Deconstructing A Day In The Life (Isolated Tracks)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 фев 2025
- Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 1967
00:00 Drums, Maracas, Tambourine and Ringo Final Chord
04:56 Bass and Paul Final Chord
09:54 Guitar, Piano, Maracas, Mal Count, Clock Alarm, Congas, Orchesta Overdubs and John and Mal Final Chord
15:02 Vocals
19:43 Orchesta and George Martin Final Chord (Harmonium)
Personal:
Drums: Ringo Starr
Maracas: George Harrison
Congas: Ringo Starr
Bass (Rickenbacker 4001S): Paul Mccartney
Guitar (Gibson J-160E): John Lennon
Clock Alarm: Mal Evans
Vocals: John Lennon, Paul Mccartney and Mal Evans
Pianos and Harmonium:
1905 Steinway vertegrand Piano (All the song and last Chord): Paul Mccartney and Ringo Starr
Challen Blond-Wood Spinet Piano (Last Chord): John Lennon
Hamburg Steinway Baby Grand Piano (Last Chord): Mal Evans
Mannbourg Harmonium (Last Chord): George Martin
Orchesta:
Orchestral arrangements by Sir George Martin
Erich Gruenberg, Granville Jones, Bill Monro, Jurgen Hess, Hans Geiger, D Bradley, Lionel Bentley, David McCallum, Donald Weekes, Henry Datyner, Sidney Sax, Ernest Scott: Violins
John Underwood, Gwynne Edwards, Bernard Davis, John Meek: Violas
Francisco Gabarro, Dennis Vigay, Alan Dalziel, Alex Nifosi: Cellos
Cyril MacArthur, Gordon Pearce: Double basses
John Marston: Harp
Basil Tschaikov, Jack Brymer: Clarinets
Roger Lord: Oboe
N Fawcett, Alfred Waters: Bassoons
Clifford Seville, David Sanderman: Flutes
Alan Civil, Neil Sanders: French horns
David Mason, Monty Montgomery, Harold Jackson: Trumpets
Raymond Brown, Raymond Premru, T Moore: Trombones
Michael Barnes: Tubas
Marijke Koger: Tambourine
For analysis, transcriptions, and sampling (for experimental purposes)
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 1967
00:00 Drums, Maracas, Tambourine and Ringo Final Chord
04:56 Bass and Paul Final Chord
09:54 Guitar, Piano, Maracas, Mal Count, Clock Alarm, Congas, Orchesta Overdubs and John and Mal Final Chord
15:02 Vocals
19:43 Orchesta and George Martin Final Chord (Harmonium)
Personal:
Drums: Ringo Starr
Maracas: George Harrison
Congas: Ringo Starr
Bass (Rickenbacker 4001S): Paul Mccartney
Guitar (Gibson J-160E): John Lennon
Clock Alarm: Mal Evans
Vocals: John Lennon, Paul Mccartney and Mal Evans
Pianos and Harmonium:
1905 Steinway vertegrand Piano (All the song and last Chord): Paul Mccartney and Ringo Starr
Challen Blond-Wood Spinet Piano (Last Chord): John Lennon
Hamburg Steinway Baby Grand Piano (Last Chord): Mal Evans
Mannbourg Harmonium (Last Chord): George Martin
Orchesta:
Orchestral arrangements by Sir George Martin
Erich Gruenberg, Granville Jones, Bill Monro, Jurgen Hess, Hans Geiger, D Bradley, Lionel Bentley, David McCallum, Donald Weekes, Henry Datyner, Sidney Sax, Ernest Scott: Violins
John Underwood, Gwynne Edwards, Bernard Davis, John Meek: Violas
Francisco Gabarro, Dennis Vigay, Alan Dalziel, Alex Nifosi: Cellos
Cyril MacArthur, Gordon Pearce: Double basses
John Marston: Harp
Basil Tschaikov, Jack Brymer: Clarinets
Roger Lord: Oboe
N Fawcett, Alfred Waters: Bassoons
Clifford Seville, David Sanderman: Flutes
Alan Civil, Neil Sanders: French horns
David Mason, Monty Montgomery, Harold Jackson: Trumpets
Raymond Brown, Raymond Premru, T Moore: Trombones
Michael Barnes: Tubas
Marijke Koger: Tambourine
For analysis, transcriptions, and sampling (for experimental purposes)
Can you isolate the backing vocals for Oh Darling?
@@dannyboy141 yes
@Jim McCracken i cant sorry
@@DLD2Music I bet you cannot isolate, 'Oh, Darling', because Paul is claiming 'copyright grounds'. Am I correct? If so...what a shame. Just shaking my head. (Should that be the case).
@@baberoot1998 I just can't do it, besides as you say, Yt is very bad with me I have 1 strike :(
Thanks, George Harrison for those beautiful sounding maracas.
@Cris Zapot it blows my mind that George only played maracas and even Ringo did more than him
@Cris Zapot It’s often believed George contributed to the vocals in the ”dream sequence” since there are at least 3 vocal harmonies, if not 4. (17:40-18:05)
@Cris Zapot It's sad cuz George is my fav Beatle, but without the maraccas the song wouldn't be the same, love them, so it's something I guess
that’s some shit they usually pass onto ringo they did george dirty on this one lmao
@@jesper7993 Oh yeah, he did the low falsetto which is hardly audible even on the isolated track! 😀
And there are indeed 4 voices, I guess even Ringo joins in at the last aaah.
Perhaps the greatest Beatles Vocal ever was performed by John Lennon on this masterpiece. No wonder George Martin said “he has a voice that sends shivers down your spine.”
Ringo was really good on this epic song.
Probably John's greatest recorded vocal performance. The sawdust!
Love Ringo’s fills in this song. The one at 3:21 is just wonderful
This song is insane. You can really see The Beatles influence on all modern music in just breaking down Sgt. Pepper tracks.
It started before Pepper. Rubber Soul ... the touch paper was lit.
This is without a doubt their masterpiece. I have always felt the drum track is the standout.
John's voice...So epic
15:05 ".....he has a voice.....that sends shivers down the spine"..........well said Mr. Martin, well said
17:39
I never heard those background vocals to John’s vocals before I am stunned right now!! Sounds like some Halloween shit is amazing my goodness the Beatles
Those are Paul's vocals
That’s Paul singing there not John
@@HeyBullfrog nope. Lennon 100pct
@@justanotherrandomcrit8115 Lennon 100pct
@mar Rubbish it's john on lead and P and g in the background
This song is so legendary that makes me cry.R.ip George Harrison and John Lennon.
21:33 when I first heard that sound I couldn't believe it, because it really adds a lot to that last chord and you don't even notice it, even if you've heard it a thousand times..
19:50 Your life flashing before your eyes. Thanks so much for making these.
The most goosebump moment in my entire life. And it's comes from the Beatles of course
I can almost hear those laughs and noises from I Am The Walrus
17:31 I LOVE THAT "Bom bom."
And that wheeze after Paul said "had a smoke"
To any guitarist that attempts to play the intro to this song....
Listen to Lennon's strum pattern at 9:55. It's very John Lennon, and very few guitarist's get it right. It's like he's " keeping time " with himself.
What a masterpiece.The photos are priceless by themselves, with Mal, and the alarm clock, not to mention Paul's lip following his scooter accident. Thank you for posting. Friggin' great.
Exactly!
Paul looks different because he's not the real Paul.
@@luisportillo7607 fake news 🤣
Can you explain what happens to the beat when he changes to e minor? I've been trying to play it by hearing it but the changing beat always confuses me.
He plays the G/Bm/Em parts in 2 down strokes , with the first being more accented, and the 2nd, lighter feel (strummimg) more of the bass strings.
Wow! The vocal track is absolutely amazing. So much in this recording, but Lennon’s vocal track is spellbinding. I’ve heard it a million times, but the isolated track lends it a humanity and vulnerability I’ve never perceived before. A standout in a prodigious catalog.
Lennon's demos are all magnificent
With the exception of the godlike vocals, nothing on the separate tracks blow you away. But when you put it all together you get one of the greatest recordings ever made
Literally greater than the sum of its parts
Listening to the drums and bass parts of this song then saying that is a bit nuts
If I were analyzing this song like a book report, I’d say the theme of time plays through the whole song. A “day” in the life, the clock sounds, the ticking rhythm in the guitar playing and straight rhythms in general, the fact that the orchestral part has clashing parts all in different tempos, etc. Kind of an interesting premise, I think
Then you’d have a book report pointing out the obvious
This confirms without a doubt why The Beatles wanted Sir Richard in the band.
Around 3:00 you can hear Come Together rhythm going on!!!
Love all your deconstructing Beatles! It's almost like getting a new Beatles record!
Ringo's shining moment
Come on gang that's John's voice.
From, I Want To Hold Your Hand to the apocalypse. Those WOOS are simply spooky.
Gracias Amigo, I love these takes. I confess I still tear up hearing John,
singing here solo, bathed in the reverb.
❤.....Peace
1) From the book "Recording the Beatles" (Kevin Ryan, Brian Kehew): "Though many have understandably attributed this vocal to John Lennon in the past, isolation of the vocal reveals it to be Paul. As the part progresses, his voice takes on a more nasal tone; this, in combination with an application of Repeat Echo similar to that already applied to John's, does much to give an impression of it being Lennon." (pg. 444)
2) It's still Paul's part, it's his dream. Why would John (or freaking George?!) sing lead here?
3) It's Paul's voice, unmistakebly. Paul is doing his normal chest voice. His timbre and the way he bends the notes going up and down are very telling too. The way his voice breaks at the very end is another definite tell. You're simply fooled because of the slap back echo that's on his voice.
Here's the part WITHOUT the reverb - sounds even more like Paul! clyp.it/npqcuc22?token=1861b0fbf5cc893c3956bbc124eb6654
4) John didn't sing this part when he recorded HIS vocals (Anthology version). Paul unfortunately didn't get to sing it at the first try, when he said "Oh shit" after messing up the lyrics before.
5) In fact, the Beatles re-recorded the vocals for the bridge AND the transition on February 3rd, so Paul could correct his blunder and "added some soaring aaahs" (John C. Winn, "That magic feeling"). They recorded the bridge and the transition in one take, so if you agree that Paul sings lead on the "Woke up..." part, you HAVE to agree he still sings lead on the transition! There's no audible cut at all (in contrast to the one at the very end of the section), and you can even hear how Paul takes a breath after "dream" before going into the "aaah" part.
6) While the very first of the "aaahs" does sound a BIT like John (because of said echo), ALL the high falsetto "uuuuhs" in the background sound VERY much like John! In fact, John does the excact same note in the excact same sound in "Sexy Sadie" (2.13). ruclips.net/video/vFt2gXpiHN4/видео.html How Giles Martin could seriously mistake THAT for Paul is beyond me, and it did cost him all respect I had for him.
7) Thankfully his mixer, Sam Okell, has better ears and confirmed several times it's Paul, explaining in detail how the "aaah" and the delay is one of Paul's vocal tracks. www.soundonsound.com/techniques/inside-track-sgt-peppers-lonely-hearts-club-band
8) There are even PICTURES of their actual protools mixer where you can see the tracks marked as "Paul's vocals".
9) About Emericks detailed story: Did any of the "John"-believers ever read Emerick's interview from 1979 where he didn't even remember who played the piano on ADITL? He thought it was possibly John! [Q: "A day in the life - what do you recall recording that? - “Mainly the orchestral crescendo.” (…) Q: "Was John playing the piano or Paul, do you remember?" - “Sorry, no. Haven’t a clue. It was basically John’s song, so it might have been him. I don’t remember.” ]
After reading this, do you SERIOUSLY believe that the SAME man could have remembered such detailed situations and conversations 27 years LATER? This is just ANOTHER blatant example of mistakes, lies and made up stories from his infamous book, famously called out by fellow Beatle-engineer Ken Scott. So although Emerick was there, he doesn't remember anything from the actual sessions (as he admitted himself in 1979), he only quotes from the book.
10) Richard Lush, in contrast to what Howard Massey wrote in "Emerick's" book, confirmed to a fan who reached out to him on something like twitter, it was Paul.
11) While Paul didn't give a specific answer when asked about this vocal part on a reddit AMA, there was this very interesting story in another comment:
maclaine
"Hopefully he comes back and answers this, but just in case he doesn't, I'll throw in my two cents. I work in the video game industry, and my first job was working on The Beatles: Rock Band. Part of my job was going through all the songs in the game and using as much reference as possible to figure out who was playing/singing which parts, what instruments they were using during that time period, what amps, etc. I and another Beatle nut were meticulous about this because a) working on the game meant the world to us, and b) our research would be reflected by the art and animation in the game forever, so we wanted to get it exactly right.
One of the things we had access to was the multitrack audio for the songs. Most of that stuff has leaked out on the internet over the years, but the mixes in game are a bit more condensed than what we had access to because of the nature of how Rock Band works. When I got to A Day In The Life and this part, it was a big bone of contention between me and some of the game leads. I'm 100% sure it's Paul and to me it's crystal clear when you hear the isolated vocal track. There's also a passage in Mark Lewisohn's book The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions where he says the same thing, even addressing the confusion that it might be John.
I made my case as strongly as I could for as long as I could, but at that stage of the game's development, the animation department had already done the facial animation for John and wouldn't be able to change it in time, so it shipped with the incorrect Beatle "singing" the part. It's one of my greatest professional regrets, honestly, but I'll die on that hill that it's Paul singing that part."
@@gutgolf74 it’s George singing that part
2:25 that part is amazing👍🏻👍🏻 exactly what I was looking for
The vocal isolation at around @15:00 goes deep! There's something very eerie and haunting about these lyrics and tone. Can still har some intrments in the background bu the lyrics alone would have been sweet.
Never gets old :) Masterpiece!
I've always wondered about that final piano chord - I always heard a kind of synth sound in there somewhere, which I now realise is GM playing the harmonium. What a revelation. This channel is amazing!
19:43 oh my God....masterful beyond words.
La voz d lennon se escucha genial, fantástica... d otro planeta.... la obra maestra jamás enjendrada
Love Johns vocals
That piano part is soooooo good 😌👌🏻
Many thanks. As I was [thinking that] I was near the end (yeah, right) of my research for my "The Beatles" play list, I came across your isolation tracks-type clips. I was about to give up on finding any worthwhile stuff for Revolver & Sgt. Pepper's, specifically... most of it was just "covers" by whomever.
Thanks... again.
Sin dudas la canción más trabajada de ellos, me agrado bastante la descripción
gracias hago lo de la descripción para que youtube no sea tan malo con mis video jajajja ademas para que no me jodan en los comentarios
Pues está bien eso hermano, se ve genial
Oh A day in the life song. Thanks so much. Another amazing song.😂
Wow, literally was looking for this all day, and now you posted it, thanksss
Just loving all these video's of the masters at work crafting the their songs. just baffled me how they could get such great and different sounds at the time, like magic. To hear the vocal tracks and harmonies is mind-blowing. Thanks so much for turning everyone on to the why they were and are greatest rock band ever.
I now can be really sure that the “dream” part was sang by Paul, i think people’s ear get acostumed to Paul’s voice in the “woke up, fell out of bed” part, since its very low and mellow suddenly hearing that high nasally voice feels like it could be John’s but you can really tell that kind of vocal run could only be done by Paul.
Well done!
17:38
Creo que el que canta esa parte es Macca, a lo mejor me equivoco pero él es muy bueno imitando y es una de las voces más versátiles de la historia, tiene la capacidad de tener tantos estilos de voz y variantes.
Hasta se escucha como toma aire antes de cantarla y en los coros al fondo se escucha a John haciendo los "oooh".
Es mí parecer.
No lo se me suena mas a Lennon, pero si en algo tienes toda la razón del mundo es que Macca era muy versátil, de las mejores voces que ha dado la historia de la musica.
A mi me suene al revés. John los aahs y Paul los ooohs de fondo 😂
Suena mas a John y aparte tiene el mismo reverb que cuando estaba cantando John
Y aparte creo que Geoff Emerick dijo que esa parte la cantaba John
@@TheRealBeyako420 la canta Paul, presta atención
It is 100% Paul McCartney
ШЕДЕВР!!!!!!!❤
In John's wordless AAAAHHHHHH vocalise part, I never heard those background WOOOO bits before. I thought the part was ethereal just because of the echo. Quite a revelation!
i think here sings paul and john in back choirs
@@DLD2Music It always sounded like John to me, especially with that "halo" that George Martin always put around his vocals. If it's Paul, I'm surprised.
@@DLD2Music clearly lennon
@@TheSanityInspector How can you mistake Lennon or mc cartney s voices?
@@dannyoneil5058 I'll be embarrassed if I did!
Masterpiece
!!
band on the run band on the run frame 21:30 to 21:39 band on the run band on the run .lol wow !
Creo el final de esta canción psicodelica está genial..me gusta y me lleva ...buena mezcla de sensaciones..
Ringo`s part is very arty
19:53 I can’t help but smile at this part
17:39 ok someone clear this up. I’m 100% sure the “ahhh ahhh ahh” part is sung by John but a lot of people here seem to think it’s sung by Paul so now I’m confused. But it sounds so obviously like Lennon
No, it doesn't sound like John AT ALL.
John couldn't do a smooth chestvoice in that register. The way Paul bends the notes and breaks at the very end, very telling.
Also, there's no cut between the "dream" and the "aah", you can even hear Paul take a breath.
Also, since John is CLEARLY doing his trademark NASAL high falsetto in the background AT THE SAME TIME it's impossible for him to do the "aah", anyway.
It's Paul's part and Paul's voice, no matter how you feel about it.
Sam Okell, the remix engineer, confirmed and explained it.
@@gutgolf74 HELP you’ve literally come at me on different videos on this topic. It’s like you specialize in this specific argument 💀
@@lilpip6408 LOL, sorry, since there are so many clips out there about ADITL and there are so many people getting it wrong or, in your case, asking for advice, it's kind of hard to keep track and remember EVERY name. ;-)
Indeed I did specialize on this topic since I stumbled into this discussion several years ago - it just annoys the hell out of me that so many people get this wrong AND feel like being condescending about it ("How is this a debate, it's obviously John, as every real Beatles-fan knows!!!"), so I like to adress them with actual facts and evidence and enlighten at least some of them!
Did I succeed with you?? 😀
All the best, cheers!
@@gutgolf74 literally sounds like John and nothing like Paul. John had raspy higher voice and Paul's voice was smoother and deeper.
@@elvis.austin LOL, you literally made a fool of you - Paul had a "deeper" voice, right? That's why PAUL always sang the DEEPER harmony and John the higher one, right? RIGHT?? 😀
Let's see if you even get how foolish that statement was...
Apart from that you kept ignoring everything I said. Because it's a fact that you can't name a single song where John does a voice like that in that register - he just couldn't do it because he couldn't sing THAT HIGH in THAT smooth voice!
Also of course you're ignoring his falsetto in the background...
So, you still got nothing but false assumptions that can VERY easily be debunked.
But you're really making a show of yourself being condescending while being literally wrong! 😀
so glad I found this video
Magnific!
I've been waiting for this !
Oh ive been waiting for this one another great video my friend (shame about the final chords)
Yes, youtube is a poop
Wow what a channel you have DLD2!!!
Thank you for doing this!!!!
One of the best channels on YT!!!!
LSD works
That was almost their studio name, fun fact
I've read that Geoff Emerick said that after the recording of the rhythm track, they re-recorded the percussion with George on Congas and Ringo on Maracas. But there are other fonts that say this didn't happen. What the heck.
Geoff didn't even remember who played the piano, he thought it was probably John in an interview from 1979.
Don't believe a single word from his book.
17:38
John at 17.30 is simply spellbinding...
That's Paul...
Yes. John sings "house of Paul."
Nonsense.
When?
@@jorgsommer9332 Never
We hear what we wanna hear. But it's "lords" obviously. The trick was the "s" wasn't barely heard so it could sound like "Paul" if you wanna hear that way.
He cristal clearly said "lords"
Greeeeeeat!!!
What the h... is so special with the final chord that its deconstruction had to be censored three times due to "copyright"??? Has it to do with the pianos that were used (because I see that George Martin's harmonium track is not censored)??? As if piano manufacturers wouldn't earn enough money!!! Really, such actions could make RUclips completely worthless!!! I am really angry!!!
im angry too
I AM ANGRY TOO!!!
Does anyone know why during the sections from 11:41 and 13:53 you can hear Mal Evans counting the band or orchestra in so loudly over a microphone echoing and how come his voice kept getting more and more intense during the final orchestra build up section to the end?
I don’t know if he did that just to make the song orchestra section sound very intense and scary perhaps to add that extra effect to the song himself.
They didn't even know about the orchestra back then - there was a blank space and they told Mal to count down the bars. Since they never did something boring Mal probably thought he should add some drama! ;-)
…and to think, it took two pianos and six hands to create that copyright ©
Hahaha, Paul`s piano is into music hall.
17:38 is paul singing you can hear john in the background and you can also hear paul going ooooo ooo
Correct, Paul is doing the lead, but - as you say - it's John in the background doing the high nasal "oooooh"
Also, there's George doing a lower "ooooh".
Also, Ringo is doing a low octave "aaaaah".
the “aaaaaaaaaaa” part sounds definitely like paul
It is Paul
@@billburns7721 finally someone got it right
And the high nasal falsettos sound even more like John!
@@gutgolf74 nah
@@HeyBullfrog
While the very first of the "aaahs" does sound a BIT like John (because of said echo), ALL the high falsetto "uuuuhs" in the background sound VERY much like John! In fact, John does the excact same note in the excact same sound in "Sexy Sadie" (2.13). ruclips.net/video/vFt2gXpiHN4/видео.html
17:38-18:07 the infamous "Is it John or is it Paul" part! I personally think it's Paul.
me too , i think here sings paul and john in back choirs
@@DLD2Music Finally someone sane I can talk too! JK>:D
Alright, I hear Paul. Hear me out though: I'm almost embarrassed to admit how many times I've listened to and played this song. I remember the first time I heard it; and I believe that moment, first being introduced to it- immediately falling in love with it- changed the course of my life in ways I haven't yet come to terms with. Blah blah blah I don't mean to be melodramatic but I've been waiting 20 years to hear these tracks isolated. Anyway, I hear Paul in the bridge- the same voice he uses in Rita- but as it progresses I hear more John. I swear my senses tell me John leads towards the end in several measures. This tracks with their style imo. The closer we get to John's final verse I hear a distinct "John". Granted, Paul was a fan of John's and would/could mimic him. My entire point is this: Paul doesn't sing lead throughout the bridge. It's 6 Paul, 4 John. Lol. And by God bless you for uploading this. Christmas came early this year.
Its definitely Paul!
@@Guitarjames97 who knows, i think it was paul but a lot of peotle think it was john
The isolated aaaaaaahs make it clear that it is John. The nasal raspy quality to it gives it away. And when his verse resumes after it's definitely the same voice. Paul's voice is much smoother, only becominig hoarse and throaty when he screams in some of his big rockers.
You're proving yourself wrong: These "aahs" are not even much raspy at all, it's a quite smooth chest voice which would have been too high for John.
Even more obviously that's John's typically nasal high falsetto in the background.
1) From the book "Recording the Beatles" (Kevin Ryan, Brian Kehew): "Though many have understandably attributed this vocal to John Lennon in the past, isolation of the vocal reveals it to be Paul. As the part progresses, his voice takes on a more nasal tone; this, in combination with an application of Repeat Echo similar to that already applied to John's, does much to give an impression of it being Lennon." (pg. 444)
2) It's still Paul's part, it's his dream. Why would John (or freaking George?!) sing lead here?
3) It's Paul's voice, unmistakebly. Paul is doing his normal chest voice. His timbre and the way he bends the notes going up and down are very telling too. The way his voice breaks at the very end is another definite tell. You're simply fooled because of the slap back echo that's on his voice.
Here's the part WITHOUT the reverb - sounds even more like Paul! clyp.it/npqcuc22?token=1861b0fbf5cc893c3956bbc124eb6654
4) John didn't sing this part when he recorded HIS vocals (Anthology version). Paul unfortunately didn't get to sing it at the first try, when he said "Oh shit" after messing up the lyrics before.
5) In fact, the Beatles re-recorded the vocals for the bridge AND the transition on February 3rd, so Paul could correct his blunder and "added some soaring aaahs" (John C. Winn, "That magic feeling"). They recorded the bridge and the transition in one take, so if you agree that Paul sings lead on the "Woke up..." part, you HAVE to agree he still sings lead on the transition! There's no audible cut at all (in contrast to the one at the very end of the section), and you can even hear how Paul takes a breath after "dream" before going into the "aaah" part.
6) While the very first of the "aaahs" does sound a BIT like John (because of said echo), ALL the high falsetto "uuuuhs" in the background sound VERY much like John! In fact, John does the excact same note in the excact same sound in "Sexy Sadie" (2.13). ruclips.net/video/vFt2gXpiHN4/видео.html How Giles Martin could seriously mistake THAT for Paul is beyond me, and it did cost him all respect I had for him.
7) Thankfully his mixer, Sam Okell, has better ears and confirmed several times it's Paul, explaining in detail how the "aaah" and the delay is one of Paul's vocal tracks. www.soundonsound.com/techniques/inside-track-sgt-peppers-lonely-hearts-club-band
8) There are even PICTURES of their actual protools mixer where you can see the tracks marked as "Paul's vocals".
9) About Emericks detailed story: Did any of the "John"-believers ever read Emerick's interview from 1979 where he didn't even remember who played the piano on ADITL? He thought it was possibly John! [Q: "A day in the life - what do you recall recording that? - “Mainly the orchestral crescendo.” (…) Q: "Was John playing the piano or Paul, do you remember?" - “Sorry, no. Haven’t a clue. It was basically John’s song, so it might have been him. I don’t remember.” ]
After reading this, do you SERIOUSLY believe that the SAME man could have remembered such detailed situations and conversations 27 years LATER? This is just ANOTHER blatant example of mistakes, lies and made up stories from his infamous book, famously called out by fellow Beatle-engineer Ken Scott. So although Emerick was there, he doesn't remember anything from the actual sessions (as he admitted himself in 1979), he only quotes from the book.
10) Richard Lush, in contrast to what Howard Massey wrote in "Emerick's" book, confirmed to a fan who reached out to him on something like twitter, it was Paul.
11) While Paul didn't give a specific answer when asked about this vocal part on a reddit AMA, there was this very interesting story in another comment:
maclaine
"Hopefully he comes back and answers this, but just in case he doesn't, I'll throw in my two cents. I work in the video game industry, and my first job was working on The Beatles: Rock Band. Part of my job was going through all the songs in the game and using as much reference as possible to figure out who was playing/singing which parts, what instruments they were using during that time period, what amps, etc. I and another Beatle nut were meticulous about this because a) working on the game meant the world to us, and b) our research would be reflected by the art and animation in the game forever, so we wanted to get it exactly right.
One of the things we had access to was the multitrack audio for the songs. Most of that stuff has leaked out on the internet over the years, but the mixes in game are a bit more condensed than what we had access to because of the nature of how Rock Band works. When I got to A Day In The Life and this part, it was a big bone of contention between me and some of the game leads. I'm 100% sure it's Paul and to me it's crystal clear when you hear the isolated vocal track. There's also a passage in Mark Lewisohn's book The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions where he says the same thing, even addressing the confusion that it might be John.
I made my case as strongly as I could for as long as I could, but at that stage of the game's development, the animation department had already done the facial animation for John and wouldn't be able to change it in time, so it shipped with the incorrect Beatle "singing" the part. It's one of my greatest professional regrets, honestly, but I'll die on that hill that it's Paul singing that part."
Still no comeback? Go figure! :-D
@@gutgolf74 bro you're so annoying lmao, commenting this EVERYWHERE. It literally sounds NOTHING like Paul, not even one bit. Where tf do y'all even hear it? It's so obviously John
The is great! Thanks very much!! Would you consider doing The Soft Parade by The Doors?
When paul goes into a dream... it’s MDMA without the isolated vocal track but WITH the isolated vocals, it’s like. MDMA times DMT and crack to the 3rd power
Very very well put!!!
RIP Mal
17:10
It’s Paul doing the aahhhs. I used to think it was John, but now that you can hear it more clearly isolated It’s definitely Paul. You can clearly hear John in the background doing the creepy parts.
Well done!
Why the bass part by Macca is so low in volume?
you wanted to hear earrape from a 60s bass.
I don't think they'll ever release the actual clear stripped down sections as they shouldn't tbh. It's Beatles and I don't want Lil tom, Lil dick or Lil Harry to take certain parts for a dumb rap song about bitches and money.
14:06 Dog Whistle?
I don't know, I've never heard one.
But many times I've heard that one was used on this song, so I thought I should ask.
Is pattie
I like the 3rd one where georgemartin goes bonkers at the end like counting I 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 etc
Yes its really funny how some one goes bonkers with echoes
That is Mal Evans, as absolutely EVERYBODY knows... It's even in the description!!
Martin is good
Los acordes de piano los tocaron, ringo, Male evans, Paul, jhon y George Martin
Sep
Nobody was really sure if he was from the House of Paul…
LOL, yeah, I know, there are actual people who actually believe THESE were the actual lyrics!! 😀
11:41 Mal counts
13:53 too
12:51 a little chuckle
whose sings those big notes after someone spoke and I went into a dream, always thought it was john, but in isolation I hear a lot of paul especially as it fades out. Who do you say John or Paul?
John.
It's clearly Paul. It's still Paul's part, that's why we only see Paul during this part in the official video!
That's why they recorded the vocals for this part IN ONE GO on February 3rd, they finished John's part weeks before.
You can even hear that there's no cut between the "dream" and the "aaah", just Paul taking a breath.
John couldn't do a smooth chestvoice in the register, the way Paul bends the notes and breaks at the end, all very telling.
Also, since John is doing his trademark NASAL high falsetto in the background AT THE SAME TIME it's impossible to be him doing the aaah anyway.
Sam Okell, the guy who did the remix, confirmed and explained it was Paul.
Sound On Sound. SOS Publications Group. Retrieved 26 October 2021. "Paul's main vocal track is in stereo, because we gave it some spread with the Waves S1 Stereo Imaging plug-in, so it has a different sound than John's lead. We also split off two little bits to be able to pan them left and right. His fourth vocal track is the 'aaah' section, and below it is an 'Aah delay' aux track."
Wait!! George only played the maracas?
yes 😎
REALLY sounds like George on a third voice in the vocal "euphoria" section! 17:53-18:02
El que más estaba esperando! Mi cancion favorita. En donde haces las deconstrucciones?? O cómo le haces?:(
esta la saque del rock band pero hay otras que uso izotope
I still can’t tell who does the ahhhhs. Some parts sound like John and some Paul. I think it’s paul but idk
It is Paul, John does the high nasal falsettos in the background.
What’s up with paul’s bass? It starts off nicely, but then becomes muffled.
17:38 the debate if it was John or Paul... they were both.
In fact, it's all of them.
Paul - lead aaaah
John - high nasal falsetto
George - lower falsetto
Ringo - low octave aaah
Ringo final chord, XD sorry copyright, una cosa, que es el tambourine? O
Pandereta
Ah, gracias
Who know, what is that sound? 12:51
someone coughing in the echo chamber
@@DLD2Music thanks
Perhaps a dumb question; who plays the piano on the track?
John Plays his part , Paul play his part and Ringo , Paul, John, Mal evans and George Martin plays the final chord
McCartney plays the piano, while John, Ringo and Mal join in on the final chord. George Martin plays the harmonium for the final chord
Paul plays all piano parts in this song, only the final chord is played by him, John, Ringo and Mal.
Before Stacks o Tracks (Beach Boys) nobody cared about trax like this...the melody is handled by the singer. Brian Wilson lives!
Why some videos were uploaded but says private?
Because some videos are blocked by youtube, and in a few day are unblocked
@@DLD2Music thanks for clarifying.
17:38 me acabo de dar cuenta que sí es Paul :o
Para ami era así pero Giles Martin dijo que es John
Es John en primer plano.
Además es SU canción.
@@fernandoaldekoa2436 I don't speak French, but Giles Martin was totally contradicted and debunked by his OWN MIXER, Sam Okell, who confirmed and explained it was Paul!
Sound On Sound. SOS Publications Group. Retrieved 26 October 2021. "Paul's main vocal track is in stereo, because we gave it some spread with the Waves S1 Stereo Imaging plug-in, so it has a different sound than John's lead. We also split off two little bits to be able to pan them left and right. His fourth vocal track is the 'aaah' section, and below it is an 'Aah delay' aux track."
@@fernandoaldekoa2436 It's NOT "John's song", Paul wrote the middle part, also the line "I'd love to turn you on", also played piano and bass and arranged and conducted the orchestra.
The "aaah" is still Paul's part, John sings only the verses.
Where did you find the separate tracks and tapes for this?
drive.google.com/drive/folders/0B0-3z16eSgqHdXNqUmVybWIybGM
@@DLD2Music oh neat, I'll have to check more of these out there all really interesting
Can you deconstruct Beatles songs with any program?
Podrías subir sgt peppers lhcb (reprise) ?
Hoy lo subo si me lo bloquean tienes que esperar 3 dias a que youtube me lo saque
Esta bien ya esperado así con otros videos
@@_.0rang3._f ya la subí
do you have any of these deconstruction stems in WAV i'd love to sample these some day
I thought Ringo counted down?
@@piplee1439 mal evans
@ new one on me
Is there a chance you could email me the different parts of the chord?
pass you mail
@@tragiclifeform347 see mail, delete your email from here before someone copies it and makes you spam
@@DLD2Music Many thanks
@@DLD2Music Hey can you pass me all the tracks if you have them through email
Thanks for sharing!!!
@@SprayJuice pass it
who sings the "AAAA" part, for the love of god???
John.
@@fernandoaldekoa2436 nowadays Im sure its Paul
@@di.galvao_ Believe me, it's John. Giles Martin says it too.
And it's John's song so when Paul finished his middle part, John continues with the rest of his song.
@@fernandoaldekoa2436 LOL!
It's still Paul's part, that's why we only see Paul during this part in the official video!
That's why they recorded the vocals for this part IN ONE GO on February 3rd, they finished John's part weeks before.
You can even hear that there's no cut between the "dream" and the "aaah", just Paul taking a breath.
John couldn't do a smooth chestvoice in the register, the way Paul bends the notes and breaks at the end, all very telling.
Also, since John is doing his trademark NASAL high falsetto in the background AT THE SAME TIME it's impossible to be him doing the aaah anyway.
Also, Giles Martin was debunked and contradicted by HIS OWN MIXING ENGINEER, Sam Okell, who confirmed and explained it was Paul.
Sound On Sound. SOS Publications Group. Retrieved 26 October 2021. "Paul's main vocal track is in stereo, because we gave it some spread with the Waves S1 Stereo Imaging plug-in, so it has a different sound than John's lead. We also split off two little bits to be able to pan them left and right. His fourth vocal track is the 'aaah' section, and below it is an 'Aah delay' aux track."
Me podrias decir cuales son los minutos en el video original que reclamaron?
Fíjate que hay una nueva versión que tiene más pistas y puedes escuchar los acordes finales
Cry baby cry is my favorite one you've done
Some people say that Lennon can’t sing, maybe they didn’t hear this or they have atrocious sense of music.
I never heard anyone ever EVER say John Lennon couldn’t sing.
the real question is who is panting like that at 17:24 ?
That is no question, that's John!
He's still in the background later, doing his trademark nasal falsetto, while Paul is singing his lead "aaah".
@@gutgolf74 You're an asshole, the main ahhhhh is Lennon
@@marcorossi1817 Ooooh, being rude and throwing insults instead of providing evidence - always the clear sign of someone being the inferiour part in a debate! 😀