There is a huge irony in not having captions on this video, given the fact this is specifically a film about being Deaf/HoH and even within it you show that there are people who did not have ASL until much later in their lives -- meaning you are already aware that this is inaccessible to anyone who cannot hear the spoken words and who cannot read the sign language of the people featured. Please fix that. Autogenerated captions are insufficient.
I took 2 semesters of ASL and was lucky enough to have a Deaf roommate. Since then I haven’t been able to practice and need a refresher, and maybe get involved with the Deaf community here.
Why is a news organization like NBC News relying on auto captions for this video? It should be open captioned, first, but if not that, at least add ACCURATE captions.
Deaf is culture and sign language is beautiful. Hearing must to learn sign language. It is very important. Hearing must respect the deaf and sign language. God possible to makes human the deaf that God responsible own the deaf and everything but man and woman never make deaf and everything. Sign language forever .
Hello, no it's not offensive. I know hearing students who attend Gallaudet University. They get their degree and they learn to sign. They have no choice but to learn to sign because they are fully immersed
No, it isn't if you're very motivated in learning ASL and are truly willing to spend at least a majority of your life working with the deaf. Many hearing people had gone to Gallaudet University and received degrees in interpretation on the undergraduate/graduate certificate program level, and social work, psychology, and deaf education on the graduate level.
@@rp6635 Learning ASL would be like taking Spanish or French - or any other foreign language. A few things do set ASL apart from these other foreign languages. If you're interested in taking a beginning ASL course, you could enroll at a nearby college that offers ASL or take an online ASL class. I have a friend who teaches ASL online - her online classes meet on Zoom. Or just download an ASL app as an app will have videos that shows you how to sign words. And....seek out deaf people in your community. It's best to immerse yourself in their language if you do that. Check for deaf social events in your community and go there.
It's honestly disgraceful that the station couldn't be bothered to put accurate captions on this video.
This caption is accurate.
It will work the caption if you click "CC."
I still can’t believe that ASL is not taught in mainstream schools as a language option.
please share this with your location city hall.
My old HS is finally offering it. for 4 years! Taught be a qualified and certified teacher of ASL, plus she's Deaf!
Now it is, my highschool offers it as a virtual foreign language and Im currently taking it!😁
@@ri.gxing.crzy0 Fantastic, hope you become fluent
There is a huge irony in not having captions on this video, given the fact this is specifically a film about being Deaf/HoH and even within it you show that there are people who did not have ASL until much later in their lives -- meaning you are already aware that this is inaccessible to anyone who cannot hear the spoken words and who cannot read the sign language of the people featured. Please fix that. Autogenerated captions are insufficient.
I do agree, but at least there's auto-generated captions, but they should have thought ahead about this!
I'm hard of hearing and don't know sign language. The captions were fine.
I took 2 semesters of ASL and was lucky enough to have a Deaf roommate. Since then I haven’t been able to practice and need a refresher, and maybe get involved with the Deaf community here.
Watch qualified teachers and look into Deaf Moth (Deaf news in ASL).. look for brief stories in ASL to brush up.
Why is a news organization like NBC News relying on auto captions for this video? It should be open captioned, first, but if not that, at least add ACCURATE captions.
Put accurate, human-written captions on this video, please. It's literally a documentary about being Deaf.
Umm you definitely aren’t deaf..
They are signing..
Wonderful
Beautiful video!
Deaf is culture and sign language is beautiful. Hearing must to learn sign language. It is very important. Hearing must respect the deaf and sign language. God possible to makes human the deaf that God responsible own the deaf and everything but man and woman never make deaf and everything. Sign language forever .
Deaf people are wonderful.
Congratulations on her saying deaf hello to my daughter
Why can’t some teacher know sign language?
And some students too
Good ask deaf
❤
The caption is there, if you took the time to click on the CC you would have seen it
Hi friend I'm hearing impaired boy 👦
Hi
@@lookingup82 hello 🙏
Will it be offensive to go to DSL College to learn sign language even if you speak?
Isnt like learning a new language?
You need to get motive to learn ASL.
Hello, no it's not offensive. I know hearing students who attend Gallaudet University. They get their degree and they learn to sign. They have no choice but to learn to sign because they are fully immersed
No, it isn't if you're very motivated in learning ASL and are truly willing to spend at least a majority of your life working with the deaf. Many hearing people had gone to Gallaudet University and received degrees in interpretation on the undergraduate/graduate certificate program level, and social work, psychology, and deaf education on the graduate level.
@@rp6635 Learning ASL would be like taking Spanish or French - or any other foreign language. A few things do set ASL apart from these other foreign languages. If you're interested in taking a beginning ASL course, you could enroll at a nearby college that offers ASL or take an online ASL class. I have a friend who teaches ASL online - her online classes meet on Zoom. Or just download an ASL app as an app will have videos that shows you how to sign words. And....seek out deaf people in your community. It's best to immerse yourself in their language if you do that. Check for deaf social events in your community and go there.
Yoyoyoyo