Pink Floyd - Hey You Reaction

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 окт 2024

Комментарии • 98

  • @sarastromseth-troy3323
    @sarastromseth-troy3323 3 года назад +17

    I love this song. I agree with your assessment that it sounds like depression and desperation. I think it's interesting how David Gilmour takes the lead vocal at the beginning and has a more calm quality to his voice, and then Roger Waters takes the higher vocal and the 'no hope at all' line at the end. As for additional Pink Floyd reaction suggestions, my personal favorite from the Pulse concert is 'Sorrow'. It's intense and I actually like it better than 'Comfortably Numb.'

    • @atomicat
      @atomicat 3 года назад

      Yepp..
      While the music in this song is not really complicated, the lyric will totally kill you..
      What a band.

  • @patrigilligan2112
    @patrigilligan2112 3 года назад +5

    It's not just a concept album, it's a movie soundtrack from a MUST SEE movie!

  • @TomTom-ui9hg
    @TomTom-ui9hg 3 года назад +5

    Great job Dad for introducing your son to some of the greatest music created. Their was a moment when his eyes light up and a small grin appeared and he was hooked. Keep it up. Peace!

    • @Polecat54941
      @Polecat54941 3 года назад

      This is being a proper father.

    • @TomTom-ui9hg
      @TomTom-ui9hg 3 года назад +1

      @@Polecat54941 Yes he is. Peace!

  • @BagsEsquire
    @BagsEsquire 3 года назад +6

    Awesome Reaction..In a small group of best songs of all time. Without a doubt my favorite band since I was a kid. This band has gotten me through some really dark days at a very early part of life from my parents fighting and getting into crazy shit throughout life down the road... Dad drinking, great heart, great provider but byproduct of abusive Father, so detached or angry with glimmers of who he really is at heart. Great man and finally fully “him” in his old age.. Have fallen asleep to more Pink Floyd songs than any band. Have probably also cried quite a few times from the absolute beauty of the chord arrangements and lyrics...I don’t think I would take any of it back because it’s made me a very specific person with my kids in a very good way. This song is heavy to me...Great content!

  • @flubblert
    @flubblert 3 года назад +2

    In the original tour of The Wall (1979, 80), a 35ft high wall is built across the entire front of the stadium during the first half of the concert. By the time the band gets to this song, they are completely obscured from the audience by The Wall. This song, Hey You, is sung from behind the wall. Roger Waters toured with The Wall as recently as 2016. The phenomenal shows were even more extravagant, playing indoor and outdoor stadiums from coast to coast and setting all time touring records.

  • @michaelmorgan9921
    @michaelmorgan9921 3 года назад +1

    Saw the wall live back in Germany. Gilmour performed this when the wall had been completed and just as he started to play a dummy fell off the top, we thought he'd fell. Brilliant.

  • @pommie5093
    @pommie5093 3 года назад

    Your description of this song-someone who trying to describe loneliness, depression-feeling isolated-and playing this song to describe how it feels, it really moved me. Because that is exactly how I feel. Dealing with depression and ptsd throughout my life, I have always felt that PF's music and lyrics so often describe things in a way I can't. So, well said. First time seeing your channel tonight, subbed.

  • @flubblert
    @flubblert 3 года назад +8

    "Hey You" though performed live during the '94 Division Bell" concerts, was left off of the Pulse DVD and album recordings of it. For the young man.. Rodger Waters is the higher voice you hear toward the end. He was the lyricist and conceptual genius behind Pink Floyd. Also co-lead vocalist and bass player. His life is what much of "The Wall" is based on, along with mental deterioration inspired by original co-founder Syd Barrett. In The Wall album, the passion and pain of Roger's vocals throughout, matches and at times exceeds Gilmour's amazing guitar playing. Roger left the band in the mid-80s before two of their biggest tours were filmed. So sadly he doesn't get the credit he deserves from younger generations. But make no mistake about his importance in the overall success of the band. None of these songs or concepts would exist without his dark and troubled genius.

    • @flubblert
      @flubblert 3 года назад +1

      BTW, you left out 'Animals' in talking about Floyd's greatest albums. It is considered by many their finest album. You might want to check out "Dogs" from that album next.

    • @marniethedyslexic6445
      @marniethedyslexic6445 3 года назад +1

      Great information. Great job❤️✌️🌼

    • @Pulsar77
      @Pulsar77 3 года назад +3

      Hey You is on the Pulse CD, and it's fantastic. They didn't play it on the night they filmed, that's why it's not on the DVD. Such a shame they filmed only one concert from the tour.

    • @flubblert
      @flubblert 3 года назад

      @@Pulsar77 OK. 👍

    • @mnewm21
      @mnewm21 3 года назад +1

      they were perfection and so it was inevitable that at some stage they would fall apart! For me the amazing thing was we got a solid decade+ of "real Pink Floyd" and in some way the greatest compliment paid to them is that there have been no pretenders to their sound and yet it was clearly very commercial.

  • @woodythepoo1
    @woodythepoo1 3 года назад +2

    In the story, the protagonist’s father dies in WWII, and he is raised by an over protective mother and he eventually builds up a wall to protect himself from any more trauma like losing his father... he eventually becomes a rockstar and junkie... that is when the album transitions to Comfortably Numb (when he OD’s) etc. Must watch the full length movie with Bob Geldof playing the main character.

    • @soniasurija8880
      @soniasurija8880 3 года назад

      Good feedback, that’s right Roger Water’s dad died in the war & his mother was over the top protective that he felt trapped etc

  • @marniethedyslexic6445
    @marniethedyslexic6445 3 года назад +3

    Great reaction. I love this whole album. Together we stand divided we fall😀👍❤️✌️🌼

  • @helmutvogel901
    @helmutvogel901 3 года назад +1

    Pink Floyd pretty well invented moving light shows at concerts. I have seen a video from 1967? where they projected a lava light effect on the group. Blobs of different colours flowing around. But they are known for lighting/special effects, as well as the music of course! So please, when you guys watch ANYTHING live by Pink Floyd, watch the screen! They always paid as much attention to detail in their shows, as they did on their albums, and we all know just how much detail that was.....
    I first heard Pink Floyd when I was in high school, in 1975. Have seen them twice, unfortunately never with Roger Waters (but they were still amazing shows, check out Pulse videos.) and have been listening to them ever since. Have also seen David GIlmour solo, as well as Roger Waters solo(With Clapton as guitarist!), three weeks apart!

  • @jamzales
    @jamzales 3 года назад +7

    For me The Wall is the greatest rock concept of all time. Roger Waters was the bass player. I remember local Seattle rock radio station KISW 99.9 broadcast the entire concert from LA back in 1980.

    • @dr.pendyke4887
      @dr.pendyke4887 3 года назад

      Although, Gilmour plays all the good fretless bass licks on this track and on other songs on The Wall. Listen to Young Lust, Gilmour plays some sick bass on that track too.

  • @Duci66
    @Duci66 3 года назад +2

    Def. Masterpieces

  • @j.lizbardo
    @j.lizbardo 3 года назад

    Colombian here, iand i just cant wait to see your reaction to quality. 😆😉
    I think they were the first to make a continous album in which one track ties smoothly onto the next, with no clear difference if you just the whole 45 minute record play all at once. I listened to this record in 1988 for the first time. Still my favorite band of all times and Im 45 in 2021.

  • @kato0828
    @kato0828 3 года назад +2

    Hey, I like seeing you guys now bigger in the screen instead of tucked up in a corner! Pink Floyd request: Shine On You Crazy Diamond - that song will take you away on a journey.

  • @rockytopted6337
    @rockytopted6337 3 года назад +3

    It's going to be fun times when you get to the Animals album. All songs on the album are extraordinary.

  • @guywillis1281
    @guywillis1281 3 года назад +5

    Jon Carin does a great job singing Waters' part on the pulse tour. So much talent on that stage

  • @TrevorSmith-wc1cz
    @TrevorSmith-wc1cz 3 года назад

    Really good guys. Lifelong PF fan at 49. And Dad you're right about the passion and hurt in his voice. That very point was brought to my attention long ago when I heard the Is There Anybody Out There live version (recordings from The Wall tour) of this song, which came out 15 yrs ago or so.

  • @jimmyperez3911
    @jimmyperez3911 3 года назад

    Great reaction to a great song yeah I listened to this song also all the time great Album keep on rockin guys 🤟

  • @uroktim
    @uroktim 3 года назад +3

    Good call. Congrats on reaching 2k subs.

  • @tonytune4342
    @tonytune4342 3 года назад

    To me ,the the most powerful line in the song , " Don't help them to bury the light ." Our problem is that there are too many out there who are trying to bury the light . The light of equal rights , equal justice and human dignity . If we stand united , we have a chance of stopping them. We must show them they are their own worst enemy.

  • @tammyphxaz
    @tammyphxaz 3 года назад

    God bless you two,,,i wish my dad loved me

  • @dougwill8850
    @dougwill8850 Год назад

    You sir are teaching your young song many life lessons and he'll be better for it.

  • @Tonyblack261
    @Tonyblack261 3 года назад

    This whole album has meant so much to me as a chronic clinical depression sufferer. The "Wall" was literally what I built in my mind to manage to separate my depression from the outside life. As in the story of the Wall album, you can only do that for a limited time and then the whole Wall crumbles. It really speaks to me.

  • @soniasurija8880
    @soniasurija8880 3 года назад +2

    Great feedback & good song choice, David’s solo with this track felt like his guitar was weeping, I’m sure everyone has a different experience.

  • @rochelleclough3895
    @rochelleclough3895 3 года назад +2

    Ah Hey You , like a mini Comfortably Numb another beaut reaction from you both ,off this album. Pink Floyd primarily began as artists who morphed into using sound to paint their pictures, unique in that regard,which may explain why they were great conceptually to derive albums that flow. Don't forget to check out the musical orgasm that was The Animals album, right up there with the others mentioned.

  • @kathyedleman633
    @kathyedleman633 3 года назад +6

    Don't forget about the album "Animals". :)

    • @Polecat54941
      @Polecat54941 3 года назад +1

      Forgot to mention their best album :)

  • @roca7108
    @roca7108 3 года назад +2

    Pink Floyd - One of these days

  • @cityhonors1
    @cityhonors1 3 года назад +1

    As a kid (JHS & HS) 😁 this Album was EVERYTHING! 🤔 Then again so was The Beatles, Who, Zep, Rush, Bowie, Queen..... Concept Albums for days yo! 😂🍿🐰

  • @grapeape1987
    @grapeape1987 3 года назад

    David Gilmour solos are AMAZING! I agree with someone that once said "David doesn't plug his guitar into an amp. He plugs it into his soul!". No one I've heard can make a guitar sing like David!

  • @0gkmedia0
    @0gkmedia0 3 года назад +3

    You MUST watch the PULSE version of this song. And try as well the Animals album and The Finsl Cut album. Oh. And try some solo work of Roger Waters.... There is much more in PinkbFloyd than only Dark Side, WYWH and The Wall.

  • @joemaurone7923
    @joemaurone7923 3 года назад +2

    RE: concept albums: This certainly wasn't the first, but it might be the pinnacle of concept albums.
    Possibly the first concept album was S.F SORROW by The Pretty Things. Then there's TOMMY, by the Who, which is probably THE concept album that comes first to people's minds (along with THE WALL). And their album QUADROPHENIA, which predated THE WALL (I hear a lot of QUADROPHENIA in THE WALL, myself...)

  • @geraldherrmann787
    @geraldherrmann787 3 года назад +3

    you forgot their album ANIMALS which arguably is their best one.

  • @stevematthews641
    @stevematthews641 3 года назад +1

    Gilmoure guitar screams its lost agony,it bleeds.

  • @simonbellamy67
    @simonbellamy67 2 года назад

    Hey guys great reactions great honesty everytime I always check to what pink floyd y9u done lately and I love the Wall reactions but you missed my favorite. " Mother ". Amazing lyrics by bother Waters and Gilmour and listen out for my favorite DG solo in the middle. The live version has an extended solo. I well up every. Thankyou. Let me know what you think.

  • @paxomatic
    @paxomatic 3 года назад +2

    Good reaction gents. Nobody does it like Floyd.

  • @ssacra22
    @ssacra22 3 года назад +1

    David Gilmour is a damn wizard!

  • @donnelson6694
    @donnelson6694 3 года назад

    Perfect reaction!! A lot of depression, pain, despair and sadness on this album.

  • @lynnhoffman247
    @lynnhoffman247 3 года назад +3

    They split after “The Final Cut” not this album.
    Check out the live version of “Sorrow” from Pulse concert 🔥🎶🔥

    • @johntaylor8763
      @johntaylor8763 3 года назад

      No they didnt bud it was momentary lapse of reason album

    • @lynnhoffman247
      @lynnhoffman247 3 года назад

      @@johntaylor8763 Nope, Roger was gone by MLOR.

    • @johntaylor8763
      @johntaylor8763 3 года назад

      @@lynnhoffman247 I know I got it wrong.he left in 85.

    • @lynnhoffman247
      @lynnhoffman247 3 года назад

      @@johntaylor8763 👍🏼🤗✌🏼

  • @badatti2d
    @badatti2d 11 месяцев назад

    sorry I just found your channel..I'm a new subscriber, thanks to your Pink Floyd reactions. Watching your PF playlist now, in fact. Would love to see a reaction to Dogs Of War, at some time. Thanks for these

  • @mamaflush9945
    @mamaflush9945 3 года назад +1

    Hey Guys, I came across your channel in recommendations and listened to your reaction to Bob Dylan. I'm a big fan! and I'd like to recommend a couple of songs I think you will Really like these songs are somewhat political but I think they are current with the times. 1st song: "BOB DYLAN - THE TIMES THEY ARE A CHANGING" and the 2nd song "BOB DYLAN - MURDER MOST FOUL (Official Video)" I find it interesting to hear both of your reactions and listening to each one of your perspectives is refreshingly deferent. I am looking forward to seeing what you think of these songs. Thanks for sharing

  • @cityhonors1
    @cityhonors1 3 года назад +2

    🙋🏿‍♀️ May I suggest 🐕🐩 'Dogs' from PF Animals Album. 🍿🐰

  • @EPhotoAlbum
    @EPhotoAlbum 3 года назад +1

    Great reaction!

  • @michaelterry3885
    @michaelterry3885 3 года назад +1

    Hey guys , glad ya back I been waiting..!!😂😂
    Love the Floyd reactions keep"em coming.....
    Would you please check out a band called
    BLACKFOOT....?
    #1 Train Train....
    #2 The Highway Song...
    Thanks again fellas...
    You're Brilliant...keep shining..!!🤙

  • @robertwatson496
    @robertwatson496 3 года назад +1

    The Who did a couple of concept albums as well, Tommy and Quadrophenia.

  • @harlanginsberg7269
    @harlanginsberg7269 3 года назад +1

    Concept albums. The Who Tommy The Who Quadrophenia The Kinks Arthur The Moody Blues Days of Future Passed. The Beatles Sgt.Peppers kind of The Kinks Lola vs Powerman and The Money Go Round Jethro Tull Aqualung and probably many more. The Kinks had 3 lesser known ones also

  • @gregrambo606
    @gregrambo606 3 года назад

    This album from '79 sold 22,000,000. Waters wrote most of their great stuff after he tossed Syd Barrett out of the band in '68. That's Waters on the second lead with the high pitched voice, Dave Gilmour on the first lead vocals.

  • @gerryweed7697
    @gerryweed7697 3 года назад +2

    next one from Pink Floyd - Coming back to life ( live Pulse 1994 ) or Marooned ( no lyrics . they win a Grammys for Marooned ) 😎👍✨🎶🙋‍♂️

  • @joemaurone7923
    @joemaurone7923 3 года назад +1

    Ah, if you think the album must be incredible, the movie would BLOW. YOUR. MIND.

  • @jamzales
    @jamzales 3 года назад +1

    The worms ate into his brain. Listen to the whole album start to finish then watch the movie.

    • @bentindle9036
      @bentindle9036 3 года назад

      The movie is awful. Waters hated the way it came out. And Bob Geldof, played Pink in the movie, hated Pink Floyd music.

  • @paxomatic
    @paxomatic 3 года назад +2

    I think the album version is the best Floyd version of this song. I don't think they really did it live much.

  • @Samsanite1
    @Samsanite1 3 года назад +1

    Definitely recommend Time by Pink Floyd or just the whole Dark Side of the Moon album

  • @lotfilotfi7912
    @lotfilotfi7912 3 года назад +1

    Try “Sorrow” from Pulse concert

  • @VampeyMK
    @VampeyMK 3 года назад

    Many people consider "Animals" to be their best album. So don't sleep on that! :D

  • @randywade6757
    @randywade6757 2 года назад +1

    Please do LET THERE BE ROCK LIVE AT THE RIVER PLATE AC/DC

  • @donrobbie1461
    @donrobbie1461 3 года назад

    Pulse was the name of the tour

  • @timmyr345
    @timmyr345 2 года назад

    The Final Cut is the follow up to The Wall and flows similarly. (Roger Waters is still with them in The Final Cut)

  • @nancypilcher5948
    @nancypilcher5948 Год назад

    Agree with you

  • @JohnSmith-mz9hj
    @JohnSmith-mz9hj 3 года назад

    SHINE ON YOU CRAZY DIAMOND, TIME, ,MONEY. BREATHE, BRAIN DAMAGE, EMPTY SPACES/YOUNG LUST (both songs go together), MOTHER, or HIGH HOPES!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @thepragmatic6383
    @thepragmatic6383 3 года назад

    Quote from Roger Waters: "Hey You is a cry to the rest of the world, you know saying hey, this isn't right; So, at the end of Hey You he makes this cry for help, but it's too late ... he's only singing it to himself, you know, it's no good crying for help if you're sitting in the room all on your own, and only saying it to yourself ".

  • @richardrobinson8459
    @richardrobinson8459 3 года назад

    Time to start Dark Side of the Moon from the beginning

  • @chubbychuckle
    @chubbychuckle 3 года назад +1

    Hey guys, i just watched all the Kanye reactions and was wondering if you guys could check out some Kendrick Lamar? He's got some great songs with amazing beats. I'd suggest Maad City, These Walls, Alright, Duckworth or The Art of Peer Pressure.

  • @jareczek1980
    @jareczek1980 3 года назад

    Pink Floyd had 3 famous albums???? Really??? What about Animals, Division Bell, A momentary..., Meddle, Atom Heart Mother, Final Cut. That is level Pink Floyd. Beyond galaxy. There are few groups that reach the stars, but they left galaxy.

  • @richardrobinson8459
    @richardrobinson8459 3 года назад +1

    Watch the movie The Wall by Floyd

  • @GoldwingGary1
    @GoldwingGary1 3 года назад +1

    Watch the movie- THE WALL!

  • @GoldwingGary1
    @GoldwingGary1 3 года назад +1

    ...and the worms ate into his brain!

  • @coversbyshubham2556
    @coversbyshubham2556 3 года назад

    hey guys, react to high hopes by pink flyod! u can do the pulse version

  • @195511SM
    @195511SM 3 года назад

    It's a crime, that you don't sit down & experience this album ......from start to finish.....in its entirety. Not for those of us, who've done it a hundred times already......but for YOU. Listening to it, one track at a time & out of sequence......your missing out on all the subtle nuances & transitions. You're not getting the whole story. The same thing applies to 'Dark Side of the Moon'.....and 'Wish You Were Here'. It'll still sound good, but when you FULLY understand it.....

  • @AndreDavila
    @AndreDavila 3 года назад

    Dude... The Wall is a Double Album

  • @1969JohnnyM
    @1969JohnnyM 3 года назад

    Roger Waters was such a great song writer and his lyrics are amazing. Gilmour is a great guitarist and has the better voice but the creative force of the band post Barrett was definitely Waters.

  • @daftoptmst
    @daftoptmst 2 года назад +1

    Roger Waters I heard left the band thinking he could do better on his own. Have you heard anything from Roger? Lol He did make a couple of albums but I don't think they did well. I think he took all the songs he'd written and they could no longer play them in concert (Allegedly)
    The band hated him after that especially David. The band said they'd speak to him when pigs fly.
    In one of their videos, they have a pig balloon flying high! Lol!
    After many yrs later, they did do a couple of concerts together and performed all their old songs.
    David joined the band when Syd Barrett who suffered a mental breakdown and became an addict left or was kicked out.. Syd was the one of the original band members. I think he started the group. Either Roger or Syd.
    Their early albums had a totally different vibe and to me weird. I don't like them but that's just me lol.
    Get the box set. They have ALL the albums, even from the beginning.

  • @atomicat
    @atomicat 3 года назад

    But it was only fantasy, the wall was too high as you can see.

  • @heliotropezzz333
    @heliotropezzz333 3 года назад

    I wish people would not pronounce the word riff as if it had a t at the end of the word. What's that all about? A rift is a break not a musical phrase.

    • @jimcarlson6157
      @jimcarlson6157 3 года назад

      like the errant second "n" in pundit

  • @kljindiana5551
    @kljindiana5551 3 года назад +1

    Check out Sorrow from the Pulse show, you won't be. Disappointed

  • @Newfie-zc7ug
    @Newfie-zc7ug 3 года назад

    spoken of course from a guy who has never seen them live but I disagree 100 %. Their studio albums are far better. And I have heard all the LIVE stuff ! SORRY.