Considering its initial cost was $11.5b, then $16.5b and now $26.5b, I think we can say the answer is no!! Especially considering there is no train to the airport or cross city train. Both are planned but not started, in case of the airport train link, it has been announced so many times that it is starting nobody believes it will ever happen.
Did you actually show footage of Heidelberg in Germany for a project in Australia? Who the hell does your research? Also please learn how to pronounce some very simple words. I understand some might be difficult but McLeod and the Yarra River are not.
So many pronunciation errors. Suburb names, OUR RIVER, OUR CITY, the population, photos from overseas, such as Heidelberg in Germany and the Eastern Freeway showed Russian footage! And I was pleased to learn that our largest city in Australia only has 1 million... where did the other 4 million go?
It did state it was the northern part of Melbourne with a population of one million, not the entirety of the city. The 4.5 million was mentioned earlier in the crap, I mean clip.
With the current cost of communications so low, I fiend it remarkable that the author did not consider picking up the phone from anywhere in the world and calling just about any local number in Melbourne and simply ask what is the local pronunciation of placenames. The narrator has mangled many (most in fact) of them as to be barely recognisable. This has transformed what would otherwise be quite an informative 10 minutes into a pain.
Not only did you mispronounce ever name incorrectly, but you also showed the suburbs of Watson and Bulleen the wrong way round! I suspect you are trying to copy another well-known construction channel, but with little research and analysis.
"4:23 these tbms each powered by11,420 horsepower engines equipped equivalent to the power of 47 cars will".......Those are some very stout cars if 47 equal 11,420 HP. Thats about 250 hp each.🤔
Next time get an Aussie to read the text out - The pronunciation of the wording is so inaccurate it's so funny no one can take this video seriously lol
i think you got your map wrong .... its from Bulleen to Watsonia :) need to switch them. Its also Yara (phonetically) as one word not YarRa (two syllables). MacLoyd is Maccloud. Its no actually help the transport hubs its just shuffling traffic elsewhere - people in the east cant get to the ring road easily, hence this tunnel, but like all our freeways, they barely have enough lanes now so if you double the population all these roads become parking bays like the south-eastern freeway is now. Too little too late.
This was a pretty good video, but it was spoiled a bit by all the errors and mispronunciations of place names that distracted from the main messages. Perhaps a bit more research prior to creating the video would have helped. Melbourne is pronounced "Melbn". Watsonia is north of Bulleen. The map is wrong. "Melborians"? Is this a joke invented by Sydneysiders? We are Melburnians. Yarra is pronounced with a short a. I kept think I was listening to Lady Gaga singing Bad Romance every time Yarra was mentioned (so many times!). Darebin is pronounced "Darabin". The politicians you showed were prime ministers of Australia (Gough Whitlam and Scott Morrison). Road planning is primarily a state responsibility (although federal funds often are contributed as well). The picture of Heidelberg is of Heidelberg, Germany. Heidelberg, Melbourne looks a bit less historic than this. Macleod is pronounced "Mcloud". Our Doncaster, unlike the one in northern England, is pronounced with a long a. "Fright operators"? Do they only operate on Halloween? "Camperfield"? Is this meant to be Cambellfield? "Reduce the resilience on busy roads"? Is this supposed to be reliance? "Fitzmons Lane"? There is an i. There is no runway 10 at Melbourne Airport. They are 16/34 and 09/27.
Cmon mate, put in the effort. So many errors in this video, it just destroys any kind of credibility your channel may have. I'm not mad, just disappointed.
Is it just me, or does $26 billion sound like a lot of money to spend on getting from Point A to Point B a little faster? Maybe I should just invest in roller skates.😁😆😅
This project should be referred-to or titled “Debt Personified”, the punt of debt this project ha racked-up equals the combined debt of NSW, Queensland & Tasmania, which also earns the other 6 states & territories are paying the deb because it’s pat of the national debt, thanks Labor Victoria. It’s also why Victoria had to relinquish the Commonwealth Games, & that cost money to dispose of as well ((in financial penalties;.. well done.
Dreadful pronunciation of place names, f for ‘fousand’ (1000), visuals of the interior of a left-hand-drive car (1:00) and scenes from Heidelberg, Germany (5:25) and a clogged freeway (4:00) somewhere in Russia (judging by the signage) where cars drive on the right. At least find out how to say Melbourne and Yarra!
Rather a shame that there doesn't seem to have been any forethought to the provision of priority lanes to EVs of all classes of vehicles including heavy duty trucks in order to drive EV adoption and improve local air quality, reducing hospital & GP attendance.
Yes, we are just a backwater, full of convicts Britain exported over 200 years ago, we're not capable of anything, we need foreign companies to do everything for us you know. Have you ever been here?
this new route comes from a past era... 20 lanes of traffic!!!! This project will boost connectivity across the city, but divide countless communities at the same time.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
A hugely expensive project, is it worth the cost?
Considering its initial cost was $11.5b, then $16.5b and now $26.5b, I think we can say the answer is no!! Especially considering there is no train to the airport or cross city train. Both are planned but not started, in case of the airport train link, it has been announced so many times that it is starting nobody believes it will ever happen.
Nope!
@@DavidJones-pi8rl It won't!
Not worth except the ring road and bus way. There better adding more freight rail and public transit lines into the city.
@@maroon9273 Metro rail tunnel a bottomless pit as well!
Did you actually show footage of Heidelberg in Germany for a project in Australia? Who the hell does your research? Also please learn how to pronounce some very simple words. I understand some might be difficult but McLeod and the Yarra River are not.
Prob AI generated crap!
That picture of Heidelberg made my day LOLs
@@robvegas9354 Das was ze WRONG 'Heidelberg' ja?
How can you get this so wrong haha
@@peterscott6977 Bots are DUMB mate!
LOL. He mentioned Heidelberg, Melbourne and shows Heidelberg in Germary.
The local Aussie comments have summed it perfectly
The tunnels go under the 'ya' 'ra' river and even under Heidelberg in Germany judging by the photo shown - no wonder the project costs so much.
by the way its not yar yar river is yarra (yarrra) river
or "ya"-"rar
are you a mel-bore-ians
Had to stop watching the video because of this!😮
the pronunciation of so many names had me in hysterics. I'm call the Yarra the Rar Rar River from now on :D Macloyd for McLeod?
her yar. lol
Melboorians. Versus what we say, which is Melburnians.
And the Yah Rah river.
So many pronunciation errors. Suburb names, OUR RIVER, OUR CITY, the population, photos from overseas, such as Heidelberg in Germany and the Eastern Freeway showed Russian footage!
And I was pleased to learn that our largest city in Australia only has 1 million... where did the other 4 million go?
“Melborians” 😂😂😂
G’day from a Sydnian! 😉😂
It did state it was the northern part of Melbourne with a population of one million, not the entirety of the city. The 4.5 million was mentioned earlier in the crap, I mean clip.
Sounds like an AI generated narration...
With the current cost of communications so low, I fiend it remarkable that the author did not consider picking up the phone from anywhere in the world and calling just about any local number in Melbourne and simply ask what is the local pronunciation of placenames. The narrator has mangled many (most in fact) of them as to be barely recognisable. This has transformed what would otherwise be quite an informative 10 minutes into a pain.
butchered this video
Started by pronouncing Melbourne wrong, and it went downhill from there.
Now Australia's biggest city......in excess of 5 million. Officially.
Not only did you mispronounce ever name incorrectly, but you also showed the suburbs of Watson and Bulleen the wrong way round! I suspect you are trying to copy another well-known construction channel, but with little research and analysis.
Where's the suburb of Watson?
@@rickstaism Watsonia is at north end and Bulleen at south end.
@@threestumps7560 Yes but I was asking where Watson was. Perhaps the poster should check their own spelling before criticising others.
"4:23 these tbms each powered by11,420 horsepower engines equipped
equivalent to the power of 47 cars will".......Those are some very stout cars if
47 equal 11,420 HP. Thats about 250 hp each.🤔
Next time get an Aussie to read the text out - The pronunciation of the wording is so inaccurate it's so funny no one can take this video seriously lol
Well said !!!
I lost all interest on the story because of laughing at the pronunciation, should have got a Melborian to read it.....
AI videos not quite hitting the mark here 🤣
JUST ONE MORE LANE BRO JUST ONE MORE LANE I PROMISE THIS ONE WILL FIX TRAFFIC
i think you got your map wrong .... its from Bulleen to Watsonia :) need to switch them. Its also Yara (phonetically) as one word not YarRa (two syllables). MacLoyd is Maccloud. Its no actually help the transport hubs its just shuffling traffic elsewhere - people in the east cant get to the ring road easily, hence this tunnel, but like all our freeways, they barely have enough lanes now so if you double the population all these roads become parking bays like the south-eastern freeway is now. Too little too late.
Did you mean too little too late?
This was a pretty good video, but it was spoiled a bit by all the errors and mispronunciations of place names that distracted from the main messages. Perhaps a bit more research prior to creating the video would have helped. Melbourne is pronounced "Melbn". Watsonia is north of Bulleen. The map is wrong. "Melborians"? Is this a joke invented by Sydneysiders? We are Melburnians. Yarra is pronounced with a short a. I kept think I was listening to Lady Gaga singing Bad Romance every time Yarra was mentioned (so many times!). Darebin is pronounced "Darabin". The politicians you showed were prime ministers of Australia (Gough Whitlam and Scott Morrison). Road planning is primarily a state responsibility (although federal funds often are contributed as well). The picture of Heidelberg is of Heidelberg, Germany. Heidelberg, Melbourne looks a bit less historic than this. Macleod is pronounced "Mcloud". Our Doncaster, unlike the one in northern England, is pronounced with a long a. "Fright operators"? Do they only operate on Halloween? "Camperfield"? Is this meant to be Cambellfield? "Reduce the resilience on busy roads"? Is this supposed to be reliance? "Fitzmons Lane"? There is an i. There is no runway 10 at Melbourne Airport. They are 16/34 and 09/27.
So you showed an image of the actual Heidelberg?! This video is almost as insane as the project it tries to present.
What do the tbms use for power, diesel or electric?
Electric
Cmon mate, put in the effort. So many errors in this video, it just destroys any kind of credibility your channel may have. I'm not mad, just disappointed.
AI narration?
Not the yah rah river 😂
@.40 you have watsonia and bullen thre wrong way around
Do we have to thank Ai for the Yarra River becoming the Yar Ra River ?
Keep the ring road, busway and replace the other highway with transit/rail freight lines into the city.
Pretty sure you got Watsona and Bulleen the wrong way around lol😂
Buses suck bring back trains to Doncaster with a metro 2.
why is the under rivrt tunnel so avusurdly deep.
Is it just me, or does $26 billion sound like a lot of money to spend on getting from Point A to Point B a little faster? Maybe I should just invest in roller skates.😁😆😅
This project should be referred-to or titled “Debt Personified”, the punt of debt this project ha racked-up equals the combined debt of NSW, Queensland & Tasmania, which also earns the other 6 states & territories are paying the deb because it’s pat of the national debt, thanks Labor Victoria. It’s also why Victoria had to relinquish the Commonwealth Games, & that cost money to dispose of as well ((in financial penalties;.. well done.
😂 Watsonia and Bulleen are labelled the wrong way round. Yar Yar? More like nar nar you got it wrong mate. Also pronounced Mel-bin.
yaa raa river.. bull lean... cant watch this listening to that
The Rah rah river?
Dreadful pronunciation of place names, f for ‘fousand’ (1000), visuals of the interior of a left-hand-drive car (1:00) and scenes from Heidelberg, Germany (5:25) and a clogged freeway (4:00) somewhere in Russia (judging by the signage) where cars drive on the right. At least find out how to say Melbourne and Yarra!
Rather a shame that there doesn't seem to have been any forethought to the provision of priority lanes to EVs of all classes of vehicles including heavy duty trucks in order to drive EV adoption and improve local air quality, reducing hospital & GP attendance.
😂....go on....🤣
@@micphoenix8200 ???? 🤷♀️🤷♀️
$26B WHITE elephant!
Why don't you get someone that has at least bean to Melbourne to narrate this.
watsonia and bulleen are in the wrong place to fix it just swich them
It’s not a rail link.
5:24 that's... Not in Melbourne.
I DIDNT KNOW THAT AUSTRALIA HAD THIS TYPE OF CAPABILITY OR IS IT FOREIGN COMPANIES DOING THE ENGINEERING.
Yes, we are just a backwater, full of convicts Britain exported over 200 years ago, we're not capable of anything, we need foreign companies to do everything for us you know.
Have you ever been here?
Cheap AI voice that can’t pronounce place names. The pronunciation of Melbourne was insulting
Melborians? Yaryar river? Bruh take like an extra 10 minutes next time to read over your script and get it right. This is such a shoddy effort.
this new route comes from a past era... 20 lanes of traffic!!!! This project will boost connectivity across the city, but divide countless communities at the same time.
MELBORIANS????
YAH RA????
You need to ask a MelBOURNian how to pronounce any of our names. This video has me go from forgiving to cringing to being insulted.
Apologies to German views for the images of your Heidelberg not Melbourne's
Who cares how things are pronounced.
Try not to let it ruin your day
Good Luck... Bulleen floods and you're digging underneath a swamp. Who plans this??
Yar ra river what a joke
😂
This may be the worst video ever. Minimum a dozen bad geographical mistakes.
Painful. Two things, this will not be finished by 2028. The Eastern Fwy running west runs into what exactly? Well done Labor. 🇦🇺👎🍺
I have never heard of the Ya ra river. Definitely won’t subscribe to this channel.