Ghost in the Shell: The New Movie - Movie Review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 ноя 2015
- FACEBOOK: / chrisstuckmann
TWITTER: / chris_stuckmann
OFFICIAL SITE: www.chrisstuckmann.com
Chris Stuckmann reviews Ghost in the Shell: The New Movie. Directed by Kazuchika Kise, Kazuya Nomura. 
Кино
Who ever decided to name this "the new movie" deserves to get fired.
+iron mask of hell Well its actually called Ghost in the Shell: The Movie but they changed it in the US. My guess so that people wouldn't get it confused for the old movie.
+Digital2Film indeed
+iron mask of hell What are you guys whining about? This is the best title for a movie since "Sharknado 2: The Second One". lol
+Digital2Film Someone still need to get fired.
i think someone was brainstorming and wrote 'the new movie' as a titlr of the brainstorm but someone took it literally
Can't wait for Ghost in the Shell: The Newer Movie and its sequel Ghost in the Shell: The Newest Movie
says he has a cold
sounds exactly the same
Right?!?
UNCLE UTTERS A tad different.
Chris, you have to review Cory in the house it's an anime masterpiece
+coryinthehouse this joke is still around?
+coryinthehouse By the way, did you see Cop Out? Its AMAZING........i said, it was AMAZING
Lmao Cory in the House!
XD. I thought you were waiting for Fallout 4?
+ETrevolutionX2014 waiting for a lot of things
*If anyone is interested in the Ghost in the Shell franchise but doesn't where to start, you can watch it like this*
>Ghost in the Shell (1995) >Ghost in the Shell: Innocence>Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex> Ghost in the Shell: Solid State Society
Then Arise, if you feel like it. I would also advise to read the manga. It's pretty different from any adaptation of the series.
+ARandomGuy Good order.
+ARandomGuy after SAC you should watch Solid State Society bcoz its a continuation of tv series
VelvetSky1102 I consider it to be part of SAC. It literally has Stand Alone Complex in the title.
ARandomGuy It's worth noting because people new to the series might not even be aware that there were as many movies as there are.
***** I'll edit it.
I don't think the "technobabble" should be considered a flaw, it's a big part of the original manga and I think it's the appeal for a lot of people.
was just about to comment this. I enjoyed it
6 years later and I was thinking the same thing. If it is a flaw it was baked in from the very beginning
the first ghost in the shell didn't feature annoying "techno-babble", imo. it just had a lot of philosophically interesting dialoge sequences...
Chris doesn't like Blade Runner so I can see why he would say something like.
TheVideoInvader really? blade runner is one of my favorite movies, but I think it differs a lot from ghost in the shell in that it doesn't try to explain the mechanics of its world very explicitly. that definitely happened in gits, but as it was done well I can't complain about it.
erraticbrain Blade Runner is my favorite film of all time and you're right. Instead it shows you the mechanics of the world with lush production design and art direction but GitS is great also.
Was thinking this ARISE focused more on political intriuge/ espionage. a little hard to follow, but techno babble? NOPE
I especially LOVE those looooooong conversations in all GITS movies and series. They contain the most intelligent thoughts, that I´ve ever seen in Movies or Animes. Nonetheless I´d also give it a C+, because it was not a movie for theaters and not on the level of the previous movies.
Thanks for reviewing Chris!
Sadly it seems Miyazaki of Ghibli Studios was right. The anime industries are full of otaku's and they are ruining anime.
+charon7111 What nonsense. Arise was ruined by the greedy producers who just went by the numbers to create a show that no-one had asked for while cutting corners and using product placement for extra cash. A proper Ghost in the Shell geek could have created something worthwhile to the franchise.
+charon7111 Honestly, it's kind of like saying "pop music is ruining the music industry"
No, real music is still being made. So are good animes. The "otaku" stuff is just easily digestible and makes a lot of money.
I'm going to somewhat disagree with all of the above. Arise, simply put, is ruined by a set of writers and a director who doesn't know what he's doing. Producers want to make money? I'm fine with that. After all, that's what they're hired to do. The problem is when those producers hire people who have no idea who don't know what they're doing. There are plenty of things that are amazing and well made that began as concepts a producer simply wanted to make money off of. The issue is who you manage to hire and your method of making that money.
+ZerogunRivale The movie and Arise fail because they didn't get what makes GITS work. Not that stuff Miyzaki was going on about.
Miyazaki didn't actually said that
I think the long "technobabble" is actually the best part of the ghost in the shell movies and series. really makes you think and wonder. plus the robotic animations whenever they talk just makes sense, and is less distracting from what the characters are saying. Like a good detective film, it forces you to pay attention and think.
review one punch man!!!
I JUS WANNA BE A SUPAH HEROOOO!!!!!!
+Holo The Hogan Johnson
is that you james ?
+Nevi1097
Yea, Chris should review it. At least a first impression on One Punch Man.
+Nevi1097 20 words or less, Saitama is a busy man
nicko bagaskara the son of aquaman Sorry to dissapoint.
Stuckmann! You need to review Neon Genesis Evangelion!
I second
Forth
+Nick Bruce Fifth? Or sixth?
+lebliu He needs to review these awesome cartoons
+videogamebomer NGE is one of my favorite cartoons of all time. I especially like Misato's slutty feet in the later episodes.
Dude you NEED to watch Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood
He should watch the 2003 version then brotherhood
+forgothispassword 2011 version, while more accurate to the manga, has like... 0 emotion in comparison to the original.
+forgothispassword I do think brotherhood is better but he should watch both and I find it hard to watch 2003 after BH, plus 2003 does give more time to things that BH goes over quickly
+forgothispassword lol noo! brotherhood is more ment to show off better fight scenes the 2003 original has wayyy more emotion and heart
I think be should review the 2003 version first then FMAB.
I just want a third season of Stand Alone Complex.
Well... I hope you don't regret your wish.
I'd love it if Chris made a series of reviews of anime series & movies airing currently. He could watch 1 or 2 shows/season & make a video on those once they have finished airing.
Day 6: still no fallout 4 review
goddamit Cory
no one can review fallout 4 in like 6day
+coryinthehouse I'm still waiting on Fandango's review
+coryinthehouse i think he is not a big fallout fan...he didnt reviewed mgs5 because he havent completed it yet as he didnt liked it that much...
Day 75: still no metal gear solid V review. Now THAT is something to be sad about
Personally Chris, I loved it. It felt like a giant love letter to the overall franchise with certain voice actors "passing the torch" if you will (sorry trying to avoid spoilers), being somewhat surprised by certain events in the story, the ending being a Massive homage to one of my favorite scenes in the series, seeing the team all work together in combat was really welcomed, action scenes were beautifully done like what you said, small bits of humor throughout the film, and the soundtrack was great. Ghost in the Shell i will admit is my overall favorite franchise since it has yet to disappoint me when the big picture is considered, across the manga, the Oshii films, SAC, and now Arise. Is there technobabble in the movie? Yes sure, but honestly (and maybe this is just me) but I've never been overwhelmed by the amount it presents since I love how GITS challenges me to think faster or hander. I'd love to discuss the series in more detail if or whenever you have time just for a friendly chat about it..
Why is it RUclipsrs always point out when they have a cold? You can't hear the difference so why point it out?
It's because some people who DO notice it would be making a big deal about it in the comments...but you managed to make a big deal anyway, didn't you? :P
+dave19941000 because he is human
+PMT's Slot Hit's n' Stuff I think it would be better if he mentioned that he has a cold at the end of the video so that you don't think about it during the video itself.
+dave19941000 It saves a comment of WTF is wrong with your voice and the Chris replying "Oh I had a cold"
Attack on titan?
I've given up hope for it at this point.
+Marcus Carlzén i dont think he will, so many other people have already reviewed it and talked about it, plus i doubt he has time to watch a full anime season
+Half-Hazard Never give up hope!
+Marcus Carlzén Maybe he will when they release season 2
+Nick Ward Its just 1 season with episodes of 20 min and totally worth it.
Great video as always Chris!
Congrats on the new Screen Junkies gig! Looking forward to your new show
Techno babble is fine as long as it's building towards something. The reason the original movie and every episode of Stand Alone Complex were interesting was because the techno babble and political weren't isolated. They were made part of the drama where they were actually steps towards understanding the situation and solving the crime. It was continuously having a dynamic impact on the progression of events.
The problem with Arise and even the original manga is that very little seems to connect at times. Things are mentioned, things are talked about, but it never feels like it's building towards something. Add on the fact that the action scenes in Arise (and I assume The New Movie) feel as if they have nothing at stake, and everything feels disconnected and boring. The technobabble feels more like exposition and less like build-up. SAC and Arise have a lot in common, but it just goes to show how masterful direction and writing can separate what is one of the greatest anime of all time (SAC) from one of the most disappointing installments in the franchise (Arise).
On top of that, GITS has always used these conversations as interesting ways to talk about interesting ideas and concepts, something sorely missing in movies today.
I should just go to you for all movies I see in the future; your reviews are awesome.
Now do a review on the live action ghost in the shell trailer :)
The entire idea behind GITS was it's techno-philosophical babble - that is what made it stand out, it was meant to be jarring by asking difficult questions such as what it means to be alive and our false presumptions of identity.
naveed akhtar The manga is more of a textbook with illustrations.
I love the exposition in Ghost in The Shell. I love trivia and the minute details of complex topics. There's nothing a sentimental scene can do to top the appeal of that, for me.
Those "conversation" are incredible. So many layers
yay you decided to do this review!!
almost same thoughts Chris, the Arise serie was ok I guess and I did expected more from the movie and I was really disappointed as well but and even tho I wanted to think it was better I ended up feeling like it was the same thing so yeah not a very good movie or serie :/
SO GLAD you reviewed this!!!! Please do review more recent Anime movies too if you find the time, Chris! :)
So if I did not like the Arise series I should skip this one?
+Marco A yea
I do wish you'd do more anime reviews. There's a lot of good stuff out there, both movies and tv shows.
Thank you for the review. It encouraged me to begin watching the episodes (Border:1, 2 and 3) of Ghost in the Shell (Arise) on Netflix. I enjoyed it to the point where I want to see more of this series. I found the action fast paced, well-animated with good voice acting. I wonder if the low intensity of emotion is a symbol for the cyber/android aspect of this anime's theme?
The prequel wasn´t exactly Arise (4 movies) It was actually Ghost in the Shell: Arise - Alternative Architecture (10 episodes)
great review Chris.
Chris, I'd like to hear your opinion or classic movies, so I was thinking, maybe you could do like a monthly series where you pick a movie from IMDB 250 (just an idea) and review them, I think it'd be awesome!
+Milan Francis Ya I'd love to see him review something like "Vertigo"
10 years from now it will be called "ghost in the shell: the old movie"
Or ... 4 years from now
Hey bro!!! Congrats on the screen junkies plus gig. I pooed right in my pants when I saw that!
I thought this was a review of the live action movie for a second
Do you think you could review Akira?
Chris, the fact that you know about 'Ghost in the Shell' makes you awesome. Live long and prosper.
+Toyboat Toyboat So, you congratulate him about knowing GitS, but make a Star Trek reference... lol, what?
It's a pretty popular series.
Since SAC there is nothing special about knowing ghost in the shell.. The real special thing is to UNDERSTAND it... To understand what its trying to tell us and why things like "the new movie" has nothing to do with the real ghost in the shell franchise...
Hey Chris, love your channel!, can you please review Black Lagoon?
Mr. Stuckman, would you ever do a review for the live action of Rurouni Kenshin trilogy if you can ever get your hands on it?
Second that
+andri wulan Third this. One of the best live action manga/anime adaptations to date.
When are they going to animate the jinchu arc doe
+ARandomGuy agreed
Thanks Chris! could you also review "Fist of the north star and "Vampire Hunter D"?
Note: this movie is a continuation of the remake of the reboot.
Movie -- AAA -- ARISE
After SAC it just feels that there’s been a dip in quality with the Ghost in the Shell franchise. I watched “ARISE” and read the Japanese manga adaption and that made me less intrigued to watch this new film. The newer properties seem to want to focus more on exposition to the point of pretension.
Nice review. I'm a new subscriber to your channel and two anime I would love to see you review are Madoka Magica and Terror in Resonance. Madoka is my #1 show and the only thing I rank above Cowboy Bebop, a true masterpiece of tragic storytelling. Terror in Resonance meanwhile is the most recent collaboration between Yoko Kanno and Shinichiro Watanabe. It does have some plot inconsistencies, but there are sequences that are truly transcendent where music, visuals, and character all coalesce into something amazing.
Hey Chris! I am a big fan of your reviews and what makes me especially excited is when you, on rare occasions, review anime since I am a tremendously big fan of that sort of entertainment. I think you are spot on, on most of your anime reviews and therefore I would really love to see more of them. As there are lots of anime I would like to recommend the most sincere recommendation for you to watch is the Fate- series. I'm not recommending it only because it's one of MY favourites but also because , judging by what appears to be your taste, YOU would love everything from the story to the unmatched animation and music. You would be doing yourself a favour watching it, I promise. Anyways keep up the awesome work and please do us anime- crazies a favour and review as much anime as you have time for.
Chris you've gotta do a review of Star Wars Battlefront that comes out Tuesday! Your a Star Wars fan and a videogame fan so you'd love it!
I'm new to ghost in the shell I picked this movie up because o watched the trailer and thought it looked cool so I bought but haven't watched it so is it any good
?
I actually really liked it. they do the techno babble but it was interesting to me. I liked how the ending ties directly into the very first movie.
When will u do another Tonnami retro rewind? Also great video!
Hey Chris, what are your thoughts on the upcoming Ghost In The Shell live action movie (2017) with Scarlett Johansson in the lead role?
Is there an official website I can buy the movies from?
Wish they had just kept on making new Stand Alone Complex shows and movies. The Arise OVA's? are just not in the same league sadly.
Chris Stuckmann, where did you get the Patrick Bateman doll? Freakin awesome!!!
Great review
Chris u need to do the original 1995 and 2004 innocence leading up to the live action next year
Chris, did you ever see "Song of the Sea", the irish animation which got an oscar nomination last year? The drawings are beautiful and the themes and characters are seriously convincing. Would've thought it's right up your street and would love to hear what you think.
Hey Chris, what's your top 10 underrated movies
could you please review afro samurai i just binge watched it including the movie and its fucking brilliant
Anyone watched Ghost in The Shell Arise TV those 10 episodes which are the full story of those 4 OVA? What's the difference between those two?
So was Kurutsu being controlled through out the movies or just here in the new movie?
The arise series is on Netflix, is it worth watching.
Hey Chris! Review "Planetes" if you can. Its the most realistic sci-fi anime out there (Excluding Space brothers, but can we really call that sci-fi?)
what ever happened to your Attack on Titan review?
Are you going to get the Miyazaki Collection on Amazon? They have all of his films on Blu-ray.
chris, please review db then z then gt cause I know your big fan and I'd love to see your in depth review
Do they have to change the title if they make another sequel?
yes Ive been waiting for this
So is it like a prequel or like a reboot ? or both?
I love those exposition scenes of long talk
Really curious what you thought of Redline
hey Chris why didn't you do Paul Blart mall cop 2?
How do you feel about the impending live action adaptation?
Great video please could you expleind the plot of this movie i dont get It.
Hi Chris, have you seen Ergo proxy? Would like to see a review of that anime :) and also Lain!
Alejita Rojas its too heavy for him
You know there's a fifth episode to Arise right? I think it came out not too long after they decided to cut each of the original 'borders' of the OVA into 2 episode releases each for television broadcast as well as creating the 2 episodes after the initial 8, making 2 more episodes of new content. The last two episodes were compounded as the 5th 'border' of the arise mini series providing for one more theatrical short film before the release of this film concluding the Arise series.
did he ever do the original ghost in the shell movie review ?
+jedaaa Nah.
One of the hallmarks of anime is near-static imagery. It gives the watcher a chance to fully contemplate the scene. It is one of the aspects I first noticed and now much enjoy about anime. But I do find it interesting that much of the original "Ghost in the Shell" has exactly those elements of lots of static to near-static shots and yet you consider it one of your favorite animes of all time. I know all reviews are subjective; however, this one seems a bit contradictory for the aforementioned reason.
I enjoy reviews. Keep up the good work.
Can somebody tell me what anime this is:
it seems to be in the future - it is possible to see the last thing a person saw before he died. lots of robots around.
female police officer (she could handle guns very well) and a male lead character go to destroy a 'system' and the woman shoots it 'in the eye' - with her right hand wounded she hits it with her left hand.
I would be very grateful if someone helped me. thank you!
+Chris Stuckmann When Battlefront comes out, will you review it.
i hope chris will review the other ghost in the shell incarnation near the release of Scarlett Johansen's one
Well there be a Cloud reaction video?
Are all the _Ghost in the Shell_ shows and films in a single timeline or are there different tellings/worlds?
And what order would one watch everything in?
+Rhett Gedies The first two GITS movies (GITS: 1995 and GITS: innocence) take place in one timeline. All of Stand Alone Complex takes place in a separate timeline. And the rest of the stuff made after it (Arise, this movie) take place in a third timeline.
You can watch it like this.
>Ghost in the Shell (1995) >Ghost in the Shell: Innocence >Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex
>Then Arise, if you feel like it.
The timelines for the anime adaptations aren't nearly as confusing as it may sound.
I would also advise to read the manga. It's pretty different from any adaptation of the series.
Hey Chris, maybe is a long shot, but I am a big fan of Neon Genesis Evangelion, have you seen any of the movies or show? If you have I would love to hear you opinion on it. Thanks man, awesome review as always.
Make a review of "Youth" it's such a good directed movie, I know you'll like it Mr Stuckmann
Anyone know how I can watch this movie now without pirating it?
Would like to see a review of The Ring, especially as a second sequel is slated for release in 2016 :)
When are you going to do your anime collection?
Review the anime thriller 'Monster"
One of my biggest issues with the entire ARISE series is that the Major seems so ridiculously overpowered to the point it seems like it's pointless for her to even have a team. Her power level is WAY over 9000!!! It's hard for me to explain. It's like back in the older series everybody in the team had their own specific skills that were equally important. But while watching ARISE it just feels like she got the team together to do all the work that she could easily do herself but just doesn't feel like doing.
HEEELP Where can I buy this movie?! I need to see it. Also, where can I buy Arise???
Hey what you think about Tokyo ghoul is a great anime
Yay, a new GITH! Thanks for the notice.
In what order should I watch the show please !!!
You should watch the animated movie. Preferably the 95 version. The live action movie seems to be based off that. The series is pretty much it's own story based off the 95 movie. You shouldn't mess with the show until you've seen the animated movie.
What happened to your previous Ghost in the Shell review, Chris?
thanks for the review. might watch Arise after i
Ok, you know very well all the "ghost in the shell" production, but why I can't find your review of the first installment? I really would enjoy it in the "retro rewind" section
Hey Chris Stuckmann since this year marks the 20th Anniversary of Toy Story, will you be reviewing the movie?
Just a little trivia for people who missed it, the ending part of this movie is the beginning of the original Ghost in the Shell movie