Dune Part Two Trailer Breakdown\Analysis

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 июн 2024
  • IT'S FINALLY HERE! After a wait that felt like forever, I will finally be breaking down the Dune Part 2 Trailer! Please hit the like button to help the channel out! :)
    Quinn's Discord: / discord
    FOLLOW QUINN ON TWITTER: Twitter: / ideasofice_fire
    Quinn's New Graphic Novel: www.quinnhoward.net/theliebeh...
    Three-Body Playlist: • Three Body Problem
    H.P. Lovecraft Playlist: • LOVECRAFT
    Hyperion Playlist: • Hyperion
    Dune Playlist: • Dune Lore Explained
    Foundation Playlist: • Isaac Asimov
    Buy Quinn's Comic Books: www.quinnhoward.net/shop
    Quinn's Website: www.quinnhoward.net
    Thanks for watching!
    Please consider supporting this channel on Patreon: / ideasoficeandfire
    or PAYPAL - paypal.me/QuinnsIdeas?locale....
    I NOW HAVE A SUBREDDIT: / ideasoficeandfire
    Twitter: / ideasofice_fire
    Like me on Facebook!: / ioiaf
    Feel free to leave a comment like and subscribe!
    Thanks For Watching!
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 1,1 тыс.

  • @QuinnsIdeas
    @QuinnsIdeas  Год назад +311

    Thanks for watching guys! The audio glitch at 1:31 will be fixed as soon as RUclips finishes processing! Sorry about the jump scare! (Update) The audio glitch should be cut out. To clarify, I said "Thousands of years". I'm working on finding a way to prevent this issue from happening in the future. It seems to be a problem with the audio settings when rending the video!
    Thanks, guys
    - Quinn

    • @zackfritz9491
      @zackfritz9491 Год назад +5

      lol Thank you for eventually fixing that Quinn. It scared the crap out of me.

    • @catcrue9656
      @catcrue9656 Год назад +2

      Totally worth it. Great review ❤

    • @610vegas
      @610vegas Год назад +2

      Worked out which one is Paul or Jessica yet Quinn? Only joking my man.

    • @c.t.651
      @c.t.651 Год назад +3

      Hype! Ty

    • @happyninja42
      @happyninja42 Год назад +7

      One of the things I find interesting about the sandworm scene, is to try and imagine it from the onlookers point of view. From what I can tell, given the editing, Paul basically runs into the sandfall of the passage of the worm, and is swallowed by the dunes, vanishing from sight. That he's literally under the surface of the desert, basically in a pocket of displaced air/sand from the passing of the worm. So then he plants his hooks, and then rises up. So, from the viewpoint of the Fremen watching, and given their religious lens, it would seem as if Paul was either swallowed by the desert, or dove into it (a more likely interpretation, given they established the idea of swimming in the opening scene with Chani), and the he swam through the desert like Shai-Hulud himself. Only to rise up from the depths of the sands, born upon the back of Old Man of the Desert! It feels very much the kind of interpretation of the events, from a mythmaking standpoint. And the kind of thing that would propel Paul into the status of legend in their culture.

  • @AscendantStoic
    @AscendantStoic Год назад +1797

    Hope Denis gets to make Dune:Messiah to complete the trilogy ... Paul's story isn't really complete without it.

    • @Bionickpunk
      @Bionickpunk Год назад +124

      All the Hebert books adapted by Denis pls.

    • @haukikannel
      @haukikannel Год назад +70

      Yeah… But I was more worried about Dune part2…we get this so I am happy!
      The idea seems that Messiah would be made, much much later to give actors time to become older. And this trailer agains seems so good, that I am really hopefull for Messiah to get green light maybe 5 in 6 years in the future.
      Much more hopefull than I was about part two. In 6 years, the Dune will become a cult hit! And that makes it easier to make Messiah eventually!

    • @seriousbismuth2173
      @seriousbismuth2173 Год назад +124

      I hope it at least makes it to God Emporor. That's gonna be weird..

    • @GangstarComputerGod
      @GangstarComputerGod Год назад +76

      @@seriousbismuth2173 that would be wild as hell and I’m here for the giant man-worm

    • @merrittanimation7721
      @merrittanimation7721 Год назад +49

      @@seriousbismuth2173 Imagine if they made it to Heretics and Chapterhouse. They'd have to tone down the Honored Matres to get a PG-13 rating.

  • @dball_94
    @dball_94 Год назад +428

    Jessica looks incredible in that "We gave them something to hope for" scene

    • @medielijah
      @medielijah Год назад +31

      Jessica looks incredible in every frame. She is a gem and I love her portrayal. ❤

    • @dangerfly
      @dangerfly Год назад

      Does anyone else think her facial tattoos look kinda lame? They're not done creatively. It just looks like text randomly drawn on and ruin her nice features. Bleh.

    • @meesalikeu
      @meesalikeu Год назад +11

      @@medielijah yeah but lets hope she is more of a badazz this time like in the book and not timid like in part one.

    • @fabrisseterbrugghe8567
      @fabrisseterbrugghe8567 Год назад +6

      I hated the way they made Jessica a wimp in Part 1. Francesca Annis was a tiny thing, but she had a backbone of steel.

    • @benjalucian1515
      @benjalucian1515 Год назад +4

      @@fabrisseterbrugghe8567 Loved Francesca's portrayal of Lady Jessica. She looked scary and dangerous and in control.

  • @mattbaldwin1150
    @mattbaldwin1150 Год назад +352

    What I love about Denis Villeneuve’s movies is their layers and rewatch-ability. He’s the perfect director for the Dune universe. Much like Peter Jackson was for LOTR.

    • @manoz6194
      @manoz6194 Год назад +13

      The pacing of the first movie was outstanding, re-watching it is a treat!

    • @williamhosford2796
      @williamhosford2796 Год назад +12

      Dude! I saw Dune when it came out at the movies and since watched 3-4 times online. Superior novel adaptation. It just never gets old,like a modern equivalent of Shakespear.

    • @paulgallagher8582
      @paulgallagher8582 Год назад +6

      Agreed, I love all the "show, don't tell" scenes

    • @zaprese
      @zaprese Год назад +3

      Yes but the layering was from the book.

    • @0vermars520
      @0vermars520 Год назад +2

      Or even Uwe Boll's In The Name of The King

  • @sebastianrook5478
    @sebastianrook5478 Год назад +56

    Quinn saying "I'm a giant Dune fan." Is the understatement of the decade.
    When it comes to Dune you are and always will be the go to.
    Keep doing what you do brother!

  • @kevinren3228
    @kevinren3228 Год назад +79

    I also noticed that there's no signs of Paul's sister Alia. Not in the trailer, not in the cast members. She played a really important role in book and I think it was intentionally hidden to be revealed with a big surprise in the film. Can't wait!

    • @nemessisx7627
      @nemessisx7627 Год назад +2

      I really hope so, she is VERY important

    • @chance1774
      @chance1774 Год назад +2

      there’s no way she won’t be in part 2, she’s in part 1

    • @noobovsky420
      @noobovsky420 11 месяцев назад

      She’s there. They just hide a bunch of stuff from us I hope. They left a lot of lore out of part 1

    • @noobovsky420
      @noobovsky420 11 месяцев назад

      @@chance1774no she’s not lol. She’s a fetus lol

    • @chance1774
      @chance1774 11 месяцев назад

      @@noobovsky420 so the smiling (maybe 6 month old) blue within blue eyed child jessica’s holding in paul’s vision is a fetus? i don’t think so. check out the scene after the spice harvester attack again.

  • @EerieV23
    @EerieV23 Год назад +81

    Alia is so central to the next 2 books. She is one of the many tragic characters of Dune.

    • @neutral_10
      @neutral_10 Год назад +22

      The most tragic imo

    • @CaffeineAndMylanta
      @CaffeineAndMylanta Год назад +2

      Agreed. What happens to her in Children of Dune really upset me.

  • @abdul9170
    @abdul9170 Год назад +74

    Love the use of afghan jewellery for lady Jessica. Since the style of the jewellery was inspired by female warriors it really fits in with the idea that the Fremen women and children could fend off the sardaukar soldiers.

    • @MohamedRamadan-qi4hl
      @MohamedRamadan-qi4hl Год назад +3

      Jewelry isn't armor. And it's painfully unrealistic that women and children would be able to do that

    • @abdul9170
      @abdul9170 Год назад +5

      @@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl ik jewellery isnt armour….

    • @SightForMemories
      @SightForMemories Год назад

      @@MohamedRamadan-qi4hl I think what Abdul is saying is that the fremen women and children are born fighters. and they will do what they can to win.

  • @c.w.simpsonproductions1230
    @c.w.simpsonproductions1230 Год назад +311

    Man, can’t wait to see this in IMAX. I saw Part 1 before reading the books, but since then I’ve read the books and binged all your Dune vids. You’ve made me a Dune fanatic!

    • @Henbot
      @Henbot Год назад +7

      David Lynch film blew my mind and then devoured Dune after that. My first experience with Dune was actually the video games (strategy ones)

    • @davezdude3200
      @davezdude3200 Год назад +10

      I've heard that Part 2 was shot in 100% IMAX as compared to Part 1's 40%. Should be terrific in IMAX, particularly with the higher quality sound systems in those theatres. But I'll probably also go see it on a normal screen, 'cause you know many of us won't be satisfied with just one viewing in a theatre...

    • @barvelo26
      @barvelo26 Год назад +1

      Bro same!

    • @elisapiettra
      @elisapiettra Год назад +1

      Same!!!

    • @williamhosford2796
      @williamhosford2796 Год назад +1

      Haha...you are now officially hooked,CW. Welcome to a fellow Dunehead.

  • @binkymagnus
    @binkymagnus Год назад +28

    i love how Villeneuve hides things behind layers. like with Jessica in the litter, Irulan behind her veil. or in the first movie, the people on Arrakis standing behind the fence, or Paul within the tree as the seeker comes after him.

  • @Rangilify
    @Rangilify Год назад +372

    Quinn I honestly want to thank you for getting in Three Body problem and Dune Book series. I have always loved reading but after finishing Asoiaf i kind of fell off it. But an year or so ago i got introduced to TBP series by you and i knew i had to read it. Then you got me in to Dune and now i am at COD. Thank you for reviving the Book reader in me. Thank you Quinn.❤

    • @abhinavav7770
      @abhinavav7770 Год назад +2

      After three body problem trilogy , I will start children of men

    • @lukez990
      @lukez990 Год назад +2

      Same here. Came here after watching Dune, then got into 3BP and the Tencent series

    • @kushalrijal9453
      @kushalrijal9453 Год назад

      @@lukez990 that Chinese show was incredibly bloated. 30 episodes were just too much.

    • @ein-ra-shah
      @ein-ra-shah Год назад

      @Rangil you got to actually finish Asoiaf??? Lol you've got the greensight.

    • @brendasmith1477
      @brendasmith1477 Год назад

      This is why I love that we have Quinn on the job. Thank you Quinn.

  • @Zeppex
    @Zeppex Год назад +100

    Best part is stilgar realizing Paul is him

  • @sharronlee5842
    @sharronlee5842 Год назад +26

    My grandma got me into Dune when I was 8 by showing me the David Lynch version. As silly as it sounds, I think the campiness made the movie more accessible to me as a kid. I sat through it all in one go, mesmerized. Getting into the books and having these adaptations as an adult makes it feel like the story grows and evolves alongside me as I comprehend more, which is really comforting. I just introduced my partner to Dune and seeing his face light up makes me wonder if my grandma was feeling the same way I was in that moment when she shared Dune with me.

  • @Zlarel
    @Zlarel Год назад +72

    My guess is Paul won't have blue-in-blue eyes for much of the film while Jessica will because she endured the spice agony. He'll probably have normal eyes throughout the film up until his own spice agony; that shot of Paul awakening with blue eyes was probably going to be a big reveal.

    • @D1str1ct
      @D1str1ct Год назад +1

      What? He should have blue eyes for most of the film. Spice is in everything that they eat and drink as well as the ritual water that they all consume, not to mention its in the air they breathe as well. He should have blue eyes from after the ritual when so many years have past, that takes us to the beginning of Pauls war to take back the planet.

    • @Zlarel
      @Zlarel Год назад +9

      @@D1str1ct In the books, sure. The film might simply suggest he hasn't been exposed to enough for long enough to have developed blue eyes. It's a simple enough change - so long as it's not contradicted within the film - possibly to facilitate a big "awakening from the spice agony with blue eyes" reveal (which, if I'm correct in my guess, the studio saw fit to undermine for the sake of marketing, not a first for Denis' films)... as well as perhaps to cut costs a sliver as they won't have to color his eyes for the whole movie.

    • @D1str1ct
      @D1str1ct Год назад

      @@Zlarel Or they will follow the book? They will have the ritual and everything with that, then they will jump over to the Harkonnen and go through their story line and when it comes back to Paul, a few years will of passed and his eyes will be blue. It makes no sense to have his eyes blue after he changes the water. If his eyes are blue when he is doing his rite of passage by riding a worm then it is before he changes the water.

    • @Zlarel
      @Zlarel Год назад +2

      @@D1str1ct Thennn... why aren't his eyes blue here? If it follows the book then his eyes should be partially blue during his first Maker ride (which they aren't in this trailer) because that is before his attempt at the spice agony.
      You silly, silly man.

    • @D1str1ct
      @D1str1ct Год назад +1

      @@Zlarel Then they have gone against the lore they have stated at the start of the first Dune movie. Also no need to insult me.

  • @davezdude3200
    @davezdude3200 Год назад +34

    In general, the coustuming, props, sets, etc. all look amazing. Weird what happens when the creatives appear to really like and respect the souce material: high quality film making that is earnest about presenting Frank Herbert's world in all its glory and accurately. Nice how the Fremen's look, especially Jessica as a Sayadina, really leans into the Fermen's Zen Sunni roots...Even the shots of Irulan and Lady Fenring were impressive and imaginative. Can't hardly wait for my early birthday present this November...

  • @reedbern
    @reedbern Год назад +74

    Great breakdown, as always! Awesome job pointing out the Irulan as a writer thread. Classic Frank Herbert: at first you think those Irulan’ chapter intros are just building backstory, but then you realize even she’s become a fanatic, or is at least helping the fanaticism grow. Gives the entire book a sense of utter inevitability. Also, loved you pointing out Stilgar’s religious experience. You can’t understand Dune without understanding that what happens to Stilgar and the Fremen is a tragedy. Dennis gets this and that’s why he’s perfect for this movie!

    • @MohamedRamadan-qi4hl
      @MohamedRamadan-qi4hl Год назад

      Not really. He wrote the freman to be unrealistic savages.

    • @Gadget-Walkmen
      @Gadget-Walkmen Год назад

      well said and nicely spotted there! Didn't even fully realize that at all here!

  • @Nobody_Special310
    @Nobody_Special310 Год назад +10

    I'm pleased to see that there's sand in this one as well. The sharp eyed among you can see a couple of grains of sand that were also used in Lynch's Dune (1:56).

  • @BattleMatt
    @BattleMatt Год назад +122

    It feels like there's almost too much to cover in one film. Two years of war and occupation pass between Jessica taking the water of life, giving birth to Alia and Paul riding the worm. That's a lot of ground.

    • @neutral_10
      @neutral_10 Год назад +38

      It has to be at least three hours

    • @thundercricket4634
      @thundercricket4634 Год назад +19

      Dune could have been 4 films, there's THAT much content.

    • @mnels5214
      @mnels5214 Год назад +24

      Yes! Unlike The Hobbit, Dune actually has enough content to support three films.

    • @thedemonhater7748
      @thedemonhater7748 Год назад +27

      @@neutral_10thankfully with movies like endgame, the stigma of a movie being over 3 hours has probably been shattered- at least for a few years.

    • @AkmalGameAtion
      @AkmalGameAtion Год назад +2

      Easy 3 hours

  • @brometheus5019
    @brometheus5019 Год назад +44

    Chani was my favorite character when I read these growing up. Because she is such an admirable woman and worthy companion to Paul. Dune Messiah especially. Good to see this beautiful actress showing some more emotion in part two.

    • @rafael_emmanuel
      @rafael_emmanuel Год назад +2

      Perfectly stated

    • @dookula
      @dookula Год назад +5

      zendaya looks pretty miscast to me. it looks like she is still mj from spiderman here. how can she be from the same tribe as stilgar and jamis?

    • @stevewhite6241
      @stevewhite6241 Год назад +1

      @@dookula same feeling.

    • @dangerboy544
      @dangerboy544 Год назад

      @@dookula I agree

    • @brometheus5019
      @brometheus5019 Год назад

      @@dookula you're not wrong. I didn't say she was well suited to the role..

  • @antoniskalakonas1876
    @antoniskalakonas1876 Год назад +33

    Just putting it here, that no matter what minor issues may arrise, I consider the first movie (and hopefully the second) one of the best adaptations of a book EVER to the wide screen.
    It gives me great pleasure to watch all the details from the book in the movie.

    • @williamhosford2796
      @williamhosford2796 Год назад +2

      Amen,brother. If anyone can pull it off successfully it is DV. Still dearly love many aspects of the `84 Lynch film i.e. shield effect,weapon styles,etc.

    • @D1str1ct
      @D1str1ct Год назад

      Really? they missed out so much. They should have done a series. They would have been able to get everything that is essential to the story in. So much has been left out an changed.

  • @ArmandoTheWanderer
    @ArmandoTheWanderer Год назад +104

    I think my biggest concern is the pacing of the movie compared to the book, but i am excited anyway. I also can't wait to see how they are going to depict Alia

    • @maxmendes6785
      @maxmendes6785 Год назад +1

      Does that mean there will be not a third movie, cause it is ending already with book one

    • @ArmandoTheWanderer
      @ArmandoTheWanderer Год назад

      @Max Mendes that's a good question I'm not sure 🤔

    • @sebb3301
      @sebb3301 Год назад +10

      ​@@maxmendes6785 I imagine they plan to end with Dune Messiah, making it a trilogy

    • @manoz6194
      @manoz6194 Год назад +8

      i've not read the books but the pacing for the first movie as just a movie was excellent, the time flew by

    • @Ethan-ct7uk
      @Ethan-ct7uk Год назад

      @@maxmendes6785 the director said he wouldn’t mind doing all 6 of Herbert’s books but it all depends on the performance of each one so if this is a banger we will get messiah and as long as that does good we will get children of dune and so on

  • @joshuahelmeke
    @joshuahelmeke Год назад +28

    I hope they give people an adaptation of Dune Messiah.

  • @tonylambert2616
    @tonylambert2616 Год назад +8

    Your channel is like comfort food.

  • @codename495
    @codename495 Год назад +7

    I love that you can see the moment in Stilgar eyes when Paul stops being a foster son and fellow fighter and becomes the fulfillment of the prophecy.

  • @tiffi5819
    @tiffi5819 Год назад +30

    The sound track is equally amazing as the visuals for me. It just draws me in and makes my heart quicken. I must say that Timothee Chalamet has one of the most interesting faces I’ve seen in cinema in a long time. I can’t stop looking at him. He’s just that gorgeous. I did not know that Christopher Walken was playing the Emperor. What an amazing cast. November can’t get here fast enough.

    • @williamhosford2796
      @williamhosford2796 Год назад +3

      Chalamet really surprised me. He is like a natural for the role of Paul.

    • @cattycats4
      @cattycats4 Год назад

      the soundtrack is like music you have while waiting in lifts, its forgettable, bland and is a disgrace to an epic like Dune that should have an epic soundtrack. Watch Lynchs Dune it has one of the best soundtracks of any film and does Dune justice. The modern films are such a let down

    • @andrewdamerau2742
      @andrewdamerau2742 Год назад

      @@cattycats4 If you compare it to elevator music it doesn't really sell as an argument. That's like if I said, the 1984 version is so bad I would have thought a highschooler made it for a class project. It discredits your point, while you could have more honestly described what was wrong with it. Or really, just said "I found it bland and forgettable, a disgrace to an epic like Dune." You don't even have to trash on this movie to like the 1984 version, but even then, "does Dune justice?" It ignores the entire premise of the book of a false messiah and replaces it with happy rain ending.

    • @sail4life
      @sail4life Год назад +1

      @@andrewdamerau2742 Basically 1984 Dune ends with the destruction of the known universe by killing all the sand worms...

    • @p_serdiuk
      @p_serdiuk Год назад

      ​@@cattycats4Soundtracks are supposed to be in the background and not draw too much attention. Only geniuses like John Williams could pull off having an OST that is also a banger on its own. Hans Zimmer is very good, but not exactly at that legendary level.

  • @JimBlessman
    @JimBlessman Год назад +71

    Quinn,
    Once again you have given a great breakdown on the Dune Trailer. I am really hoping that this film becomes successfully enough for Denis Villeneuve to do Dune Messiah and fingers crossed Children of Dune. The idea of Denis Villeneuve being able to bring the God Emperor into being would be amazing.

    • @jamezkpal2361
      @jamezkpal2361 Год назад +2

      Wouldn't that be something to see!

    • @williamhosford2796
      @williamhosford2796 Год назад +1

      I pray for that daily. AAAAAAHHHHHH (angelic choir voice).

  • @shakenbacon-vm4eu
    @shakenbacon-vm4eu Год назад +18

    Quinn has entered a mini universe suspending time itself, coming out with a banger immediately.

  • @jshooper7819
    @jshooper7819 Год назад +24

    I became a fan of Dune after watching your videos when I saw the first movie. I learned so much! I'm really excited for Part II.

    • @siriusakari6729
      @siriusakari6729 Год назад +5

      Same here. Quinn's enthusiasm for Dune is contagious.

  • @ironwarriorkrieger4011
    @ironwarriorkrieger4011 Год назад +4

    The look Stillgar give has two meanings, one where he's amazed at Paul's triumph over the worm, another where he now regretfully has to face off against Paul for position of leadership over the fremen.
    Or atleast that's how I interpret that look.

  • @magetaaaaaa
    @magetaaaaaa Год назад +15

    This series has a huge following. The trailer has been out for hours and has millions of views already and breakdown videos are already coming out. So awesome to ride the hype wave. I'm doing another read-through of the books now.

  • @rasheedqe
    @rasheedqe Год назад +16

    After reading the book again I look at that Stilgar thing differently. I think that is the point he realize paul was going to have to kill him to take leadership. At least that's what he was thinking in the books.

    • @p_serdiuk
      @p_serdiuk Год назад

      Both at the same time. Fear, surprise, reverence.

    • @rasheedqe
      @rasheedqe Год назад

      @@p_serdiuk Idk because he didn't really start believing until the end of the book and it doesn't show it here but they were other young fremen basically saying kill Stilgar the whole time. The movies make the fremen a lot dumber than they are in the books.

  • @bryanolivermusic9011
    @bryanolivermusic9011 Год назад +3

    Trailers are usually made before post-production is finished so it would make sense that Alia not be in the trailer if the cgi elements of her character haven't actually been finished yet

  • @trel
    @trel Год назад +10

    I think Count Fenring is being played by Tim Blake Nelson. I can’t wait for November.

    • @elmolady25
      @elmolady25 Год назад

      he'd be a great choice

    • @sectorgovernor
      @sectorgovernor Год назад

      I also think so and I hope I'm right. If he would play a smuggler or Guild member, I think it would have been revealed already.

  • @mikerolf1
    @mikerolf1 Год назад +9

    Not only did we not see St. Alia of the Knife, we did not see Walken as the Emperor. Still a Cool trailer though.

  • @Retic_01
    @Retic_01 Год назад +1

    The Combination of your Dune Knowledge and excitement along with that stunning intro track.. just increases any hype I have for the dune franchise. Much appreciated man and keep doing the good work.

  • @commanderknowledge8360
    @commanderknowledge8360 Год назад +2

    9:00 Stilgar also understands that Paul will now be expected to call him out.

  • @corywarren5297
    @corywarren5297 Год назад +9

    I love how it turned out Paul forced Irulan to write every one of those. "White this down." Kills me everytime 😂 marry her just to turn the emperor's daughter into a secretary 😅💀

  • @genmaicha.lapsang
    @genmaicha.lapsang Год назад +23

    I'm excited! I think that the costume design is really knocking out of the park this time. And even though I really enjoyed the first one I was still not 100 percent convinced. BUT now I have more hope.

    • @williamhosford2796
      @williamhosford2796 Год назад +1

      It just had the look,the feeling of the Dune universe. Love it!!

  • @JustJayGaming
    @JustJayGaming Год назад +51

    I really like the black and white look for the Harkonnens, I'm not sure they can pull of the size of an army that is about to conquer the universe, pretty difficult. All the new important characters and Pauls transition. This is a really hard movie to pull off.

    • @barvelo26
      @barvelo26 Год назад +2

      It gives it an alien feel to it! I love it!

    • @XsmithyboyX
      @XsmithyboyX Год назад +2

      If anyone can pull it off, its Denis

    • @jonathancohen479
      @jonathancohen479 Год назад +9

      The scenes are black and white because it’s taken from the Dune Encyclopedia and book. Geidi Prime has a low level of photosynthesis which means the light spectrum appears different than say Caladan or even Arrakis. This is yet another example of Denis really paying attention to detail from the source material.

    • @austinmasoni2067
      @austinmasoni2067 Год назад

      I actually thought the black and white was makeup

  • @rumpalumpa4739
    @rumpalumpa4739 Год назад +4

    Quinn thanks so much for sharing your Dune passion. I’ve been even more stoked for these movies thanks to your videos!

  • @blockmasterscott
    @blockmasterscott Год назад +30

    For me the actress playing the girl is a good match from the book. Even the way she talks is similar to the book.
    Well done. 💪👍

    • @seriousbismuth2173
      @seriousbismuth2173 Год назад +4

      Zendaya? Yeah, she's actually pretty great here, despite all the weird fanboys flocking for her 😂

  • @maotseovich1347
    @maotseovich1347 Год назад +3

    I love how much Paul and Jessica contradict themselves, and how you see them recognise it and agonise over it. And I love that they're clearly doing it because they're being forced to choose between things that are hugely important to them and their core values because circumstances have put those things into opposition.

  • @seemoret
    @seemoret Год назад +2

    You always bring a depth of knowledge of the original source material, which makes this such a great video.
    Loved your intro and the view of your gorgeous library. I was happy to see the Dune Encyclopedia on the shelf there. I know that was not an easy acquisition. Looking forward to the next trailer review.

  • @swiftbow2110
    @swiftbow2110 Год назад

    Love the way you explain things. Really helpful to folks who don’t know anything about dune. Keep it up my man 😊.

  • @tuffguy0134
    @tuffguy0134 Год назад +6

    I can't wait to see Alia and the Emperor. This movie is going to be awesome.

  • @scottmantooth8785
    @scottmantooth8785 Год назад +4

    *when properly applied or introduced even the smallest amount of chaos can be a powerful instrument of change*

  • @centurion09
    @centurion09 Год назад +2

    I greatly appreciate all the hard work you put into making these videos; keep them coming!

  • @marymohr2799
    @marymohr2799 Год назад

    I always love how you analyze Dune. It has helped me to understand what is going on and explain it to others.

  • @AbstractCatsMedia
    @AbstractCatsMedia Год назад +13

    Love that they've added at least one part of the 80s version, so far. One of my favorite 80s sci-fi's. One of the great things about being 56, is having scene so many great sci-fi movies of this era in the theaters. Would be great to see all rereleased for Imax.

    • @weswatson4616
      @weswatson4616 Год назад +2

      What did you see from the David Lynch movie?

  • @ClipStreamSage
    @ClipStreamSage Год назад +6

    10/10 excitement for the movie and all the content you’ll make around it!!

  • @ds698
    @ds698 Год назад

    Every little bit of knowledge I have of the dune universe is from you homie, thank you! From a fan who just got into it because of the most recent movie and because I’m really into space and consciousness and Dune seems to cover it big time I’ll get into the books soon! But your page is loads of fun man! Thank you so much!

  • @1980buendia
    @1980buendia Год назад

    Your insights into the Dune universe are downright scholarly! Sending you a high-five from Los Angeles!

  • @EsotericCat
    @EsotericCat Год назад +3

    Im so glad you made a video about this. You have such clear interpretations of dune and it is eye opening, makes the book very accessible.

  • @neilpatton7174
    @neilpatton7174 Год назад +3

    “A beginning is a very delicate time.”
    Lynch gives the princess the first words

  • @SpikeMarchant
    @SpikeMarchant Год назад

    I came to you to hear your thoughts on the trailer rather than anyone else, I have always appreciated your Dune insights. Great job!

  • @ThomasBaxter
    @ThomasBaxter Год назад

    Thanks Quinn.
    Your mastery of the Dune topic is amazing and I appreciate the consideration in which you present it.
    New trailer gave me chills.

  • @Confield
    @Confield Год назад +3

    Vivien Lyra Blair who played young Leia in Obi Wan Kenobi could be a good Alia

  • @HorySmokes
    @HorySmokes Год назад +9

    I don't get why people are speculating that Alia won't be in it - they revealed Jessica's pregnancy in part one.

    • @CyberMongoose
      @CyberMongoose Год назад

      The question is whether she will appear just as a baby, or if they will jump forward in time so she can have a bigger role. Honestly I think it would be better if they didn't do that in order to maintain continuity.

  • @Quarlitox
    @Quarlitox Год назад

    Subscribed. This is exactly the kind of content I was looking for to learn more about Dune.

  • @katemoon1594
    @katemoon1594 Год назад

    I love all of your insights about these books! It helps me appreciate aspects of the story I haven't noticed on my own and adds so much to my enjoyment of the series. I wish you all the best, in thanks!!

  • @lestatdelc
    @lestatdelc Год назад +3

    Minor nitpick, but I think you meant “the role Chani plays in Muad'dib’s success can't be overstated" (not "understated"). That said, good reaction/breakdown.

  • @maryamkim1281
    @maryamkim1281 Год назад +3

    I can't wait to see Alia. This will be really interesting.

  • @MrLecksy
    @MrLecksy Год назад +2

    I’m so happy you mentioned the preborn girl at the end. I watched the trailer twice looking for a glimse of her

  • @josephgraham3006
    @josephgraham3006 Год назад +1

    You’re breakdowns are fantastic, and your knowledge and insight solid and appreciated. Thanks so much, man.

  • @nobodyexceptme7794
    @nobodyexceptme7794 Год назад +11

    Not a huge fan of the dune series or movies, but your passion for it definitely is fun to watch and gets me almost just as excited to watch them as well. keep up the good work, love your channel, and please give us some more good book recommendations

  • @twilightcitystudios
    @twilightcitystudios Год назад +3

    I love that I got an ad of the trailer itself while watching this video. Lol

  • @grandpachas1267
    @grandpachas1267 Год назад +2

    The "chapter headings" you reference, in and of themselves, are very good.....some are fantastic!

  • @nicholasspicer5171
    @nicholasspicer5171 Год назад

    I really love your videos, they scratch that itch for hearing well thought out analyses on science fiction. Your TBP series is captivating and the next trilogy ill read after the hyperion cantos.

  • @jakesvitak5533
    @jakesvitak5533 Год назад +5

    Quinn with the very common W

  • @clamrollvideos
    @clamrollvideos Год назад +4

    Dune: "IF THEY CAN'T F**K THEY MUST FIGHT!"
    Battlestar Galactica writers: *taking notes* "This is gold"

  • @BookishChas
    @BookishChas Год назад +1

    Thanks for this Quinn! Great breakdown. You’re always my go to source for in depth Dune lore.

  • @milamber82
    @milamber82 Год назад

    This trailer is great. The tension it builds is fantastic and the way it looks! Really looking forward to this. Great vid as usual.

  • @0Metatron
    @0Metatron Год назад +51

    Love how Chani actually looks like she’s been in the desert for a while.
    No fake hairdos and makeup, much more real
    I feel like Irulan should have had an English accent to make her more regal and believable.

    • @pacotaco1246
      @pacotaco1246 Год назад +36

      I also expected that with Irulan but then again doing that just reinforces the idea the the Br*tish are some kind of special royalty instead of just people with a silly king

    • @maryamkim1281
      @maryamkim1281 Год назад +5

      Yes, an English accent for this character would have fit more, absolutely.

    • @recurrenTopology
      @recurrenTopology Год назад +11

      I'm guessing her American accent was better than Walken's English accent.

    • @elimoran7345
      @elimoran7345 Год назад +4

      I couldn’t care less about the accent, since you can express and embody regalness in any accent. My main issue with the depiction of Irulan here is that she doesn’t look as Irulan in the books: more royal indeed, enigmatic, deeply intelligent…

    • @Sarah_9132
      @Sarah_9132 Год назад

      Space is for Americans

  • @xAdam2gx
    @xAdam2gx Год назад +8

    youre the reason i got into the Dune series, ive read the series once but read the first book like 6 times now... i will say theres a lot of poor moisture disipline with open faces while in the desert lol... the only thing i question from the trailer was Chanis joyfull look on her face... i just felt that wasnt a freman reaction as everything is always so serious in the books and everything is about life and death or water and the tribe.

  • @secretsofdune
    @secretsofdune Год назад +2

    Great breakdown as always Quinn. Side note, whoever it is, loving that background music. Really suits the mood.

  • @jdghgh
    @jdghgh Год назад +1

    What a fantastic breakdown of the trailer! Especially when you highlighted Stilgar's reaction to the wormride.

  • @etet4736
    @etet4736 Год назад +4

    Love the character Alia! Can't wait!

  • @610vegas
    @610vegas Год назад +16

    I truly love these books so much, it is so heartwarming to see such an adaptation as this. Denis is the man.

  • @rockingranny5278
    @rockingranny5278 Год назад +1

    I'm so excited for this movie!! I can't wait. Great job on the breakdown Quinn!

  • @bethmarriott9292
    @bethmarriott9292 Год назад +2

    Princess Irulan being the historian to tell the story of all the chaos reminds me of the Byzantine princess Anna Komnena who wrote the Alexiad about Emperor Alexios Komnenus in the 1100s and I wonder if Frank Herbert had some inspiration from that

  • @Pffffffffffffffffffffff
    @Pffffffffffffffffffffff Год назад +5

    This is gonna be so good 🤤 Feyd-Rautha looks alien! The worm is so fast and massive. I love Javier Bardem's Stilgar. And I'm thrilled to see Jessica's and Paul' transformations into a Reverend Mother and the Kwisatz Haderach.

  • @chadsmith3363
    @chadsmith3363 Год назад +3

    Nice work as always! I've held off getting the Dune blu-ray because I'm holding out for the inevitable super deluxe box set.

  • @musicman7943
    @musicman7943 Год назад

    Loving the back to back uploads bro. Keep ‘em comin

  • @goos98
    @goos98 Год назад

    Been watching for years, really love your stuff thanks!

  • @browe
    @browe Год назад +59

    You've addressed the problematic White Savior theme before, and I'm glad you referenced it here. It is important to recognize. I agree with your take: Herbert did just the opposite in his book, although it's easy to miss if one doesn't also know (as you've noted) that Herbert in part "...wrote the Dune series because [he] had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: 'May be dangerous to your health.' " I have great trust that Villenueve will respect and underscore this in Dune Pt. 2.

    • @peeko_luxx2873
      @peeko_luxx2873 Год назад +4

      Greatly said. I know it’s way too early to hope but I really would love Messiah made soon after Part 2 release. Hard to really capsulate what FHs message was without telling the story of Messiah. Despite its flaws, it’s one of my favorites in the series and I think it’d make for a great slow burner film for an “explosive” ending that would leave the audience questioning their own beliefs. Loads of people like myself saw the film before reading the books and I sort of understand their discourse with certain aspects, especially before reading the books. I feel Messiah would really wrap up the message for those that aren’t too familiar with source material. Cheers

    • @davezdude3200
      @davezdude3200 Год назад +12

      Yeah, Dune is a cautionary tale, not an instruction manual for aspiring White Saviors

    • @browe
      @browe Год назад +1

      @@peeko_luxx2873 Cheers. Great points.

    • @browe
      @browe Год назад +1

      @@davezdude3200 "Not an instruction manual" -- great way to put it!

    • @medicin3man1
      @medicin3man1 Год назад +3

      Thank you for this. I hate the fact that the “white savior” is bandied around when talking about Dune. I agree with these comments. Thank you!

  • @alexanderbookchin2447
    @alexanderbookchin2447 Год назад +23

    I am fascinated by the symbiotic relationship of Baron Harkonnen and Judge Holden, I am pretty convinced the Baron was part of the inspiration for the Judge and seeing Villeneueve's depiction of the Baron as a towering, ultra violent, hairless albino who spends alot of time naked doesn't seem accidental at all.

    • @sebb3301
      @sebb3301 Год назад +3

      I know right! The moment I saw 4:48 I couldn't help but think of the Judge

    • @Zlarel
      @Zlarel Год назад +3

      Noticed a clear inspiration from Colonel Kurtz in Denis' Dune, too

    • @happyhammer1
      @happyhammer1 Год назад +7

      I would love to see denis villeneuve take a crack at Blood Meridian.

    • @happyhammer1
      @happyhammer1 Год назад +1

      @@alexanderbookchin2447 well I hope he can do it justice. I think the perfect person to direct Blood Meridian would have been Stanley Kubrick. Shocking take, I know.

    • @happyhammer1
      @happyhammer1 Год назад +1

      @@Zlarel the actor said he was the inspiration. Hell the scene where he's coming up out of the oil is almost a shot for shot remake. Even the mannerisms and the way he talks is totally Kurtz.

  • @javierantoniovarasgenestie5313

    Haven't been here for a while. Always enjoy your videos.

  • @dfailsthemost
    @dfailsthemost Год назад

    Your reminders to like the video are the best, for some reason. It actually does remind me to like when I'm maybe too engrossed to remember.

  • @azmc4940
    @azmc4940 Год назад +5

    I'm sure fanfiction writers will find lots of ways for Paul and Fayed to mate.

    • @benjalucian1515
      @benjalucian1515 Год назад

      As the saying goes "If they can't f--k, they have to fight."

    • @sectorgovernor
      @sectorgovernor Год назад +1

      Yeah, it's true... Like the 'thilbo' (Thorin + Bilbo) fanfics...

  • @Cydonia2020
    @Cydonia2020 Год назад +4

    I’m hoping they will finish Thufir’s story. I always felt he was given short shrift in the previous two productions. He was such an interesting character. It would be a shame not to see him forced to serve the Baron while covertly trying to manipulate the House from within.

  • @MisterTutor2010
    @MisterTutor2010 Год назад +2

    The fact that she is scholar and writer is mentioned in the miniseries but very briefly and at the very end.

  • @gnollman
    @gnollman Год назад +2

    Alia is so critical to later books, I just don't see how Villeneuve can leave her character out of Part 2. The 'That's not hope!' scene made me think more of Paul's resistance to the Golden Path, moreso than an outcry against the Bene Gesserit Missionaria Protectiva. It's been a minute since I've read the books, though, so maybe I'm misplacing that in the timeline. All said, though, I am totally stoked for this second film.
    I really need to reread the books, it's been at least seven years since I last read the original series.

  • @ljbeats00
    @ljbeats00 Год назад +8

    I just hope one day we get to see a live action God Emperor of Dune, definetly the most profound book in the series

    • @seriousbismuth2173
      @seriousbismuth2173 Год назад

      Yes!!

    • @pxlbltz
      @pxlbltz Год назад

      Me too. It's my favourite book of the series. I want to see the god emperor on screen and I'm sure Denis would make him look awesome.

  • @nickfunkhouser7096
    @nickfunkhouser7096 Год назад +2

    It appears to have more political intrigue as well. That's the one thing I thought we didn't get enough of in Pt. 1 given that they had to establish world building and character arcs. Also love the parallels to Lawrence of Arabia like the shot of the figure walking through the desert, Paul raising the crysknife to the crowd of Fremen, etc. It's all so beautiful.

  • @Terraproject
    @Terraproject Год назад +1

    Love your vids Quinn, you gotta fan for life.

  • @luckyplvys
    @luckyplvys Год назад +3

    I wouldn’t worry about Alia not being in Part 2 given that we literally see a glimpse of her as a baby in Part 1. The question moreso is how they execute her portrayal.

  • @NerdyGuyRanting
    @NerdyGuyRanting Год назад +3

    I think Stilgar's look is also partly him knowing that Paul successfully riding his first worm will give him the status among the men to challenge Stilgar for leadership. And he knows he wont stand a chance against Paul. That is a religious experience mixed the knowledge that he is going to die because of that religion.

  • @avecrali
    @avecrali Год назад

    Thank you Quinn for your work and dedication, you're awesome : ))

  • @adamdavis4690
    @adamdavis4690 Год назад

    I love your excitement for Dune, thank you for sharing with us

  • @andrewg.2996
    @andrewg.2996 Год назад +3

    I think the Count Fenring might be Tim Blake Nelson's character, I can see that being a thing