistency. You can enjoy the charm of the fish meat by eating it as sashimi, sushi and marinading it. Even when boiled, you can enjoy the tender texture of sturgeon.
Amy Shumer is living her best life with this new career change!
*Gordon Ramsay says he’s on his way.*
Gordon Ramsey wants to know your location
Quick, get the lamb sauce
Officer- “did you *stab* the victim during the crime?
Me- “ no officer...I was just preforming a biopsy with a screwdriver! I promise it was stress free”
Officer- ...
Yup... oh the fish dont mind it its a tiggle ... yet the human is 4 times heavier
"I was just harvesting them"
Limelight🍋💡
Rachel Hammer. Your killing me.😂🤣🤣🤣👌
They do the same type of biopsy on women at the ob/gyn, its called a copo.
If you really look at it, the word play is made so we don't feel bad for the fish. Examples like "farmed" "processed" "euthanized" are used instead of "kill" or "harvested"
Rip stabby fish
Hit in the head with a hammer???
Yeah that’s really a good humane quick way to die. How many of them don’t die straight away while their being gutted 😔
omfg thanks for the likes 👌👌👍👍🙌
ok minecraft
rip creepers and pigs who never became tracer
Little Alie Pie what you have to understand is that they’re trying to be as humane as possible. I understand if that’s your belief and you don’t want these animals to die, but these fish aren’t human. It’s not cold blooded murder and you have to understand that. What some people don’t get is that there are two ways to harvest food that don’t hav to do with crops. One way is cold blooded killing them by letting them suffocate, or by using some means of force that doesn’t kill them instantly, or the second way is by making it quick and painless. Hitting in the head with a hammer, slitting their throats, dislocating their head... don’t get me wrong it sounds horrible, but if someone is gonna do it they should do it right.
MrDerpy17Y T unlike German when they say Fleisch like flesh instead of saying meat. Now there is a really high percentage of vegetarians there. Coincidence?
One of these farms is right up the road from me and I got to visit it a few weeks ago with my aquaculture class. Loved it.
Very lucky class! A vet friend of mine got her masters in aquatics. Super interesting.
"Russian sturgeon is only imported from russia"
YA DONT SAAAAY
@ HEY
There's something called a joke
Might be useful to look it up
Lol
@@choxoletyo8518 the joke is no longer valid.
@@vishalworldoffire wdym?
@@choxoletyo8518 actually never mind.
“You have to make sure that there calm “ while she continues to stab with screwdriver
What time is it in the video cause I cant find it
@@yayayayayayayayayayaa 4:10
It was three different fish and they were put in water with some electro current to make them calm so I think they were fine
Brienne Wolf right I noticed that I was thinking is a screwdriver the professional tool used for proper extraction of caviar
For anyone who is critcizing the living conditions and euthanizing methods at this farm, you should consider that these fish live considerably better than most livestock.
Welfare standards at this farm in particular look acceptable. Animals raised for food are almost never raised in that great of a way. That’s just the truth.
Even the biopsy would not have hurt as much as branding, dehorning and castration. So anyone who is calling THIS cruel better be a pretty f-in dedicated vegan as not to be a hypocrite.
Bork PomPom 🙌🏻🙌🏻
Bork PomPom you know how much brain cells I lost reading this? Grabs some more so I can lose more you idiot
Owllover66 Fry
R/madlads
This was a great documentary🐟
If the fish were replaced with dogs everyone would start suing
Very true
Junyi Chen because no one eats dogs normally if they did that for no reason obviously people would get mad
But dog's don't lay eggs, tho?
Roxbalt people do eat dogs. Entire countries eat dogs.
Roxbalt they can be a source of food for some people
People: *OMG THIS IS SOOO CRUEL*
Me: And where do you think our meat come from?
It was so scary when the girl casually stabbed a fish, am I right?
@@farylduncan It was a little but I heard and saw way worst.
Just dont eat meat at all
@@olan5653
But that isn't going to stop people from stabbing pigs in the neck!
@@dzmp2534 sure aint going to stop me from eating pork and beef along with chicken and goat
That biopsy looked painful.
A stab in the gut. Very insensitive
It’s a fish not your mom, calm yourself. They also place the fish in water that has a mild electric field so they are sedated. Just like we sedate or anesthetize people to biopsy them.
HindsightPOV Fish don’t feel pain..
MrAdonis258
Are you serious? Fish are vertebrates. They have a spine like humans do. They can definitely feel pain.
Code Name
Oh, yes. It feels so good to be mildly shocked in the water we’re submerged in. It’s more like being incapacitated so there isn’t resistance when being jabbed in the belly.
I’m actually glad that a place like the exist with high quality standards and uses the whole fish and not just the eggs. There are places that will just kill the fish for the eggs and throw the rest away which is a total waste with no quality control.
Like others have said this kind of place is great as it doesn’t wipe a whole species of fish out as they are captive fish they use and wait till the fish itself is ready to be harvested instead of just snatching it up at the first sign of roe.
I knew it wasn’t amy Schumer because she made me laugh
And they didn't throw her into the tank and drown her.
Ikr
Brutal
😆😆😆
🤣🤣🤣
Imagine living in that small tank for 7 years only to be killed for your eggs
The fish don't get pregnant. They lay eggs. They're mostly virgins anyway since they don't reach maturity until they're 7 or 8 years old anyway.
Ethan Jones I was going to say that. Glad someone knew that.
Well, is that a big difference? "Imagine living in that small tank for 7 years only to be killed when you lay eggs." I'd say not much difference in terms of the meaning behind.
You're a vegan aren't you? Or maybe a peta supporter? Oh well, more delicious animal based food for me. Have fun battling scurvy and anemia.
Ok I don’t think they should make caviar cause it’s not a necessity and I would understand if like there was to many sturgeon but theirs not so it’s just sad and that after 7 years of living in a tank and then only being killed for your eggs and honestly that is just messed up
Biopsy? Thats poking fish to me.
Al Delgado legit
fish don't feel pain :)
Luke Mesquita weird flex but ok
Luke Mesquita NOT TRUE
@@bsmoove1031 you dont know that, would you feel pain if i poke you?
This video was very informative
"We hit the fish with a hammer right away" is...that supposed to calm me down?
Z I don’t Know if it’s a myth or not but apparently fish you don’t feel as much pain because somethings in there nervous system
@@blackberry1852
Hey. I read about this.... they feel basically like us.
@@blackberry1852 ok that... wasn't funny
@@blackberry1852 Nothing feels much, not even you after one good hammer blow over the head.
Hmm imagine being kept in a glorified tank just to be hit in the head by a hammer and being cut in half to extract your children
Everything you consume is alive. There is no non living thing you can consume without worrying about harming. Lion King, circle of life.
It’s not a matter of alive or not, it’s a matter of sentience and suffering. I don’t have any problem with using a brain dead mans body as dog feed if he chooses to do that.
Bakemono! HUMANS ARE DESTROYING AND EATING EVERYTHING! A disease, not a circle of life. After all, who eats humans?!
Kenji I do agree with you 100% but this people are trying to sell the idea that the fish are not tortured, the biopsy part was like a ridiculous scene from family guy show.
**masive gulp of tea**
Salt
Imagine being pregz and getting stabbed in the stomach. No thank you.
Nicki B its just like getting a needle, no big deal.
Nato Except the needle would be 1-3 cm in diameter
SRAt clorox What would need to be 1-3 cm? No needle is that big...
Nato if you would compare the size of a Sturgeon to the size of a human
SRAt clorox thank you
Don't tell me I'm the only one that finds these satisfying
Amy Schumer's doing well now that she's taking her meds.
johsor1984 yeah wtf
Ok, I'm glad I wasn't the only one that clocked a doppelganger.
I don’t know why this was in my recommended and why I watched it but I’m not complaining
Finally someone answer my question about how caviar are harvested. Thanks eater
Makes me sad :( I've seen other methods that involve harvesting the eggs without killing the sturgeon. Why don't more farms use that method?
@@danielchin4464 At least they use the whole animal.
Gordon Ramsay did a video about caviar harvesting.
No kidding!
Because there isn’t a hundred videos on this already.
3:05 ok Sabine is hilarious 😂😂😂 I don't know if I like caviar but I would like to work at the fish farm just to learn more about fish as I want my own ponds for my own consumption one-day
Bro i read the title as how russian surgeon extracts caviar😂
Me too
That's why I came.... thought they cut take and let live.🤣
Exactly what I read
Imagine that your pregnant and getting stabbed then your babies turn into a snacc , hell no
NINJAmorph12 HD hello Ml player
Stfu
Yeah its disgusting
Well its not fertilized eggs i believe...Its more like someone putting you in a bath of ice and instead of stealing your kidneys, they take out your ovaries and harvest the eggs inside
dont you eat chicken eggs??
Who else thought this was daily dose of Internet?
Me
Highlight Hell hahah me
Me…
HELLO EVERYONE, THIS IS YOUR DAILY DOSE OF INTERNET.
Freaking me
I wasnt expecting the reggaeton outro 😂
Like if never had caviar 😭
me..😂 ..
Its not that great like the shark fin soup
Probably not worth for 2nd try unless you really want it
I never had, and I never want to have one.
@Adidas s its not that gross
“We use a electric current to calm the fish down” *starts stabbing the fish with a screwdriver*...... LOGIC RIGHT THERE LADIES AND GENTLEMEN
Edit: GUYS IT WAS A JOKE! Calm downnn
xXmerylXx they dont feel
it, no nerves in the area that they biopsy in
@@laurenrichards1415 whats better
Being stabbed by a minus screwdriver or a ice pick
R/wooooosh
@@ale-sh4vj That is completely wrong, there are nerves everywhere.
Yeah since you work there.......slam.
dang, that fish is screwed.
THEOFFICIAL SIMONCOWELL I hate this 😂
SubNovva 😂
I hate that I laughed so hard at this I’m literally crying 😂
I knew something was *fishy* about this...
THEOFFICIAL SIMONCOWELL Why 😂
I took a good hard look and I can say for those of you calling it a screwdriver, it's not, it has no wedges anywhere.
It made me feel so uncomfortable when the lady shove the Iron needle thing up the Fishes unterus and sucked up some of her eggs like that must hurt like a damn saw movie in real life
lesjuice let me do that to you. science said it won't hurt you, u pos.
@@grammadoh1 are you mental?
lesjuice fish do feel pain stop spreading lies idiot
Fish do feel pain 😞
@@lesjuice u crazy ,maybe they are not sure or lie with intention so people to continue eat cavier
**sips tea while reading the comments**
Edit: owo thanks for the 223 likes. Never had this much likes before
Happy Days.
😂😂😂
Is your pinky in the air when you do? Mine is.
Lol
Silver Chopsticks yes, I like feeling fancy when sipping tea with my pinky up too :3
If I was the Fish I would poop the eggs before they can Disect me.
Gregor Jerman smart boy, if you don’t produce eggs, they will consider u are a male fish and kill u for the meat
You realize you have to be inseminated before you can give birth? The use of the word “poop” also concerns me
Actually I watched a video where the caviar extractor gathered the eggs without killing them
Its called a joke kids
Did thee learn basic science?
Now i know the best job in the world is to test the taste of this expensive caviar 😋😍🤩
Getting a biopsy/stabbing them is not keeping the fish happy☹️
XxYorWrstNigtmre they dont feel it
Teona Music how do u know your not the fish
xXminifox 310Xx you’re**, and it’s scientifically proven.... if they don’t have nerves there they can’t feel it.
Eating pork meat does not make pigs happy
XxYorWrstNigtmre dont care its just food not your sister or dad
Did she just stab the fish in 4:12 like its nothing! :))))))))
She knows what she's doing.
Lol u ppl r so close minded, and sensitive..
Well.. that's the point
Just a biopsy :)
If you made a lot of money for it I bet you would do the same
*_Gordon Ramsay wants to know the location_*
ruclips.net/video/88aDJFdUjH4/видео.html
Watch it ✌️
My favorite Ramsey clip
Well duh, he would want to find another place to get caviar since the idiots he had on The F Word dropped his
I think he's already been there!
Wow so nice...thank you for the info.🙏
You want your fish to be happy * casually rips out the meat*
I’m Russian, and when I was little and we had caviar on hand my grandma would always make me a bread, butter and caviar sandwich
Was it good?
MsSexyDiva4Lyfe yes
Omg same !
sounds wonderful
fecking delicous
this makes me want to go vegan
Box of chocolates please do! you won’t regret it :)
Do it then,nobody cares
Do it then your not down
You'll go back..
Do it dawg
I love caviar it tastes so good it’s like a little eggs but it’s so good
It is not only "like *little eggs", caviar IS little eggs.
Stabbing fish belly with a screwdriver, that's called biopsy...hmm Ok.
Chinese just cut off shark fins and throw them back into the water to drown. Mind you deluded people will tell themselves anything to forgive themselves. Peasants used to just squeeze the eggs out.
Lance: *tastes* *caviar* "mmmm this is good, whaaaaat is it?"
London's friend: "caviar "
Lance: "what's caviar? "
London's friend: "fish eggs"
Lance: *spits* *out* *caviar* "UNBORN BABY FISH! WHY DON'T YOU JUST FEED ME PUPPIES!"
This video is approved by the Sturgeon General
J-Mac's Amateur Kitchen well played.
My Russian boyfriend’s family use caviar as a regular bread spread (especially on occasion) : )) they normally put this on top of the bread 🍞
They rich
"This is our top quality product you are sampling."
*sampler proceeds to say nothing about flavour or seasoning
Bibbly seriously that bugged me too.
So mad
Astro Beats humorous?
Seasoning? You don’t season caviar.
Code Name salting?
Oh! So many caviar!
Great!
Eyy luv ur channel btw
What are u doinh here
Well yeah because sturgeon lay up to 700,000 eggs
Why is Amy Schumer so into caviar.
I come back to watch this video at least once a month
How are people still eating this?
with toast usually
LOOOOOOOOOOOOL
Wdym lol
Martin Tobon welcome to real life
hekasoram 💀
I wish there a way to take the caviar out without killing the fish
There is a way to do it
It can be done, that is what we do here at KASPERSKIAN Caviar in Switzerland. Our sturgeon produce their caviar naturally over a long and healthy lifetime, not just once but many times.
There are ways, but most times it’s not very effective.
It can be done by hormone therapy
THERE IS.... but they chose to do it so it’s convenient for them 😬😩😫😭😭😭😢😢😢😤😤😤😤😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Wow that's absolutely fascinating. I'm glad there are sustainable and environmentally friendly solutions to problems. The thing is, if you take away something like this, even worse happens to the environment long term.
4:35 i was stunned at the sight of the piercing, anyway, still nice film to share... thank you!